Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

31 January 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions on the 2003 Yakovlev crash victims' families and rising electricity prices during a January 2017 congressional control session.
Main themes
Yakovlev air tragedy accountability, apology to victims' families, military aviation safety, parliamentary questioning of the Prime Minister, electricity price regulation, defense ministry responsibility, democratic transparency, tribute to fallen soldiers
Duration
~21 min
69th percentile
Words
2,572
69th percentile
Sentences
106
66th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
3.19
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
24th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 49%47%
  • Institutional 25%25%
  • Ceremonial 17%16%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

106 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Antonio Hernando, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Hernando.- Madam President, Honorable Members, Mr. President of the Government, on May 26, 2003, 62 Spanish soldiers returning from a mission in Afghanistan lost their lives when the plane they were traveling in crashed, a plane that should never have taken off. The accumulation of irregularities surrounding that flight makes it unjust for us to speak of an accident, because accident sounds inevitable, and that disaster could have been avoided.

Many voices were raised speaking of the poor situation, the bad condition of the aircraft. Even the military confessed to their families that they were more afraid of those flights than of their missions in Afghanistan. Unfortunately, no one listened to them, and they lost their lives fulfilling their duty because others did not fulfill theirs.

After the disaster, one of the most shameful events in our recent history occurred: a Government, of which you were a part, was in a hurry to close the matter, and the identification process was a fraud. Families who awaited recognition, who awaited truth and justice, received contempt and, in some cases, threats.

The person ultimately responsible for all of this was the then Minister of Defense, Mr. Trillo; someone who since then has neither retracted nor apologized for such ignominy; someone who should have disappeared from Spanish political life and who, however, his Government appointed as ambassador; and someone who has recently shown us again his moral character by saying that he is going to return to the Council of State.

But these are not events of the past. Fourteen years have passed, but the families of the victims have had to fight tirelessly to achieve justice and truth, and they are succeeding. The latest proof of that truth is the opinion of the Council of State, which must become a fair and not miserly resolution from the Ministry of Defense. In light of the evidence, your Minister, the Minister of Defense, has apologized. Now it is your turn, Mr. President of the Government, who met with the victims yesterday, finally, after almost five thousand days, and today you have the opportunity to solemnly apologize to the deceased, to their families, and to the Spanish society to whom those soldiers served.

For the dignity of them and our democracy, you should, Mr. President, apologize.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Hernando. I appreciate your interest in this matter, but I have been President of the Government for five years, and not a single member of the Socialist Party has asked me a question in this Chamber or anywhere else in the General Courts about this issue.

I want to say that, indeed, the air tragedy of the Yakovlev was one of the most terrible events in our recent history and has caused great pain not only, as is evident, to the families and loved ones of the victims but also to our Armed Forces and to the entire Spanish people. Therefore, I want this brief intervention to begin by paying tribute to the victims of that tragedy, to their families and their comrades, to whom I reiterate the support of the Government and of all Spanish society.

I also want to extend this recognition to all those who work for our defense, for our security, and for maintaining peace in places far from our country. They do so with invaluable patriotism and commendable sense of duty, honor, and dedication to others.

I want to reiterate and take as my own the words that the Minister of Defense pronounced in this same Chamber a short time ago. I take her words as my own because I believe it is just.

Yesterday I was with the families of the victims; a frank, cordial meeting. I listened to them and shared their feelings. I am absolutely aware, and I have told them, that there is no possible consolation in the death of a loved one; but we want to help mitigate part of that pain with the resolution to which you have referred and, above all, the most important objective for the future, without a doubt, will be to prevent such events from ever happening again.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pablo Iglesias, of the Confederal Parliamentary Group of Unidos Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. Mariano Rajoy, what measures does your Government plan to take regarding the rise in electricity prices?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Iglesias.

