Responses from the President of the Government in the Control Session in the Senate

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

26 April 2022 · Control Session in the Senate · Senate, Spain

Context
Sánchez addressed the Spanish Senate during a control session on April 26, 2022, responding to questions about Spain's response to war-driven inflation and energy prices.
Main themes
Russia-Ukraine war economic impact, energy prices and inflation, Spain-Portugal gas price agreement with EU, national economic response plan, political opposition cooperation, consumer and household protection measures, transport and agriculture sector aid, minimum vital income increase, rental price cap, European energy market reform
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,729
84th percentile
Sentences
129
75th percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
14.3
70th percentile
Syntax
3.43
91st percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
56th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 47%47%
  • Institutional 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Environmental 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

129 sentences in 55 paragraphs

President: Thank you very much, Mr. President. Thank you, Your Honor. I will take this first turn of reply to express my solidarity with the journalists who are currently in Ukraine, with Fran Sevilla, with those displaced from Radio Nacional, and many others who have suffered the consequences of this war. It is important to recognize the work of the media and the information they have been providing throughout these long months of war in Ukraine.

And, of course, we also express our solidarity with the Ukrainian people and condemn the illegal, unjust, and absolutely inhumane war of the autocrat Putin.

Regarding what you asked me, Your Honor, I believe that, indeed, you have made a reference to the rise in prices. That is evident. The data is there, the evolution, not only in Spain, but in Europe, in the overall global economy.

It is also evident that Putin's war is having an impact on the rise in prices of unprocessed food, as well as energy products. The Ministry of Economy states that 70% of the rise in prices is justified precisely by the increase in energy prices and also in unprocessed food.

The Government of Spain, since the beginning of this war crisis, has been working on two fronts, Your Honor: one, the European level, and the other, the national level.

At the European level, I believe that today we have found very good news, a political agreement between the Government of Spain, the Government of Portugal, and also with the European Commission to set a reference price for the gas that produces electricity for the next 12 months. This will be good, Your Honor, for consumers, for small and medium-sized enterprises, and also for industry in our country.

In short, I do not ask you to applaud the actions of the Government of Spain, but at least I do ask you to recognize the efforts and the policies that we are implementing thanks to dialogue and also to the proposals we are putting forward at the Brussels level.

Because, no matter how much we do at the national level, if we do not modify the energy market at the European level, it will be difficult for us to face, with all the instruments that Europe has, this rise in prices, as unjustified as it is unfair.

Secondly, Your Honor, I would like to say that this proposal, this political agreement would be incomplete if it were not accompanied by a national response plan to the economic and social consequences of the war that we approved a few weeks ago in the Council of Ministers, through a Royal Decree Law that, by the way, we hope will be validated next Thursday in the Cortes Generales.

A plan, Your Honor, that we had the opportunity to discuss, negotiate, and agree upon with the affected sectors. I want to remind you, for example, of the transport sector, 1 billion euros in direct aid. Also agriculture, livestock, and the fishing sector.

A plan that caps the rise in rental prices at 2%. A plan that increases the Minimum Vital Income by 15%. A plan that extends protection to 2 million households defined as vulnerable consumers and, therefore, also protects them against rising prices.

In short, Your Honor, a wide range of proposals at the national level to cushion the effects of this war, from an economic and social perspective. To protect the economic growth and job creation that we were recording before the war began. And, finally, also to make the redistribution of the burdens of the war as fair as possible across Spanish society.

And the question, Your Honor, that I would like you to answer is: what are you going to do? Are you going to approve this plan or not?

Reply from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the reply made by Senator Javier Maroto of the Popular Parliamentary Group.

President: Thank you very much, Your Honor. Do you not read the papers? In the meeting that Mr. Feijóo and I had at the Palacio de la Moncloa a few weeks ago, I offered eleven agreements, Your Honor.

The renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary, the renewal of the Constitutional Court, the reform of Article 49 of the Constitution, for the Popular Party to return to the Anti-Defection Pact.

And I also offered you, Your Honor, an agreement on the National Response Plan to the economic and social consequences of the war. Therefore, I have requested the support of the Popular Party for the validation of this Royal Decree Law, Your Honor. Inform yourself before, well, submitting your question to the Government.

Because this is the truth, Your Honor. The truth is that I have requested support, and to this day we do not know what the Popular Party is going to do. Whether they will support or not support the reduction of 0.20 euros, for example, on the liter of gasoline or diesel. We do not know if you will support the increase to 2 million households protected by the electricity social bonus. We do not know today if you will support a 60% reduction in the taxes on the electricity bill, Your Honor. We still do not know that today; it is time for you to land and commit to the well-being and social protection of our fellow citizens.

