Appearance of the acting Prime Minister after the meeting with the leaders of PP, Cs, and UP.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

16 October 2019

Context
Sánchez addressed party leaders and the public on October 16, 2019, following violent protests in Catalonia triggered by the Supreme Court's ruling on independence leaders.
Main themes
Catalan unrest, state security forces, political unity, democratic firmness, right to peaceful protest, rule of law, violence condemnation, proportionality in response, constitutional order, civil rights protection
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,538
68th percentile
Sentences
113
69th percentile
Readability
40
37th percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.19
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
55th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 42%35%
  • Institutional 28%24%
  • Social 17%14%
  • Ceremonial 14%12%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 15%

113 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Good evening, thank you for attending this appearance.

I want my first words to be dedicated to the members of the State Security Forces and Corps. To the men and women of the National Police Corps, the Civil Guard, and the Mossos d'Esquadra who, in these days and at this very hour, with extraordinary professionalism and also under enormous pressure in their work, are working to protect the constitutional rights and freedoms in Catalonia.

On behalf of all Spanish society, I wish to convey recognition and gratitude for their indispensable work in defending constitutional and statutory legality in Catalonia. And, alongside that recognition and gratitude, the wish for the swift recovery of those members of the State Security Forces and Corps and also of the Mossos d'Esquadra who have been injured by the violent disturbances we have witnessed in recent hours.

The professionalism, combined with the great coordination with which the different Security Forces are operating, both state and regional, is the best response to violent extremists. All of them—National Police, Mossos d'Esquadra, and Civil Guard—must know that they have the support of the entire citizenry because they are the guarantors of the most precious thing, which is the defense of public freedoms and civil rights. So thank you for your work and thank you for your restraint in the face of provocations from extremists.

Last night and today we have witnessed in parallel the peaceful exercise of the right to protest by people who are dissatisfied with the ruling issued by the Supreme Court, and also the deployment of perfectly organized violent groups, determined to intimidate and disrupt coexistence with violent and vandalistic actions. There is nothing to object to those who peacefully demonstrate exercising their constitutional right. Moreover, it is the responsibility of public authorities to guarantee their right to the peaceful expression of their ideas.

However, in the face of violent acts, the Government reiterates that it will not allow under any circumstances for violence to prevail over coexistence. The Government of Spain acts and will continue to act with all the mechanisms of the State to guarantee the full validity of fundamental rights and the maintenance of order in Catalonia, including the right to peaceful protest.

The Government of Spain confronts, and will continue to confront, any form of violence against people, against public property, as we are seeing in the city of Barcelona, and also against private property that occurs from organized violent groups or isolated violent individuals.

Catalan society and the whole of Spanish society must know that the Government of Spain considers all scenarios and will respond at every moment with three rules that I have reiterated over the past few days. The first of these is democratic firmness, the serene firmness of our democracy. Secondly, the unity of political parties. And thirdly, proportionality in the response.

Firmness in the defense of democracy and, consequently, the guarantee of our coexistence. Proportionality in the response to the challenge to avoid falling into provocations. And unity, unity of action with all political forces willing to defend constitutional order and, consequently, the rights and freedoms of all Spaniards.

Today I have held meetings with the main leaders of the main parliamentary forces in our country. I have invited them to maintain unity, to set aside party interests in order to provide a united response to this challenge.

And I want to convey to the Spanish people directly what I have just expressed to the leaders of the different parliamentary forces.

First, that the State will always be a guarantor of those who exercise their right to peacefully express their ideas. Secondly, that organized violent groups and, in general, those who aspire to break democratic laws will not achieve their purpose. Our Social and Democratic State of Law is strong and is fully protected by law. Thirdly, that the only hope of violent groups is that we make mistakes; their only hope is to see us exalted and divided. They want us exalted so that we fall into their provocations and feed a violent spiral. And they want us divided to weaken us and try to impose their will over democracy. And they must find us as the gravity of the moment demands: firm, serene, and united.

