28. Speech at the Meeting of Mukhtars

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

19 October 2016 · 28th Meeting of Mukhtars · Presidential Complex, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed the 28th Meeting of Mukhtar (village heads) at the Presidential Complex on Muhtar Day, October 19, 2016, welcoming representatives from 16 provinces.
Main themes
Mukhtar (village head) governance, local democracy, public service and trust, July 15 coup attempt, Turkish history and War of Independence, Lausanne Treaty debate, National Pact, civic duty, critical and questioning youth, appointed vs. elected officials
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,670
90th percentile
Sentences
277
94th percentile
Readability
66
95th percentile
Grade
8.3
6th percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
45th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 57%56%
  • Social 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

277 sentences in 57 paragraphs

Dear esteemed village heads,

My precious brothers and sisters;

I greet you with my heartfelt feelings, with longing and affection. Welcome to the Presidential Complex, the house of the nation.

We are together with you at the 28th Muhtar Meeting. Today, we are hosting you, our esteemed muhtars from the provinces of Batman, Bingöl, Burdur, Erzincan, Gaziantep, Giresun, İzmir, Kayseri, Konya, Manisa, Osmaniye, Sakarya, Sivas, Şanlıurfa, Yozgat, and Zonguldak.

At the very beginning of my words, I congratulate you on your Muhtar Day, October 19. On this important day, representatives from 10 different muhtar federations and the Turkish Muhtar Confederation are also present among us.

Today, our youngest muhtar, our longest-serving muhtar, and our husband-wife and mother-son muhtars who serve simultaneously are also with us. I extend a warm welcome to you as well.

Our muhtars are the fundamental stones of democracy as the first step in positions that are filled through elections. It is truly very difficult to explain to those who do not know what it means to win the hearts of the people and to gain their votes as a candidate for service.

As you know, there are appointed officials and elected officials. In fact, some of those who appear to be elected are in effect appointed. Because they have come to their positions not through their own merit but through manipulation and trickery. For this reason, they belittle the people, the people's preferences, and the people's values. They regard the struggle to win the support of the public as insignificant in their own minds. However, most of these individuals would not be able to secure the votes of their own spouses, children, neighbors, or even the tradespeople in their neighborhoods if they were to enter a real election.

Similarly, we see that those who have been appointed to certain positions to serve the people have also fallen into similar errors. All public officials who come through appointments, from undersecretaries, general directors, governors, district governors, department heads to clerks, are obliged to serve the nation with the resources of the state. Whether elected or appointed, the resources allocated to them as a result of the duties they undertake are a trust. The essence is to regard and protect this trust as a matter of honor and to fulfill the requirements of their duties properly.

I know very well that our muhtars act with this awareness as individuals who have taken on the trust of the neighborhood or village they were elected from. Since the day we took on the responsibility of governing the country, we have been striving to establish the principle of "live the person so that the state lives" at all levels of public administration.

My brothers and sisters; I believe we have made significant progress in establishing a governance understanding that serves the people rather than ruling over them.

On the night of July 15, our nation filled the streets and squares to protect its homeland and flag, standing by its state with this understanding. Our heroic citizens who stood against the coup plotters that night knew that they could only secure a safe future by defending their independence. That is why we refer to July 15 as our second War of Independence.

Dear brothers and sisters;

We must learn and understand our War of Independence, both before and after, very well. Therefore, yesterday at the meeting held by the Higher Education Institution, I expressed to all our rectors, vice-rectors, deans, professors, and young people that my request from our teachers is this: Let us teach our history well to our children, because they have deceived us with a history that always tells lies. I also advised our students and young people to learn their own history well. As you know, the topic we have recently brought to the agenda by referring to the Lausanne Treaty, followed by the National Pact, is the clearest expression of how this process has been managed and how some truths have been taught to us incorrectly.

