Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

12 December 2016 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions during a congressional control session in Spain on December 12, 2016, facing Socialist Party challenges on inequality and poverty.
Main themes
Inequality and poverty, minimum vital income proposal, working poor and precarious employment, wage devaluation, labor reform criticism, social exclusion, redistribution of wealth, unemployment benefits, gender wage gap, social cohesion, collective bargaining
Duration
~52 min
94th percentile
Words
6,187
94th percentile
Sentences
238
92nd percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
12.7
54th percentile
Syntax
3.19
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 43%42%
  • Economic 31%31%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

238 sentences in 83 paragraphs

Mr. Rajoy, thanks to your policies, Spain is today the second country in the OECD where inequality has grown the most, only behind Cyprus. Poverty and social exclusion in Spain have alarmingly increased in recent years, with 13.4 million people at risk of poverty. And it is the second country in the European Union where the gap between high and low incomes has grown the most, only behind Estonia, with the most disadvantaged households suffering the greatest drop in income.

In this scenario, Mr. Rajoy, we have a challenge of the utmost priority in our country, which is to articulate redistributive policies that allow us to achieve a fairer and more equal society. We must generate opportunities for all. The foundation of the social discontent that exists today in Spain is inequality. The increase in inequality in terms of opportunities, wages, or disposable income in Spain has occurred, fundamentally, due to the cuts made in basic public services and the wage devaluation resulting from your labor reform, which caused significant precariousness in employment, particularly affecting those with the lowest wages and those forced to change jobs. It meant lowering the standard of living for the majority of citizens by affecting wages, pensions, and unemployment benefits.

All of this has led to a very negative redistribution of wealth, as there has been a loss of weight of wage income in favor of corporate profits. This redistribution of income has been unjust and inefficient. I say inefficient because it also caused a collapse in domestic demand. That is to say, wage devaluation, working poverty, and increased inequality have gone hand in hand, which is why we are obliged to act urgently, not only to promote collective bargaining but also to end the deterioration of job quality and to act on those who have been left without any resources to live with dignity.

Let us remember that almost 50 percent of the unemployed do not receive any benefits. There has also been no progress in equality, in the wage gap between men and women, with a gap exceeding 18 percent, according to Eurostat, which is the sixth highest among the twenty-eight member states of the European Union.

In short, GDP is growing, the highest incomes are recovering, and inequality is increasing in relation to the lowest incomes due to the lower growth of labor income.

For socialists, tackling inequality in the distribution of wealth, the distribution of income, and radically reducing the high rates of the population at risk of poverty is an absolute priority in our political action, and it requires immediate measures.

We know that job creation is undoubtedly an effective tool to tackle poverty; however, today it is no longer enough to prevent it, because more than half of the poor belong to families that have some income. A new social class of working poor has emerged, victims of low wages and high temporary employment. Reducing working poverty also requires other social measures to complement income.

For all these reasons, Mr. President, we must be aware that with these levels of poverty and social exclusion in Spain, we can face very serious problems of social cohesion and also affect the stability of our democratic system.

We know that the proposals made must be developed within a coordinated system, integrating all existing benefits, which are currently dispersed and disconnected, and also doing so in permanent collaboration with the Autonomous Communities and Local Entities.

For all the reasons argued, Mr. Rajoy, today I bring you here, on behalf of the Socialist Party, two urgent proposals. The first is to create by law a minimum vital income, as a new non-contributory benefit of Social Security, aimed at households without income or in a situation of vulnerability, which covers their basic needs to live with dignity. The second is that we extend unemployment protection and recover the subsidy for the unemployed over 52 years old, extending its duration until they find a job or access retirement pension.

I simply ask you to express your position on this with a yes or a no. Next Sunday, once again, the trade union organizations will take to the streets to demonstrate with demands that we consider just, such as those I have just formulated, and others that I have already presented on previous occasions. We will be there supporting them, because we are convinced that these are demands that benefit our society to be fairer and that reduce the growing inequality.

Mr. Rajoy, we cannot leave all those people who suffer such harsh situations as the current one to their fate, and that is why I ask you to get moving, to open a negotiation space so that those 693,000 families without income in Spain can have a minimum vital income that allows them to meet their most basic needs, which is also a new dimension of human rights recently agreed upon by the United Nations. That is what I hope for in a negotiation framework and in a framework where politics prevails over any interest and, above all, the general interests of our country.

President.- Mr. Álvarez Areces, I can agree with many of the statements you have made here this afternoon, but, unfortunately, as happens so many times in life, some things are good wishes, which we all have, and another thing is how we achieve that those good wishes can be realized in reality.

