Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

22 May 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy addressed the Spanish parliament during a parliamentary control session on May 22, 2017, responding to questions about Spain's response to the WannaCry global ransomware attack.
Main themes
WannaCry ransomware cyberattack, national cybersecurity strategy, government response to cyberattack, critical infrastructure protection, National Cybersecurity Center, international cooperation on cybersecurity, coordinated action protocols, Spain's ranking among affected countries, Manchester terrorist attack, future cyber threats
Duration
~51 min
94th percentile
Words
6,101
94th percentile
Sentences
229
92nd percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.28
80th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 66%60%
  • Technological 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

229 sentences in 94 paragraphs

Mr. President, on May 12, a massive cyberattack was launched with a ransomware virus, "WannaCry," which, according to the latest data provided by the National Cybersecurity Council, affected more than 360,000 computers in 180 countries around the world. Spain ranks 18th in the list of affected countries, with 1,200 devices, and a logic of social alarm has been created among users, companies, and Public Administrations responsible for managing essential public services, such as hospitals, emergency services, public transport, and so on.

This virus and its variants have triggered the largest known cybersecurity crisis to date on a global scale, and have highlighted a significant security gap in our society. Cybersecurity experts warn of even worse and latent threats that can be activated at any moment.

Surprisingly, so far, there has been no detailed information or assessment from the Government regarding what happened in Spain, other than some generic comments. My question is: what kind of measures were taken by the Government of Spain and, above all, what urgent responses does your Government plan to provide to address the foreseeable cyberattacks that may occur in the immediate future, in order to protect the State's infrastructures, companies, and users from such threats?

President.- I want to begin this intervention by saying that I join and endorse each and every one of the words spoken by Mr. Álvarez Areces regarding the savage terrorist attack that occurred last night in Manchester.

I would like to start this intervention on a topic that I consider important and that, without a doubt, I believe it is, by explaining what has happened since the morning of Friday, May 12.

From mid-morning, data began to be received about the existence of a computer virus that encrypts the information on computers, kidnaps it, and requests a ransom to recover it. It does not extract data or information; it only kidnaps it and asks for a ransom in electronic currency. This virus also spreads automatically across the network without user intervention.

The second comment is that this type of attack, as you hinted in your intervention, is relatively common; but it is true that on this occasion, the impact has occurred on many countries at once and in a very significant way. We are indeed the 18th country out of 180 that have been confirmed to be infected with the virus. There has been a massive attack.

And the third point I want to highlight is that the spread in Spain was quickly controlled, because by 7:00 PM that Friday, a vaccine had already been developed to prevent the virus from entering more computers; a vaccine that was later used, after obtaining the necessary consent, by other affected countries.

In general, I would like to say the following: we live in increasingly connected societies, so a secure cyberspace is one of the greatest challenges we will face in terms of security; terrorism and this.

In 2013, as you know, with the support of your party, we approved the National Security Strategy, which stated that one of the greatest challenges to be faced was this. Then, also in 2013, we approved the National Cybersecurity Strategy, and in 2014 we created the National Cybersecurity Center, which is headed by the director of the CNI. Little by little, we have been increasing our capabilities; I believe we are in a good position compared to other countries in our environment, and I insist, the creation of the National Cybersecurity Center in 2014 guarantees the coordination of all available resources.

What should we do now, considering that we are not dealing with an easy issue? First, persevere in what has been done; then, improve the means, not cease in efforts, and, most importantly, increase collaboration with our allied partners. This is undoubtedly a problem that has only recently begun, that affects all countries in the world, and, just as with terrorism, increasing collaboration with them seems to me to be a key objective.

Mr. Álvarez Areces.- Mr. President, I believe your explanation addresses some aspects but, from the perspective I present, it is unsatisfactory, and I will explain why.

I know that, regarding the realm of Public Administrations, in a decentralized country like ours, there has been no early warning system, no coordinated action protocol, nor information directed to essential public services of the Autonomous Communities or Local Administrations.

