Address by the Prime Minister at the Awards Ceremony for Excellence in Public Administration on Civil Services Day

India Narendra Modi · Prime Minister of India

21 April 2017 · Civil Services Day awards ceremony for excellence in public administration

Context
Modi addressed civil servants at the Civil Services Day Awards Ceremony on April 21, 2017, honoring excellence in public administration across India.
Main themes
Civil services excellence, public administration reform, government competitiveness, accountability and responsibility, enabling governance, changing role of civil servants, citizen expectations, competition and quality improvement, civil service culture, India's administrative transformation
Duration
~49 min
94th percentile
Words
5,875
94th percentile
Sentences
330
96th percentile
Readability
66
95th percentile
Grade
8.4
7th percentile
Syntax
2.76
18th percentile
Vocabulary
1.87
2nd percentile

Translated from Hindi

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 60%58%
  • Social 18%18%
  • Economic 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 3%

330 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Today, this day as All India Civil Service Day is, in a way, a day of re-dedication. To all of you who have had the privilege of serving in this capacity across the country, I extend my heartfelt congratulations and best wishes.

You all are very experienced. I do not believe that you are unaware of your power, nor do I think you are oblivious to the challenges; that is not the case. You are aware of your power, aware of the challenges, and aware of the responsibilities. And we have seen that under the existing system, the country has achieved excellent results. However, there is a significant difference between the situation 15-20 years ago and today, and there will likely be a considerable difference in the situation five years from now. Because 15-20 years ago, we were the only ones who were there; we were all that existed. All the necessities of an ordinary human life passed through our hands. If someone needed education, they had to come to the government; if they fell ill, they had to come to the government. If they needed cement or iron, they also had to come to the government. In other words, it was a time when the government was everything. And when the government was everything, we were everything, and when we were everything, it was natural for evils to arise. The habit of ignoring shortcomings also developed, but in the last 15-20 years, a period of competition has begun. As a result, the ordinary person now compares, saying, "Well, the government’s airplane goes like this, and the private airplane goes like that." And they immediately feel that the government is useless. The government officials are useless because they have this alternative to look at.

Earlier, if a doctor came to a government hospital and did nothing but check blood pressure with kindness, the patient would still feel that their health was improving, that the doctor had served them. Today, even if a doctor comes ten times, they think, "This is government; it would have been better if I had gone to a private one." In other words, in the life of an ordinary person, an alternative has become available in the last 10-15-20 years. Now, because an alternative is available, the responsibility of the system called government and especially of those associated with the civil service has increased significantly compared to what it was 20 years ago. The workload has not increased. The challenges have increased. Difficulties have not arisen due to the workload. We are finding it harder to stand up to the challenges. Any system should be competitive, and that plays a significant role in bringing about qualitative change. If there is stagnation, if there are no aspirations, if there is no comparative system, it seems that everything is fine as it is. But when a comparative situation arises, we also feel that we need to move forward. The solution is not to bring others down so that we appear to be ahead; rather, we should keep elevating those who can rise, and it would be better if we change our working style and our way of thinking as quickly as possible. The sooner we emerge from the mindset of being a regulator and develop as an enabling entity, the more this challenge will turn into an opportunity. What seems like a challenge today will become an opportunity, and therefore, in changing times, we should feel the absence of government, but not feel the burden while the government is present. How do we develop such a system? This system will develop when we start looking at things in that way.

