Intervention following the agreement at the European Council

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

21 July 2020 · European Council agreement intervention

Context
Sánchez addressed the media on 21 July 2020 after EU leaders agreed on a €750 billion recovery fund to tackle the economic fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Main themes
EU recovery fund agreement, COVID-19 pandemic response, European solidarity, Spanish economic interests, green and digital transition, historic EU fiscal policy, Marshall Plan for Europe, transfers and loans to member states, European Commission borrowing, human capital investment
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,514
93rd percentile
Sentences
206
90th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 42%42%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 17%17%
  • Geopolitical 16%16%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

206 sentences in 61 paragraphs

Good morning, everyone.

First of all, to the media, to the journalists who are with us, thank you for your patience. To the workers from Foreign Affairs, from the Economy and Finance departments, thank you for your work and also for your professionalism. Thank you, ultimately, for your commitment to Spain.

I have always said that it was imperative for Europe to reach an agreement in July. They deserved it, those of us who have lost due to this damn pandemic, for those who suffer its health consequences in hospitals and at home, for those who have lost their jobs or closed their businesses as a result of the lockdown and the very strict measures we have had to take in Spain and across Europe, and because many Spaniards and Europeans live with anxiety in these moments filled with uncertainties. For all of them, for the hundreds of millions of European compatriots to whom we owe and serve, we needed to reach an agreement in July. Europe had to reach an agreement in July, and Europe has reached an agreement in July.

It has been, as you know, a difficult, complex negotiation. A marathon that we started a few months ago, a few months that, as you know, have been extraordinarily complicated, because we have had to focus much of our effort on responding to an unprecedented health emergency in 100 years, and its final stretch, with five days of lockdown, has been exhausting and successful, as exhausting as it has been successful.

Europe faced a historic challenge and has managed to respond with an agreement in the same terms, in historic terms. This is a great agreement for Europe, a great agreement for Europe, and it is also a great agreement for Spain.

Today, there is no doubt, one of the brightest pages in the history of the European Union has been written, and as a profound European I am, allow me to convey my deep emotion for the moment we are living.

I will now detail the most relevant points of the agreement:

First of all, we have approved the creation of a large recovery fund, if you allow me to call it that, of 750 billion euros for the next six years. To give you an idea of the magnitude we are talking about, 750 billion euros represents 60% of our country's Gross Domestic Product in 2019, and 4.6% of the European Gross Domestic Product. This is the magnitude of the fund that the European Council has approved today, in historic terms. A true Marshall Plan to provide a strong response, first of all, to the COVID crisis, but also looking to the future to make the transformations we need to make if we want to be a resilient, competitive, inclusive, digital, and green economy in the coming decades.

The objective of the recovery fund is to mobilize a massive amount of European public resources, which will also lead to a corresponding mobilization of private resources, for economic recovery after the COVID crisis, and that this recovery is prompt, strong, and sustainable. And I want to pay tribute and recognize the work, first of all, of the European Commission, the work of various European governments, particularly the German government and the French government, which presented a joint package of 500 billion euros. And I also want to recognize the work and contribution to that European debate, to that push that many governments have made to make today possible, including the Spanish Government, with the proposals it presented over the past months, precisely advocating for that Marshall Plan. This recovery, based on this fund we are approving today, must be sustained on the three pillars that will allow us to grow strongly, with balance and sustainably. First, the digital transition; second, the ecological transition; and third, the education and training of our students and workers. In summary, a recovery that must be green, that must be digital; the improvement of human capital, to ensure that the European economy and, consequently, the Spanish economy, is a more competitive, inclusive, and sustainable economy.

Of the 750 billion euros of recovery from the Recovery Fund, 390 billion euros will be in the form of transfers to all EU countries, and approximately 360 billion euros will be in loans.

To mobilize all these resources in the next six years - remember, I think it is very important to emphasize again, these resources represent 4.6% of the European Gross Domestic Product, that is what will be mobilized - the European Commission will borrow for the first time in its history to finance programs. This is also unprecedented in what we are experiencing, in what has been approved today, not only the mobilization of historic resources, as I mentioned earlier, but also that the European Commission will borrow for the first time in history to finance these programs.

