Intervention of the President of the Government at the economic forum 'CREO', organized by the newspaper Cinco Días.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

20 May 2024 · CREO economic forum organized by the newspaper Cinco Días

Context
Sánchez addressed the CREO economic forum organized by Cinco Días on May 20, 2024, discussing Spain's economic progress and condemning recent far-right incidents involving Argentina's president.
Main themes
Spanish economic growth, Spain-Argentina diplomatic tensions, far-right international movement, social justice and democracy, territorial cohesion and Catalonia, employment and labor market recovery, pandemic economic response, institutional defense, economic forecasts and upgrades, financial crisis comparison
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,339
80th percentile
Sentences
116
70th percentile
Readability
37
29th percentile
Grade
15.1
76th percentile
Syntax
3.34
85th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 54%51%
  • Geopolitical 19%18%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 5%

116 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Thank you very much for inviting me to this meeting.

I would like to begin by conveying, as the President of the Government of Spain, a reflection to the Spanish citizens and also to the Argentine people. What we experienced yesterday in Madrid does not reflect what Spaniards and Argentines feel. It does not speak of the union of two peoples who, in the most difficult moments, counted on each other’s hand to rise up. It does not speak of the common roots that make us feel at home when we visit Buenos Aires or when the Argentine people visit Madrid.

Therefore, I want to say that I am fully aware that the person who spoke yesterday did not do so on behalf of the great Argentine people. In contrast, what we experienced yesterday in Madrid does speak of the risk that this far-right international movement represents for societies like ours, which base our democracy on the pillars of economic progress, social justice, and coexistence.

Spain and Argentina are two brother countries. We are two brother countries whose peoples love and respect each other. This has been my conviction since I took on the high responsibility of being the President of the Government of Spain. Obviously, among governments, affections are free, but respect is non-negotiable. That is why we have asked the current President of the Government of the Republic of Argentina for a public rectification, and accordingly, the response of the Government of Spain will be in line with the dignity that represents Spanish democracy and the bonds of brotherhood that unite Spain and Argentina, currently presided over by a president who, unfortunately, has not lived up to his statements.

On a national level, I would like to make two reflections to my fellow citizens. The first relates to defending Spanish institutions from insults and defamations that may be made by foreign leaders; this does not allow for exceptions, because beyond ideology, there are education and patriotism. The second is that what we saw yesterday, also from Mr. Abascal, was an explicit appeal to political violence. To say that a legitimate government should be kicked out is anti-democratic and demands a resounding condemnation from all political forces, all media, and the entirety of society.

In short, I also want to thank, as it could not be otherwise, from the beginning of my speech, all the entities and companies that have made this event possible, and particularly the team of Cinco Días with its director, Amanda Mars, at the helm.

I would also like to start this intervention by recalling a cover or, better said, a news item from the newspaper Cinco Días dated January 22, 2018. It stated: Spain will be the only one among the major world economies to suffer a downward revision in its economic growth forecast by the International Monetary Fund. And the reason for that cut was clear; it was the situation that, unfortunately, was being experienced at that time in an important territory for our country, which is Catalonia.

Six years have passed since then, and today the Spanish economy does not suffer downward forecasts due to territorial conflict. The opposite is true. We have seen how the Bank of Spain, the OECD, and the International Monetary Fund have revised their economic growth forecasts for our country upwards. The latest to do so has been the European Commission, with an upward revision of 0.4%.

This same newspaper, Cinco Días, included the following headline in its edition last Thursday: Moody's, the rating agency, believes that the decline of independence movements in the Catalan elections reduces risks for the Spanish economy. Therefore, the conclusion is clear: today Spain is more united and more prosperous than in 2018, and this is a national success, of which I am convinced the majority of Spaniards are proud.

Six years ago, Spain was facing a triple economic, social, and territorial crisis. Obviously, in the economic sphere, we were still suffering the consequences of what, in my opinion, was an incorrect response to the financial crisis, an anti-social response that made us lose a huge amount of time, resources, and also expectations for many generations. This contrasts with the response we have given with solidarity and effectiveness to such disruptive and potentially devastating blows as the pandemic or the current wars, both in Ukraine and in the Middle East.