Now, some efforts are underway here. Just remember this Civil Service Day: why was it like this before, and why is it like this now? The answer should not be that the Prime Minister thought of it and we did it; no. The way of thinking should be that such a great opportunity existed, and we turned it into a ritual. If we breathe life into it, connect ourselves to it, and think about the days to come, then that very opportunity gives us new strength. The change that is visible in this one opportunity, and if you feel it is right, then the same possibilities are inherent in every work you do. It just needs to be touched once, and the realization will begin. Can we learn from these things? What are the reasons? You too have come out of that process at some point. You have worked in a village. Gradually, you came to the district, and by doing this, we have reached here. There will be many others who worked in the district last time and are working in the district this time as well. But they did not feel it before, which is why the entry was less than a hundred. And this time, it suddenly increased. There has been a quantum jump, and I welcome it. Perhaps someone asked, "Did you send it or not?" So, they felt that not sending it would raise questions, so they sent it. But when the report came to me, my mind started working differently. I said, "Let’s do this; it’s good that there has been a quantum jump. We were below a hundred, and now we are over five hundred; that’s a good thing. Now there should be a little qualitative analysis. We should see that even if we cannot give someone the number one, number two, or number three position, at least we should look seriously; we should feel, 'Hey, let’s see how well they have done.' How many are in the category of excellence? I do not want to disclose the figures; live TV is on. But still, I am satisfied because, well, a start has been made, a quantum jump has occurred. Now I want to see qualitative change in a year. There should be no entry below excellence. Because in this system, there are people who have the stamp of excellence; that is why they have reached here.

It is true that they may have joined some coaching classes... well, you all understand. But still, the stamp of excellence is here. If excellence is here, then we must also develop the habit of performing accordingly, and gradually, you may have seen that a housewife sometimes does not get noticed for her status, skill, or capability in the family. It is taken for granted. But if the head of the family is suddenly taken away by God, it becomes apparent that the housewife, who was once connected to the stove, starts running the entire family business. She raises the children excellently. And the men in the neighborhood feel embarrassed as she elevates her family life to great heights. Until yesterday, she was anonymous; inherent strength was there, and as soon as the opportunity arose, she blossomed, fulfilling her responsibilities. Here, those who have taken exams must have gone through a lot of pressure, but now you have such a large system. A great opportunity has come, and you have the chance to look at things in new ways. Will you adopt this? I am experiencing that the burden of hierarchy is indeed there. Perhaps it is a legacy from the British era, which we have not been able to shake off even from Mussoorie. But I know everything; in my time, it was like this. "Hey, you just came; we have been district officers for many years, 20 years ago." This burden of experience is being transferred continuously. We should think, senior people should think, is this burden of experience not becoming a hindrance? Is my experience not acting as a brake on new experiments? Do I feel that I have now become a secretary here? In that district where I used to work, I tried to complete this work in my time, but I did not succeed. Twenty years have passed. Now this new guy has come and is doing it; my respect will be tarnished. Someone will ask, "You were not able to do it; look, this child has done it." So, the burden of my experience is increasing the brake, and I become the obstacle. I can do it in another district, but in the district where I worked and where it did not happen during my time, now you cannot earn respect by doing it... this is the reality. Whether it feels good or bad, this is the truth. We should take pride that the field I plowed, I moved on from there, but the one who came after me managed the water supply. The third one came and brought a sapling from somewhere. The fourth one came and made it a banyan tree. The fifth one came and brought fruits to me. All five have value when the results are achieved. If we carry this sentiment forward in this tradition, we will add strength, and adding strength can be our effort. We should try.

I said last time, what has been the greatest strength of the civil service? And this is not a small strength. In Gujarati, we have a saying; I do not know what it would be in Hindi. "Thothnishar," meaning the value of the clever is felt more by the one who is weak in studies. The one who is completely weak knows that the one who is fast is indeed fast. Money is a quality that we politicians understand equally. And I believe this is a very great strength. We should not let it go. It is a tremendous strength, and that is anonymity.

You will see many officers who must have had some vision or idea during their tenure. They must have implemented it, created a complete framework for implementation, and the results must have benefited the entire country. But even when searching, it may not be known who had the opportunity, who had the idea, and how it was done. This anonymity, I believe, is the greatest strength of the civil service in this country because I know what its power is. But unfortunately, somewhere, is it diminishing? I am a person who recognizes the power of social media. I understand its importance. But if the development of systems happens through it, and it helps connect the systems to the public, then it is useful. If I am a district officer through the network of social media and I use social media to promote vaccination, saying that vaccination is on the 20th, please come, spread the word. I am using social media, but if I go to administer two drops of vaccination and my photo is being circulated on Facebook, then I become a question mark for anonymity. How can I use the same system? Today, I see that district-level officers are so busy, so busy, that most of their time goes into this. I have recently closed entry for everyone in my meetings. Otherwise, all meetings start with this. What power should come for what purpose, and what should not come? If there is no discernment in this, it is necessary that we have excellent means to reach the people.