Let us go to the main issue, the origin of the problem you raise, which is the increase in inequality in our country, and the main issue is the following: in Spain, during the years of the crisis, we lost almost 10 percent of the Gross Domestic Product, 3.2 million Spaniards lost their jobs, and the Public Administrations lost seventy billion euros in revenue. There lies the origin of our problems, and it is very well understood: we lost 10 percent of national wealth, we lost more than three million jobs, seventy billion euros in revenue, we reached a public deficit of 11 percent, and from there, enormous difficulties, if not impossibility for some Administrations, as you know very well, to finance themselves.

These ills, which were the ills we had to face, brought others, and one of them, and very important, to which you have referred here, is the increase in inequality and also the threat of poverty and social exclusion.

We had to face those ills, and we did so with an economic policy that was fundamentally based on three pillars: first, structural reforms; secondly, a strong control of public spending, which was necessary after losing seventy billion euros in revenue and with the impossibility of financing ourselves externally -- you started doing that, and rightly so, in 2010, as you surely remember very well; and the third major objective was to set priorities, and the priorities we set were: first, let us attend to the people in the most difficult situation.

We preserved pensions, unemployment insurance; we attended to the Autonomous Communities with the Autonomous Liquidity Fund and the Supplier Payment Plan, dedicated fundamentally to the major public services (health and education) and made important decisions, in agreement with the unions, such as extending the PREPARA or establishing a plan for the long-term unemployed.

This policy yielded results because, after five years of negative economic growth, the greatest recession in modern Spanish history, in economic history, we have now had three years of positive economic growth. The most important thing is that this also led to an increase in job creation in our country.

When that happened, and as could only be expected, the trend of increasing inequality began to improve. If you look at the latest indices that have been published, both the 80/20 and the Gini, they are already improving after the deteriorations of the years of the crisis.

I have here a data point on severe material poverty that Eurostat published recently: "Spain is fortunately evolving better than the euro area." Although, of course, I cannot be satisfied with these data. The same goes for the Arope Index that sets the risk of poverty, and the same goes for the number of households with all members unemployed or the number of people who cannot make ends meet. The latest Living Conditions Survey, published by the INE, encourages us to continue working intensively because we see that things are improving.

That is why I said at the beginning of my intervention: I do not agree with the statement of your question, because I do not agree that things are getting worse; but I do agree with your concern about inequality, because it is evident that we still have much to do. And what do we have to do? Well, look, continue working to create jobs, because that is the key to everything. When there are people who were not working and now work, their position will improve, we will collect more money, and therefore we can better meet the needs of the people and improve public services.

I agree with something you said in your intervention: it is absolutely, I do not say necessary, but essential, to coordinate the assistance policies in Spain, the number of benefits that exist and that are paid by the different Administrations: the central, the autonomous, and also the local.

You have made two proposals here today, in this Chamber. I am willing to consider them, but first, it is more important that we have knowledge of the facts, to know what benefits some provide, what others provide, who receives some and who receives others. Frankly, you have extended your hand to discuss these matters, and I am willing to do so; but the issue is not the objectives we pursue, which in the end will be very similar; the issue, and where the difficulty lies, is in the recipes and in the economic policies that each of us intends to apply.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Lluis Cleries, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Mr. Cleries.- Mr. Rajoy, your statements offering dialogue contrast with the ways of doing things of your Government. They especially contrast with the judicialization of politics in relation to the demands of the Catalan institutions. What kind of State do we have when those who facilitate a democratic, participatory, and civic process are judicially pursued, despite the contrary opinion of the prosecutors of the Superior Court of Justice of Catalonia, or those who simply allow discussion in the Parliament? Fifteen British MPs have already denounced this situation in their Parliament.

If today you say you want to dialogue, it means you recognize that your option until now has been, and is, "no dialogue." You come from a monologue where you have not wanted to listen to Catalonia in its diversity and plurality, nor to the majority demand of Catalan society that wants to exercise its right to decide.

In this sense, on the 23rd, a Summit of the Pact for the Right to Decide will be held, faithfully following our electoral commitment to the citizens. As your government delegate in Catalonia says, this Summit is a great opportunity, it is to remain faithful to our roadmap presented and approved.

