Press conference by President of the Government after attending European Council meeting
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez addressed a press conference in Brussels on October 18, 2018, following the European Council meeting to report on Brexit, migration, and the Euro Summit.
- Main themes
- Brexit negotiations, EU migration policy, FRONTEX border control, Gibraltar protocol, Ireland-Northern Ireland border, European Council conclusions, internal market freedoms, Euro Summit preliminary meeting, Spain-UK bilateral relations, EU common migration policy
- Duration
- ~40 min
- Words
- 4,814
- Sentences
- 225
- Readability
- 55
- Grade
- 10.8
- Syntax
- 2.98
- Vocabulary
- 2.06
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
225 sentences in 79 paragraphs
President of the Government .- Good afternoon. Thank you all very much for attending this press conference to share with you the main conclusions of this day and a half of work performed here in Brussels with my European colleagues.
I will present you with the conclusions on Brexit. By conclusions I mean the reflections made yesterday by all the EU partners in relation to such an important issue.
Secondly, the Conclusions from today's European Council, above all, those in relation to migration, although I will also make reference to some other concrete aspects on security, which I also believe are important.
And I will end this hopefully brief speech with some reflections that the Government of Spain has made and proposed at the Euro Summit. There are no conclusions, there is no resolution, because, as you know, this work is a preliminary meeting before the Euro Summit to be held in the month of December.
So, as regards Brexit, I want to convey something you are already aware of. No agreement has been reached. As at today's date, there is no agreement. No progress has been made in these last few weeks between the European Commission's negotiating team and its counterpart in the United Kingdom. And hence, what we have instructed the team of negotiators to do is continue with these talks with the United Kingdom and, above all, to urge the United Kingdom to complete these most sensitive issues on which no agreement has been reached.
As regards the position declared by the Government of Spain and which I believe is shared by all 27 Member States, we feel it is vital and fundamental to respect the four freedoms that define the European Union: the free movement of capital, goods and, of course, people. Secondly, to resolve once and for all, the question of the border between Ireland and Northern Ireland. You are aware that this is a key issue for the people of Ireland, and I would even dare to say that this is also a key issue for the European project.
The negotiator Michel Barnier expressed this very well in some of the other meetings and also in public when he defined the internal market on our continent as an eco-system. And hence, if some kind of freedom or fundamental principle of this internal market were to be disrupted, then this would probably have a negative effect on the functioning of this internal market.
Hence, the question of the border between Northern Ireland and Ireland is not only of concern for Ireland, it is also of concern for the whole of the EU in terms of the effects that this may have on the good functioning of the European market.
And thirdly, and in regards to Spain, I also conveyed, and this has been acknowledged by the negotiating team, because the Government of Spain has done its homework, the issue of the protocol. You are aware that the withdrawal agreement must have three protocols: one, on Ireland, which is pending resolution; another on Cyprus, and the one that affects Spain, on Gibraltar.
Well, for us, the protocol on Gibraltar is now resolved; this has been agreed with the British Government, and now we are involved in resolving the four memoranda on bilateral relations between the Government of Spain and the United Kingdom. These bilateral relations include such elements as taxation, environmental recovery, the recovery of security and police actions. As regards the movement of workers and citizens between Gibraltar and Campo de Gibraltar, well, these talks are still pending. But in the talks I held with the British Prime Minister this morning we urged each other to reach an agreement on two of these memoranda out of the four that are still pending resolution. These are obviously the ones related to taxation, which are the most sensitive issues when talking about Gibraltar.
So, this was the first of the questions. Later, you can ask me whatever you want about Brexit.
As regards the ordinary European Council, let's say that the most important agreement reached on migration, which was preceded by the informal meeting of the European Council in Salzburg a few weeks ago, was basically on strengthening borders by increasing the workforce of FRONTEX.
This was the clearest and most decisive issue that formed the main consensus of the 28 Member States - the decision to increase the workforce of FRONTEX - whereby borders should be controlled by the EU.
Well, this is a long-standing debate. This is a debate on which most Member States have systematically declared and also urged the European Commission to draw up a proposal to increase the workforce of FRONTEX.
We feel that is a good idea. The Government of Spain supports this, although I have declared that I consider it to be insufficient. In other words, we feel this is a good measure, it is good news to enhance border control and everything related to supporting this by FRONTEX, and we will not oppose this.
