Press conference by President of the Government and German Chancellor
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez held a joint press conference with Chancellor Merkel in Sanlúcar de Barrameda, Spain in August 2018 to discuss European integration and migration.
- Main themes
- European integration and reform, Spain-Germany bilateral relations, migration challenge, Economic and Monetary Union, EU leadership and values, Doñana National Park and sustainability, multiannual financial framework, inequality between Europe and Africa, biodiversity protection, pro-European commitment, Mediterranean migration crisis
- Duration
- ~38 min
- Words
- 4,524
- Sentences
- 184
- Readability
- 44
- Grade
- 13.1
- Syntax
- 3.22
- Vocabulary
- 2.12
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
184 sentences in 68 paragraphs
President of the Government.- Good afternoon to everyone. Thank you for attending this press conference. Firstly, I would like to thank the German Chancellor, Angela Merkel, for her presence here today in Spain. To come here from Berlin is an effort that we are grateful for, and the government views the meeting we have held today as very important. And we have held it because, for a pro-European government such as Spain, Germany is at the head and also at the heart of Europe. Europe needs Germany's leadership and the pro-European commitment of Chancellor Merkel.
So, dear Chancellor, dear Angela, welcome to Spain. And welcome to this land, to Andalusia, a land full of history and also full of nature. The history of Spain and the history of Europe, as well - I would dare to say - can be seen here in Sanlúcar de Barrameda, in this building, at the Palace of the Dukes of Medina Sidonia, where so many cultures have left their mark.
And later, we will also have the chance to visit nature in all its splendour.
The Doñana National Park is not only a place of extraordinary beauty, which it indeed is; but it is also, to a certain degree, a symbol of Europe that we have built over recent decades with values such as the protection of biodiversity and inter-generational solidarity that represents the sustainability of our planet.
Spain joined this Europe, this Europe of values just over three decades ago, much later, and hence, due to its vocation, culture and history this was right to do but which, like everything, only took place after a long trip, but we are now here to stay. Spanish society is profoundly pro-European, and this is principally so because Spanish society and Spain have always identified Europe with progress, with social justice, with democracy, with liberty and with stability.
Spanish democracy and also the autonomous system in Spain is greatly inspired by federal Germany, and are inextricably linked to membership of the European Union. And precisely because it was so tough for Spain to join, this country is determined to fight to keep this great collective work that is the European Union alive.
And this is, in short, the purpose of the meeting between Chancellor Merkel and myself. We are here because we share a common vision of the strength of the European project to respond to the global challenges we are facing. We are here because we not only believe in the validity of the European project but, above all, because we believe in its future, in the values it promotes and in the principles on which it is based.
We are here, in short, because Spain and Germany believe that Europe must move forward and not backwards and, to achieve this, Europe needs Germany's leadership, with Spain at its side.
Today, at this meeting, we not only spoke about the immediate future, of what is pressing for our governments, such as the challenge of migration, which I am convinced will be one of the questions addressed in the press conference. We also spoke about the future of the European Union, of what shape tomorrow's European Union must take. That is why the work agenda of this meeting we held included such issues as the Economic and Monetary Union, the multiannual financial framework programme and so many questions that I am sure will come up in the press conference.
In essence, what we have spoken about is how Spain and Germany can contribute to strengthening the foundations of a much sounder construction than some would have us believe.
All of the countries in the EU need Europe, and Europe needs Germany's leadership. Europe does not accept tactical retreats; at least in my opinion, and we must reject the opportunism of those who only promise a return to the failed solutions of the past.
And that is the spirit with which the Government of Spain is tackling one of the main challenges all European societies are facing - migration - thus boosting, in a defined fashion, the need for a global, wholly European vision, to a phenomenon that has placed Spain in the front line for obvious reasons, which are geographic, but which affect and are incumbent on the whole European Union, the whole European continent.
