Appearance of the Minister of Education, Vocational Training and Sports and Government Spokesperson, the Minister of Housing and Urban Agenda, the Minister of Economy, Trade and Business.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

15 October 2024

Context
Sánchez addressed a post-Council of Ministers press conference on October 15, 2024, presenting economic data, housing measures, and financial allocations approved that day.
Main themes
Economic growth and employment, housing affordability and policy, inflation reduction and purchasing power, fiscal and structural plan, SME and youth entrepreneur loans, digitization of municipalities, short-term rental regulation, young rental voucher, healthcare funding, welfare state expansion, Spain's EU economic leadership
Duration
~99 min
98th percentile
Words
11,857
98th percentile
Sentences
350
96th percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
15.7
81st percentile
Syntax
3.43
91st percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
38th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 36%36%
  • Economic 29%29%
  • Social 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

350 sentences in 56 paragraphs

Furthermore, this debate comes at an important time for our country with some data and a very positive forecast as well. You know that Spain is today the leader in growth and also in employment; we lead, therefore, growth in Europe, something that is evidently not a result of chance, but rather the fruit of hard work and the policies that our country has been implementing hand in hand with the Government of Spain. In fact, today you will have learned, just as we have, of a new report, in this case a report from BBVA, which has once again raised the growth forecast for our country to 2.9% for this year. Moreover, while these growth forecasts are rising in parallel, we see that thanks to the measures that this government is also implementing, inflation is decreasing. In fact, today it stands at 1.5%, which is the lowest in the last three years, a decrease that, on the other hand, allows for an improvement in the purchasing power of many families in our country. This is good news that the Minister Carlos Cuerpo, who is accompanying me this morning, will certainly inform you about, and he will also present to all of you the fiscal and structural plan that will be sent to Europe.

Additionally, in today's Council of Ministers, we have also approved important financial allocations. The first is 78 million euros from the Ministry of Industry, allocated to two fundamental lines through loans. On one hand, there will be loans for small and medium-sized enterprises, ranging from 25,000 euros to 1.5 million euros, with a repayment period of ten years. On the other hand, there will be loans for young entrepreneurs, in this case, amounts between 25,000 and 75,000 euros with a seven-year repayment period.

On another note, the Ministry of Health has also approved an allocation to the autonomous communities of 44 million euros for projects that promote the rational use of medications or also for the National Bone Marrow Donation Plan and the National Umbilical Cord Blood Plan, among other measures.

From the Ministry of Digital Transition, a grant of 13 million euros has been approved, in this case, 13 million euros allocated to the Spanish Federation of Municipalities and Provinces, with the aim of improving the digitization of data in important areas such as smart mobility or the management of critical resources like electricity and water, or the possibility of generating a map of economic activities in different cities. In short, as I said, sharing data for the improvement of the digitization of the good management of our cities.

And finally, as you can all see, I am also joined by the Minister of Housing, Isabel Rodríguez, who, as you know, is leading one of the most important and fundamental policies for this government. This government is also fully aware of the difficulties that many families in our country face in finding and living in decent and affordable housing. That is why from the very beginning, the Government's commitment to the citizens of our country has been to ensure that housing is a right and absolutely not a business, nor, of course, speculation. Therefore, the commitment of this government to the thousands and thousands of families in our country is absolute. We are fully aware of the important work that we must continue to carry out, work that must also go hand in hand with the rest of the public administrations in our country. In that regard, today the Minister of Housing will detail two important matters that we have approved in the Council of Ministers.

On one hand, a system of registration, information, and transparency regarding short-term rentals in Spain, and on the other, a new and important distribution, in this case, to the autonomous communities, of 200 million euros for the young rental voucher. I would also like to remind you that this is the third year that the Government of Spain is once again implementing this important measure. And before giving the floor to the Minister, as I said, I want to reiterate once again the commitment of this Government to make housing policy the true fifth pillar of the Welfare State. So, Minister, I give you the floor first.

Minister of Housing and Urban Agenda, Isabel Rodríguez. - Thank you very much, Minister Spokesperson. I greet all of you; it is always a pleasure to be here in this room to share important decisions of the government, undoubtedly those that pertain to the portfolio that I have the honor of directing, one of the most important, because they affect the main concerns, the main problems that Spaniards face today. This government has always proposed solutions wherever there has been a problem, and that is what I have also brought to the Council of Ministers today: two measures, as the Minister Spokesperson said, within the framework of many other actions we are carrying out to guarantee the right of access to housing for all Spaniards, as proclaimed in Article 47 of the Constitution, which we developed by law in the past legislature, with a clear long-term objective of expanding the public housing stock to converge with European standards so that no Spaniard would have to dedicate more than 30% of their resources to housing expenses. Today, that objective is still very far from the reality of many Spaniards, and that is why we will not stop putting measures in place. As I said, today I bring two very important ones that I will share with you, which relate to the regulation of short-term rentals and also to addressing the young population that is particularly affected by the housing access problem, impacting vital development processes. These are not the first nor will they be the last in these ten months, a little more than ten months at the head of the Ministry. We have made very important decisions regarding the regulation of the rental market, with the reference price index and the stressed areas already implemented in Catalonia and that will be implemented in other autonomous communities in our country, which are allowing families to save around 100 euros monthly on their rent. We are providing unprecedented financing to achieve that public housing stock; undoubtedly, the most important initiative by volume of 100% affordable public housing that will be developed in Spain is already unlocked, and it is the new Campamento neighborhood. As I said, we are supporting all these measures with a significant investment boost that today, since President Sánchez took office, totals more than 20 billion euros, 20.4 billion euros, which clearly shows this Government's commitment to public housing policies. I say that these measures are two new measures that add to those already approved and those that will come because this Government will not stop. All Spaniards must know that we will not stop, that the Government will not stop until we find a solution to the problem that millions of people in our country face today, thousands of people, young people, families, a problem that is now transversal and that, as we have done on other occasions when we have faced major problems, we will put all resources, all willingness, all determination to respond to the housing problem. We did it to alleviate a health crisis, we did it to address an energy crisis, and we will also do it to respond to the housing problem.

Specifically, what I have been able to share today with my colleagues in the Council of Ministers is something very important that was not completed in the parliamentary processing of the Housing Law, which was to address short-term contracts. When I talk about short-term contracts and what we are addressing today in this regulation that we will publish this very morning in public consultation, I have taken a preliminary step before its processing in the Council of Ministers due to the significance and importance we attach to this tool. With this information that I have conveyed today, we will regulate seasonal rentals, we will regulate tourist rentals, and we will address the reality of room rentals.

