Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

12 September 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions from opposition MPs on the Catalan independence challenge, economic inequality, and unemployment in Spain in September 2017.
Main themes
Catalan independence crisis, economic inequality, unemployment and labor market, social welfare and poverty, government economic policy, active employment policies, terrorism, parliamentary accountability, wage purchasing power, long-term unemployment
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,611
70th percentile
Sentences
95
60th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
12.9
55th percentile
Syntax
3.33
84th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 41%40%
  • Economic 31%31%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Social 9%8%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

95 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Margarita Robles, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Ms. Robles.- Mr. Rajoy, my Group is fully aware of the situation this country is facing with the independence challenge in Catalonia and the terrorist threat, and you know better than anyone how we are supporting legality and the defense of the Constitution, with a clear sense of state. But that sense of state we have cannot make us overlook the reality in which many citizens live in this country and, unfortunately, inequality and impoverishment exist in Spain. And that support for the fight against terrorism and the defense of legality cannot be an excuse for not addressing the problems that matter to the citizens.

After ten years of economic crisis and now that the country is growing at 3 percent, it turns out that—Cáritas Diocesana says it; my Group does not say it—70 percent of families in this country do not feel that we have come out of the crisis; one and a half million people receive no income; six million are on the brink of poverty; wages have lost their purchasing power, and today a national newspaper, even "ABC," acknowledges it.

Meanwhile, what are you doing? What you are doing is granting a tax amnesty so that no income enters the public coffers, 42 billion will be lost in the bank rescue, and what you are doing is cutting benefits that many workers are entitled to.

You have a minister who says we are living in the spring of employment. The spring of employment, what is it, Mr. Rajoy? That one in four contracts signed in July lasts less than a week? 21 percent of workers under 55 are registered in employment offices, 300,000 receive no income and cannot contribute to Social Security, and 370,000 have been unemployed for more than two years.

What are you going to do in that situation? Please do not hide behind the issue of Catalonia to continue with your policies of social inequality.

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Robles. I do not hide behind anything. I believe that one thing is the issue of Catalonia and another is the economic policy of the Government and what you may think about it.

I appreciate your position on the two issues you referred to at the beginning of your speech: on the issue of terrorism and on the issue of Catalonia. I think it is a sensible and reasonable position, which corresponds to the Socialist Party; it is very commendable. And I do not share your opinion on the economic situation in Spain.

Spain is a country that has gone through the greatest economic crisis in decades, five consecutive years of negative economic growth; more than three million jobs were lost. The situation was very complex, we had to overcome a rescue, and many institutions could not finance themselves because the markets did not trust them. Many decisions have been made in recent years, and today we can say that things are better.

Undoubtedly, we still have to continue working to consolidate the economic recovery, and what we need to do, in my opinion, to ensure that the long-term unemployed over 55 years old become fewer is, first of all, to maintain the economic policy of the Government, the one we have carried out in these years, which has worked, because it has allowed us to recover more than two million jobs, and to implement it in all Autonomous Communities, in all sectors, in all groups, and in all age groups. And, secondly, what we need to do is improve active employment policies to promote the labor integration of those long-term unemployed and those over 55 years old, specifically.

That is what we intend to continue doing in the future, the same economic policy, because it has worked, and, at the same time, with the agreement of the Autonomous Communities, which is necessary, to improve active employment policies.

Ms. Robles.- As always, Mr. Rajoy, you have not answered me. Stop with theoretical speeches and give practical solutions to the citizens of this country.

President.- In reality, you have not said anything in this second intervention. You have simply said "give practical solutions." Well, some we have given, right? Because the fact that more than six hundred thousand jobs are being created each year is not bad, and I think it is quite practical, and that today in Spain the number of people over 55 who are working is greater than ever, specifically, 3,108,700 people, I think is also a positive figure. Since we came to power, there are 669,000 more people over 55 today than there were at that time.

