First reply from the President of the Government, Pedro Sanchez, to all Parliamentary Groups

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

17 July 2018 · Debate on the state of the nation (first reply to Parliamentary Groups)

Context
Sánchez addressed the Spanish Parliament on 17 July 2018, delivering his first reply to all parliamentary groups during a general policy debate session.
Main themes
Democratic regeneration, ETA dissolution and counter-terrorism legacy, Spanish Socialist Workers' Party history, parliamentary conduct and respect, penitentiary policy reform, political responsibility of opposition parties, unity of democratic forces, Basque Country politics
Duration
~102 min
98th percentile
Words
12,293
98th percentile
Sentences
532
98th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
3.12
63rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
30th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 32%31%
  • Economic 26%25%
  • Geopolitical 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

532 sentences in 123 paragraphs

Thank you, Madam Speaker.

It falls on me to reply in the order of participation, and, consequently, I will begin with Mr. Hernando, to be followed by the response to the People's Parliamentary Group.

First of all, I would like to express appreciation to both the Spokesperson of the People's Parliamentary Group and to the Spokesperson of the Parliamentary Group of Ciudadanos , who have more or less coincide on the same criticisms, the same tone, the same parliamentary style towards my speech, towards the nature of my government and also in respect of the actions it has taken.

I think it's very important, Honourable Members, that when we talk about democratic regeneration, we also respect all our manners. I think that in dialectics it is very important, of course, to express oneself as one wishes. One can be more abrupt, softer, more refined or less refined in parliamentary dialectic. But what is important is not to be disrespectful on a personal level, and not be unjust to the historical legacy of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, even with the actions that I and many of us here, have deployed at critical moments in the very recent political and democratic history of our country. Saying that this government is little more than an accomplice of terrorists seems to me an injustice, Mr. Hernando, Mr. Rivera.

First, because of the history of the Socialist Party. We count as our own the victims of terrorism of the People's Party as we do all the victims in Spain during more than forty years of murders at the hands of the terrorist group, ETA. What I ask, Mr. Hernando and Mr. Rivera, is that you are fair in the political defence of your positions, which like ours, are legitimate. I ask that you are not swayed by the victory that has taken place and been certified this year - the dissolution of ETA. I ask that this does not divide the democratic forces present here. Above all, when the political history of this party, the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, which forms the main basis of this government, has not only suffered the loss of human life, of comrades who simply believed in a society in the Basque Country, and in the whole of Spain, was different from others, and were killed as a result, or had to flee the Basque Country for their beliefs and also because the Socialist Party, when it has been in opposition, has been deeply loyal; deeply loyal to all governments, whether Mariano Rajoy's or José María Aznar's, at a very difficult time in the fight against terrorism. The Socialist Party supported bringing ETA prisoners closer to home precisely to defuse the situation in the Basque Country. I think that both Mr. Rivera and Mr. Hernando have to reflect on this.

What you have committed, if I may, Mr. Hernando, is a greater crime because Mr. Rivera has only just arrived and it seems he has not read much about the political history of Spain or about the political commitment of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party in the fight against terrorism. Or how it has led the State Pacts against terrorism. But you, Mr. Hernando, on behalf of the People's Parliamentary Group - your party, when you have governed, has brought prisoners to the Basque Country, and, moreover, this has counted on the silence, in this case, on the support and institutional loyalty that every party of State must have, every party of government, as is the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, and there has been no reproach when you have done so. I believe, Mr. Hernando, of course, you can criticise, pour all your blame on the current government, for its actions. But I believe that, for the sake of maintaining democratic life, for the sake of having as calm a debate as possible, to set the best example for citizens watching us on the social media or on television, it is best to leave aside reproaches that you know, Mr. Hernando, are unjust. They are unfair.

To be precise, the main reflection we should make in this country after the dissolution of ETA was announced a few months ago, which is basically a certificate of failure, already assumed in 2011, under another government, which was not yours, is that they should not see democrats divided, precisely now that it is democracy that has defeated ETA.

Therefore, I am not going to refer to the matter again, because, honestly, Mr. Rivera, Mr. Hernando, it seems to me that there is no greater contempt than to not appreciate these words. Therefore, I will not remind you here how José Maria Aznar took prisoners to the Basque Country. I will not recall here the unfortunate use by previous administrations of the counter-terrorism policy.

What I am going to reaffirm, Honourable Members, is that once ETA has been defeated and dissolved, the Government of Spain will comply with penitentiary law. Consequently, if penitentiary policies were used to think how ETA was defeated, once ETA is defeated, of course, prison policies must be rethought. That is what the Government of Spain is going to do and let me tell you one thing, Mr. Rivera, this will be done publicly, just as I'm doing, here from the lectern. This is the question.

Well, you said, "the bills" of the new government. The only "bill" that this government is paying is the one your people left, Mr. Hernando.

Sure, you talk to us about public deficit, you talk about public spending. I said it in my first speech, Honourable Members, the public deficit of 3.1%. The highest public deficit in the European Union, compared with the average of 1% of GDP. Mr. Hernando, the Government of Spain is going to approve, following a report and prior meeting of the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council, a new path of stability, acknowledging what you already know. It will be acknowledged that the Budget that you, together with Mr. Rivera, designed, is not credible. It will not meet the public deficit targets set by Brussels. What is the issue? You come here and say that when Spain went to Brussels it arrived without credibility. Anyway, that's all relative, Mr. Hernando. It may well be in your eyes, I can assure you that the experience I had in Brussels was not that. But I am going to tell you one thing, Mr. Hernando, what is evident is that it does not contribute to the credibility and prestige of a country to systematically default on the public deficit, as you did during the seven years that you were governing this country.

So, let's not lie. Don't lie, Mr. Rivera, don't lie, Mr. Hernando.

We are saying we can perfectly propose a path of stability, which recognises not only the social reality and economic reality of our country, but also the consensus of the study services. Also, as the Spokesman for the Basque Nationalist Party reminded us earlier, the AIReF report itself shows we are going to have a public deficit of 2.7%. So, what do we do? Shall we deceive ourselves? Do we say we can meet the 2.3% public deficit? Or do you want us to meet the 2.3% deficit, and therefore continue making cuts to the Welfare State, which is what you did when you were ruling? We are not going to do that. We are not going to allow it, Honourable Members.

We say 2.7%, five tenths more; 1.8%, five tenths more compared with the following year, the year 2019, and with that we will be doing two important things: one, to guarantee the budgetary stability of this country; the health of public accounts, and ensuring that Spain comes out of the corrective arm of the Stability and Growth Pact and, therefore, we can begin to breathe after many years subject to that correcting arm.