If anything is demonstrating this decision, it is precisely that Europe has taken a united response, a common response to a crisis, that of COVID, which affects in its triple aspect - health, economic, and also social - everyone to a greater or lesser extent.

Regarding Spain, our country has managed to obtain approximately 140 billion euros to mobilize over the next six years. To give you an idea, we are talking about 11% of Spain's Gross Domestic Product in 2019. Of those 140 billion euros, 72.7 billion euros will be in transfers. The rest will be in loans. Therefore, approximately 140 billion euros, equivalent to 11% of Spain's Gross Domestic Product in 2019, and of them, 72.7 billion euros in transfers and the rest in loans.

To give us an idea of what this will mean in historic terms for Spain, I want to recall the cohesion funds. Funds that represented a leap in modernization, in cohesion, in the competitiveness of our country in the 1990s.

If the Cohesion Fund meant for Spain the equivalent in six years of 7.8 billion euros, what we have approved today means the mobilization of almost 73 billion euros over the same period, that is, six years, almost ten times the size of those cohesion funds that meant so much for the progress and prosperity of our country.

This extraordinary boost of resources, pooled by the European Union, complements what the European budget already does in other central areas of European policy: cohesion policies, agricultural policy, which have once again demonstrated their essential, central role during the pandemic.

Regarding programs from the recovery fund, allow me to highlight the following: first, the recovery and resilience mechanism, which will have a total of 672.5 billion euros, of which 312 billion euros will be in transfers and to which Spain will be entitled to 59 billion euros.

And thanks to this program, we will be able to launch the National Reform Plan, of investments, for that green, digital, inclusive growth and transformation I referred to earlier, also channeling economic resources into science, vocational training, and education.

The Government, as you know, has already been working on this plan for several weeks, which we will take to Brussels as soon as possible for approval. This will mean, as I said earlier, a new modernization of our country following the modernization in infrastructure that those cohesion funds and structural funds from the 1990s represented.

Secondly, the REACT program of the European Union, which will amount to 47.5 billion euros, of which Spain will receive 12.4 billion euros. This new program is essential to address the economic and social consequences of the COVID crisis, and all these funds, combined with the traditional cohesion policy funds, in the new financial framework, will particularly contribute to ensuring economic growth and social and territorial cohesion in our country.

Thirdly, within the multiannual financial framework, the Common Agricultural Policy. The government, as you know, committed to providing sufficient funds to our farmers, to livestock farmers, and also to rural areas. This has been the objective, the commitment for the Government from the beginning of the negotiation. Well, I can say that we have met the target we set for ourselves. The total interventions of the Common Agricultural Policy in the form of direct aid, rural development measures, and market measures will have the same amount as in the multiannual financial framework from 2014 to 2020.

It is evident that the conditions of the political and budgetary context have been much more difficult in the negotiation of this framework that we have just given birth to in the Council, but despite this, we have achieved a deserved European support, and I would also like to emphasize this, and sufficient to face the challenges of economic, environmental, and social sustainability of our farmers and livestock farmers.

Regarding governance, there has also been quite a debate throughout this council. First, I want to remind you that this is a historic milestone, the Recovery Fund is a historic milestone, it is a new instrument created by the European Union and therefore requires a new governance. It has nothing to do with the governance of other existing instruments. Therefore, it is a historic milestone, it is a new fund and it has a new governance, where the European Commission is the central pillar of it.

We have strengthened the supervisory role of the European Council over the Recovery Fund, but most importantly, what the Spanish Government and the majority of the members of the European Council have always wanted, safeguarding the institutional balance between the Council, the Commission, and granting the role that corresponds to each. When there is a flagrant non-compliance by a country in the execution of the recovery fund, any other country may request, in a reasoned manner, a political debate within the European Council. But it will still be the Commission that has the capacity to execute that fund.