As I said, it was a matter that remained pending in the Housing Law. A month after arriving at the Ministry, we began work on a group for seasonal rentals. At the same time, with the Ministry of Industry and Tourism, we addressed the reality of tourist accommodations and their limitation and, where appropriate, their prohibition so that they do not collide with the right of access to housing. In these two efforts, we found an ally that has been very important for us, which is a European regulation that already addressed this reality because what happens in Spain is not an isolated fact; today, most countries in our environment are in a situation similar to that of our country regarding housing access problems. With these three instruments, we have worked around seasonal accommodations, the reality of tourist accommodations, and the presence of a European regulation. We have articulated a regulation that will respond to the problems posed by these types of accommodations compared to contracts for a habitual residence for the development of our lives.

This announcement of the regulation has already gone through public consultation, and the interest in it is evidenced by the more than one hundred contributions we have already received. As soon as we announced that we were going to work on this regulation, last week we approved its urgent processing, and it will be ready before the end of this year 2024, making us the first country in the Union to develop this regulation, this European norm. This regulation that we are promoting sets the keys to increase the available information regarding short-term rentals, with a unique registry without which commercialization on platforms cannot take place. That is to say, all those seasonal tourist homes or room rentals that do not have this registry, that have not gone through this registry, will not be able to be marketed. If the registry is not complied with, and I will elaborate on this, they will not be able to be marketed on platforms. We address tourist accommodations, we address seasonal rentals where we also incorporate causality. Therefore, this regulation will prevent homes for tourist use from being offered in seasonal or room contracts that do not comply with current regulations. Thus, we are also being an ally with this instrument to the other administrations that have competence in the matter.

To implement it, this single window, which will ultimately connect with the European single window, will be ready by the end of the year, by mid-2026. In May 2026, we will have in the formation of this registry the Property Registry, which gives us a lot of legal security and rigor when facing this reality. Why? Because when that accommodation, when that home has to receive that registry, which is a number, an identification, a license, the Property Registry will be able to certify, one, that it complies, in the case of tourist accommodations, with the autonomous regulations for tourist housing licenses; two, that it complies with the municipal ordinances that some municipalities already have and others are fortunately implementing regarding tourist licenses; and it will even be able to certify those communities of neighbors that in their statutes have prohibited the establishment of tourist rentals. That is to say, with the Property Registry, which will support us in the single window, we will be able to pursue all fraud and all illegality that is occurring around tourist accommodations, seasonal accommodations, and even room contracts. This, as I said, will later connect with the European single window to provide coverage and to have all those instruments that also allow for better management of public policies. One of the problems that has been detected in the member countries of the Union and for which this regulation arises is precisely because there is an absence of data or, worse, in many cases, this data does not come from public administrations but from private sectors interested in that data for particular purposes that are not in the general interest. You have heard me say many times that another of my objectives at the head of the Ministry is to ensure that there is public data and that this data serves the general interest. Therefore, with this new instrument, which is a useful instrument, the Government achieves a double objective: to pursue fraud, to protect those who really need seasonal accommodation of this type, and to curb illegal tourist accommodations. Why? To prioritize above all habitual rental housing. The ultimate goal is to mobilize a larger housing stock to meet the needs of life, so that these rentals respond to developments in housing matters.

The second matter we have approved in the Council of Ministers is related to this Government's commitment, an electoral commitment and a commitment from the Government to continue assisting in the emergency, as we consolidate that public housing stock that will guarantee that all Spaniards, especially young people, have opportunities for emancipation. As we achieve that objective, we will help them in the emergency through these aids, this young rental voucher; we will implement this third edition, as the spokesperson mentioned, with an additional 200 million euros from the Government of Spain. As you always hear me say, I also call on the autonomous communities to complement this effort that the Government of Spain is making today so that their fellow citizens have the possibility to increase the number of beneficiaries of this measure. We will address, with them, the territorial distribution that you will know in the reference, but we have also detected some issues that we need to improve throughout these first two editions, which we have already incorporated into the Conference that we will hold in the coming days to ratify these amounts. The autonomous communities need to improve the processing; we have detected in the analysis and diagnosis we have made of the first two editions that it has been uneven. I will tell you that in the evaluation data of the functioning of the young rental voucher, we have seen that some autonomous communities have needed three months to resolve aids, while others have taken up to a year. We want payments to be made more immediately and for all autonomous communities to cover the pending payments they had to the beneficiaries of this voucher, to reduce the resolution time, the average payment time, and to ensure that there is no discrimination between some young people and others, depending on the territory and the best management that can be done by the housing departments of each of the autonomous communities. I insist on the importance of the autonomous communities advancing in the financial co-responsibility of policies in the housing sector. We are increasingly seeing that commitment from some autonomous communities, some significantly, as you may have noticed. The requirements remain the same as in the first editions: three times the IPREM, aids of 250 euros for a period of two years. There are some communities in that call that have already been completing this voucher, such as Catalonia and the Community of Valencia, which have already been doing so, and Asturias, which will join. The Basque Country and Navarra do not enter this call due to their foral regime, but these two communities were precisely pioneers in this type of aid to youth, so they have been implementing it for a long time and, therefore, seeing its effectiveness and how it serves as a cushion and a generator of confidence for young people when it comes to emancipating themselves. Therefore, two important measures in the right direction, which is to guarantee the right of access to housing for all Spaniards, with that clear and distinct message that I shared at the beginning with you: the Government is determined to make whatever decisions are necessary in these three years that remain in the legislature. We have already made a good number of decisions, but many more will come because, just as we responded to other major problems, to the problem of housing, the Government of Pedro Sánchez will provide the response that Spanish citizens need.

Spokesperson. - Thank you very much, Minister of Housing. Very well, Minister.