14 kilometres - that is all that separates the Spanish coastline, and consequently Europe, from North Africa. But there is a much more important distance, an infinitely greater distance between our two continents in terms of economic and social development, the protection of human rights and also political stability. The larger the abyss, the greater the drama that unfolds in the waters of the Mediterranean. And hence, reducing the size of the abyss of inequality must also be one of the main tasks of the European Union both now and in the medium term. This can only be achieved with a global vision, not from the isolated perspective of individual Member States of the European Union.
I believe that Spain and Germany share this vision. And that is something that I wish to reaffirm today, because it constitutes the basis on which we must continue to drive, in our opinion, the common migratory policy. That is the spirit that is present in Spain's proposal: to step up dialogue and cooperation with countries of origin and countries of transit, and particularly with a key partner of the European Union and of Spain, which is Morocco. I know that Spain can count on the will of Germany in this task. And on this question, I wish to personally thank Chancellor Merkel for being as interested in this issue at present as she is, because it represents, in short, the materialisation of the principle of solidarity, which is one of the founding principles of the European Union.
That is how Europe is built, from solidarity and responsibility. The same is true of the completion of the Economic Union, by taking steps towards social union. And, in short, these are the questions we spoke about in our meeting.
To end, this government wishes to play an active role in the debate on the future of the European Union, and not just because this is a shared desire of the vast majority of the Spanish people, but also because of its own conviction. Because it understands that strengthening Europe means strengthening the societies that make it up and, above all, making ourselves stronger to tackle the global challenges facing us.
I said at the start of this speech that Spain joined Europe late, but that once it joined, it did so with the intention of staying. And I would add something else, not only to stay but also to act. To make progress towards a united and strong Europe, and I am convinced that Spain and Germany have a great deal to say and also to do. And we will do this from a pro-European perspective that resists any form of retreat.
So, may these words of introduction to the press briefing serve to welcome Chancellor Merkel to Spain and to Andalusia. It is an honour to receive you, and I hope that over this day and a half both you and your family will feel at home here.
Chancellor.- Mr President of the Government, dear Pedro Sánchez. We are very pleased because shortly after your visit to Berlin, I received this invitation to see a little of the culture and history of Spain, here in this historic location of Sanlúcar de Barrameda.
We are truly in a location that has played a key role in European history. This is a very beautiful spot and, furthermore, I am going to visit other Spanish beauty spots in my trip to the Doñana National Park. But our meeting also coincides with a time in which we must still address many issues through the European Union. And it is good to know that we not only maintain excellent relations at a bilateral level, but also that both governments have a common approach to the main issues in Europe. We are convinced that only together, as Member States of the European Union, can we overcome tomorrow's challenges. This is closely tied into our economic future, with a view to digitalisation, to the multilateral focus on resolving issues such as climate change and reciprocal trade issues.
We know that as Europeans we are stronger in resolving problems when we work together rather than individually, which is less successful.
Obviously, we paid particular attention to the issue of migration because this was the key question: if the European Union can successfully tackle great challenges, and I am very pleased because Spain and Germany share a joint approach.
You already mentioned that we are just a few kilometres off the coast of Africa. The situation is similar in Malta and Sicily. And hence, we are facing a challenge that we must resolve on a joint basis. And no country can avoid this challenge and avoid the solution and commitment in this regard, regardless of whether Spain is the leading country in terms of the number of arrivals at this time, with an increasing number of refugees. Or whether Germany is one of the main destinations for secondary movements.
That is why I wish to welcome, first of all, the agreement reached with Spain to better regulate secondary movements. This shows that we can solve problems by working together. In the same way, we wish to support you in negotiations with Morocco. Similarly, we have made contributions to the Trust Fund for Africa, with Morocco and Greece, which need support in strengthening their borders to improve their possibilities of development. Because if the difference between the perspectives in Africa and Europe are so great, then the cause that originates these exodus movements cannot be overcome.
Hence, we are in favour of close cooperation, of very close cooperation with African countries, which must be honest cooperation based on the fact that both sides come out on top, and that people traffickers have no more business opportunities. So, it is not important and sufficient to talk about Africa, but to talk with Africa, and that can be seen by the trend we confirmed at today's meeting, where we saw we shared many criteria.
