Press conference by the President of the Government of Spain, Pedro Sánchez, after the European Council meeting
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez addressed a press conference after the October 2024 European Council meeting in Brussels, summarising Spain's positions on Ukraine, the Middle East, and migration.
- Main themes
- European Council outcomes, Middle East conflict and international law, UNIFIL and Lebanon, Ukraine peace plan, EU-Israel association agreement, arms exports to Israel, two-state solution for Palestine, migration and solidarity, gender-based violence, homophobic hate speech, Gulf Cooperation Council meeting, Venezuela and Georgia
- Duration
- ~34 min
- Words
- 4,028
- Sentences
- 156
- Readability
- 46
- Grade
- 13.1
- Syntax
- 3.29
- Vocabulary
- 2.09
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
156 sentences in 115 paragraphs
Good evening, good afternoon here.
Sorry for the wait.
First of all, please allow me to begin by roundly condemning the homophobic insults and expressions of hatred that Minister Fernando Grande-Marlaska received today in the Community of Navarre because they take us back to another time, to a dark Spain to which we do not want to return and which, unfortunately, a minority still yearns for.
Hate speech is not harmless because it ultimately normalises barbarism. So for the sake of democracy I ask for respect and sanity.
I would also like to begin this speech by expressing my regret for and condemning the terrible male-perpetrated attack on a woman in Segovia, who has died after days of fighting for her life, a victim of gender violence and a victim of murder by her ex-partner.
I believe that, between all of us, the media - as they already trying to do - political parties and society as a whole, we must once and for all eradicate this structural violence that is so shameful and that is causing so much pain to women in our country and to many of their children.
And if you think it is difficult to say anything about the Council after this, I would like to begin by thanking the media, as I always do, for their presence. I would also like to thank the diplomatic services of our European Union Embassy, Marcos, for the work in preparing for this Council, and also for the meeting of the Gulf Cooperation Council we held yesterday.
As always, the Government has approached this Council with a very clear idea, which is to defend coherence and international law. Always, everywhere. In Ukraine, we have done this with President Zelenski's presence. In the Middle East, as we have done this with the representatives of the Gulf countries. And in Venezuela, which has also been discussed and incorporated into the text of the conclusions. And in Georgia, in Sudan, and also, of course, at our borders in the migration debate.
If we are not consistent regarding the trampling of territorial integrity and the violation of human rights, wherever they occur, we as Europeans will lose our moral authority in the eyes of the rest of the world in a war that has gripped us for almost three years now, the war in Ukraine.
And if we also give up on humanity, on looking at the phenomenon of migration from a humanitarian perspective, the principle of solidarity that defines our union will falter and thereby weaken the European project.
And in this Council, Spain has called for coherence and respect for international law in the Middle East, defending three key positions.
The first is that there will be no withdrawal of the UN Peace Mission. This is the approach taken by various governments, and undoubtedly also by the Government of Spain.
We reclaim the essential role and autonomy of UNIFIL.
We condemn the serious statements that Prime Minister Netanyahu has made in this regard, and on this we are categorical. We will not tolerate any questioning of the work of the UN in bringing peace and ensuring stability in that part of the world.
And allow me, furthermore, as President of the Government, to express a special sense of pride and a message of support for our Blue Helmets deployed in southern Lebanon. Because obviously the Government of Spain, like Spanish society as a whole, is with them.
Second, I have called again- as I did a few days ago in a media forum and previously in Cyprus- for us to review the association agreement between the EU and Israel if the violation of human rights and international humanitarian law in Gaza, in the West Bank and in Lebanon is definitely established.
And third, I have asked that the countries that are exporting arms and weapons to Israel cease to do so, as Spain did right at the beginning of the crisis, at the beginning of the war, back on 7 October 2023. All the countries of the EU must do this, and that is what I have asked for.
And I have also said to all countries- to dissuade Prime Minister Netanyahu from this escalation of violence he is perpetrating throughout the region- that it would be good, it would be productive, if those countries that have not yet recognised the State of Palestine would do so.
Because this would be a way of demonstrating to Prime Minister Netanyahu, and also of course to the Israeli Government, that Europe as a whole is committed to the two-state solution, before we sit down at that peace conference to achieve a ceasefire and a political horizon of peace and coexistence for the Israeli Government and the government of the newly recognised state of Palestine.
We want coherence, coherence and dignity, which is what we have conveyed to President Zelenski, who has presented us with his plan to achieve a just and lasting peace in Ukraine, and who we are fortunate to have with us today at the European Council.
