Statements at the Permanent Representation following the European Council

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

16 October 2020 · European Council (press statements following the summit) · Permanent Representation of Spain to the EU

Context
Sánchez addressed media at Spain's Permanent Representation in Brussels following the October 2020 European Council summit, summarizing key outcomes on COVID-19 and Brexit.
Main themes
COVID-19 pandemic response, European Council outcomes, pan-European coordination, vaccination strategy, Brexit negotiations, harmonization of quarantine measures, risk mapping, mobility restrictions, testing capacity, Spain's EU engagement
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,507
93rd percentile
Sentences
223
91st percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
3.16
67th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
10th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 61%61%
  • Geopolitical 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

223 sentences in 80 paragraphs

First of all, I would like to thank the media for being here. For attending this appearance, to be more precise, and also to thank once again the entire team at the Embassy, the Permanent Representation, and also the Foreign Affairs team for the prior work that has been done to ensure that this Council reached a successful conclusion.

Well, we have addressed many topics over this day and a half. I will start not by the order in which we have discussed them during this day and a half, but by what I understand may be of greater interest to all of you and also to the Spanish public opinion.

First of all, I would like to talk about the debate we had on Covid-19, on the pandemic. The evolution of the pandemic across Europe. All European leaders have expressed concern about the evolution of the infection data across the European continent.

There has been a shared analysis of the need to reinforce the message, to appeal to the individual responsibility of each and every one of us. After all, the virus is transmitted through people and therefore, we must not let our guard down. Maintaining what we have said on many occasions, the three Ms: the mask, the two meters of distance, and also hand washing is essential for us to collectively curb the curve of infections on the European continent.

Secondly, alongside that individual responsibility, we have also talked about the need to harmonize responses, to improve coordination regarding the pandemic response.

I believe that precisely at the last European Council, before this one, at the beginning of October, we had the opportunity to discuss Covid-19 and as a result, the General Affairs Council this week achieved two important advances in that common harmonized response we need to provide at the European level to the pandemic.

First, a recommendation based on a risk map of areas that indeed have a higher accumulated incidence and another series of indicators. And secondly, the recognition of tests among the different countries. These have been two recommendations that Spain worked hard on to reach this agreement, these recommendations.

It is true that we found it insufficient, that it must be the first of many other steps we need to take at the European level to provide that harmonized response.

We have two topics left, which we consider important. One relates to the definition of what a quarantine is. Whether it is fourteen days, ten days, or seven days… You know that there is a different response depending on the country. Obviously, always based on scientific criteria, but we believe from Spain that we need to provide a harmonized response to this issue.

And the other relates to mobility restrictions and also the need to reinforce testing capacity in contrast to that premise.

Well, I believe that these issues have been endorsed in the European Council. It is also encouraged in the conclusions to continue working on improving that coordinated response and it also recognizes the effort made by the European Commission to propose a common vaccination strategy when the Covid-19 vaccine arrives.

This is an important issue. You know that we also, I believe it was three weeks ago, four weeks ago, my memory is a bit hazy, reached an agreement in the Interterritorial Council to create a working group among the autonomous communities to start planning a common vaccination strategy against Covid when it is provided by science.

Then it was proposed to create that working group, especially to define which groups would be the first to be vaccinated against Covid. Well, this same thing that we did a few weeks ago in Spain is something that has also been proposed by the Commission at the European level.

I think this is very good news. I believe it is also consistent with the work that the European Commission has been developing, especially in the area of the vaccine. You know that fortunately the European Commission is leading the joint purchase and signing with the major pharmaceutical companies that are currently the most advanced in the Covid vaccine and therefore for us, for the Government of Spain, it is very good news that we are taking steps in the direction of harmonizing, coordinating our response to the pandemic in a much more reinforced manner.

As a second point of interest, I think we can talk about Brexit.

Well, it has simply been a statement of the state of the negotiation with the United Kingdom by the negotiating team led by the French Michel Barnier.

Well, I think it is evident that there are ten weeks left, just over ten weeks until the exit date that the United Kingdom voluntarily proposed back in June-July to make its exit from the European Union effective, or to materialize, to be more precise, its exit from the European Union.

