Responses of the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

20 June 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy addressed the Spanish Parliament on June 20, 2017, responding to opposition questions about the Constitutional Court's ruling declaring his government's tax amnesty unconstitutional.
Main themes
Constitutional court ruling on tax amnesty, tax regularization procedure, fiscal responsibility, parliamentary accountability, economic crisis management, state duty enforcement, political responsibility, Spain's fiscal deficit inheritance, OECD compliance, comparative tax policy
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,420
66th percentile
Sentences
103
64th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
3.21
73rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
61st percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

103 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Margarita Robles, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Ms. Robles: Mr. President, how do you assess the Constitutional Court's ruling of June 8, which declared your tax amnesty unconstitutional?

President: Your Honor, don't take it the wrong way. I do not assess this ruling or any other. I comply with all of them because I do not think it is appropriate for the head of the Executive to dedicate himself to applauding, criticizing, taking a position, or entering into controversy over the content of court rulings.

Ms. Robles: I did not expect any other response from you. It would be good if other ministers in your Government did the same regarding the assessment of rulings that are not pleasant or comfortable for them; but I will tell you that you, as the President of the Government, as a man of law, cannot remain on the sidelines of what the Constitutional Court tells you. And it will not be this Parliamentary Group telling you.

I will read to you what the Constitutional Court, unanimously, has said, and it has said that "the adoption of measures that, instead of serving the fight against tax fraud, take advantage of it, under the pretext of obtaining revenues considered essential in a scenario of economic crisis --pay close attention, Mr. President--, constitutes the abdication of the State from its obligation to enforce the duty of all citizens to contribute to the fiscal burdens." And furthermore, Mr. President, it says something that, in the opinion of my Parliamentary Group, is of particular gravity, because it says that with your Government's tax amnesty, "you have come --listen carefully-- to legitimize as a valid option the conduct of those who, in an unsupportive manner, failed to fulfill their duty to pay taxes according to their economic capacity, placing them formally in a more favorable situation than the rest of the citizens."

Of course, Mr. President, you naturally have to respect the ruling; but look at what the Constitutional Court tells you unanimously, and at the request of the appeal of the Socialist Parliamentary Group: that "the State's duties have been abdicated in such an important matter as the contribution of citizens." And also, "that tax fraudsters are being legitimized."

Really, if you do not take political responsibility for your Government, with what moral authority are you going to heed other pronouncements of the Constitutional Court? With what moral authority are you going to ask citizens to contribute, at a time like the one we are in, to the tax burdens?

President: It is worth remembering, Your Honor, what we are talking about. That is, the Constitutional Court declares the procedure used for tax regularization unconstitutional, that is, that the Royal Decree-Law was used instead of the Bill. Furthermore, it is also worth remembering that the Constitutional Court itself says that "the ruling will not have effects and, therefore, the actions carried out that are final cannot be reviewed."

That is the truth, and the rest are value judgments. Something different from the truth is the noise you want to make. For my part, I will only make some considerations on this matter.

Spain, at that time, was in a critical situation, on the brink of bankruptcy and on the verge of a bailout, because you left us with a deficit of 9.6% and seventy billion euros less in revenue. That was the inheritance we received. Decisions had to be made that, probably, in other circumstances would not have been made. Not only this one that you are interested in, but also a tax increase --which we later lowered again--, or, for example, the nationalization of the banks, something that you will consider is not the most reasonable in a party like mine nor was it in our electoral program.

Additional revenues were obtained, 1.2 billion euros, and forty billion euros were brought to light that have since always been taxed. This was done in line with OECD recommendations and was done in many European countries, and very important ones, such as the United Kingdom and Italy, or in the United States itself. This tax regularization neither cleans nor erases crimes.