And out of coherence and dignity, the Government of Spain and, of course, the European Council will continue to support the Ukrainian people in the face of Russia's aggression, on all fronts and for as long as necessary.
This is what the conclusions state.
And of course we very much welcome the mobilisation of a 35-billion-euro loan to Ukraine. But help, as we always say, must come now as a matter of urgency. This is what we have advocated, and Spain will do everything in its power to ensure that this comes to pass.
In particular, we have discussed formulas for making progress on military and financial support to circumvent the blockade of Hungary, whose government, as you know, has for too long been hijacking important policies, transcendental policies of the EU. We cannot keep bowing to the impulses of a government that is clearly part of the European ultra-right, which in our opinion is not responding to current demands when it comes to defending international legality, national sovereignty and territorial integrity in Ukraine.
And beyond the difficult international scenario, as you know, we have focused our discussions on competitiveness and migration.
I am not going to dwell on competitiveness because it was not something we spoke in depth about. We are going to have another discussion at the end of the year, and I will therefore refer to it in due course when we have that substantive debate.
But I will talk about emigration, because Spain has a clear and resolute position that we have defended in this Council.
It is also, again, a position consistent with the values that have always characterised not only our constitutional order, but also the whole of the EU acquis communautaire.
And it is also a position based on humanity, as I said before, which is necessary to address the complex phenomenon of migration.
Orderly, responsible, well-managed migration, i.e., legal migration, as I defended before in my appearance in the Spanish Parliament, is the answer to the demographic challenge facing Europe and Spain.
And we must be clear. Our present and future competitiveness, the economic growth of our country, the sustainability of our welfare model also depend on migration. And our credibility in the eyes of the rest of the world also depends on how we deal with migration policy.
As I said before, a few days ago in the Lower House of Parliament, I evoked the memory of Spanish migration, and today I would like to recall that this continent, from east to west, from south to north, is steeped in the same memory, that of millions of Europeans who left everything behind, everything, to flee from misery.
We are aware that this debate will naturally generate conflicting positions, but ultimately what is at stake is what kind of Europe we want to be.
And just as I asked Spaniards what kind of Spain we want to be in the medium and long term - a prosperous and therefore open Spain, or a poor and therefore closed Spain - this is the dilemma we must also tackle in Europe.
Do we want a prosperous and therefore open Europe, or do we want a poor and therefore closed Europe? We need, therefore, to address the migration phenomenon with future generations in mind and not the next elections.
We must manage migratory flows from this perspective, that of the demographic challenge, that of how to respond to the demographic winter that Europe is suffering.
And I believe we have valuable tools to tackle this, such as the Pact on Migration and Asylum, which I have of course requested the early approval of, or the application rather than the approval of, for the year 2025.
In short, I believe that in this Council we have dealt with issues that are very relevant for Spanish citizens as a whole, not only from a geopolitical point of view in terms of the situation in the Middle East, the situation in Ukraine, but also in terms of relevant aspects such as, for example, competitiveness, Venezuela, Morocco, and undoubtedly the phenomenon of migration and how all the member states can respond with a common policy at a European level.
And what we in Spain have defended in each and every one of these matters is coherence. A coherence that is based on our constitutional values, that faces challenges with the high beam on, and with leadership and courage.
And now, Director Carmen, I am at the media's disposal to answer your questions.
Q.- [Víctor Tuda, Europa Press].
I wanted to ask you about the review of the Association Council with Israel.
I would like to know how you raised the issue at the summit, how you pressed this issue, and whether you have found more allies, and whether you feel that the EU partners are somehow more open now than they were a few months ago, or whether they are somehow losing patience with Israel after the attacks on UNIFIL.
And then a second question, about a news item that came out a few hours ago. The UN Special Envoy for the Sahara has proposed for the first time the partition of the territory so that one part would be managed by Morocco and another part could be an independent country.
This is something that is supported by Spain, and I would like to know if you were aware of this initiative.
President: Well, thank you very much, Victor.
With regard to the second question, which is the simplest, because it is so short. No, we do not know about the proposal. We will have to study it when we do, so I cannot tell you a position until then.
Second, in relation to the Israel Association Council.
Let's see our position. You know that a few months ago, before the European elections, we asked the Commission together with Israel and the Irish Prime Minister for information on whether or not Israel is complying with one of the articles of the association agreement, which is respect for human rights.
We are waiting for a report to be discussed and presented to the Foreign Affairs Council. In short, I believe that in the coming weeks we will know the content of this report, and from there we will know exactly what opinion the Community institutions have of what Israel is doing on the ground, and whether or not it is complying with international law and particularly with international humanitarian law.