What did we say? Let's not forget other dimensions of common migratory policy. The first is the external dimension, in other words, cooperation and dialogue with countries of origin and countries of transit, something you have heard about on other occasions, in this same press room, and regarding this specific issue of cooperation and dialogue with other countries, we feel that the role being played by Morocco in regulating this migratory flows should be brought to the table and greatly increased. This is something we have shared with the 28 Member States when speaking about migratory policy and the pressure that currently exists on the Western Mediterranean route. And, in this regard, I wish to tell you that, from a perspective of communication and cooperation between EU institutions and Morocco, satisfactory steps are already being taken. Firm and decisive steps are being taken which I believe are satisfactory for both parties.
A few days ago, a meeting was held between a European Commission delegation and the Government of Morocco which I believe justifies and is the definitive realisation of these agreements we reached some weeks ago and which hadn't been seen but which is now starting to come to fruition, above all, to help Morocco in terms of all the capabilities required to control the borders on the part of Morocco. So, that is the second dimension.
And the third dimension is the internal dimension which clearly interests those countries that do not have external borders, but which are internal countries, like Germany, Austria and several other countries.
We, as the Government of Spain, from the outset, always advocated reforming the Common European Asylum System; we have always maintained that idea, as we did again at today's meeting. And so, what we must now hope is that in the coming months we can undertake this necessary reform of the Common European Asylum System. We have argued for this, we have advocated this, and we hope that this will be implemented in the near future.
Other questions in relation to the ordinary European Council. Some of the things I have heard spoken about at the informal Council. As regards security, we spoke a great deal about cyber security, about the need to strengthen our capabilities as Member States and as the European Union on cyber security, and, in this regard, strengthen the interoperability of data bases to fight international terrorism.
You also know that the Commission's proposal, accepted by the Council, is to strengthen the capabilities of the European Public Prosecutor's Office on those matters related to the fight against international terrorism.
We, the Government of Spain, have also asked for the European Public Prosecutor's Office to have powers in the fight against human trafficking. Something else that is very important for us; this was an initiative of the Government of Spain and in the end this has taken place - civil protection.
You know that steps are being taken at a European level not to create a FRONTEX-style civil protection body, but to reform and increase the capabilities of the European Union in all matters related to civil protection to tackle natural disasters. Some examples have not only been seen in Europe but also, and in particular, in Spain. Hence, I believe that this initiative, which was backed by all 28 Member States, is good news. First, because it came on a proposal from Spain, and second, because I believe it is very necessary. And this helps build Europe.
Because, in the end, when people see planes dropping water on fires that not only carry the flag of the countries but also of Europe, then they can clearly visualise the usefulness of belonging to the European Union. And strengthening the capabilities to respond of civil protection is very good news in my opinion, above all when faced with such a tremendous challenge as climate change and its consequences.
Two more questions that affect this government, one of which was proposed by the Government of Spain. And that is to declare our commitment as the European Union and as each and every Member States to the 2030 Agenda. This has a great many meanings. The first is to show that the European Union is committed to the 2030 Agenda. The second is that the European Union and all its Member States are committed to the 17 Sustainable Development Goals, And in that regard we are talking about gender equality. We are talking about the fight against climate change. We are talking about social cohesion. We are talking about elements that I feel define the type of Europe we want to see.
And finally, you are aware that, at the end of this year, a COP (Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change) will be held - COP 24, in Katowice, which is a city in Poland. The mandate derives from meeting the commitments taken on under the Paris Agreement, and logically to make them effective and real as soon as possible.
This is the second issue that I would like to share with you. So, Brexit, the Conclusions of the ordinary European Council, and the third is related to the Euro Summit.
We held a lunch for those countries that belong to the Club. Basically, you know that this was an informal meeting with no resolution because what we did was share and analyse, and take stock of the preliminary work done with a view to the Euro Summit to be held in December.
So, what did the Government of Spain advocate there and what, in short, is the roadmap drawn up by the Eurogroup and by Ecofin? Well, we must complete the Banking Union once and for all. And we must complete the Economic and Monetary Union in everything related to the European Stability Mechanism, to the European Deposit Insurance Scheme, to Banking Union, and basically to all the issues that you are aware of.
What contribution has the Government of Spain made? We made the following contribution: we spoke, particularly about Banking Union and the whole financial system, and stated that we now need to start talking about the Fiscal Union.
