Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

16 May 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to opposition questions during a parliamentary control session in Spain's Congress of Deputies on 16 May 2017, defending his government's handling of corruption scandals.
Main themes
Corruption in the Popular Party, government response to corruption, ministerial accountability, judicial independence, parliamentary control, presumption of innocence, blackmail allegations, contract rigging in Madrid, anti-corruption measures, political credibility
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,652
70th percentile
Sentences
96
61st percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 80%77%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

96 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Antonio Hernando, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Hernando.- Mr. President of the Government, yesterday all the Groups in the Chamber, except yours, from the Popular Party, condemned the Minister of Justice, the Attorney General, and the anti-corruption prosecutor. We condemned them, but the recipient, of course, is you, and that is why I have two questions for you: first, do you consider that keeping them in their positions is positive for the credibility of Justice, and second, do you consider that the Government's reaction to the corruption cases we have known is adequate?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Hernando.

To the first question, I answer yes. I have full confidence in the people you have referred to.

Regarding the Government's reaction to corruption, it pursues four objectives: the first, to prevent it and, therefore, to improve controls; second and third, to pursue it and uncover it, and for that, we must support those who have that function entrusted to them by our Constitution and our legal system; and the fourth major objective would be to punish it. To that end, we have increased sanctions.

Honestly, although it is never enough, we are improving, both in control, as well as in public knowledge of it -- now it is known and discovered -- and in its sanction. But, I insist, we all have to keep persevering.

Mr. Hernando.- Well, Mr. Rajoy, I expected nothing less from you. How can you make them resign or how can you dismiss them if they are doing what you want them to do, which is to stop the avalanche of corruption that is coming down on you!

They are not being loyal to Justice, but obedient to you, a bunch. And that is why you keep them where they are.

But, look, last week news appeared about an alleged blackmail of you by some people regarding the corruption of the Popular Party. Your spokesperson hurried to deny it. But why do we have to have a whole President of the Government at the mercy of and responding to this type of information? Because at the heart of your problems, it continues, Mr. Rajoy, is the black financing of the Popular Party for twenty years, because yesterday we had the umpteenth report from the Civil Guard, in this case mentioning Cristina Cifuentes, regarding the rigging of contracts in the Community of Madrid, Mr. Rajoy, and because you live on edge at the mercy of corruption since those famous SMS; at the mercy of the Courts, and not only at the mercy of the Courts, but also of blackmailers, Mr. Rajoy.

And the Government's reaction is not adequate from the moment your Government delegate in Madrid, when she is indicted, criticizes Justice; the President of the Community of Madrid, when the Civil Guard implicates her, criticizes Justice, and the lawyers of the Popular Party in this document ask that you declare via plasma, Mr. Rajoy. If you live ten minutes from the National Court and do not declare as President of the Government, you declare as President of the Popular Party.

I can already imagine that it is not pleasant for you to go to the National Court and cross glances with lifelong colleagues who are now in the dock; but do not think it is a good procedural strategy to do it from a renovated office in Genoa with black money.

Therefore, look, Mr. Rajoy, if you want to make the citizens believe -- you do not make us believe anything anymore -- that you are seriously fighting against corruption, come on, renounce your privileges and go to declare in person at the National Court. I can tell you another way, Mr. Rajoy: be strong, face the Court, and forget about the plasma.

President.- Mr. Hernando, if you know that I was not going to dismiss the minister or the prosecutors, I do not understand what reasons you have for asking me, especially in parliamentary proceedings, to proceed with their dismissal, especially when you yourself have just acknowledged here that I was not going to dismiss them. You were right, Mr. Hernando. So, I recommend that in the future you do not waste this Chamber's time.

You talk about blackmail and say that someone had to deny that information. I do not even take the trouble to deny it, just as I am not going to deny many of the statements you have just made in this Chamber because, honestly, I am not willing to play the game of some.

