Speech by Prime Minister Rutte at the 60th anniversary of the Dutch Society of Editors-in-Chief

Netherlands Mark Rutte · Prime Minister of the Netherlands

11 April 2019 · 60th anniversary of the Dutch Society of Editors-in-Chief

Context
Rutte addressed the Dutch Society of Editors-in-Chief at their 60th anniversary dinner in The Hague on April 11, 2019, reflecting on press-politics relations.
Main themes
Free press and democracy, press-politics relationship, media landscape transformation, journalistic independence, social media revolution, news consumption changes, media fragmentation, de-pillarization, tribute to Max van Weezel, political accountability to press
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,082
77th percentile
Sentences
188
88th percentile
Readability
57
82nd percentile
Grade
9.3
14th percentile
Syntax
2.85
27th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from Dutch

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 40%37%
  • Institutional 29%27%
  • Ceremonial 20%19%
  • Technological 6%6%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 6%

188 sentences in 38 paragraphs

The changing tango: on the importance of a free press and its relationship with politics

Ladies and gentlemen,

First of all: congratulations on your 60th anniversary. A true ‘society’ is already quite chic, but a society that is 60 years old is certainly very venerable, especially in

Des Indes.

That is tradition piled on decorum, topped with grandeur.

And a reason for a celebration. Although I cannot ignore the fact that it is also a celebration overshadowed by the passing of Max van Weezel. A man who was a phenomenon in parliamentary journalism for most of your existence, over 40 years. We knew, of course, that Max was seriously ill, and yet there is shock when you receive the sad news that he has passed away. Max was a journalistic icon, a craftsman, and a role model for many.

Always sharp in his questions and analyses, but never below the belt. Very well-informed, without being pretentious. And above all, a master interviewer with a sense for the right atmosphere. I still remember very well, when I started in The Hague, how I looked up to him. He was already working at Vrij Nederland when I was in elementary school. But over the years, we built a mutual bond of respect and personal appreciation. Even in that last period, I spoke to him a few times, and I cherish the memories of those moments. But I think I am not the only one in this company with fond memories of Max. Dutch journalism became poorer yesterday.

Ladies and gentlemen, I am of course honored to speak here today, thank you for that. But you are immediately saddling me with a small problem. On the one hand, I do not want to speak with sugar-coated words, and I hope you do not expect that from me either. At the same time, it is not my place as acting Prime Minister to have various judgments about your work and that of your editorial teams. Journalism is, after all, the fly in the ointment of politics. That is precisely why, immediately after my appointment in 2010, I moved the weekly press conference after the Cabinet meeting from the Ministry of General Affairs to Nieuwspoort. The Prime Minister should be a guest of the press, and not the other way around. That is how it should be. So tonight will be a bit of an exercise in walking on eggshells. But that is actually always the case in my job, because it is as the Belgian politician Herman de Croo once said: ‘With a newspaper, you can kill both a minister and a fly.’

So let me start safely, by looking back. And that is also appropriate, because at such anniversaries, you almost automatically look back. It remains astonishing how quickly and profoundly the world has changed. Especially the relationship between your profession and mine. Legendary is, for example, the story about Beel, who was awaited at the bottom of the airplane steps in Jakarta, then Batavia, by a group of journalists and subsequently received this significant question: ‘Did you have a good trip, Excellency?’ Those were the days!

In 1959, the newspaper, quite literally, was still a gentleman. We can hardly imagine it now, but when this society was founded, the leader of the Anti-Revolutionary Party in the House of Representatives was simultaneously the editor-in-chief of Trouw. A combination of roles that is unthinkable today. A few hundred thousand people had a TV in their living room, and on the days when there were broadcasts on that one available channel, they lasted a mere 2 hours...

These were also the years in which the legendary parliamentary reporter Henri Faas of the Volkskrant – the one and only ‘Wandelganger’ – was boycotted by Prime Minister Drees as punishment because he allegedly published prematurely from the Prinsjesdag documents. Later, it turned out that it was not a leak, but a display of clever deduction and top journalism. But back then, it was still possible for a Prime Minister to simply exclude a journalist. Those were truly different times. Just imagine: Drees being interviewed by Rutger or Jaïr. Den Uyl as a candidate on the smartest person – which he undoubtedly was. Or Ruud Lubbers or Dries van Agt having to settle for 140 characters to say something.

In short, the media landscape and the media logic, as we have come to call it, have completely changed in those sixty years. First through the de-pillarization, which also removed the self-evidence of authority. Later through the internet and social media revolution, in which we are still very much immersed. But you all know that better than I do. How recipients have become senders and vice versa. How the number of media – print, image, and sound, online – continues to grow and become more intertwined. How at the same time, circulation and the number of independent titles are under pressure, because paying for news has become less and less self-evident. How the risk looms that we as news consumers will all spin in our own news bubble. And how traditional newspapers and current affairs programs have increasingly become the interpreters of the news, because hard news comes to us 24/7 in other ways. That has changed your work enormously. But it has also changed my work, if only because I, as the serving Prime Minister, am increasingly directly addressed about everything that is happening in politics. I am officially the Minister of General Affairs, but I often feel like the Minister of all affairs. And that has everything to do with the information society and media logic of today.

