Speech by Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz on the 75th anniversary of the German School of Journalism (DJS) on June 3, 2024, in Munich:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

4 June 2024 · 75th anniversary of the German School of Journalism (DJS) · Munich, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the German School of Journalism's 75th anniversary celebration on June 3, 2024, in Munich, reflecting on journalism's role in democracy.
Main themes
Role of journalism in democracy, media trust and public orientation, disinformation and information overload, political alienation from elites, media fragmentation and new formats, social media and journalism competition, quality journalism and training, financing of independent media, public discourse and engagement
Duration
~15 min
51st percentile
Words
1,768
51st percentile
Sentences
123
73rd percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
8.7
8th percentile
Syntax
2.71
14th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 52%52%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Technological 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

123 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Dear Ms. Löwisch,

dear Minister-President Söder,

dear students of the DJS,

dear former DJS students,

ladies and gentlemen!

A confession upfront: My day begins with a newspaper. And preferably on paper. And it also ends with the newspaper, as I can read the online editions in the evening on my tablet. I read not only the politics section but almost everything. Because that is the best thing about a well-made newspaper: not only to see confirmed what you already know but to discover what you have not yet encountered.

So if someone asks: What do we need newspapers, magazines, radio, podcasts, talk shows, or news broadcasts for, when every piece of information can be found on the internet – and for free at that?

What do we still need journalists for, when anyone can record videos with their phone and post them online? When AI can write scientific papers and tailor news precisely to the preferences of the recipient?

Then I reply: We need you for orientation! So that we do not sink – in a sea of information and disinformation.

We need you especially now. Because reliable information is absolutely essential for political debate – and even more so for public debate. That is why it is a problem when some claim that "politics" and "the media" belong to the same sauce.

In fact, the opposite is true: Maintaining critical distance from those they report on is what distinguishes good journalists. A distance that broadens the perspective and sharpens independent judgment. As a politician, I say: I respect that and I appreciate it. Because I believe that this critical distance is an essential component of good reporting, as it has been taught here at the DJS for 75 years.

But back to the sauce. I believe it is about alienation. A feeling of alienation towards supposed and actual elites, to which politics and journalism are equally counted.

For politics, I can say: It is not always entirely innocent in this regard. When personal ambitions overshadow the struggle for substantive solutions; when the quick headline seems more important than Weber's "drilling hard boards"; when disputes serve not the matter but personal profiling – then citizens quickly turn away, shaking their heads.

And then politics seduces journalism not to report on the matter itself but on performance, on personalities and egos, winners and losers. Journalism then reduces itself to theater criticism.

However, today it should not be about the media's view of politics, but rather the other way around, the view of a politician on journalism and the media. That is how I understand the invitation to me to give this keynote address.

The question I ask myself, and which surely many of you are concerned with: Why has the trust of "the public" in German media and politics been declining for years?

However, one must actually pose another question first. "What is this ominous public – where can I find it?" One thing seems clear: The times when Tagesschau, Wetten dass, Sportstudio, or Tatort were the great campfire around which the nation gathered are all over. And they will not return. The offerings and channels are simply too diverse. Instead of one big campfire, there are now many smaller ones.

Politics and media must respond to this if they want to create public discourse and not just reach shrinking parts of it. And I believe that must be the goal. Because it is dangerous to lose sight of parts of our society whose day does not begin with the daily newspaper and end with the daily topics. Those who no longer subscribe to a local newspaper.

It is no coincidence that I, as Chancellor, and also the Minister-President, can now be found on TikTok, Instagram, WhatsApp, and X, or record football podcasts. I do not participate in singing and dancing, which distinguishes me from Markus Söder. I have drawn a clear red line there.

Many of you in the editorial offices, in publishing houses, and also at the DJS are constantly testing new formats and outlets. In doing so, you are in more or less direct competition with around five billion users of social media worldwide, who post, produce content, influence, comment, and blog.

The difference, however, is: You are journalists! You provide the orientation that we urgently need every day in social media. My plea is: Embrace this role, because no one can do it as well as you. You have the necessary training.