And indeed, there are still pending issues to work on and negotiate, and they are all public, right? They are governance, the so-called "Level Playing Field," that is, the competition conditions between countries or the rules that the United Kingdom would have in this case, fishing, which is also important for our country.

As you know, it is important that the trade agreement incorporates important elements for our interests, for example in air transport as you know. And undoubtedly also that bilateral negotiation we are maintaining with the United Kingdom regarding Gibraltar and what its situation will be after the United Kingdom leaves the European Union.

Well, what we have stated and what all members of the European Council have said is, first of all, that our disposition is absolute, it is total to reach an agreement with the United Kingdom. That obviously what we want is to have the best relations with the United Kingdom, with a third country. Close relations with the United Kingdom, but that the agreement cannot be just any agreement. It has to be an agreement that benefits both parties and that obviously maintains some elements that are very important for the European Union, and one of them is fundamental. I would say, logically the single market and the proper functioning of the single market.

From there, what we have conveyed to all members of the Council is support for the negotiating team in these last meters if you allow me, of negotiation after five years with the United Kingdom.

Secondly, unity. I believe that the strategy of maintaining unity among the 27 member states has worked, it has been very positive to create synergies and defend the multiple interests we have as the 27 member states when we talk about the United Kingdom.

And finally, solidarity. I believe that showing solidarity, for example, with the Irish issue in the negotiation with the United Kingdom, is as important as solidarity, for example, with those countries that are more affected than others in issues related, for example, to fishing or many others that are still pending resolution.

The third point, which I also consider important - there are four points and with this I will finish - the third point is in the conclusions the debate we have initiated and that will be substantiated in a much more concrete manner in December, on climate objectives, on climate ambition.

You know that Spain, along with ten other countries, has signed a letter advocating for greater ambition in climate objectives for reducing CO2 emissions.

The proposal made by the Commission and the European Council that we all agreed on was to make the European Union a climate-neutral economy, that is, climate neutrality by 2050.

The European Commission during this time has been conducting studies to see what the economic feasibility of that transition to climate neutrality by 2050 is, and therefore, we have been presented with the possibility of accelerating and intensifying these agreements by proposing a reduction of emissions to 55% by 2030 as an intermediate objective.

It is included in the conclusions of the Council. I imagine it will be an intense debate that we will have in December. But well, Spain shares those objectives, shares the climate ambition, positions itself at the forefront along with many other countries of climate ambition. I believe it is something very important for our country and also a source of opportunity to define a new leadership after this post-pandemic world, when it emerges and we overcome this pandemic on the part of the European Union.

And finally, some elements related to foreign policy. On Turkey, the Eastern Mediterranean, well, you know what the conclusion is. Some countries have expressed their concerns regarding some attitudes of Turkey and consequently, we have appealed to the conclusions of October 2 and ultimately also to continue on that path of positive dialogue that the High Representative Josep Borrell has always defended and also the President of the Council and the President of the European Commission.

We have always maintained a constructive dialogue with Turkey. It is a strategic partner for the entire European Union, with a stabilizing capacity in a very, very important area for the entire European Union, which we undoubtedly want to reinforce with that constructive attitude.

We have logically talked about the opposition leader Navalny, the conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh. We have also talked about the strategic relationship, the partnership between the European Union and Africa, which for us as a country is, logically, very important. And in that sense, we have proposed some elements of what that partnership between the European Union and Africa should be. And well, we are waiting for the summit to be held, hopefully, in December between the European Union and Africa.

These are the topics we have addressed. Well, they are topics that may seem distant from our interests, but undoubtedly they are very close, they are very everyday.

Africa, after all, is not only a continent very close to our territory, but it is also a continent with which we have many interests in many countries. Not only from the point of view of migration policy, security, but also economic interests.

Logically, talking about the United Kingdom is talking about our interests. We are ten weeks away from the definitive exit of the United Kingdom from the European Union and this will have its consequences. No matter how much there is an agreement, there will be consequences and we will logically have to be prepared for it within the framework of the European Union and also in our bilateral relations.