Minister of Economy, Trade and Business, Carlos Cuerpo. - Yes, thank you very much. I believe I take the message you pointed out, Spokesperson, because today is an eminently economic day and, moreover, with good news, which, as we usually say, is also news; not only the good news related to the confirmation of the price growth figure of 1.5% in September, which today also has the detail of the components, but also a very positive element related to food with a growth of 1.8%, which is the lowest rate in the last three years. In fact, what I believe is confirmed is this message of the progressive recovery of purchasing power of households, with wages that are growing significantly above prices and particularly above the shopping basket. Furthermore, the good news continues to be accompanied by upward updates of forecasts by the main analysts. Today we indeed had a new case with the BBVA Research Service, which updates the forecasts for this year to 2.9% and, even more relevant at this point in the year, where the growth for 2024 is practically closed, it also raises its forecasts for 2025 to 2.4%, in line with the Government's forecasts. I believe this again configures a positive view regarding the maintenance of the growth pulse of the Spanish economy, not only in the short term but also in the medium term. We also continue with the good news related to the measures just announced regarding that enormous challenge of access to housing under affordable conditions, as the Minister of Housing has just mentioned. Finally, I will directly connect with the presentation of the submission to Brussels of our structural fiscal plan, our medium-term umbrella framework for the 2025-2028 horizon.

Here you have the initial slide, just a reminder of how we are evolving, how this growth pulse has been maintained in recent quarters, with a quarter-on-quarter growth of around 0.8-0.9% and year-on-year growth above 3%, based on a very good performance of the labor market with record figures of 21.2 million affiliations, in addition to greater stability. This provides support to our growth, which is also balanced, balanced in that it is compatible with price moderation and a very positive performance of our external sector, and with a dimension on which we will place special emphasis today, which is fiscal responsibility, that is, the reduction of our deficit and our debt going forward. In fact, in the next slide, we can see an important element related to this fiscal responsibility, such as the reactivation of the European fiscal rules starting in 2025. The European fiscal rules will be back in force after a few years of being deactivated due to the pandemic, and they are rules that have been reformed compared to the previous rules. As you know, during the Spanish presidency in the second half of 2023, we reached an agreement to reform these rules based on a series of dimensions or characteristics that are particularly important in the current context and that also help to understand the figures I will present shortly. These are rules that have a forward-looking vision, a vision aimed at avoiding past mistakes when consolidating public accounts, and that in this case do not come at the expense of stifling economic growth, nor should this forward investment rule be penalizing, as it is the main engine of potential growth of our economies. These rules introduce an additional element of flexibility; in fact, they allow member states, if they present a set of ambitious reforms and investments, to extend the adjustment effort period from 4 to 7 years, thus extending the number of years and making a smaller effort year by year to reduce that deficit. It is a medium-term orientation, as I have already said, since it is a plan from 2025 to 2028. There is an element of simplification compared to the previous framework; before we had to look at variables such as the evolution of debt, the evolution of the deficit, and spending. Now everything is concentrated on a single variable, which will determine whether we comply with the rules or not, which is the evolution of computable spending, that is, spending after removing some elements, such as interest spending or spending on items financed with European funds or spending on unemployment benefits, among others. This spending is what we will have or what we have a reference for going forward, and which we will have to transparently comply with year by year to be in line with the fiscal rules. As I said, it is a medium-term framework, a four-year horizon that will be accompanied year by year by an annual document. This structural fiscal plan is for four years, and each year it will be accompanied by an annual document, which is the Budget Plan, where all the necessary measures will be detailed to meet the objectives for the following year.

Well, if we move to the next slide, just to recall the starting point, as I mentioned earlier, we have been doing our homework even in the absence of fiscal rules. We have been reducing our deficit and our debt, as we can see in this slide, also based on strong growth. Moreover, once the national accounting series have been updated by the National Statistics Institute, to give you an idea, since the peak of the deficit, we have decreased from 10% to 3%, which we expect to be the closing figure for this year 2024. In terms of debt, the peak of debt was reached in 2021, in the first quarter of 2021, and we expect to have reduced more than 20 percentage points of GDP in debt by the end of this year 2024, reaching 102.5%, which is our target.

Well, as I said, having complied with this element of fiscal responsibility, even in the absence of rules, positions us at an unbeatable starting point to move forward, also complying with the framework of rules that is back in operation.

And we see in the next slide the summary of what the fiscal plan sent today to the European Commission entails. The summary is the effort to correct the deficit and maintain that element of sustainability of our debt, and that this sustainability is compatible with robust growth. It translates into a growth path for spending; this growth path for spending, on average over the seven years during which this effort will take place, is a growth of 3%. A growth of 3% that, if we focus on the period of the plan, that is, from 2025 to 2028, is an average growth of 3.4% between the years 2025 and 2028, as you can see in this slide. Just to give you a comparative figure, if we look at the period 2014-2018, the comparative evolution of this same spending variable averaged 2.5% compared to this 3.4% that we would have on average between the years 2025 and 2028. This is nine-tenths more growth, which can be directly translated into millions, into billions of euros; we would be talking about the new framework of rules allowing us to spend 6 billion euros more per year compared to the average spending that existed between the period 2014 and 2018.

Well, compliance with this forward-looking spending rule, as we can see in this slide, guarantees the continuity of the fiscal responsibility strategy that we already presented in July, that is to say, it is compatible with those deficit targets presented in July of 3% for this year, 2.5% for 2024, 2.1% for 2025, and 1.8% for 2027. This umbrella framework for the deficit corresponds and is compatible with the compliance of this spending rule that we have included in the structural fiscal plan, which, as I mentioned, implies an average growth of spending for the total of the seven years of effort of 3% and for the four years of the plan of 3.4%. This evolution of the deficit, with a progressive correction in the coming years, of course, also translates into a correction of the debt, the debt that, as we see here, will reach some significant psychological references, such as, for example, going below 100% already in 2026, around the year 2026, that is to say, by the end of this legislature, in 2027, we will be below the pre-pandemic level, already at levels around 98% by the end of the adjustment period, that is to say, in 2031 we would already be around 90%. I simply want to point out so as not to cause confusion, we are talking about two different periods: the adjustment period, which is seven years during which we have to make that effort, but the plan refers only to the first four years of this adjustment period. When four years pass, another new plan will be drawn up, so let us not confuse these two time horizons. And as I mentioned earlier, these figures, this compliance with the growth of spending that we present today, is also compatible with continuing this pattern of balanced growth going forward. Here I simply want to point out the expected evolution of our potential GDP, which is around 1.9% on average during this period 2024-2028, which again reflects, as we said, that element of compatibility or soft landing in fiscal policy. We are reducing and consolidating our public accounts, but doing so in a way that is compatible with robust and reinforced growth.

