Press conference by President of the Government after ruling handed down by Supreme Court on Stamp Duty on mortgage loans
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez held a press conference on 7 November 2018 to announce government measures following the Supreme Court's ruling on stamp duty for mortgage loans.
- Main themes
- Supreme Court ruling on stamp duty for mortgage loans, transfer of stamp duty payment from citizens to banks, Royal Decree-Law amendment, legal certainty in financial sector, Independent Authority to Protect Financial Clients, consumer protection, judicial independence, mortgage loan taxation
- Duration
- ~50 min
- Words
- 6,053
- Sentences
- 269
- Readability
- 56
- Grade
- 10.9
- Syntax
- 3.02
- Vocabulary
- 2.07
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
269 sentences in 94 paragraphs
President of the Government.- Good day to you all. Thank you for attending this press conference.
I want to begin my speech, before taking your questions, by stressing that the government respects, as it has always respected, the work and the independence of the judiciary.
However, the government regrets the situation caused by the ruling handed down by the Supreme Court on 18 October, which culminated yesterday with the announcement by the plenary session of the court stating that this doctrine will be rectified.
This situation, in our opinion, is not positive for the financial institutions, for the judges, and above all and in particular, for our citizens.
Since the outset, this government declared its commitment to legal certainty, firstly, and secondly, to the interests of our citizens.
That is why, within the powers that correspond to the government, we are working to guarantee a foreseeable and stable scenario in the interest of all the operators involved in this ruling handed down yesterday by the Supreme Court.
I spoke with the General Council of the Judiciary yesterday and both today and tomorrow I will speak with the government.
Many citizens who can hear me, who are following this press conference, will share the view with me, I am sure, that the acquisition of a property is a major investment plan, but above all, it is a life plan, that must be endowed with legal certainty.
For that reason, and after seeing the ruling handed down by the Supreme Court, I can announce to you the decision that we will take tomorrow at the Council of Ministers, which will be that Spanish citizens will never again pay this tax, but rather it will be paid by the financial sector, by the banks.
To that end, what we are going to do is to amend the Law Regulating Capital Transfer Tax and Stamp Duty to ensure that banks, rather than clients, pay this tax.
We are doing this just two days after becoming aware of the ruling, that is, tomorrow, through the approval of a Royal Decree-Law that will amend Section 29 of the 1993 Act that regulates this tax. By doing that, it will be clear and final that the payment of the variable quota of Stamp Duty, in the case of mortgage loans, will always correspond to the banks, and never again to the man in the street.
The second announcement I would like to make to you, which is just as important, is that in order to raise the level of protection and rights of financial clients, in the coming weeks the government will submit, for approval by Parliament, the creation of the Independent Authority to Protect Financial Clients.
The government's aim is to guarantee legal certainty for everyone. To that end, the reform will be applied as from the date on which it comes into force. Both the Independent Authority, following its passage through, and approval by, Parliament, and Stamp Duty, as from the day following its approval by the Council of Ministers in the form of a Royal Decree-Law, in other words, the day after Friday, through its publication in the Official Journal of Spain, will come into force.
As regards the Independent Authority, I want to say to you that this authority will step up, which is the goal of its creation, protection from potential abuse and improve the capacity to resolve conflicts which logically arise in the financial sector.
Hence, these are the two measures that I wanted to share with you and convey to the Spanish public. Firstly, the approval of a Royal Decree-Law that will amend this tax so that banks and not the Spanish people pay Stamp Duty. And secondly, the proposal to submit to Parliament in the coming weeks the creation of an Independent Authority to strengthen consumer rights in their relations with the financial sector.
That is what I wanted to announce to you. I will now take any questions.
Q.- Luis Ángel Sanz, from "El Mundo": Good day, President of the Government. As regards the first measure you have announced to us, I wanted to ask you whether you don't feel that the banks are going to charge this tax that they will have to pay as from the approval of this law to their clients, through commissions or some other bank charges. And I wanted to ask you whether the government will be able to prevent this and indeed if it is going to do so.
On another note, your parliamentary partner - Podemos - is calling for people to mobilise in the streets against this ruling. I wanted to ask you whether you share this call to mobilisation and what you feel about demonstrations being assembled at the door to the Supreme Court. Thank you.
President of the Government.- Well, in relation to your second question, thank you Luis Ángel, thank you for your questions, but each political party is free to show its opposition as it sees fit.
We believe that opposition should be shown through institutions, which is why we have the Lower House of Parliament, and Unidos Podemos , like the other parliamentary forces, has the ability to make proposals in the Lower House.
