Speech by President of the Government in Lower House of Parliament

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

30 August 2017

Context
Rajoy addressed the Lower House of Parliament on 30 August 2017 in an extraordinary plenary session called by opposition MPs demanding political accountability over corruption allegations.
Main themes
Political accountability, corruption in the People's Party, parliamentary oversight, terrorism and national unity, vote of no confidence, rule of law, government transparency, Spanish constitutional democracy
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,608
89th percentile
Sentences
163
83rd percentile
Readability
44
44th percentile
Grade
14.2
69th percentile
Syntax
3.22
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 69%53%
  • Ceremonial 13%10%
  • Geopolitical 10%7%
  • Economic 7%6%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 24%

163 sentences in 91 paragraphs

Honourable Members,

They have hurt us, but they have not defeated us, nor will they defeat us. They may continue attacking us but each time we will be better prepared to stop them. Firstly, through our unity, united in everything we share, the values of life, of liberty and of peaceful co-existence; united in our decisive commitment to wipe out the worst threat that exists to the West at this time, as the European leaders who met in Paris on Monday stated; united in showing the fanatics that they will not find any support in Spain, because in the show of force that the Spanish people and their representatives wish to display we are not prepared to leave any cracks that can be exploited by their senseless conduct.

Let us move on, Honourable Members, to today's issue at hand.

This is an issue that has been extensively debated in this House in recent years, in different formats, on different aspects of the same issue and with different requests on the part of the parliamentary groups that have formulated them. Specifically, and in the Lower House alone, I have offered explanations on as many as 52 occasions on this matter. I will remind you of the most important of them:

- Appearance on 1 August 2013, more than four years ago.

- Similarly, on 27 November 2014, I defended the government's position in the debate on all of the draft laws that comprised the National Democratic Regeneration Plan.

- We also addressed these issues in several appearances to take stock of the meetings of the European Council. I refer, specifically, to the debates on the European Councils on 7 and 8 February 2013, on 22 May of the same year, on 23 and 24 October 2014, and on 18 December 2014.

- We also addressed the problems of corruption in all of the Debates on the State of the Nation during the 10th Legislature: specifically, in those in the years 2013, 2014 and 2015.

- We also had the opportunity to address this in the last four Investiture Debates: one in the year 2011 and three in the year 2016: on 4 March, 2 September and 29 October.

- And furthermore, in the weekly government control sessions I have answered 32 verbal questions on these same issues since February 2012.

I wanted to specify that in the list I have just given you, I have only referred to debates that have taken place in this House and in which I have intervened in my role as President of the Government. Hence, I have disregarded all those that have taken place in the Upper House and the countless speeches my ministers have made on this subject, both in plenary sessions and on committees.

Moreover, I would remind you at this time that there are two parliamentary committees - one of them an investigative committee - already working in this House on this matter. The degree of detail being adopted in these works can be seen in the number of people who left the People's Party and public life more than a quarter of a century ago.

Lastly, Honourable Members, I would remind you that just two months ago several MPs sought for this House to demand political accountability from the President of the Government. In order to achieve their goals, they activated the instrument that the Spanish Constitution has established to this end; an instrument that had not been used in our country for more than 30 years: the vote of no confidence.

In short, Honourable Members, I have always willingly submitted and complied with the control of this House. Since the very first day I have answered for my actions, I am accountable for my words, I take part in all forms of debate and respond to all the questions that you raise. I do this, among other reasons, because it is my obligation as President of the Government.

It is quite another matter that some of you don't like anything that I do and scorn those explanations that you insist on asking from me; that you seek for me to simply say you are right; that you express your conformity with what you present as un undisputable truth; that you meekly admit charges brought - whatever you feel is most appropriate at any given time - and that, consequently, the corresponding sentence should be imposed; sentences which, as if it's not enough, you also establish yourselves and, if possible, consist of me abandoning the government.

Honourable Members,

You will appreciate that I cannot accept these suppositions. That is not how things work.