In summary, the necessary institutional balance between the European Commission and the European Council is maintained, and this is what the Spanish Government has defended throughout this debate. At this point, allow me to also emphasize the significance of the decisions we have made regarding the origin of the recovery fund. The Commission, as I mentioned earlier, will go to the markets to finance itself to obtain financial resources that will be distributed among all Member States in the form of transfers. Therefore, it is an absolutely revolutionary mechanism, the Recovery Fund, which allows us to understand the position of some countries regarding this issue.

And finally, I do not want to fail to mention the Multiannual Financial Framework, the budget for the next seven years. We have agreed that it will reach one trillion euros. Or rather, one trillion 74 billion euros.

This is a very important, very ambitious amount, especially considering the context in which we are operating and which is added to the Recovery Fund, which we have also just agreed upon.

In summary, this is a great agreement for Europe, it is a great agreement for Spain.

Today Europe lays the foundations to respond to the crisis that Europe is suffering, which is the COVID crisis, but without losing sight of tomorrow, without forgetting the changes that have accelerated and that need a prompt response from everyone: from public institutions and also from private actors. The ecological transition, the digital transition, the education of our children, and the training of workers.

Europe is starting the path towards a great change. We are at the beginning of that great change. A great step towards modernization. We are taking momentum to place Europe where it deserves to be, at the forefront of the digital transition, of the ecological transition, without leaving anyone behind and without leaving any territory behind.

Ultimately, it is an exercise of leadership and inclusion that has been carried out by the European Council and the European institutions over these months and that culminates today. This is the task to which all Europeans are called: a European leadership that, I want to emphasize, is more necessary than ever in the world today.

When we see that there are other geopolitical spaces that have difficulties in finding a swift and consistent response to this unprecedented crisis we are going through, Europe has sent a strong, forceful message to the world and has said that it is ready to face the global challenges that await us.

Today will be a day to remember among the most significant chapters in the history of the European Union. Today all Europeans win, and the European Union emerges much stronger. The challenge was extraordinary. The work has been exhausting, but the result has been worth it.

And I conclude. Great agreements have behind them many hours of work, endless hours of technical negotiation, and even also of renunciations to be with our families and also, logically, to sleep.

Spain is fortunate to have a highly qualified body of civil servants, committed and dedicated to the task of defending the legitimate interests of our country, a task they have performed and continue to perform with extraordinary brilliance and effectiveness. And to them, I want to dedicate my recognition, because this historic agreement for Europe and for Spain would not have been possible without them.

So thank you very much for your work.

And I am at your disposal to answer any questions you may have.

Q. Good morning, Mr. President, Jacobo Regoyos from Onda Cero. This money can be used for reforms; what structural reform do you think is a priority for Spain to be funded with this money? And do you believe that this agreement strengthens the rule of law in the European Union? Thank you.

President. Well, notice that one of the things I did not mention in my speech, but that we have achieved after long hours of negotiation, is that the eligibility period for incorporating into the national reform plans is February 2020. Why February 2020? Why have countries like ours wanted to include those reforms starting from February 2020? Not only because it is when the pandemic began and, consequently, when we started to articulate a response to the COVID crisis, but also because we have started to make reforms. I simply remind you that, for example, the draft Climate Change Law is one of the reforms we are going to propose and include in that National Reform Plan. For example, the Law for the Modernization of our Educational System is also a bill that is currently being processed in the Congress of Deputies, which we will incorporate into the National Reform Plan, because it aligns with many of the issues raised by the Government of Spain and also the European Commission in its specific recommendations to each of the countries, or for example, everything we are doing with temporary employment regulation files and social dialogue, linked to temporary employment regulation files, will logically also be able to, if it reaches a good conclusion, be one of the fundamental elements of that national reform plan.

Therefore, it is important to convey that we are already making these reforms and thus, for Spain, it is important to incorporate them from February.

And regarding the second question, I believe that it is a first proposal that we have made in the European Council, but there is obviously a legislative project underway and other institutions will also have to incorporate their views, in this case, the European Parliament.

Q. Thank you, Mr. President, I am Griselda Pastor, from Cadena SER. Continuing with the reforms, I would like to know if the Labor Reform, which was inherited from President Rajoy, can or cannot be reformed as a conditionality and as part of the discussions that have taken place here, and then, well, it is evident that you reached an agreement, but it took you five days and many nights; can the Union continue to function like this?

