Reply by President of the Government to all parliamentary parties in plenary session of Lower House of Parliament, dedicated to next meeting of European Council
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez addressed the Spanish Lower House on June 27, 2018, responding to parliamentary parties ahead of the European Council meeting on migration.
- Main themes
- Migration and refugee crisis, European Council meeting, solidarity and human rights, Aquarius rescue ship, EU migration policy, demographic pressures in Africa, Schengen and freedom of movement, economic and monetary integration, parliamentary accountability, external border control, secondary movements and asylum
- Duration
- ~62 min
- Words
- 7,382
- Sentences
- 262
- Readability
- 49
- Grade
- 13.3
- Syntax
- 3.29
- Vocabulary
- 2.04
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other262 sentences in 69 paragraphs
I will try to speak and answer all the Members of Parliament who have participated in this debate, going from the smallest to the largest party, and I will therefore begin with Mr Xuclá, the representative of PdeCat.
First of all, I would like to thank Mr Xuclá for recognising that what the President of the Government is really doing is to appear before the European Council meeting is held, because I believe that is important; I suppose it means bringing this House into line, as it were, with what happens in other parliaments in the European Union, such as in Germany, where the leader appears before the European Council meetings so that the Chancellor (in this case) can present not only the government's political approach, but also search for a consensus with all the parliamentary parties. So let me start with thanking Mr Xuclá and the rest of the parliamentary parties for recognising this effort, and of course this change of attitude: the fact that we are appearing before this important European Council meeting.
Mr Xuclá has in fact spoken about the 'Aquarius'. There is an idea that I would also like to express to the rest of the parliamentary parties, and that is that I refuse to believe the 'Aquarius' is what could be called a marketing gesture. On the contrary, I believe it is a gesture of solidarity, a call to the European Union as a whole to express its solidarity; and the best we can do is ask those 620 human beings whether or not it is a marketing gesture to have offered Valencia as a safe port, and for Spain to have received these people. Because, it is clear that what we saw in the Mediterranean as a result of this crisis was precisely that we were close to a humanitarian tragedy, and the Government of Spain - recognising, as of course one must, the role of the State law enforcement agencies, the regional authorities and all the local authorities, and of course the NGOs - gave an example of solidarity and made a call for the European Union as a whole to demonstrate its solidarity.
And in fact that put us in a completely different situation to that of other governments, which had this vessel much closer, and unfortunately did not offer the response that public opinion largely expected of them.
It is true, as Mr Xuclá says, that we have to admit we are not only being faced with the challenge of migration, which has to do with causes such as civil wars, political conflicts, armed conflicts, in some parts of the world such as Africa, but that we are talking about a demographic reality. And in this sense, I believe it is positive to recall and highlight what you have commented in figures, in line with what I said in my first speech, but also with data such as, for example, that now around 50% of the population of Senegal - to cite the case of a country that of course suffers this migratory pressure, and arrives not only at the Canary Islands shores but through Morocco to the shores of southern Spain - over 50%, are people who are under the age of 25. So it is a demographic reality not only in the short term, but in the medium term, to which the whole of the European Union will have to provide an answer to.
What do I mean by all this? Well, that we are not in fact suffering from a magnet effect. The 'Aquarius' is not a magnet effect, nor of course is the fact that we are sending a message of empathy, of respect for human rights, of commitment to the international agreements signed by Spain and the European Union as a whole, of the values and principles that we as Europeans often call on when we talk with other parts of the world. This has nothing to do with the magnet effect; rather, it has to do with calling on the principles we want to make our own, as political praxis, when we talk of migration.
I believe that Mr Xuclá is also right when he says that we really have to approach the migratory challenge in terms of responsibility and solidarity, and, yes, as an integrated policy. Well, I took part for the first time as President of the Government at the mini-summit held on Sunday in Brussels, and one of the questions that most caught my attention and appeared intelligent on the part of the European Commission (which organised this meeting), was to set out, as it were, the migratory challenge in three phases, each of them perfectly interwoven with the next.
