"It is the hour of truth: progressive government or more blockage."

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

30 September 2019

Context
Sánchez gave a press interview in September 2019 addressing Spain's political deadlock and the upcoming repeat general election on November 10.
Main themes
Government formation deadlock, Spanish political crisis, progressive coalition negotiations, PSOE electoral strategy, Podemos coalition rejection, November 10 elections, stable government, political party relations, climate emergency, social inequality, Spain's European role
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,768
72nd percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
57
80th percentile
Grade
9.2
12th percentile
Syntax
2.69
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 76%69%
  • Geopolitical 9%8%
  • Social 9%8%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

180 sentences in 49 paragraphs

Question. What responsibility for the electoral repetition corresponds to the PSOE?

Answer. A blockage has occurred that has prevented the winning party from forming a government. Everyone remembers what the national and international media said on the night of April 28: victory for the PSOE. It was very emphatic. To the point that between the second and third parties, they had the same number of seats as the socialists. I believe it is no longer a time for reproaches or continuing the exchange of accusations. What matters is to look forward and decide whether Spain can remain blocked or if it finally has a stable and coherent government. It is that simple.

Q. Did the PSOE want to go to new elections?

A. It would be absurd for the party that wins the elections to bet on a repeat election. We tried to form a government. It is true that we had a limit: a government for a couple of months would not suffice, a government that would get through the investiture and then fall apart shortly after was not enough. We wanted to form a government for a legislative term, a stable and coherent government, a government to govern and face the challenges we have as a country. Unfortunately, it was not possible. We all know what happened: we remain in a blockage. And now we must decide whether to continue prolonging the blockage or to get to work and respond to the great challenges we have as a country. I am referring to the challenge of climate emergency, I am referring to the challenge of technological revolution; to the challenge of women's equality; to the fight against social inequality. And also, to the challenge of placing a cohesive Spain at the forefront of Europe.

Q. You have stated that you "would not sleep at night" if Podemos were in the Government. Was it a mistake, then, to propose the coalition?

A. Allow me to clarify. I said that if I had yielded to what Unidas Podemos demanded, neither I nor 95% of Spaniards would sleep at night. It is a colloquial way of saying that their demands were incompatible with the coherent and stable government that Spain needs, in my opinion. I did not yield to their claim to manage certain departments for which they were not qualified, and I did not yield to their demand to form a kind of double government that would have been doomed to failure from the start. I reached the limit of flexibility that I considered compatible with a coherent government.

Q. If Podemos had accepted it in July, would we have a government "at any price" today?

A. As I have told you, I took flexibility to the limit that I believed was compatible with Spain's need for a coherent and stable government. Going further would have meant disregarding my convictions.

Q. Is your relationship with Iglesias as bad as it seems? And with Rivera and Casado?

A. I strive to maintain correct relations with the three leaders you mention. And also with others who represent smaller parties but deserve equal respect. It is my duty because education and respect are essential in coexistence. I try not to resort to disqualification or insult. I try to attend the meetings proposed to me. Beyond good manners and the personal sympathy that each leader may evoke in me, I believe they represent many thousands of Spaniards who voted for them, and I must behave as their president, not as the head of a faction. In any case, it is not worth losing time lamenting a victory that others squandered; nor does it serve any purpose to indulge in reproaches towards those who prevented it. We must not look back or sideways. We must look ahead because Spain needs answers, and it needs them now.

Q. Surely the votes of Podemos will be necessary after November 10, given that the PSOE will not achieve an absolute majority. Is it possible to redirect this bad relationship? Would the coalition be recovered if Iglesias joins?

A. The electoral repetition has caused discontent among many people, including us who had won, although it seems that some conservative parties were pleased to have another opportunity. But it is true that the upcoming elections are taking place under different conditions than those of April 28. To begin with, there are more electoral offers. But also, citizens have more information. And the most important thing they know is that if they want a progressive government, there is only one ballot that guarantees it, that of the PSOE. If they want to continue with the blockage, they have options to choose from. But if they want a government, it is advisable to vote for a government. Therefore, if the information is greater and the competitors are different, the result can be different. And we want support for a progressive government to be broader so that there is no blockage.

