Speech by Prime Minister Mark Rutte at the VNG Members' Meeting

Netherlands Mark Rutte · Prime Minister of the Netherlands

23 May 2024 · VNG Members' Meeting

Context
Rutte addressed the VNG extraordinary members' meeting on 23 May 2024 to discuss municipal finances and the growing responsibilities of Dutch local governments.
Main themes
Municipal finances, decentralization of government, Thorbecke's constitutional legacy, local government responsibilities, intergovernmental relations, social domain decentralizations, housing and shelter, migration and international pressures, citizen trust in government, VNG membership
Duration
~11 min
40th percentile
Words
1,378
40th percentile
Sentences
89
57th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
8.7
9th percentile
Syntax
2.90
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
12th percentile

Translated from Dutch

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 60%60%
  • Ceremonial 24%24%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

89 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, dear people,

When I became Prime Minister not so long ago – at least that’s how it feels – I didn’t change much in the decor of the Torentje.

And in the years that followed, I didn’t really change much either. That’s because my predecessor had bought new furniture not long before, we were in the midst of a financial crisis, and to be honest, I thought it was all fine as it was.

But there is one thing I did do right away. I had the portrait of Thorbecke, which had once been removed from the Torentje, hung back up immediately.

I still consider it an act of historical justice. Because we all stand on the shoulders of giants. And there are few giants in our parliamentary history greater than Johan Rudolf Thorbecke.

No matter how you look at it, it remains phenomenal how that house of Thorbecke was built by him in just a few years and still stands strong after more than 175 years. Of course, with a few extensions here and there, with necessary major maintenance from time to time, and with a peeling window frame or two that need some attention – but nonetheless: indestructible.

That image of a shared administrative house with one front door remains so strong because it does justice to Thorbecke’s original intent.

‘The state,’ for him, was municipalities, provinces, and the national government together. And not in a hierarchical relationship, but as an organic whole, in which each layer of government has its own role.

And certainly not a small or subordinate role for local government. On the contrary, he once said about the Municipalities Act of 1851 that ‘there could hardly be a greater blessing to the nation.’ You can still take that to heart.

So when we talk about the principle of one government in our time, that also goes back to Thorbecke. Moreover, the municipality of Rotterdam actually thought at the beginning of the last century that it was completely unnecessary to become a member of the VNG, which had just been established.

Because, as the then mayor said, ‘A Union of Dutch Municipalities? That already exists! That is the state of the Netherlands.’

That was very logically reasoned, but of course that was before the VNG had been able to convincingly prove its right to exist. Let me add that right away, to avoid any misunderstanding that I do not hold your association in high regard. The opposite is true.

Dear people, if you have the same job for a long time like I do, you have to be careful not to fall into repetition. Although that is sometimes unavoidable.

I don’t know who here still remembers it, but in June 2012 I also had the honor of addressing the VNG. That was on the occasion of the 100th anniversary. And just like today, the finances were the main theme of the meeting back then.

Today, that is even the direct reason for calling an extra members’ meeting. And I understand that very well.

Because there is quite a lot on the plate of the municipalities. Even more so, also due to the decentralizations in the social domain and the Environmental Act.

And I am not revealing a secret when I say that the call for a government that provides tailored solutions, that applies the human scale and thus stands close to its citizens, is becoming increasingly stronger. You could cautiously conclude that the role of municipalities is unlikely to diminish.

Personally, I still believe that the principle of ‘decentralized where possible’ is a good principle. Because the town hall, whether online or not, is for the vast majority of people the first and only place where they encounter government. Where a real person answers the phone and responds.

There they renew their passport and driver’s license. There they arrange their WMO provision. There they apply for a permit for a dormer window or a demonstration. And there you speak out on plans that the government has for your street, your neighborhood, your district. Not in an anonymous policy tower in The Hague. And not in the House of Representatives either.

In that sense, the concept of ‘first government’ is completely justified. Although such an honorary title also creates obligations, but I don’t need to explain that to you. People naturally seek support and certainty as close as possible. With what they know. And I believe that this need is only growing in these times, with everything that is happening internationally.

Because no matter how far away some things may seem, they often come very close, very quickly. The war in Ukraine, the violence in the Middle East, migration – it all lands locally as well. And that touches on very important questions, for example about shelter, housing, public order, but also on individual feelings of safety and trust in the future. Just look at the recent protests in student cities.

Municipalities also have a large and important task for their residents in this regard. With everything that is already on your plate in terms of legal responsibilities. And I know that you want to take on that role.

I realize very well, we as a cabinet realize very well, that sufficient funding is needed for all those municipal tasks. But you will understand that I stand here as a very caretaker prime minister and representative of a very caretaker cabinet with not one but two hands tied behind my back. First of all, I am not the minister responsible, and secondly, our successors are, so to speak, already waiting in the wings. The conversation that you will undoubtedly want to have about the further elaboration of the framework agreement is really with the next cabinet.

But let me say this about it. I still remember how I had to come to your celebration in 2012 with a rather gloomy financial message. We were facing major economic problems as a country, the threat of enormous deficits, and thus unprecedented cuts. And that inevitably meant less money for the Municipal Fund in the step-up-step-down system.

Today, I stand here with a somewhat different feeling, especially after the latest Spring Memorandum. Understand me correctly, I am fully aware that not all the financial issues you face as municipalities can be resolved with the Spring Memorandum with one stroke of the pen.

But hopefully, you also agree with me that the Spring Memorandum shows that the conversation between municipalities and the national government has yielded a positive outcome. If only because of the abolition of that not very popular scaling discount, I might add euphemistically.

That is simply the result of consultation. Of listening to each other. As is appropriate in and at the house of Thorbecke.

We consult with the knowledge that not everything can be done and certainly not at the same time, but also with the realization that we must do it together as governments. Because in our shared house, we constantly encounter each other, in the stairwell, in all the rooms, on all the floors.

We seek each other out. And that must remain the case. As it also states in the Spring Memorandum: it is always about the balance between shared ambitions, the tasks that go with them, and the financial resources. And that is not a static whole, so that conversation does not stop.

In my experience, that administrative consultation is never a pink cloud that you sit on together. It is usually also a bit of pushing and pulling, but almost always very constructive.

And with results. As was the case during the corona period. What municipalities were often able to achieve in a few days or sometimes even a few hours borders on the incredible. I can only bow deeply to that in hindsight.

And I want to express my great appreciation for that again today towards the VNG and towards you as municipal officials. Just as for all the other good work that is being done in the municipalities, of course.

And I promise that I will leave the portrait of Thorbecke hanging when I depart from the Torentje. As a reminder that we must always continue to work together in administrative Netherlands.

Thank you.