First, we have to talk about the foreign dimension of migratory policy. I'll refer to this when answering the rest of the speakers. You also have to talk about control, and about external borders. And you have to talk about secondary movements, and as a result about what you mentioned before in relation to asylum and the alert we have to raise if there is a reform in the form of a reversal of Schengen; in short, of freedom of movement of all the citizens of Europe.
Of course, we agree, Mr Xuclá, with all the progress that has been made on the matter of economic and monetary integration. This is what I personally told President Macron. I said so to Chancellor Merkel: we agree with this agreement signed in Meseberg, a small town in Germany, where the talk was not only of Banking Union, but also of the Eurozone Budget. I share with you, and with some of the speakers here, the idea that we have to improve accountability and democratic control. I will deal with some questions related to this later. But in any case, I would like you to know that this will be the position of the Government of Spain in relation to this issue as well.
Mr Baldoví has spoken along similar lines to Mr Xuclá. So I believe that the Europe of Valencia, of course the Europe of Andalusia, the Europe of Catalonia, the Europe of Madrid, the Europe of the Basque Country, the Europe of many and each and every one of the territories, put all their efforts into accepting and looking after the migrants on the 'Aquarius', and the many others that come to the shores of the south and south-east of Spain.
I liked very much what Mr Baldoví said, I admit, in fact I believe that I also wanted to say it, perhaps in a very general way, in my first speech, but I agree that Spain is very much a European country, also for historical reasons. Also because we look to Mexico, we remember Lázaro Cárdenas, and we remember and appreciate countries such as Mexico, for example, and other Latin American countries, for what they did in historical circumstances that were traumatic for Spain. It was precisely to receive many Spanish people, and not only to receive, but also to integrate them into the social, political and economic life, people who today, if you have the chance to visit the country, obviously feel as Mexican as they do Spanish. And without a doubt, I feel this exercise of empathy you have expressed in your speech is very important.
So without pretending the situation is the same, we would like people to feel solidarity for our compatriots, who are now outside Spain, making a life for themselves and working outside Spain in other parts of Europe, particularly in Germany or in the United Kingdom or in other parts of the world, we would like people to accept them and integrate them; so they are not object of discrimination but of integration; and we also, to the extent that we can, do that with the migrants who come to us from Africa.
Mr Matutes has referred to more or less the same questions. He has made a reference that, although in some cases I am critical with some of the decisions that have been taken by the European Union, here I cannot share. But he has referred to Greece, or has at least made mention of Greece, and in this respect, Mr Matutes, what I would like to tell you is that we welcome and are also part of that well-known group called the "Washington Group", which has dealt with the economic situation of Greece and its financial bailout. We welcome and it consider an extraordinary piece of news that at last there has been an orderly exit from Greece's bailout programme.
And in this respect, I believe that the reflection we should make is to take advantage of this exit, take note and make the improvements that can be made in the Economic and Monetary Union, so that these situations cannot occur again and Greek society suffer as a result.
Mr Alli says that this government aims to flaunt its faculty for dialogue. That is something, of course, that we extend to the House as a whole. At the European Union, at the mini-summit, which we are also going to hold on Thursday and Friday, I can guarantee you that our position is going to be constructive and integrating. We are not going to give lessons to anyone. Quite the reverse: we are going to provide solutions. We are going to aim to share experiences to improve migratory policy in these three dimensions. We are going to be supportive with countries such as Germany, which was supportive with the Syrian migrants and refugees in 2015-2016. And we are also going to ask for this solidarity in relation to the enhanced dialogue with the countries of origin and the countries of transit.
With respect to the other question that you have raised, I understand that this is a question that is sensitive for your party. The government's commitment and that of the Socialist Parliamentary Group has, I believe, always been the same. ETA was defeated by democracy. And as a result, what we have to propose as a government - and this is our responsibility, and what I ask this House to support - is to review prison policy, to bring it into line with a single reality, while being empathetic, of course, with the victims of terrorism.