I am not here to criticize what has been done or the things that have not been done well in this type of action, but rather to look to the future. I want to look to the future because I believe that what we are dealing with is of exceptional importance, and we must know that the risks are very high and that the need to respond urgently to the challenge of cybersecurity, by developing a global strategy, does not allow for any delay.

Everyone knows that cyberattacks can pose a greater threat than traditional terrorism; what happened today has been very serious, but it can be worse.

Cybercrime develops its threats with increasingly sophisticated means to steal or encrypt files from users, companies, and governments, to collapse computers and demand ransoms in bitcoins, the virtual currency, which leaves no trace in transactions.

Those who devised the attacks, as pointed out by Microsoft President Brad Smith, were able to do so thanks to a vulnerability stolen from the U.S. National Security Agency. That is to say, public agencies design this type of virus which, when stolen, are used by cybercriminals and influence actions and cause extraordinary damage.

We live in a world where the vulnerability of systems is used by governments without judicial control and, moreover, putting at risk that these viruses, as I say, are stolen and used for the benefit of criminals.

By the way, did the Government inform the Prosecutor's Office of these facts to open a thorough investigation into what happened in Spain for crimes of fraudulent access and extortion, as has been done in other countries?

What is happening is not an isolated and anecdotal event; it reflects a growing trend in the realm of international relations and the economy as a whole. The trend towards the rapid expansion of the Internet of Things increases that risk, as does the digitization of our industry.

The European Digital Agency has also raised a series of protocols of which, as a member country, we must participate, because the Digital Agenda is unstoppable, but it is unthinkable that digitization arises without elements of cybersecurity attached to it, because the dangers are extraordinary.

The European Union has established protocols for member countries, mechanisms for cooperation among them, also directed at companies and digital services for risk management and Public Administrations. They obligate operators of critical infrastructures, as well as financial services, transport, energy, and health; IT service companies, app stores, e-commerce platforms, online payment services, cloud computing, search engines, and also Public Administrations. In Spain, which is a decentralized country, Public Administrations cannot wait for each one to react as best they can, but rather common and coordinated protocols and strategies must be established.

That is why I believe that, in light of the deficit of actions, we must prevent by coordinating actions and doing them together by specialized services and with the necessary precautions. I believe that in this Senate, as a territorial chamber, a meeting could naturally take place in that direction to work together with the Spanish Public Administrations, the Autonomous Communities, and Local Entities, represented by the FEMP, to inform them of what has happened, also to draw conclusions and to implement a coordinated strategy among the Public Administrations that configure the structure of the State in Spain to prevent future cyberattacks and mitigate risks.

I believe that this is working positively, looking to the future. It will happen again, and experts say it will happen again, perhaps with risks much greater than those we have faced now. We offer our collaboration, but this is not just a political realm; it is a realm of how the entire set of State Administrations, civil society, companies, and users function. That is what we want to have, and we await your response.

President.- Mr. Álvarez Areces, I want to say that we have taken this matter, which is not easy, as I mentioned earlier, seriously. I remind you: in 2013, we approved the National Cybersecurity Strategy; in 2014 we created the National Center, and, as I mentioned in my first intervention, by 7:00 PM that Friday, the spread of the virus was controlled.

From there, there are some things that, without a doubt, I think we must do. The first is to give importance to this matter, and I agree with you that we are facing a security threat only comparable to terrorism. The second is to reach an agreement among all political forces: we can certainly discuss many things; but on a matter of this nature, it does not seem to me to be the most reasonable. Third, continue with the efforts that have already been applied for some time. Fourth, I believe that international collaboration is fundamental. Just as intelligence services are essential in the fight against terrorism, so too is it when we talk about cybersecurity.

I want to say that on the 17th, the National Cybersecurity Council met, evaluated what happened, and adopted measures aimed at strengthening capabilities and intensifying public-private cooperation, which is also another important issue that we must focus on in the coming months.