The data is there. In the last financial crisis, it took us 12 years—it's quick to say, 12 years—to recover the previous levels of employment, a decade to recover the previous levels of GDP, and it has taken just 18 months to recover all the jobs lost as a result of the pandemic and the response we had to give due to the confinement of our economy.

The relevant thing is that now we have not only limited ourselves to recovering lost ground. Today we have 3 million more affiliates than in 2018, almost 1.7 million more than we had in January 2020, just before the pandemic. On May 15, we surpassed the figure of 21 million 300,000 contributors to Social Security, and the OECD has just confirmed that we have surpassed the level of purchasing power prior to the pandemic, with growth rates higher than those of the major economies of France, Italy, and Germany.

Moreover, the economic growth forecasts for Spain in 2024 and 2025 are well known; they are significantly higher than those of the other major economies in the eurozone.

That is what we found in 2018. This is the current situation of the economy. In 2018, we also faced a significant social crisis. In that 2018, we encountered a deep wound in terms of inequality, a wound caused by three counter-reforms, in my opinion: the first, labor; the second, education; and the third, pensions. Imposed and not agreed upon with social agents or the teaching community, which led to a high level of labor and social conflict.

The effects were particularly damaging. The paradigm of precariousness and wage devaluation was imposed. I still remember the words of the then Minister of Economy, Luis de Guindos, saying that they were going to approve a highly aggressive labor counter-reform regarding the rights of workers. In short, the paradigm of precariousness and wage devaluation was imposed, as I mentioned earlier, especially affecting young people and all that it represents. In short, instability of income, job insecurity, and risk of social exclusion.

To each counter-reform, we responded over the last six years with agreements, with negotiated reforms: the labor reform, the pension reform, and the educational reform. Not only with the social groups that represent this significant percentage of the population of our country but also with community institutions, with the European Commission.

And I believe the fruits of the agreement are visible, as are the figures of Spain in 2024 compared to 2018 in terms of inequality. Today, the average pension in our country is 34% higher than in 2018. The minimum interprofessional wage is 54% higher. The school dropout rate has fallen by four points to 11%, the temporary employment rate is 12 points lower, and investment in R&D almost doubles in 2024 the allocation we had in 2018.

These are data, facts that we have achieved without compromising, by the way, the stability of public accounts. On the contrary, this unprecedented effort we are making is absolutely compatible with the path of fiscal consolidation that guarantees the reduction of public debt, public deficit, and consequently, compliance with the objectives set with the European Union.

And finally, in that 2018, we had to face a tremendous territorial crisis, a huge constitutional crisis, and today we can say with all certainty that we were right; that we were right those of us who defended that in democracy, forgiveness is more powerful than resentment, coexistence is more powerful than confrontation, and unity is more powerful than division. We were right those who thought that the unity of Spain is not built by confronting or threatening, but by building a common project of social advancement whose pillars are those: economic progress, social justice, and coexistence. And we are right those who believe that, in politics as in life, problems are solved head-on, without avoiding them, without chronicling them, and, much less, without exacerbating them, as happened in a not-so-distant past.

The fruits of that bet, in terms of social peace and stability, are more than evident, and you know better than anyone what that represents in economic terms. And I believe that this is also behind the reason why Spain is advancing right now; why Spain is your model of success if we look at it in the European context and also in the international geopolitical context, not only in the economic sphere but also in the territorial and social spheres. And I insist, this model of success has been written by many hands in recent years. The Government has logically done its part, but so have employers, trade unions, and civil society as a whole.

Consequently, we have favorable economic and employment data; with good data on the evolution of inflation and public deficit; coexistence and understanding are gaining ground in Catalonia, and therefore, the catastrophism of an opposition, unfortunately increasingly far-right, is the greatest of its lies. Because far from the catastrophic discourse we have heard over the last few years that "Spain is breaking," that "Spain is sinking," what we see today is that Spain is more united than in 2018 and is creating more jobs and growing more robustly and has more social justice than when we came to power in 2018.

