Speech by President of the Government at meeting of daily paper "Expansión"
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez addressed the executive committee and editorial team of the Spanish financial daily 'Expansión' on 12 November 2018, outlining Spain's economic outlook and government priorities.
- Main themes
- Spanish economic growth, inclusive growth and well-being, economic cycle sustainability, unemployment reduction, labour market reform, public debt reduction, institutional quality, eurozone comparison, economic policy duties, social democracy and liberalism
- Duration
- ~35 min
- Words
- 4,231
- Sentences
- 162
- Readability
- 44
- Grade
- 13.4
- Syntax
- 3.25
- Vocabulary
- 2.10
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other162 sentences in 69 paragraphs
Ladies and gentlemen of the executive committee of the editorial unit. Madam Director, dear Ana, of the daily newspaper "Expansión". Sponsors, journalists, public officials, dear friends at "Expansión".
Keynes said that our problem, that of democracies, is to build a social organisation that is as efficient as possible without subverting our idea of a satisfactory way of life. In my opinion, there is no better definition for a government's mission.
The British economist spoke to us of the great goal of the whole of society, of all good governments, which is to guarantee well-being and prosperity for everyone. This well-being begins with growth, without a doubt, but it goes far beyond that and calls for inclusive growth which we haven't seen for many years, unfortunately.
Last Thursday, the European Commission published, as you are well aware, its macro-economic forecasts for the period 2018 to 2020. This confirmed to us what the Bank of Spain, AIReF and the consensus of various private analysts had already estimated, as well as the government in its own estimates: the Spanish economy will continue heading up economic growth in the Eurozone to stand above our peer economies.
It also said to us that the unemployment rate will continue to fall to stand at 13.3% by 2020 (the lowest rate since 2008). And that the current expansive cycle of the Spanish economy still has many boom years ahead. The latest national accounting figures, corresponding to the third quarter, point to the Spanish economy not only responding well to the slowdown, as mentioned earlier by Ana in her speech, that the international economy and, in particular, the economy of the Eurozone, is experiencing, but it has even grown slightly more than in the first half of the year. Specifically, Spain's GDP grew by 0.6% in the last quarter, compared with 0.2% in the Eurozone, 0.4% in France while it remained flat in Italy (we don't have the figure for Germany yet but it will probably not be above 0.2%). In terms of the next few years, the forecasts by the European Commission point to almost 1% more growth of the Gross Domestic Product in Spain, in other words 0.9 points of GDP, than Germany in 2018 and 0.4 points more in 2019; 0.9 points more than France in 2018 and 0.6 points more in 2019; and 1.5 points more than Italy in 2018 and 1 point more in 2019.
I believe we all agree on our sound economic outlook. And, despite that, as Antonio and Ana both rightly pointed out before, it is true that many qualified voices exist that are wondering about the duration of the current expansive cycle. I am sure that some of you are wondering the same thing at this time, and I am sure that you are doing this in a reasoned and informed fashion, as I would expect. In this regard, I would like to leave you with a thought and see if you share my analysis and help us to all dispel together any doubts we may have.
In my opinion, economic cycles, dear friends, do not die of old age. And if that is the case, this cycle is still young in an historical sense. In my opinion, economic cycles dry up due to an accumulation of fundamental imbalances; for example, private debt, which has been falling over recent years; the public debt, as Antonio rightly pointed out before, which the Government of Spain proposes to reduce by 2 points of the Gross Domestic Product in budgetary terms, for the first time in many years; the balance of the current account, which continues to post a surplus; the unemployment rate which clearly, as I said before, is falling and which will see significant reductions both this year and the next compared with other countries in the Eurozone and the EU, and which will undoubtedly be lower than those recorded in 2009 and 2010, and will be in line with the rate recorded in the years prior to the crisis. And not only this, I also believe that one of the main imbalances in the labour market is related to temporary and permanent employment contracts. On this matter, I would also like to underline that the number of permanent employment contracts recorded in the month of October has beaten all records, with a 19% rise on October 2017.
And not just this. Economic cycles are as robust as the State is in performing its economic duties. Firstly, defending institutional quality, which Antonio succinctly mentioned in his speech earlier; fostering competition, which I believe is closely related to liberalism, which Ana mentioned in her speech before, and which we, as social democrats, also agree with; the provision of goods and services; and economic justice. These are the four keys, the four duties which, in my opinion, the public sector must perform in terms of economic policy.
Whether economic policies are discussed thoroughly and transparently, whether they are appropriately legislated on, whether they are implemented in due time and form, whether they are complied with, depends, in the end, on the smooth functioning of institutions and on their democratic quality. And on the executive, of course. But they also depend on the other State powers, which are obviously the legislative and the judiciary. I believe that this is the primary obligation of the State, of the public sector, in relation to the smooth functioning of the economy - the defence of institutional quality.