And finally, Honourable Members, we plan to ensure social cohesion. This is the real debate, the debate of substance, and it would be appropriate, Mr Hernando, that when you reflect and your parliamentary group reflects, along with the parliamentary group of Ciudadanos , because it's much of a muchness, you declare your position in this House regarding the path of stability, especially those of you in power, because Ciudadanos is not in power. You will have to explain to your regional presidents why they will have to refuse to have an injection of more than 2.4 billion euros in the autonomous regions. When we talk about this, we're talking about health and education. We are talking about long-term care and we are talking about all those policies that bind our country socially and territorially.

Also, in short, it is paradoxical that you come here to tell us there are investments that are not going to be fulfilled, but instead tell us we will see what happens to the path of stability, the position maintained by the People's Parliamentary Group. The two things are incompatible, Mr. Hernando. Either you are committed to the autonomous regions having more economic resources, which is reasonable within this path of growth and stability, which has been the position of the current government, or logically you are saying that what the Government of Spain should do is implement more cutbacks and, consequently, worsen our Welfare State. And that, Mr Hernando, from an ideological point of view, and from a perspective of economic policy, is certainly not what we want.

So, bills? The social security bill, Mr. Hernando. What is the social security deficit? What is the battered state of the Social Security Reserve fund right now? What's the situation for today's pensioners? Many times when we talk about today's pensioners, what worries them is not so much their retirement but the retirement of tomorrow, of their children and of their grandchildren. What you have done is simply live off credit, asking the Treasury for credit to continue paying the extraordinary payments of the country's pensioners.

Honourable Members, we want to offer a great agreement deal to the House, so we can reach a new Toledo Pact. That's what we want. Don't you want to? Well, you'll have to explain. You will have to explain that you do not want an agreement, a new agreement and a new Toledo Pact. Because it is you, moreover, who have squandered the Social Security Reserve Fund, have put into question not only sustainability, but also the dignity of pensions due to the 2012, which broke the Toledo Pact because it did not even have the agreement of the social stakeholders.

The bill, of course, is that of precarious employment. In this sense, of course, we will raise the matter in this House along with legislative amendments to the labour framework. Our intention and our interest would be to repeal the whole labour reform, but we must also be realistic and know that there is no parliamentary majority in this House to produce that. But we can alter many of the elements that are most damaging to the labour market, which is a product of its reform. Here, Article 42 on ultra-activity has been raised by different parliamentary groups, which is now in its passage through Parliament. In short, there are issues I think we can find and we can begin to dismantle their most damaging effects. These come in the form of precariousness and wage devaluation, caused by the labour reform that you imposed with an absolute majority in the year 2012.

You talk about public revenue and then you come back with the argument that the Socialists are very bad, that we only raise taxes and that we squander, when we are the ones that really lower taxes, and help the middle and working class. In short, this string of arguments is old politics, Mr. Hernando, Mr. Rivera. You who came here to say that you would change policies when what you do is mimic and copy the oldest, most old-fashioned discourse of the Spanish right. Then I have to remember obvious things, which frankly I am obliged to do by, Mr. Hernando and Mr. Rivera. Let's look, Mr. Hernando, the People's Parliamentary Group supported a government that raised income tax, that raised VAT, that raised taxes on the middle and working classes. And what is the result? You have raised taxes on the working middle class. You have cut public spending on education, long-term care and health, breaking the principle of the universality of public health, which has seen it deteriorate to disgraceful levels, just like the unemployment coverage rate. In short, what you have done has is to raise taxes on the middle classes and to cut the Welfare State. And what is the result of all this, Honourable Members? Well, we have a public deficit of 3.1% of gross domestic product and a public debt of 100%. And you come here and tell me that we want our grandchildren to pay for today's public spending. But, you are the ones who have placed the public debt of this country at 100%.

Honourable Members of the People's Party and of Ciudadanos , I would like to have a much more constructive debate, which I think is much more intelligent and much more suited to what the citizens of this House expect. I would be interested to know your opinion on whether it is really worthwhile or not for this country for Parliament to modernise our tax system. Mr. Rivera, Mr. Hernando, I would like to know if you are willing to impose a tax on the digital services of large corporations, who do not pay taxes in this country. As they do not pay taxes, what they do is devalue and deteriorate, to a large extent, the working conditions of many companies and of many workers. In addition, they do not allow public revenue to be collected, which goes to sustaining the Welfare State.

Ergo, what's the conclusion? If we do not implement this kind of reform, if we do not modernise our Welfare State and also our tax system, what is going to happen, Mr Hernando, Mr Rivera, is that finally, it will be the working and middle classes who once again have to pay to sustain the Welfare State.

We say social justice yes, and that means fiscal justice. And that's why we're going to open a debate on whether companies that exploit their workers and who, today, by the way, have been in the news, on whether or not they should have to pay taxes in Spain.

By the way, do not get too confused, you are so interested in Europe, precisely because there is a broad consensus in Europe regarding the need to incorporate taxation on digital companies. Therefore, that is the debate we want to open. Do you not want to open this debate? Well, that will be your problem. But you will be behind the times and outside the European Union.

By the way, Mr Hernando, you who have criticised this so much, I will only say one thing, because we have started reading the reports and papers of, for example, the Ministry of the Treasury. Ask Mr. Montoro what the position of the former government was on these issues.

Corporate income tax. Mr. Rivera and Mr. Hernando, you say the People's Party and Ciudadanos are defenders of small and medium-sized enterprises, of self-employed workers, you shout out loud and tell us that "the Socialists are here now." We are not going to touch taxes for the working middle class, whether they are self-employed or are small and medium-sized enterprises. Now, moving on to the big conglomerates that have effective rates of less than 10% We are going to force those companies to pay at least 15% because we will not resign ourselves to the effective rate of corporate income tax being below 10%, and therefore of course, being lower than that of small and medium-sized enterprises.

Mr. Rivera, is this an ideology? Is it effective? I think it's the two things: it's ideology and efficiency. Of course, it's efficient, Mr. Rivera, that corporate conglomerates start paying the taxes they owe. It's even ideology too, Mr. Rivera. The difference between you and me is that I defend small and medium-sized enterprises and self-employed workers because, amongst other things, we open channels for greater public revenues from business conglomerates.

Mr Rivera, I do not know what interests you are defending and the people and interests behind your party? But, I can guarantee you one thing, Mr Rivera, this government is going to carry out fiscal justice. It is as simple as hat.