Also with a view to the Informal Council meeting to be held in Salzburg in September. We will adopt this position and prepared the summit with other countries with similar standpoints.
We also tackled commercial issues, also thinking about the United States of America. We both agreed that the trip by Jean Claude Junker was very important and that it is also important for President Trump and the European Commission to hold negotiations.
We have also spoken about the medium- and long-term financial outlook, about Economic and Monetary Union, etc. This conversation was very important under the premise that Europe must be part of the solution; we must guide our actions towards solutions and our destiny - for Spain and for Germany - will only be positive if we cooperate and there is no class of antagonism. So, thank you very much for this invitation. And I am very pleased to have seen this aspect of nature, here in the south, because it is something I consider to be very important: preserving nature, the climate, and the cooperation we need in this field.
President of the Government.- Thank you very much Chancellor. We will now take any questions that the media may have for us.
Q.- I wanted to ask whether Germany, Spain, France and Portugal are the countries most prepared to form a bloc against xenophobia in Europe. In Spain, in particular, the opposition is applying intense pressure on the issue of migration. What do you think can be done so that Spain does not become a new Italy? And another issue, what is happening with Morocco? How much money can the European Union raise for Morocco?
President of the Government.- As regards Morocco, the Chancellor and I agreed at our working lunch that it is one of the main partners of the European Union, and also of Spain.
Furthermore, Morocco is also suffering migratory pressure from counties in Sub-Saharan Africa and, consequently, we need to strengthen bilateral cooperation, not only with the countries of origin but also with the countries of transit, such as Morocco. I believe that at the first European Council I had the chance to attend as President of the Government, the commitment of all the EU institutions and also of the Member States regarding the need to step up this cooperation with Morocco was contained in the Conclusions, whereby Morocco is granted the role it already plays, which is key, in ordering migratory flows.
Furthermore, I feel that Chancellor Merkel outlined clearly the approach both our governments have and that we want to advocate to the European Union on migratory policy. It must be cross-cutting, horizontal and holistic. In other words, we cannot only talk about border control, although that must clearly be discussed; we cannot only talk about the humanitarian reception of those migrants that reach the shores of Europe, which include the Spanish shores, although that must clearly be discussed. Above all, we must strengthen the control of secondary movements. And furthermore, we must strengthen European Union cooperation with African countries, particularly in North Africa, which amounts to development cooperation, political stability and opportunities in the medium term for the young people of those countries.
What do I mean by this? That the approach by the German Government and the Spanish Government on the migratory phenomenon is not a specific policy on what to do in terms of border control, although, I repeat, this needs to be managed. This is cross-cutting. It is, in other words, holistic in the sense that, in the end, if we want to talk about how to order migratory flows, about how to tackle this global challenge facing European society as a whole, we must undertake this, first of all, from a shared standpoint, through common approaches and, of course, this must be done from a much more cross-cutting perspective than has been done to date. That is the approach of the Government of Spain, and I believe that this is also the approach of the Government of Germany, and of the EU institutions as a whole.
Various media outlets have expressed surprise that Spain has signed an agreement with Germany, precisely to regulate secondary movements. But Spain does not only ask for solidarity but also takes on responsibility as regards migratory policy.
We want the solidarity of the European Union. We want the solidarity of other Member States to face up to this challenge of migratory policy in a country like ours, but we also take on our certain responsibilities in controlling secondary movements that are, in this case, affecting Germany. And hence, as she said in her speech, and I agree with that, it is gratifying for us to sign this bilateral agreement with the German Government and we also take joint responsibility for these secondary movements together with the German Government and German society.
Chancellor.- The European Union is not just any association but one that is based on shared values that include respect for human dignity. And that must be reflected in all our internal and external actions.
We defend human rights and take the dignity of each and every human being seriously. That also means that we need legal structures. Racism is opposed to the fundamental values of the European Union, and is excluded from these values. Hence, we must strongly oppose fascist trends with great determination.
I believe that both Spain and Germany do this. And my government does so in that it defends human rights as a daily undertaking.