And finally, I just want to point out as a summary or repository that, as I said at the beginning, to have this margin of flexibility and to be able to make the adjustment over seven years, we have put ambitious commitments on the table in terms of reforms and investments, where we have gone beyond what the recovery plan itself puts forward, addressing the requests of the European Commission, since the recovery plan, in principle, the commitments end in 2026 and here we have a scenario until 2031, so we are putting additional commitments, particularly emphasizing some issues that, as you know, are of total priority for us, such as housing, immigration, or also the business climate.

I also want to point out, simply to avoid going into the details of the slide and of course, I am ready to answer questions, that there are specific measures related to budgetary sustainability in this case, including of course, the pension reform aspect, the increase in revenues related to pension reform, elements also related to the fight against fraud, such as the strategy of the Tax Agency, elements related to electronic invoicing, also supporting the fight against fraud, elements also of the tax reform that will take place within the framework of the fifth disbursement, that is to say, as I mentioned, a complete package of measures that help us meet this objective of growth of the spending rule.

And without further ado, I will simply conclude by stating that this plan we present today guarantees the sustainability of public accounts going forward and does so in a way that is compatible with maintaining the Welfare State, modernizing our economy, and ensuring sustained and balanced growth.

Spokesperson. - Well, thank you very much to the minister and the minister, and now we will try to answer all your questions.

Carlos Elordi Cué (El País). - Yes, to the spokesperson minister, how are the negotiations with Junts? Because today we heard a leader talking about a possible motion of censure, if they are getting complicated, since the Minister of Economy is here, I take the opportunity because a central element is the deficit that you have told us about in that negotiation. What margin is there to redistribute that deficit in the negotiation between the State and the autonomous communities? Also to the spokesperson minister, in Brussels, you spoke about the European Summit in Brussels, the possibility of deportation centers outside the European Union is being considered, in the style of Meloni. Is Spain in agreement with this proposal? Is President Sánchez going to say that he is against or in favor? And regarding the issue of corruption, which we have experienced scandals this week and today we also have a decision, first, how does the Ábalos case affect the image of a government that came against the corruption of the PP, and today we have learned that a person who sat there not long ago, Eduardo Zaplana, who sat in the same place where you are, who was the government spokesperson, has been sentenced to ten years, what do you have to say about that?

And to the Minister of Housing, we have seen a lot of tension within the government regarding the housing issue these days, Sumar says that what you are doing is not enough, that the housing market needs to be intervened now. How was the Council of Ministers? What can you tell us? And the prior negotiations? Is there a point of agreement or is Sumar going to continue, or have you not satisfied what Sumar is asking for? And a detail question, who has to prevent those irregular tourist apartments, because there are many irregular tourist apartments at this moment and no one is stopping them, so who has to prevent them from reaching the platforms?

Minister of Economy, Trade and Business. - Yes, I will start, as mine is the easiest, well, you can evaluate that. I think it is important to point out one thing that we have had from the beginning, and it is that this framework we present today for the evolution of spending, which is compatible or that directly translates into an evolution of the deficit, is compatible with the fiscal path presented in July with this evolution of the deficit, which is like the umbrella element going forward, this 3%, 2.5%, 2.1%, and 1.8%, and this umbrella element is what we then have to land and distribute among the different subsectors within the framework of the entire annual budgetary process that occurs and that is launched with the approval of the spending ceiling. Precisely, the distribution of these objectives, and we are now in the process of, as I say, with this global objective, with this umbrella framework, redistributing that 2.5% of next year among the different public administrations, among the subsectors, between the General State Administration, autonomous communities, local corporations, and social security. At this point, steps have already been taken, and I think it is important to point this out as well, steps have been taken by the government to give an additional margin to the autonomous communities, and this was the proposal that was put on the table just a few weeks ago and also before the summer, which was rejected. I believe that this is the point of discussion and negotiation we are in, where we believe it is possible to reach an agreement on the distribution of this 2.5% target among the different sectors that is favorable and that can be agreed upon by the autonomous communities themselves and that allows us again to comply with an element of fiscal co-responsibility with that total objective of 2.5%.

Spokesperson: whenever you want, minister.

Minister of Housing and Urban Agenda. - Thank you, minister, spokesperson minister. Regarding the tension, the only tension that concerns me is that of rental prices, because it is what citizens are suffering, and from the governments, and of course, I as a minister, what I try to do is respond to that suffering of the people, doing it as we have done today, with measures that, among other things, aim to respond to many frauds that citizens are currently encountering when looking for a rental apartment in any of the major Spanish cities. Therefore, my priority, my attention, is to resolve these problems and not on other issues. I will also tell you that if I have to confront someone, it will certainly be with those who defend positions different from those defended by this government and this minister. I heard this morning some spokesperson from the Community of Madrid talking about how there will be no regulation here. The government is proposing regulation; in fact, this government has implemented a price reference index that, with all due prudence, but in the initial data we are observing, is allowing rental prices to decrease where it is being applied. The Generalitat of Catalonia is applying this measure, and in Catalonia, rental prices are decreasing by around 5%. We, and I myself, have even advocated for the prohibition of tourist accommodations, and we have implemented measures; I will refer to that now. Therefore, if I have to confront someone, it is with those who defend a model opposed to ours, which is in favor of the public housing stock and its permanent protection, as we want to do in the new Campamento neighborhood. Those who continue to talk about the free market of survival of the fittest, a little bit of makeup for public housing, and in 15 years we empty all the public effort we have made. This government demands the permanence of public effort in the construction of that affordable housing stock. If I have to confront someone, it is with those who say, hey, that there is no problem in Madrid and that there is no need to regulate tourist accommodations, a city where there are 14,000 illegal tourist apartments. The Campamento operation, the new Campamento neighborhood, which is the most important public housing initiative that will be carried out in Spain in the coming years, consists of 10,700 homes. By addressing the tourist issue in Madrid, we would be freeing up the illegal tourist market to be able to direct it with other types of measures towards residential use, 13,000 homes. That is the model I want to confront and the one I also want to expose to public opinion, because I mentioned the concept of freedom, manipulating that beautiful concept of freedom. They talked about freedom here, also to not regulate the housing crisis that the Community of Madrid is suffering. Where is the freedom when one has to live with their parents beyond the age of 30? Where does freedom go when one at 40 has to share an apartment? Or where does freedom go when, in making the decision to become a mother or to expand the family, we find ourselves with the inconvenience of our housing? There is no freedom there; what remains is social pressure, a social emergency, as I have often qualified the housing problem. Therefore, if I have to confront someone, it is with these positions of the right that return to the same recipes of the free market of letting things happen, which already led us to another crisis where there was also much social suffering.