But let us return to the story of the facts that bring me to appear here today. What is true is that some of you decided on 24 August that I should appear here, in this same month, and at an extraordinary plenary session, outside of the normal period of sittings, to once again speak about the same issue.

On this occasions, and in light of the clear absence of any new element that could justify this urgency, the excuse you apply is my alleged refusal to be politically accountable since I testified before a court.

Honourable Members,

You are entitled to call for me to make an appearance. I will not reproach you. Nor will I get caught up in reflections or speculations on the true intentions that would seem to encourage the inquisitorial jealousies of some of the Honourable Members. But you will allow me to repeat what I have just pointed out a few moments ago: that I have reported on the same matter on 52 occasions, that there is no overriding reason that requires my presence here and that, in light of the problems we are facing at this time in Spain and of the challenges that we must tackle, the need to hold, on an extraordinary basis and outside of the normal period of sittings, a debate on this matter is incomprehensible when we should be focusing on other matter that are perhaps more worthy of the attention and interest of the Honourable Members.

At any event, you are the ones who establish your priorities. This is what seems to concern you the most and I respect that although, as I have just stated, I do not share this opinion.

Having said that, allow me to make two further considerations.

The first one that stands out to me regarding this request for my presence here, and I don't know whether I should welcome this or not, is that it has been justified, not due to the actions of my government, as stipulated in the Spanish Constitution, which is habitual and would be logical, but by the actions of my party, some of which, by the way, date back more than 20 years.

Quite frankly, Honourable Members, in light of this strange disregard for the government's actions, I can only think that we must be doing things so well that we do not offer any grounds for criticism, or that you haven't taken the trouble to find any - I am referring to grounds - and prefer to continue moving down a path that is so well-trodden that is threatens to go nowhere.

Secondly, Honourable Members, your obsession with trying to judge and condemn my political formation in this House is also quite a colourful idea, because we are not talking about the Government of Spain but about my political background. You do this every time you have the opportunity. Your alliances allow you to have enough votes to do this, although it is true that it is not always the case; but allow me to say to you that by joining up your minorities is not enough to find fault with the clear will that the Spanish people have expressed on the last three occasions on which they have been called to the ballot box.

Don't take this badly, but you must understand if I point out one inescapable fact: when making political judgements and valuing the responsibilities of one party or another, the opinion of the Spanish people is significantly less biased, less partisan, and hence more judicious than that of some of the Honourable Members in sittings such as this one.

So, Honourable Members, having made these reflections, I will refer to what you have asked me to explain: why do I refuse to be politically accountable as you demand I must be? I must say to you that, in light of your demands, the concept of political accountability that you proclaim has nothing whatsoever to do with what our constitutional text states and far more to do with your political urgings.

Such as you seem to understand political accountability - when it is a question of mine, but certainly not when it is a question of your own - this seems to be a bottomless pit in which you can place, as and when you deem fit and opportune, your specific interests.

Honourable Members,

I say to you in all honesty that I don't object to you demanding political accountability from me. That is one of the most important duties incumbent on you, as well as approving laws and controlling the government, and this power to demand accountability falls exclusively on you. Only you can do this; not even the Upper House is empowered to do that. That is logical and reasonable.

The President of the Government holds that status because this House has placed its confidence in him and this House can also withdraw that. That is the definition of demanding political accountability. And how can it do that? Historically, it withdrew its trust when the government lost an important vote. Quite simply by doing that. But that raised two problems that can be easily appreciated: first, it confused a parliamentary decision on one specific issue, whatever it may have been, one was enough, with a wholesale expression of confidence, or lack of confidence in the government; and secondly, it led to situations of great institutional instability, because the loss of a simple vote meant the government fell, and then a process began to see who would govern and how, if it was possible to achieve that.

So, Honourable Members, in order to avoid this situation, modern constitutional systems, among them our own Constitution, established an instrument, just one, to demand the political accountability of the government - the vote of no confidence - which is subject to a series of material and procedural requirements that I will not list because you are perfectly aware of them.