It is also very important to raise awareness in society against these threats, so that self-protection measures are adopted to reduce vulnerability.

We are working to enhance the role of the National Cybersecurity Council. One of the key objectives is to improve the monitoring and response capacity of the General State Administration, which must be adequate and proportional to the dimensions of the Public Administrations. And it also seems reasonable, and is an effort we must face in the future, that the General State Administration has a cybersecurity operations center as a horizontal service to all Public Administrations.

It is also worth noting that there are agreements with some Autonomous Administrations, not with all, and also with some important municipalities; but, I insist, we are still, as are almost all, in the first phase of a process that will certainly not be easy because, without a doubt, in the future things like what we have seen will probably happen again.

I agree with what you have proposed. I believe that the Senate is a good space to work together and to do so sensibly, reasonably, and in an orderly manner, because, I insist, this issue, like the fight against terrorism, are issues that affect us all as human beings; not at all as political leaders, but as responsible Spanish citizens, as is the case in other countries. Your proposal is accepted.

Thank you very much.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Ramón Espinar, of the Parliamentary Group Unidos Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea

Mr. Espinar.- First of all, we join in the condemnation of the terrible attack that occurred in Manchester last night and send the condolences of my Group to the entire British people.

Mr. President of the Government, I wanted to know your assessment of the corruption in your party, in light of the judicial proceedings and investigations by the State Security Forces and Corps known in recent days.

President.- Mr. Espinar, my assessment of corruption is always negative, whether it affects my party or anyone else. That is why we are currently working in a threefold direction: first, in prevention, improving controls; second, it is essential to pursue and uncover corruption and provide resources to those who have the obligation to pursue and uncover it; and third, it is also essential to punish corruption, and for that, we have approved, as you know, a series of laws that increase penalties.

I believe that all the measures we have implemented in this direction have been effective, because in many cases, events and acts of corruption that occurred even more than ten years ago are now being uncovered. What we need to do now is to continue persevering in this.

Mr. Espinar.- Mr. President, first of all, welcome back to the Senate, because you have been absent for almost two months for a control session. It is true that you were on a visit. You have been in Brazil, meeting with Mr. Temer. I must tell you that, in terms of corruption, you are like Attila; wherever you go, grass does not grow back, because Mr. Temer is being investigated for serious corruption suspicions.

That said, I know that this topic can heat up the atmosphere and we can have a high-toned and tense debate, and I know that you are a cordial person, so I will try to maintain the most cordial tone possible with you; but you will understand that, in the most cordial tone possible and maintaining respect for the Chamber, there are some things I have to say to you, Mr. Rajoy.

On April 3, 2016, in a television program, which had a large audience, by the way, you said two things regarding your responsibility in matters of corruption. The first thing you said is that "the person responsible for acts of corruption is the one who commits them." Up to that point, I agree. And the second thing you said -- I quote verbatim -- was: "for me to have responsibility, I would have had to commit the act of corruption myself, or a person appointed by me would have had to commit the act of corruption." Well, I agree with that too.

But in the Official State Bulletin from a year earlier, on April 10, 2015, you appointed Concepción Dancausa as the Government Delegate in Madrid, and today Concepción Dancausa is being prosecuted for fraud in Mercamadrid. I hope you have something to say regarding your Government Delegate, appointed by you and with your signature, in the Official State Bulletin.

But you, Mr. Rajoy, are not only the president of the Government; you are also the president of the Popular Party, and in the Popular Party, as you would say, some things are happening, and I want us to discuss those things.

The person who was president of the Community of Madrid until two years ago, and whom your party appointed because Mrs. Aguirre left, Mr. González, is in prison for leading a criminal organization; a criminal organization whose epicenter was the Canal de Isabel II, in which the current president of the Community of Madrid, your vice president, two councilors, and the parliamentary spokesperson for the Popular Group in the Assembly of Madrid were advisors when this was happening.

Mrs. Cifuentes, as all of you always seem to do, seems, as the song by Aute says, to have just passed by and not noticed anything; but the truth is that in a board meeting, one should notice something.