And this tax regularization had also been done in Spain, with a Socialist Government, and on two occasions; but with two differences from the one we did: the first is that we were in a pre-bankruptcy situation, something that did not happen to the Socialist Party, because the last one, in 1991, was in a buoyant situation; and the second is that with you the disclosed incomes did not pay and with us, they did, and with you the fraudsters were not identified, because you gave them opaque promissory notes, and with us, they were. That is the only difference, Ms. Robles.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Aitor Esteban, from the Basque Parliamentary Group (EAJ-PNV)

Mr. Esteban: Mr. President, how do you assess the ruling of the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg regarding the "Atutxa case"?

President: Thank you very much, Mr. Esteban. I just said it now: I do not assess rulings, neither this one nor any other. However, I comply with all of them, as is natural: those of the Spanish courts and also those of the European Court of Human Rights, since Spain is a signatory State of the European Convention on Human Rights. I ask you not to misinterpret me. I never do it, I should not do it, it is not my function, and it would be bad if the President of the Government dedicated himself to commenting, in favor or against, the rulings of Spanish or foreign courts.

Mr. Esteban: Mr. President, the independence of the judiciary is not a bad refuge; but Mr. Atutxa, Gorka Knörr, and Conchi Bilbao were the subject of a public hunt.

Carlos Iturgaiz labeled Atutxa as a presumed criminal who is not in his right mind. Carlos Urquijo: "The judges know what they have to do in the face of disobedience." Acebes accused him of contempt for the rule of law: "ETA only has the PNV left. What happened in the Basque Parliament will have consequences." Mr. Rafa Hernando: "Atutxa must resign immediately because he cannot suppress his sectarianism and nefarious attitude." Mr. Mayor Oreja: "Atutxa is degrading the Parliament and is facing the rule of law."

When the Superior Court of Justice of the Basque Country filed the case, you, Mr. President, said that the prosecutor must urge an appeal, interfering there in the work of the Prosecutor's Office. When the Attorney General of the State, Mr. Conde Pumpido, said that he did not see disobedience in Mr. Atutxa's attitude, the Popular Party called for the Attorney General's resignation, labeling the Prosecutor's Office's action as "shameful" in the Senate. And Mr. Agustín Conde praised the brave attitude of Manos Limpias for filing an appeal, while the Prosecutor's Office decided to accept the filing of the case.

Well, it is by using Manos Limpias that the case reaches the Supreme Court --look, Manos Limpias, eh!, with its leader sent to prison for being a crook and a blackmailer-- and, thus, the Supreme Court changes its jurisprudence; eliminates the "Botín doctrine," creating a difference by seven votes to five. And then, with the invaluable collaboration of Mr. López in the Constitutional Court as a rapporteur --a biased judge if there ever was one, whom you imposed, through the Senate, against other Groups for the Constitutional Court itself--, denied protection violating the right to judicial impartiality, equality, and a process with all guarantees.

Now Europe has partially repaired the outrage; but the disqualification is not removed by anyone, and everything that Mr. Atutxa and his colleagues had to endure, neither. He has been a person persecuted by ETA, even attempting to assassinate him, and then, also politically persecuted with malice. Therefore, I expect from your mouth a redress for what has happened with Mr. Atutxa.

President: Mr. Esteban, the European Court of Human Rights has issued many rulings on matters that have occurred in our country: for example, the banning of Batasuna said it was legal; there is a recent one on the dispersion of terrorist prisoners and said it was legal; the "Parot doctrine," however, it annulled, and this one you are interested in also annulled, although, as you also know, it did not enter into the substance of the matter, but merely stated that the accused should have been questioned as witnesses before the Supreme Court itself.

That is, in some cases, it sided with the Spanish courts and, in other cases, it did not side with the Spanish courts. However, there is a fact that I think is very positive: Spain is the fourth country with the fewest admitted claims per inhabitant before the European Court of Human Rights. It is very interesting to see in this sense the website of the Court itself because it demonstrates the capacity and competence of the Spanish courts.