That is how political accountability is demanded in Spain today and that is a responsibility that has nothing to do with civil, administrative or criminal offences, which are judged in other jurisdictions, and which is also different from the reproach that can be made of the government's actions through other control, information or investigation instruments contained in the Regulation of the Lower House and that you are all very familiar with and indeed frequently use.

Or, to put it another way, criticism of the government for a specific event or policy does not determine the requirement for political accountability. To do that, it is necessary for the House, by a majority, to withdraw its confidence in the government and appoint another President of the Government; that is, to pass a vote of no confidence, as provided for in our Constitution.

Having said that, Honourable Members, which was necessary in order to speak with authority, let's move on to the heart of the matter.

This House has placed its trust in me; it has done so on two occasions, something which I am profoundly grateful for, as I did back at the right time, and which was only reasonable because, at the end of the day, the People's Party was the political force to have received the most votes and to hold the most seats in this House. And not long ago, following the debate on the vote of no confidence, this House did not withdraw its confidence in me; to put it another way, it did not force me to be politically accountable. And, moreover, my party and I, as its candidate for the Presidency of the Government, have maintained the confidence of the Spanish people, by majority, on three occasions.

Hence, Honourable Members, my obligation is to govern - that is of course my obligation - and I will continue to do that to meet my obligations to the Spanish people and to this House. I repeat, that is my obligation and I am not going to abandon that.

Honourable Members,

We are facing a great many challenges and, unfortunately, some of them have been made clear over these recent dramatic days. The very serious attacks in Barcelona and Cambrils serve as a reminder to everyone that the fight against terrorism, defending life, the rights and liberties of people, must be our top priority. Honourable Members, that is, and must remain, our top priority.

Preserving the unity of Spain, our constitutional text, and with that, our democratic system, is something that requires all our attention and that we cannot and will not renounce.

Nor should we forget that, despite the progress made following the most serious economic crisis that the Spanish people have suffered from in decades, we must continue persevering with the economic recovery, avoid endangering that and ensure that it filters down to all households.

In my opinion, those are the most important challenges. I suppose they also are for the majority of you here, although today some of you have preferred that we debate, on an extraordinary basis, other matters. That is your decision, that you have sought to prioritise, and, as I said before, I respect that.

At any event, and for your peace of mind, I can assure you that I am also concerned, and I have been for a long time, by the fight to improve rectitude and the transparency of our public life. To that end, I have worked a great deal - believe me I have - in recent years and I am prepared to continue doing that in the future.

Honourable Members,

We have approved a dozen laws, which might sound easy to say, with the sole aim of improving the trust of the Spanish citizens in our democratic system. We have done this with a democratic conviction, without anyone forcing us to do so, with a majority that granted us the ability to do it or not. I repeat, without anyone forcing us to, and on many occasions without anyone else supporting us, because I have always believed, Honourable Members, that reforms are more effective against corruption than reproaches.

I would remind you that at the first Council of Ministers in 2011, after appointing my Cabinet, we approved the reform of the Party Funding Act, before anyone called for this and even a long time before any opposition MP asked me my first question on this matter. We reformed a law approved by the previous government and which my government wanted to further strengthen, not only cutting the subsidies to parties, but limiting, for the first time, the funding they receive from other sources. Among other decisions, we banned a body that receives public funding from making a donation to a party. We established more limits and more controls, because we also stepped up transparency requirements. For example, our political parties must publish their accounts on their web page pursuant to this law.

We not only reformed the Party Funding Act, we approved a new law to control all their economic and financial activity, which ranges from the content of their Articles of Association to the functions of the Court of Auditors, in order not to leave any loophole for irregularities and to completely change the way in which parties operate in our country and how they are controlled.

Donations from legal persons are now banned - they weren't previously - as are those above 50,000 euros made by natural persons, and all donations must be notified to the Court of Auditors.

Bank debts of political parties can no longer be written off or renegotiated outside of the market. Before I was President of the Government the situation was very different, as some people here today can substantiate who were blessed with sizable loans written off by financial institutions.

