"Rodalies will receive 1.9 billion during this term."

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

28 March 2017

Context
Rajoy gave an interview to La Vanguardia in March 2017, addressing Catalan political tensions, infrastructure plans, and his government's refusal to authorize an independence referendum.
Main themes
Catalan independence crisis, infrastructure investment in Catalonia, referendum rejection, rule of law and legality, dialogue with Catalan leaders, Spanish-Catalan relations, financial assistance to Catalonia, political responsibility, EU integration
Duration
~23 min
71st percentile
Words
2,723
71st percentile
Sentences
146
80th percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
57th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 53%49%
  • Economic 25%23%
  • Geopolitical 15%14%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

146 sentences in 64 paragraphs

And to get down to work, Rajoy has decided to gather a broad representation of Catalan civil society this morning to explain the infrastructure investments that his government has planned, even knowing that the Catalan issue is not just a matter of public works. Nor is it just about financing, although he is not opposed to establishing some mechanism to alleviate Catalonia's debt. In the interview with "La Vanguardia," he reviews the current situation in Catalonia, denies that there is room for a referendum, but concludes that he is absolutely convinced that "this story will end well."

- Is Catalonia today the main problem that your government has to solve?

- I do not believe that Catalonia is a problem. I have come many times and I have never encountered a problem. What is different is that there are certain political leaders who want to create a problem that does not exist by transgressing a basic principle in democracy, which is compliance with the law. That said, indeed, that issue is probably what I dedicate the most time, interest, and attention to, as does my entire government.

- When did it all start? President Montilla, in 2007, already warned of a disaffection of the Catalans towards the Spanish State; was it with the ruling on the Statute that the ties between Catalonia and the rest of Spain were broken?

- I do not know if it makes much sense to ask when it all started. Whether it was three days ago, three months ago, or three years ago. I find it more useful to see how we can overcome this situation of blockage that has become frustrating for everyone. I think it is time to leave behind a stage that has brought nothing good and look to the future.

- But was your position on the Statute a mistake?

- After the ruling on the Statute, we approved two budgets for the Generalitat because CiU and Artur Mas did not have enough votes. So that argument does not match what has been the subsequent reality. This started when, in the face of the crisis, some understood that it was more comfortable to blame the cuts on the poor financing from Madrid. When one does not assume their responsibilities, they end up having problems.

- The PSOE is now talking about rescuing what the Constitutional Court cut.

- I do not know if it makes sense to correct the Constitutional Court. It is advisable that the things we do are respectful of the law and the rulings of the courts. If not, we enter a perverse and undemocratic dynamic.

- In your investiture speech, you said that something had to be done to address the Catalan problem, but you added that you were not clear on what or how. Do you have an answer now?

- My position is clear; I want us to continue living together, as we have done throughout our lives, as all the human, economic, and emotional ties that unite us advise. Also as the current world advises, which demands greater integration; look at what we just agreed upon in Rome, a Europe that can advance at a greater pace. That is my proposal; I know that there are many formulas being considered that are false solutions because I can tell you in advance that there cannot be a solution contrary to legality. There are things we have seen lately that are unacceptable for Catalonia or for any normal democratic place.

- What does the so-called dialogue operation consist of?

- For now, it consists of demonstrating that what is happening here concerns us and matters to us. That we take the demands of the Catalans and the issues that concern them very seriously. For example, infrastructure, the quality of public services, healthcare. We already know what we disagree on, but the question is whether that disagreement should block everything else.

- Is the referendum the only thing that cannot be discussed?

- We can discuss everything except for violating the law. The other thing is the agreements we reach.

- Do you not think that in recent years there has been little presence of the central government in Catalonia?

- These past years have been some of the most difficult for Spanish life in decades. We have had to deal with an unprecedented crisis. They were years of true emergency for everyone, but it is not fair to say that we neglected Catalonia; to begin with, there is financial assistance; since 2012 we have allocated 67 billion euros to Catalonia to guarantee the normal functioning of its institutions. I believe that if we can be accused of anything, it is of not having explained better the enormous work of the Spanish government in Catalonia.

- What did you discuss in your meeting with President Carles Puigdemont at Moncloa?