Of course, I'm told, Social Security. We already know what it is, we already know the right's formula of Ciudadanos and of the People's Party. They don't say we have a problem. Do we agree, Mr Rivera, Mr Hernando, that there is a Social Security problem? Do we agree, Mr. Hernando, Mr. Rivera? Do we agree that there is a problem regarding the Social Security deficit? Do we agree that there is a problem of Social Security underfunding? Do we agree that currently, with the characteristics of the jobs created and the number of contributors we have, that this does not cover and resolve the Social Security problem in the medium term? Not today's pensions, but tomorrow's and the day after's, yours and of those speaking, or those of our children? Do we agree that, as a result, we also have a 'baby boom' generation, which in a few years is going to retire and which, among other issues, will also place an obvious risk of the unsustainable nature of the Social Security system? Do we have a problem financing our Social Security, yes or no? I believe that all of us here, on the Toledo Pact Committee, can say yes, that there is a problem of country and of State that we have to resolve. What's the red line? It is clear that the red line is that pensions have to be dignified. They need to be pensions that do not lose purchasing power, which have no rises of 0.25%, which you chained to the retirements of this country with the reform in the year 2012.

If we have that agreement, Honourable Members, it is clear we will have to do things and not only create jobs, and that we must also be aware of if we want to raise Social Security contributions. Some parliamentary groups may wish to propose this; the government, of course, does not want to raise Social Security contributions, because precisely what we want is not to increase the cost of labour. We have to start looking for different formulas. Rationalising spending is one of the measures we are going to implement and of course open the debate on a taxation to help Social Security. In that regard, Mr. Hernando, Mr. Rivera, you will say no, but we are going to create that finalist tax and we are going to link it to a sector that has been rescued by the effort of the Spanish people, worth 40 billion euros. Therefore, the philosophy of a bailout for its own sake, Honourable Members, is a philosophy that this House has to apply and that this government will apply.

I will also tell you one thing, if you, and Mr. Rivera in particular, are so concerned about the impact that this type of tax may have linked to the sustainability of Social Security, I simply ask you, Mr. Rivera, since you look so much at Mr. Macron; ask Mr. Macron how it is done in France. Ask him, and you will see that nothing has happened that you threaten us with, or that tell us will happen in Spain.

Mr Hernando, a thought or maybe two, which I could also direct at Mr Rivera. Mr. Rivera threatens to speak to me about Catalonia. But, Mr. Rivera only speaks of Catalonia. He is always speaking of Catalonia, but only negatively. The question is, what is the alternative to dialogue? Confrontation? Shall we continue with confrontation, Mr. Hernando, Mr. Rivera? Shall we continue with confrontation?

I believe that the responses at the beginning of this debate clearly show those who are still involved in conflict, and those who want to break down this conflict. So, in the end, there are likely to be parliamentary groups who consider that the relations between the Government of Spain and the Regional Government of Catalonia are best suited to a boxing ring. That is not the case of this government, Mr Hernando, Mr Rivera, that is not the case of this government.

Mr. Hernando you have made a reference to historical memory. You imply this government is looking to the past grudgingly and opening wounds, which are already closed. In short, Mr. Hernando, I think we are doing the opposite. We want to close wounds and our generations should look forward peacefully at our past.

Mr Hernando, there are many people in this country, you have to admit, whose wounds are open. In global terms, Spain is unfortunately a country where many have disappeared and are yet to be found in the ditches that line our roads. And I think, Mr Hernando, that it is an act of historical justice to do everything possible to close those wounds. Of course, the Government of Spain will help to do this.

I will also say, Mr. Hernando, the People's Party years ago, I can't remember the exact date, I do not know if it was in 2008, in short I do not remember when it was, but Mr. Hernando, the People's Party condemned the Franco dictatorship. It condemned the Franco dictatorship.

The other day in a control session, I said to you I wish you would soon find a compass. Find it, Mr. Hernando, and above all, guide towards the parameters of a modern right, well founded, pro-European, cosmopolitan and open, and not the extreme right that some governments have such as your sister parties in Hungary, Austria and other countries.

Of course, this has been referred to by Mr. Baldoví and I have also referred to it in my first speech because I found it quite disturbing that, not in the squabble of the primaries, that is another thing, but I of course respect this and can say things and sometimes even repent. But, in the end it was said by your Spokesperson in the European Parliament. He said that Schengen must be suspended. In short, Schengen, Mr Hernando, is the guiding principle, the core principle of the European Union. Do you know what you are saying, that millions of young people in this country are not going to be able to move freely on the European continent? Is that the proposal that the People's Party brings to this House?

I believe there are much more intelligent ways of approaching issues such as those you have raised and we are waiting for you and are reaching out to you. It will be very difficult, Mr. Hernando, I am very aware of that, but I hope we can understand each other on issues that have to do with the State.

To the Unidos Podemos Parliamentary Group, allow me to respond globally to Ms. Belarra, Ms. Martin, Mr. Garzón and Mr. Gómez-Reino. First, the purpose of this appearance is to first clarify the resolutions and conclusions of the European Council and also to explain the Government Programme from my perspective. Ministers have done this in the different committees, and the logical intention was during this intense month of transfer, in a novel period for Spanish democracy, to make this appearance as soon as possible. Therefore, I have not focused so much on my speech at the European Council because, among other things, many of the conclusions I have to make to you after the Council remain open because they have not been effectively resolved.

I, of course, said publicly we are not satisfied with the findings reached on immigration and I am going to tell you precisely why. The draft conclusions found by the government, upon entering, were a draft of conclusions, that you do not need to know the development and work of, but I agree they were very guided and highly focused on the reality of German politics and Italian politics. It was an approach to migration that we do not share, where there was more talk about the reaction to that migratory flow beyond integration, or for example, about the necessary cooperation with countries of origin and countries of transit. In that sense, I want to share with you that the measures that were most stressed in those conclusions related to the control of borders, the creation of centres euphemistically called "regional platforms" for the management of these migratory flows in the countries of origin and in the countries of transit. In short, all the issues you mentioned and that I don't wish to dwell on. But I will tell you that the Government of Spain, from that point of view, first had a clear objective while the debate that arose was not so evident within the Council, Honourable Members. It was very clear to us that our main objective, our main purpose, was to maintain and preserve an EU approach to a challenge that is global and that needs a European response and not, therefore, a unilateral, nationalist response. Second, we had to incorporate two important issues for our country: first, the need to recognise the importance of cooperation with African countries. That is incorporated in the Council resolution, in its conclusions. Second, to recognise on the part of the European Council, of the EU institutions, that right now, the pressure is on the Western Mediterranean route and consequently, Spain needs solidarity resources in addition to demanding responsibility and needs these resources to face the migratory challenge. These were the main causes, the main objectives of the Government of Spain, to vindicate and strengthen the cooperative link with countries of origin and countries of transit and to show that solidarity and also show the integration policies that are necessary for development on the African continent. But, secondly, to logically recognise that Spain is suffering from pressure, which has been increasing for a long time and that, consequently, we needed the solidarity of all European countries.