The representative of Foro Asturias, Mr Martínez, has talked about energy policy and also about trade. With respect to trade, what I can guarantee to him is that the position we have expressed both to Chancellor Merkel and the President of the French Republic - and, of course, we are going to refer to this at the European Council meeting - is that the European Union has to remain united. It has to remain united as a block, above all when it comes to dealing with the trade war that the US Administration is now planning not only with the European Union but also with other major countries in the global trade system such as China.
What I will tell you is that we are concerned about this escalation, which I believe that at the end of the day is in no-one's interest; in the end we all lose. And the United States also loses. And I believe that first of all we have to be very intelligent, pragmatic, of course, with respect to this question, because we are talking about sectors that are very important for our own economy, indirectly related to the automotive sector, also sectors linked to the primary sector; and in this sense, we are going to propose a concerted action by all the European countries.
And in relation to energy policy, Mr Martínez, what I can tell you is that this government is planning a fair transition. The aim is to anticipate many of the effects that this energy transition may have for the world, for the European Union, and for us as a Member State of the European Union; and what these mining communities you referred to in your speech should be feeling is solidarity, and not that the Government of Spain is turning its back on them. That is what we are going to try to do; and this commitment is as much for the society of Asturias as it is for the mining sector. And that is how I would like you to perceive it as the representative of Foro de Asturias .
Ms Oramas has referred to the migratory crisis experienced in Spain in the years 2006, 2007 and 2008, and I would like to thank you, Ms Oramas, and also by extension, Mr Quevedo, as representative of Nueva Canarias , for the support you have expressed in your speeches for the position of the Government of Spain. I believe that it is important for us to improve dialogue with the regional governments and with the local councils. That is the commitment I would like to express to you, and what I want to express to you, particularly Ms Oramas, as representing the party that right now is governing in the Canary Islands, is that of course what we are going to do is inform the regional governments, improve cooperation and collaboration with the regional governments, and in particular with those regions that are suffering most from these migratory flows. And I am aware that the Canary Islands is one of them.
I must tell you, Ms Oramas, that one of the proposals I have made in private to my European colleagues is that we have to enhance this dialogue and cooperation with the countries of origin, and with the countries of transit. I believe we are going to achieve significant progress in the conclusions of the European Council meeting, precisely with respect to Morocco, and also with Senegal. Not only from the point of view of a political declaration, but also financial resources. And in this respect, I believe that the attitude that the Government of Spain has displayed over these last weeks of debates we have had with Germany, France and of course also in the mini-summit, have been constructive. They have been based on dialogue, calling on the responsibility of all of us, and being aware that we are being supportive with these countries as well; with Germany, but also with Italy, Malta, Greece and others, which can provide, let's say, additional resources and greater commitment by the European Union in relation to the countries you have mentioned. That is what the government wants. I want you to know that we are working on it, and I hope that in the coming days, or in the coming weeks, we can have good news in this respect.
I would also like to thank Mr Quevedo for his attitude, his support and of course also for sharing with you the fact that we are, as he says, facing a European-wide challenge that needs the support and joint response of the whole of Europe. It's obvious, Mr Quevedo - and you are aware of it - that there are countries in the European Union, such as those in the Visegrad group - which were not actually present at the mini-summit held on Sunday in Brussels - where there is practically no talk of refugees, migration, or solidarity by them in terms of accepting this reality.
By the way, Mr Hernando, who talks so much and reproaches other political parties for their alignment with parties of, let's say, dubious democratic quality, should be reminded that, for example, Hungary is at present led by a certain Mr Orban, who is, I think, a member of the European People's Party. In other words, things are seen differently depending on who you are referring to.
I would like to thank Mr Esteban for his contribution, his reflection. I agree with you that these three dimensions of migratory policy - the foreign dimension, that of border control and secondary movements - must be dealt with as a whole.