- I told the president that I cannot authorize a referendum that would liquidate national sovereignty. No country in the world provides for the right to self-determination in its constitution. Only the former Soviet Union, the former Yugoslavia, and Ethiopia did.

- What did the president respond?

- He is fully aware that I will not authorize this referendum because I do not want to and because I cannot. But the most important request I made was that I missed his presence at the conference of presidents where issues that matter to the Catalans would be discussed.

- What do you imagine should be put on the dialogue table between the central government and the Generalitat?

- The first thing that must be put on the table is respect for the rule of law and legality. If we do not start from that basis, it is impossible to move forward anywhere. There is no alternative to compliance with the law other than anarchy.

- In terms of investments, there has been deep discontent in Catalan society for quite a few years, in the sense that their needs have not been met.

- Everyone wants more investments. It is true that we have not lived through the best budgetary period in our history, but it is also true that Catalonia is the only community that has its four provincial capitals connected by AVE, that significant investments have been made at El Prat airport, also in the port, the train connects us with Perpignan, we were the ones who started the construction of the Mediterranean corridor and got the EU to say it was a European priority. We have done things. In the future, more can be done, but I do not think it is fair to say that compared to other regions of Spain that do not have AVE or other things, Catalonia has been left behind.

- Rodalies is one of the main demands of Catalan society. A plan was agreed with Zapatero for 4 billion that Ana Pastor reduced to 400. But of those 400, barely less than 5% has been executed...

- I am aware that, in this aspect, citizens do not want headlines but a realistic and viable plan. I will tell you something that may surprise you; 48% of all investment made in Spain in suburban rail has been here in Catalonia. Now we have developed a plan between 2017-2025 that contemplates an investment of almost 3.9 billion euros, 1.882 in this legislature. But, more importantly, our intention is to share this plan with the Generalitat to coordinate and share responsibility in execution.

- But will Rodalies be a priority in your budgets?

- It will be a priority, and so will the Mediterranean corridor. But we cannot do everything at once; budgets have their limits.

- In the Mediterranean corridor, the third rail between Castellbisbal and Tarragona is paralyzed, and nothing is known about the Vandellòs-Castelló section...

- It is a priority. We have never stopped investing in this project. The Mediterranean corridor is the great work of modernization of the Spanish economy. As for the sections, the Vandellòs-Tarragona section will begin trial operations next year, and the Castellbisbal-Vilaseca section will soon be awarded.

- Regarding autonomous financing, delays continue when it should have been reformed a long time ago; are there options to address Catalonia's demands to improve the relationship between what Catalans contribute and what they receive?

- I was not responsible for this financing system; I did not design it, negotiate it, or vote for it. But creating a model in the midst of an economic crisis, on the verge of being rescued and after losing 70 billion in revenue, and without the State being able to contribute a single euro would have been a monumental folly. Now we have opened a commission of experts in which all the autonomous communities are present except Catalonia. It is absurd to create a model without the Generalitat being involved, but we will have to do it. Catalonia should be there, defend its arguments, and also listen to those of others.

- What deadline have you set?

- Six months to present the proposals of the experts, and then we will submit them to the criteria of the communities in the fiscal and financial policy council.

- Vice President Oriol Junqueras has requested that short-term debts be converted to long-term, which would relieve the Generalitat's finances. Is that possibility feasible?

- It is a matter that can be studied, but I want to remind you of the effort we have all made. When I arrived in government, the Generalitat was financed with patriotic bonds at 7.75% annual interest. Now, it is financed by the State at 0% interest and currently at 0.8%. The effort made by the State has prevented a financial collapse of the Generalitat.

- President Carles Puigdemont has requested to give a conference in the Senate; why is he denied that opportunity to explain himself?

- I am not the one to speak on behalf of the Senate. I understand that he was offered to speak before the General Commission of Autonomous Communities, which is the natural forum for that type of intervention. Everyone wants to hear President Puigdemont, but it is also good for him to listen to others.

- Why do you think it is not possible to hold an agreed referendum someday?

- For that, it would be necessary to first agree on a new Constitution that eliminated the concept of national sovereignty. Until that happens, any self-determination referendum will be illegal, even if I were willing to negotiate it or if Parliament accepted it. It does not depend on us; it depends on all Spaniards.