The great paradox of our time is that in the overload of information, opinions, and viewpoints, it is becoming increasingly difficult to distinguish fact from fiction. This is something that both journalists and politicians should be concerned about. Because fake news and internet trolls are truly among us, and that is not something to take lightly. If a fact becomes merely an opinion, the public debate and the democratic rule of law are the first victims. Hence, for example, that government campaign about fake news, because it is so incredibly important that people, especially around elections, remain critical of the sources of news. Another great danger is that it is becoming increasingly acceptable to blame serious media for everything and anything. Even in our country. That is unjust, and we must continue to stand against it. And by ‘we,’ I mean you and me. We share that responsibility for the protection and cultivation of the democratic culture and the freedom of expression in our country. Each from our own role, of course.

Of course, we all need to be able to handle criticism, and freedom of expression does not stop at opinions about the press. In that sense, resilience is as good a quality for journalists as it is for politicians. The press is also part of the societal debate, and there is nothing wrong with that. But we must not slide down that slippery slope that leads to self-censorship or, worse, because that undermines the very root of what the press is and should be for our society: a source of information, a gathering point for opinions, and a check on power.

That slippery slope to self-censorship is subtle and implicit. But sometimes the threat is also very explicit and direct. 6 out of 10 journalists have been threatened with violence at some point, and for 3 out of 10, this happens even regularly, meaning weekly or monthly. That cannot be and must not be allowed. That is why it is good that the Public Prosecution Service from this month has a doubled penalty demand for threats and violence against journalists, just as we do for emergency workers. And that is also why it is good that there is now a special site to report incidents, so that priority can be given to this even better. Your Society plays an important role in this, and that deserves great praise.

When I look at myself, there are those moments when it really matters, such as after the attack on Charlie Hebdo in January 2015. Even if I live to be a hundred, I will never forget that silent march through Amsterdam and the incredible anger and strength of all those thousands of people on the Dam. ‘Hands off our freedom,’ I said there at the time. And that remains the core for me, because in a well-functioning democracy, everyone must be able to say anything within the bounds of the law, and journalists must be able to do their work freely. That is essential. Hence, I am now increasingly critical on behalf of the Netherlands about what is happening in countries like Poland and Hungary, where freedom of expression and a free press are under pressure. There can only be one response from the other member states: it cannot and must not be allowed.

But let us also continue to look at ourselves. Because freedom of expression and a free press are never a quiet possession. Not so long ago, Herman Tjeenk Willink published a small but significant book in which he expresses his great concerns about the dangers threatening our democratic rule of law.

Think bigger, act smaller is the title – you probably know it. It is a book full of uncomfortable questions. About politics and to politicians, but also about and to the press. Who, for example, still presents the often uncomfortable facts in all the social media noise? And who dares to say out loud that some opinions in that same social media noise may be less well-founded than others and therefore carry less weight?

Tjeenk Willink formulates that important role of independent journalism with a few poignant sentences, and I quote:

‘Its ability to weigh information, expose connections, and pay attention to developments behind the incidents. Its task, supported by facts, to contradict authorities and give the other reality a chance. Its goal is to enable citizens to form their own judgment.’

End of quote; the ideal picture, of course.

But let me also allow myself a critical remark, because I am not here today to curry favor with you. To be honest: I can sometimes get worked up about the hyperbole and breathlessness of the news. After all these years, I can still be amazed at how the sensational, the personal drama can dominate the news. Even in the 1970s, there was an unnamed journalist who always seemed to say: ‘We want nice news; we prefer to see those people with their pants around their ankles.’ Whether that quote is accurate, I am not a hundred percent sure, but some stories are also too good to fact-check. And there is, in any case, a kernel of truth in it, because the conversation of the day often revolves more around the incident than the content.

I add to that: I too, we politicians, do not get off scot-free. Fair is fair. Your daily obsession is also ours. Politicians also care about a newspaper headline, a 1-0-1, a trending tweet, or an opening of the news broadcast. Most parliamentary questions, especially the oral ones during the Tuesday question hour, nowadays have a news item as their trigger. That mutual dependency has always existed, even though the relationships were completely different in the past. The unforgettable Kees Lunshof once described the relationship between politics and parliamentary journalism as ‘tangoing under a cheese dome.’ And indeed, it is a relationship of repulsion and attraction, of tension and relaxation. A relationship in which one always ultimately needs the other and also makes use of it. And I would almost say: that is how the game should be played.