And which countries support or endorse it. Well, this is a proposal that the Government of Ireland and the Government of Spain first put forward.
But I do sense, I am seeing that the countries that have been most vocal in defending Israel are having increasingly serious difficulties in defending the actions of the Israeli government and its prime minister Netanyahu.
Q.- [Almudena Guerrero, TVE].
Good evening, Mr President.
First, on immigration, I wanted to know whether you have talked with Ursula von der Leyen in the margins of this summit, and whether you have conveyed to her your rejection of the proposal to create these deportation centres outside the EU.
Second, there are two more local issues.
If you are concerned that the non-resignation of the Attorney General of the State may damage the image of this institution, and whether it is a good decision for a person under indictment to continue in this body.
And last, why the Government, and you yourself, the president, have given different versions of Delcy Rodríguez's visit to Spain.
Thank you.
President: Well, thank you very much Almudena.
With regard to the first question, I believe that the position of the Government of Spain is well known, public and clear.
We have expressed this both in the media and to our European colleagues. And this is the first time I have spoken out publicly, and I say it clearly. We are not in favour of formulas like these because they do not tackle any of the problems and create new ones.
Therefore, as I said before, we have opted for a vision that is much more focused on the external dimension of the migratory phenomenon. In other words, how we can anticipate the arrival of irregular immigrants from the coasts, in this case from Africa, by strengthening collaboration and cooperation, including in everything that has to do with the security of the borders of these third countries.
That is why we have asked, for example, that Frontex reach agreements with the government of Senegal, with the government of Mauritania, with the governments of West Africa, to collaborate on the ground in their countries and to prevent and anticipate the arrival of irregular immigrants.
And of course, everything that has to do with what I explained in the Lower House of Parliament, including greater coordination between European countries, bringing forward the application of the Immigration and Asylum Pact to the summer of 2025.
And of course, everything that has to do with economic aspects, because look at the challenge of irregular migration, which affects all countries and which is a serious concern for many countries of the EU, which only has 2 billion euros allocated to it in the Community budgets in the multiannual financial framework, I think I remember, Ambassador, just 2 billion euros.
Therefore, we need more resources to curb this situation.
But in any case, my approach within the European Council has always been to take a positive approach to the migratory phenomenon, and to reinforce everything that has to do with regular migration, as I did in my appearance before the Lower House of Parliament.
It is clear that if we want to face the European demographic challenge, if we want to guarantee the sustainability of our pensions and welfare state, and also guarantee the economic growth that Spain and Europe as a whole are currently experiencing, we also need the contribution of migration.
And this migration has to be regular, it has to be safe, it has to be orderly, and this is what the Government of Spain has defended. What I mean is to balance much more the message that Europe is sending out in terms of migration, where we are effectively attacking the whole phenomenon of irregular migration, not because of the victims of this irregular migration, but because of the traffickers of human beings who gamble with the lives of the victims.
And of course, we must also take a positive view of the contribution of migration to all the socio-economic aspects we are experiencing, for example in Spain, and without forgetting the humanitarian aspect, either.
We have therefore expressed our rejection because it does not tackle the problems and creates new ones.
On the national issues, on this question of the State Attorney General, I believe that the Government of Spain has made its position clear and categorical from the outset.
We respect, of course, the position of the Supreme Court, but we support the action of the State Attorney General because he has done his job, he has done what he was supposed to do, which is two things: first, prosecute the offender, and second combat disinformation and fake news.
And probably also in this case, the news we heard yesterday will take us back to the start of all this. Because the start of all this was when the chief of staff of the president of the Community of Madrid- who at the time was the partner of this self-confessed criminal- spread fake news and disinformation to place the lie with the Attorney General's Office.
Therefore, in political terms, what we have to ask ourselves as a society is when is the PP going demand explanations and accountability from the president of the Community of Madrid, who is the partner of a self-confessed criminal who has defrauded the Treasury, as he himself has acknowledged, and who has also profited and enriched himself with the masks during the pandemic?
And allegedly, the president of the Community of Madrid may have benefited from this situation indirectly.
Therefore, it is clear that the State Attorney General has done the work entrusted to the Public Prosecutor's Office in a state governed by the rule of law, which are democracy advocates Pursuing crime, combating fake news.
And what we need is for the PP, Mr Feijóo, and his boss, Mrs Ayuso, to demand political accountability, which can be no other than the resignation of the president of the Community of Madrid.
I hear the PP demanding responsibility in a case such as that of Mr Ábalos and Mr Koldo, regarding which we took the most forceful action eight months ago, demanding the expulsion of Mr Ábalos and Mr Koldo from the Socialist Party. And the PP is giving me lessons in what?