You say to me, we do not like regional platforms. I said here in the speech I made before the Council: we have many doubts about these regional platforms. We said that if these regional platforms are put into operation, it will first have to be with cooperation and with the will of the countries of origin or countries of transit where they will be located. And secondly, logically, the rules that these centres or regional platforms have to manage must be those provided by the UNHCR and the International Organization for Migration. And this was the approach that the Government of Spain advocated in the debate.

Secondly, in relation to the reception centres in Spain or on the European continent that you mentioned earlier. I believe the Minister for Home Affairs said this in Parliament, but it is clear that we also need to create centres, ports where many of those boats can arrive, which are now arriving directly on the coast at Tarifa, on the coasts of Almeria, the coasts of the Spanish Levante and the south of Spain in general. I think that is precisely the opposite of what you are trying to infer in your speech. On the contrary, what we want is that when they arrive they have the best attention from the Red Cross and the different NGOs, that those people fleeing from horror and war are effective managed as quickly as possible and consequently be considered as asylum-seekers. This, Honourable Members, is the commitment and intention of the position that the Government of Spain, at least, has in relation to this matter.

The CIE (internment camps for foreigners), remarked Ms. Martin, should be closed. I believe that the government, and I said this before the European Council meeting, wants to endorse the resolution of the Lower House of Parliament. We want to review the CIE, but, of course, we need centres where we can attend and be able to receive and hold the illegal migrants that arrive on our coasts. I think, Honourable Members, it is important to maintain this, but that we have to improve their management? What we have to do is guarantee respect for human rights at the CIE? That is where we are going to take on the position of this Parliament. But I think it is important not to deceive our citizens either. It is important to be aware that we need spaces where we can place illegal migrants, those who are not asylum-seekers, and in that sense, Honourable Members, that is the position of the Government of Spain. We are empathetic, we are sensitive to these issues that many NGOs have communicated to us, but, of course, we also consider that we need these centres in order to be able to manage migratory flows as closely and as intelligently as possible.

You may not be aware of it, but a few days ago the Italian Government again rejected illegal migrants who were on a ship and did not allow them to dock in Italy. When it is said the Government of Spain is not sensitive to the very harsh reality that many migrants face in the Mediterranean, I think we can criticise many things about this government but not this. Honourable Members, this cannot be criticised, among other reasons, because exactly two days ago, we reached an agreement between the French Government, the Portuguese Government and the Government of Spain to take care of different migrants who are now in the Mediterranean due to the closing of the borders by the Italian Government, so long as they also take care some of those migrants who are on the ship.

I believe this is only fair, firstly because we are focusing on the migratory problem from a European point of view. Secondly, what the Government of Spain is demonstrating is solidarity; it is supportive not only of the migrants who arrive on the southern and eastern coasts, but also supportive with the migratory realities of those who leave Libya and, unfortunately, are being rejected at borders, which in this case have been closed by the Italian Government

I believe we can be criticised for many things and I am also willing to learn from mistakes, to recognise those mistakes, but on this matter, Honourable Members, the Government of Spain cannot be criticised. All you have to do is listen to Mr. Rivera and Mr. Hernando about the migration policy of this country, which is completely different from what you accuse us of.

You speak about the path of stability. You are a party, you are a conglomerate of parties that govern in different cities. You, in addition, have made reference to some of those cities, have described them as "host cities". There are many "host cities" and many "host autonomous regions".

In fact, if you will allow me firstly to return to migration for a moment, the Government of Spain has made two decisions that I believe are very important. The first, for everything relating to the MENA, for everything related to migration policy and the need to coordinate and to cooperate, which I referred to earlier, we have set up again the Delegate Committee on Migration that was closed and did not meet for many years in this country. Secondly, we are going to convene the Sector Conference on Migration so that, precisely, the Government of Spain and the regional governments have an all-encompassing approach to a reality that affects all the territories and all the municipalities.

But I will return to the question of budgetary stability. I return to the question of the path of stability that I announced in my speech. You say it is insufficient, that it is not what you expected.

I'm not going to look at the Tsipras. Indeed, we must look at what Tsipras has changed and I would just encourage you to talk to him. An absolutely social-democratic approach to what the European Union is and what should be the correct management of public resources.

But anyway, go to the City Council of Madrid. In the City Council of Madrid, the mayor is carrying out a Stability Program, which is necessary to balance some accounts although, by the way, she was not responsible for them needing to be balanced, for this debt and this public deficit. But she set up this Stability Programme, a Budget based on this Stability Programme, that whichever way you look at it, was supported by the Socialist Municipal Group.

Therefore, I believe that the debate and probably the challenge remaining for us on the left is to be aware and convey to Spanish citizens what has been transferred to the citizens of Madrid, which is that we are able to perfectly combine, in contrast to what the right does, budget stability, the cleaning up of public accounts, with the consolidation of the Welfare State.

Would we naturally prefer is for this to became a reality faster? That we could do many more things in less time? It is obvious, of course, we could agree on that. But I would ask you to take a midway perspective, Honourable Members, because are going to understandably need the support of your group to push through important measures, which are going to need budgetary support. Naturally, I hope I can count on your help. Of course, we extend our hand in friendship and I think this gesture is important. Bear in mind that of those five tenths of a point of public deficit that have been gained, one tenth will be for Central Government; two tenths for the autonomous regions, and two tenths will be for Social Security.

Therefore, in short, I think we are clearly focusing on what the objectives, needs and sacrifices of this government are: they are the autonomous regions, they are the territorial and local administrations and also Social Security. That is where we are going to focus, at least for the proposal of a path of stability.

Ms. Martin asks me about the question of refugees and the breach of the Supreme Court ruling. We want to comply where the previous administration was in breach. We have found huge numbers of asylum applications and logically what we want is to process them, as you would undoubtedly expect.

There has been a debate regarding the defence budget that has also arisen that I would like to address it as I was unable to in the press conference after the Summit.

There is nothing new in saying that at the latest NATO summit, the proposal brought by the US President was to no longer reach the agreement reached in 2014 at the summit in Wales of 2% of the gross domestic product in defence. The US administration proposed to initially reach 4%, by the year 2024.

In our view, the debate, and I have said this publicly here in this House, should be empathetic and sympathetic with a country that is the main donor and main contributor of the support for NATO. I believe it is unfair to only measure the joint defence of all the allies in terms of budgetary contributions. Our reality is that we have a budget of less than 1% of the Gross Domestic Product in Defence, of 0.93%. But it is also a reality, Honourable Members, that in two other issues relating to capabilities and contributions, as in the overseas presence on international missions of Spain, whether in the Baltic States or in Latvia, guaranteeing and ensuring populations that currently feel, and believe me I witnessed it when they explained it to me, the very important and worrying presence of Russian troops on those borders. The presence of the Spanish Army in Turkey, defending settlements on the border with Syria (right now there are around 2 million people protected by that Spanish military presence in Turkey). Spain is committed to leading counter-terrorist training in a country whose images of terrible, brutal Jihadi terrorist attacks in Tunisia we can all remember. Our commitment is to be there in the fight against terrorism. To tackle hybrid attacks and destabilisations being carried out by certain groups, via social networks, through 'fake news' and through all the issues relating to new technologies, Honourable Members, demands we rethink our contribution, I am not saying that of Spain, but that of the whole of the European Union, of the European countries within NATO.