Now you hear me claim from time to time that I better say nothing about topic A or B, because it does not help in the process. Former Minister Piet-Hein Donner quoted in a speech in 2011 Bismarck's famous saying that laws are like sausages, and you better not see how they are made. That brought him a lot of criticism at the time because he also concluded that the Open Government Act should be significantly curtailed. I certainly do not share that conclusion, but it is true that in some cases, a form of confidentiality is inevitably needed to achieve a result.

The formation of the second Den Uyl cabinet, which never came to be, is legendary in that respect. The press was almost at the table, and every Dutch citizen could follow all the skirmishes day by day. That

Diary of a Negotiator by Ed van Thijn is still both shocking and delightful. So much openness that you can hardly believe it. That undoubtedly contributed significantly to the establishment of the first Van Agt cabinet.

But I also think, for example, of the migration deal with Turkey. Of the social agreement from 2013. Or more recently: the purchase of shares in

Air France-

KLM. These are all topics where too much openness beforehand – and sometimes also afterward – hinders the result. That is a consideration every time. And I understand that this is annoying from your perspective and that you do everything you can to get a finger in the door. But I also ask – on behalf of my colleagues – for understanding for the fact that we occasionally push back and resist. That is all part of that joint tango.

How paradoxical it may sound: a pluralistic and transparent democracy cannot do without confidentiality at certain moments. In a political system with coalitions, you simply have to negotiate and make compromises. That is becoming increasingly necessary. And yes, you must be accountable for that, but that cannot always be during the process, because then everyone will choke on their own righteousness, and it will fall apart. Just look at that second Den Uyl cabinet that never came to be. The alternative is sham transparency for show, and no one is waiting for that.

What we as a cabinet are increasingly aware of is that it is important not to always present ourselves in absolute terms and with goal-oriented reasoning. As politicians, we prefer to speak in final images and clear opinions, without a trace of uncertainty. In a sense, that is the easiest approach, because we live in a time of quick judgments, where any hint of doubt is harshly and directly punished. A time where changing one's mind is quickly seen as a loss or weakness. Or even as unreliability. The great tile lighter himself, Henk Hofland, once said this about it: 'My only opinion that might be a bit contrary is that a person should be able to change their conviction or insight an unspecified number of times during their life, without being bothered by others who supposedly stand firm in their shoes.' I agree with that, and I speak from personal experience: there must always be room for evolving insight. That is why you will never see me cling to an unachievable plan.

The reality is that politics is about the distribution of scarcity, and that means you always have to make choices, you always have to weigh different interests against each other, and there are always dilemmas. It is never just yes or no, black or white. And what we are discussing in the Trêveszaal now is how we can involve you and the rest of the Netherlands more and earlier in all those considerations and dilemmas. I would like to avoid that rotten word 'gap' today, but understanding does start with insight, with clarity. And I take a hard look at myself. We need to dare to show much more often what is really in those sausages. Including the political struggle that often accompanies it.

To give just one concrete example: the climate agreement and the climate debate. If we are not careful, the discussion about it will forever narrow down to for or against, with ominous reporting about unaffordable measures on one side and apocalyptic images about the end of the world on the other. I truly believe it is up to us as a cabinet to make it clear that the truth lies in the middle. Without shying away from unpopular messages - because they certainly belong there. But also by bringing realism into the discussion and nuance. By showing the alternatives and choices early on. And by – as you have seen – also adjusting plans when necessary. That is vulnerable in today’s stormy media and social media landscape, but that is precisely why we need to do it more often. I lay that intention here today openly and plainly on the table, hoping that some of it will seep into your newspapers and programs in the coming years. Because among all the different interests between your and my profession, is not the nuanced consideration and professional doubt a shared interest, as it makes us both stronger and more convincing?

And to preempt your first critical question: this does not stand in stark contrast to what I just said about the confidentiality that is sometimes necessary. It is about explaining very clearly why we bought those shares in Air France-KLM and why it had to go the way it did. That is also a dilemma about which you can be clear.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Looking back 60 years is easy. Looking forward sixty years is actually impossible. None of us has a crystal ball. But I dare to make this prediction: just as the media landscape of 1959 is from another planet, the media landscape of 2079 will be as well. It may also be obvious that the printed newspaper and television in their current form will no longer exist in sixty years. But beyond that? I dare not say, because reality will undoubtedly surpass our wildest dreams.

Yet some things hopefully remain as they are. As one of your almost ex-members, Peter Vandermeersch, once said: 'We are not in the world to make white paper black, we are in the world to do journalism.' That can be done in various ways and in various forms. But the essential democratic role of critical, independent, and idiosyncratic journalism does not change. That remains. So even for the sixty-year-old Dutch Association of Editors-in-Chief, the retirement age is not yet in sight. I wish you, as a collective and as individual media, many more years and a very successful future.

Thank you.