This government is clear. Tomorrow, the government will approve a Royal Decree-Law, which will have to be ratified in the Lower House of Parliament. That is why, as I said before, I spoke yesterday with the judiciary; today and tomorrow I will speak with the government, and we hope that when the Lower House ratifies the law, it has the support of all of the parliamentary forces, including Unidos Podemos .
And in relation to your first question, I believe and I hope not. I believe not because the mortgage market is fairly competitive, in the sense that there is a broad offer, and not only from Spanish banks. We are part of the European Union, and hence, you also have the interest rates and quotas that are offered by other banks.
And secondly, it is also clear that a debate is opening up on whether or not you can have abusive clauses as a result of this repercussion in financial products that have nothing to do with mortgage loans. And in this regard, I call for responsibility from the financial sector.
What the government is doing is clarifying the situation, guaranteeing and strengthening legal certainty and, above all, guaranteeing and strengthening a basic principle for this government, which is equality. And in this regard, I believe that a very significant step forward is being taken through the fact that it will now be the financial sector and never again our citizens who have to pay Stamp Duty.
Q.- Carlos Cue, from "El Pais". Yes, President of the Government, thank you. I wanted to see if we can have your thoughts about whether the credibility of the Supreme Court will not be somewhat undermined precisely at a delicate time as the trial over the independence process, ['procés'] is about to begin. And I wanted to know whether you feel that it is urgent to renew the General Council of the Judiciary and replace Carlos Lesmes, who only has a few weeks left in his post.
And now, on to another matter, which has been talked about a lot this week, which is the possibility of snap elections. You said to us at one point that if the pro-independence movement prioritised the conflict, then we would go to the ballot box. Are we facing imminent elections or do you totally rule this out? Thank you.
President of the Government.- Well, let's see. As regards your first question, on the debate that has opened up as a result of this ruling, regarding the credibility of the Supreme Court. I clearly believe the Supreme Court should think hard about these last two weeks in which it has left not only the financial sector, the financial markets, but obviously also most of the people in this country, on tenterhooks. And I believe that it should take time to reflect, while respecting the independence of the work and of the judiciary, as is only right and proper, since no authority is, let's say, not subject to criticism, and I believe that the judiciary should be somewhat self-critical of what has happened in recent weeks.
Aside from that, I repeat, one thing is the judiciary, and another thing is what the executive and the legislative powers can and should do.
The government acts quickly, expeditiously, because only two days will have elapsed since the final ruling taken by the Supreme Court, after two weeks of deliberations from the time that the plenary session of this court was convened.
Hence, we are going to offer a way out, we are going to offer this legal certainty, we are going to offer this principle of strengthened equality to the people of this country, which is why we have proposed this Royal Decree-Law which we hope will be ratified as soon as possible by Parliament.
Aside from that, I do believe that the Supreme Court needs to critically look at its own actions.
As regards whether this undermines its credibility or not, I believe that is a completely different debate. One thing has nothing to do with another. And hence, I would also like the media to convey this.
And lastly, as regards bring the elections forward or not, the question you asked me is about the pro-independence forces which say that they don't want to approve the Budget.
The question I would like to ask the pro-independence forces is what does a worker in Catalonia who received the minimum wage and the proposal being made by this government to raise this to 900 euros a month next year have to do with the judicial situation of the leaders imprisoned for heading up the 'procés'? What does recovering unemployment benefit for those over the age of 52, which was eliminated by the previous government, have to do with the judicial situation of the leaders of the 'procés'? They obviously have nothing to do with each other.
The Government of Spain governs on behalf of everyone, whoever they may vote for. And what the Regional Government of Catalonia has to do is govern on behalf of all the people of Catalonia. Consequently, the question is whether they agree with raising the minimum wage to 900 euros or not. Whether they agree with recovering this unemployment benefit or not. If they agree with increasing by 600 million euros, which is the proposal we made in the Draft Budget, the provision for the national long-term care system, or housing policies, then I consider that what they should do is support this Budget. And open up this debate in Parliament for its ultimate approval.
Now, I will also say that if they don't want this and they confuse one thing with another, and put the well-being of those workers who are receiving a minimum wage that is so clearly below the figure for their vital needs in the same basket as the procedural situation of those political leaders who are now in prison, then that is their responsibility. Ours is to attend to these urgent social needs. And, if it is not through the Budget, then we will guarantee this through budgetary amendments. That is our commitment. Aside from that, the Constitution establishes who will call the elections, and that is me.