I have told you many times, Your Honor, and again you give me the opportunity to remind you. Because one must be coherent and credible, Your Honor, in the past, in the present, and in the future.

You, when you have governed, have raised all taxes. It is true that you, when in opposition, promise to lower taxes. But let us make a brief recap, Your Honor.

During your seven years of government with Mr. Rajoy, you raised taxes 50 times. You raised university fees, you created pharmaceutical co-payments, you raised income tax, you raised VAT, you raised property tax, you raised special taxes, you created new taxes, such as the sun tax, which stifled the development of self-consumption, which is fundamental, Your Honor, in this energy crisis we are experiencing. This is what you did.

But look, the height of the somersault, Your Honor, is that you raise taxes when you govern and cut the Welfare State.

I will remind you, Your Honor, that you cut unemployment benefits starting from the sixth month, from 60% to 50% of the regulatory base. That you cut health spending as soon as you came to power by almost 4 billion euros, Your Honor.

You raise taxes, cut the Welfare State. Now, of course, you approve tax amnesties so that those in your party can launder the money they have evaded.

Your Honor, the agreement in Brussels is a great agreement for the Iberian Peninsula, for the Portuguese government, for the Government of Spain, and for the entire Spanish and Portuguese citizenry.

And just as this is a good agreement that will help small and medium-sized enterprises, industries, and also the citizens of both countries in the Iberian Peninsula, it is necessary, it is essential, that next Thursday a Royal Decree Law is validated, which is fundamental to protect, to cushion, and to make a fair distribution of the burden of the economic and social consequences of the war.

Therefore, Your Honor, the question is very simple: are you going to support that Royal Decree Law or not?

And I will tell you something more, you say that you are going to lower taxes and will not cut any policies of the Welfare State. The other day I read that you are willing to de-index pensions according to the CPI. Answer whether that is true or not.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator José Miguel Fernández of the Democratic Parliamentary Group.

President: Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Your Honor. I believe we all share that, indeed, in an economic context where before the invasion of the war we had very positive forecasts for global economic growth, both European and national, now they have been clouded as a result of the economic and social consequences of the war and, above all, their translation into energy prices, prices of unprocessed food. Let us remember that both Ukraine and Russia are the main or among the main producers of raw materials, fundamental also for food, and that this can indeed be causing a potential food crisis, not so much in Europe, but in many other countries with, let us say, an institutional framework and an economy less resilient than the European economy.

What is clear is that every time financial frameworks are negotiated in Brussels, the debate always arises about whether to cut economic resources from policies that some countries consider outdated, such as the Common Agricultural Policy, and precisely the pandemic and also the war indicate to us that we need to talk about greater strategic sovereignty on the part of the European Union and that this food sovereignty is fundamental, and that is why the CAP must continue to have the necessary resources to guarantee the economic and financial sustainability of small, medium, and large agricultural, livestock, and fishing productions in our country and across the continent.

That said, Your Honor, I believe that the most important thing is not only to remain in lamentation or in the diagnosis of the situation caused by Putin's war but to propose solutions, to propose solutions at the European level, to propose solutions at the national level.

I insist again that the proposal we have achieved, the political agreement we have reached in the Iberian Peninsula, the Portuguese government, and the Government of Spain with the European Commission, is a very good proposal to defend, for example, the electro-intensive industry, to which you referred earlier, because ultimately what we are going to achieve is to set a reference price for electricity production that comes from gas, for one year, and therefore, guarantee a, an environment, as safe, as certain as possible, in the face of such uncertainty as that which the war is causing.

From there, Your Honor, all the economic and social policy proposals that the Government of Spain is putting forward incorporate the perspective of territorial cohesion, Your Honor. Each and every one of the economic and social policies of the Government of Spain incorporates, I repeat, the perspective of territorial cohesion. We are also doing this with Cantabria. I remember having been on many occasions talking with President Revilla about the payment of the debt of the Valdecilla Hospital. Well, this Government, Your Honors, is addressing that payment of the debt of the Valdecilla Hospital. A reference hospital, by the way, not only for Cantabria but also for the whole of Spain.