Some people are disturbed by our young people studying and researching Lausanne; let them be disturbed. Why are you afraid? Let it be discussed, let it be examined, let’s see who said what, let’s know what is right and what is wrong. In other words, the logic of "my party's founder went to sign at Lausanne or signed there, so this is true" cannot exist. Is it true? Let’s ask ourselves this question. If there are those who say it is wrong, let’s also ask why they say it is wrong. We do not want a uniform-minded youth; we want a questioning youth, a researching youth. That is why when they question and research, they will grasp the truth. I want to see our youth as bees, not as wasps. And let them go from flower to flower, making honey so that all humanity can benefit from it.

We mentioned the National Pact, didn’t we? Now, why does the National Pact disturb? Who brought the National Pact to the agenda? Gazi Mustafa Kemal. Why are you disturbed? Look, we are not disturbed. How does the National Pact start from the West? Is there no history here? Does this nation not have a past? Why are you disturbed? Do not be disturbed. Therefore, let’s learn this, let’s know what was yesterday, what is today? And of course, some do not want to understand this; they have other concerns, but thankfully there are those who understand. And at this point, as Mr. Bahçeli expressed in his speech yesterday, I thank him. Because as long as political movements unite in the truth, this nation will win; we must achieve this.

Now, when we look back today, what is the picture? The Ottoman Empire was such a great and deep-rooted state that its collapse caused deep wounds, both materially and spiritually, on our nation. In 1914… Look where we have come from. Ah, I wonder if our youth knows this? When we signed Lausanne, the size of our lands, which was 2.5 million square kilometers, had fallen to 780 thousand square kilometers, including Hatay, which was later added. Look, from 2.5 million to 780 thousand square kilometers, the time is so short.

As we entered our War of Independence, our goal was to defend the borders of the National Pact. Unfortunately, we could not protect our National Pact goals on both our western and southern borders. Those who try to excuse this situation due to the conditions of the time may be able to justify this approach to a certain extent. The real tragedy is the understanding that accepts this situation, which arises out of necessity, as the essence and completely confines ourselves within this shell. We reject this understanding. The aim of those who have trapped Turkey in such a vicious cycle since 1923 is to make us forget our thousand-year existence in this geography, our Seljuk and Ottoman past. Do you know what we have come from to 780 thousand square kilometers? If we look back, we have come from 20 million square kilometers.

We cannot act with the psychology of 1923 in 2016; insisting on this is the greatest injustice to the country and the nation. Since we established our Republic, while everything in the world has changed, we cannot see maintaining our position at that time as an achievement, because we are a nation that won our independence with the strategy of "there is no line of defense, there is a plane of defense, that plane is the entire homeland." Although we won our independence with this understanding, we must leave behind the mentality that forces us to pass the entirety of our Republic's history through a line of defense. Everything that has happened to us in the last 93 years has stemmed from this understanding.

Indeed, when we look back, we see that we could not take action until the problem knocked on our door, until the knife was at our throat, until we were sunk in the quagmire. For this reason, if you pay attention, our door has never been empty; we have never had a period where we could breathe easily, and we have paid such costs in every period. We have paid great costs in politics; we have lost a lot of time due to coups, memorandums, and tutelage regimes. We have paid great costs in the economy; unfortunately, we have fallen far behind the countries we started competing with in the same lane. We have paid great costs in humanitarian terms; we have lost thousands of our children, our young generations in the fight against terrorism and in brotherly conflicts. We no longer want to pay costs.

Dear brothers and sisters;

Here, in the presence of you muhtars, I declare: Turkey has now abandoned this wrong security understanding; it has put an end to it. From now on, we will not wait for problems to knock on our door. From now on, we will not endure until the knife is at our throat. From now on, we will not accept being sunk in the quagmire up to our throats. We will now go after the problems. Do we have a terrorism problem? We will not wait for terrorist organizations to come and attack us; wherever these organizations operate, wherever they nest, we will go there and crush them. Are there threats against us in Syria and Iraq? We will not wait for these threats to reach our borders; we will look for ways to eliminate and resolve these threats at their source. Instead of dealing with the flies, we will find ways to dry up the swamp.