Just three data points to reinforce this argument. Four out of ten new jobs in the European Union are created in our country; four out of ten. Compared to 2018, the volume of employment in the field of scientific, technical, and IT activities has grown by 50%. The second point is that we attract more foreign direct investment; we are the 4th country in the global ranking for the volume of greenfield project attraction between 2018 and 2024. And thirdly, we are expanding our export capacity with more companies—more and more small and medium-sized enterprises—opening foreign markets and promoting Brand Spain. Additionally, in 2023, we exported goods worth over 383 billion euros, thus closing the second-best year in the historical series.

Behind these figures, what do I see? Well, there are great agreements, there are great agreements like, for example, the labor reform, which explains why today the affiliation of those under 30, which has always been one of the pending subjects of our labor market, has grown by 11.4%; that we have almost 3.5 million more workers than in January 2022 with a permanent contract and half a million more than last year at the same time.

I could mention many others, such as the progressive increase of the Minimum Interprofessional Wage in the last six years, to which I have previously referred; the aid we have implemented during all these years since, unfortunately, the invasion of Putin in Ukraine began; or also an important innovation in public policies related to redistribution, the fight against social exclusion, and also the reintegration of those excluded from our labor market, such as the Minimum Vital Income.

All these, in my opinion, are brave decisions, courageous decisions that have allowed Spain to be the second country in the OECD, that is, among the main developed economies in the world, where real per capita income of households grew the most in 2023, and that we have recovered after 16 years—it's quick to say, 16 years—the levels of income prior to the financial crisis.

Decisions and structural reforms that we have also agreed upon with the European Commission, such as the Business Creation and Growth Law, which is one of the main pending subjects of our economy so that companies can scale up and export much more. Reforms like the Vocational Training Law, all the momentum we are giving to R&D+i, reforms, in short, that are contributing for the first time in almost three decades in our country—since 1995, I believe I remember that it had not happened—to a simultaneous growth of employment and productivity.

But there is one factor that, in my opinion, explains the great performance of the Spanish economy, and that is undoubtedly the impact that the Recovery, Transformation, and Resilience Plan, that is, the European funds—so we can understand colloquially—are having on our economy.

This is a bet that represents a radical challenge to the way in which the European Union faced the crisis of 2008. It can be said that Europe learned from its mistakes, and I had the opportunity, by the way, to negotiate with Chancellor Merkel at that time, the European funds, the requirements that would also be posed to access those European funds. And I can attest that Europe and those who led the response to the financial crisis learned from the mistakes that occurred then and that, logically, materialized in the formation of those European funds, the mutualization of public debt at the European level, and everything related to the reform agenda.

I also believe it is important to say that Spain fought for a solidarity-based solution to that crisis. But above all, we fought for Europe, unlike what happened in 2008, to be true to itself and its values. And the difference lies between the increase in unemployment and public debt and the collapse of private consumption that followed those neoliberal recipes, which led us to an extraordinarily severe depression, in economic and social terms, in Europe.

The excellent results that the deployment of the Recovery, Transformation and Resilience Plan is already delivering; or, for example, the 12 strategic projects with the acronym PERTE in strategic sectors that combine the capacity to drive economic growth, also job creation and improvement of the present and future competitiveness of our economy. By the way, with public-private collaboration as a great lever not only to recover economically from this crisis but also to transform the country in a completely determined manner.

Look, the 160 billion euros allocated to Spain for the period 2021-2026 are allowing us to modernize our productive fabric to address two unavoidable challenges such as the ecological transition and the digital transformation of our economy, while we are, consequently, reforming other aspects of our productive fabric and gaining competitiveness.

They are allowing us to close existing gaps, advance in the development of digital skills, especially to reinforce what we have called territorial cohesion; that is, in rural areas to provide opportunities and ensure equality of opportunities in our country, where through the Recovery Plan we have already trained more than 150,000 women, to give one example, in digital skills and connectivity; in rural areas, I mean.