The world has begun to move from E-governance to M-governance. Mobile governance is the reality of the time; we cannot stay away from it. But it should be for fulfilling the needs of the people, for providing public facilities. I believe this anonymity; this has been our entire strength. How many have designed the Taj Mahal, how many have prepared concept papers, how many have worked hard, but neither you know nor I know; but the Taj Mahal reminds us that by and large, the people in this field have done this work throughout their lives. Occasionally, after retirement, you may ask yourself, "Hey, tell me five things," and you may not even remember because they have become so dedicated to their work that they feel, "Oh, I was doing it, I did it, let’s move on." What a tremendous strength we have in our country. And you are the owners of that strength. I understand its value because I know that if our photos go from here to there, our night becomes bad; our community is like that. And therefore, I know that working day and night for the country without establishing one’s own identity is not a small thing. I can appreciate this very well. I understand this strength very well. But it is a very big responsibility of our new generation to maintain the tradition that our previous generation and our seniors have built, and it is necessary to ensure that it does not get scratched.

As we celebrate this civil service day, committees for governance reform will have been formed all over the world, commissions will be sitting; they will be in the central government, in the state government. And those who created them may not have read them thoroughly. Because six people must have written pieces, and then someone must have combined them. This is the reality, whether it feels good or bad, this is the truth. And after that, perhaps the address will not even be known, where it is kept. In the states too, many governments must have thought, "We will make some reforms, we will make some reforms, we will create commissions," and it is fine; some people get work after retirement, but change does not come. Even today, from my experience, I can say, I have been fortunate that if I were in this system like you, it would not have been possible because I did not have any coaching classes, but if someone works for 16 years, what can they become? They become deputy secretaries, what do they become? They become directors, so I would fall into the category of director because I have been working with you for 16 years. I have been working with you in this very system. And therefore, my opinion is, and I have seen the experience, truly, the experience of those working in this system and their suggestions cannot be surpassed by any commission’s recommendations for reform; this is our wrong thinking. The suggestions you have are better than any that can come from outside, sir. We still do not give it attention, nor do we follow it. Can we bring this into our character? A small person, from their experience, this exercise that is going on, the paper being written, I asked the four latest batch people, "Please write something, let a new thought process come to us," and everyone wrote. Some may have cut and pasted. I did not see it all, but this is human nature; it happens. But still, something must have come out of it that involved some contemplation. Now it is the main task of the key people in this system that this exercise was not done to obtain a degree; it was not done for academic ranking; it was not done for my paper to be accepted. What has come are the experiences, the words of those who work on the ground, who spend their lives with farmers, who spend their lives with clerical workers, who spend their lives with their new computer operators, who see the crises that arise due to office timings and seasons; they have said it.

Can we hold this like a Holy book? Even if a small person has said it, if it has come from within us, then its strength is very great; can we prepare our mindset for this? You see, when it comes from within, it has ownership. Ownership is the first guarantee of any success. Success comes when the team takes ownership. The more the number of ownership increases, the faster success comes, responsibilities decrease, the burden decreases, and the glory of the results is shared by all. This effort is a kind of ownership movement. These two days we sit together, this is the most significant aspect; it is an ownership movement. Everyone feels that yes, this country is mine, this government is mine, this responsibility is mine, I must bring results, I must provide solutions to problems.

It is certain that the true test of a person comes at a certain time, and you are well aware of this because you are in that position. A state of deprivation does not accurately assess a person. A state of influence does. When you have everything yet feel detached, that is when it becomes clear that yes, this is something. When there is nothing, one feels, well, we live like this; no one notices, it doesn't matter. You have every kind of influence, the entire governance system is at your fingertips, the power of your words, your signature, can change someone's world from here to there; what you do then is your test. And therefore, a person is not evaluated in a state of deprivation, but in a state of influence.