- When you hear Puigdemont talk about "referendum or referendum," what do you think might happen?

- I regret that there is insistence on presenting people with things that are not possible and that are also being imposed on a very large part of the population that does not want them. That this referendum is not possible is known by Mr. Puigdemont and everyone else because the Constitutional Court has made it clear, as constitutional courts do around the world. No one can be deceived anymore; insisting on that idea does not contribute anything to coexistence or the future of Catalonia.

- If the Government persists in its intentions and tries to hold the referendum, how do you plan to prevent it?

- Let us not anticipate events. But it must be clear that the President of the Government of Spain has certain obligations, and one of them is to ensure that the law is complied with and not to allow it to be violated. Another is to act with proportionality, prudence, moderation, and balance. I will do both.

- Those who are calling for the application of Article 155, what do you think they are asking for? What would applying that article consist of? Would it be a proportionate measure?

- In the worst years of this crisis, especially in 2012, I heard countless times that it was essential to intervene in certain communities to reduce the deficit. I was also told that I had to request a rescue for the economy because we were going under. Well, neither was there a need to intervene in any community, nor did we request a rescue, and here we are. Therefore, Article 155 is in the Constitution and is fully in force, but the State also has many other mechanisms to uphold its legality, as is being seen. Solutions always have to be proportionate and generate the least possible problem.

- It does not seem that you appreciate that route.

- I do not like to reach extreme solutions. But what is evident is that it is not possible to hold a referendum to liquidate national sovereignty.

- Some experts like Herrero de Miñón or Rubio Llorente have argued that Catalonia's personality could be recognized in the Constitution. In fact, an exception was found for the Basque Country; would it not be possible for Catalonia?

- I am not a constitutionalist; I am the President of the Government of Spain; my fundamental mission is to comply with and enforce the law. At this moment, it does not seem reasonable to me to make a reform that would force us to dissolve the Chamber, hold elections... we must be prudent. Today, I do not see a situation of sufficient stability and serenity to make a constitutional reform. That does not mean that it cannot be done in the future.

- You attend European councils... do you think that the issue of Catalonia concerns EU leaders?

I have never heard Catalonia mentioned, and I have been going for five years. What the EU is very clear about is that these are matters that correspond to the states, and that when someone tries to liquidate the Constitution of a state, they are attacking European principles.

- Do you see it possible for PDEcat to play an important role again in Spanish politics and in governance in Congress?

There exists a moderate, consensus-seeking, open, and entrepreneurial Catalonia that has probably stopped recognizing itself in certain political forces. When one puts themselves in the hands of radicals, they lose centrality and end up losing the trust of the people.

- Do you miss when Convergència guaranteed you governance?

- Convergence has guaranteed governance in Madrid, and I remind you that the PP has also guaranteed governance for Mr. Mas in the Generalitat. That is normal, the pact between political rivals when circumstances demand it. By the way, the PP was a much more loyal and responsible partner than the current partners of the Generalitat government. You ask me if I miss that time, and I would answer in the Galician way: do Catalans miss that time?

- There is already a president of the Generalitat, a vice president, and two councilors disqualified, and there may still be more important officials of the Catalan institutions in the same situation. If at some point relations need to be redirected, do you think it would be possible for them not to be sidelined from politics through the route of pardon?

- The best way to redirect relations is to change course. Not to keep taking steps toward nowhere.

- What message would you send to Catalans who feel vertigo about the situation looming in Catalonia?

- To the Catalans who have always felt Spanish, I would tell them that we are with them, I am the president of the Government of all Spaniards, also theirs, and we are going to defend their interests. We have helped the Generalitat a lot because political decisions made by some have nothing to do with the interests of all citizens. They should be encouraged and calm and know that there are many people who think like them. To those who have been sold the idea that independence is the panacea that will solve all their ills, I have to tell them that it is not so, and that if it happens, they will lose a lot in their lives, their economies, and their relationships in the European Union. It seems absurd to me that people have to choose between being Catalan or Spanish and European.

- Will this story end well?

Yes. I am absolutely convinced.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of the newspaper "La Vanguardia."