Joint press conference of the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, and the President of the French Republic, Emmanuel Macron, following the joint signing of two declarations on migration and Economic and Monetary Union.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

26 July 2018 · Palacio de La Moncloa, Spain

Context
Sánchez held a joint press conference with French President Macron at the Palacio de La Moncloa following the signing of bilateral declarations on migration and Economic and Monetary Union.
Main themes
Spain-France bilateral relations, European migration policy, Economic and Monetary Union reform, Banking Union completion, Eurozone budget, European Monetary Stability Mechanism, cooperation with migration origin countries, dignified employment in Spain, joint declarations signing, Active Population Survey employment data
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,617
93rd percentile
Sentences
189
88th percentile
Readability
40
37th percentile
Grade
14.8
74th percentile
Syntax
3.32
84th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

189 sentences in 62 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. First of all, I would like to apologize for the delay, but what is important is that I have had a meeting with the President of the French Republic, and I would like to first thank the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron, for his visit to the Palacio de La Moncloa on this first official visit to Spain.

Mr. President, before anything else, I would like to make a very special mention of a very important matter, and that is to congratulate France, the French society, and of course, also the President of the Republic for the victory in the World Cup in Russia. Congratulations, Mr. President, congratulations also to all the French people. You have one star advantage on your jersey, at least until 2022, and we will take care of tying it up again.

But, in any case, for Spain, dear Mr. President of the Republic, friends, France is a neighboring country, a partner country, and a friendly country, with which we share deep ties both politically and culturally, as well as socially and historically. We are also united by values, values and principles with which we build our societies, the French society, the Spanish society, and also the European society. And regarding the Union and the challenges that Europe faces, we have spoken during this short period of time that we have had, but we have been talking since we took on our responsibilities as leaders.

We have approved --and in this I would also like to thank all the teams, both from the Government of Spain and the French Government-- various declarations that I would like to share with the media, at least the headlines.

The first of the declarations that we will approve in this meeting between both Governments is on immigration. We both agree that this challenge is a global challenge, a challenge that affects the entire European Union and that, consequently, requires European responses based on solidarity and also on responsibility.

In the declaration, you will see that the three essential principles of migration policy, at least as we understand it in these two Governments, are based, first of all, on something very important, which is cooperation for development, on the need to stabilize socially, politically, and economically in the countries of origin. Secondly, the protection of borders with respect --and this is very important-- to the dignity and human rights of migrants, and finally, strengthening cooperation with the countries of origin and also with the transit countries.

The second declaration is the agreement we have between both Governments to advance in the Economic and Monetary Union. The objective behind all the measures that you already know and that have been announced repeatedly, such as, for example, the completion of the Banking Union, the implementation of the Eurozone budget, which is a true obsession of the President of the French Republic and which I share, of course, with him; and the creation of the European Stability Mechanism. In short, all these objectives serve a common purpose, which is to equip the French, Spanish, and the entire European society with useful, efficient, and equitable mechanisms to respond to future economic crises and future financial crises. Both Spain and France give the highest political priority to this issue --and I would like to emphasize this again-- we give the highest political priority to the construction and completion of the Economic and Monetary Union.

In the case of Spain, the experience of the crisis serves as a stimulus to move forward firmly in this area, and I would also like to emphasize doing so today. Today, precisely, the data from the Active Population Survey has been released, which shows very positive employment growth figures, such as the increase in employment by almost 470,000 people, and in this sense, I want to reaffirm our commitment, the commitment of the Government of Spain, to consolidate job creation, to ensure that this employment is dignified; to consolidate economic growth and, of course, also to redistribute wealth to the middle and working classes of Spanish society. The data from the EPA, however, cannot divert us from the goal of improving the quality of employment, which you know is one of the main objectives of this Government, and in that sense, I would also like to announce that tomorrow in the Council of Ministers we will approve a Master Plan for Dignified Employment for the next two years; that is, a plan -as I announced to you-- to combat labor exploitation and promote dignified employment in our country.