I agree with you that yes, what this government will do is take a long-term view and be very alert and careful with any kind of cut or reversal that may take place within the framework of Schengen and the freedom of movement of people. I believe that we can make some adjustments so that societies like Germany see that a society like Spain is also supportive of those exiles who are now in Germany but first asked for asylum in Spain, and I believe that we can reach an agreement within the framework of the European Council.
The government is working towards this end. And I share with you, and in fact I talked about this with the head of the Regional Government of the Basque Country, Mr Urkullu on Monday, your concern for MENAS (unaccompanied minors), which is not only felt in the Basque Country, but also, and in particular, in Vizcaya, and in the country as a whole. And I'll tell you the same thing I told Ms Oramas. We undertake to enhance the coordination, cooperation and information provided to regional governments as a whole to local councils, within the limits of our competences. This is a subject to which we will pay particular attention, give particular priority, and the only thing we ask is to be given time to be able to put in order all the policies linked to MENAS. Now, of course I am not unaware of the bus that you mentioned that stopped in San Sebastian. A member of the Upper House told me two weeks ago about it, a member of the Basque Nationalist Party in that House. So I would like you to know that we are dealing with it.
I absolutely agree with you on the question of family reunification, and this is an issue that is also of vital importance when we are talking about asylum, when we are talking about secondary movements. This is an issue that I have talked about in particular with Chancellor Merkel. I believe that Chancellor Merkel also sympathises with it, and of course any type of solution that we can provide in the case of secondary movements must respect this sacred principle of family reunification. We cannot allow for something similar to occur in Europe as [Donald] Trump has done in the United States. And that is how we are going to act.
Now, let's talk about both the external platforms, and the platforms that have been proposed at the level of the European continent. First, let's look at the external platforms. What we have to know first of all is the proposal that the President of the European Council will bring to the European Council meeting. You know that this proposal is Mr Tusk's, and right now we don't know precisely what its principles, or parameters, are. We consider that it could be a good option, but we'll have to examine it in detail, because the devil is precisely in the details. We want to know what the principles that will govern it are, whether they will respect the agreements we have signed on human rights.
But yes, it's true that we have to regulate this migration, and that we have to prevent this migration. So what I warned about at this mini-summit in Brussels on Sunday is that the only message the European Union cannot send is that the solution is to create platforms in third countries, among other reasons because there will be countries that will not accept these platforms. There will be countries that would consider it to be, let's say, a violation of their national sovereignty. And as a result, I believe that the options have to be other than this, different. There are countries that can accept them, and we will have to see under precisely what conditions. I have to say that there are a number of countries, including ours, and we expressed our doubts in terms of, first, knowing precisely what we are talking about, what principles, what they would be, in other words, the way of dealing with migration using these platforms. But we understand and sympathise with the need to prevent this migration, to control it in the countries of origin and transit as well.
So we are going to wait and see what proposal the European Council will provide us with, its President in this case. And on this question, I hope to be able to inform you later, once we know more details.
With respect to the reception centres that were suggested by President Macron at the meeting I had with him on Saturday, and that were also raised at the mini-summit; basically, Honourable Members, the idea, at least as I understood it and as I believe was proposed by Emmanuel Macron, is clear: whenever there is an NGO vessel in the Mediterranean, there is a debate about determining what the safe port is. There is a debate about where this vessel should dock. There are countries that are not meeting this requirement. Italy, for example, has not done so in the case of the 'Aquarius'. And Malta did not do so either in the case of the 'Lifeline'.
So what I believe that the European Union should consider is that when a vessel docks in any country of the European Union, it is docking in Europe. It is not docking in Malta, or Greece, Spain or any other country. And as a result, the proposal - at least that is what I understood of Mr Macron's proposal - is to create safe European ports. In other words, to locate certain safe ports in the Mediterranean, where the response to be given will be European. Not of any specific country. There are countries that do not have the capacity because they are overwhelmed as a result of the arrival of migrants. So what we would be looking for, in these places, is a European response that is perfectly aligned with UNHCR and with the International Organization for Migration; so there can be personnel with the skills, both with respect to reception and asylum policies, and policies on return, who are linked to the European Union and not to the particular country where these migrants dock.