Only following that is it possible to define the game plan. The game plan must be effective to guarantee prosperity and growth. But is must also be economically fair to guarantee social cohesion. The conflict between efficiency and equality, or between growth and distribution, is one of the issues most extensively tackled in economic literature. Decades, if not centuries, of economic thought have allowed progress to be made on understanding the virtues and limitations of the markets.
For example, economic theory has shown that when companies and consumers lack the ability to set prices or influence them unilaterally, the markets optimise the collective interest. We all agree on that: this allows greater exchanges of goods and services at a lower price than any other market structure. In practice, however, I believe that we all agree that this situation is the exception rather than the rule. To the extent that large companies acquire the ability to influence global prices, the markets adopt operating structures that are increasingly less competitive and move further away from the collectively optimum situation. The last stage of this dynamic is the formation of oligopolies and monopolies.
This is the State's second economic obligation: to foster competition without which the markets are undermined. We are talking, as you are well aware, about eliminating barriers on entering and exiting the markets; of preventing and sanctioning collusive practices; of avoiding the existence of privileges in certain sectors of activity; of combating the asymmetries of information which undoubtedly exist in many markets (there you have the example of the financial sector); of regulating natural monopolies; of incentivising the correction of externalities, which exist and thus must be acknowledged (this is an externality), etc. In short, of fostering, in my opinion, equal competitive opportunities - a level playing field where the best player wins.
Now, ladies and gentlemen, it is not enough to foster the necessary conditions for competition. I wonder, can the markets, even those that are perfectly competitive, provide basic services such as justice, national defence, citizen security, healthcare, education or the culture of universal accessibility? According to the Nobel Prize Winner for Economics in 2014, Jean Tirol, and one of the most renowned theorists of market regulation, this type of service cannot be offered by private enterprise without this restricting its access by price, quantity or quality.
The second question I would like to think about with you is, can these same markets administer those goods that have a value but lack a price, such as ecological or environmental assets? According to the first and only woman to date to have received the Nobel Prize for Economics, Elinor Ostrom, in 2009, these types of goods, without public intervention, are doomed to be over-exploited, and even to become extinct. To some extent, that is what we are already seeing today.
That is, thus, in my opinion, the State's third obligation as regards the economy: to directly provide, finance or administer certain goods and services that private initiative is not in a position to offer. By this I am not saying that it should be solely and exclusively responsible for managing the public sector. Ways can be sought, let's say, of forging public-private collaboration, but clearly without the cooperation and leadership of the public sector we would be facing the risks that I mentioned before.
And the State is under a fourth key obligation, in my opinion, which is the defence, if not the promotion, of what is called economic justice. I would like to share this concept with you. Although we can all describe a situation as fair or unfair, there are no universal criteria that allow us to objectively define what is understood as economic justice. That is why we need rules. We need a social contract that the economic crisis clearly swept away, not just in Spain, but also in Europe and in a good many of our societies. And this leads us, in short, to the question of the correct functioning of our social and democratic State under the rule of law, as Antonio quite rightly mentioned before.
The markets cannot provide the right response to the lack of equal opportunities. A society that does not want to regulate itself by the factor of class must decide between the undoubted right of individuals to prosper from the fruits of their efforts, and the distribution of the income necessary to ensure that equal opportunities become a reality for everyone.
In short, the markets, in my opinion, have no response to games of chance. No-one is condemned to bad luck; we saw that during the crisis. Just a few days ago, I had the chance to meet up with the RAIS Foundation, a foundation that is precisely in charge of protecting and provide a roof for the homeless. And don't think that those people who are living in the streets at this time have not studied, or don't have professional qualifications. These are people who, some years ago, would probably be in similar situations to where we are right now. So, no-one is condemned to bad luck; this may come from an illness, a family drama, an economic crisis or a natural disaster…
If we think, as I believe all of us here do think, that it is not acceptable to place all our trust in family solidarity, which is of course important, or in charity, then we have to admit that it is the State, that is, the public sector, that must design a dignified response that guarantees this economic justice.
Ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, the government firmly intends to tackle these key obligations that define the role of the public sector in the economy. Not only from the arguable point of view of what everyone may consider to mean building a better world, but also from the point of view of pure pragmatism, to ensure that the potential growth of our economy in the long term does not decline, but actually, increases.
That is why I want to announce to you that the government is working on a reform plan, the main pillars of which can be found in what we coined the Agenda of Change, being headed up by Minister Calviño, part of which I will outline for you in the next few minutes. I would like to call on you here and now so that, between us all, we can improve this plan. We want you to collaborate with us in its design and its development.