The legitimate right to protest and assemble recognized in our Constitution in Article 21 must be protected. However, there are no causes, no reasons, no ideals that justify the use of violence in a democracy like the Spanish one, which has conquered freedom after a long and painful struggle.

That is why the first obligation of any democrat is to prevent violence from prevailing over the right to live in peace of millions of Catalans, regardless of their political opinion. Also, the right to coexist of those who, from independence, categorically reject the use of violence. Precisely for this reason, I wish to make an explicit call to the President of the Generalitat of Catalonia. Both he and the members of his Government have the political duty, the moral duty to condemn without excuses and without palliation, with maximum clarity and determination, the use of violence in Catalonia.

In Catalonia, millions of people live who, regardless of their political ideas, have the right to live in peace and security. And that is incompatible with the behavior of violent groups that jeopardize the peace of their cities, the properties of their neighbors, and the physical integrity of citizens, including themselves.

No ruler can camouflage their failure behind smoke and fire curtains.

I also want to inform you that, for weeks, the Government of Spain has been working on various response scenarios. Since last Thursday, October 10, a coordination committee has been activated preventively to monitor, inform, and advise the Presidency of the Government on events that may occur in reaction to the Supreme Court ruling regarding the events that took place on October 1, 2017, in Catalonia.

This committee is composed of representatives from various departments of the Council of Ministers. The Cabinet of the Presidency of the Government, the Vice Presidency of the Government, the Department of National Security, the Ministry of the Interior, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Ministry of Defense for cybersecurity tasks, the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Economy, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Development, and the National Intelligence Center along with the State Secretariat for Communication.

This is the first time this has been done to ensure that coordination is impeccable and that the situation is evaluated as rigorously and meticulously as possible. Coordination that, since last Monday, is also reflected in cooperation through constant communication with the main leaders of political parties.

The activation of this committee, indeed preventive, allows for comprehensive work and access to multidisciplinary information for better decision-making. There is, therefore, as you can see, planning, but also action.

And I want to announce that since last weekend this coordination committee has been on "permanent alert."

The Minister of the Interior, as the media knows, acts as spokesperson and throughout the week has been continuously informing the media about any incidents or developments observed.

I wish to conclude with a call to the whole of Catalan society and the whole of Spanish society. A call for serenity and temperance. The Government of Spain guarantees and will guarantee the rights and freedoms of all in Catalonia. And it will do so from the serene firmness that the Social and Democratic State of Law grants us, from unity, and from proportionality in the response to violence.

Moderation, moderation in the response is also another form of strength.

I am convinced that we will overcome these episodes of violence and there will be no doubt in Catalan society and in the whole of Spanish society that sooner rather than later tranquility and coexistence will be restored in Catalonia.

Thank you very much.

Q: Yes, good afternoon. We know that the Government is investigating who is behind the self-styled Tsunami Democrátic movement. I wanted to know if the Government, as of today, has information that links President Torra to these violent groups acting in Catalonia. I would also like to know what the Government thinks about the fact that the President of the Generalitat participated in a road blockade. And what the Government plans to do if President Torra continues to fail to clearly condemn, as you request, the violence in Catalonia. Thank you.

A: Regarding the first question you raised, I cannot provide you with any information. Right now, as I mentioned earlier, in that Coordination Committee we have been working on for a few weeks, with the Department of National Security, the National Intelligence Center, and the Ministry of the Interior, we are investigating, as the Minister of the Interior, who is acting as spokesperson for that Committee, has said, about that platform. We have information. We are beginning to know exactly who is behind this platform, but I must ask you to allow me not to say anything more about the matter until we can indeed have all the information and be able, in some way, to act on this platform.

And, secondly, regarding the President of the Generalitat of Catalonia, I believe I have been quite clear in the communication, in this institutional statement. I believe that not only the President of the Generalitat but also all members of the Government of the Generalitat must categorically and forcefully condemn any act of violence. Any act of violence. And, of course, and look, I—who have some experience in this, because I had to live through it in circumstances much more dramatic than those we are currently experiencing in 2017—I am very aware that we must be firm. Because, moreover, the Social and Democratic State of Law provides us with the instruments to be firm and effective in the response; but we must guarantee the unity of all political parties. And, above all, we must be proportional in our responses.