What did The Government of Spain advocate? One, the Government of Spain advocated a move towards a progressive increase in the defence budget precisely because we want to guarantee security and peace, not for any other reason. To guarantee peace and security. Peace and security are not only guaranteed on our borders, they are also guaranteed in the Baltic, in Latvia, they are guaranteed in Turkey, they are guaranteed in Libya, they are guaranteed in Tunisia, they will be guaranteed by other allies in many other parts of NATO. What do I mean by this, Honourable Members? We are going to have to reflect because it is true that the United States wants to cut back on its investment in contributions towards NATO, and therefore the allies and above all, the European Union, must rethink what our contributions are and how we measure those contributions.

As a deeply left-wing person and a progressive person, as you are, I can guarantee you that the left is also committed to guaranteeing and ensuring security and peace in the world. That also requires that NATO, which we hope continues, which is what we want to see, together with a Common Foreign and Security Policy, which is also what we want to see and what I, at least, advocated at that NATO summit.

So if we leave the great headline 'here come the socialists who want to raise the budget in defence because they bow to the interests of Trump', and here we are really getting to the heart of the matter, we are aware there are threats from international terrorism, mainly Jihadi terrorism, and also threats to cyber-security from countries close to the European Union that are now being brought into question, even the territorial sovereignty of some countries, such as, for example, Ukraine or Georgia. We will have to be aware that we may have to make a higher contribution.

Does that mean, Honourable Members, that we have to place ourselves in the parameters that the Trump administration told us to? No. That means, Honourable Members, that we have to make a fair and reasonable approach as to what contributions we will make economically, what our capabilities are and what our contributions are on those international missions. I understand that in this case maybe we do not understand each other, that we cannot share a path with some left-wing parliamentary groups, but in that sense, I do hope that other parliamentary forces that have been in charge of these responsibilities are empathetic to this issue .

And in short, as regards the questions that have been raised by Mr. Garzón and other members of the Unidos Podemos group. Parliament is equipped with its committees. It has a committee that is called Reserved Expenditure, that is, the extinct Official Secrets Committee. What we have said is, we will wait and see what information comes out, the clarifications that the Director General of the National Intelligence Centre (Spanish acronym: CNI) makes, and thenceforth, we will obviously take action. But let's substantiate the debate where the House itself recognises that this type of debate must be substantiated. And then we will see exactly how to proceed. This is the approach that the government has and that the Socialist Parliamentary Group has.

But I will tell you one thing, Honourable Members: I have no idea who the beneficiaries of the amnesty are. I give you my word. No idea. Really none. You, Mr. Rivera, seem to have information about those who benefitted from this amnesty. Come out here and say it, Mr. Rivera. Say it. I can assure you that I have no idea. No, none, I have no idea. What I will not do is prevaricate. I will not prevaricate, Honourable Members, I will not prevaricate.

You Mr. Hernando, supported a government that precisely passed a tax amnesty law, which said in one of its articles "that the confidentiality of those who benefit from this tax amnesty will be guaranteed". So, we don't need lessons from you, Mr. Hernando. Aside from that, I repeat, what we are proposing is a new law that precisely prohibits by law any new tax amnesties. In other words, we cannot act on a past event that has already been ruled on, but we can act on the present and the future which is what this government is going to propose. So that is the government's approach, that is the approach in relation to the debate that has to be conducted in the former Official Secrets Committee and from there we will obviously see what measures need to be taken.

Finally, Mr. Gómez-Reino says that we have to build and that we have to start up to guarantee decent pensions, equality and the fight against job insecurity. The other spokespersons of Unidos Podemos have talked about the path of stability, taxation, housing, rents. In short, the important thing will be to know what your position is when we bring those laws and those budgets from Unidos Podemos .

We have said we are going to modify the Law of Urban Leases and that we are going to put a limit on the property rental bubble, which has come about exactly as a result of tourist apartments. We have said we are going to push through an indefinite public housing plan for rentals over the next four years. In short, the important thing will be to know the position of each and every one of the groups that make up Unidos Podemos ; of course, we will extend our hand.

To Mr. Rivera, I make the same reflection I made to Mr. Hernando before in relation to the respect we owe each other. I think you have more dialectical ability. It seems that even as a young person - we have seen this in a video - you won some debate, some contest, some debating competition without having to insult, without having to disparage the Presidency of the Government or the Council of Ministers. In short, you are clearly smart. You can find elements of criticism much more sophisticated than saying, ugly, bad things and that the Socialist Party are collaborators and borderline terrorists. I am convinced, Mr. Rivera, that you can give much more of yourself in the parliamentary debate.

You have just said, you have made a statement of deep ideological substance which is that modern politics need to be made. I agree that modern politics must be carried out. Among other things, when you speak, for example, of ballot boxes or legitimacy or lack of legitimacy of this government, which has been formed under Article 113 of the Spanish Constitution, I only ask Mr. Rivera, that you do your homework before speaking. Read the Constitution. This government is perfectly legitimate because, among other reasons, it had the majority support of this House.

And Mr. Rivera, when we talk about ballot boxes, what do you do with the results of the polls? What do you do, for example, in Catalonia? You are the leading parliamentary force in Catalonia and what have you done? Nothing. What have you done? Nothing. Simply blame the majority pro-independence bloc of the Regional Parliament of Catalonia and you also come here to lay blame, in this case, at the door of the Socialist Parliamentary Group. It is the only thing that you can do: blame, blame, blame.

You live well from conflict, but Mr. Rivera, that story is over now. In this House there is a government that does not live off territorial strife, as you do. You commit to division while we commit, Mr. Rivera, to rebuilding. That is the difference between you and us. We talk about modernisation and transformation, and then Mr. Rivera arrives and tells us, again, about the diesel issue. Mr. Rivera tells us that he agrees that the ecological transition must be made, that he agrees that we must fight against climate change, but that we should not impose taxes that actually discourage the use, for example, of fuels - basically pollutants - which is what all countries are doing, for example, in Europe, Mr. Rivera. Those who belong to the Socialist Party, some who are from Liberal Parties and also from your sister party, the People's Party. With this, what we are presenting are deeply pro-European fiscal proposals that are in line with the recommendations of the European Commission and of many governments of different colours in the European Union.