Similarly, in progress, by and large, we have gone through a phase in our country where many of us have thought about how to find paths amidst deprivation. Working amidst abundance is something that, by and large, a large class of us does not think about. They knew how to manage perfectly in times of drought, but they did not know how to manage when there is an abundance of food; that is where they falter. They knew how to admit students when there were vacant seats in engineering colleges, but when the seats are fewer and the number of students increases, they struggle to manage.

As the country progresses, as the expressions of the general public are merging with their hard work, we are also witnessing abundance. When there is less water, one learns how to bathe, but when the fountain is running and the information comes that one should bathe with less water, it becomes difficult to follow. In the midst of abundance, wherever the possibilities of abundance are visible, or we see abundances before our eyes, can we change our strategies for that? Can we change our mindset? Otherwise, we will not be able to grow. The limits of our thinking will remain the same. We have thought of accepting those challenges and moving forward.

As I said at the beginning, we were in our own world, there was no competition with other districts. In this district, there is water, so agriculture is good; in that district, there is drought, so agriculture does not happen; it happens, it happens, I, my ancestors did this, that was the case. Now it is not just about districts; the world has changed so much that now there is competition between states, now there is competition between countries, there is competition between yesterday and today. Every moment we have to rise above the challenges of this system and it is necessary to do so in a global context as well.

Another strength of the civil service, and I believe it is also its duty, is that a person in the civil service has no right to act outside of that duty; whether they are sitting in a district, in a tehsil, or as the final authority; it is their responsibility to weigh every proposal, every incident, every decision on the scales of national interest, they do not have the right to see it in fragments. This decision I make here, but will it not have a negative impact somewhere in my country? I will manage here, I will get applause, but will this decision not impact some corner of my country? This scale belongs to the civil service. Their training has been done in such a way that there should never be a deficiency in it. Governments will come and go; leaders will come and go; this system is eternal. And the fundamental duty of this system is to weigh every decision on the scales of national interest. And they must also consider what impact it will have in the future. If they do not think about the impact in the future, it will not work. And therefore, in the civil service, we have received training to understand the changing times, how do we make ourselves relevant in it? If we become irrelevant in a changed world, then perhaps the situation will reach a point where we will not exist. And therefore, our institutional growth, institutional development, institutional mechanism, we must continuously overhaul it; it needs lubrication.

Yes, there has been a lot of talk about HR here, I do not know if the topic of lubrication came up in HR. What is the reason that we all civil service people have a 25-year-old issue hanging, a 30-year-old issue hanging, not due to a lack of leadership decisions, but stuck between the files of two departments, what is the reason? And that same issue when the Prime Minister of India initiates the PRAGATI (Pro-Active Governance And Timely Implementation) program and it gets listed in such a way that so many things are to be seen in the PRAGATI program and decisions are made quickly within 24 hours, all clearances are obtained, and projects worth 8-9 lakh crores are cleared, what was the reason? If PRAGATI is successful, I can celebrate that there is a Prime Minister of the country who is solving many long-standing problems using technology. For me, that is not a matter of satisfaction; for me, the lesson is that all my colleagues should think, what is the reason that the decision you made in 24 hours was hanging for 15 years? Roads are being built, people need them, but the forest department is stuck, but the Prime Minister intervened and it got cleared, this situation is not good. Celebrating the success of PRAGATI for Modi will not benefit the country; that is a temporary thing. The benefit to the country lies in the fact that my system runs smoothly, there should be a lubricating system among every officer, there should be lubricating cooperation. Friction consumes power; lubrication smoothens power. Are we thinking in that direction? I still do not understand. Why are two departments of the government fighting in court, I do not understand. Two different departments with different views in court, the government is one. Do we, as an All India Civil Service, accept our weaknesses? Is anyone afraid of responsibility? Is anyone running away from responsibility? Or is there some ego coming in between? I would like this Civil Service Day to be an opportunity for self-reflection. How much time is being wasted in the country’s courts, how many obstacles are there for the common man who needs it? And what causes a case to win or lose, if an officer writes a line in a file without thinking it through, and some interested group gets hold of that file, the matter gets ruined. Meeting, discussing, and thinking that someone makes a quick decision with bad intentions is not necessary. Those who make such allegations have not yet substantiated any allegations. And therefore, there is no need to hesitate; if it is done with integrity, honestly for the public interest, no power in the world can hold you wrong. If something happens for a moment, it happens, it will be seen, I stand with you.