But we not only have the problem of "Operation Lezo"; we have other judicial operations underway, such as "Púnica" and "Gürtel," for which you yourself, Mr. President of the Government, will have to go to court to testify. It is true that as a witness, but you will testify as a witness regarding the corruption of the party you lead. And I ask you a question: can you imagine this happening in any democracy in our environment?

I ask you the question sincerely, looking you in the eyes: can you imagine in the United Kingdom, in Germany, in France, or in Portugal that the president of the Government or a prime minister had to testify in court because the judge has proven that their party has been illegally financed, because the Court of Auditors has said that their party ran with more money than it should have in the elections of 2007 and 2011? Do you know what would happen in any democracy in our environment, in any democratic country? Elections would be called, political leaders would go home, and they would not run for election again.

That is why my Group, that is why my party, along with our sister political forces, have had to make a motion of censure, because you are not going home out of decency. So let’s see if luck has it that you do so because of the motion of censure from Unidos Podemos.

But look, the problem is not just corruption; the problem is that in this country today, everyone suspects that you are using some State institutions for your own benefit. Mr. Moix, the Attorney General, was, according to a recording heard between your former parliamentary spokesperson, Eduardo Zaplana, and the former president of the Community of Madrid, Ignacio González, "a great guy." I have no problem with Mr. Zaplana and Mr. González considering Mr. Moix however they want or with him being their candidate for Attorney General; the problem is that a few months later, he became Attorney General as the candidate of a corrupt person, Mr. Rajoy.

Therefore, there is serious suspicion about the control of the State apparatus and the media, and I am not the one saying it; Mr. González and Mr. Zaplana were saying it on the phone when they said: if you do not control the State apparatus and the media, you are dead. Is that a democratic conception of the State and of relations with the media, Mr. Rajoy?

We are suffering, in addition to your party, a sort of Berlusconization of politics. What did Mr. Berlusconi do? When he was investigated by judges and when he was investigated by the units of the State Security Forces of Italy, he said it was all a persecution, which is exactly what Mrs. Cifuentes is saying.

We have had to endure you, let me tell you, we have had to endure you, lessons on the rule of law, on respect for institutions… You have given us some tirades in Parliament that I do not even want to recount, and one has the feeling that when you pronounce "rule of law," what you might be referring to is a right-wing state that protects you and not the citizens, Mr. Rajoy. And that worries me because your Minister of Justice has been challenged by the Congress of Deputies; not by someone who just passed by, but by the seat of popular sovereignty. And he has been challenged, as you know, because of the mess.

But we have also heard your Minister of the Interior say, in this very chamber, in this very Parliament, that he no longer hides like he used to. What was Mr. Zoido hiding from, Mr. Rajoy?

The Attorney General is in question; the chief notary of the Kingdom is in question; the Minister of the Interior is in question; the previous Minister of the Interior, with proven illegal wiretaps of political opponents… Can you imagine what you would say in other latitudes if wiretaps of a Minister of the Interior on the political opposition were proven, Mr. Rajoy?

And I am not the only one saying this; yesterday the European Union released a damning report on corruption in Spain. So I will tell you with all cordiality that, out of respect for the institutions, because you preside over a party that cheated in the elections of 2007 and 2011, according to the Court of Auditors, Mr. Rajoy, and out of respect for the rule of law, I tell you with all cordiality: go home, Mr. Rajoy.

President.- Let’s see, Your Excellency. I will begin my intervention with some initial statements. I hope you have not called into question the result of the last democratic elections held in Spain, because that is what I understood from your intervention, because that is what has happened.

Second, it is absolutely false that my party or my Government control the State apparatus in the sense you just referred to here.

It is absolutely false that my party controls any media; if anything, yours, which was criticized by the Press Association for attacking journalists. Your Excellency, I will not remind you of some of your tweets on the Internet about certain journalists in this country. Find one of mine similar to those you published in your day.