I believe that the good thing about our institutional system, our institutional architecture is that deadlines are met in relation to the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary, and the government is on the case.
Q.- Mercedes Serraller from "Expansión". The Minister for the Treasury quoted the impact of the deficit yesterday as 5 billion euros, and that the regional governments were going to have to take responsibility for this by resorting to the banks. The Bank of Spain, in a report published today, speaks about risks to the banks for these and other activities and for the favourable ruling to consumers. You said that yesterday's ruling by the Supreme Court was not good for anyone, but aside from the image of the Supreme Court, wouldn't it have been a better solution for everyone if the government had promoted a reform to favour citizens?
And then, I wanted to know if you now see the issue as done and dusted, since, if I understood rightly, if will come into force when published in the Official Journal of Spain. Will there be a transitional period? What will happen with outstanding appeals; there may be hundreds of cases subject to retroactivity? And then, do you not fear an avalanche of cases for financial liability against the State, for bad legislation, which could be claimed as far back as 1995 when the Regulation was passed, which would be another kind of different legal action. Thank you very much.
President of the Government.- Well, as regards your second, third and fourth questions, I will say to you that the fiscal rules do not respond to the principle of retroactivity. That is clear. Just look at case law.
And, in the first instance, I say to you that we are approving this Royal Decree-Law and consequently, we are providing a response to a situation that has been caused by several different rulings handed down by the Supreme Court. I don't think there is anything else to say on the matter.
Q.- Juan Antonio Nicolay from "Cuatro". President of the Government, as a result of the first ruling by the Supreme Court on this matter, which is what led to the controversy, some people spoke about judicial populism. I don't know whether today's decision is then executive populism. And my second question, the radical change of criteria by the Supreme Court has given rise to speculation. Do you feel that it would be opportune for the judges that took such a radical decision to publish their declaration of interests in the stock market, for example?
President of the Government.- Well, thank you Juan Antonio for your questions. The truth is that as regards your second question, allow me to first find out the details regarding this. I don't have the information right now to make a statement on this issue. And as regards the first question, I think it should be you and the commentators who analyse exactly what description to give to this decision. The adjective that the government uses is responsibility, social commitment, the guarantee of legal certainty, and of safeguarding the principle of the equality of all citizens.
And, then, you are there to classify this and employ the adjective you see fit.
Q.- Teresa Loureiro from "es.radio". Yes, good afternoon, President of the Government, I would like to ask you three questions. The first is whether the government has thought about eliminating the mortgage tax. The second is about your change in criteria; you said, before becoming President of the Government that the criminal offence of rebellion had been committed in the case of those being prosecuted for the 1 October referendum. And you also stressed at the time that the offence of rebellion had been committed and so I would like to know why you no longer hold that opinion. And also, as regards the question of confidence and elections, you said that if a government was unable to approve the Budget then it should be subject to a vote of confidence or call early elections. I would like to know whether you still hold with that criterion. Thank you.
President of the Government.- Yes, thank you Teresa. As regards the first of your question, what we want is for the banks to pay this tax, and not the people. Those who propose to eliminate this tax should speak with the regional presidents. And the regional presidents will tell them whether they agree or not to lose part of the revenue they collect from this tax.
I repeat, we believe that this is good for the autonomous regions, which manage healthcare, long-term care, education, etc. These are issues that are perhaps beyond the scope of political parties as they do not manage them; they don't see them as so important as perhaps a progressive option, such as we represent, and hence they consider that it is best to eliminate it. We believe that the banks must pay this and not the people.
Secondly, look, as regards the issue of rebellion, sedition, misuse of public funds, it will not be the government or the opposition who decides this, but the judiciary, the justice system. Hence, let's let justice work.
And thirdly, what is a priority and urgent for me, and what I place above any other consideration is that we raise the minimum wage for workers and help them recover the rights that have been cut over recent years as a result of conservative political ideologies. Aside from that, if this is through the Budget, then great, and if not, then through amendments to the Budget we have at this time.
Q.- Yolanda Mármol, from "El Periodico". Good afternoon, President of the Government. I wanted to ask you about the budget amendments. Can you tell is what they consist of and whether you are indeed going to present the Budget now, as the government announced, which would be during the course of December, and if the government is going to go ahead with the measure announced by the Ministry of the Treasury to increase the contribution from the financial institutions to the Deposit Guarantee Fund and thus avoid any new public aid going to the banks this year. Is that still on course or not. Thank you.