Regarding the education agreement: I have asked here and have proposed an education agreement. Mr. Rivera, beyond the agreement in education and bipartisanship, we are very bad at bipartisanship. Well, that is where we are at, Mr. Rivera. What are you doing to forge this education pact? Absolutely nothing, Mr. Rivera. What you have done has been to approve a budget that cuts back on public education and you walk backwards like crabs, Mr. Rivera.

Talking about vocational training, well, what is your proposal? You talk about not wanting it either. Anyway, do you not agree on the subject of Civic and Constitutional Values? OK. Well, we've already begun to reach agreements, Mr. Rivera. Let's put them all together and do something, among other issues, to finally repeal the LOMCE that was unilaterally approved by the previous government with an absolute majority in the 2011-2015 term.

You say, 'no, Mr. Sánchez has made a speech about the past, not about the future, and then you say that the future discourse is to talk about job insecurity'. I understand that mine has been a long speech, but I also understand, Mr. Rivera, that you have attended to it, correct? I have talked about job insecurity. I have said that we are going to present a Master Plan to fight labour exploitation and job insecurity. I would like to know what your position is on the temporary contract, on ultra-activity, on Article 42 of the labour framework that was approved by the previous government. In short, I would like to know what your position is. Do not just scratch the surface. Come down to earth and tell us what your approaches are to each and every one of these points we have presented.

On the question of taxation, I already mentioned this to you at a control session, Mr. Rivera. There are many differences between you and me and, look, we started by agreeing a long time ago. That was prehistory. You have truly lost an extraordinary opportunity to be in the centre. You are more and more like the European far right. You are less and less like the centre, which you proclaim to defend as necessary in our country. Then you tell us that we have to go from the reds and the blues and position ourselves, if it can be done, in the orange that you defend, and therefore, we have to talk about taxes. You say that you do not want to approve taxes on large digital corporations, that you do not want to approve taxes on banks so they can finance or sustain the Social Security system. Nor are you in favour of creating a Corporate Income Tax where business conglomerates have an effective rate more or less similar to that of small- and medium-sized enterprises. Nor is that acceptable to you. The ecological taxation is not acceptable to you either. Now, yes, what is the proposal of Mr. Rivera and Ciudadanos regarding taxation? I tell you, to raise the super-reduced VAT on essential products, while the general VAT rate is dropped, for example, on luxury goods. And, of course, on Corporate Income Tax, Honourable Members, what Mr. Rivera and Ciudadanos propose is a 20% rate for small- and medium-sized enterprises and also for large corporations. That is what you say you want. Therefore, Mr. Rivera, we are more modest and we propose 15%. If you propose 20% and we 15%, I ask you to support that 15%. Support the 15%, Mr. Rivera, but do not stop supporting me because you consider that I raise taxes very little in relation to your initial proposal on large companies, Mr. Rivera.

Now, what I cannot accept is that you advocate raising the taxes of companies to 20% and then tell me that it is me that s raising taxes on large corporations and companies. In short, Mr. Rivera, it would be convenient if perhaps you read your electoral programme more carefully and hence not commit these errors to which you have been accustomed for so long now.

And in relation to the Electoral Law, I have never said that we do not want to reform the Electoral Law. Never. Where did I say no to this? The precise agreement that I had with you was to reform the Electoral Law, but it is evident that the Electoral Law will have to be reformed among all of us. What is not proper of a democratic regime, is, for example, to say we are going to put a minimum of 3%. No, that is not democratic. That is unworthy of a democratic regime, Mr. Rivera. Because what cannot be done is to silence the rights of many citizens of our country. Especially in our country.

Mr. Rivera, even Mr. Casado's proposal seems clearer to me. Since you are both here, at least propose the outlawing of all parties that do not think as you do, so you can be left alone in this democracy. But that is not what the government or the Socialist Parliamentary Group wants. Nor do I think that most of the citizens want either.

Where can we find common ground? We can find it in the amendment that I proposed at the beginning of my speech, which is that of the " voto rogado ". I believe that there is a large majority in the House as a whole, precisely to amend that legislation.

I am grateful, not for all, but for many of the questions that Mr. Tardá has raised in relation to the need to structure left-wing policies and take a turn to the left in the government's action. You have my commitment on that matter. In fact, I believe that the agenda you have laid out, that each and every one of the ministers has presented in the committees, as in I have also done in this House today, is closely related to a progressive idea of a social-democratic society.

On reconstruction, protection, and the recovery of many of the rights and freedoms lost in the field of healthcare, in the field of education, in the field of long-term care, in the field of vocational training, in the field of the recovery of labour rights and, of course, also in the field of freedoms with the repeal of the Gag Law.

On the labour reforms, Mr. Tardá, it is clear that there is not a majority in this House at present, to date, capable of totally repealing the labour reforms made by the previous government. But it is clear that there is a parliamentary majority to start dismantling a good part of those articles that have introduced precariousness, inequality and wage devaluation. I am thinking, for example, of everything to do with collective bargaining to which, for example, reference has been made by the spokesperson of the Basque Nationalist Party. Well, that is the direction in which we are heading. Even the social stakeholders themselves are telling us to move in that direction. That we look at the question of Article 42, precisely for subcontractors, that we look at ultra-activity, that we also look at everything related to the prevalence of sector agreements over company agreements. And let's look at that pact on rents that unions and business associations have signed and that we applaud.

I believe we can find common ground, Mr. Tardá on left-wing policies and ultimately, on everything that you have mentioned before in relation to pensions, to their increase, to health spending, and of course to all the policies that you have referred to in your speech, I hope that we can find there different left wing parties that share the same vision of social justice and the cohesion of our societies.

You have made reference to historical memory. This government has set up a specific Directorate General on Historical Memory, and that is not to brush over the matter, but rather to structure and to materialise many of the policies that you have referred to in your speech.

We presented, when we were in the opposition, an amendment to the Historical Memory Act, which was vetoed by the previous government, together with the Ciudadanos Parliamentary Group. We have lifted that veto. I think it is a good touchstone for us to begin to modify some of the issues of the Historical Memory Act. And also, there in the application, in the realisation of many of the things that were already on their way, which Mr. Esteban mentioned before, of the Basque Nationalist Party Parliamentary Group, which we, of course, intend to promote, to a great extent, during this time at the head of the government.

Speaking logically of the question, he tells us that we have to be audacious, that we have to have a long-term vision of how to resolve the political crisis in Catalonia. We are willing to do so, Honourable Member, Mr. Tardá. We are willing to explore a solution to this crisis with you, together with the rest of the parliamentary groups in the Regional Parliament of Catalonia.

We are very aware at present, Mr. Tardá, and in this respect I do not believe that we are wrong and that we are not deceiving anyone, that there are enormous differences. There is a huge gap between your group, the government and the Socialist Parliamentary Group, with regard to the solution to the crisis in Catalonia.

