Statements by the President of the Government after the extraordinary meeting of the Council of Ministers.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

28 September 2014 · Extraordinary meeting of the Council of Ministers

Context
Rajoy addressed press after an extraordinary Council of Ministers meeting on 28 September 2014, announcing Spain's constitutional appeal against Catalonia's planned November 9 independence consultation.
Main themes
Catalan independence referendum, constitutional challenge, national sovereignty, rule of law, self-determination, unity of Spain, Constitutional Court appeal, democratic legitimacy, rights of Spanish citizens, Generalitat of Catalonia
Duration
~19 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,229
62nd percentile
Sentences
97
61st percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
28th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 72%72%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

97 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, good morning and thank you very much for your attendance at this meeting.

As you know, I am here to inform you of the agreements adopted by the Council of Ministers, which has met extraordinarily this morning.

After analyzing the opinions requested from the Council of State, the Government has formally submitted to the Constitutional Court the appeals of unconstitutionality against the Law of non-referendum consultations approved by the Parliament of Catalonia and against the Decree calling for the consultation on November 9 signed by the President of the Generalitat of Catalonia.

As you know, if the Court admits both appeals for processing, the validity of both the Law and the Decree is automatically suspended, as provided for in Article 161.2 of our Constitution.

I will not reiterate the arguments presented in the appeals that the Court must evaluate. You are well aware of them. The consultation that is intended to be carried out is incompatible with the Spanish Constitution, both in its object and in the procedure followed.

Today's decision is consistent with what the Government had already anticipated since December 12 of last year, when I appeared here in this same room. It was then that the President of the Generalitat announced his decision to call a self-determination referendum. On the same day, we established the Government's position, which, as is evident in a matter of this nature, has not been modified.

We have always said that this consultation would not take place because it directly violates the Constitution. We have insisted on that same argument every single time the issue has been raised. And today we fulfill our obligation to file an appeal against a decision that seriously undermines the rights of all Spaniards.

The self-determination consultation that the Government of the Generalitat intends to call is openly contrary to our Constitution, which in its first article enshrines that "national sovereignty resides in the Spanish people, from whom the powers of the State emanate."

Sovereignty resides in the Spanish people as a whole, and a part of it cannot make decisions about what affects everyone. The Constitution is based on the indissoluble unity of the Spanish Nation, and therefore any attempt to dissolve it is radically contrary to the Constitution. And certainly, the Constitution can be reformed, but the intended consultation does not fit, in any way, into the procedures that the Constitution itself establishes for its reform.

It is false that the right to vote and to decide is a right that can be unilaterally attributed to a Community, denying it to the rest of the nation. It is demagogic to appeal to something that sounds good: the right to express oneself, the right to be heard. The problem is that those who wield these arguments are actually depriving the one who truly holds that right, which is the entirety of the Spanish people. Therefore, the consultation is profoundly undemocratic: the right that it seeks to grant to some is being taken away from all the others.

Legally speaking, the Government cannot and should not do anything other than what it is doing today, and from a strictly political point of view, there is no other way to act.

There is nothing and no one; neither power nor any institution, that can break that principle of unique and indivisible sovereignty on which our coexistence is based. In other words, there is nothing and no one that can deprive all Spaniards of the right to decide what their country is; however, that is the practical consequence of the consultation called by the Generalitat.

The Government, therefore, is obliged to appeal in defense of the Constitution, which is tantamount to appealing in defense of the freedoms and rights of each and every Spaniard, including the citizens of Catalonia. We are also defending them and their rights with this appeal.

I want to remind you that the Government's position has been politically and legally supported by an unquestionable majority in the Congress of Deputies, as well as by the Constitutional Court itself in its ruling of March 24.

Allow me to elaborate a little more on the argument because, in addition to appealing, we must explain with crystal clarity what this challenge implies.

The first thing I want to say is that with this appeal we defend the validity of democratic Law. The Law is not a corset, nor a restriction against freedom. It is the opposite: the Law is a guarantee of equality, of the rights and freedoms of citizens. It is the guarantee of the security of all. The Law is not a whim of the Government, neither this one nor any other. The Law is the expression of the will of the majority of citizens, and therefore, the main task of a Government is to defend it: to comply with it and to ensure its compliance.

It is unacceptable, as some do, to oppose law to democracy, because without law there is no democracy nor respect for the rights of citizens, and without law there is also no politics.

No one is prevented from speaking or expressing their will. Fortunately, Spaniards have been doing so for decades. But what cannot be allowed is for the will of a part to deprive the whole of its rights.

Laws can be changed, but always through the established democratic channels. Anyone wishing to modify this situation has the full freedom to propose a reform of it: to propose it in the democratically established terms and to gain the necessary support to carry it out. That is the way to do things. What cannot be done, or should not be done by a responsible ruler, is to seek shortcuts or subterfuges to violate legality, no matter how adorned they may come with pretty words.