The General Budgets for the year 2022 allocate to Cantabria, Your Honors, 293 million euros. Of course, said like this, it may sound like little, but if we look at what it means from the point of view of per capita investment, we are talking about 411 euros. That is to say, it is above what represents the percentage of the national GDP and the participation, the participation of the national population. In other words, Your Honor, we are demonstrating a strong commitment, if we can call it that, to Cantabria and its citizens.

From the perspective of infrastructure, I would simply like to recall some data to put into context the issues you have raised and that you have certainly mentioned to me even before I asked this question about the Cercanías plan. I will contrast this with the Minister of Transport, Mobility and Urban Agenda, but what I want to convey to the entire Cantabrian citizenry is that, for us, sustainable mobility is fundamental. The Cercanías are a priority, and consequently, I would like to remind you that of those 2 billion euros through economic funds, aid, and subsidies from the General State Budgets in 2022, referring to Cantabria, 64 million euros from those budgets go to the Cercanías Plan for Cantabria. I could mention many investments that have been communicated to me by the Ministry of Transport, Mobility and Urban Agenda, 2 billion euros, which include, for example, the continuity branch of Sierra Pando Barreda, the new access to the port of Santander, the imminent start of works on the Hermida gorge, the arrival of high-speed rail in Cantabria, which I believe will also be a historic milestone for your region, and from the province of Palencia, 186 million euros in investments in Cantabria from the Transformation, Recovery, and Resilience Plan. To make a reference, if we continue with the infrastructure of the state road network, 100 million euros have been invested since June 2018, that is, since I became president of the Government in Cantabria. In Education, ladies and gentlemen, 12.4 million euros for the digitalization of the educational system in Cantabria, which is fundamental. In social investment, 20 million euros allocated to policies such as the thermal social bond in environmental protection. Ladies and gentlemen, the commitment of the Government of Spain to energy efficiency, innovation, and biodiversity protection has even manifested itself in the area of representation and decentralization of institutions, as expressed by the Minister of Science regarding the decentralization of the Spanish Institute of Oceanography in the city of Santander. In short, ladies and gentlemen, I believe that the Government of Spain undoubtedly incorporates territorial cohesion as an element of progress and economic and social policy in our country.

I would like to tell you, ladies and gentlemen, that in the field of the primary sector, returning again to the important debate we have next Thursday in the Cortes Generales, this Royal Decree Law of aid and response to the economic and social consequences of the war includes direct aid to the livestock sector, direct aid to the fishing sector, and also to agriculture. Reductions, for example, in port fees for the fishing sector. I also want to recall the Food Chain Law, the commitment of the Government of Spain to the transport sector, also to introduce transparency in the value chain so that services are not provided at a price higher than the cost, I mean the selling price. And as I said before, all the economic resources we are implementing to protect the intensive electro-industry, which is so important for Cantabria.

In short, ladies and gentlemen, despite all the difficulties, all the complexity, and I also understand the uncertainties that the Cantabrian society has, what I want to convey to you from here, from Madrid, is that this is a government that does not forget any of the territories. Not Cantabria nor its citizens.

And I hope, ladies and gentlemen, and I also recognize in your parliamentary group, both here and in the Congress of Deputies, your reliability, your loyalty, and your commitment to Cantabria and to Spain, supporting this important Royal Decree Law next Thursday, which will provide more tranquility, uncertainty, certainty, rather, to all Spanish citizens.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator Clemente Sánchez-Garnica of the Mixed Group

President: Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you very much, ladies and gentlemen. First of all, I would also like to acknowledge the presence of the Vice President of the Government of Aragon, Mr. Aliaga, here in your chamber, in the Territorial Chamber of all Spaniards. And I also want to recognize the work he has been doing for over a decade with the creation of the hydrogen foundation in Aragon.

You have rightly said, ladies and gentlemen, we are in such a complex, difficult moment, so full of uncertainties, in the midst of a transformation that requires unity, setting aside, let’s say, partisan struggle, which is legitimate, and thinking about the common good, about the general well-being of all citizens, and therefore, proposing measures in the short and medium term.

In the short term, to protect, to cushion, and to make a fair distribution of the burdens of the economic and social consequences of this war, but without losing sight of the fact that in the medium term we need to implement many substantial reforms if we want to address, first, the strategic autonomy, in this case, the energy autonomy of Europe based on renewable energies.