Despite all the justified concerns about the financing of independent quality media, I also believe that there will be even more media business to be found in the future. With relevant content, money can still be made in the future, I am deeply convinced of that. Being present on TikTok is initially easy. All it takes is a smartphone, an app, and a briefcase. But breaking down complex political content and finding an angle that works on this platform is significantly more difficult.

Recording a podcast is not rocket science. But shaping a conversation so that it has substance and is not just chatter is the high art. An art that you have learned or are currently learning here at the DJS. I am convinced that this will be even more important for journalism in the future. At the same time, however, journalism must be better than ever to stay afloat in the sea of information and disinformation. Because it is not enough to simply engage new channels and attract new target groups. It is, of course, also about the quality of the content – that is and remains central.

From my own experience as a passionate newspaper reader, I can tell you: There are still happy reader-newspaper relationships, even today. Even a Social Democrat can be pleased while reading a newspaper with a rather conservative orientation.

Sapere aude – have the courage to use your own understanding! Kant elevated this to the guiding principle of human enlightenment. But for independent thinking to be possible, I need a breadth of information and a place where I can find it. Those who specifically search for a particular piece of news on a topic will end up with Google or ChatGPT. And those who only want to perceive one opinion, in doubt their own, will end up in the echo chamber of their own milieu.

The difference between a well-made newspaper or a professional news broadcast is that I may not find the political tendency there great or right. But I do not have to look elsewhere to feel: I am well informed all around. I can form my own opinion. Think for myself. What is presented in the media and what is not – this curation – is therefore of fundamental importance. It structures our world.

One of your colleagues from ZEIT wrote a piece about this a few weeks ago, and it made me think. She wrote regarding the German media on topics such as Russia's war in Ukraine or the Corona pandemic: "A consensus is suggested that does not exist in Germany."

Do not get me wrong: I am convinced that Corona restrictions were necessary. They saved many people's lives. And Germany is, for good reason, by far the largest supporter of Ukraine in Europe.

But I also repeatedly find that in conversations with citizens across the country, I am often asked completely different questions than in interviews. Instead of questions about specific weapon systems, I hear concerns about an escalation of the war and sometimes questions about whether our support has already gone too far. By no means are all who think this way radical.

But these are concerns that are publicly – if at all – only perceived as expressions from the extreme political spectrum. Then we should not be surprised if people feel unheard. When a study shows that a quarter of respondents say: Topics that are important to me are "not taken seriously" in the media. Then that is an alarming finding.

I would like to contribute two suggestions that might help remedy the situation.

First:

I know you have to sharpen and simplify to keep complex issues understandable. That is not only your job. It is absolutely necessary. But I probably do not reveal a secret when I tell you: Some things become too simplistic for me. In a time of growing complexity, reporting cannot become less complex without losing credibility.

And that is why my appeal is for more diversity of opinion in a publication. More facts instead of nudging. More content instead of campaigns. More information instead of attitude. That would do our country good.

Second:

To address the entire breadth of the population, something must also change in the editorial offices. In local newsrooms, but also in the capital.

In Berlin, men often report on men. The debate about women in leadership positions continues – also in publishing houses and broadcasters. There are still too few East German voices that are heard nationwide. When it comes to diversity in the editorial offices, there is, to put it cautiously, still room for improvement.

That is why we, as the federal government, supported the project "Strong for Diversity" of the New German Media Makers and also supported the initiative #dukannstjournalismus of the DJS. Because not all young people have grown up with German newspapers, listen to Deutschlandfunk in the morning, or watch the evening news with their parents.

But we need these people, especially if we want to reach as many as possible in our country. A country in which 25 percent have a migration background. If we want diversity of opinion in the publications and broadcasts, if we want quality journalism to have a future. I firmly believe in this future.

Artificial intelligence can support journalists in their work. But it cannot replace the good ones. Writing simple news, the weather and stock report, that may soon be done by AI. Condensing the dpa report into eight lines.

But to comment and contextualize in a balanced way, to investigate and portray? How this profession works can be learned in an excellent way here at the DJS for 75 years. This is important because citizens – and I too – rely on you.

Without a free, independent, and diverse press, it will not only be difficult to think for oneself. Without a free, independent, and diverse press, there is no democracy.

For 75 years, the DJS has reliably provided the best talent for our free press.

That is why I say today not only: Congratulations! – but also: All the best and thank you very much!