It is an idea that at present is still at an early stage. It consists only of what I have told you. But I think that it is good for our country and good for the European Union. First, that the ports determined to be safe in the Mediterranean should be located and defined. Second, that financial resources are allocated from the European Union as a whole; because what lies behind this logic is an explanation that when these migrants dock they are arriving in Europe, or are arriving in a Member State of the European Union. And third, what we are proposing is a European vision, and thus one that is supportive of the phenomenon of migration. As I say, it is an idea that at this stage is still taking its baby steps, to use a colloquial term, and we are going to work on it over the next few months.
Something that appears to me to be substantive and that I would like to share with the House, and is related to Mr Esteban's reflection, is that obviously what would be desirable is for there to be an agreement between all 27 Member States. But it is also true that this is very difficult on an issue such as migration, when the reality is what it is in the centre and north of Europe, with governments which refuse absolutely to participate on any issue that has to do with reception of migrants.
So the reflection that we have to make, and this is what I call on this House to do, is whether as there is no consensus in all the Member States of the European Union, we should hide behind a rhetoric that runs the risk of becoming empty, saying that since there is no European agreement we cannot do anything, and we leave the border countries to respond solely with their own resources. Or should we begin to look for, let's say, dialogue and proposals between the different countries in the European Union, so that it is these countries that spearhead these responses. And in this sense, one of the ideas that was suggested, I believe by a number of countries, among them ours, is that if there are countries that have experience in making contacts, in dialogue and in cooperation with other countries of transit or origin, why should these countries not head up the contacts for ordering migratory flows in the name of the European Union? Let me give you an example: in the case of Italy-Libya, Spain-Morocco, Germany-Ghana; I believe there are options without the need to reach a majority agreement of the European Union, to begin to provide short-term responses to construct foundations that can subsequently be the basis in the medium term for the construction of a more common response from the EU as a whole.
And this is more or less the approach that I believe will begin to take shape at the next European Council meeting; that we should begin dialogue between the different countries, with the countries of origin, with the countries of transit, in the name of the European Union. And I can tell you now, Mr Esteban, that the approach of the Government of Spain is, to the extent of our possibilities, of course, to head up this dialogue, this cooperation, with some of these countries of origin and transit, in the name of the European Union; and of course, with the European Union's financial resources and political commitment behind us.
I believe that this was the approach proposed at the mini-summit that can take shape over the next few days, at the European Council meeting. It may be a pragmatic position, but one that is effective when it comes to dealing with the question of migration based on common sense and respect for human rights; and Spain will be - and this is my wish - part of this enhanced cooperation, if you allow me the expression, on the question of migration.
On the matter of Fiscal Union, I have nothing to add to what you have said. On the subject of Gibraltar and the opportunity of Campo de Gibraltar, it's true, I share with you the view that when you go to Campo de Gibraltar you can see what the situation of Campo de Gibraltar is. In fact, at the first real Council of Ministers meeting we had, one of the questions we discussed, and that the Minister for Home Affairs is right now dealing with, is how to deal with the presence of drug trafficking in Campo de Gibraltar. This is a question on which the Government of Spain will not look the other way. We are going to look straight ahead, we are going to address it head-on, being fully aware that in the short term we need a police response, one that guarantees public security. But of course, many more things are needed that have to do with job creation, with creating opportunities and with comprehensive social policies.
And in this respect I share with you the idea that perhaps we have an opportunity to create these positive dynamics in Campo de Gibraltar. I want to tell you that we are not going to let slip this opportunity, and we are also going to address it thinking about the locals in Campo de Gibraltar, because very often, hidden behind the rhetoric on the age-old debate, we forget about the people who are actually living and suffering the consequences of this lack of dialogue.