But, returning to Europe, it is now and not when we face cycles of recession or less favorable economic cycles, I say, it is now the time to decisively advance in the mechanisms that strengthen the architecture of the Economic and Monetary Union. And, on this matter, I would also like to make a brief stop, which I also made with President Macron in the short meeting we had, but which I think is important because yesterday we also saw a meeting of the President of the European Commission with the President of the United States, Donald Trump, and, in this sense, the position of the Government of Spain regarding international trade is clear.

We defend multilateralism, we do not want unilateralism. We defend, ultimately, that we must dialogue, that we must negotiate with our partner, in this case, the United States, but --of course-- what we do ask the U.S. Administration is the withdrawal of tariffs and, above all, and very especially, that the common agricultural policy, which is also fundamental for the economy and for Spanish society, is safeguarded.

Therefore, migration, Economic and Monetary Union and, within this declaration, I think it is also very important to pause on something that we have incorporated into the debate on the Economic and Monetary Union, and that is the need to build or continue building a social pillar, in particular, everything related to social cohesion and the improvement of labor rights for workers across the European continent.

Also today, one of the declarations that will be approved is the important commitment we have achieved in advancing the Europe of defense. Spain, as you know, particularly values the European intervention initiative or strategic commitment initiative promoted by the French Government. Common defense through NATO is perfectly compatible with the European efforts we can make in terms of Defense and Security. And on this issue, the President of the Republic and I have also spoken.

And to conclude, this is not a European issue but it is a matter of --well, it is European but, above all, it is a matter of bilateral cooperation-- and I would also like to emphasize this in this meeting before the media. Today, the delivery of the so-called ETA stamps is officially taking place. These are thousands of documents, effects, and weapons seized by the French police over the last 20 years of ETA. They will contribute to the National Court clarifying some of the crimes perpetrated by the band, and in this sense, Mr. President, dear Emmanuel, Spain will never forget the cooperation between our two countries that was decisive in winning the battle that caused so much harm to our country. But also in France, because it was the scene of the last deadly attack by the terrorist group in March 2010 with the death --which we felt in Spain personally-- of a member of the French Gendarmerie. On October 1st, and this is what I also want to announce to the media, there will be a solemn ceremony for the delivery of all the seized material in which the memory of the victims of ETA will be very present, of course.

Spain felt the closeness, dear President of France, in those times, and France has been able to feel closely the breath and support of Spain every time the threat of jihadist terrorism has struck hard on French territory. That, dear President, is also advancing in the European project from empathy, feeling as our own the pain caused in Paris or Nice by jihadist terrorism. The cooperation and friendship between our countries is the best guarantee on which to continue advancing in an even greater endeavor, which is to strengthen that common project that is the European construction project to face --as I said at the beginning of my speech-- the common challenges we have, whether they are economic, migratory, or of any other kind.

So, welcome to Madrid, welcome to Spain, welcome President of the French Republic.

Mr. Macron.- Thank you very much, thank you very much, Mr. President of the Spanish Government, dear Pedro Sánchez, for these words. Thank you also for your courtesy in apologizing for a delay for which I am the only one responsible. Between our two countries are the Pyrenees, and I was there, in those beautiful mountains, and that is why I was delayed a bit.

I apologize for that delay, and the President of the Spanish Government has nothing to do with this. Thank you very much for the warm welcome of this visit, for what is, indeed, the first trip I make to Spain as President of the Republic after your visit to Paris last June for our first bilateral exchange. Since then, in the European Councils, through telephone exchanges, we have often been able to continue our dialogue and make progress on many issues.

As you mentioned, the relationship between our two countries is strong, it is historical, but it has also been forged or reinforced every time there has been a crisis or common struggles, and I thank you for the kind words you had about the history of the last decades and the cooperation between our two countries. The issue of ETA and the delivery of these stamps is normal, and it was our commitment, and Spain has always been by our side when France has been attacked by other terrorism, and I refer, in particular, to jihadist terrorism. France has also always been there every time you have suffered political crises in your country because I believe that is what unites us. This relationship, this common bond, is rooted in the rule of law, in constitutional order, in what has shaped our contemporary history of our two countries and constitutes the very heart of the values that underpin Europe. The President of the Government has recalled the two main issues of our dialogue and also of the work we have been doing from our respective Governments in recent weeks, and I will start, indeed, with the migration issue.