Work should be done with integrity, who stops it? And today there is an opportunity to make bold decisions, today there is an opportunity to think out of the box, today there is an opportunity to step onto a new path even while following the determined path and I believe that every colleague working with me may have had very few such opportunities in their lives as they have today. Because I am a person of this thought.

Here, the talk of reform, perform, transform is happening. The political will depends on the desire for reform, but your duty power depends on performance. The political will can bring about reform, but if the duty power of this team falls short, then performance does not happen, and if there is no public participation, then transformation does not happen. So these three things; political will power can bring about reform, but the bureaucratic system, governance, performs. And public participation transforms. It is very important for us to run these three on the same wavelength. When we run all three on the same wavelength, we achieve the desired results.

I would like us to not be negligent in self-reflection on the occasion of Civil Service Day. Think about the day you were selected for the civil service, how your parents saw you, how your friends saw you, and remember that moment when you left home. I believe that moment, that moment is the best guide you can have, which was the first moment of your life. That is the strength of your life. If there is something else, then you have derailed; if that remains, then you are on the true path; there is no need to remember my words, nor do you need to remember how many of your seniors in India have told you to remember someone, just remember the thought that came to your mind the day you were selected for the civil service; that will remain your inspiration; I do not believe that this country will suffer any loss. There is no need for anything from outside. Just remember that, remember it again and again, remember Civil Service Day; go back 30-40 years, remember that moment when your parents found out that you passed UPSC, became IAS, and were now moving forward, now about to leave for Mussoorie. Remember that moment, your parents must have come to drop you off at the railway station, remember that moment. Just remember the first 24, 48 hours, how many dreams you set out with, was there any dilution, diversion in that? There is no need for anyone else's advice, no need for any inspirational story; this is a very big strength in itself.

The government has a nature, and it needs significant changes, and that target has been achieved. Does change really come from the game of numbers? There is a story that is quite popular among you, perhaps you know it or we hear it, I do not know who thinks what. Some people were working in a garden. A senior person saw this. These two people are working so hard, sweating. One is digging a pit and the other is filling it with soil. So he became very curious, he was a little aware citizen. He went and asked, brother, what are you doing? You are two people, no, they said, we are not two, we are three. He asked, three? No, they said, the third one did not come today. So he asked, what work are you doing? They said, it is my responsibility to dig the pit, the one who did not come is responsible for planting the sapling, and this one is responsible for putting in the soil. But he did not come, but our work is going on. He is digging the pit, I am, he did not come. Was it reduced? It was done, as many hours as it was supposed to be done, as much soil as was to be taken out, was taken out; what benefit did the country get? Why? Because one was missing.

Outcome-centric, we should weigh everything, and this time for the first time there has been great courage, last year with the budget, an outcome-related document was provided with the budget, very few people may have studied it. For the first time in India, an outcome document was provided with the budget. We should propagate this down to our culture that everything must be weighed on the scales of outcome, not output. Output is fine for the CAG, Outcome is a step CAG+1, and that is the democracy of the country; which is two steps ahead of the CAG. And therefore, if we look at CAG-centered Output, we may not see change in the country, but if we do it with CAG+ thinking, with Outcome, then we will leave something for the country.

After 70 years of independence, for the first time, completing all processes 100%, the country’s budget will be completed by March 31, and on April 1, the new budget will start spending new money, for the first time after 70 years of independence, it has happened, it has happened for the first time. You are the ones, it is your achievement, you have shown it. This means that even today, among my colleagues, there is the strength to do what my army decides, I experience that. And therefore, my confidence is many times greater. People sometimes talk about despair; I remember you, I remember your duties, despair does not resonate with me, it does not touch me.