I am sure, Mr. Rajoy, that if you engage in dialogue, you will not set aside your ideology and political orientation. Right? Do not ask President Puigdemont to do what you are not willing to do. Dialoguing is not renouncing; dialoguing is sharing, contrasting, proposing, and agreeing when possible. Dialoguing is always speaking with a willingness to reach an agreement. I assure you that on our part, we can talk about everything with a willingness to explain ourselves and listen to each other; but we will not renounce our yearning for freedom for our nation.

If you follow the path of your Minister of the Interior, I believe you are not on the right track. Mr. Zoido has said: "we have to impose dialogue and not yield to this kind of blackmail." Imposed dialogue? Will you also tell us what we should say? Blackmail?

On the other hand, do you find it logical and correct at an institutional level that the Vice President of your Government meets officially first with the representatives of the opposition in Catalonia than with the representatives of the Generalitat Government? Is this your institutional loyalty? Do you not consider it a mistake not to start with those who have the legitimacy to govern? Meet with everyone, of course, but maintain institutional respect, the respect that the Generalitat deserves. Do not only speak with those who think the same as you, do not only speak with those who form the new tripartite that supports and sustains the State Government. It is a mistake, Mr. Rajoy, to propose dialogue as a cosmetic operation. We would feel, once again, disappointed and deceived.

In this context, how do you plan to give content to your "dialogue operation" to make it credible?

President.- Mr. Cleries, I indeed propose dialogue, and you ask me, as you have just done, and as is stated in the text of the question that has been sent to all of us, about what contents that dialogue should cover, in my opinion.

Well, I am going to explain it to you. The subjects that I believe the Government of Spain can discuss with the Generalitat, and with the various deputies and senators elected in the Catalan provinces, are many, they are very important, and I think they interest and affect a lot of people. I will try to summarize them.

First of all, today in the Congress of Deputies, we are debating issues that I believe are very important to the people, such as the future of pensions, the educational model — this matter is also being discussed with the Autonomous Communities — and the fight against gender violence. I believe we can talk about these issues, and they are topics that matter to a majority of citizens.

Very soon, in the Cortes Generales, first in the Congress of Deputies and then in the Senate, we will have to decide on very important issues, such as the maximum expenditure that the Government of Spain can make in the year 2017, such as the deficit of public institutions — and that affects, and a lot, as you know, the Generalitat of Catalonia and, therefore, the citizens of Catalonia — and we will also have to debate the state revenues for the next year 2017, something that is undoubtedly a key issue and affects everyone.

Also, before the end of the year, we will have to talk about something very important, which is the Autonomous Liquidity Fund and payments to suppliers, because there are Autonomous Communities that cannot assume them at this moment. Therefore, we need to talk and we need to resolve it, because we have to attend to the people.

In January, there will be a Conference of Presidents, which I would like all those who are summoned to attend, and there we will have to talk about things that affect us all as Spaniards. The agenda is not yet closed; but there we have to take the first steps to initiate a process that leads us to a new model of autonomous financing. I believe that this matters to us and affects us all. And there we will also have to talk about such an important issue as Europe; we will have to talk about our position on the "Brexit" issue, which is not a minor issue; we have to talk about the process of European integration, which I believe affects and matters to us all; we have to talk about the major fundamental services such as healthcare and education, and we will have to talk about the fight against fraud.

There are also important issues in the coming dates, such as the General State Budgets that matter to Catalonia and the Catalans, and to the rest of the Spaniards; also about state investments in Catalonia; also about how we can reduce the conflict between the Generalitat of Catalonia and the Government, and in some other Autonomous Communities. We can also talk about your 46 requests and, above all, we can try to talk to prevent laws contrary to the Constitution from being made. It is very important that we talk about this.

All of these are, I believe, key issues, Mr. Cleries, and you know it. They are issues that affect, matter, interest, and are part of the daily lives of citizens. And I would sincerely like to be able to do so. I believe we would make progress and better address the needs of people.

I want to say that at this moment, discussions are already taking place. Not only is there dialogue with other political forces, as you have said here and you think is good, and I think it is good that you think it is good. But the Vice President has also spoken with the Vice President of the Generalitat of Catalonia on several occasions, and various members of my Government have done so as well. Therefore, discussions are taking place, we would like to continue talking about important issues, and I would like to hear from you if you indeed agree with the proposal for dialogue on specific issues that affect people and that I have just explained to you here in my speech.

Mr. Cleries.- Obviously, we have always been at the dialogue table. What has happened is that we have been alone because we have not found you at this table. Now you are signing up. You are welcome.