The message I would like to convey to Catalan society as a whole and to Spanish society is that we will indeed modulate our response depending on the attitude and decision taken by the institutional political leaders in the Generalitat of Catalonia. But that coexistence, the rights, the freedoms of the Catalans, regardless of what they think and when exercised peacefully, will certainly be preserved by the Government of Spain. Do not doubt that.

And, I also tell you, I am convinced that, despite the dramatic images we have been witnessing in recent days, in these last hours, coexistence and tranquility will be restored in Catalonia. And I believe that one of the main guarantees that this will happen is the extraordinary cooperation that is taking place between the Mossos d'Esquadra, the National Police, and the Civil Guard.

Q: Good evening, President. I would like to return to the question my colleague Beatriz asked you. I would ask you what specifically needs to happen in Catalonia? What needs to happen for the Government to adopt exceptional measures? And I wanted to ask you, above all, for a reflection as President of the Government. You know well that this ruling, these sentences have shocked public opinion in Catalonia, both among independence supporters and non-independence supporters. What message do you send them and how will the dialogue you appeal to be possible with political parties that have their leaders in prison and will have them for 13 years?

Thank you.

A: Well, I believe that on the day the ruling was announced, I was quite clear with Catalan public opinion and also with the Catalan political leaders. And I told them that, first of all, the first thing we had to do was to comply with the ruling, to abide by the ruling. And, secondly, that the Catalan political leaders had to engage in a self-critical exercise; because if anything is demonstrated by the Supreme Court ruling, it is the shipwreck, the failure, of the so-called Catalan independence 'procés'.

I then appealed, and I appeal today before the whole of Catalan society and the whole of Spanish society, to open a new stage. But this new stage must be opened under parameters, premises, that remain valid today, as they did yesterday, and will in the future. And that is that any dialogue must be conducted respecting the law. And the democratic legality that we have all conferred democratically, through massive voting decades ago, by Catalan society, of the Spanish Constitution and the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, are the legal frameworks within which we must dialogue.

And I will also tell you one thing, which is that independence in Catalonia, while significant in percentage, is not a majority, as some Catalan independence forces themselves acknowledge. And therefore, Catalonia needs to reconnect with Catalonia. That Catalan independence must reach out to non-independence Catalans. And that the Catalan institutions must govern for all, not for a part, which is precisely what we are seeing in the figure of President Torra. Look, I believe that he is not governing even for the minority majority of independence supporters in Catalonia, but increasingly for a radicalism, let’s say, in the percentage that may represent independence in Catalonia today. I believe we need to open this new phase, that all political parties, in Catalonia first and foremost, must make an effort to open channels of dialogue, but we must do so, logically, within the framework of statutory and constitutional legality. And there, the Catalan Socialist Party is always willing to engage in dialogue. And, of course, from the perspective of the Government of Spain, we will also be willing to facilitate that dialogue.

And in relation to the first of the issues. Look, I believe that there was an application of Article 155 of the Spanish Constitution in 2017. There is talk or not of the application of the National Security Law by some leaders of the different political parties. There is already doctrine from the Constitutional Court regarding the premises, the conditions for applying Article 155. I believe we have guaranteeing laws. We have the premises, the contexts that can justify the application of one law or another, whether it be an article of the Constitution or the application of the National Security Law. But as I said before, I think what is very important is that the violent and those who shelter those violent individuals or cheer them on, even if only verbally, are very aware that they will find moderation as a form of strength in response. That we are not going to overreact.

I have said it many times, we will be calm and firm, proportional in our response. And therefore, under those premises, I am convinced that tranquility and coexistence will be restored in Catalonia, and that, well, these phenomena of violence that we are witnessing will remain as what they are: a display of the radical marginality that today, in a certain way, represents a part of independence, but which does not represent, in any way, the majority of Catalan society, regardless of whether they vote for independence forces or for forces that do not share independence goals.

Thank you very much.

(Transcription reviewed by the State Secretariat for Communication)