On climate change, I think it is something that citizens, and especially young people, have much more incorporated into what the challenges and opportunities of the future represent and that ecological transition.

And finally, regarding Covid, well, I obviously want to convey that I think we can say that we are making progress in a common response to a shared concern that is common to all European countries regarding the evolution of the pandemic.

And in this context, and with this I will finish because I forgot to mention it in the first reference I made about Covid, well, most countries have asked the European Parliament to accelerate the processing of the multiannual financial framework, the approval of the Recovery Fund so that as soon as possible, at the beginning of next year, we can have all the instruments in place to address economic recovery, transformation, and the future resilience of our economies.

And with this, I am at your disposal to answer your questions.

Q.- Hello, good afternoon, President. I wanted to ask you how you interpret the statement made yesterday by the European Commission regarding the reform that PSOE and Unidas Podemos have promoted to renew the Judiciary. Do you see it as a wake-up call from Brussels?

And on the other hand, I wanted to know if you think that for that reason the recovery funds may be at risk. Thank you.

President.- Well, thank you very much, Sandra, for your question. It should be noted that in the report presented by the European Commission just a few weeks ago, there was talk of the need to renew the General Council of the Judiciary.

I believe this is important. To know exactly what the root, the origin of the institutional crisis that is being experienced in Spain is as a consequence of the blockage by the Popular Party.

The proposal that has been put forward by the parliamentary groups in Congress, that is, in the Legislative Power, I believe is a proposal that what it does is propose a way out. It is an anti-blocking law in the face of an absolute obstruction position that the Popular Party has been exercising in the General Courts for the renewal of the governing body of judges for the past two years.

It has an easy solution. The solution is for the Popular Party to return to the path of state responsibility, to return to the path of fulfilling its constitutional obligations, and for us to be able to address the renewal of a fundamental body for the proper functioning of our democracy, which is the General Council of the Judiciary.

As simple as that.

Who is holding the General Council of the Judiciary hostage is the party that has been blocking the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary for two years.

It should be noted that the General Council of the Judiciary stems from a parliamentary majority that dates back to 2011, and we are now in 2020. We are in 2020. Parliamentary majorities have changed, and consequently, all of this must be seen, let’s say, visualized, materialized in the renewal of the governing bodies as mandated by the Spanish Constitution.

In short, this proposal put forward by the Legislative Power, two parliamentary groups that I would like to remind you do not have an absolute majority, that is, they total 155 seats and therefore will have to talk with other parliamentary forces.

This proposal, if you allow me, can be summarized as follows. The Popular Party, if it uses the law to block the Constitution, the Legislative Power has the responsibility to modify the law so that the Constitution is upheld.

Now, we as the executive power, tell the Popular Party that we are open from the very first minute, starting today if they want, to sit down and negotiate under the premises and conditions agreed upon in July, early August, which were inexplicably unilaterally broken again by the Popular Party, to reach an agreement for the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary as soon as possible. Because that is what we want. Because that is what we want.

Q.- Good afternoon, Mr. President. Does that mean then that if the Popular Party agrees to sit down to negotiate, that the parliamentary initiative from the PSOE and Podemos would be withdrawn from this moment? We would also like to know if during this European Council, have any heads of government spoken to you, shown any reservations, or asked you any questions about this reform? And I also wanted to ask you. The budget plan was presented yesterday. It foresees an income of three billion three hundred seventy million from tax changes, which has not yet been detailed to the Government. I wanted to know if you could provide more details on those tax changes, if there will be additional measures on VAT, besides those already mentioned regarding diesel or new tranches of personal income tax. Thank you.

President.- Thank you very much, Patricia, for your questions. Regarding your second question, no, no comments.

In relation to your third question, you will soon know not only the music but also the lyrics and the numbers of the budget project that we are going to present to the chambers. Therefore, at that moment we will be in a position to answer all your questions.