Therefore, decisions have been made, important objectives have been achieved, and we will persevere in that policy because we believe it works and is useful for the people.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pablo Iglesias, of the United Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea Parliamentary Group

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. Mariano Rajoy, what is your Government going to do to recover the money of the citizens that you used to rescue the banks?

President.- Mr. Iglesias, when we came to power at the end of 2011, Spain was living, as I just recalled, the greatest economic crisis in decades. Difficult decisions had to be made, reforms had to be implemented, and spending that was out of control had to be controlled, and one of the most important reforms was the financial reform. As you know, the existence of a sound financial system is essential for the economy to function, for investment to occur, and for jobs to be created.

We had to restructure some financial entities, recapitalize others, and we did the same as Germany, France, the United Kingdom, and Italy, with similar aid to ours, and there were other countries, such as Greece, Ireland, or Portugal, that even had to dedicate 25 percent of their GDP. We did it with transparency, with the backing of our European partners and international organizations, and the alternative to that would have been bankruptcy, it would have meant that depositors would have lost all their savings, and there would have been a lack of credit, making economic recovery and investment impossible.

Fortunately, thanks to those decisions made by many other countries, Spain did not go bankrupt, we did not need a rescue, depositors kept their money, credit began to flow, investment and consumption started, we have created many jobs, and we have had four years of economic growth. Therefore, it was a very positive decision.

Now we are waiting for, when the privatization of what is still nationalized banking occurs and the sales of SAREB take place, to recover some of the resources we have put in to sanitize the Spanish financial system.

Mr. Iglesias.- Today you have indeed answered my question, but I am surprised by the response. According to you, it is very positive to give away forty billion euros of taxpayers' money to the banks. Three out of every four euros that were used for those aids have been given away by you to the banks. Do you know what this means for many Spanish families to whom the banks do not forgive their debts, to whom the banks have even evicted from their homes?

Allow me, because you spoke of 2012, to remind you of some things you said. You stated here, in parliamentary session, on June 13, 2012—I quote literally—: "this is a loan that the banks will repay." Mr. De Guindos, who is not gracing us with his presence today, stated—yes, he is gracing us with his presence; I had not seen you, Mr. De Guindos—that same June 13, "it will not cost the citizens anything." And the vice president said at a press conference in August—I quote literally again—: "the basic and fundamental objective of the restructuring of the financial system is that it does not cost taxpayers a single euro."

From this, two conclusions can be drawn: the first is that you lied, but this is not a novelty—you lie from the moment you get up until you go to bed; but there is another more terrible conclusion: you did not fulfill your obligation. The obligation of a Government, when it lends money, is to recover it, because it is not your money, Mr. Rajoy. It is not your money; it is the money of all Spanish citizens.

And with those forty billion euros, many things can be done. I will give you some examples: with forty billion we could quadruple the pension reserve; with less than a fifth of what you have forgiven to the banks, cuts in healthcare could have been avoided; with half the money you have given away to the banks, investment in science could have been maintained between 2009 and 2016.

Mr. Mariano Rajoy, you have not only lied; you have shown yourselves to be incompetent.

President.- Sir, I reminded you earlier that all of Europe had to carry out operations of this type.

When we came to power, the previous Government had already given aid worth 15,617 million euros. The only person in Europe, and probably in the world, who understands that this was not necessary was you. What happens is that with your thesis, the Spanish financial system would have collapsed, depositors would have lost 490 billion euros, all the people working in financial entities would have stopped working, there would have been no credit, and there would have been no economic recovery, no investment, and no jobs.

It is advisable to study the issues well because governing is very difficult, and to do less demagoguery than you do.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Albert Rivera, of the Citizens Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rivera.- President of the Government, in the investiture agreement, and also in the agreement we reached with the PSOE at the time, there are many pending reforms in this country that we have committed to make: educational reform, reform of the labor framework, reform of the Public Administration… But there is one of them that, not because it is not urgent, is still important, which is the reform, the updating, the strengthening of our Constitution.