But what I can tell you, Mr. Tarda, is what I said at the beginning of my speech, the important thing is not to see what we renounce, but to see that we are willing to reach agreements for the good of the people of Catalonia and Spanish society in general.

Sure, you proposed a vote, and I also said this in the debate on the vote of no confidence. I am convinced that Catalonia, after the ruling of the Constitutional Court, has a Statute it did not vote for. It has a statute of autonomy that it did not vote for, and, consequently, the crisis in Catalonia is only going to be resolved by voting. But, Mr. Tarda, the basic discrepancy we have is that we want to vote for an agreement, and you, in our opinion, and I'm telling you this, you've heard me on many occasions say, I think what you want is to vote to break away. And in that sense, I would say that if you make any proposal, then also take into account that in the Regional Parliament of Catalonia, for things such as the modification of the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, or for example, the approval of an electoral law in Catalonia, you need, I believe, three fifths of that Parliament. At present, you do not have this to exercise that right to self-determination. Beyond mere constitutional questions, beyond mere political issues, which, of course, we also stressed in the conversations we have had with you, and also with President Torra, I told you, it is clear that Catalan society is deeply divided in relation to this matter.

Therefore, I also think it is fair to tell you that we are willing to explore political solutions in Catalonia, that we are going to be courageous, that we are going to be daring, but that, of course, we will do so within the framework of the constitution, which is the great consensus that unites us all, the whole of Catalan society, and the whole of Spanish society.

And we are very aware that this is going to take a long time, that this is a long-distance race, that there are many disagreements. Consequently, we have to start arranging meetings. To that end, we have activated the Bilateral Committees, we have outstretched the hand that you have proposed in relation to social cohesion, with progressive policies. I think this is a good starting point, and I thank you for this.

Mr. Esteban, it is true that I have answered practically all of your questions. We have been concerned, indeed, that the ultra-right is currently governing many Eastern Europe countries, and that they are questioning Schengen. It is clear we will probably have to reform Schengen due to the migration issue that we have through the secondary displacements. But it is clear, too, that we need another reform, which is that of the Common European Asylum System.

I had the opportunity to speak with the President of the Regional Government of the Basque Country, precisely, about migration. We are well aware of this, and the Inter-ministerial Committee addressed the issue with the MENA, which are under pressure in the Basque Country, and in that sense I believe we can address this together and find solutions that are appropriate for their interests.

I thank you very much for the reminder you have made about AIReF's statement on the path of stability. Also the outstretched hand offered to us in relation to the specific modifications we can make to the regulation of work and in the path marked by the social stakeholders.

And in relation to moving prisoners closer to home, I think I have been quite clear - I deserve the reproach of the People's Parliamentary Group and the Ciudadanos Parliamentary Group - but, of course, with the utmost respect for the victims and their memory, the government has decided to contribute to the normalisation, in the sense you previously commented on.

And in relation to the dialogue on the renewal of the Statute of Guernica, I believe the approach being made by the Socialist Party of Euskadi, the vision, which at least has been conveyed by the Regional Government of the Basque Country to me, I am not going to say it calms me, but I believe I feel comfortable with it. That is to say, the proposal for these to be cross-cutting agreements, which demand the renewal of the Statute of Guernica; the proposal for this not to be an agreement between one party while forgetting the other, but for this to be transcending and to overcomes these bloc dynamics. I believe this is the best contribution that the different parties present in the Regional Parliament of the Basque Country can make to the renewal of the Statute of Guernica, which, it should be remembered, is the only statute that has not been renewed in recent decades in our country.

Therefore, I believe that we must learn from the lessons of the past. I precisely believe that which we created this plurality, which the Basque Country has enjoyed between nationalists and socialists, I believe things have gone very well, really well, not just in the Basque Country but also, consequently, in the country as a whole.

To sum up, Mr. Campuzano, I have more or less answered many of the questions when responding to Mr. Tardá. Of course, I indeed think it takes audacity and courage, but we all need this audacity and courage, not only the government, but also, in this case, the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party. I think it is also important we all speak clearly to our citizens and know exactly what it is we can do and what we cannot do.

We can talk about everything, but not everything is possible. And, in that sense, when we talk and when we listen, obviously, I think we can find much in common. Of course I very much appreciate the fact that you value the activation of these Bilateral Committees. I think there is a tremendous scope to explore there. There are unconstitutionality appeals that are being reviewed by the Government of Spain, something already being done by the Minister for Territorial Policy. There are issues relating to economy and finance, which were already the subject of the meeting held by the Vice-President of the Government with the Vice President of the Regional Government of Catalonia. There are issues relating to the Mediterranean Corridor, which I think are fundamental for the Regional Government of Catalonia, and obviously, from there, I think we can start to build something that I believe we both still lack. And when I say this, I not only refer to the Government of Spain, but, to a large extent, to all the national political forces. And it is precisely by rebuilding trust and rebuilding loyalties which I think we can do, both within the framework of this Parliament and also within these Bilateral Committees. These committees that, incidentally, are included in the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, and that we recognise, and are, of course, going to activate.

You talk about fiscal policy. We agree on the necessary fiscal justice. We agree. You speak of the need to update the fiscal system to the 21st Century. We agree. There is a wide field that I also expressed in my first speech and also in the reply to other parliamentary groups. We are dealing, logically, with the request that you and other parliamentary groups have made, to the rule on spending of the local councils.

And in relation to the self-employed, it is true and you are right, that I think it's important to reflect on these people. It is true that the Minister for Work has already made some contributions to the debate, and, above all, announcements regarding this important group. I will only tell you two issues that I feel are fundamental. One, I had the honour of participating when I was an ordinary Member of this House, which is the benefit for cessation of activity of self-employed workers. There are many conditions applied to self-employed workers when it comes to receiving unemployment benefits. I think that we have to review this. And, secondly, together with the main Associations of Self-Employed Workers, we have set up a working group precisely so that Social Security contributions can be adjusted, once and for all, to the real income of self-employed workers. That is the attitude and the spirit with which we are going to address the issues of the self-employed. And of course, also in the Master Plan on the Fight against Labour Exploitation, we are going to put an end to those falsely self-employed.

There was no reason why Mr. Baldoví should have known this, but I am going to informally meet with the President of the Regional Government of Valencia, Mr. Puig, this Friday in Castellón. The issue is that we are holding the meetings here, in the Presidency of the Government with the autonomous presidents in order of seniority of approval of the Statutes of Autonomy. We are following that order so that there are no sensitivities, but consequently, even though I would have liked to meet with the President of the Regional Government of Valencia beforehand, I will, in any case, do this informally on Friday in Castellón.

I share with you the criticism made on the People's Party's questioning of Schengen. I think that, indeed, that is going against the course of history and against the interests of our country, but in short, we are on the case.