As regards Morocco, this is a country that plays an important role in the context of migration whilst it is also a partner with which we wish to advance in terms of cooperation and economic development. There is a long track-record of development cooperation between Germany and Morocco. We maintain close ties. We are aware that Spain, because of its geographic and historical proximity, maintains even closer ties and hence we have agreed today to act in a coordinated fashion, under Spanish leadership, in cooperating with Morocco. Germany will provide support where Morocco needs support, because Morocco also has the task of cooperating with the countries of origin, which are often on the other side, beyond the borders of Morocco.
In recent years, Germany has started to step up relations with countries in Africa in a more intensive manner, by founding associations; today we mentioned, for example, the Association Agreement with Niger, which Spain also supports.
I am convinced that we don't all have to do the same things but rather we should support the intense contacts that Spain has with Morocco while a country like Germany can intensely cooperate with Ghana and with other countries, and that we should all act in the same European interest, in a European context to overcome these challenges, instead of each country acting on its own.
President of the Government.- It is not a question, Carlos, of how much money. The Chancellor said this earlier when we were talking about the European Union's experience in cooperation, and for example, when we talk about Spain and Morocco we are talking about what economic resources can be supplied for a multitude of policies in the Kingdom of Morocco. And of course, also in terms of border control you are fully aware that we are in talks about this with the European Commission, precisely in order to release a series of economic resources that will allow Morocco to obtain materials that will enable it to be much more effective in terms of border control, and in terms of preventing these boats, these rafts, from embarking for the Spanish coastline.
But, at any event, it is not a question of quoting a figure, because that would be unfair and, moreover, it would be inappropriate. Because if we talk about numbers and about economic resources invested in Morocco, in Tunisia and in other countries in North Africa, we are talking about a great many resources already being invested by the European Union; not only in migratory policy but also in development and in a multitude of policies, let's say, related to the development of this society.
Q.- A question for the Federal Chancellor. Spain is increasingly taking in migrants that arrive across the Mediterranean. What is expected by Spain and Germany as regards taking these migrants in?
Chancellor.- We can all see at this time that the current Dublin system in the context of the free movement under Schengen is not working. According to the theory, no migrant, no refugee, should reach Germany, but that is not the reality. Hence, the Member States of the EU that are in the Schengen space must work to achieve a fair system of distribution to jointly organise the returns necessary for those who are not entitled to permanently stay in the European Union. So, we must talk with the countries of origin and create associations, as we have done with Turkey and as we have done with Libya. We must negotiate with Morocco, we are going to do this with Tunisia, with Algeria, but not only with the countries of transit, but also with the countries of origin, with Senegal, with the Ivory Coast, etc. Each country has its own needs and must create a situation in which both parties benefit in order to ensure refugees are returned.
And those that are entitled to stay in the European Union must be distributed fairly. And this is a continuously ongoing issue. We don't yet have the right solution, but as the number of countries grows that back a fair distribution of those who are entitled to stay here on grounds of asylum or civil war in their country, they must be distributed throughout the European Union. Because it is true that we must say to the countries of origin that we are facing a challenge that involves everyone.
The task of attending to refugees in the European Union cannot be limited to just a few countries, because we all enjoy the benefits of free movement. That is what is most important, and finding a solution here is extremely difficult. We have seen that we have had a certain degree of success with Turkey and with Libya in the sense that many people are no longer setting out on this dangerous journey. Because it is very dangerous to be a migrant, to be a refugee, which can be seen in the number of deaths in the Mediterranean and how many people endanger their lives, and have to spend vast amounts of money to get to Europe. In other words, this situation is a problem for everyone. We want to find a solution to this situation within the framework of European solidarity and we must take both direct migration to the European Union and secondary movements seriously. And we must find the way to share out the tasks among all the EU Member States.
Q.- (Inaudible)
President of the Government.- Well, first of all, the Government of Spain is well aware of the challenge of unaccompanied minors. I have always said that migration did not begin with this government, but what has begun with this government is a migratory policy, particularly when talking about unaccompanied minors.
