Speech by Chancellor Scholz at the International Peace Meeting of the Community of Sant’Egidio on September 12, 2023.

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

12 September 2023 · International Peace Meeting of the Community of Sant'Egidio · Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the International Peace Meeting of the Community of Sant'Egidio in Berlin on September 12, 2023, speaking on war, peace, and support for Ukraine.
Main themes
Peace and justice, Ukraine-Russia war, support for Ukraine, Thucydides Trap and geopolitical conflict, weapons supply to Ukraine, Community of Sant'Egidio, rejection of false peace, territorial integrity, Germany's historical responsibility, interfaith dialogue, ethics of self-defense
Duration
~13 min
47th percentile
Words
1,608
47th percentile
Sentences
80
52nd percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.36
85th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 50%49%
  • Ceremonial 27%26%
  • Social 21%20%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

80 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Dear Professor Riccardi,

dear Professor Impagliazzo,

Eminences,

Excellencies,

esteemed representatives of churches and religions,

ladies and gentlemen,

a warm welcome to Germany ‑ or rather: A heartfelt "welcome back"! We are pleased and honored that your peace meeting is taking place in Germany for the fourth time. You are not only always welcome guests here ‑ you are also visiting friends.

With your meeting in Berlin, you underscore the connection between your community and a country ‑ Germany ‑ whose own path to peace is marked by terrible errors, by imperial and nationalist delusions that have plunged Europe and the world into unimaginable suffering twice. And precisely for this reason, Germany today is a country that extends its hand to anyone who dares to pursue peace.

At the outset, I would like to tell you about a book that I was finally able to read over the summer and that has occupied my thoughts since then. Some of you may be familiar with it. It is by the American professor Graham Allison, and the title is: "Destined to War."

Starting from the ancient contrast between Sparta and the rising Athens, Allison deals with the so-called "Thucydides Trap," the assumption that the rise of new great powers inevitably leads to war with the existing hegemon. Of course, the current, extremely troubling question looms: Is war ultimately unavoidable in an increasingly multipolar world like ours? The purely statistical answer of the book is: In twelve of the sixteen cases studied over the past five centuries of human history, war occurred in such constellations. For the pessimist, this means: The outlook for peace is grim ‑ namely 3:1 in favor of war.

However, Sant’Egidio has never resigned itself to such arithmetic. On the contrary: Your entire movement is founded on the rejection of a supposed logic of war. You counter it with the "audacity of peace." That is why you are here today. That is also why I am very pleased to be here today, because I share not only your optimism but also your goal: to dare peace.

But this observation alone is not enough in practice. We all know that. Today, no one in Europe longs for peace as much as the Ukrainians. Every day, they defend their freedom, their homeland, their lives against the imperial, historically blinded power fantasies of the ruler in the Kremlin. The peace plan that President Zelensky is advocating worldwide clearly expresses this longing for peace.

At the same time, we must guard against false solutions that merely carry the name "peace." Peace without freedom means oppression. Peace without justice is called diktat.

That is why we fully support Ukraine's demands for a just peace that respects the principles of the United Nations Charter and honors the principles of territorial integrity and independence. That is why we support the Ukrainians in defending their homeland.

We do this by supplying weapons. This decision was not made lightly ‑ and we do not take it lightly. Precisely because we are aware of the impact of the weapons we supply, we coordinate closely and continually reassess what is necessary and responsible in the current situation.

But that does not change my fundamental conviction: The law must overcome violence, not the other way around. Anything else would mean recognizing the law of the stronger. History has taught us where this path leads, through centuries of colonial exploitation and war destruction.

For me, this means: We will continue to support Ukraine in its right to self-defense ‑ for as long as necessary. I consider this not only politically and strategically necessary but also ethically required for peace.

I am grateful to the German Bishops' Conference for making this unequivocally clear in their statement right after the beginning of the Russian war of aggression. "Resist aggression ‑ win peace," the bishops titled their statement ‑ and in this order. Because defending one's own existence against the aggressor is the prerequisite for an independent, free Ukraine to regain peace and for Russia's leadership to be ready for genuine negotiations.