Regarding tourist rentals and who needs to regulate them. One of the handicaps or complications in addressing housing policies in our country relates to the complexity of the institutional architecture, which is why you have heard me so many times, in addition to clearly stating the Government's position, which is to limit or prohibit tourist accommodations if they are hindering the development of life through residential housing. We have made decisions in that direction, those that were within our competencies, such as the processing of the property law, the modification of the Horizontal Property Law in the direction marked by the Supreme Court's doctrine. However, the regulation concerning tourism is autonomous and also plays a fundamental role in municipal ordinances. When I started to convey this message, I gathered the autonomous communities; today, no one disputes that we need to bring order to tourist accommodations. Fortunately, municipalities are now following the path of brave mayors like the mayor of Barcelona, who not only prohibits but also inspects what that instrument the Government is implementing will allow: facilitating their work, facilitating inspections, facilitating enforcement, facilitating sanctions for these administrations that have jurisdiction. Above all, in practice, it will be impossible to market tourist accommodations on platforms that do not comply with these regulations, that do not comply with the autonomous regulations, that do not comply with the municipal ordinance regulations, or even that do not comply with their statutes. It will be the owners of these properties who will have to go to the registry to request that, as I mentioned earlier, to request that identification, that number, which will be incorporated, and there will be a period of 15 days to analyze compliance with that regulation. If not, if that legal requirement is not remedied, then the number will be suspended, and therefore they will not be able to market on the platform. You are aware that this type of economic activity is currently marketed on platforms; it is from the commercialization on platforms that the problem arises. Therefore, it is another tool; also, one of the virtues of this regulation is that it is a tool at the service of the autonomous and local administrations so that they can do their work in line with what this government defends, which is intervention to prioritize access to housing as a habitual residence.

Spokesperson. - Very well, thank you, Minister. Well, regarding the questions you asked me, first about the deportation centers you mentioned thirdly, well, you know that Spain has also expressed its position against considering the creation of centers in third countries, and, of course, what we will continue to defend in Europe is that humanitarian and solidarity application of the Migration and Asylum Pact. Furthermore, Spain will continue to work in that direction that bets on regular and safe migration routes and, of course, working with those countries of origin and transit and, above all, working against that mafia that traffics in people. Logically, the policies we are already developing in migration policy in Spain are working; so much so that we have managed to correct 40% of irregular departures in these countries.

Secondly, you also asked about, the Minister of Economy has already partly responded to that. I can tell you that negotiations are ongoing; it is true that we have been saying this from the very beginning, and the First Vice President is maintaining those negotiations and allows me, with discretion and prudence, which I believe are fundamental elements for them to come to a good end. But look, regarding the issue of that motion of censure, right? I read this morning in some media; obviously, I am here as the Government's spokesperson, and it is up to Junts to respond or convey this information. But I can tell you that I do not see Junts wanting to return to the past, to the year 2017, hand in hand with Vox and the Popular Party, nor do I think Junts wants that. But above all, what seems most important to me is that I believe the majority of Catalan society does not want that, which has already spoken clearly in the various electoral processes.

And regarding the last question you asked us, look, I believe that what is truly important here, or the question regarding how to confront corruption or how to address possible cases of corruption, and this government is clear about it, with determination, with transparency, and with collaboration from the very beginning with the State Security Forces and with justice, and also demanding accountability when it has happened. I want to remind you that eight months ago, on the part of the Socialist Party, an expulsion file was opened within the Socialist Party for Mr. Ábalos, and it was also requested that he leave his position and abandon the Socialist Group. In the face of that refusal, he was expelled, as you know, from the Socialist Group. Therefore, determination, firmness, transparency, and above all, zero tolerance towards corruption, and that is our way of acting and our way of working. This government will always be firm against corruption, in contrast to other administrations, in this case, the Popular Party, which has always been lenient with corruption. I say this because, look, the height of irony, on Sunday we learned that the Popular Party, I say the height of irony because we learned that they are filing a lawsuit from a headquarters that is financed with illegal money and announces the filing of a lawsuit. But look, this announcement is, for me, a clear example, if you allow me, of how the mud machine works. We first learn that there is a website that publishes information from anonymous testimonies, anonymous testimonies that are news picked up by the Popular Party, amplified and made available to justice. And all this is done by the Popular Party, the Popular Party of Gürtel, the Popular Party of Púnica, the Popular Party of Kitchen, the Popular Party of Perla Negra, and so on, up to 38 pending cases for trial. Therefore, as I said here, what is clear and evident is how the reactions differ from one side to the other in the face of different cases of corruption. This Government, firmness, transparency, determination, and collaboration, always with the State Security Forces and with justice, in contrast to those who have historically been lenient with corruption. In fact, today, as you rightly said, we have learned of the ten-year sentence for Mr. Zaplana. I don't know if today is a good day for Mr. Feijóo to provide explanations and answer some questions because I believe he has been a week without answering questions from journalists and entering through the back door of the Congress of Deputies. Therefore, today he has a magnificent opportunity to provide explanations. What is clear is how this Government responds to any case of corruption: transparency, firmness, and above all, collaboration with the State Security Forces, in a very different way than how other governments did, obstructing justice or smashing hard drives with hammers.

Juan de Dios Portillo Caurcel (Expansión). - Yes, hello, good morning, Juan de Portillo from Expansión. Thank you for the press conference. I wanted to ask the Minister of Economy about the structural fiscal plan sent to Brussels. First, I wanted to ask you to detail within that fiscal path of deficit reduction that you have shown us what the evolution of revenues and expenditures that supports that deficit reduction is, which I imagine is information that you have provided to Brussels. From there, I wanted to know what specific measures in the tax area you have committed to with the European Commission and which of them are structural reforms from those offered in that last table. Any note on using the spending reviews from AIReF, I don't know if it commits us to apply them all in full or to what extent it has been communicated to the European Union, if you can explain that to us. And then, to clarify exactly what we are talking about, because there is some confusion regarding whether it is a four-year plan but with commitments for reduction over seven years, I would like to know exactly what the Government of Spain commits to the European Union, the data for four years, for seven, that final reduction by 2041 so that the path is downward ten years after the plan, exactly what it commits to in front of the European Union. Thank you very much.