Hence, what I can tell you is that there will be an agreement, because there will be one. The government cannot envisage another scenario. There will be an agreement and I hope that this involves a shared vision to a shared challenge such as that of unaccompanied minors, which is undoubtedly principally affecting the Regional Government of Andalusia, the Autonomous Region of Andalusia, but also, of course, other regions as well.
So, there will be an agreement. The government cannot envisage another scenario that does not involve an agreement between all the regional governments. And of course this will be headed up by the Government of Spain.
I repeat, the Government of Spain has implemented an action plan over these last two months, with more than 30 million euros invested from now to the end of the year 2018, precisely to strengthen the humanitarian reception of all migrants arriving on the shores of our country.
We have approved a single command to improve operational efficiency, to control migratory flows and to fight the mafias that traffic human beings.
And thirdly, we have made a commitment to each and every autonomous region to implement an Integration Fund for Migration under the 2019 Budget, in which the previous government, unfortunately, invested nothing. Hence, migratory policy and an agreement on the issue of the MENA will be implemented by the Government of Spain in all the autonomous regions. The Government of Spain is not working on any scenario other than forging an agreement. I repeat, a sector conference will be held at the start of the month of September. We are looking for solutions and it is clearly the intention of the Government of Spain to reach an agreement with all the regional governments.
Q.- (Inaudible)
Chancellor.- Well, refugees from Spain haven't arrived in Germany by crossing the Austrian border since June.
Q.- (Inaudible)
Chancellor.- Well the value of this agreement revolves around Germany and Spain committing to European solutions. Hence, I very highly rate this agreement. Spain is not the only country with we are going to reach this type of agreement. We are holding talks with Greece, for example. But this is a clear example of us helping that country when it has a specific problem. In the same manner, Germany is clearly saying that if there are problems in Spain, for example, regarding support for Morocco, we will help and that is the way to live side-by-side, to act together, something which seems tremendously important to me.
Q.- (Inaudible)
President of the Government.- As regards the last of your questions, to start at the end, the first thing I want to do is express my gratitude at the tone that the events, the commemoration, on 17 August in Barcelona and Cambrils are taking on. We should remember that these were very serious attacks, terrible attacks; they not only attacked the society of Barcelona and also of Cambrils, but the whole of Spanish society and the whole of European society. Hence, we should not forget that we are all called to stand united against terrorism, and to send out a message of solidarity to the victims and their families, which I feel is the best message we can send out on 17 August. And we are all going to be there at that event, from the first to the last of the Spanish people. From the Head of State to the Queen, the government and, of course, all the institutions that feel it is appropriate to attend this demonstration.
And as regards your first question, it seems reasonable to me for the opposition to do its work. This is a democratic system, what the opposition must do is oppose the government. What I would ask both the People's Party and Ciudadanos is not to oppose the State, because opposing the State is tantamount to opposing oneself, because in the end, you contradict yourself, whether over counter-terrorism policy, the transfer of prisoners to Basque jails or what relates to migratory policy.
I believe that we are talking about the unity of democrats, precisely in the year in which the terrorist group ETA has announced its dissolution. Hence, if the unity of democrats was what democracy needed to defeat ETA, then we should not lose this unity precisely now that ETA has dissolved and gone for good from our lives, fortunately.
And in relation to migration, the same is true. Not Ciudadanos , but the People's Party, governs in town and city councils, it governs in some autonomous regions. This is a party that was in government until not long ago and is perfectly aware of the challenge of migration.
Hence, I offered a State pact, a countrywide agreement to the PP and I also offered this to the rest of the parliamentary forces, because I believe that, in the end, what we are talking about is a challenge that transcends the actions of a government. And I am not only talking about a government at a national level, but I am also talking about governing at a local level, at just a short distance from here, in Algeciras or in Tarifa, or in other places on the Spanish coast, and of course in the regional governments as well.
I believe that if we focus the work of the opposition on something that should be done to the government, and not to the State, then I believe we would be aiding in ordering the debate on emotional and rational terms that may be understood by part of Spanish society as a whole.
Thank you very much.
Non official translation