And in relation to courage, you have called for taxes on large corporations, which I agree to. Historical Memory and Franco, I agree to. Gag Law, I agree. Pensions, I agree. In short, I think we can find many issues that we can agree on.

You have commented on the issue of regional financing, which seemed insufficient to you, at least, that is what I have understood, regarding the path of stability, which we have proposed for the autonomous regions. In short, I think two tenths is quite generous given the context we are in, and, above all, with the need to clean up our public accounts and to reduce the public deficit.

But, in any case, I can tell you that the Delegate Committee for Economic Affairs has already enabled, specifically, the procedure for the autonomous regions to progressively begin to enter the progressive financial markets. In the case of those whose volume or structure of indebtedness does not permit entering the markets at this time to, as is the case of the Regional Government of Valencia, what we are going to do is start a process of restructuring to accommodate maturities to the profile of debt of the autonomous regions. But, in the end, this is a question that will be discussed by the Minister for the Treasury in the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council meeting next Thursday.

Therefore, the commitment we have with Valencia is firm, Honourable Members. Mr Baldoví, do not be in any doubt, but obviously, as I said in a control session in which you reproached me for not updating and totally renewing the regional financing system, I can tell you that this work will continue, and we do not reject the possibility of renewing this system of regional financing in the medium term, but in the meantime, what we have to do is address the financial urgencies of the regional governments, which are very different depending on which region we are referring to. And in the case of the Region of Valencia, it is evident that this has much to do with its indebtedness.

The Spokesperson for Bildu, in short, has referred to self-determination. He has made reference to issues that, are, well, the hallmark of the House to speak colloquial, and without any kind of reproach or pejorative meaning. But I will tell you two things, Honourable Members, in relation to RTVE, the Socialist Parliamentary Group, on its own initiative, and with the parliamentary support of the majority of this House, approved a draft bill that was precisely done to change the form of renewal of the Board of Directors of RTVE. For the sake of that consensus, we not only created a form of distribution that included the plural representation of this House in the Board of Directors, but we also said that we recognised the need to incorporate a public consensus to renew the Board of Directors of RTVE. We put a small safeguard clause in there for the sake of that consensus. It said that if renovation was not reached through a public consensus because it was the first time it was going to be done in the history of our democracy, obviously, before 31 December 2017, then what we would have to do was renew it using the old mechanism.

We arrived then at 31 December 2017, and for the sake of consensus, the Socialist Parliamentary Group extended the election of those members of the Board of Directors based on this consensus.

What has happened since then? What has happened since then, Honourable Members, is very clear, a parliamentary stalemate has been orchestrated by of the People's Parliamentary Group in particular, with the acquiescence of the Ciudadanos Parliamentary Group, precisely so as not to renew the Board and perpetuate the "status quo".

The dilemma that had to be addressed, and that the government had on the table, was when the term of the RTVE Board of Directors expired, it was very simple: would we let the political stalemate and the corporate stalemate be perpetrated in the public corporation? Or would we enact a royal decree, which specifically responded to the risk of a political and corporate vacuum of the management of this public corporation, and urge this House, by a way of decree, to expedite the procedures for the renewal of the Board of Directors of RTVE?

That is to say, would we let lie the renewal of the Board of Directors of RTVE, not with a political stalemate, but with a corporate blockade, that was affecting the sustainability of the public body, or would we take issue with the matter and assume our responsibility? But Honourable Members, this responsibility is shared. It is the responsibility of the government to propose solutions, but it is also the responsibility of Parliament to channel these solutions. The Royal Decree is provisional. The Royal Decree simply seeks to fill a void that, unfortunately, the People's Parliamentary Group was willing to perpetuate sine die .

I believe, Honourable Members, and this is the approach I bring to the House. I believe that with the Royal Decree we have expedited the procedures so that the Board of Directors of RTVE, by open competition, can be renewed, and, meanwhile, the only thing I ask from this House is to support the last step in this Royal Decree until the Board of Directors is renewed by this House.

And I say and I repeat what I said at the beginning of my speech; Honourable Members, of course we are grateful, and I say this publicly, to all those political groups that have supported this Royal Decree, which I believe is important for the workers and, above all, to guarantee an essential public service such as the news.

Mr. Alli tells me that I have to say publicly if I recognise the Fueros de Navarra . In short, that doubt is offensive. Of course, if I enter that game, it is akin to little less than recognising that what I have done is not recognising it. Therefore, I will not enter that game, Mr. Alli. I, of course, believe that the doubt offends and that the position of the Socialist Party of Navarra is quite clear, that the position of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party is quite clear. In that sense, we have a clear idea of what is, logically, our conception of Navarre. And you have the public statements of the General Secretary of the Socialist Party of Navarre and my own.

So, you say to me, but note the perversity of your argument, if I may say so. You say you would be willing to support the reconstruction of the national system of long-term care, the health system, repeal some of the articles that are at present the most damaging and precarious for our workers if I win the election and, consequently that I must call elections. Well, in short, I think there's no time to lose. I believe that this constitutional mechanism which is provided for in Article 13 of the Spanish Constitution on the vote of no confidence, which has to be constructive, that gives rise to a government, is perfectly legitimate, Mr. Alli.

The government will call elections, as cannot be otherwise, when it deems it appropriate and in the general interest. But of course, the important thing, Mr. Alli, meanwhile, is to respond to the urgent needs of all citizens.

The representative of Foro de Asturias makes reflections on two things in relation to infrastructures, and, also to coal. I want to convey a message of confidence, of calm, to the mining basins, to Asturian society. And of course, a true commitment that, evidently, the energy transition that needs to break through in our country also needs that veneer of social justice. And, in that sense, as I said in my first speech, the climate change law will give a comprehensive, integrated response to all these difficult realities, which are very complex. And of course, we are going to guarantee this transition is fair.

To Ms. Oramas, representing the Canary Island Coalition, I take note of the duties she has given me in relation to Brexit. I appreciate the recognition that has been made of the government's action to issues such as the 75% transportation bonus for citizens of the Canary Islands, also from the Balearic Islands, Ceuta and Melilla. There are many sector issues relating to the road agreement, to the employment plan, and so on. I am convinced that the ministers will be able to respond to this.

In short, Honourable Members, I began my first speech by saying that the purpose of this government is basically to set the time of our country, or rather the watch of politics, with the time of Spain. And I believe that is the main task that lies before us. To accompany Spanish society in a process of democratic regeneration that was opened on the basis of the vote of confidence, and which must be the object of cultivation and consolidation by the parliamentary groups. The agreements are there. Agreements on four fundamental pillars, the economy and employment, equality and social cohesion, democratic regeneration, the territorial cohesion, and, of course, European construction. This government will make this endeavour, and I also thank each and every one of you for the tone of this debate.

Thank you, Madam Speaker.

Non official translation