And with respect to structured cooperation on defence, President Macron's idea with respect to this European initiative, yes, we are going to take part in it. I believe it is a good mechanism, and in fact is not more than a further commitment in the construction of a common policy in the area of defence.
Mr Tardá reflected on my statements yesterday in Berlin. Well, you can interpret my words as you wish, but I'll tell you what can be inferred from my phrase, what I said yesterday: when I said that it was time to move on from the events of 1 October. And on that day, on 1 October, as Leader of the Opposition, Mr Tardá, I appeared at the headquarters of the Socialist Party in calle Ferraz to say that I condemned the images that had been seen and what was suffered by some Catalan citizens that day. What I wanted to say yesterday in Berlin, Mr Tardá, and that is how I would like you to interpret my words, is that on 1 October what it must do, what it represented as well, and it's something that you to some extent also appear to forget on many occasions when you raise the question of what occurred on 1 October, is end unilaterality.
We have to move on from unilaterality, Mr Tardá. When we talk about 1 October, we also have to talk about 6 and 7 September, which were also the prior cause of what occurred on 1 October. And on 6 and 7 of September in the Regional Parliament of Catalonia what happened is that a parliamentary majority of a social minority in Catalonia imposed their rules and unilaterally broke the Constitution and the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia. So when I say that we have to move on, it's that we have to put an end to the unilateral way. And in this respect, Mr Tardá, we do not consider that the Constitution provides little room, a narrow field for dialogue and for finding a solution to the crisis in Catalonia. Quite the contrary. The Constitution, the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, among other reasons, because they have a majority support with respect to what you represented on 6 and 7 September in the Regional Parliament of Catalonia, is the basis on which we can construct a new consensus that can respond to the crisis in Catalonia. That is the approach with which we are going to address this reality.
And in this sense, Mr Tardá, we all have to learn from our mistakes. You too have to learn from your mistakes. And on 6 and 7 September you committed a mistake in the Regional Parliament of Catalonia. And you also have to move on from there. Well, I believe I have now responded to Mr Tardá as well in relation to the platforms and the doubts that he obviously has, which I have also expressed in private to our European colleagues; and we are going to see precisely how this question will take a more concrete form.
Mr Rivera, you talk about the government. Well, what I can guarantee you, Mr Rivera, is that this government will govern with Parliament and not against Parliament. This government has lifted the veto on many parliamentary initiatives that were approved in this House and that the People's Parliamentary Group, with your active participation, vetoed as a result of the agreement you had.
And by the way, Mr Rivera, I would like to thank you that despite the very tough speech that you made on the Bill on euthanasia, yesterday you finally changed your mind and said yes to an initiative that is also so important for this country.
Let me say something, and I say it with all my respect: you sometimes give the impression of inaugurating Spain every day. It seems that Spain did not exist before you came to this House. And so, I would make what is in fact a suggestion, so that you do not make a mistake: hiring at source was a model implemented in 2004, Mr Rivera, not something that you have invented, it was invented a long time ago, and it was precisely a Socialist government that put it into practice. You should inform yourself better. Just as with the case of the fight against illegal migration which, of course, was combated precisely under a Socialist government.
Now, with respect to your dialectical response to the nationalists/populists, in short to all those who want to break up Europe, here I would echo the words of Mr Iglesias. You appear to share a political family in the European Union with a variety of nationalist parties. So show them at least their due respect, and don't come here bringing your own contradictions, because it makes it very easy for the rest of the house to reproach you with them.
With respect to education, Mr Rivera, I am not going to let this issue go. We support education with resources. You support education without resources. We support education with resources, Mr Rivera. And so if you are prepared to force a consensus on education, with resources, to support public education in this country, fine, you will have the sympathy of the government and of the Socialist Parliamentary Group.
Of course, you talk about the 'Aquarius' and say more or less elegantly the same thing that Mr Hernando has said. What you say is that the 'Aquarius' has led to a magnet effect to the Spanish shores. But what this seems to me, Mr Rivera, is in fact the kind of egoism and Europhobia that we have to combat at a European level. Solidarity never causes a magnet effect, Mr Rivera. Of course, I'll give you the figures, but I am also giving them to Mr Hernando so that he can learn from them, because his party was governing this country until a few weeks ago.