I must remind you, and you will understand that I remind you, Mr. Rajoy, that you propose dialogue when you promoted the ruling against the Statute. It was you and the Popular Party, with Mr. Arenas, who is here, making announcements in Andalusia against Catalonia, asking for a signature against Catalonia. You remember well, don’t you? Were you seeking dialogue with that action and what was best for Catalonia with that action? Allow me to doubt it.

I want to remind you that Catalonia is the only territory where, having voted in a referendum for a Statute, the will of the people of Catalonia was not respected. You propose dialogue with the terrible financing that has been, and is, a punishment for Catalonia, and that is legally expired. You propose dialogue while we have a fiscal deficit for Catalonia estimated at about fifteen billion euros annually. You propose dialogue with very low annual investments, around 9 percent of the total, a good part of which are not even executed. You propose dialogue, those who boasted of having destroyed Catalan healthcare. You propose dialogue with the abandonment of Renfe-Cercanías, with the attacks on our language, which remain very much alive, and with an inequality between territories that harms Catalonia. You have never respected the principle of ordinality. Catalonia has always been more than sufficiently solidary with the whole of the Spanish state, despite what they say.

Catalonia is clearly aware of the mistreatment that you have applied to us; a set of causes that have evidently led us to where we are. The Gospel says, "by their works you will know them"; the Gospel says this. Without a doubt, the works do not accompany you much when it comes to talking about dialogue, proposing it, and making it credible. We expect dialogue, bilateral dialogue, because we have earned it. We expect respect for democracy and, especially, respect for the will of all the people of Catalonia. We expect politics to provide a political response, not a judicial one.

We expect to talk about everything, also about the referendum, which you have left off your long list. Because, you see, you spoke of the Constitution, of constitutional laws, and you, like me, saw this poster years ago: "Constitution, one vote is worth more than a thousand shouts. Your right is to vote. Vote freely." Today, if you want to vote in Catalonia and do not go to the tune of those who command, who are you, it is a crime. This goes against the Constitution that we voted on at that time, which I, at least, voted for. I don’t know if you voted for it, because perhaps we have a problem: that those who today speak of the Constitution are those who did not vote for it and apply it in their own way, different from how it is.

Dialogue without content, Mr. Rajoy, is a monologue that, evidently, leads nowhere. It is a self-deception that seeks to confuse society to grant itself a moral authority that they do not deserve or have in this case.

If you want to dialogue, Mr. Rajoy, I tell you from the heart, go ahead; but bilaterally, openly, without conditions, without red lines. Afterwards, there will be agreements or not, but, sincerely, it will be a sincere dialogue or it will not be a dialogue.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Cleries. I fear that with reproaches and grievances, few things can be resolved in this life, and if someone seeks confrontation, they will not find me, because what I seek is agreement and I will work for it.

Ladies and gentlemen,

We have talked and done many things throughout this Legislature: liquidity mechanisms, attention to debt maturities, attention to the debts of the Catalan autonomous government with suppliers… We have dedicated a lot of money to infrastructure: the four provincial capitals of Catalonia with AVE, the third runway at the airport. There was good dialogue between the Ministry of Development and the Generalitat; and also with the Ministry of Agriculture and the Environment regarding the Segarra-Garrigues canal; and also in matters of industry and tourism, energy interconnections, and investments in R&D; and also in cultural matters.

There was a lot of dialogue and there were several results throughout this last Legislature, and now the goal is to increase that dialogue. I mentioned earlier a series of topics that I believe we can discuss because they are issues that matter to all citizens of Catalonia. You have not said anything to me about that; I will not take it as a negative; but we can talk about the Mediterranean Corridor, which we have already started; about the railway access to the Port of Barcelona or about the new Rodalies Plan. We can talk about many things.

Therefore, we have talked, and I think we could talk more if there were a little goodwill on your part, Mr. Cleries. And allow me to say something, because I think it is also important, just as I have listened to you, you should listen to me: it is not fair that you set the thermometer of dialogue at the only point that neither you nor we can decide, because that corresponds to the whole Spanish people.

You know the position of the Government of Spain and of the vast majority of the Cortes Generales, of the members of the Congress of Deputies and the Senate, and that position is the only possible one. The proposal made to us in the Cortes to say "yes or yes, I will do what I want, legally or illegally" leaves us with no margin at all. It leads nowhere, it is not fair, it denies negotiation because it proposes a contract of adhesion, and that is not, of course — as you, I believe, know — a good formula for negotiating or reaching any understanding.

You should make an effort to put yourself in the other person's shoes, which is the only way to negotiate truly.