Fourth, Mr. Espinar, one cannot speak so lightly. You have named many people here, and none of those people have been convicted by the courts. There is something very important about the rule of law, which I do want to talk about, which is the presumption of innocence, which some now seek to replace with the presumption of guilt.

I will not cite anyone. You have cited many people here; you are missing one, for example, a person referred to the other day in your intervention by Mr. Luis Aznar, who is sitting there. Mr. Luis Aznar referred to a person, did he not?, and I will do exactly the same. Therefore, I will not refer to that person to whom Mr. Luis Aznar referred.

As your national leader said, what needs to be done is to "make a fuss," because I suppose that is where you handle things best. I am fully aware that what I may say to you here does not concern you at all. You do not care what I say to you, and therefore, you do not expect me to respond to anything; but I would like to say a few things.

I believe in the rule of law, I do believe in it, and I believe in the presumption of innocence. I know that this means absolutely nothing to you. The only positive thing you have is a great capacity for work, because you are, at the same time, a private prosecution, prosecutor, investigating judge, and tribunal that resolves people's problems, and, if you let them, a newspaper director.

Ladies and gentlemen, I see things differently. I believe in the separation of powers; yes, I believe in the separation of powers. I believe in the rule of law; I believe that the Judiciary acts with absolute independence; we condemn all kinds of corruption, ours, that some people in our party have committed, and we have acted, but also that of others. We do not do like some who only see what happens to others. We respect the institutions. We do not have deputies who, when summoned by the Supreme Court, say they are not willing to go before the Supreme Court. If everyone in Spain did the same, what kind of country would we build?

We do not have judicial insubordinates, Mr. Espinar, we do not have them, nor do we say that the Civil Guard is good when it makes reports that may refer to someone from the Popular Party and then label the aggressors of the Civil Guard as victims, as other political forces do. We do not do that.

Ladies and gentlemen, do not get angry, because that does not lead to anything at all. I see you angry. Don’t I see you angry? Well, then, continue without getting angry; but act with a little balance, sensibility, and moderation, so that they do not have to recommend to you, instead of so much Coca-Cola, to take some herbal tea, which will sit better with you.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Mirella Cortés, from the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana

Ms. Cortés.- Our Parliamentary Group also joins today in condemning the attacks that occurred in Great Britain. On the other hand, I want to say that I am astonished at this staging that has just been made.

Yesterday afternoon, the conference of President Puigdemont, Vice President Junqueras, and Councilor Romeva was held in Madrid; a conference that the President of the Generalitat of Catalonia had requested to hold in this Chamber as a territorial Chamber, but the Senate Board opposed it.

In the Senate, all kinds of events have been held, even wine tastings, as Jokin from the Basque Nationalist Party said this morning. They have even allowed wine tastings, but they have not allowed a discussion on democracy. We are not surprised, considering, for example, that the President of the Commission of Autonomous Communities insulted the Catalan independence supporters by calling us crazy and deviant, and your Parliamentary Group has still not moved a muscle.

Fortunately, the Mayor of Madrid, not an independence supporter but a person of democratic conviction, received and welcomed the representatives of the Catalan Government and allowed the conference "A referendum for Catalonia. Invitation to a democratic agreement" to be held at the Madrid City Hall.

Mr. Rajoy, you were invited and, as always, you dodged dialogue. You dodged getting first-hand knowledge from the Catalan Government about the current situation in Catalonia; you dodged the invitation to a democratic agreement. You prefer to impose rather than listen. This is what we understand.

You, if I remember correctly -- I quote verbatim -- in your investiture speech, which President Puigdemont also recalled yesterday, said: "the Catalan problem is the most serious challenge currently facing Spain." If you acknowledge that there is a problem and even consider it the most serious problem currently facing you, confront it. It is simply a matter of political will.

Mr. Rajoy, we ask you: what is the real will of the President of the Government regarding the majority demand of the Catalan people to decide their future in a referendum? Are you willing to reach an agreement with the Government of the Generalitat of Catalonia so that the citizens of Catalonia can vote?