This double standard, this one law for one and another for another, seems to me to be unsustainable, and in any case the situation, which unfortunately the Attorney General is suffering, should serve as a reminder of where this whole issue, this whole story, started.
Because this whole story began with a self-confessed criminal, who is the partner of Mrs Ayuso, who profited from mask provision during the pandemic, who has defrauded the Treasury, and regarding which, within the PP, nobody, I insist, nobody has so far taken any political responsibility; and, of course, nobody has demanded political responsibility, because let us all remember, within the PP, how those who demand political responsibility from the President of the Community of Madrid end up. And if you don't remember, just ask Mr Casado.
And last, regarding the visit. I think we have all said the same thing loud and clear. And what we are saying is that this visit did not take place as soon as it became known that there were indeed individual sanctions against the vice-president of the Venezuelan Government.
Q.- [Nacho Alarcón, El Confidencial].
You have been here in the European Council since 2018. The migration debate has been going on since then, regarding which the other day a European source told us had swung far to the right.
The other social democratic governments, Denmark, Slovakia, were at today's meeting with Meloni. Germany has also been very pivotal in migration policy.
My question is whether you think that Spain is becoming isolated with this discourse on migration. If you feel supported by other member states. And should this be so, which ones, and the extent to which Spain would be willing to fight to ensure that these centres, this innovative idea of centres outside the EU, enters into the discussion on the return directive, which is what we see as the backdrop.
Thank you very much.
President: Well, thank you very much Nacho for your questions.
I believe that on many occasions, when we face certain debates, more than the ideological aspect there is the geographical aspect, and it is clear that there are countries that have been suffering from the migratory phenomenon for a long time.
And you mentioned some of these countries in terms of the integration of migrants in movements that are called secondary - wrongly called secondary because we are in the Schengen area - and so I believe that not only is it about belonging to a political family, but the geographical status of the prime minister of the day also intertwines, intermingles.
And in these matters, I obviously feel closer to some prime ministers of Mediterranean countries than perhaps to some of my colleagues from my own social democratic family.
But in any case, what seems relevant to me about Ursula von der Leyen's letter- which establishes what, let us say, the main proposals for migration policy are- is that one can agree or disagree with some of these proposals, as is our case, for example, with these detention centres in third countries.
But there are many other things, other proposals, which we feel recognised for and the protagonists of.
And if you look at some of the proposals put forward by the President of the Commission in her letter, they are clearly proposals that Spain has been advocating for some time.
Therefore, I believe we are moving forward within a framework of migration policy in which we can find common elements, although there are indeed some that are clearly contrary to our values, our principles and our way of looking at migration policy.
But in any case, I believe that to say that Spain... Spain was the creator of the Pact on Migration and Asylum in the year 2023, during our presidency!
So all countries, or at least the majority of countries, are saying that we need to bring forward the implementation of the Migration and Asylum Pact.
I think it is a good agreement that took us- and you know this because you have been following Community policy for a long time-15 years to come to, and it was under a Spanish presidency that we did so.
We also had to compromise on this agreement because there are many things we don't like either, but for the sake of this agreement we had to concede to.
I believe it is now up to us to develop this agreement and implement it in a way that is not only effective, but also balanced.
Because you will remember that the great debate that took place in relation to this agreement was about responsibility and solidarity, so the two concepts must go hand in hand.
And we are of course responsible for controlling our borders, but we also demand solidarity from other countries.
Q.- [ Manuel Gómez, El País].
Good evening. Today we heard the news that Anticorruption says that Mr. Ábalos was central to the plot of the Koldo case.
I would like to ask you if you take any responsibility for the appointment of Minister Ábalos.
Thank you.
President: Well, thank you very much, Manuel.
Look, I assume three responsibilities, which I talked about in the General Courts the other day.
The first responsibility is to act decisively. And this Government and I, as secretary general, in this case of the Socialist Party, acted forcefully eight months ago, five days after some of the evidence was made public, which now seems to have been confirmed by the Guardia Civil and the UCO.
Second, as I have always stated, collaboration with the justice system, with the state law enforcement forces and agencies, and even the opening of a Commission of Inquiry in the Lower House of Parliament, which by the way was closed with the affirmative vote of the PP.
And last, I would like to inform the citizens that the Government is going to continue with its economic and social progress until the year 2027, regarding which my commitment, which I expressed in my investiture speech, is clear and firm.
In three years' time, we want Spain to be a much more prosperous, more socially and territorially united country than it was in 2017, the last year of Mr Rajoy's mandate.
Thank you very much.
Original speech in Spanish