Minister of Economy, Trade and Business. - Yes. I understand the confusion because it is not easy after years of discussing these new fiscal rules. The main objective, if I recall, was to simplify them, and I am not very sure that we have achieved that. But I believe there is an element of transparency in that everything is now concentrated in a single variable, and that also helps to explain it. The time horizons, perhaps I will start here, the structural fiscal plans are four-year plans, just like the stability program in the previous framework. These four-year plans entail the necessary effort for debt to follow a decreasing profile, so that our debt does not grow from now until 2041. We concentrate all that effort in these four years. What do the fiscal rules tell us? They give you an additional element of flexibility so that the effort, instead of concentrating it in four years, you can do it over seven years. But your plan is for the next four years; in four years, you have to update it. But the commitment to effort is the total to which you have committed to ensure that your debt does not increase from now until 2041, which in this case you are extending over seven years. In fact, the average growth of expenditure for these seven years is 3%. That is the commitment that entails the necessary effort that the new framework of fiscal rules requires from us. When we translate it to the time horizon of this plan, which is four years, we have the figures I mentioned, with an average expenditure in these first four years of 3.4%. I don't know if that makes it clear.

Then, regarding the evolution of expenditure and revenues, the new framework is also very clear. What it does is look at each country, what your growth forecasts are, the forecasts for, therefore, tax collection or taxable bases associated with that growth, and then it says, given this growth and therefore this evolution of revenues, how much does your expenditure need to evolve to meet what we said earlier? That the debt does not grow, and that is how that evolution of expenditure is determined, and everything is concentrated in this expenditure. In the end, we have revenues, we have expenditure, and therefore you can translate it to deficit, which is the variable I have shown you in the plan. You have the specific detail of each of those variables in the plan, and I also want to remind you that at 3:30 PM there will also be a technical briefing for the level of detail you want on this topic. But that is, let's say, the modus operandi we have for determining these variables. A small note here because I think it is important. For example, one of the things that this plan takes into account, having that horizon that my debt does not grow from now until 2041, is that it includes the impact of aging. That is, this plan requires me to make that effort to ensure that my debt does not grow, taking into account the impact of pension reform or population aging. It is already included there. That is to say, the effort I am going to make in the coming years is an effort that ensures the sustainability of my public accounts and my debt also in the long term, including this element of aging and including the last tax reform, as well as the last pension reform.

And then regarding tax measures here, indeed, one of the legs is the measures related to spending reviews or processes of expenditure reviews, some of which AIReF has already carried out, others are pending. Here, what we have is a commitment over the next two years to review all the procedures, all the analyses that have already been carried out and to advance based on that principle of comply or explain that we have in our relationship with the independent fiscal responsibility authority, which is either I comply with what the authority is recommending, or I transparently and explicitly justify the reasons why I deviate from that recommendation, which is an internationally accepted principle that works very well in providing transparency to this interaction with an independent authority.

And then regarding the tax reform, here I do believe we can detail that it obviously involves the extension or the permanence of the two taxes on electricity companies and the financial system, and then we are landing, we are also in conversations with the Commission to provide more details on the rest of the measures that are also being discussed within the framework of that fifth disbursement that we hope to launch, whose request we expect to submit before the end of the year.

Juan de Dios Colmenarejo Ávila (Onda Cero), Good afternoon. Thank you very much, spokesperson minister. Following the last report from the UCO that we learned about last week, to which you have referred, I mention the Central Operational Unit of the Civil Guard as an example in other cases, such as the case of Begoña Gómez, it emerges that the Government was aware four days before the arrival of Vice President Maduro, Delcy Rodríguez. Why was the reality not reported at that moment? Why was transparency, decisiveness, and collaboration not applied at that time? And if you allow me, that report also mentions the fluid relationships and business dealings between your former cabinet colleague, your party mate José Luis Ábalos, and Aldama, José Luis Aldama. My question is whether you were aware of that relationship between them or if Aldama was ever at the Socialist headquarters in Ferraz. Thank you very much.

Spokesperson. - Well, what I can convey is how the Government acted regarding that visit that did not take place by Mrs. Delcy Rodríguez. As soon as the Government of Spain became aware of that individual case or that individual sanction, which is the more correct term, that visit was made impossible and prevented, and that is how the Government of Spain acted. We know that this individual sanction on this person therefore prevents that visit from taking place. And this is what happened.

Regarding different visits and so on to the headquarters of a political party, in this case the Socialist Party, I believe that the Secretary of Organization has clearly responded, and you will also understand that from this table I will not give credence to anonymous testimonies.

Ingrid Gutiérrez Sánchez (La Información). - Hello, good afternoon. I wanted to ask the Minister of Economy. Considering what you have told us and the projections you have, will the pending consolidation rely more on revenues or on expenditures? And why? I ask you this also because the AIReF or the Bank of Spain continue to talk about an adjustment that would require a cut, an adjustment of up to 9,900 million in the projected horizon. So, in that sense, what do you attribute to their continued talk of adjustment? And do you believe that you can carry out that consolidation process without cuts as such? And then I wanted to ask the Minister of Housing if the Government would have room to approve some type of measure or public guarantee aimed at small landlords so that they do not exclude families with young children in the selection of tenants. Problems are already arising in this regard, so I would like to know if such an action would be viable, but at the state level, so that there are no differences between autonomous communities. Thank you.

Minister of Economy, Trade and Business. - Yes, thank you very much. It is an excellent question. Well, no, it is true. I believe that we are clear when we talk about consolidation, as I said before, that everything translates into a single variable, which is expenditure, but I have been talking about expenditure and in reality, if we get into technical details, we talk about net expenditure and net expenditure of possible additional measures in terms of revenues, that is, the framework of rules allows this fiscal consolidation to be carried out through a specific evolution of expenditure or allows you more expenditure if you put additional revenue measures on the table, right? This is the flexibility that the current framework gives you, and for us, it is also important, obviously, that we are not talking about cuts because the process is completely the opposite. What we have here is that the adjustments or the evolution, the effort in terms of expenditure depends on what your forecasts are, depends on what your growth is going forward. The greater your growth, the more capacity for expenditure you will have, and it is in that margin in which the comparison between how much your revenues grow and how much your expenditure grows, that gap, that breach is what will allow you to consolidate and reduce the structural deficit to the extent that the new fiscal rules require it. That is why I made the comparison at the beginning between what expenditure will be able to grow in this period 25-28 and what it grew in 14-18. We are talking about a growth of practically one point above, and that translates into more capacity for expenditure. I believe we are in a different context in which this expenditure, as I said, is aligned with how strong our growth is, and therefore the evolution of our revenues. That is why the importance of the beginning of my presentation, to maintain that good growth momentum going forward.