You know that both the French and German Governments spoke about the need to create an EU Budget at the bilateral meeting they held in Meseberg. That is on the table; we will see what developments have been made in this regard among the Ministers for Economy and Finance of the Eurogroup and Ecofin. We also wanted to propose something that we felt was important and that I want to share with you. As I announced, I advocated this at lunch - this proposal made by the Government of Spain to create a European system for unemployment insurance.
The Government of Spain feels that everything related to the construction of the Economic and Monetary Union, and to Fiscal Union, should include the key element of the creation of the European unemployment system. A European unemployment system that complements, rather than replaces, current national systems by the European Union, thus guaranteeing a suitable level of protection for those citizens worst hit in times of crisis.
Hence, this proposal to create a European unemployment scheme is complementary, rather than a replacement which, above all, seeks to strengthen the European response in a social area to all those citizens that in the future may be affected by an economic crisis.
We have called this "citizen insurance". And we believe that this will strengthen the Economic and Monetary Union and the European project in general, by re-launching a concept that is essential for us as a government, which is European citizenship, the rights of all European citizens.
So, logically, there were countries that took this more sensitively than others, and this is, logically, a debate that we need to have at the level of the Eurogroup, between countries that are members of the Eurozone. At any event, I feel that it is important that the Government of Spain and other governments also encourage this debate, and that we are aware that one thing is talking about Banking Union - which must be completed - and another is talking about the new deposit scheme, but we also need to move towards this Fiscal Union, and as part of this create instruments that truly protect our citizens. And this directly does that. It certainly does.
Hence, the conclusion from this day and a half and, irrespective of the meetings we will hold with the leaders of Asian countries, I believe that this has been a positive and constructive European Council that has made progress on important issues with a view to December in relation to the Euro and also in relation to creating migration policies, and in relation to policies related to security, although we are also dependent upon - because this depends more on the British Government than the other European Governments - the conclusion of the Brexit negotiations.
I will close off my speech now. I am sorry it took so long, but I will now take any questions.
Q.- Jaume Masdeu from " La Vanguardia ". Two questions that are somewhat related to the Draft Budget presented by Spain to Brussels. Tomorrow, I believe, you will receive a letter from the European Commission, the main strands of which I am sure you already know. I wanted to know whether you fear a strong correction to this Draft Budget. And secondly, in relation to the visit that Mr Pablo Iglesias will make tomorrow to Oriol Junqueras. I believe that this visit has created certain division, certain discontent in your party. Is Mr Pablo Iglesias the mediator to seek an agreement on the Budget?
President of the Government .- Let's see, I will answer your second question first, Jaume. I am grateful to Mr Iglesias for his support for the Draft Budget. But I would also remind you that only the government negotiates on its own behalf.
Secondly, the letter. Look, this is the third letter in three years that the Government of Spain has received, following one in 2017 and one in 2016.
The only thing I would ask for is that, given that you are so insistent on the letter, when you see it, compare what we are being asked for in 2018 with what the Government of Spain was asked for in 2016 and 2017. So that you can see the favourable difference in what is asked for this year, in the confidence in the pro-European stance adopted by the Government of Spain, and you will see that this is well received and acknowledged by the EU institutions.
Yesterday, I held a meeting with the two presidents, the Presidents of the European Council and of the European Commission, and the message is fairly clear, or rather very clear, the message is one of confidence in Spain, in its European commitment and in the public accounts we have presented.
Public accounts which it is true perhaps do not sit well with the far right we have in our country, who precisely used the crisis to make cuts in the Welfare State. I am referring to the opposition. But this is a political proposal; it is a Budget proposal that, for the first time in 12 years, contains a primary surplus in our economy, that lowers the structural deficit by 0.4% and that lowers the public debt by almost two points. And which, at the same time, rebuilds part of the Welfare State that was harmed by the wrong economic policy employed, in my opinion, by the previous administration.
Why are we doing this and how will we achieve it? Well, we propose a debate that is necessary in our country, which is a debate on taxation. If we want to enjoy social justice, we need fiscal justice. And precisely tomorrow, at the Council of Ministers, we will propose two royal decree-laws with the tax initiatives necessary to guarantee this public revenue that will allow us to achieve this social cohesion, and meet the public deficit and public debt targets. That is our approach.