We have addressed the migration issue many times, at length, in the last European Council. It is the subject of a political crisis in Europe of which everyone will have been able to follow the evolution, the different stages --so to speak-- in recent months, and in this context, I want to emphasize how exemplary the cooperation between our two countries is, whether at our common border or, more recently, in the reception, for example, in Valencia, of the migrants who were aboard the "Aquarius." Spain has favorably accepted our offer: a mission from Ofpra that has allowed the identification of seventy-eight people who are seeking asylum and who arrived in France on July 12. An effective, humane, joint European cooperation. In Malta, nine member states in total participated in the reception of the people seeking asylum who a few weeks later would be on the "Lifeline." Our two countries have once again been together to cooperate with our Maltese partners. This is the philosophy we have for the migration issue. Only cooperative solutions are a humane and effective way in Europe, given the geographical reality we have and the reality of primary and secondary migratory flows. This is the challenge of implementing the decisions of the European Council from last June, which we have been working on a lot, France and Spain.

First, the external issue. We are making progress in all actions, in the countries of origin and transit such as the Sahel or Libya to end the mafias, also to dissuade migrants from crossing the Mediterranean and, more generally, to stabilize and ensure the development of Africa. We also converge on this initiative with the Spanish Government. Spain is a pioneer in this area in its relationship with various African countries, and we must take advantage of this expertise, this knowledge to organize a coherent, ambitious European strategy to strengthen our support for the countries of origin and transit of migratory phenomena.

We both want to intensify this work, which consists of a policy of cooperation, development, and accountability of all our African partners. And for that reason, I congratulate Spain for organizing the upcoming meeting of the ministers responsible for migration issues in France and Europe to develop joint initiatives.

And then there are the common borders and the will we have through Frontex to strengthen the available resources. We will have proposals in September, and this is also an important point in our migration strategy. It is, especially, about speeding up the accompanying procedures for those who do not have the right to asylum. At this point, we also have a common position that will allow us to react jointly to the proposals that the Commission will put forward in September.

We will also move forward with the work, together with the European Commission, around its proposals based on French and Spanish ideas— that idea of controlled centers— and, more generally, to achieve greater effective solidarity and greater European support to manage arrivals in the countries of first entry, and also to better prevent secondary flows by strengthening and speeding up the accompaniment of people who are not candidates for the right to asylum. On the external side, the protection of borders and, also, an internal aspect, reception and solidarity at the internal level in Europe. These are the pillars of the initiative we have been carrying out for several months now, and in which the convergence is genuine between our two countries, and the positions we defended at the last Council have, in fact, always been progressive on the matter. Today's declaration and this work will allow us, in terms of external cooperation, to do even more.

On this issue, I believe I can say that our two countries share this vision, the vision of effectiveness, of national cohesion, which is important to us, and the need to maintain necessary control over the different migratory flows, but also a vision of partnership with African countries—among others— in a spirit of humanism, of solidarity that consists of rejecting any solution that does not align with our values and that would not be effective.

In this specific case, all the solutions that have emerged, merely nationalistic, have succeeded in the short term but have very quickly failed in the face of the reality of facts. We can have nationalist friends in a neighboring country, but the day we share a border, these nationalisms can no longer be reconciled.

We have also talked about the future of the eurozone, and you will see in the statements we publish today the agreements we have reached. I will focus on three main elements: first, Spain and France are very active players in the intense reform process of the Eurozone, driven in recent months and materialized by the Franco-German declaration of Messenberg. It is essential to maintain this dynamic to achieve concrete advances before the end of the year, and both of us are very, very committed to this, because the debate we had in the June Council must materialize into an Agenda for the heads of state and government by the end of the year with recurring, frequent meetings, and that is what we have asked President Tusk for, to have a summit of conclusions in December on this point.

The second element is that I observe that France and Spain are very much in favor of a reform of the Eurozone. The Single Resolution Fund, the European deposit guarantee, or the eurozone budget, which must allow for strengthening growth, convergence, and stabilization, are topics on which we agree, and as President Sánchez has rightly said, it is at these moments, with a better context, that we have to achieve these agreements, because sometimes we have been slow to respond, and Spain has paid the political and social price of this delay. It is when things are going well that we must anticipate the structures, the mechanisms of responsibility in the Eurozone to prevent future crises and potential imbalances.