Finally, allow me — I know I am not in a position to give it — to give you a piece of advice: steer clear of those who want to end everything, steer clear of extremists, those who want, desire, and are seeking with all the strength they can muster, confrontation. They will not get anywhere that way.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Jokin Bildarratz, from the Basque Parliamentary Group

Mr. Bildarratz.- Mr. President of the Government, before I ask you the question, I would also like to share a series of ideas, and the first is how important it is to work on the concept of community. We have a society, like the Spanish one, with more than 46 million inhabitants, and if you want to make it easier, more manageable, I will refer to a small community such as a community of neighbors, where together, democratically, they adopt a series of decisions to carry out, whether they are investments, work, or construction. If any of the members of this small community does not fulfill their responsibilities, the rest will evidently demand them, through one means or another, and they will also have to do so.

A second idea is that each community has a series of representatives, has a series of leaders, has a series of icons, and evidently, these icons have to play or we have to play an important role. They have to be exemplary, model-like; they have to have transparent pockets, because it is the only way we can convey credibility. And we all enter here: we enter politicians, we enter the people who are references in the communities I have mentioned, and of course, elite athletes also play a very important role in this community, in this society, setting an example for many young people, children… many people.

As I was saying, these days a series of public information has emerged about fraud, both from football players and from a number of teams. And let’s analyze the situation. The Ministry — and this is the third idea — of Finance establishes that, as long as 85 percent of the athletes' income comes from their contract and not from image rights, they can tax the remaining 15 percent through the Corporate Tax at 25 percent.

And it is here that we establish a behavior or when we see that a behavior can be generated that is contrary to the law, contrary to rights. First, athletes sell their image rights to a company at a price that is often zero. That is the first indicator that they are going against the community and against the responsibilities they have to the community. The second issue is that, in addition, when they sell it to a company, this company is most of the time not located in Spain, because it does not matter to them that it is in Spain, which is already the second point that can at least generate a type of doubt. And, third, most companies, most of the time, have no type of activity, none.

It is evident that based on these three issues, this action is already going against the law. The conclusion, what is it? That the benefits that the company provides to the player should go to the performance of work and not to those image rights.

We all know that the Tax Agency pursues the self-employed, we all know that the Tax Agency pursues the average person, and here comes the question: but are the necessary resources dedicated to addressing this type of facts, to the facts I have described? And, if you want, Mr. President, I will pose the question for the future. What measures will the Government adopt to prevent tax fraud among the wealthy, including the multimillion-dollar contracts of some athletes?

President.- I share the rationale that has led to the question you have asked me. What you are asking is what measures we are going to take to prevent tax fraud, including the multimillion-dollar contracts of some athletes. And the first thing I want to answer is that we are going to try to do what we have done over these four years, where we have fought a great battle against tax fraud and we intend to increase it in the future.

You know what the objective of our economic policy has been over these four years: to achieve economic growth, create jobs, and thus achieve a recovery and definitively overcome the crisis. And, as I said before, the instruments were clear: structural reforms and fiscal consolidation. Fiscal consolidation required many things, but one of them was to have sufficient revenues to carry it out successfully, and for that, obviously, fighting against tax fraud was a major objective.

I believe we have fought that battle, and that battle aimed to achieve more tax revenues, and, above all, it aimed to do justice: everyone must pay exactly what the current legislation approved by the Congress of Deputies and also the Senate of the Nation states.

Frankly, I believe that we can report some things because the results have been positive; they have been, plain and simple, the best in history in absolute terms: 50.449 billion euros in the period 2012-2015 is the result of this fight against tax fraud. And in the first half of this year 2016, 7.092 billion euros. Who has paid those amounts? Many taxpayers, including very important football players. We all know, because we read the newspapers, that there are important football players from major clubs who have many followers in our country, who have paid significant amounts for defrauding the Public Treasury.

From there, I have the absolute and total conviction that the State Tax Agency does everything in its power to go after any taxpayer who fails to meet their obligations, whether they are athletes or not.

What are we going to do in the future? Persevere in that policy because, I insist, it has been positive: in four years, more than 50 billion euros. And the goal is for people to pay what they have to pay according to the law based on the income they receive. And, if any legal modification is needed, I am willing to do it. That is to say, any contribution you want to make to the fight against fraud, to be more effective and to do things better, I must say will have our support; but I cannot accept, because there are already many cases we have seen in the media, that these people who defraud the Treasury are not pursued by the State Tax Agency, because they have been. It is evident that I am not going to name the names that are on the minds of many, but we do know that there have even been court rulings with prison sentences for some of those people.