President. Well, I think today is a great day for Europe. It is a great day for Europe. We are 27 countries. We all have the right to vote, regardless of whether we have more or less population, whether we are more or less important in terms of GDP in the European Council. And I believe that this is also one of the main riches of the European Union, that we are all on the same level and that we all contribute. And it is true that we have had to give up many hours of sleep, but that effort, as I said before, has been exhausting, but in the end, the result is successful. It has been worth it. Today Europe is taking a giant step and, by the way, is responding to the crisis in a completely different way than it did ten years ago.

Today we are talking about a Recovery Fund that will mobilize 750 billion euros in total, for digital transition, for ecological transition, for worker training, for education, for the better training of our youth… In short, it is a completely different response than what was proposed ten years ago and, therefore, I want to assert that this is a great agreement for Europe and a great agreement for Spain.

And secondly, regarding the Labor Reform. Remember the following: the procedure, first, is a new instrument; this new instrument requires a new governance, a new governance that cannot break the institutional balance between the European Commission and the Council, which is what we have achieved. And then, Spain, like all member countries of the European Union, has to negotiate with the European Commission and also adhere to many of the specific recommendations made by the European Commission to the countries within the European semester. That is to say, there is nothing new, there is nothing new. And by the way, I will tell you one thing: the agenda of the European Union, if you look at what the recommendations by country were in 2019 and 2020, which are the ones that will refer to the national reform plans and also the negotiation we will have with the European Commission and its subsequent approval in the European Council, what does it talk about? It talks about digital transition, it talks about an inclusive economic policy that promotes social cohesion. It also talks about digital transition. Those are the main lines in the specific recommendations made by the European Commission to the countries, and what I have to say is that the agenda of the European Union and the agenda of Spain are in absolute sync.

Q. Yes, Mr. President. María García, from Aquí Europa. Mark Rutte has emerged as one of the great villains of this meeting. We have seen, well, we are receiving leaks of intense moments with Macron, the Bulgarian, Borisov, and even Orbán. We would like to know if you also had that clash with the Dutchman and what the tone of the negotiation was like. We have seen Conte a bit more aggressive, stronger. I don’t know if you were the good cop and Conte the bad cop of the negotiation.

President. No, not at all. On the contrary, I think that in five days of negotiation one has many papers, assumes many roles, but I believe that Spain has always wanted to have a constructive role, a role of… in the end, the only red line we had in these negotiations was not reaching an agreement. Europe could not afford not to reach an agreement. This is a great agreement for Europe, a great agreement for Spain, and certainly if Spain has done anything, it has been precisely that, to build bridges, not to fall into any kind of provocation, which often is not so much a conviction but a negotiating tactic, and in the end, to be aware that we are all part of the same club, of the same team. Each one has their perspective, their view of how Europe should be built. Of course, I, evidently, have a different view from other European colleagues, but ultimately, in the end, unity is strength, and I believe that the result is that we are going to mobilize 750 billion euros over the next six years. 390 billion euros, that is, 60% of Spain's Gross Domestic Product, to make the great transformation, the great modernization of our continent, of our common project.

We are really, really at the beginning of a new milestone, a new chapter in European construction, one of the brightest, most luminous pages in European construction. Perhaps we are not very aware of it yet because we are very close; we are just minutes away from having approved an unprecedented, historic decision, but I assure you that the mobilization of resources that will occur, the multiplication of energies that it will provoke over the next six years, to provide a positive response to this crisis and to make a great leap in modernity in Europe and in Spain, I believe will call millions of citizens towards a horizon of hope that is now more necessary than ever, because millions of Spaniards and millions of Europeans live their day-to-day lives with great anguish, not only due to the health emergency but also due to the economic and social consequences we are facing.