President.- Your Excellency, thank you very much for your question. You know my answer very well. In a matter such as the one we are dealing with, the President of the Government should not change their criteria; that would indeed be concerning. In any case, I will remind you of it.

My will is to address the real needs of Catalonia and the Catalans; it is my will and, moreover, it is my obligation, which are two different things. And, frankly, I believe we are doing very positive things for Catalonia, while others are engaged in different matters.

In 2012, Catalonia, like, by the way, a good part of Spain, was in a critical situation: with recession, with daily job losses, with competitiveness problems, with macroeconomic imbalances, with a good part of its financial institutions in a practically impossible situation… We have made many decisions, we have had to do many things, and today everything has changed absolutely: there is economic growth, there is employment, and, above all, there are exports… There is a different economic situation.

On the other hand, we have helped the Generalitat. I remember that when we came to power at the end of 2011, the Generalitat was, as you very well know, practically in a state of bankruptcy; it could not finance itself, it could only resort to patriotic bonds and was paying 7.75% interest per year; public services could be attended to with difficulty and suppliers were not being paid. Well, we made many decisions that I sincerely believe were very positive for the interests of the citizens of Catalonia. We continued to invest in infrastructure and in R&D. As always, there are opinions and discussions about whether too much or too little is invested in Catalonia or anywhere else. But I believe we have done positive things over these years.

I believe this may not seem very important to you; to me, it does, because what I have just referred to is the life of the people and is part of my way of understanding politics: I try to solve problems, Senator, and not to create them. Others prefer to appeal to divisions, generating instability, very serious frustrations for a good part of the population. I will never do that.

I am willing to talk about all reasonable matters. What I am not willing to talk about, Senator, is with someone who, in the event that I do not do what he says, threatens me with a Law of legal transitoriness to leave Spain and to carry out one of the greatest absurdities that has been announced in many years. A president of the Government, Senator -- no, neither a president of the Government nor anyone -- cannot accept blackmail, and we will not do so.

Ms. Cortés.- Mr. Rajoy, as I see it, you still have not told us your proposal; but your vice president did give it to us, and the vice president's proposal was that our president come to the Cortes Generales to present his proposal and that we submit to the absolute majority of the Popular Party, the Socialist Party, and Ciudadanos.

Remember, Mr. Rajoy, that the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, after being approved by the Catalan Parliament, was debated in the Cortes and there it was dismissed. On June 18, 2006, the Catalan people voted on it through a binding referendum. Later, the Popular Party, your party, challenged 114 articles, and the Constitutional Court ruled to cut the Statute. For this reason, we now find ourselves in this situation, for this. We have requested more than fifteen times, through the appropriate parliamentary procedures, legislative changes so that a consultation can be held with the people of Catalonia on whether they want to continue being part of the Spanish State or prefer an independent Catalan republic, and you have responded more than fifteen times that no, that the citizens of Catalonia cannot vote within the framework of legality. You expected us to settle and for everything to continue the same, and for us to accept your radial Spain, your centralist Spain, your plundering Spain. Well, no, we do not settle and we will not settle, because if the people of Catalonia are predominantly independentist, it is because for decades they have shown us the impossibility of changing Spain and that the Spanish State be different from what it currently is.

Mr. Rajoy, the best response is to put the ballots out and let the people decide. In Catalonia, there is an immense majority willing to vote, and this is called democracy. Some will vote yes and others will vote no, but we will vote, and I tell you that I will be within my right to vote yes, and perhaps Mr. García Albiol will be within his right to vote no.

If you talk about dialogue and you talk about democracy, do one thing: annul all the judicial processes filed and let us sit down to talk from government to government, from the Catalan Government to the Spanish Government. You always talk about legality, and we want to hold the referendum with full legality; but you refuse to change Spanish legality to make it possible based on your legality, but we have the legitimacy of the Parliament of Catalonia to do it based on our legality.