Minister of Housing and Urban Agenda. - Yes, thank you very much for your question. The Housing Law already includes actions that must be developed by the competent administrations, not only in terms of housing but also of social services, because in some cases, unfortunately, the circumstances we observe go far beyond the need for housing. We must address them from the perspective of labor orientation, the care of their children, their schooling, and therefore we are talking about social policies in the strict sense, and the law itself already tells us how we must also protect these situations that are undoubtedly affected by the right to housing, but also by other types of actions that we must address from public administrations, in this case from the competent public administrations in terms of social rights. Perhaps a general idea, we have a good legal framework, and political determination is fundamental. I have conveyed to you what the political determination of the Government of Spain is, which is to put all necessary resources in place, to adopt all necessary measures until we put an end to the problem, and what we are going to do is what we demand from all public administrations: let us put all necessary resources, all necessary measures until we put an end to the problem. There are several milestones that we will experience in the coming months that are fundamental to reach this great agreement, which is an agreement that goes far beyond a political agreement, it goes far beyond a state pact. It is what I call a national alliance because it calls on all of us, mainly public administrations, but also private collaboration and very especially that social complicity that we cannot abandon. In this sense, the President of the Government has summoned the autonomous communities, and this very month the work begins for a Conference of Presidents where we will lay out in black and white the commitments that we have from the different administrations to respond to this problem. I believe that will be a good moment to address this issue with the dimension of complexity that it has, in the difference also of how this problem is experienced in the different territories in our country. And regarding the Ministry of Housing, we have also already begun work on the next State Housing Plan, which we will delve into with the different autonomous communities, but there are already measures that are also promoting that guarantee so that a greater, ehh, the largest possible rental housing stock can be mobilized because certainly, as we consolidate a public stock, we have the existing stock and we must put all necessary resources to do so. I spoke to you about the law; the current Housing Law already incorporates the possibility that rents could be reduced by 5% while benefiting from 90% rent bonuses, and what is not understood is why there are public administrations that refuse to allow tenants and landlords to benefit from a legal framework currently in force in Spain.

Lucía Fernández (Antena 3). - Hello, good morning. I wanted to emphasize to the Minister of Housing the discrepancies with your government partner, Sumar. Today they said that the measures they have presented are insufficient, that the young rental bond does not work and even that it means giving another Bizum of public money to landlords. I wanted to know if they have shown you these discrepancies and what you think about your government partner's position.

And then I wanted to ask the spokesperson minister because yesterday we learned that the Government is considering enabling the Ciudad Real airport, whose use is now marginal, to temporarily accommodate migrants. The Government of Castilla-La Mancha has complained, saying that this is literally outrageous, that it is not a space to accommodate them in a dignified manner, and that they found out through the media that the Government did not provide any explanations. I wanted to know what exactly the Government wants to do and what you think about this position of the Government of Castilla-La Mancha. Thank you.

Minister of Housing and Urban Agenda. - Thank you very much. I refer to the answer I gave to your colleague; my interest and attention are focused on providing solutions to the problem, and I do so within the framework of a government committed to this cause, which has also sealed and signed its agreements. The two commitments that I see fulfilled today in my management are in the coalition government agreement, one related to the reissue of this young rental bond and another that involves responding to the development of the Housing Law. We are complying with the first additional provision and the fifth additional provision of the Housing Law, and therefore developing it so that the instrument we now have to respond to this problem is as effective as possible in order to alleviate, as much as possible and in the shortest time possible, the problem faced by thousands of people in our country.

Spokesperson. - And regarding the question you asked me, well, first of all, it has almost become evident that there is a controversy, if you allow me, that is absolutely artificial and unreal. I say this because, as you know, the Government of Spain studies hundreds of locations, as has happened now with the Ciudad Real airport. By the way, I want to remind you that it is a 100% private airport, but the Government of Spain studies hundreds of locations, logically with the aim of being able, if you allow me, to alleviate the tensions we have in the islands and also for everyone's peace of mind. The Secretary of State of the Ministry of Inclusion has already contacted the relevant minister of the Government of Castilla-La Mancha to explain a bit about the entire procedure, but always, of course, as we do with all administrations, within an environment and a climate of absolute collaborative work and dialogue. But, well, there is no novelty here, nor is there any controversy; there is a matter that falls within the normality of a job that the Government of Spain does in locating different sites that are studied and evaluated, and of course, it is always discussed, as it cannot be otherwise, with all administrations.

José María Camarero Vecino (Colpisa). - Yes, hello, good afternoon. I had questions for all three ministers. First, for the Minister of Economy, I would like to know how you are going to convince the European Commission with this plan you have presented, considering that for now there does not seem to be any signs of a new general state budget for next year. I mean, maintaining the 2023 budget, can these long-term or medium-term commitments be established with the European Commission? I don’t know how you are going to explain this when I understand they will ask you about this issue. You also indicated that you plan to extend the tax on energy companies and banks. But what will happen with other taxes given that the President of the Government indicated the other day that there is room to increase taxes, not the taxes themselves, but to apply different figures and equate ourselves with the tax burden of the European Union?

To the Minister of Housing, I would like to ask if the measures that have been approved today in the Council of Ministers represent an acceleration or if they have been accelerated basically due to the demonstration on Sunday, or if coincidentally everything was already prepared, both in the issue of the young rental bond and in the issue of that regulation of tourist apartments, and especially if they can prevent there being loopholes in that regulation because we have already seen that there are loopholes with other measures that have been approved and have not had effects, as in the case of the autonomous communities. If they do not apply it or start to put obstacles, what does the Ministry plan to do in this regard?