Our Constitution is today, as is being seen, the guarantor of our rights and freedoms. We have one of the best Constitutions in the world, but, like everything in life, it needs to be improved and updated.

And I ask you, Mr. President, if, in accordance with that point 122 of the agreement in which you and I committed to update and improve our Constitution, without whims, without nonsense, with jurists, with people of prestige… I propose to you, Mr. President, not today, surely, nor at this moment when we need to stop the blow to democracy, but in the future, that we start working. I propose to you, Mr. President, that the main parties in this Chamber designate jurists, designate experts, people who can do a great job, to bring us a proposal for updating our constitutional framework.

I want to propose this to you, Mr. President, because today is not a day for whims or immobility; it is a day to look to the future, and as this party supports the Government of Spain without reservation and is a constitutional party, I believe it is legitimate for us to ask whether the Government is willing to start promoting point 122 of the agreement.

President.- Mr. Rivera, I believe that in your speech you have hit upon the key of what is urgent at the moment. I think that today the priority is not so much the reform of the Constitution, a matter I am willing to discuss, of course, and we have also talked about this issue in the moments leading up to the Investiture Debate; I believe that today the priority is to defend the Constitution, as we are doing, the Socialist Group and you, and to defend it against those who want to liquidate it.

Consider that at this moment there are those in Spain who are trying to end national sovereignty, the principle of legality, and the rule of law, which are the basic pillars of our constitutional text. They even want to invent a parallel legality to the one that already exists, bypassing all the procedures proper to the regulations of parliamentary democracies, as has happened on the 6th and 7th of this month in the Parliament of Catalonia.

Therefore, I believe that defending the Constitution at this moment and preventing the nonsense in which some have become entrenched is the priority. From there, I have no objection to discussing what things can be done for the future and, of course, as you have said, with rigor, with seriousness, and without any kind of whims, of which we are unfortunately oversupplied in Spain in recent times.

Mr. Rivera.- Totally agree, Mr. Rajoy; but those of us who love this Constitution and this democracy are the first ones who have to improve it.

Immobility is not the solution, nor is whimsy. The problem in Spain is not that in this case Madrid is a nation, as proposed by the Socialist Party, or Formentera a State, and being a nation of nations; the problem in Spain is to defend the freedoms and equality of our citizens and our nation. That is why we do not want whims nor to join a kind of "show" commission, but what we want is to give the best jurists in this country a proposal, a mandate; to tell them: bring us a document to discuss how we improve our Constitution.

Yugoslavia made a nation of nations in 1974, and we already know how Yugoslavia ended. In contrast, Germany has amended its Constitution sixty times... Yes, yes, read history, do not be scandalized. In 1974, the right to decide of the peoples of Yugoslavia was recognized, and that is a legal and political fact. And, in contrast, Germany and the United States have amended it.

I believe, Mr. Rajoy, that it is much better...

President.- I believe that I have already stated my position in the previous response. However, I would like to point out that this idea of immobility is very relative. Sometimes, there are people who move in the opposite direction to reason, and in that case, the best thing is to stay where you are; especially when you do not know where to go and do not have it clear, stay where you are, because you end up having no problem.

I want to tell you that the Constitution, of course, is not an immutable text; but all constitutions are born with a vocation for permanence. Look, the French one is from 1958, the German one is from 1949, the Italian one is from 1947, and the United States one is from 1787, and there have been minimal changes in all of them; including ours, where there have been very few changes, only two and when it was necessary.

We do not have to build anything from scratch. I believe that the basic pillars of the Spanish Constitution are there, and we agree on them -- not all -- which are national sovereignty, the rule of law, the guarantee of individual rights, and political pluralism.

But I, in any case, as I have said before, am willing to talk with you; but first it would be advisable that this battle we are fighting, and which democracy, the law, and the rule of law, reason, and common sense will evidently win...