Second, to face the challenge of climate change. Just a few days ago, the international panel of scientists from the United Nations warned us that if there is not a drastic change in greenhouse gas emissions across the planet starting in 2025, we will not be able to reach that goal of not exceeding two and a half degrees of temperature by the end of the century. And therefore, that the consequences of climate change are still reversible and not irreversible, as, unfortunately, the dynamics are leading us. From that perspective, ladies and gentlemen, the Government of Spain is very clear. We have been the government that, during the last 40 years of democracy, has approved for the first time a legislative framework, which is the Climate Change Law. We have approved a National Integrated Energy and Climate Plan that has been recognized by the European Commission as one of the best proposed by the various governments of the member states, and we allocate around 40% of the European funds, of those 70 billion euros that we will receive over the next three years, 40%, 40% of that, ladies and gentlemen, to a just energy transition.

And in that sense, ladies and gentlemen, I regret that there are political parties, and I am not looking at you, I am looking more at the right-wing bench, that are betting again on nuclear energy, that are betting again on reopening thermal power plants, when, ultimately, what we need to do is move towards a much more sustainable energy model from a social, economic, and also environmental perspective.

I tell you, ladies and gentlemen, that the commitment of the Government of Spain is to advance and not to retreat a single millimeter and to use precisely this energy crisis to return to past energy models.

And in that context, ladies and gentlemen, green hydrogen is, let’s say, the fundamental pillar.

As you know, within the framework of the Recovery, Transformation, and Resilience Plan, we have approved a strategic project, you know it, the PERTE for renewable energy, renewable hydrogen, and storage. We launched, at the end of last year, the first of four calls for an amount of 250 million euros to promote the entire value chain of renewable hydrogen in our country. I must also acknowledge, as I said at the beginning of my speech, and you also conveyed in your speech, the commitment of the Government of Aragon collaborating with the Government of Spain to make the Ebro Valley the Hydrogen Valley in the future. And in that sense, I want to highlight the case of Renfe, the public company Renfe, which will undertake the remodeling of a Cercanías unit in Zaragoza to transform it into a demonstrator of the hydrogen train.

You know well that there are still technical difficulties to overcome, such as, for example, hydrogen traction that can handle large gradients. And that is why there is a group of companies and national and international organizations, including Adif, Renfe, and the National Hydrogen Center, involved in the European project to work on replacing polluting railway energy with renewable hydrogen.

I would like, in relation to the question you posed, to give you two dates. First, January 22, 2021, when I had the opportunity to present, together with the President of the Government of Aragon, Javier Lambán, and the Vice President of Aragon, the Recovery, Transformation, and Resilience Plan at the Congress Palace in Zaragoza. There, I expressed my commitment, the commitment of the Government of Spain to advance in the railway connection with France through Canfranc, also developing technologies that allow trains powered, as I said before, by green hydrogen.

And second, on February 28 of this year, when a meeting of the four-party working group was held in Zaragoza for the reopening of this railway line Zaragoza-Canfranc-Pau, composed of the Government of Spain, the Government of Aragon, the Government of France, and the Government of New Aquitaine in France, where significant progress was made in terms of technical specifications and the creation of an economic interest group to participate in any relevant European calls, such as the one I mentioned earlier.

Therefore, ladies and gentlemen, I believe that the commitment of the Government of Aragon and the Government of Spain to green hydrogen is unequivocal. And while those technical advances are being made that will allow us to achieve that railway connection powered by, let’s say, environmentally sustainable trains, what we are doing is continuing to advance in that line of railway policy, simply to convey some proposals that are already being implemented between Huesca and Canfranc through the modernization of the line in preparation for its future expansion in the international stretch.

Today, in the Council of Ministers, by the way, we have authorized the renewal of the track between Ayerbe and Caldearenas, promoting, secondly, the implementation of standard gauge. This is what will allow, ladies and gentlemen, an interconnection or rather, a connection through the Pyrenees. In the case of freight transport, the corridor will connect the Zaragoza Plaza terminal and the Huesca Logistics Platform, which I believe is also very good news. And we will also award, as we did last year, the study for the reopening of the Somport tunnel, which is being drafted in collaboration with the French side.

I believe, ladies and gentlemen, that we are indeed, as you rightly indicated at the beginning of your speech, in a moment of profound changes that are extraordinarily complex, requiring collaboration, dialogue, and agreement among multiple actors at the European, national, and territorial levels.

And in that sense, ladies and gentlemen, I greatly appreciate the loyalty and stability that you guarantee to the Government of Aragon and undoubtedly, also the constructive attitude you have in all these present and future projects for Aragon and for the whole country. And once again, I recognize that work in the presence of the Vice President of the Government of Aragon here today in the Territorial Chamber.