Our search for peace must start from this reality. That is why I am grateful to you, Professor Riccardi, for always demanding realism in action alongside the hope for peace and aligning the work of Sant’Egidio with that.

When the Jewish-Christian scriptures speak of the wolf finding protection with the lamb, of the calf and the lion grazing together, this is unfortunately neither a description of our reality then nor now, but a promise and a call to work for a different, better, more peaceful world.

In other words: While we must not close our eyes to the fact that man can be a wolf to man, we must not resign ourselves to this verdict either. Especially since this famous saying by Plautus has a second part. It reads in full: Man is a wolf to man, at least as long as one does not know each other.

With that, I return to Sant’Egidio and the principle that has shaped your community since its founding in 1968. You rely on the peace-building power of encounter, of mutual knowing and recognizing, of learning from one another. It is this power that sooner or later leads to the realization that we are all human beings ‑ endowed with equal rights, equal duties, and equal dignity, regardless of where one is born, regardless of whether or what one believes.

Implementing this realization in everyday life is the task of all states that have committed themselves to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. At the same time, as the successful work of Sant’Egidio shows, it is within the power and responsibility of religious leaders like you to strengthen this realization of our shared, unifying humanity, especially because in the name of religion, not only peace has been created but also wars have been waged and are still being waged, precisely because religion has been and is being misused to deny women and men their human rights.

All the more significant is it when you raise your voices together for peace and mutual respect, as you, Grand Imam al-Tayyeb, did when you declared together with Pope Francis in 2019 that "religions must never incite to war and must not awaken feelings of hatred, hostility, extremism, or call for violence or bloodshed."

This realization that it is not war that is sacred, but peace, has become the common foundation of your work. It follows the principle that those who want peace must also prepare for peace. Sant’Egidio has demonstrated how this can be done around the world, for example, through your successful mediation in the civil war in Mozambique, through support for the disarmament of fighters in the Central African Republic, through your reconciliation work in South Sudan, together with representatives of the Anglican Church. This list could be extended, and I want to encourage you to continue your humanitarian work in Ukraine with all your might. This includes assistance for refugees and discussions about the exchange of prisoners. Often, it is precisely such small advances that help to eventually create the ground for an end to violence and thus for a just peace.

We are also working on this. Recently, with our support and that of many other friendly countries, Ukraine has succeeded in bringing important states from Africa, Asia, and Latin America to the table, including China, India, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Brazil. Together, we are now working to advance the different elements of the Ukrainian peace formula and principles for a peace solution. This is not easy ‑ especially considering the different perceptions of the Russian war in the world ‑ and it takes effort and time, time that we actually do not have, as Russia continues to bomb, torture, and kill in Ukraine.

Yet, as pressing as time is ‑ Pope Francis is right when he describes the work for peace as the "work of patient craftsmen." This is an apt description because it conveys the realization that peace does not fall from the sky but is the product of human effort, and that the path to peace leads from the small to the large. To be craftsmen of peace means to advocate for equal rights, equal duties, and equal dignity every day. The path begins where we ensure that children and young people everywhere in the world have good educational opportunities, where we seriously and solidarily fight against poverty and the consequences of man-made climate change, where we welcome women and men who flee from war and political persecution. This is a command of humanity!

At the same time, we must ensure that acceptance for this remains in our societies. This also belongs here when we understand peace as "social peace" and when we want to counter the great simplifiers, the black-and-white thinkers, the fearmongers, and the populists.

We should dare to walk this path of peace, and to do so in growing unity. Because in a world with many new centers of power, in societies that are becoming increasingly diverse and individual, we all must learn anew to live together in mutual respect for our differences. This applies in the multipolar world. It also applies in a country like Germany, where today people of many different religions and worldviews live together. Seeking not the divisive but the unifying, namely the inviolable dignity of each individual, also means "daring peace." Whatever I can contribute to this as the German Chancellor, I am happy to do.

For the tireless commitment with which Sant’Egidio and all of you dare peace, I want to say to you today from the bottom of my heart: Thank you!