I said this before, in my first speech. Mr Hernando, Mr Rivera, in 2017 the number of migrants arriving on the Spanish shores was 100% more than in 2016. Perhaps there were some migrants who thought that the Socialist Party was going to govern in 2018, but that does not appear likely, Mr Rivera.
In 2018, the increase has been 64%. So we are not talking about a magnet effect, Mr Rivera, Mr Hernando; what we are talking about is the flight effect of many migrants from a social reality that is unacceptable for them. And as a result, the only thing that the Socialist Government did with the 'Aquarius' was not 'look the other way, and not 'convert into a humanitarian tragedy what some countries with their indifference were indirectly achieving.
And with respect to trade, Mr Rivera, the position of the Government of Spain will be clear. It is going to be the defence of social rights, of labour rights, and of environmental rights. And as a result, also, the construction of mechanisms for conflict resolution at an international level, which among other matters, does not put large corporations in a position of inequality with respect to small and medium-sized businesses or citizens when it comes to ability to respond in the conflict resolution mechanisms that right now have been implemented in international treaties. This is the key issue, Mr Rivera. This is the key issue.
In CETA, we consider that the mechanism that has been implemented does not guarantee equality between companies when it comes to demanding or being able to organise responses to some of the trade effects of this free trade agreement. But I will also tell you something else: if this point is resolved, Mr Rivera, we are not against free trade. We are against free trade that reduces social rights, reduces labour rights and reduces environmental rights. Among other reasons, Mr Rivera, because what they do is modify the Treaties of the European Union by the back door.
As for Mr Iglesias, of course I thank you for being here, your attitude, the words you have used; in short, I say to you again: it is not a question of marketing, we haven't fallen into this trap of the conservative parties and parliamentary groups.
Here, the gesture of 'Aquarius' was not a marketing gesture, it was a humanitarian gesture, it was to put on the table a reality to which, in this case, the countries of the Mediterranean, Malta and Italy, were not providing a response to, and therefore Spain demonstrated its solidarity.
I said it in my first speech and I say it again, that of course it was an exceptional measure. Exceptional because, it's true, as you commented in your speech, we have "aquariuses" arriving every week on the south-east and southern shores of Spain. And it's true, and I said it in my first speech, that of course we are very proud, and we have recognised the work of all the cities, of all the regional governments, in relation to the response to the 'Aquarius' and the reality of the migration that is arriving on our shores.
I have to tell you in relation to the CIEs (immigrant detention centres) that of course our position is to respond to the mandate of the Lower House of Parliament and review the conditions under which the migrants are held in the CIEs. But I have to tell you, Mr Iglesias, that we are not in favour of closing the CIEs. Another matter is improving the government's response capacity at these CIEs, but we obviously need places to deal with the immigrants that arrive on our shores.
I agree with you that we have to reform the Dublin Regulation. I agree with you that yes, we have to strengthen the Eurozone on the matter of the EU Budget. I am not aware that it has actually disappeared from the agenda; what I can guarantee, Mr Iglesias, is that it is not because of the Government of Spain. The Government of Spain is supporting a strong political declaration, in this direction, and if this has occurred or finally occurs, then I imagine it will be due to a rejection by the countries of the north and centre of Europe that do not agree with moving in favour of this integration.
Regarding the references you made to Portugal: obviously, for us Portugal is a mirror for many things that we have to look to. I would also point out, since you said that there is no other socialist party in government: the Swedish Socialist Party is in government. You also know that thanks to the boost from Sweden, an important summit was held in Gothenburg, which created the social pillar of the European Union. But at any event, I believe, and here I agree with you, that it is important to refer to the need to create a European unemployment insurance, on the need to strengthen fiscal union and of course to improve accountability.