Q. The balance of power after November 10 may be similar, seat by seat; would we be doomed again to blockage if the coalition is refused and dialogue with Rivera is not possible?

A. I do not consider a new blockage even as a working hypothesis. First of all, I want to point out that what Spaniards vote for are parties, not blocks. It is the parties that can behave in a blocking manner, not the citizens. That does not correspond to the reality of our country. There are many people who consistently maintain their vote for one party, but there are people who change their preference. Otherwise, there would be no need for periodic elections. Moreover, I have always defended the importance of transversal agreements on matters of national interest. Why can't we agree on state matters with parties of different orientations?

Q. Did the PP suggest at any time that you abstain to avoid blocking the government?

A. Unfortunately, I did not find any collaboration of that kind to prevent the vote of the independents from being decisive.

Q. Is understanding with Rivera impossible while he is at the head of Ciudadanos?

A. That is not a question I can answer. Everyone knows that I have called the main leaders to discuss the possibilities of forming a government, and Mr. Rivera has been the only one who has repeatedly rejected contact. He has only shown interest at the last minute and only for the preventive application of Article 155 in Catalonia, ignoring the guidelines established in the rulings of the Constitutional Court. I overlook the labels he uses against us. But, evidently, under those conditions, understanding is impossible.

Q. The same four leaders, projects, and programs are presented on November 10. Why should Spaniards vote for something different?

A. As I told you before, citizens have much more information. For example, they know that Cs has formed a block with the far-right throughout Spain and has put a sanitary cordon around the PSOE, which is a rarity among European liberals. They know that UP has again prevented the formation of a progressive government, which is also exceptional in Europe. And they know that we are facing a dilemma: either a progressive government is formed or we continue in blockage. And the problems of our country, the threats of a hard Brexit, economic cooling, or the resurgence of the Catalan crisis as a result of the 'procés' trial, will not evaporate. Spaniards can draw their own conclusions.

Q. What impact can Íñigo Errejón's emergence in the national arena have for the PSOE? The division of the right favored the PSOE on April 28; would three parties on the left compromise its position?

A. It is a phenomenon that I observe with respect and distance because I do not usually meddle in the internal affairs of other political forces. I believe that a recomposition is taking place within the space that was Podemos five years ago, and now there is a dispute between two vectors led by the two founders to impose one orientation or another on that space. You will find no reproach from our side. We will run an open and positive campaign. However, I insist that we will see the post-electoral scenario starting the night of November 10, and until then, the PSOE will focus on explaining the progressive program it has for Spain, in order to obtain a sufficient majority to provide stability to our country.

Q. In the PSOE, they assume that the campaign will be difficult and that they will have to educate the electorate. Are you afraid of a strong demobilization?

A. Absolutely not. Sometimes they ask what is particular about these elections on November 10. Well, we are seeing that there are more and more electoral offers. That is the first difference. And the curious thing is that, the more that present themselves, the more evident something becomes: there is only one option that guarantees a progressive government; there is only one option that can break the blockage and guarantee stability and security. Moving towards the future. Only one. Everyone knows it, although many do not want to talk about it. On November 11, there will be a socialist government or we will remain in blockage. The time for truth has come: either a progressive government or more blockage. I think that is a very strong argument.

Q. Are changes expected in the electoral lists?

A. The electoral lists will, in substance, be the same as in April.

Q. If after November 10 the PSOE cannot renew the government, would you consider assuming responsibilities?

A. I assume responsibilities all the time. In April, we were the most voted party. We had the same number of seats as the second and third parties combined. The second had the worst results in its history; the third failed in its "sorpasso" bet; and UP lost 40% of its representation. And yet, it was not possible to form a government.

Q. The old politics will prevail over the new in these elections. Do you miss bipartisanship?

A. Everyone has the right to present themselves because the decision is made by the citizens, not by those of us who present ourselves. The votes belong to them, and the decision is theirs. We are a very veteran party, although we were the most voted by young people. We have seen many parties born and disappear. I do not need to remind you of all the acronyms that were born and went the same way they came: to nothing.

What concerns me is the governability of Spain. My only nostalgia is for the social turn and the stability that all Spaniards demand. Political parties have a dual function in democracies: they serve to channel popular will and, at the same time, are a fundamental instrument for political participation, that is, for forming governments. I want as many parties as Spaniards want, but I want a stable and coherent government. A government is not an assembly of people who meet once a week. It is a team that must take the reins of the country and make important decisions. And for that, it must have a clear orientation.