France and Spain will also work together with our European partners to present detailed proposals on the topic of the European budget by autumn, and we have also mentioned the need to take more into account the social dimension of the Economic and Monetary Union and the way we manage structural and cohesion funds.

And we have reminded how important it is to impose more on digital companies. It is a more united Europe, economically and socially, that we need. The European Union and the Eurozone within it will not be able to advance sustainably, they will not be able to progress, unless it is through greater solidarity and greater convergence, establishing precisely these mechanisms such as, for example, the greater taxation of digital companies.

Our areas of convergence are not limited to these two, but there are many more. The Europe of Defense, for example. And I welcome Spain's participation in the launch of the European intervention force that will allow us to maintain the excellent cooperation we have between our two armed forces. This convergence also appears in trade issues. I suppose we can mention it again in the questions, but there is, of course, first, the will to avoid any kind of trade conflict at present and, also, to avoid any form of culpable laxity that could lead us to give up our agricultural ambitions, for example, or to reach agreements in a tense environment that would deny our common principles, those we want to propose to our peoples, and that is why food, health commitments cannot be subject to any compromise in the name of any trade agreement.

Tomorrow, in Lisbon, we will have another moment to illustrate this convergence of viewpoints on European issues with the summit organized by Portugal on energy transitions. We share the will to make Europe a leading area in this matter, and we will see each other shortly at dinner at the Royal Palace, but also tomorrow in Portugal to continue this common work.

Thank you very much, then, Mr. Prime Minister, dear Pedro, for the pleasure of these exchanges and for all the work we will continue to do together. Thank you very much.

President.- We are at your disposal.

Q.- Good afternoon. Speaking of trade, could you be a little more precise? What is your reaction to the Trump-Juncker agreement from yesterday? And what reservations do you have regarding that agreement?

Mr. Macron.- Well, I can start by saying that we have talked about it a lot. First of all: Europe and France never wanted any trade war, and yesterday's conversation allows us to reject any form of unnecessary tension, as it is positive. But a good trade dialogue—and I say this from the outset—can only be based on a balanced, reciprocal relationship, and under no circumstances under threat. And in this case, we have some doubts, some concerns that we will have to clarify in the coming days with our European partners.

I am not in favor of starting to negotiate a broad trade agreement, like the TTIP, because the context does not allow it, and what we have seen so far does not allow it. I am not in favor of this idea because, in these discussions, agriculture cannot be involved at any time, and I believe that no European standard should be lowered or eliminated in terms of the environment, health, or food, for example. Why? Because it is the very principle of the sovereign Europe in which I believe. We cannot ask our industrialists, our farmers, our fellow citizens, our workers, to orient themselves towards a new productive model that is more respectful of the environment and the social balances in which we believe, and on the other hand, sign trade agreements with powers that do not respect these obligations, thus creating an obvious imbalance.

Respecting these standards is essential. European values must also be respected, for example, access to the U.S. public market, which is very limited at the moment. We need clear signals from the United States on issues like steel and aluminum, which are subject to illegal tariffs from the United States, and for me, this would be a prerequisite for any concrete progress with the limits I have just mentioned.

President.- The reflection made by the President of the French Republic, with which I agree—I also mentioned it in my first remarks— the Government of Spain is in favor of multilateralism, and therefore, we do not believe in unilateralism and in the imposition by a certain economy of its criteria and policies regarding international trade.

Secondly, we do not want any trade war, but it is evident that the European continent, the European Union, has achieved, over these last years, over these last decades, advances that have a lot to do with social, labor, and, of course, also environmental standards, which must be preserved.

And, thirdly, it is always important to remember that international trade policy is led by the European Commission but that, logically, it must be done in coordination with all member states and then must be approved in the European Parliament and then in national parliaments. Therefore, member states have a lot to say in any alteration of our trade relations with other countries or, specifically, with the United States.