And regarding your first question. Of course, we want to negotiate and agree with the Popular Party on the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary. We have wanted to do this for two years. You see, in these two years, since Pablo Casado became the leader of the Popular Party, there have been two agreements for the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary: one in 2018 that was unilaterally broken after being reached; and two, the agreement at 99 percent that we reached in July, early August, which was also unilaterally broken by the Popular Party. Since then, what has happened? What has happened is that the president of the Supreme Court and president of the General Council of the Judiciary have sent a letter, not one, but several letters to the Congress of Deputies to say that the General Council of the Judiciary must be renewed. By the way, a governing body that has been in office for two years and continues to appoint judges, continues to appoint judges.

Well, the Legislative Power over these weeks has done two very important things; both the Congress and the Senate have proposed motions and resolutions in a majority manner, and we are not talking about 176 seats in the case of the Congress of Deputies, we are talking about 188 seats in the case of the Congress of Deputies, saying that it was necessary to renew the General Council of the Judiciary and urging the Popular Party to end the blockade. A blockade, moreover, that has no basis that places them outside the Constitution and the sense of state that is required of the main opposition party.

Therefore, the Judiciary has spoken, the Legislative Power has spoken. The Executive Power, logically, has urged, and you know very well that for quite some time, the main opposition party to sit down, negotiate, and comply with the Constitution. And I insist, we are willing based on the terms of the agreement from July, to sit down again with the Popular Party and unblock this situation now, tomorrow if they want, we have no problem.

What does the proposal put forward by the Legislative Power do? What it does is not evade its responsibility to provide a solution to this inexplicable blockade by the Popular Party. What it does is respect the majority of 300 in the first vote and create a safeguard to avoid the blockade, to avoid the blockade in the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary.

Therefore, between the blockade and the reform, evidently, their parliamentary groups have opted for the reform. But I insist, it is the Legislative Power that will now have to provide a response and a reform to a situation of blockade that has been posed by the Popular Party. Now, if the Popular Party returns to the path of state sense, which is actually common sense, then evidently the Government of Spain is more than willing to reach an agreement now, without waiting a second longer.

What is not acceptable, what is not acceptable is that we maintain not just for two years, because the proposal being made by the Popular Party is for no renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary during these four years of the legislature. So, what would the situation be? To have a governing body of judges in office for six years or five years. This is the proposal being made by the main opposition party. It seems unacceptable to me. That is why I call for common sense, for state responsibility, to comply with the Constitution, to sit down with the Government, and I insist, to reach an agreement as soon as possible.

You see, today, in fact, the person responsible for Justice and Interior, I believe it is Mr. López, gave an interview in the newspaper La Razón, where he says he is willing to sit down and negotiate with the Government of Spain for the renewal of the Council. Perfect. Tomorrow itself. Who leads those negotiations on behalf of the Government of Spain? The Minister of Justice. We were about to reach an agreement in July, the agreement was already 99 percent closed, the representation of a majority, of another majority, and therefore all we have to do is, once and for all, resolve this dilemma that is evidently not sustainable over time. I believe that citizens understand this. Citizens understand that we cannot have a government in the governing body of judges for six years in office. Because, moreover, it is not guaranteed that if in four years, when the elections are held, the Popular Party loses the elections again, then what? Is there also no renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary? It makes no sense.

Q.- Good afternoon, Mr. President, I wanted to clarify if I understand correctly, what conclusion do you personally draw, apart from what you have already said about the comment made yesterday by the European Commission in the Justice Department of the European Commission, regarding the reform? Because it seems to me that in the view of this problem, the European Commission would accept a reform, but surely in favor of greater independence of the Judiciary, and not in greater dependence on it. And then regarding that, well, the question is, what conclusion do you draw from that note, from this?

And secondly, I am struck by the fact that you insist you are willing to negotiate with the PP. The question is, are you willing to make concessions, let’s say, to facilitate that negotiation and come closer? I say this because normally in negotiations, one concedes, the other concedes as well, in short.