Here the question, Mr Iglesias, is, and you know it very well. How is this accountability to be implemented? By creating a parliament of countries in the Eurozone different from the European Parliament? In fact, different positions are held by different countries, and of course we will move forward towards greater democracy and transparency and accountability in relation to the European policies linked to the Euro.
Mr Hernando, I will answer you. You don't listen to me. That's the problem. Loyalty, as I said during the first question time, is something that I believe we should have for the State, not only when one is in government, but also when one is in opposition.
I remind you that not so long ago, in 2016, you supported what you called the "operation dialogue" of the Government in Spain with the Regional Government of Catalonia. And at that time, you said you had to talk a lot, to dialogue a lot, to pact a lot, to agree a lot. You said "we have to do a lot of talking" again in 2017. "You have to have a correct and fluid relationship." "Dialogue must continue for the good of the Catalans" you said in 2016 and in 2017. And at that time, you didn't get any response, any criticism from any member of the People's Party Parliamentary Group, or of the government or of the members linked to the People's Party. That doesn't surprise me.
But I would also point out something to you, Mr Hernando: you didn't get any criticism from the Socialist Parliamentary Group or from the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, because what we wanted was for this dialogue with the Catalan institutions to prosper. So I'm not asking for loyalty to the Government of Spain: I know I'm not going to get that. In a very short space of time we are once again seeing the ghosts that you brought to this House, in relation to the victims of terrorism, in relation to ETA violence in the Basque Country, also linking it irresponsibly with, I won't say dialectically, but at least combining it, coordinating it, with other questions that have nothing to do with it, such as the situation in Catalonia.
What I ask from you is, I insist, that you should lead the opposition, but not the agitation. Because, look, I'll tell you one thing, Mr Hernando. Look, in relation to Catalonia, you are now in the process of renewing your leadership, which I respect. I'll start from that fact. In your seats you have a candidate for this process of renewal that supports constitutional reform to resolve the Catalan question. You have someone who created the "operation dialogue" I referred to before. You have another candidate who says that Article 155 should have been applied much earlier. What I mean by this, Mr Hernando, is that you do not have a discourse for Catalonia. You have been overtaken by your own failure in the political arena. And what I ask is for a sense of statesmanship, responsibility, support for this government, to resolve a question for which you too have been responsible.
In short, I'm not telling you this, I'm telling the candidates that are part of the renewal process. I don't know what will happen in the Lower House. The only thing I ask of you, Mr Hernando, is for your party to get back on course in this matter as soon as possible. And don't go for the easy way out. The easy way, Mr Hernando, Honourable Members of the People's Parliamentary Group, is to say "Nothing's happened here. The People's Party has nothing to do with it," and we return to the feeling of territorial grievance, of territorial conflict, of reproaches, and of accusing this government falsely of breaking up the country and breaking the territorial coexistence. You know that it's not true, that it's a lie. And so, the only thing I ask of you is that you do not take refuge in what is comfortable, that you look at yourself in the mirror, that you learn from your mistakes, that you are loyal to the State.
And to end, Mr Hernando, because the rest are all just clichés. The only thing I agree with you on in your speech - look, I've taken note of it here - is to thank the State law enforcement agencies and services for their work in relation to the migratory flows. But this government... as you have asked what we are going to do with the 2018 Budget, and whether we are going to meet the deficit target or not, I believe that the Minister for the Economy said so in the summit that we had in Luxembourg. I myself had the opportunity to talk to all my European colleagues. I also said in my first speech, this government is going to comply with its commitments on fiscal consolidation.
In short, Mr Hernando, be a little self-critical. The AIReF, the European Commission, the Bank of Spain, all the research services in this country, said when you passed the Budget that it was very difficult to meet your budget deficit targets.
So I understand that now you are in opposition, you have to be demanding with the government; but once more, also on the matter of the Budget, not only on the Catalan question, don't apply the law of the funnel: very wide for you and very narrow for everyone else.
Non official translation