The approach is that we are going to meet our deficit targets and our public debt targets, and we are also going to meet our commitment to redistribute this public growth.
Q.- Good afternoon. I wanted to ask you what the letter asks for. The letter asks you to re-submit the Budget to Brussels following its passage through the Lower House of Parliament, because, what they want is to see the details that justify what it promises to achieve. You are being asked for details on the accounts. So, when do you intend to do this? What details do you intend to present to the Lower House?
President of the Government.- Well, thank you Andrés and welcome to this European adventure. Let's see. These public accounts have been endorsed by AIReF, and that is important, because AIReF is an independent institution, precisely set up on a motion from the EU institutions as a result of the bailout of the financial sector that was never acknowledged by the previous government.
They have said that this macro-economic outlook is viable. And hence, I believe that this is backed up, if in addition to the government's opinion, you also take into account the opinion of an independent institution, and I think that if you also add the positive perception, that I can warrant, of the European Commission, to the Draft Budget of the Government of Spain.
But let's not forget one question, which seems fundamental to me. Spain is subject to the Excessive Deficit Procedure. That was not caused by the present government but in fact dates back a long time.
What we have proposed in our forecasts and in our Draft Budget is that, for the first time, Spain will exit this Excessive Deficit Procedure next year. And logically, while a country is subject to this procedure, it is normal that the EU institutions ask for more information from this government.
But I repeat, and this is true, when you see this letter - which you are so interested in - the only thing I would ask of you is that you compare what they said in the past with what they say now. Because you will see that the EU institutions have great confidence in this government and in its commitment to the people.
Now, if you asked I would also say that this confidence is being perceived, and this was explicitly stated by the EU institutions, despite the attempts by the opposition to cause confusion. If they want to extend their level of irresponsibility throughout Europe, that is their choice. The Government of Spain is meeting its targets. And that has been acknowledged and is being acknowledged by the EU institutions.
Q.- Good afternoon, President of the Government. What is your opinion of the Italian budget?
President of the Government.- I am not familiar with it so cannot form an opinion.
Q.- Are you aware of its main strands?
President of the Government.- Only from reading the papers.
Q- Don't you have any opinion in this regard? Could this affect Spain, for example, and the Spanish economy? In its recovery?
President of the Government .- I believe that what could affect Spain is if we present a credible Budget, as we are doing, that is committed to our European obligations. In short, it is down to the European Commission to classify the draft budgets of each and every one of the Member States. I have my hands full with ours.
Q.- Ana Núñez, from " Telecinco ". The letter that some of us have already been able to see says that the Government is making insufficient structural effort and hence it calls for measures, let's say, to offset this insufficient effort. It also queries whether the Budget sent will coincide with the Budget following its passage through the Lower House. So, I don't know whether you have some additional measures on the back-burner to help convince Brussels that this Budget is in line with the main goals. And, "off the record", we know that you described Pablo Casado's attitude as disloyal by coming here to Brussels and asking Angela Merkel to be equally as demanding with the accounts of this government as she was with the previous government of Mariano Rajoy. Can you say this publicly? Do you believe that Pablo Casado is being disloyal to this government? Thank you.
President of the Government.- Well, let's see. As regards the accounts presented by Mr Rajoy, I repeat, when you see the letters sent to the previous governments by the European Commission you will see the degree of plausibility they were given, or not. Hence, perhaps Mr Casado should get his facts straight first. The problem of the opposition is clear; they say what they think. Now, it is quite a different matter for them to think what they say. I believe that it is wrong for a government party to make accusations and work against the interests of their own country outside of Spain. But, in short, everyone has their own way of exercising their role in the opposition; it will then be down to the Spanish people to judge this.
And as regards your first question, I repeat, the European Commission knows that we are going to make a structural effort - the reduction in the structural deficit of 0.4% is significant.
The European Commission knows that we are going to make a fiscal effort. It is true that this is on the backs of those who over the last seven years have not paid as much in taxation as they should have with their economic capacity, whether large corporations, high net worth individuals, those with the highest incomes through Personal Income Tax - which is where we are going to focus this new tax proposal - but the forecasts are what they are.
The Government of Spain has made a commitment, and that is that it will remove our country, for the first time in a great many years, from the Excessive Deficit Procedure. That is the commitment made by the Government of Spain. And, I repeat, this has been taken on-board by the European Commission and the other EU institutions.