President.- Absolutely. Well, I have to tell you that all, all, and moreover, the interlocutors of the Popular Party know that we have shown the utmost willingness, the utmost availability to concede, because we understand that an agreement ultimately always benefits everyone and is detrimental to each and every one of the parties. And therefore, we have the utmost availability to make concessions to unblock a situation like the one we have been living for two years. But I insist, look at how much that is the willingness to agree of the Government of Spain, that we reached two agreements in the last two years; I have been waiting for Mr. Casado for two years to renew the General Council of the Judiciary, and in two years there have been two agreements, and those two agreements have been unilaterally broken by the Popular Party. But I insist, if the third time is the charm, then welcome the third.

I appeal to that common sense, to that state responsibility, to return to the Constitution and fulfill the obligation that the Constitution mandates. If I insist, this has an easy solution. And that is that the Popular Party sits down to agree on the renewal of a body that, by the way, what we are proposing on the part of the Legislative Power and that will now be processed in Congress and all parliamentary groups will have to debate, and we will see what the result of that parliamentary processing is, is the election of the governing body, not the election of the judges. This is important. All concessions that are possible within, of course, logic. And secondly, absolute respect, because the spokesperson of the European Commission said absolute respect.

Q.- Hello. Thank you very much. Expanding on this, what is your opinion on the judgment of the European Commission, does the Government interpret it as a wake-up call, does it interpret it as an opinion to be taken into account? I think we need to know how the government interprets the message from the Commission.

And as a result of that, I wanted to ask if you are going to engage in conversations with the Commission to explain to them, well, yesterday Casado and Dolores Montserrat sent a letter to Commissioner Reynders. I don’t know if the Government is also making efforts to explain the project it has on the table.

And finally on this, what deadlines do you set for negotiations with the PP, to continue the parliamentary process? And if you have support for that parliamentary process. Thank you very much.

President.- Regarding, thank you Andrés, regarding your questions, first, absolute respect for what this spokesperson of the Directorate General of Justice says. Absolute respect. Secondly, you see, since we started the legislature and this pandemic hit us, Andrés, you will have seen what the Popular Party's opposition stance has been here in Brussels. During the first wave, we encountered a proposal for a report that was raised to the community institutions by the European People's Party, by the Spanish delegation of the European People's Party, from a former minister, by the way, of Health, Dolors Montserrat, from the previous government of Mariano Rajoy, where our country was said to suffer from democratic conduct, that we were using the state of alarm not for public safety and health to save lives, but for who knows what issues. In short, the Popular Party has used everything against the Government of Spain to undermine the Government of Spain during this pandemic, even coming here to the community institutions to say and do things that it considered.

Not only did it do that during the negotiation of the Recovery Fund and the agreement in July, we also heard the main opposition leader say the things he said about Spain, about the need to, well, create difficulties for the Government of Spain regarding the reforms it had to make. Subsequently in Madrid, I witnessed a meeting that the opposition leader had with the 27 ambassadors stationed in Madrid from the different countries of the European Union, questioning the management capacity and a potential risk of nepotism in the distribution of recovery funds by the Government of Spain, as if our country had no controls or public employees who defend, as they have always defended, transparency, accountability, and the fight against corruption.

And now this. Therefore, in short, this is not new. This is part of a strategy that the Popular Party has been implementing since it has been in opposition, since Mr. Casado became the leader of the opposition, and I think it is a mistake, because in the end it is not an opposition to the Government of Spain, it is an opposition to the interests of the country and therefore, I believe they are mistaken. But in any case, I insist, this has an easy solution: the Popular Party sits down with the Government of Spain, we renew the General Council of the Judiciary and therefore, we overcome this position of blockade. But what the Popular Party cannot do is use the law to violate the Constitution, because in the same way, the Legislative Power will have every right to modify that law so that the Constitution is upheld.

And the procedures, in short, I represent the Executive Power, it will have to be the Legislative Power, in this case the groups who decide what procedure and what deadlines to give.

I insist, there are two important issues in that proposed modification made by the parliamentary groups of the Socialist Party and Unidas Podemos: one is, indeed, to create that safeguard and anti-blocking clause in case the 300 votes are not met in the first vote for the election of the government of judges, not of the judges, which is an important nuance; secondly, something important that we have been seeing over these two years is that a caretaker government cannot continue appointing judges to the chambers of the Supreme Court. Therefore, we need to define, or at least the Legislative Power needs to define, what the competencies are in a situation of blockage like the one we are experiencing, in this case, the Judicial Power of the Supreme Court and the General Council of the Judiciary.