In my opinion, transformations are necessary in our country, reforms, as described by Antonio and Ana in their speeches, which I, to summarise them, would place in five main blocks:
1.The first is related to education. And within education, we can incorporate vocational training, active employment policies and the training policies that a country needs where one of the main challenges within the framework of the fight against unemployment is long-term unemployment.
2. The second transformation is that of the labour market and our business fabric, above all something that Ana mentioned in her speech, which is, of course, the digital economy and the re-industrialisation that our country needs.
3. The third is related to the debate on how to finance our Welfare State: the healthcare we want, the public pension system we want, the education system we want, the long-term care system we want. In short, the Welfare State we want. Do we want to be on a par with Germany and France, or do we want to be at the bottom of the EU ranking? That is the debate. Aside from that, fiscal policy can be designed for each political project.
4. The fourth great transformation is the ecological transition. The electricity market, the bill that we have seen grow in recent months in an extraordinary fashion. The energy transition we need in our country. These are matters you are very familiar with.
5. And the fifth transformation, and on this I don't wish to disagree with Antonio but simply add something to what he said, I believe that it is important to reform our Constitution to strengthen this constitutional pact that we will celebrate in its fortieth year in December, in order to extend rights, recognise new liberties and even new realities that did not exist in our country 40 years ago. And also, logically, to significantly enhance our territorial unity. And on this question, you are aware that last Saturday I announced the government's firm intention to present a reform, which I believe will be able to count on broad-based support from the Lower House, which is the elimination of privilege, particularly for MPs, something that is already taking place under several statutes of autonomy, the latest being the Statute of Autonomy of the Canary Islands, and which we believe should also be passed on to national politics.
We have seen governments, dear friends, with larger parliamentary majorities afflicted by political paralysis, under which Spain has wasted time, in my opinion, time that was precious for addressing these tasks. A paralysis that also affected a fundamental pillar of the economy, which is foreign action. In these last few months, I have even been criticised for spending too much time outside of our country when what we have done is seek to recover Spain's place in Europe, but also, and particularly, in Latin America.
This week the Head of State and I will attend the Ibero-American Summit in Guatemala because we are fully aware that the future of our economy lies in greater internationalisation, above all where we have strong economic and trade ties, which undoubtedly means the Ibero-American Community.
Aware of this reality, you know that in the coming weeks the Government of Spain will also make its first official visit to Cuba in 36 years. We will also take a significant representation of business leaders with us to that country, a sister nation, a country we must not forget, which has been unfortunately abandoned in recent years to seek opportunities in other countries with which we have no historical, cultural or affective ties.
The previous government, in my opinion, camouflaged its reformist laziness by lowering salaries and making the economy more precarious, a delusion that stopped working to the extent that the tailwinds ran out of steam, which is, in short, what has happened in our country. Some of these tailwinds, such as a more expansive monetary policy, or lower oil prices, have meant that we have grown more than expected.
Spain must be, in my opinion, at the forefront of the new economy, but without forgetting the social rearguard. These are aspects that are not only compatible, in my opinion, but essential.
The economic crisis derived from an institutional and political crisis - which Antonio also mentioned in his speech - which has taught us many things. I would also like to add some further thoughts to what he said earlier.
In my opinion, what this crisis has taught us, and also the political reaction that a good many Spanish citizens have seen, must lead us to take away an important lesson, which is that inclusive growth and social well-being are the best vaccination against the authoritarianism of the enemies of democracy and liberty.
And if this lack of inclusive growth and prosperity reaching the social majority of the country is unsustainable in economic matters, recently we have seen in several countries, not in Spain fortunately but in other countries, that this is also the case in political matters.
In my opinion, we have seen in recent years that there was never room on the social ladder of neo-liberalism for everyone. Social unrest is never good for economies, nor for open societies like ours. Those of us who believe in them, in open societies, in free, social, market economies, must take the initiative.
Ladies and gentlemen,
The Spanish economy is not what it was a decade ago. At present, it is growing in a much more balanced fashion. Take the construction sector, which has taken onboard the excesses of the crisis and begun a new expansive cycle without the burdens of the past.
The foreign trade sector has undergone a transformation that can only be described, in my opinion, as exceptional. The figure for the balance of the current account in 2008 showed a deficit equivalent to 10% of GDP and yet, as from the start of the economic recovery a surplus has been posted, which you are well aware of, standing at around 2% of GDP. In other words, the Spanish economy now exports goods and services to the rest of the world that are 90 billion euros higher than what we exported 10 years ago.
And not just this, we are also less dependent on imports, because close on 20 billion euros less of imports are being acquired than in 2008. And yet, despite this, it is more than clear that we need to undertake a broad, credible and realistic reform to face the future in optimum conditions. Because the credibility of a government is measured by its reformist ambition. This is the case of the reforms undertaken in the last five months and the Agenda for Change that we are designing.