I would like to say something about dialogue. The Government has always kept a dialogue open with the Government of the Generalitat, and I, personally, have maintained it with its President. But the truth is that the Generalitat has been developing a policy of faits accomplis that it has pursued relentlessly and expects the Government to be forced to find a solution to unilateral decisions that are impossible to share. My position has been open, clear, and firm. I have been willing to negotiate from day one, but there has never been a real possibility because, first, decisions have been made by the Generalitat, and then it has been attempted that the Government of Spain not only accept them but also find the political and legal ways to carry them out.

When one part acts against the legal framework and the interests of the whole, it cannot be the obligation of the Government to find a middle ground for agreement. The only real way of dialogue would have been to raise the problems and jointly seek possible scenarios to resolve them. The opposite has been done. Unilateral decisions have been made, pretending to reach a point of no return that would force the rest to accept it without more.

And I want to talk, finally, about responsibility, because those who have initiated this entire process are responsible for its serious consequences. Consequences that include the unjust delegitimization of our democratic institutions or the fracture of the bonds of brotherhood that have united Catalonia and the rest of Spain throughout our long common history.

In particular, together, the Catalans and the rest of the Spaniards, we have granted ourselves a Constitution that has provided the longest period of prosperity and well-being in democracy in our history. Supported by a vast majority of Catalans and ratified by the Spanish people, our Constitution, the result of consensus, dialogue, and the generosity of all parties, has allowed Catalonia to enjoy the greatest recognition and the highest level of self-government, and for the longest time, in all of history.

I deeply regret that, despite all these considerations, the President of the Generalitat has called this self-determination consultation. I regret it because it goes against the Law, exceeds democracy, divides Catalans, distances them from Europe and the rest of Spain, and seriously harms their well-being, not to mention the frustration to which it is condemning a part of the citizens of Catalonia by encouraging them to participate in an initiative that cannot, due to its illegality, come to fruition. The worst part is that he knew it from the beginning.

I believe we are still in time to correct the course, to overcome a sterile dialectic of confrontation and seek fruitful dialogue. Both the Government and I are open to any initiatives that seek that objective; but always within the most scrupulous respect for legality, an inescapable condition of any dialogue in a serious and responsible democracy like ours. And, of course, I want to make it very clear that, as long as I am President of the Government, the Law will be respected in its entirety. That all Catalans and the rest of the Spaniards can be assured in that regard: all dialogue within the Law and none outside the Law.

Thank you very much and good morning.

If you have any questions, I am at your disposal but, please, on this matter.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to ask you if you are willing, if you are still willing, to accept the twenty-three proposals that President Artur Mas brought to Moncloa last July, if President Mas abandons this path of illegality.

President.- Let's see. The proposals that the President of the Generalitat has made to me are some reasonable, others more debatable; but, in general, they are proposals that are made in line with what other presidents of other Autonomous Communities can do; that is to say, they are proposals that affect infrastructures, in some cases proposals on financing issues.

I am willing to talk about that, but with Mr. Mas and with the president of any Community, because it is my duty and because I believe it is good that we talk and dialogue, and, if possible, reach an understanding. What I will not talk about is violating the Law, because you will understand that that is the last thing expected from the President of the Government of any serious country.

Q.- In this same vein, will you respond to those twenty-three proposals? Is there a proposal for dialogue? Is there an offer on the table for a possible meeting with Mr. Mas, something that will happen in the coming days? In any case, if that is not the case, if that proposal is not accepted and if Mas continues with the idea of bringing the ballot boxes to the streets, what will happen? What measures does the Government have planned?

President.- I have always been willing to dialogue. Whenever the President of the Generalitat has wanted to see me, I have received him, always. There has never been a time that I have refused to meet with the President of the Generalitat since I became President of the Government. Therefore, I am open to dialogue, to talk about those proposals or any others that the President of the Generalitat wants.

From there, allow me not to enter into scenarios that have not yet occurred. At this moment, I do not contemplate a scenario other than that the President of the Generalitat complies with the Law. That is to say, I do not want to contemplate a different scenario.

Q.- Mr. President, when you say that we are still in time to correct the situation, do you mean that if the ballot boxes are not brought to the streets, formulas for the integration of Catalonia can be sought and that a constitutional modification could even be reached by agreement?

President.- When I say that we are in time, the first thing is that, if the Constitutional Court admits the appeal and, therefore, the Law and the Decree are suspended, that what the Constitutional Court says is attended to and complied with. That is the first thing, and from there, we can talk about other things.

The reform of the Constitution is something that our legal system admits and, in fact, it has already been modified on two occasions. What happens is that at this very moment, the important thing is to defend the Constitution. That is the priority at this moment.

The Constitution is a norm that has been in force, as you all know, for some years now, since 1978, and during the period in which the Constitution has been in force we have lived the best period of many in the history of Spain, and certainly, of recent times. The Constitution guarantees our rights and guarantees our freedoms. With that Constitution, we have entered Europe, we have progressed as never before in our history, and with that Constitution, the Generalitat of Catalonia has the greatest powers in all its history.

Therefore, the first thing is to defend the Constitution. From there, it can be reformed; it has already been reformed on some occasions. Some even propose it. But the priority today is to defend it, and then we will talk in the future.

Therefore, I remain open to dialogue, as always. What I cannot accept is for things to be done that violate the Law, because that is why I am the President of the Government.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much.