My position has always been the same and cannot be otherwise: I have to respect and comply with what the Courts say, whether they go in one direction, give me the reason or not. The only thing I want to add, and I think this is the most important thing about the issue you raise with me, is that the rule of law has worked --the rule of law is a fundamental principle of democracy-- and it has worked, yes, the system of control and review of judicial resolutions and appeals. That is the greatness of democracy, that one can be condemned and then acquitted, or vice versa. The rule of law has worked here and also in the European Court of Human Rights. I see it that way, Mr. Esteban.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Baldoví, from the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Mr. Baldoví: Mr. Rajoy, don't you think you have already accumulated enough reasons to start resigning?

President: Absolutely, I think that, Mr. Baldoví. I tell you frankly. Moreover, I believe that my duty is to govern and work to consolidate economic recovery, growth, and job creation in Spain.

There are three reasons why I believe I must govern: firstly, because I lead the party with the largest number of seats in this Chamber, 137 deputies, and the second, 85; secondly, out of respect for this Chamber that only seven months ago distinguished me by giving me its investiture; and thirdly, also because this same Chamber, just a week ago, rejected a motion of no confidence. Therefore, the logical and reasonable thing is for me to fulfill my duty and govern. It is, in short, a matter of democracy and a matter of responsibility, Mr. Baldoví.

Mr. Baldoví: If it had been a motion of confidence, you would not have overcome it.

I will give you ten reasons, as I could give you fifty.

- One, Minister Fernández Bermejo resigned for attending a hunt with a judge. You repeatedly exchanged messages with a criminal, and nothing, Mr. Rajoy.

- Two, Minister Corcuera resigned because the Constitutional Court invalidated two articles of one of his laws. You, as the ultimate responsible of the Popular Party, had a tax amnesty overturned for laundering black money from criminals, and nothing.

- Three, Minister Pimentel, from your party, resigned because the wife of a general director obtained public funds for a company. The party you lead has 65 open corruption cases, 900 public officials have been charged, and the PP is the first party in democracy to be charged with destroying evidence.

- Four, when you were appointed president, 28% of Catalans wanted an independent state; now it is 44%. You should think about it.

- Five, in June 2012 you stated that the bank bailout would not cost citizens, today we already know that the banks will not pay, that it will cost us all sixty billion euros.

- Six, your Government has never met the deficit target.

- Seven, this Parliament has reproached your minister for trying to manipulate Justice in favor of the Popular Party.

- Eight, your former Interior Minister has an open investigation commission for using the Police to spy on parties for his own benefit.

- Nine, the National Court has summoned you to testify for the "Gürtel" corruption case.

- Ten, as a Valencian, I tell you that you have been a real plague: underfunding, underinvestment... You, Mr. Rajoy, cost us a lot of money.

I finish. Mr. Rajoy, you have been everything within the PP: deputy secretary-general, president, you have directed electoral campaigns... Honestly, it cannot be that you were unaware of anything, neither that they pay for electoral acts, nor of the reform of your electoral headquarters. So much ignorance is not possible. Think about it. You would do a great service to this country.

President: I am very sorry, Mr. Baldoví, but your intervention has not convinced me.

You are determined for me to resign but, then, when someone puts forward a motion of no confidence to oust me, you scold them for putting forward a motion of no confidence. No wonder you have been labeled as "conservative elites."

Your Honor,

You have a problem, and that is that the Spanish people do not think like you, and this Chamber does not think like you either. That is the problem you have, and democracy is a system in which people vote, and each person has one vote, and they choose whom they prefer to govern them. The Spanish people have said that the Popular Party, with 137 seats, must assume the responsibility of governing. Perhaps you do not like the democratic system; but I, of course, have to fulfill my obligation, and my obligation is to govern for the reasons I mentioned at the beginning: because this Chamber has given me the investiture, because this Chamber has rejected a motion of no confidence, and because we have more popular support. If you had more popular support, you would have to do it.

You do not have the obligation to govern, nor any of the other obligations that I have, because you have four deputies, but I have 137. The only thing I ask is that, since you do not have the obligation to govern, at least use those four deputies with a little more political level and intelligence.

Thank you very much.