All those people responsible for the economic management of a party are now subject to requirements of suitability and honour, and are obliged to appear before Parliament, not because someone requests that but because this is imposed by law.

All political parties must now present their accounts to the Court of Auditors, all of them, without exception, and furthermore, they cannot receive any subsidies if they do not comply with this law or have outstanding debts with the public authorities, and nor can anyone who has been convicted of corruption-related offences.

In short, Honourable Members, all political parties, whether represented in this House or not, must now comply with the strictest rules that have ever existed in our country, and not only that, but they also face criminal liability if they do not comply with them, which didn't exist before; or they may be charged with a criminal offence of illegal funding, which was not previously provided for in our Criminal Code.

And all of these are improvements that we have introduced and it is only right that this should not be ignored because, among other things, it is not fair to do so since this represents a major step forward in the fight against corruption.

Honourable Members,

Not only have we stepped up controls over political parties, we have also subjected the public authorities and senior public officials to maximum control, and it was my government that approved, in the end, a Transparency Act for Spain. It has been my government that has made what was previously completely opaque into something public ex officio. Subsidies, contracts and buildings belonging to the public authorities, remuneration, compensation and the compatibility of public positions - all of this is now public information , which wasn't the case prior to the latest reforms.

Furthermore, we have taken on the public responsibility of making good governance an obligation, with appraised public management rules and specific sanctions in the event of their breach. That is why we reformed the Criminal Code, so that whoever does not meet their obligations will face the consequences.

Honourable Members,

Both group and individual obligations because, similarly, it has been my government that has approved the first Statute on Senior Officials, with the maximum requirements of suitability and honour in order to be appointed. And, above all, stricter controls are established on their assets, appointment and dismissal, in order to detect any possibility of unfair enrichment and bring these cases to justice, as the case may be.

Honourable Members,

We are and have always been aware that it is not enough to simply make the rules more demanding. It is necessary to make them more effective and, as the case may be, also make sanctions tougher in order to dissuade those who might seek to use politics with other more spurious ends that go against the public interest. That is why we have worked to facilitate and strengthen the action of the justice system with reforms at a criminal and procedural level. And this allows me to assert that the government has provided the courts with additional instruments to tackle corruption, not only more criminal offences can now be prosecuted beginning, as I have said to you, with illegal funding, but also because greater accountability is required by having increased the limits to time-barring corruption-related offences. Tougher penalties can now be imposed, together with longer periods for disqualification from office and more instruments are available to ensure that the very last Euro stolen from the Spanish people can be returned to them.

In the last few weeks of the 10th Legislature, we set up, as you know, the Office for the Recovery and Management of Assets seized in the fight against corruption. Just a month ago, the person in charge appeared here, in this House, because that procedure was established by the government in its regulation, to answer for the management of the office and its results, and he reported that, at today's date, more than 250 assets seized from the proceeds of crime are being dealt with and its deposit account has a balance of close on 17 million euros.

Honourable Members,

We have also worked to provide the justice system with more instruments and with greater resources as far as possible, despite the economic difficulties which, as you are well aware, or should be aware, we have suffered. Let me give you a few figures:

- The current 2017 Budget provides for the creation of 89 new courts, as well as 16 second instance criminal courts; in total 105 courts to strengthen our judicial system and the fight, among other offences, against corruption.

- Specifically, the workforce of Anti-Corruption Prosecution Service is now 40% larger than in 2014 and the number of its provincial delegates has increased by 14%.

- The number of support personnel for the Spanish Tax Office has increased by 22% and for the Guardia Civil by 35%.

Honourable Members,

All of these democratic regeneration reforms have been proposed and approved so that there can be no doubts that our public service is guaranteed by controls and the rule of law, and this also makes it clear to the Spanish people that those who are removed from their political activity in this public service will be removed from their responsibilities and from politics.