Certainly, we are not reassured by the positioning that has been made regarding the Common Agricultural Policy, and in that sense, what we expect is first to know firsthand what President Juncker has to say to us, but secondly, if we are going to defend something, it is precisely the Common Agricultural Policy as it is currently defined by the European Union.

Q.- Good afternoon, presidents. I wanted to ask, first to President Sánchez: tomorrow there is an important vote in the Congress of Deputies. I wanted to ask you if you have guaranteed the parliamentary support of those groups that made you President of the Government to approve the deficit path in Congress? And, I also wanted to ask you what plan B the Government has in case the PP vetoes it in the Senate? And, if I may ask a second question, I wanted to ask you if you rule out early elections in case you cannot move forward with your government project? Thank you.

And to President Macron, I wanted to ask you if, after what happened in Spain, do you fear that a motion of censure against you could be reproduced or could prosper in your country? Thank you.

President.- Well, regarding the issue of elections, we are in a democratic system, and there will be elections. There will be elections in due time and form, that is, in 2020. That is the will of the Government.

The objectives of this Government are well marked, I expressed them in my appearance before the Congress of Deputies a few days ago, where what we want is to stabilize our country socially, politically, and economically, to rebuild the welfare state, to consolidate economic growth, to create decent jobs, and to consolidate the democratic regeneration that was opened in this country after the motion of censure. That is the objective of this Government.

Secondly, the Government of Spain has proposed a coherent stability path. Coherent with our economic reality. Coherent with the forecasts being made by all international organizations and, specifically, the European Union regarding what the deviations of public deficit and public debt are. And coherent with our social reality. There is a lot of inequality, there has been a very significant cut to our welfare state, and consequently, what the Government of Spain is proposing is that we clean up public accounts, continue consolidating the public deficit in our country but, above all, do it with social justice, redistributing growth, consolidating and recovering rights that have been cut over the last ten years of economic crisis to the middle and working classes of this country.

Moreover, with those five tenths of a stability path more, the General State Administration has made an effort of solidarity and responsibility with the territorial administrations. And we have said, of those five tenths, only one for the General State Administration, two for Social Security—because it is evident that we have a deficit problem in Social Security—and another two tenths, that is, more than 2.4 billion euros, for the Autonomous Communities and the Municipalities.

Therefore, those parliamentary groups that do not vote in favor of this stability path will be voting against rebuilding the welfare state in our country, against recovering public health, against advancing in the consolidation of public education, against reviving the National Dependency System, against reactivating social services; therefore, I appeal to the responsibility of all parliamentary groups—and if you allow me—even, first and foremost, the Popular Party that governs in Autonomous Communities, that governs in Municipalities and that will have to explain to their neighbors that for a party interest, what they are doing is voting against a stability path that gives greater financial capacity, precisely, to the territorial administrations and local entities.

It is certainly paradoxical that the territorial chamber, which is the Senate, rejects or vetoes a greater financing capacity for the Autonomous Communities and the Municipalities. If that happens, logically, it is not out of a territorial interest, nor a local one, but exclusively partisan. From there, each one must assume their responsibilities. The Government will assume its own, and its responsibility is to propose a General State Budget for the year 2019, and we will do so, with this path of stability or with the previous one, but the Government of Spain will do it.

Mr. Macron.- The parliamentary opposition in the French National Assembly has indeed presented the motion of censure that will be subject to a vote next week. We will see what the result of that vote is, but the reality and the political arithmetic of the French National Assembly do not allow us to imagine that this motion of censure could, indeed, sanction the Government of Prime Minister Édouard Philippe.

Q.- Presidents, good afternoon. Since we are talking about national issues, I wanted to return, Mr. Macron, to one of your statements. You say that there are people who had an interest in it coming out two months later, referring to the Benalla case. Alexandre Benalla himself says that the first target was the President of the Republic with this controversy. Who are those people that you do not name?