What I do want to say is that I can add little more to what I told you last week, the week before, and the week before that in this Chamber. I am not going to reiterate the countless laws that have undoubtedly been useful to improve the fight against corruption and all the means we have made available to those who have to fight. I am not going to tire you, nor would I have time to talk about all the corruption cases that affect your party; I would tell you, Mr. Hernando, to jot down some idea so that we can all be more effective in the fight against corruption; defend the presumption of innocence and do not apply that concept, which is already becoming generalized, called "presumption of guilt," and support the measures we have proposed.

Honestly, I believe that the most important thing in this matter of fighting corruption at this moment is that next Sunday, the 21st, your Pentecost arrives and you stop making merits for one to win and another to lose.

Thank you very much.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Albert Rivera, from the Citizens Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rivera.- Mr. President, last December, after signing the investiture agreement for you to be president, since you had won the elections, Citizens made a series of conditions to change some of the current laws. You told Mr. Hernando to propose some idea. It is true that Mr. Hernando and others do not propose many ideas; but I am going to propose an idea that is in the Investiture Agreement and you will have to commit, because your spokesperson signed it.

Mr. Rajoy, I asked the Vice President about this matter in December, the elimination of the privileges in our Constitution, so that all public officials in this Chamber, the Senate, and the Government do not have any privileges, and if one day someone is indicted, we do not have to go to a special court, nor to a special tribunal, but we go to a natural court.

I want to ask you, Mr. Rajoy: now that some time has passed since the investiture, almost six months, after the response from the Vice President; having already eliminated the privileges in some Statute of Autonomy, like in Murcia; being already in process in Andalusia, and having made the proposal in Castilla y León and in Madrid; Mr. President, to you, who say that we should not only talk about the mess, but talk about proposals, I ask you: is the Popular Party willing to commit to an express reform of the Constitution so that no one from this Chamber has to go to the Supreme Court or any privilege, and we can be judged, if it comes to that, in a First Instance court, by a natural judge, like any other citizen?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Rivera.

I would like to make some comments and submit them for your consideration. As you know, the Legislature has just begun, we have fulfilled many aspects of our investiture agreement and there is time for the others; but this matter that you are interested in is not minor and it is advisable that we do it, because it is not minor, with a broad agreement on the substance of the matter and, also, with an agreement that has the greatest number of agreements possible in this Chamber. And none of this is happening, at least in my opinion, at this moment.

There are some issues that concern me, Mr. Rivera, and on which I believe we must work: Article 71 of the Spanish Constitution states that deputies are inviolable for the opinions expressed in the exercise of their functions, that is, that any of us here can say what we deem appropriate about anyone and that produces no effect whatsoever.

Also, deputies and senators, the Constitution says, have immunity; that is, they cannot be arrested except in the case of a flagrant crime. Nor can deputies and senators be prosecuted or indicted without authorization from this Chamber. And, fourth, it says that they will be judged by the Second Chamber of the Supreme Court. Do we only want to change this or do we not want to change the part related to inviolability, immunity, and authorization to prosecute, because that, without a doubt, is a much greater guarantee for deputies? For what crimes? Only for those not related to public life or for those related to public life, do we not change?

Ladies and gentlemen, senators and deputies going to the Supreme Court have no possibility of appeal. If we make a change, the one you propose, how many instances will they have the right to use in the event that they are convicted?

There are two thousand privileged individuals among public and elected officials; fifteen thousand judges and prosecutors, and 263,000 partial privileges from the Armed Forces and State Security Corps. Does this affect everyone? I, honestly, ladies and gentlemen, believe that we should think about this, as we should think about whether it is good to have some autonomous deputies privileged and not central deputies or senators, because that can affect the principle of equality of Spaniards. Therefore, I propose that we have a debate on this matter, study the issue, and, with knowledge of the facts, bring it here to approve it in due course.