President of the Government.- Well, as regards your last question, that is for the Minister for the Economy to respond to at the right time.
And in relation to your first question, I repeat, we want to approve the Budget because we want to see a Budget that responds to common sense. When we talk about raising the minimum wage there will be workers on the minimum wage who do not vote for the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party that I represent; they may vote for Ciudadanos , Podemos , or for pro-independence parties. Why? Why shouldn't they have this salary increase when we are growing and this growth is being redistributed in another way?
Why can't we improve the financing of our education system? Is that something that only affects the potential voters of the Socialist Party or the majority of society who take our sons and daughters to public schools? I believe that the latter rather than the former. And hence, I believe that if this is a Budget that responds to common sense, then what we should ask is for the Lower House as a whole to undertake an exercise in institutional responsibility which will allow it to be passed. I am not only looking at the nationalist parliamentary forces, as I said before, I am also looking at Ciudadanos and at the People's Party, and I demand responsibility from them, and a sense of State. They should put their hand-waving to one side, act responsibly, and make themselves useful to society as a whole.
We are also willing to speak with them regarding why they like this Budget less than others, and how we can improve it. Why avoid this debate? We don't want to avoid it, but rather will assume our responsibility now. Firstly, by presenting the Budget, and secondly, in the event that this Budget does not receive sufficient support, by proposing improvements that I believe are beneficial to our citizens as a whole, whoever they may vote for.
That is why I feel it is irresponsible of the pro-independence forces to flatly refuse to push through this Budget which is good for the people of Catalonia, whoever they may vote for, because there are many people in Catalonia who receive the minimum wage.
And Catalonia, it should be remembered, is the autonomous region to have suffered the greatest cuts in recent years in public health and education. Why renounce greater funding? Why renounce better infrastructures? Particularly when I have heard the pro-independence parties in recent years say that one of the reasons why the pro-independence movement has grown so much in Catalonia has been because of a lack of investment in infrastructures. Part of this investment will be recovered, while the new approach being adopted at this time is to not even help push through this Budget.
That seems irresponsible to me, and irresponsible to all the people of Catalonia whom they should be governing.
But, I repeat, I am not only looking in that direction. The government is also looking towards Ciudadanos and towards the People's Party and demanding that they assume their responsibility as well, for their opposition to be a State opposition and a useful opposition. And useful means opening up a debate on how much a worker should earn as a salary, which means the minimum wage.
This debate is being opened up throughout the world, so why can't that happen in Spain? Even the People's Party acknowledges this. Let's talk about it.
Q.- Juanma Romero from "El Confidencial". Good afternoon, President of the Government. I wanted to ask you, in relation to mortgages, whether you consider that clients should be able to claim financial liability from the State and apply for the reimbursement of the tax.
Secondly, as regards the Budget, I wanted to ask you, coming back to the question from my colleague, Yolanda Mármol, what schedule you have planed, and when will you present this Budget to the Lower House, when will we see that you don't have enough support to push it through and hence that you will start to pass Royal Decree-Laws?
I also guess from your previous answers that you plan to see out this term of office, as you have mentioned on other occasions. I wanted to ascertain whether that is indeed the case.
And I also wanted to address another matter, which has also been fairly controversial. In recent weeks, on the matter of the exhumation and re-burial of Francisco Franco, I wanted to ask you, given that the People's Party and Ciudadanos intend to stretch out the parliamentary procedures, and this would make it impossible to exhume the remains before the end of the year, what complementary mechanisms the government plans to broker to guarantee that this can be achieved swiftly, or do you already accept that this will be at the start of 2019?
President of the Government.- Thank you, Juanma, for your questions. The first one is not down to me. It is not down to me to say to our citizens whether they have that ability or not. The second question, in relation to the schedule, this remains the same - in December. The third, the answer is yes. I want to see out this term of office because the government is pushing through important reforms for our citizens as a whole, which are related to recovering rights and liberties, and with re-building the Welfare State.
And fourthly, I simply want to clarify to you that it is not how you have outlined it. The administrative procedure is what it is. At tomorrow's Council of Ministers we will precisely finalise one of the administrative procedures regarding the exhumation of the dictator. What I can guarantee is that the government is determined to exhume the dictator in 2019, finally, and 41 years on there will be no mausoleum that pays tribute in our country to the dictator Franco. And hence, we are undergoing an administrative process at this time, which has nothing to do with our wishes to speed up or not the procedures on the part of the Government of Spain.