Mr. Macron.- I do not know, perhaps you can tell me. You are the journalists, I am the President of the Republic and I take care of my own matters. As I have already said, it is like a storm in a teacup. Something serious has happened, which has provoked an immediate and proportionate response from the Élysée Palace. Then, through the press, everything has been stirred up a bit, but I am not responsible for that. And then, there is a job that must be the job of justice and my duty is to guarantee the tranquility and effectiveness of justice. And then, there is another job that is parliamentary, which is very legitimate and is neither of justice nor of the Executive. The Executive is the President of the Republic who works, who moves forward. We will see how all this ends when each one has drawn the consequences of what has been denounced, but I believe that the collaborators of the Élysée have done their job as they should, at the moment they should, and that the necessary responses were provided in due time. And then, I will await the conclusions of Justice, of Parliament, and of the Executive with the investigations that have been requested, and I have asked for a thorough, real analysis, and for the conclusions to be published when they come out.

What matters to me and what matters to our fellow citizens is that a law on vocational training has been able to be voted on in the Assembly, that a law has been able to be voted on, or that a law on asylum and immigration is being debated in the Assembly, or that a law against tax fraud has also been able to be voted on, involving a historic revolution -- which we call "the lock" of the Treasury -- and that has been approved. This is what matters.

And in the coming weeks, the ministers will continue to announce measures so that our country can reactivate, that work is at the heart of our values, and to continue the transformative agenda in education, or in social matters, health, or social cohesion.

I believe that this is what is useful for France and what our fellow citizens expect. That is what I will try to do and with your work, surely, you will find the answer to your own question.

Q.- Yes, good afternoon, I had a question for Mr. Macron. If you could tell us a little more about why your delay, as we did not understand it because the translation was not ready yet, if you could say something more about the reason for this delay.

And, for President Sánchez, I wanted to ask him if he thinks he was wrong to use the official plane to attend the festival. But, more than anything, for not putting it as a cultural agenda in his public agenda, and if he would do it again. And, if he thinks that the explanations of the director of the CNI regarding the recordings of Corinna have been satisfactory enough for a commission of investigation to be opened in Parliament. Thank you.

Mr. Macron.- I understand that you know a lot about transportation so I will try to answer methodically on the subject. Well, personally, my delay is due to the fact that I had to attend a stage in the French Pyrenees, go to Tourmalet and Campan, where I received a delegation from the agricultural world and then I inaugurated some facilities at Pic du Midi, and it is also true that I greeted a lot of people there and this took longer than expected. These are the completely transparent explanations for my delay for which I apologize. Simply, before I used to make a joke saying that the delay appeared at our common border, which are the Pyrenees.

President.- We thank you, President, for making the effort to be here. It is important for us that, being a neighboring, friendly, partner country, the President of the French Republic is present. We have also agreed to see each other again soon, both in France and in Spain, so what is important is to strengthen cooperation between both countries, we have very important common challenges of which we have spoken, and therefore, we will leave it there.

And, regarding these two issues: of course, I have been in charge of the Government for a month -- a month and a few weeks -- and I have asked, after this controversy, I have asked. I would say a false controversy, an artificial controversy, but I have asked how the President of the Government travels, whether it is José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, José María Aznar, Felipe González, Mariano Rajoy, in my case, how he travels. Well, that is decided by the Security Department of Moncloa, I have asked and that is what they have told me.

Secondly, since 2015 the Security Department of Moncloa recommends that all transportation and mobility of the person holding the presidency of the Government be done by air means. Therefore, that is the issue. Of course, I believe that the opposition, in this case from Ciudadanos and the Popular Party, is not so much about the means by which the President of the Government is transported but about who, as President of the Government, is being transported. They have not accepted it. But that is not my problem. What I ask of them is to accept it and for us to stop artificial controversies and focus on the real problems of the citizens, which are important, and which have been addressed here.

And secondly, regarding the statement and appearance of the director general of the CNI in committee, I would like to say that the Government of Spain certainly has no doubts about the details of the appearance of the director of the CNI, and I also convey to the media and to the entire Spanish public opinion, that there should be no doubt that we will not accept any blackmail against the State. None. Therefore, these are the two issues you have asked me about and, to close, because we have an important visit to the King, I would like to convey again all my gratitude, all my affection, and consideration, and my respect to a President of the Republic who is doing a lot for Europe and is doing it from a progressive perspective and, certainly, for me that is also a pride and a relief, to have a partner and an ally like President Macron at the head of the French Republic.