What can be done better? Undoubtedly, but already this year there are more than 7 billion euros, and I would like it to be less in the future, because it would be a sign that everyone pays and complies religiously with the Public Treasury because, if not, among other things, what they are doing is defrauding others.

Mr. Bildarratz.- It seems that this afternoon is about agreements, because I also agree with many of the things you have mentioned, totally agree. But, with that same understanding, you also have to accept that if you continue to implement the same policies, there have also been a series of frauds, and that is an objective fact. I understand that you have done a great job; but you also have to share with me that the system has not functioned in its entirety or, at least, not as well as you want to make us believe, because these same days we have also seen how many players have evaded taxes or have not contributed with the first idea I mentioned, with the idea of community.

Moreover, from everything I have mentioned, there is an adulteration of the competition itself, with all the economic and sporting consequences that this entails. Illicit means are being used to compete advantageously against the rest.

I also agree on a diagnosis and the usefulness of overcoming the fraud you have mentioned, because we are aware of the economic situation. In the coming years, as has been announced, there will be an adjustment of twenty-six billion euros. The pension fund is running out, the gap between the rich and the poor is very large, the poverty rate I believe is too high, and the unemployment rate, evidently, is at shameful figures for everyone.

In that context, Mr. President, it seems at least strange that no one detected the ostentation of luxury of some players and contrasted it with the reality of their tax declarations, because there are people, there are players, who have sold their image rights for one euro and who have given us information about companies that they did not use at all. In fact, they have been aware of all of that.

To conclude, while some traveled on a private jet, they were stealing taxes from those who have their needs, their great needs, on the ground, from those who are suffering, from many. And I repeat the question. Obviously, you will also have us to collaborate, but we need to define what measures you are going to adopt to ensure greater control of fraud, and we will not accept the response of another tax amnesty, because it will not be acceptable.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Bildarratz. You have made a series of considerations. First, is the system improvable? Absolutely. More than 50 billion euros have been collected in these last four years. Probably, more could have been collected; but it is much more than has been collected in other stages of history.

You talk about an adjustment of twenty-six billion. No. Initially, from 4.6 to 3.1 percent this year will be fifteen billion euros, but the cycle is evident that will also allow us to increase revenues without making any decision.

I do not know if this adulterates the competition or not. That would already be a debate for a note that exceeds the two minutes and fifty-one seconds I have to speak. Probably, and we all know this, there are clubs with greater resources and that is why they can pay higher salaries. This is the case here and everywhere; but it would already be complicated for the Government to also set the salaries of football players. I am absolutely convinced that this is not what you are proposing here.

What I want to say, which is where I have to go, and it is to the greater, is that this Government has demonstrated its willingness to fight against fraud. Back in 2012, we approved the Anti-Fraud Law. I do not want to exhaust you or bore you; but there, the limitation of cash payments to 2,500 euros was approved, the system of modules of personal income tax was reformed, the obligation to report on accounts and assets located abroad was established, the Penal Code was modified with the modification of tax crime to create an aggravated type for cases of special gravity, that is, amounts exceeding six hundred thousand euros.

In 2014, the instruments for fighting fraud in the area of VAT and corporate income tax were also reformed, as well as the reform of the General Tax Law in 2015, and this very year, and we are going to bring it here soon, to the Senate, if Congress approves it first, we are going to increase control and reduce fraud in taxes such as VAT, and we are going to reduce the maximum limit of cash payments to one thousand euros. We are going to once again strengthen the human and material resources of the State Tax Agency.

We have done a great job, as you know very well, at the international level, signing agreements with the four major countries of the European Union. From this very year, the demand for transparency for multinationals has increased. We have promoted very important bilateral agreements for the exchange of tax information.

We have done things, and we are willing to continue doing them, and, as I told you before, we are willing to accept the suggestions you want to make. However, the path to follow is the one we have carried out over these years simply because it has worked. In fact, the plan of the State Tax Agency for next year will reinforce the investigation of assets and income abroad, international taxation, and the fight against tax havens and other higher value-added services.

From there, both the Prosecutor's Office and the courts of justice, independent powers as you know, have made important decisions that affect, as I told you before, very important football players who play in teams that have many fans in our country. Those have appeared in the media. I would like no one to have any problems with the Treasury because everyone complied scrupulously with their obligations.

This is like the homeowners' associations you referred to in your first intervention. They are really a magnificent place, and I could talk to you about that for a while, to learn something as important as human condition, because there you can distinguish between good and manifestly improvable.