In the last three years, I have experienced, my experience in Gujarat is deep, but here my experience of three years; in three years I have experienced that I have put forth an idea and I have not seen its result, I do not recall any such incident, who did it? And therefore, political will is needed to reform, I do not have that problem; perhaps it is extra. But duty is very necessary for performance. And who does this work, tell me? The Prime Minister says that I have an idea, who converts that idea into policy? You do. Who converts it into a scheme? You do. Who allocates responsibility? You do. Where will the resources come from? You do. After deciding, who monitors? You do. Who finds out where the shortcomings were? You do. Who finds out what went wrong? You do. Everything, when an outsider sees, they will be surprised that these people also find their shortcomings! These people also find their mistakes! These people strive for their improvement! Such a homogeneous system is a great gift to the country from the All India Civil Service, and therefore today is a very important day for the country because this is a system that continuously tests itself against its own standards, correcting itself; it may be that it falls two steps behind expectations, but the effort is to fulfill those expectations, that is what the Team does; how can the respect of this Team among the citizens of the country increase? Why has this feeling arisen in the minds of the common people instead of a positive feeling towards you? What is the reason? We should do this self-reflection. And if we do self-reflection, I do not believe that there will be a need for any major change. It is a small issue that needs to be handled. If we can handle this, then it transforms from deprivation to positivity.

When floods come in Kashmir, and when the army people risk their lives to save anyone's life, then those same people also applaud them, even if they throw stones later; but for a moment, it touches them too, these are my people who are willing to die for me. This strength is within you, this strength is within you. We are the people who will move forward with such a bright past.

I would like to say to you, in 2022, we are celebrating 75 years of independence. We should not run the country in fragments; we should unite the country with a dream. To transform every dream into a resolution, we should play the role of a catalytic agent. Why should this sentiment not arise in the hearts of 1.25 billion countrymen? In 2022, the dreams that the freedom fighters saw, which led us to independence; and which brought us to this state, we should also have a resolution to fulfill their dreams. We should also have some churning. The unit that I see, will that unit have its own resolutions or not? With the people I do business with, will I pull them along with my dreams or not? Will I take them with me or not? If in 2022, the 75 years of India's independence do not become a dream for every employee, big or small, sitting within the government of India, then we will do injustice to those freedom fighters who laid down their lives for the country. This should be our collective resolution.

We talk about cleaning the Ganges; there must be some civil service person who is in charge of some village on the banks of the Ganges, right? There cannot be a village on the banks of the Ganges that is not connected to some civil service person. Since the time of Rajiv Gandhi, the talk of cleaning the Ganges has been ongoing; there must have been some civil service person in charge of that village on the banks. They must have been in the district when that village came under their jurisdiction, and they must have been in the tehsil as well. If I am in the civil service, and the country wants to clean the Ganges, and the Government of India has a program for cleaning the Ganges, at the very least, I will not allow filth to go into the Ganges from that village; can my colleague not make such a resolution? Once my officer decides who will be in charge there, I will ensure that no filth goes into the Ganges from the village I am in charge of; who says the Ganges cannot be cleaned? We need to create methods right here. We need to connect our dreams and resolutions with micro-level management. We will have to take responsibility, feel a sense of ownership; if we do these things, we can bring about change. And let us keep in mind that the world is looking at India with great hope. With changing democratic values, the world is viewing India in a different light. Until yesterday, we did whatever we did to make ends meet, but before 2022, we should dream about how India can emerge as a power in the world; we should move forward with this dream. And this is not just the duty of the elected people; it is the duty of those working in public life, and it is even more the duty of those living in the governance system. If this happens, and if every administrator or ruler moves in one direction, if the wavelength is the same, I am confident that we can achieve definite results.

We always remember Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel. Everyone has made efforts to align this system with the dreams of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel in the Indian context. Now it is our responsibility to prove ourselves in this changing era, in the period of challenges, in the competitive environment, and to strive to fulfill the dreams of the common man.

Once again, on this Civil Service Day, I extend my heartfelt congratulations to all our colleagues in this field across the country and in every corner of the world, and I acknowledge the debt to all the generations that have worked to bring the country to this point; I thank them and wish you all the best.

Thank you very much.