And lastly, to the spokesperson minister, I would like to insist on a question regarding the possibility of that, of that motion of censure that is being discussed this morning, in which Junts would be included. I don't know if it's a motion of censure, but what does seem clear is that I don't know how those negotiations are going, ehh... with Junts, especially regarding the budget. What we are seeing is that there is a blockage of the major measures that the Government wants to implement, the general state budget, first of all, the Land Law, which, as the Minister of Housing knows, is also not being implemented, the energy taxes and those on banking, which Junts and even the PNV do not seem to agree on, or even on the issue of the working day, which is also being negotiated in another ministry, in this case, the Ministry of Labor. These are major measures that, while there is no motion of censure on the table, do imply that there is a parliamentary blockage of government action. So, I don't know how those negotiations are going to move forward at least on these measures that are being talked about so much. Thank you.

Minister of Economy, Trade and Business. - Well, yes, regarding the need or not to convince the European Commission, I believe that Spain currently has a very high level of credibility regarding compliance with its fiscal objectives in recent years, in fact, even exceeding them in the absence of active fiscal rules. I believe that this is what has led us to fulfill our duties, to be among the good students for the European Commission, without macroeconomic imbalances and also without excessive deficits. This is what also frames the dialogue we have had in these last few weeks, very intense, as you can imagine, with the Commission, in order to finalize the figures and the text we presented today, which I believe configures, as I said earlier, a realistic plan capable of reducing the deficit while being compatible with growth. Therefore, what we trust is that this will, of course, receive a positive assessment in line with this effort, this compliance, and this credibility that we have earned in recent years.

Then, regarding specific compliance year by year, as I mentioned earlier, this document is an umbrella document that outlines the medium-term strategy, and then the annual details of this strategy are developed in a complementary parallel document, this budgetary plan that is sent to Brussels every autumn. This budgetary plan is associated with the budget, with the General State Budgets, and we will send this when we have the budgets on the table. When we present the budgets, this budgetary plan will go in parallel, and the Commission will have to assess it in parallel to its assessment of the fiscal plan. These are two linked but distinct assessments, and we hope, of course, that both can be carried out with total normality.

And then regarding the last part, I believe it is important to point out that we are in line with what the President of the Government said, that right now, regarding the tax burden or the ratio of income to GDP, Spain has room compared to the European average, contrary to what has been discussed in recent months or quarters. This, evidently, provides room to implement measures or reforms in terms of income without harming growth or exceeding that average, right? And in that framework, we are precisely landing, in this case, the reforms associated with compliance with that tax reform, the measures associated with compliance with that tax reform that is part of the fifth disbursement, among which, as I mentioned earlier, is also the maintenance of these two figures permanently.

Minister of Housing and Urban Agenda. - Thank you very much for your question. Regarding attention, of course, always to any social expression, much more so that which arises from pain and personal dramas, always the attention, but the government must work with absolute rigor, with determination, as I said, in this case, and from the very first minute of this legislature, when the president wanted there to be a department directed exclusively to address this issue, we have worked with great determination, with many agreements that I have been sharing with you and with the journalists who usually follow me, with public opinion, and responding to each of the circumstances, as I say, with absolute rigor. Both agreements that we bring today to the Council of Ministers, you can imagine, do not process in a week. I have given you a brief account of seasonal accommodations; this working group began its work just a month after my arrival at the Ministry of Housing and Urban Agenda, meeting three times. I convened a sectoral conference to address issues in tourism due to the competence anchoring, also with the Ministry of Tourism. In April, the European regulation was definitively approved; we merged the three working tables that have concluded in this text that we are going to publish for public audience, but which was already announced more than 15 days ago, as mandated by the administrative processing of a public exposure space of up to 15 days, where I have told you that we have received 100 proposals. Therefore, a whole administrative procedure has followed, with urgency, rigor, serenity, legal certainty, but attending to the emergency. Just last week, I brought to the Council of Ministers the declaration of urgency for that processing; the previous week, I believe, I brought the addendum from SEPES to build that public housing park. A few days earlier, I sealed the agreement for Campamento. In short, every week I could come to report on everything we are developing in the Ministry to respond to that problem. Likewise, the youth bond that we have been analyzing and diagnosing the situation in the autonomous communities; this summer we submitted the request to see the degree of execution, a sectoral conference was convened that previously has some administrative work in a multisectoral commission that must be convened 15 days in advance. In short, what we have brought up to this point has been preceded by work, effort, and it will continue to be so throughout the legislature, as I said at the beginning, because we will not stop until we respond to this problem. And I have no doubt that it could be an interference, that it has not responded to that part, in the competence area, as I said, I held a meeting with the autonomous communities; some of them have records related to the tourism area that will have to be, via technology, merged with these records in the regulations. I believe that all of this will be very operational, and above all because it is an instrument that will facilitate their management of their competence, because we have previously discussed it with them, we have shared it, and in this case, I believe it is a useful instrument for the whole country, also for the Union, and that responds to combating that fraud, those illegalities that we are observing.

Spokesperson. - Well, regarding the question you asked me, notice that during the press conference, there was information from Junts where they rectified and said that they would not support a motion of censure. But look, the negotiations with Junts and the rest of the parliamentary groups continue their course and their path, and above all, I believe that what is important is that we focus on the facts, and the facts are that we are not yet in the first year of the legislature, and in the Congress of Deputies, 17 laws have already been approved, 12 are already published in the Official State Gazette, and 5 are in process in the Senate. So we are already talking about 17 laws that have been approved thanks, above all, to that dialogue that is open with the rest of the parliamentary forces, which has allowed us, as I said, to reach these important figures that I believe say a lot about the possibility of dialogue and negotiation with this Government, which ultimately is what this Government is about, focusing on the people's issues, that is why we are here. For example, today, we are in this press conference on the same day that we learn that we have the lowest inflation in the last three years, where we have approved more than 200 million euros, especially for young people, so they can better cope with rents. Or, for example, we know a fact that seems fundamental to me, which is that in our country, there are currently more than 21,200,000 Spaniards contributing to Social Security, that in our country, more jobs are created than in France and Germany combined, and that is the real Spain, and these are the issues to which the Government is dedicated. It is true that we face an opposition that has been living since 2018, if you allow me, with that hyperventilated policy, a policy based on histrionics that, by the way, is increasingly questioned, even internally, within the Popular Party itself. They started with "Spain is sinking, Spain is breaking," and so on for seven years. I will also tell you that I believe that when the only offer and the only proposal you can make to citizens is a deafening noise, it is because you clearly have to cover up your lack of leadership and your lack of a project. That is why what this government will do, for all that remains of the legislature, is to focus on what is important, which is the people's issues. Very well, thank you very much.

Edited transcript by the State Secretariat for Communication.