This is an administrative process. We explained when this administrative process commenced that we wanted to offer the maximum guarantees possible. It will now rest in the hands of the Regional Government of Madrid, and also in the Local Council of San Lorenzo del Escorial. Subsequently, once again, the Franco family will be able to file pleas, because we want this to be a procedure that offers the maximum guarantees possible. And then, aside from how long the administrative process lasts, and I don't know whether this will be in December or in January, we will clearly proceed to exhume the dictator.
This has nothing to do with the much criticised administrative obstacles and burdens, or rather parliamentary obstacles that the right-wing of the People's Party and Ciudadanos have got us used to in the Lower House of Parliament.
Just look, even today I just heard the General Secretary of the People's Party say that he wanted to file an amendment to another law on the issue of Stamp Duty. Just imagine that!
Q.- Juande Portillo from "Cinco Dias". Good afternoon, President of the Government. I wanted to know whether the government is concerned that yesterday's ruling by the Supreme Court may be a false closure of the debate and that the issue may end up being referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union and that we may be facing a case such as with the 'floor clauses', and that once again public resources of the regional governments amounting to some 5 billion euros may be at stake. And secondly, I also wanted to know whether the government, beyond this legal change as to who should pay the mortgage tax, is in favour and will foster a more specific distribution of the expenses for arranging a mortgage and also clarify, once and for all, who should be responsible for the fees for the administrative agency, the notary public, the property registry, and whether you feel it is necessary to do this through the mortgage reform. Thank you.
President of the Government.- Well, I believe that the debate you have pointed to is precisely the passage of the Mortgage Act through Parliament, taking place at this time. That is why what we are doing, and what we are going to propose tomorrow, is the approval of a Royal Decree-Law to act on the law regulating this tax. And everything related to the mortgage market is now under debate in the Lower House of Parliament. A paper will be presented, if I remember rightly, next week and hence there are obviously many aspects that must be addressed in the passage of this new law through Parliament, where I hope I will be able to count on the consensus of a majority of the House.
And, as regards your first question, it is not a question of whether I am worried by this or not, they are within their rights to do so. Hence, we live in a social and democratic State under the rule of law and they are entitled to do so.
Q.- Eduardo Ortega from "El Economista". Good day, President of the Government. I have two questions. Firstly, if you believe that these alternatives which will be approved by the Council of Ministers will receive parliamentary support, above all, the second of them. And I also wanted to ask you about the banking tax. I don't know if this change of context offered by the ruling of the Supreme Court means that the government does not intend to take this reform on again, above all in light of the fact that both AIReF and other economic bodies consider that the forecast revenue submitted to Brussels for next year would not manage to reach the level of the government's forecasts and that, by implementing this tax, another 1 billion euros would be collected.
President of the Government.- Well Eduardo, as regards your second question, this will all depend a great deal on whether or not the Budget is approved. If the Budget is extended, then quite clearly we cannot increase taxes that are already registered in the General State Budget, much less create new ones, can we? We have proposed the Financial Transactions Tax and the Tax on Large Technology Companies.
What the Government of Spain is saying is that this tax already exists, and simply that it should be paid by the banks and not by our citizens.
And as regards whether we believe that these two issues will be able to count on sufficient parliamentary support, I hope so. I have listened to the parliamentary forces and, albeit with some amendments, everyone agrees on the direction taken by the Government of Spain. Hence, I not only believe this, but I also call on their responsibility.
Q.- Carles Castellnou from "TV3". Thank you, President of the Government. I have two questions for you. The first, aside from the fact that you say that you respect the independence of the judiciary, is that I wanted to ask you about the President of the Supreme Court, Mr Lesmes who, in some way, was the person who two weeks ago paralysed a final ruling which, in the end has been changed, and he has even said in a statement made a few minutes ago that the problem was that the law wasn't clear. And you, in some way, called for a certain reflection from the judiciary and he, perhaps, isn't on the same wavelength.
And secondly, and the fact that he is here, and given the current situation in Catalonia where the pro-independence forces are telling you that they are not going to offer their support to the Budget, I was wondering whether a meeting with Regional President Torra is pending. And furthermore, whether a Council of Ministers will be held in Barcelona before the year is out. Thank you.
President of the Government.- Thank you, Carlos. As regards your last question, a meeting of the Council of Ministers will indeed be held in Barcelona in December. And yes, I will meet up with Regional President Torra in the run-up to this Council of Ministers, if he wants. I, of course, am willing to.