As you know, the price of electricity, in addition to taxes, has two parts: one, free, which is set by the market, and another, regulated, which is set by the Government. I am not going to tell you, because it makes no sense and you know it, how we found things at the time and the decisions we had to make. What I can tell you is that the regulated part, which depends on the Government, which is 42 percent of the bill, has been frozen for three years, and last year it decreased by 2.8 percent. The problem we have today is in the free part, that is, the part that depends on the market. This has risen, and why has it risen? Because, since the minimum price in January of last year, 2016, oil has risen by 112 percent, natural gas by 130 percent, and coal by 113 percent, and therefore, it is normal for there to be an increase in the price of electricity.

Moreover, the weather conditions do not help. Can we produce electricity? Yes. With hydroelectric or wind power plants, water or wind, it is cheaper to do so than with gas or oil. It is incredible that this still needs to be explained, because it seems that it is not understood, but it is so. The situation in France and other factors do not help either. But, I insist, the most determining factor is the increase of one hundred percent in the price of oil, natural gas, and coal.

This has not only happened here; it has happened in all European countries. Bills in France, Switzerland, Italy, Belgium, and other countries have risen more than in ours.

What will happen, which is the most important thing, over the course of the year? We are now at 2015 prices. Last year, 2016, was exceptionally good due to the drop in the price of oil and gas. We are, therefore, at 2015 prices, but at cheaper prices than in the previous years 2013 and 2014. And it has been precisely the decisions made by the Government that have allowed us to freeze the fixed part of the rate, which have led us to be at 2015 prices and not in a much worse situation that would have occurred if we had not made the decisions that I hope you will applaud in the second part of your intervention today.

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. Mariano Rajoy, I thank you that on this occasion, in addition to looking at the sky and waiting for it to rain, you have given some further explanation. As you will agree with me that the rise in electricity generates enormous social alarm among Spanish citizens, I am going to propose that we be constructive in this control session. I am going to propose five measures that your Government could take, and I will ask you to note them and tell me whether you think they are good or not. I believe it is a very sensible way, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, for us to address each other.

The first measure I propose: to conduct an audit of the costs of electricity generation in Spain. If that audit tells us that, indeed, the costs of electricity generation are very far from the final price, then we change the pricing system and limit the abuses of the electricity oligopoly.

The second measure: to tax the so-called windfall profits of nuclear and hydroelectric plants.

The third: to recover public management of hydroelectric plants when the concession expires, thus preventing speculation on stored water.

The fourth: to eliminate the "sun tax" and thus truly promote self-consumption.

And the fifth: since electricity is a basic necessity, I propose that we reduce the VAT from 21 percent to the super-reduced rate of 4 percent or, at least, to the reduced rate of 10 percent. You cited examples from other countries; I am not proposing anything strange: in Italy, it is at 10 percent; in the United Kingdom, at 5 percent; and in Belgium, it is at 0 percent.

Finally, as I have thirty seconds left, I will also ask you if you do not find it unacceptable that there are former ministers and former presidents of your party and the Socialist Party who still sit on the boards of directors of electricity companies.

President.- Of the five proposals you have made, I only agree with one, which is the first; but the problem we have is that the model has already been audited and is audited continuously. I do not agree with any of the others. Above all, there is one, which is the issue of self-consumption. Look, people who have self-consumption...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Albert Rivera, of the Citizens Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rivera.- Mr. President of the Government, the Court of Auditors in 2014, but it has done so again in January 2017, has informed us Spaniards of something that neither you, in your Government, nor the previous Government of Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero had explained to us. It has told us that it costs Spaniards, it will cost us, the bill for the looting of the political savings banks 41 billion euros of public money and 19 billion from the Bank Deposit Fund.

Mr. Rajoy, in Spain we have had to raise taxes and make cuts in health and education, while in this country looted savings banks have been rescued, as is being seen in the Courts, by some former political officials.