Good afternoon, Mr. President. The Popular Party sets as a condition for sitting down that Unidas Podemos is not at that table. Would you be willing to accept that condition? And secondly, aside from the criticisms from the opposition, considering the controversy generated by that announcement, that reform proposal with a large part of the judiciary rejecting it and questioning it, even your investiture partners show doubts, are you not considering taking a step back? Thank you.

President.- Well, let's see, regarding the first of the issues, I simply think that the proposal says little about the willingness to reach an agreement on the part of the Popular Party. They know perfectly well that this is a coalition government, and the legitimacy of each and every member of the Government and also of the seats that are freely elected by the citizens must be assumed and accepted by the political parties. Moreover, under that premise, I tell you that the one leading the negotiations is the Minister of Justice. It is the Minister of Justice.

I have said it many times, there are no ministers in my Government, neither from the Socialist Party nor ministers and minister from Unidas Podemos. There are ministers of the Government of Spain, which is a coalition government, yes, but they are the ministers of the Government of Spain. And therefore, in this case, the one with whom the Popular Party has to negotiate is the Minister of Justice, who is in charge of these matters within the Council of Ministers. As simple as that. Well, it seems to me to be common sense.

And regarding the other issue, I insist. Governments, parliaments, are here to solve problems, not to create them. And therefore, if there has been for the past two years a total unjustified blocking will that flagrantly violates the Spanish Constitution, as the Popular Party is doing, without any reason, because, well, when it is said that the General Council of the Judiciary is politicized, who is holding that General Council of the Judiciary hostage because they block its renewal as mandated by the Spanish Constitution. Well, what the Legislative Power does is propose a solution, propose a solution that, I insist, does not start with an absolute majority. It starts with 155 seats, which responds to a resolution of the parliamentary majority of the Congress and the Senate, 188 seats in the Congress of Deputies, which states that indeed the Legislative Power must renew the General Council of the Judiciary and that respects, I insist, the three-fifths majority. In the first vote, it respects those three-fifths and what it does is create an anti-blocking clause to avoid this obstructive position that, unfortunately, when the Popular Party is in opposition, we always suffer when we talk about judges and the governing body of judges. And this is profoundly harmful to our institutional architecture and also to the proper functioning of such an important body as the government of judges. Therefore, I insist, I want to end with a positive message. The Government is willing to reach an agreement, already, tomorrow, not to wait any longer with the Popular Party to unblock the situation and the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary. We show our absolute and with absolute clarity, our availability, the absolute availability to negotiate, to agree on that renewal. What cannot be done is to maintain a blocking position that has lasted for two years and whose prospects are to last six years. Until the next legislature, at least, because I insist, if the Popular Party loses again, then maybe it is more.

What is unacceptable is that we have a General Council of the Judiciary with a parliamentary majority from 2011, from the absolute majority of the Popular Party when we are in 2020. I understand that the Popular Party wants to be in 2011, but we are in 2020. There are different parliamentary majorities. The people have spoken, not once, but several times. And the Constitution mandates that every five years the General Council of the Judiciary, the Constitutional Court, the Ombudsman must be renewed, we have been without renewing it since 2017.

I think that returning to common sense, to a sense of state, to their responsibility towards the Constitution, I no longer say in the interest of reaching agreements with the Government of Spain, which, well, does not have much interest, but at least to comply with the Constitution and to reinforce the Constitution seems to me to be a duty for all those parties, like the Popular Party, that boast of being a Constitutional Party. Well, if you are constitutionalists, you must comply with every single article of the Constitution, from the first to the last. Not those that interest you and those that do not interest you, no. And that is what the Popular Party has to do.

I urge a return to that path of agreement, of common sense, of responsibility towards the Constitution and of renewing a very important body that cannot continue to be in a caretaker situation at this critical moment that our country is experiencing.

Thank you very much.