Q. President, you mentioned the emergency brake; in these negotiations, it has been noted that there is a certain distrust, so to speak, among the frugal countries regarding their partners when it comes to making decisions. Do you really believe that there will not be excessive use of that brake or that it will not harm Spain when it comes to making certain reforms or taking steps forward, because do you think those countries will not use it? President: Thank you very much, Patricia. Let's see, what would harm Spain and Europe is not having reached an agreement, that is the first thing. Secondly, I insist, this is the first time in the history of the European Union that the Commission is going to incur debt to finance programs. It is the first time, and let us be aware of the step we are taking, that we are taking; it is the first time in history that the European Commission is going to incur debt to finance the digital transition, to finance the ecological transition, to finance the boost to science, education, and training. That is what the European Commission is doing; it is going to incur debt, and with it, we are all going to incur debt. Because those 750 billion euros will be paid by all member states, not just the Netherlands, not just Sweden; Spain, Portugal, France, Germany, all countries will pay the debt that the European Commission will incur, contributing to the budget. This is not free. We are all going to pay for this. What do I mean by this? Well, I understand that it is a new instrument created in this new governance, so there may be countries that say, "Hey, if I am going to incur debt, let those economic resources be spent on those plans and programs for which this Recovery Fund was created."

What has been, for me, the objection I have raised to this approach? Well, not to break the institutional balance, not to degrade the position of the European Commission because it is necessary to maintain an institutional balance between the Council and the European Commission, and that is what Spain has defended. And regarding conditionality, I insist, Spain already has its agenda aligned with the agenda of the European Commission, as it could not be otherwise. Not only Spain, all member countries, because all member countries have to examine themselves, we have to present all our economic policies in what is called the European semester.

P.- Good morning, President, Jorge Valero from El Economista, two quick questions. The first, you have repeated on several occasions that the 750 billion and 500 billion in non-repayable aid were the minimum, I believe the last time was with your counterpart Costa. Why is this agreement so good then when it reduces non-repayable aid by 20%? And a second question. Your colleague Rutte has shown a lot of interest in pension reform and labor reform, I don't know if in these various meetings he has had over these days to facilitate the agreement he has inquired about the reforms that Spain was going to make in these two areas or if you have given him any hints about where it was going, for example, being cautious with labor reform or the introduction of sustainability in pensions that the Commission has also requested. President: I will tell you, I have an extraordinary relationship with the Dutch Prime Minister, he knows that we are a reformist government. He also shares that the Spanish government is a reformist government and in relation to the first question, I will tell you clearly that yes, I would have liked to have 500 billion euros in transfers. But between having 500 billion euros in transfers and 150 billion euros in transfers, plus loans, to having zero, well, there is quite a significant leap. I also said during those visits I made to some of the toughest countries regarding the conception of opening the door to transfers for the first time in the history of the European Commission, I said that I was willing to yield, because the real red line was not reaching an agreement, that is the only red line we had. We had to reach an agreement in July and Europe reached a great agreement in July that is going to benefit Europe a lot, its economy, and Spain and the peace of mind of our compatriots, because it provides certainty, because it gives hope, because there is a horizon and because it will convey a very positive message to workers and entrepreneurs in our country and on our continent. We are going to mobilize public and private resources, as had not been mobilized for decades precisely in favor of those great transitions that our country and our continent need. I believe it is a huge step. We are facing a historic step. There are many times that this term is used, but believe me, today is a historic day in the European common project. And I will tell you more, the paradoxical thing, on some occasions, is that it is true that the transfers have been cut. We have gone from 500 billion to 390 billion, as you rightly recalled, from the Commission's proposal to the final proposal of the Council that we have approved, but given that they have been maintained, they have been the main pillars where the percentages of return of each of the countries had already been established, we, well, look at that proposal of 500 billion euros and 750 billion euros, we, I think we were around 140 billion euros, 140 billion euros, as proposed by the Commission. We came out with 140 billion euros. It is paradoxical, but that is what has been achieved in Spain. The transfers have been cut in aggregate terms, but in terms of what corresponds to us as a country, we have the same proposal as the one put forward by the Commission before entering the debate and negotiation in the Council. I believe that also says a lot about the people who have negotiated on behalf of Spain this agreement.