Q.- Marisa Doctor, from " Canal Sur TV ". My question is about immigration, not the Budget. As you know, Andalusia is overburdened by the mass influx of immigrants. We have heard many leaders, upon their arrival at this European Council, say that Spain needs to be helped. I wanted to know how this aid will materialise. What commitments have been made here? There was money that needed to be sent to Morocco but which hasn't yet been sent. We need specific measures; it is all well and good strengthening FRONTEX, but what is needed there is funding.
President of the Government .- Well, the Government of Spain has made a budgetary amendment in recent weeks to allocate 40 million euros to attending to unaccompanied foreign minors. And logically the main beneficiary of this will be Andalusia, because it is the region most suffering from this migratory pressure. But I will say to you that, as I mentioned in my opening speech, the European Commission is already talking with the Moroccan Government precisely to unlock significant economic resources in order to increase the capabilities of Morocco to manage its borders.
Morocco is doing an extraordinary task, make a huge effort, to contain and manage the migratory flows arriving from Sub-Saharan Africa. This responds to a consensus and recognition from each and every EU country; and also from the European Commission. And I want to express my gratitude here, moreover, for the effort that the European Commission is making to allocate economic resources and aid to Morocco, precisely to respond to this common challenge.
Q.- Lucía Abellán, from " El País ". President of the Government, I wanted to ask you about negotiations on Gibraltar. What guarantees has the British Prime Minister given you that the pending challenges will be resolved in the coming days, taking into account that the whole Brexit agreement is being called into question? And was the renouncement of the airport finally included in the elements contained in the memorandum? Thank you
President of the Government .- Well, let's see, principally so that we are all clear as to what we are talking about. I feel it is important to have things clear. As regards the whole Brexit process, what we are doing at present is negotiating the agreement, that is called the Withdrawal Agreement of the United Kingdom from the European Union. As part of this Withdrawal Agreement, the European Union and the United Kingdom are negotiating the agreement plus three protocols: Ireland, Gibraltar and Cyprus. This protocol is now firmed up and agreed upon, hence, Gibraltar will not be a problem in reaching a Brexit agreement.
Two, there are four memoranda that the Government of Spain is negotiating with the United Kingdom. If an agreement is reached, then great. If an agreement is not reached, then it doesn't matter. We have time to reach that agreement. Among other things, because the protocol is already in place. It hasn't been signed but it has been concluded. What does the Government of Spain want? To agree on these four memoranda, because we believe that this is important for the region, for Campo de Gibraltar, and also for the people who live in Gibraltar. And hence, what we want is to reach an agreement.
And what we have done, so that you have an idea, is take on the baton from the previous administration. We haven't changed one iota of the negotiation strategy with the United Kingdom on Gibraltar. We consider this to be a State matter, and so we must follow the roadmap set. What does that mean? When I hear certain criticisms from the opposition that we are putting to one side some very important issues such as sovereignty and the airport, then I recall that we have taken the baton from the previous administration in the negotiations on Gibraltar, and we are following to the letter everything that was previously designed.
And as regards what was previously designed, even I have to say that this seems normal and reasonable to me. What we want, above all, is to reach an agreement, and what we want is to offer stability and certainty to citizens in Campo de Gibraltar and in Gibraltar, since those areas where it is clear that we are light years away from reaching an understanding with the United Kingdom, such as the use of the airport, or the question of sovereignty, will be left to one side. We have respected this strategy.
And although we have respected this, we are now seeing that we are being criticised for having respected this, by the same people who designed it. So, I repeat, they say what they think, but they don't think about what they say.
Q.- ¿Memorandum, protocols?
President of the Government .- Let's see, there are two types of negotiation. Firstly, between the European Union and the United Kingdom, which is where the protocol is incorporated on the issue of Gibraltar, and secondly you have bilateral relations between Spain and the United Kingdom, which, so that we understand each other, are the day-to-day issues, such as environmental cooperation, taxation or tobacco.
So, if we reach an agreement, then great. And that is what we want.
Hence, to answer your question, both the Prime Minister and I have agreed to reach an understanding on these four memoranda.
And I should add something else - we appreciate the favourable and positive change in attitude of the British Government to reach an agreement on these four memoranda.
Thank you very much.
Non official translation