I have said on many occasions, and wish to reiterate that here today, that there is no impunity in Spain, our institutions work well, the controls alert us and irregularities are sanctioned where they should be - in the courts and in the ballot box. Should this not have been the case, we would never have uncovered the cases of corruption that have come to light in recent years. And the most important aspect is that the police, the Guardia Civil, the judges and the prosecutors have brought these individuals to justice, they are being prosecuted and tried, because there is no impunity for corruption and corruption is being stamped out harder than ever.

There is no impunity because Spain is a country with controls. It has always had them but they are stricter now than ever before.

We have freedom of press in Spain and anyone can report on what they see fit and opportune.

In Spain, we have a Court of Auditors that audits the economic and financial activity of political parties.

In Spain, we have a judiciary that prosecutes crime and punishes those guilty.

In Spain there is a government that follows the law and ensures that it is upheld.

And in Spain, Honourable Members, everyone does their duty. That is how it is and how it should always be.

Our institutions, justice system and rule of law all work. I have always defended this and been convinced of this, and I will always work to ensure that this is the case, as hard as I can, because I believe in that.

Honourable Members,

I have said this on some occasions, but I want to reiterate it here today: I believe in politics and in those people who, from any democratic ideology, put all their talents at the service of the common good; I believe in the nobility of the individual vocation for working towards collective progress; I believe in this dignity of politics and in those who know how to exercise this. And, since I am not a sectarian fanatic, I include all of you in this general consideration.

I would also reiterate to you what I have said on many occasions in this House: that I am prepared to continue working to improve the instruments of control, prevention and sanction that allow us to be more effective in the fight against corruption.

In short, Honourable Members, I have appeared once again before this Lower House of Parliament because that is what you have decided. I will do the same whenever you ask me to do so. What I cannot and will not do is abdicate my responsibilities to govern, those required of me by this House and by the majority confidence placed in me by the Spanish people.

And, to end, allow me to insist on something that I mentioned earlier, I consider it significant and for me this was this most important part of the speech I have given today. We are facing some very serious challenges that merit our full attention and, to the extent possible, this requires a constructive attitude from all of us, and that we place the interests of all the people of Spain to the fore.

It is necessary that we are united in tackling the threat of terrorism, united in Spain, to which end we must work and strengthen the Pact against Jihadi Terrorism, and united with our European partners. Just a few hours ago, we ratified our firm will in Paris to fight together and to strengthen coordination on operational issues and intelligence.

We must also be aware of the gravity of the challenge posed by some people bent on wiping out our national unity and way of life together in a unilateral fashion and with blatant disregard for the most basic rules of a democracy.

The government will respond as firmly as the magnitude of the provocation to our rule of law, our Constitution and the very self-governance of Catalonia requires. It will defend the rights of all the Spanish people to decide on what they want their country to be and it will protect the people of Catalonia from an autocratic project, headed up by radicals, that can only bring division, confrontation and the loss of liberty and well-being.

Lastly, Honourable Members, although no-one has questioned the results of our recovery and the positive figures on economic growth and job creation for some time now, what is true is that we still have a major task ahead of us. We have overcome the worst economic crisis that Spain has faced in decades. The latest Labour Force Survey reminded us that in the last year the number of people in work in Spain has increased by 660,000. Well, despite these good figures, there is still a long way to go to reach the figure of 20 million people in work, which is the target I set at the Investiture Debate at the start of this term of office. That would not only be good in itself, but would also help provide funds to improve our public services, our pensions and the level of well-being of the Spanish people. Let's not forget that.

Honourable Members,

Those are the priorities of my government and I believe that of the majority of the Spanish people. There is undoubtedly more to do. Of course, we must continue to fight corruption, making it increasingly difficult to commit, punishing reproachable conduct more firmly and strengthening the confidence of citizens in our democracy.

What I am not sure about - and I say this quite frankly - is that this type of debate is very useful to that end. Rather, I fear that the goal of some people is quite different and I guess, moreover, that there are many people who are starting to realise that.

Thank you very much, Honourable Members.

Non official translation