Mr. Rivera.- Mr. President, this conversation you and I had in August before closing the investiture agreement; but you seem to be a scholar of Law instead of an executive. Decisions must be made, Mr. Rajoy. You are not here to ask rhetorical questions: "And what do we do with such and such article? And what could we do with such and such?" Do, Mr. Rajoy; act, change. The Vice President answered me the same as you did in December. Until when, Mr. Rajoy? Do not be afraid to lose the privilege. We do not have to be afraid to go to a court that is not chosen -- do not get nervous; you are very nervous today, I do not know why --.

Mr. Rajoy, what I ask you is to act. You are the Government, we are legislators. Here we have a proposal that we have made known to your Group, not to ask questions of scholars, but to be executives and legislative. Here, in this reform document, in which we talk about those two articles that you say, which I know as well as you do, there is already a signature stamped. The signature of the Citizens parliamentary group is stamped, and with your signature, if you have your word, should be that of Mr. Hernando. 169 seats, and then go look for more seats.

Here we have to execute, Mr. Rajoy. The reforms will be made with the PP or without the PP, but they must be made. Do not be afraid and do not say that this is a mess, because the mess is what you have set up.

President.- I agree, Mr. Rivera, that decisions must be made, but not by getting up early does it appear earlier, and if you go too fast, you run the risk of crashing. The point is for dawn to come, and for dawn to come, it is advisable to study the issues well, instead of being a nuisance with the past, look to the future and make concrete proposals.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Gabriel Rufián, from the Esquerra Republicana Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rufián.- Mr. Rajoy, a curiosity, do you have anything to say to the thousands of people who have made, are making, and will probably make hours-long queues at the passport control of the Prat airport?

President.- Yes, Mr. Rufián, I have something to say to them. The origin of the situation you are interested in derives from a measure adopted by the European Union in the fight against terrorism, which is reasonable, Mr. Rufián -- it is enough to remember the unfortunate terrorist attacks that have occurred very close to our home, in the United Kingdom, in Belgium, in France, and in Germany --, and the measure adopted by the European Union consists of increasing border inspections of all those people benefiting from the community regime.

I insist, it is about preserving the safety of people, something I think is very reasonable. This, which I insist is a European measure, is something very commendable and what generates problems. What we are working on now is to solve those problems, because in what is happening today in many airports in the European Union we are all coordinated and we are taking measures to ensure that the inconveniences are minimal. I hope that within a few days you will no longer have to ask me this same question, because there will be no cases or inconvenience for people.

Mr. Rufián.- The truth is that I also hope so, Mr. Rajoy, Mr. President. In the meantime, we ask for some idea from the Esquerra Republicana Parliamentary Group. In fact, we demand that you tell your number two, Mr. Nieto, alias "the friend of the Dalton brothers," and we also ask you to tell your number one of the Interior, Mr. Zoido, alias "we are not fools, we would hide like before," that all those police, all those policemen, who are at demonstrations, at evictions in "Operation Catalonia," in "patriotic brigades," and, above all, hitting and shooting in El Tarajal, that they be sent to the passport control of the Prat airport in Barcelona. And, above all, that they stop making a fool of themselves at passport control, at least until in the future Catalan republic we take control of the airport, if that is what your people want.

Thank you very much and good morning.

President.- Mr. Rufián, one can ask for things and make proposals without the need to disrespect people, because, besides, it costs nothing; you would look very good, and maybe we would even find you a nice gentleman; but, look, things are as they are.

I will try to respond to you. I already told you before that we are facing a security problem. What we are doing is the following: increasing the number of agents to address the growing number of passengers, which are many; increasing the number of computer equipment and the number of assistants to help passengers, and we will conduct weekly follow-ups to ensure that things go well in the future.

Now, since we are talking about things, you could also do the same in the Barcelona Metro so as not to always blame what happens on that indeterminate legal concept you call "Madrid," because in the Metro there are strikes, there are crowds, there are platform problems, and there are also Mossos d'Esquadra doing exactly what you say the National Police does, which they do not.

Therefore, Mr. Rufián, I will take care of my obligations; you take care of yours and do not make politics simply an exercise against Madrid, because you have many competencies to exercise and you are causing a lot of harm to the citizens. Just look at the Barcelona Metro.