In terms of your first question, in relation to the President of the Supreme Court, I am sorry to disagree with him when he talks about the mortgage law not being clear. We are talking about a law that regulates stamp duty, which are two different matters. One is the mortgage law, which is processed through the Lower House of Parliament and the other is the law that regulates this duty. And we are acting on this law that regulated this duty.
Q.- Víctor Ruiz de Almirón from "ABC". President of the Government, good day. A couple of things about issues you have mentioned. I wanted to know whether you have spoken with the regional presidents because you have said that we should ask the regional presidents what they think about eliminating this tax, so I wanted to know whether you had spoken with them. And whether the government assessed at some time the option of eliminating the tax altogether, which you finally ruled out.
And then, on the matter of the Budget, and regarding insisting on talking with Ciudadanos and the People's Party, my question is, if this finally takes place, in what situation would your alliance and agreement with Unidos Podemos be? Because you know better than anyone what happens when you try and unite Podemos and Ciudadanos . I don't know what formula or mathematical possibility you would be envisaging by opening up this option. Thank you.
President of the Government.- Thank you, Victor. As regards the regional presidents, let's see, I will leave you with the following thought. In the month of June/July, the Government of Spain proposed a path of stability, which would increase the capabilities of each and every regional government to the total sum of some 6 billion euros. In other words, what we were proposing was for the regional governments to have more financial resources to fund education, healthcare, long-term care, social services, etc. The People's Party and Ciudadanos rejected this; they said no. They will have to answer for this in the regional and municipal elections, including in the elections in Andalusia on 2 December for their position on this matter. I won't get involved, I will just leave you with that thought.
Now, as well as rejecting 6 billion euros more for the regions, there is one political party that says that a tax should be eliminated that, let's say, helps fill the coffers of the regional governments. Well this party will have to speak with its regional presidents because when I speak with their regional presidents the only thing they ask me for is more financial resources for long-term care, for healthcare, for education and for infrastructures… For me the accounts don't balance. These people need to be more coherent. If they want fewer financial resources, that means they want less Welfare State powers in the hands of the regional governments. It is not possible to have everything, unless they are fooling themselves. I will leave this for the journalists to analyse and assess.
And, as regards your first question, let's see, is this a progressive Budget? The answer is yes. Is this a Budget that responds to common sense? Yes it is. Is this a European Budget in the sense that it takes into account all the rules under the Growth and Stability Pact, and precisely what it will do is take Spain out from under the corrective arm of the Excessive Deficit Procedure? Yes, it is. Furthermore, just look, if we extended the budget, the public deficit would be higher than the Draft Budget we are proposing.
Hence, the opposition, to some extent, is contradicting itself, because it doesn't support this Budget saying that it is too expansive and that the public deficit must be lower. But, on the other hand, if the Budget is extended the public deficit will be higher than that which we are proposing.
In short, what do I mean by this? If this is a Budget that responds to common sense, if this is a Budget that benefits almost 20 million Spaniards directly in terms of pensions, minimum wage, unemployment benefit, nonprofessional long-term carers, housing, science, education… Well, we are prepared to talk with the rest of the parliamentary forces, logically, without questioning the agreement we have already reached. But, I repeat, I call for responsibility. If they don't want this Budget, they will have to explain why.
It is interesting how some people accuse me of being complicit in repression while others accuse me of kowtowing to the pro-independence forces. It is impossible to be both things at once, it must be either one of the other; both are impossible. Isn't it more likely that both groups are complicit in the same error, which is precisely of continuing to contribute to regional and political confrontation? Well, the Socialist Party and the Government of Spain are not going to take part in that game.
Q.- Gabriel Sanz from "Voz Populi". Good afternoon, President of the Government. I wanted to ask you about the Budget, which you say you still trust will be pushed through, but you have also said that if it is not approved, then you will effectively approve it via Royal Decrees and Decree Laws and amendments. My question is, if you are going to leave this until after 1 January to increase, for example, the minimum wage, as Podemos demands, or will you wait and give it time, given that the Council of Ministers will present Parliament with the Draft Law in December, or later on, in February or March, in other words, what term will you allow to see if there if fuel in the tank?
President of the Government.- We will offer a response to this unknown in December, Gabriel.
Any more questions?
Q.- We understand that the response from your partners, your potential partners, will start to apply to the measures that would not be applicable in a Budget that wouldn't be approved through Royal Decrees and Decree Laws.
President of the Government.- If you are asking me whether the minimum wage will come into force on 1 January, it is very much the government's intention to do so.
Thank you very much
Non official translation