This is a raft of measures designed to improve our infrastructures, our pillars of economic growth, that will allow us to combat inequality, which I believe is one of the main outstanding tasks, including in terms of economic policy. Measures that guarantee the sustainability of our economy and its competitiveness; that improve the functioning of our labour market; and that transform the public authorities into dynamic facilitators.
Allow me to announce some of these measures:
As regards the labour market, which you will remember was the second of the main transformations I mentioned, together with the business fabric; in the next few weeks we are going to approve a series of measures to improve the labour market, particularly to prevent two of its main faults: inequality and its current duality.
Among other measures, we are going to recover the value of collective bargaining; we are going to strengthen the causality of temporary employment; we are going to recover forced retirements on grounds of age, as an employment policy within the framework of collective bargaining; and we are also going to establish an obligatory register of hours worked to avoid exploitation, abuses and to facilitate the resolution of discrepancies.
Furthermore, we will continue debating, within the framework of social dialogue, with business owners and trade unions, a radical simplification of the number of contracts, essentially leaving three forms of contract: permanent, temporary and training.
And we also want to substantially reduce the number of discounts and deductions on hiring, leaving only those that affect the most vulnerable and the most needy groups.
In this area, the last announcement I want to share with you is that we will approve, before the end of the year, an action plan to create jobs for our youngest workers - an action plan for young people - placing great emphasis on improving digital skills and foreign language skills. This plan will include measures to support young people overseas, with specific and comprehensive actions that will incentivise their return, and that of their talent, to Spain.
As regards the first major transformation - education - I wanted to make an aside on dual vocational training. It is fundamental for our workers to adapt to new times and become more productive. I believe we all agree on that.
In this field, we are shortly going to present a Vocational Training Act to develop a model of dual vocational training, incorporating companies through flexible formulas and creating consortia throughout the country.
At an institutional and supervisory level, we are going to propose certain measures related to the financial sector.
I believe that the financial crisis has shown us that we need better tools to prevent financial and credit bubbles that can end up causing major economic crises of a systemic nature, as we have seen in recent decades.
We have already announced the strengthening of the institutional architecture of the regulatory and supervisory bodies, within the field of financial governance, through the creation of a macro-prudential authority to be known as the National Financial Stability Authority, and precisely last Thursday the Council of Ministers also set up the Independent Authority to Protect Financial Clients. These are two commitments that are included in the Agenda for Change.
These, I believe, are important reforms, in line with what is being called for from Europe, and which, in my opinion and that of my government, will clearly serve to improve the functioning of our financial markets.
The fourth question I would like to propose is related to the ecological transition. The Agenda for Change will include a Climate Change and Energy Transition Act, which will be presented before the end of the year. This Act will tackle actions to comply with the Paris Agreement and with European commitments on energy and climate to be met by 2030. Under this law and other actions set out in the Agenda for Change, the goal is to boost renewable energies and also facilitate self-consumption, something I believe we have started to ensure by eliminating the so-called "Sun Tax".
And we are also going to tackle sustainable mobility through the 2014-2020 Strategy to Boost Alternative Energy Vehicles in Spain.
In short, our reformist agenda is firm, and I believe that the General State Budget and the proposal we have made to the different parliamentary groups is an important tool for implementing this.
At present, as you know, the Budget is undergoing a period of negotiation with the different parliamentary forces. We want this Budget to be approved. We will not throw in the towel, which is why we have stretched out our hand to the other parliamentary forces.
But let me tell you something else: the Budget is not the only tool available to the government.
And true to the commitment we took on with the Spanish people to regenerate the political and economic life of our country, we will push on with these reforms through budgetary amendments if we do not manage to reach agreement on the National Budget. We owe this to the social majority of citizens in our country. And if the case arises, it will be others who will need to explain why they rejected this Budget.
In my opinion, this is the time for reform and this Budget proposes the first main cornerstones of these great transformations, of these five transformations that I have mentioned.
Ladies and gentlemen,
I believe that we need to take a clear course, with a clear horizon, and also with the firm determination to tackle the reforms that Spain and the Spanish people need. And that is what this government is offering.
We are aware that this task involves everyone, that major changes take place when society as a whole takes on these challenges as its own and assimilates the economic changes that business leaders and political leaders implement.
That is why we hold out the flag of dialogue, of agreement and consensus and between the different parties and also between the different regions, I feel that it is important to underline this; between the different social and economic stakeholders, and of course, to the benefit of the social majority of our country.
Along the lines of the beginning of my speech, this seeks to be the best government, at the level of the best society, capable of guaranteeing economic growth and, in short, prosperity for one and all.
In this regard, dear Ana, dear Antonio, I would like to end by wishing you the very best on this anniversary and carry on writing, even though it may be critically, about the good actions of this government.
Thank you very much.
(Transcription edited by the State Secretariat for Communication)
Non official translation