We are leaders in Europe in the deployment of fiber networks, we are leading the deployment of 5G technology across Europe, we are improving our security through a law, which is the Cybersecurity Law and the National Security Scheme for 5G networks, responding to cyber threats, placing ourselves at the forefront of technologies such as artificial intelligence or undertaking the digital transformation of the public sector and businesses.

All of this, I believe, offers us an extraordinary opportunity to tackle one of the pending issues in Spain and Europe, which is the reindustrialization of our continent and our country. Reindustrializing, moreover, in territories unjustly ignored in the past. I think, for example, of Extremadura, but not only that, also of Andalusia. Areas that have unfortunately suffered the stigma of decline, of depopulation caused by the lack of opportunities in rural areas.

They logically help us to advance in the energy transition, specifically in objectives such as the decarbonization of industry, the promotion of electric vehicles, you know that we are one of the main European powers in automobile manufacturing and also, logically, in everything related to the connection of that electric vehicle, or positioning ourselves as one of those major European references in green hydrogen and renewable generation.

In short, in six years our country has gone from 13% to 23.6% of the solar energy produced by the five largest economies in the European Union. And that is not a matter of chance. It is logically the result of the collaboration and commitment of the private sector and also of a Government that has clearly bet on and seen in the Green Transition a great opportunity to reindustrialize our country and also to protect the average household in our country against rising energy prices, as we have experienced, by the way, not long ago as a consequence of the invasion of Ukraine.

In short, a successful model admired by many, which identifies our country with a society that looks to the future with ambition, with optimism, without fear, with stronger foundations to grow and to seize the opportunities that this dual transition, both digital and ecological, can bring us. And with an unprecedented commitment to the training of human capital as its main asset.

Ladies and gentlemen, I have described to you a successful model that I believe is not the property of an executive, but rather the property of the entire Spanish society. A society that has faced extraordinary challenges, first the pandemic and now two wars in Ukraine and the Middle East.

You know this, and the media have also been participants in this success. But I would be lying if I did not warn of the risks that threaten both the Spanish model and the European social model.

Earlier, the moderator referred to it, a European social model, which I believe is responsible for an unprecedented era of peace, democracy, and prosperity on our continent.

Out there, unfortunately, there are leaders willing to channel despair, fear, and disenchantment, with authoritarian discourses. We heard them just a few hours ago right here in Madrid, denying the very essence of social justice, labeling it as an aberration.

A concept, that of social justice, which, although it is true that from progressive options we have always championed, is not only the property of the European and Spanish political left, but is shared by institutions, such as the Catholic Church, or that were embraced by the major political families when building Europe.

A few days ago, thirty major German consortia decided to take a stand and mobilize to stop the vote for the far-right and the rhetoric of extremist and racist formations. I believe this was a brave decision, commensurate with the significant challenges our continent is facing at this decisive time.

Months ago, at the World Economic Forum in Davos, I personally asked the business world to step forward in defense of democracy and the humanist values that have helped forge and build the best Europe. This Europe, which is at the same time the best thing that has happened to our country throughout our history.

And today I reiterate that request: let us defend our democracy, our welfare model, the social justice that embodies that social and market economy that is Europe. Let us defend a successful model like our country against the regression of reactionaries.

And I want to conclude with some words full of wisdom on this matter. As the president of the Economic and Social Council and one of the great economists of our country, at least for me, one of the most insightful, Antón Costas, states. I quote him verbatim: "In the era of radical uncertainty that we have to live in, when many of the old certainties seem to have dissolved, social dialogue and the search for agreement are more necessary than ever."

I share this conviction and, like him, I believe that dialogue and coexistence are essential requirements for stability, economic development, and the progress of societies. I assure you that this is the spirit that has always motivated me and that will continue to drive the actions of the Government of Spain.

Once again, thank you very much for the invitation and thank you all.