In the face of the clash of legalities, we continue to talk about political will and dialogue, but if you refuse this will and dialogue, we cannot and do not want to renounce the mandate of the people who elected us.

How far are you willing, Mr. Rajoy, to go to stop the referendum? Drop the charges against those charged for democracy, drop them. Look: while your friends are being prosecuted for corruption, which is increasing every day, ours are being prosecuted for wanting to put out ballots and for drafting a Constitution: Mas, Ortega, Rigau, Forcadell, Simó, Corominas, Nuet, and Barrufet. Drop the charges against those charged for democracy.

Mr. Rajoy, all this being said, we will see each other at the polls this autumn. There is not one step back, not one. You will not stop us, nor will the Constitutional Court, nor all the tricks you use against us. Even so, we are willing to negotiate, as we have always been. In fact, this very morning the Government of the Generalitat of Catalonia has agreed to formally request the Government of the Spanish State to open negotiations on the terms and conditions for holding the referendum.

I ask you again: are you willing to reach an agreement with the Government of Catalonia so that the citizens of Catalonia can vote? And I will add more: are you aware that the political majorities of Catalonia and those of the Spanish State are completely different, and not just now, but systematically? We expect a response commensurate with the question. Do not evade it, Mr. Rajoy; do not evade the question.

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Cortés. You may have one opinion and I may have another different one, I hope; but what you and I, and everyone, are obliged to do is to respect the rules, the laws, the democratic system, and the rule of law.

Senator, what you and you all intend is to bypass the Law, that is what you intend, and moreover, you intend for me to bypass it, as I am the president of the Government; for me to violate it, as I am the president of the Government, to do what you say I have to do with what, on the other hand, I do not agree with. That is exactly the situation.

What would you say if I bypassed the Law, because I deemed it appropriate and convenient, to do something that you did not like? Well, you would say the sensible and reasonable thing: that it was intolerable what the president of the Government had done.

My position is the following: you and I have to do the same, which is to comply with the Law, because that is inextricably linked to the concept of democracy, which is what seems that there are still people who have not been able to understand. And if you do not like the Law, you have every right to change it, and for that, you must talk to those who can do it, and those who can do it are the Congress of Deputies, where there are 350 deputies. I do not know what the members of the Popular Party, nor the Socialist Party, nor Ciudadanos will vote. Well, it seems more reasonable to me that if the majority has a position, the position of the majority should prevail and not the position of the minority, because that is a strange concept of what democracy is.

What I have told Mr. Puigdemont is something that is textbook: that he should go and tell the 350 deputies, who are the ones who can open the possibility for his proposal and that of Mr. Puigdemont to move forward… That he should convince them. I think it is good and positive for him to go to debate and to dialogue, to exercise leadership and to tell everyone, to all Spaniards and to all Catalans, that he is convinced that what he proposes is good and positive for everyone, and that is why he is capable of going there to face them and to debate.

I, of course, if Mr. Puigdemont goes, will debate with him and I will do so with great pleasure, and I hope he has the courage, determination, and bravery to do so. Then, I also hope he will explain to the 350 deputies the threat posed by the Law of legal transitoriness. That is, if we do not do what Mr. Puigdemont or you say, we are not worried at all -- that is what you have said -- for one reason: "we are going to pass this Law," which is one of the greatest absurdities I have seen in the years of democracy that exist in Spain. It is a matter of pure common sense.

But, moreover, this Law is intended to be approved in twenty-four hours, because you have reformed the Rules of the Chamber in one of the greatest abuses I have seen in my life, so that a new Constitution for a country can be approved in twenty-four hours. Please, Senator, do you know of any country in the history of democracies in the world, any, tell me one -- I mean democracies -- in which someone proposes that in one day, one day, a Constitution will be approved, it will be done without debate, without the opposition being able to say anything, liquidating national unity, centuries of history of a country…

This only happens in the worst dictatorships; but Spain, for now, is a democracy and a rule of law, and we are going to preserve it.