P.- How are you? Good morning, President. Well, beyond the figures, we also want to ask you about the origin of this whole problem, the epidemiological situation in our country. I wanted to know if the government is concerned about the outbreaks we are experiencing and seeing in our country in recent days, especially the situation in Catalonia, and if in any of those areas, specifically in Catalonia, the conditions would be given, for example, to apply that partial state of alarm that the Executive said it could implement if the circumstances arose, or if the situation worsens in any of the areas of our country. And also take the opportunity, if you have been able to talk with the French president, Emmanuel Macron, about preventive measures, perhaps at the border, we have heard information aimed in this direction.

President: He hasn't said anything to me about that (Macron).

In short, of course, we continue to monitor, I would say, the evolution of the COVID crisis throughout Spanish territory. I have spoken with President Torra on more than one occasion, the Minister of Health is in daily contact not only with the Government of the Catalan Generalitat, but also with the Government of Aragon and many other governments that are experiencing outbreaks, not of the same magnitude as in Catalonia and Aragon, but we do need to continue monitoring.

And what I can guarantee you is that the Government of Spain has always maintained the same criterion, the same attitude, based on one: the fundamental thing is to defend the public health of our compatriots, the fundamental thing, and therefore we offer the utmost institutional loyalty to the regional governments, which are the ones who manage health, as you know, the utmost loyalty and maximum collaboration. We are here to lend a hand, we are here to coordinate all the work that within our competencies we have to strengthen that common objective of defending the public health of our compatriots, with the Government of the Catalan Generalitat, with its mayors, also with the Government of Aragon and with each and every one of the regional governments. We have done this since the beginning of the pandemic and we will continue to do so now that, well, we have these outbreaks that we are logically following with great attention.

P.- Thank you very much, President. From El Confidencial. Two questions.

The first, you said that Spain ultimately comes out more or less the same as the proposal to the European Commission, which now, however, due to the size of the transfers you mentioned, seems that we lose 5 billion in transfers. I imagine that this comes through credit, so in that proportion, I imagine that yes, yes we have come out losing. And another question, Spain was the first to make the initial proposal for a fund of more than one trillion euros, which I wanted to ask if you think, therefore, that this may be sufficient, especially considering the possibility of a second wave, if you think this could fall short if the situation worsens.

President: In relation to the first of the questions, indeed, we are not satisfied with transfers one hundred percent. We are at 95%. Well, but that is the negotiation. In any case, it is 140 billion euros, 72.7 billion euros in transfers.

To give you an idea, I repeat: the Cohesion Fund that did so much good for our country in terms of competitiveness and social and territorial cohesion represented just over 7.8 billion euros. Here we are multiplying that amount almost tenfold. Therefore, we are talking about unprecedented magnitudes that will require an enormous management effort. But well, I have the peace of mind that we have extraordinary public servants. We have political leadership, we have practically finalized the plans. Some of them we already have done, for example, the National Energy and Climate Plan, which you know, or the Modernization Law in Education or the Digital Agenda, which we will present shortly. Therefore, I want to say that we are clear about what the objectives are. We share them with the European Union and we have carried out and developed quite optimal work from a political and technical point of view in recent months. And in relation to the second of the issues, it is true that we proposed a mobilization of resources of 1.5 trillion euros because we indeed thought, as the European Central Bank thinks, and also the International Monetary Fund and the Government of Spain's own estimates, that the fall in Gross Domestic Product as a consequence of the confinement in these quarters has been intense enough for us to have a very intense rate of decline this year, unprecedented in Spain, as it will be in Europe, and therefore we needed to mobilize resources of the magnitude of the fall in GDP that we are going to have in Europe. To these 750 billion euros, it should be remembered that we must add the agreements of the Eurogroup, which already mobilized more than 500 billion euros.

I believe we have the foundations, the instruments to respond effectively within this uncertainty in which we operate as a consequence of the unprecedented crisis we are going through, I believe we have the instruments to provide an effective response. But I insist, we are living in a moment of enormous uncertainty and we will have to see, step by step, if these are the necessary instruments or if we will need more in the future. But this is something that, I insist, I cannot answer because no one can answer that question categorically and definitively.

Thank you very much.