Q. You took the transfer of Franco's remains to the UN, but in Spain, you are accused of stirring up history.

A. It is a decision made by Congress. The dignity of our democracy demanded it. There is no democratic country that pays tribute to a dictator: this was understood, in addition to the UN, by the Legislative, the Executive, and the Supreme Court. The three democratic powers of our country.

Q. The ruling of the 'procés' trial will cause a disruption in the electoral campaign.

A. We will overcome that crisis. I have no doubt about it. And in fact, we are already seeing how the number of followers of the independentist postulates has decreased, and we also see how more and more people in that sector are understanding that the unilateral breach of the law only produces pain and frustration. The independentist leaders are aware of their failure and recognize it in private. They said they would not return to the Spanish Parliament, and there they are, they have put themselves first in line to run for elections. Now even the most radical, who had never presented themselves before, want to come to the Spanish Parliament.

The independentists know they have failed. They are aware of their defeat. They are increasingly alone, completely isolated in the world and divided. But as their desperation increases, we should not rule out new moments of tension. That is why I believe that leaders should have the courage to explain the truth to their followers. It is an open secret because they have even declared it before the courts: they deceived them. They led them into a dead end. They must acknowledge that they have economically regressed Catalonia; they have fractured it socially; and they have only produced misfortune and pain both inside and outside their own ranks. As long as they do not tell them this, they will only produce more and more pain. And they may even lead some unsuspecting followers down more dangerous paths. That is to say: cause more pain both inside and outside their ranks.

Q. Is it possible to turn back?

A. Their mistake has been gigantic. But they still have time to avoid even worse mistakes. They must stop inflaming the more impulsive young people whom they have deceived and who believed in their words. They must distance themselves and condemn any form of violence. They must respect the actions of judges and security forces. Spain is a full democracy; in Spain, there are no political prisoners. There are citizens prosecuted by independent courts that apply democratically approved laws. And they are also held in prisons managed by the Generalitat and guarded by officials of the Generalitat.

Q. How will you address the reaction to the 'procés' ruling from the Government?

R. Whatever its content, the ruling will demonstrate that there is a separation of powers in Spain and that the trial has been conducted with all guarantees. The Socialist Party will defend the democratic Constitution without hesitation. We will defend the independent action of the judges without wavering. We will defend the actions of the regional and state security forces to ensure the safety and freedoms of all Catalans and all Spaniards. And, in particular, we will defend the presence and actions of the Civil Guard. That is one more reason why Spain needs a progressive and stable government. Progressive to avoid escalating the conflict and to overcome it through dialogue. And stable to firmly and without fanfare guarantee the rule of democratic laws.

P. Would you apply Article 155 if the Generalitat returns to disobedience?

R. Our party does not boast of constitutionality nor does it distribute certificates of constitutionality; but it is deeply identified with the democratic values of the Constitution. We love the Constitution and that is why we do not want to appropriate it and wish to share it with everyone. We will defend the democratic Constitution without hesitation, as I have said.

P. Are you in favor of elections in Catalonia?

R. Catalonia has been in a state of absolute paralysis for too long. It is being governed with the extension of the budgets approved in 2017, which is a true nonsense. The Government of the Generalitat is lost in the same delusions that led us to conflict. And Ciudadanos, the party that won the elections there, has done nothing but complain and call for the perpetual application of Article 155.

P. Will the axis of the electoral discussion be left-right or will it be constitutionality?

R. The axis of the electoral discussion in Catalonia should be decided by the Catalan parties, and as far as the socialists are concerned, by the PSC. But I believe there is little doubt about what Catalonia needs at this moment: coexistence and a progressive and stable government that cares about the needs of the citizens. We need to talk about employment, healthcare, education, housing, transportation... This should be the focus of the discussion.

P. Do you already have a new government in mind?

R. The government I formed in June 2018, besides being the Executive with the most women in all of Europe, is made up of highly respected professionals from the party and civil society who have performed magnificently during just fifteen months. Everything in its time. First, we must listen to the Spaniards.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of La Razón.