The main characteristic of these savings banks is not that they are poorly or well managed; it is that there are former ministers and former presidents of Autonomous Communities from the PP or the PSOE, or from other parties, at the head of this ruin. And I ask you, Mr. Rajoy: with a report from the Court of Auditors --which is not from Citizens, nor from the PP, nor from the PSOE, it is a report from the Court of Auditors-- that says that there are 41 billion that have gone to waste, literally, of public money, what does the Government plan to do to investigate that hole? Are you going to stop blocking, as the PP and PSOE did yesterday in the Table, the investigation of the savings banks' hole, or will you continue to agree with the PP and PSOE that it cannot be investigated in parliamentary proceedings that looting of public money from the pockets of Spaniards?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Rivera. Without a sound banking system, there is neither credit, nor investment, nor growth, nor employment, nor economic recovery.

When we came to power, the situation of our banking system was, as you know very well, of immense weakness, and we had to act so that there would be economic recovery in Spain. But we did not do this alone; the vast majority of countries in the European Union did this: Germany supported its financial institutions with 8 percent of its GDP; Ireland, with 31 percent; Greece, with 22 percent; Slovenia with 18 percent; Cyprus, with 18 percent; Spain, with 5 percent; Luxembourg, with 5.5 percent; the Netherlands, with 4.8 percent, and so we could continue.

You talk about a rescue. If we had done nothing, what would have happened to the savings banks? A disorderly bankruptcy of the entities, which would have destroyed confidence in the Spanish economy. Why has the Italian Government now had to give 8 billion euros to Monte Paschi di Siena Bank? Because, if not, the entity would be liquidated in an unorderly manner, generating a huge problem that undoubtedly and greatly affects the situation of the Italian economy.

What we have done is defend savers and depositors, who were beneficiaries of the decisions made by the Government; and also the people who worked in the various financial entities.

Therefore, what we have done is recapitalize the system, restructure the sector, remove the executives, limit salaries, and direct ourselves to the prosecutor, who, as you know, has already acted. We have done what was necessary. I could not do anything different, which is exactly the same as what the rest of the countries in Europe have done, and if not, we would have had bankruptcy in our financial system and very serious economic problems that would have affected us all.

Mr. Rivera.- Mr. Rajoy, you have not answered my question. I asked you not about the rescue, but whether we are going to investigate why 41 billion have disappeared from the pockets of Spaniards, with former politicians at the head of those savings banks, which is enough and we need to speak clearly: these are former politicians put by you and the PSOE at the head of savings banks, who have ruined them, which has been paid for by Spaniards with cuts and higher taxes. We want to investigate it, we want to know the truth.

And, Mr. Rajoy, you did not need to lie: "Rajoy claims that banking will not cost citizens anything." This is a lie, Mr. Rajoy. Just as Rodríguez Zapatero said that we were in the Champions League, and that was also a lie. The problem is that you lied. You told Spaniards that it would not cost a dime, and look, the Bank of Valencia was sold for one euro; it was sold for one euro. That is a scam in every sense, because you told us it would not cost a dime, and it has cost us 41 billion. And we want to investigate it in parliamentary proceedings.

Mr. Rajoy, the political map has changed. The PP and PSOE can no longer agree in silence. I ask you to stop sweeping the dirt under the rug, because it already smells, and I ask you to let us investigate in parliamentary proceedings, because the Chamber has changed...

President .- Mr. Rivera, it is important not to forget the reality. In the latest tests by the European Central Bank, it is stated that, out of 130 banks that have been tested regarding asset quality, the Spanish banks have the best results and are second in the situations to which a stress test has been applied.

The most important thing is that there is credit in our country: credit for individuals, credit for families, credit for SMEs, and credit for large companies. The most important thing is that the risk premium, which was above seven hundred basis points, is now at a little over one hundred basis points. This is what the restructuring of our financial system has achieved. We have done exactly the same thing that the vast majority of European countries have done. Now it turns out that you will be the only person in Europe who has a different criterion from the one we all have. Therefore, I insist…