Look, Turkey has been fighting the PKK terrorist organization for over 30 years. We have eliminated about 40 thousand members of this organization, but we could not stop their actions because for many years we were responding when the PKK attacked us; from now on, we will find and neutralize the PKK in the hideouts where it has been hiding inside and outside the country. We have identified the places where they have been hiding, concealing themselves, and preparing for actions for years. We are eliminating each one of them, and we will continue to do so. We will eradicate the roots of anyone who supports or provides resources to the separatist organization. Look, I am saying this clearly; we will let them go wherever they want until we find and eliminate them. I am saying this openly. Similarly, they will not have a single day of peace in the places they are stationed abroad. Why? We will constantly disturb the heads of state and government of those countries regarding this issue, and we will present them with the files. Whatever they do, whether they imprison them or do whatever they need to do, let them do it. Whether they hand them over to us or whatever they do, let them do it. We are capturing the members of organizations like DHKP-C before they can act and delivering them to justice.

We are also fighting against FETÖ in the same way. We are tracking every member of this treacherous gang within civil society organizations and the business world step by step. No one’s betrayal in this country will go unpunished anymore. We will not harbor any terrorist organization or terrorist in this land. They will either be eliminated, or they will surrender, or they will leave.

Dear brothers and sisters;

Turkey is displaying a stance in line with this new security understanding in the face of the events occurring in Syria and Iraq. For years, we waited for a solution that would both alleviate the suffering of the oppressed Syrian people and ensure the security of our borders. But we saw that as we waited, the problems were coming upon us. When the ISIS terrorist organization waved its flag on one side and the PYD-YPG terrorist organization on the other, we understood that there was no benefit to be gained from anyone; we needed to cut our own umbilical cord.

When Turkey began the Euphrates Shield Operation, of course, it informed other relevant countries, but it did not seek permission from anyone. Seeking permission is one thing, informing is another. We initiated this operation together with the members of the Free Syrian Army, and thankfully we are carrying it out successfully. The result we achieved in Syria in two months could not be achieved in four years before. Once we entered the field, we saw that the real problem in Syria is not ISIS; there is a tactical and strategic game at play. The Syrian people have been chosen as the victims of this game. Can you imagine? The move that broke this game, which cost the lives of more than 600 thousand people in six years, was initiated by Turkey two months ago.

Thus, Cerablus was cleared of ISIS. What did nearly 30 thousand people from Cerablus do now? They came and settled in Cerablus. Similarly, Rai was also cleared of ISIS. Now the people of Rai have started to settle there as well. Now, the famous sacred place of theirs, the name of their magazine and what they express in their magazine, Dabık, which is also referred to as Mercidabık in our history, has been emptied of ISIS, and now the residents of that place are settling there. But now some are giving us advice. What do they say? "You have entered Dabık, good, we congratulate you for that; but do not go further down." What is further down? There is El-Bab. Excuse me, we will go there too. Why will we go? Because the area we are under threat from does not end at Dabık; it extends south of El-Bab. And from there, we need to besiege Manbij together with coalition forces. Because Manbij is 95% Arab. But who wants to occupy it? PYD and YPG. We told the Americans, "PYD-YPG will leave from here." Now let’s see, they promised. If they leave, there is no problem. "Can we act together in Raqqa?" they asked. We said we can, because Raqqa is the center of ISIS. Let’s also clear it of ISIS, and let the real owners settle there; we are also okay with that."

However, right now a similar scenario is being played out in Mosul, this time to incite sectarian conflict. It is quite clear that the Baghdad Administration, which has turned its own country into a playground for terrorist organizations, is not the real actor of this game. Those who are trying to prevent Turkey from entering the Mosul operation are disturbed by our disruption of their games in Syria. They want Turkey to sit still, watch what is happening, and then pay whatever price comes its way. Because they previously tried the same method through the refugee crisis.

Those who directed 3 million migrants from Syria and Iraq to our country thought we would be crushed under this burden. When the result did not turn out as they expected, they tied their hopes to terrorist organizations. ISIS and PYD-YPG are merely pawns that serve the same purpose and are supported by the same powers. Within Turkey, PKK and FETÖ are playing their roles in this scenario as well. The real issue is the restructuring of the region.

The project being attempted to be implemented through structures like the Baghdad Government and the Assad regime, along with terrorist organizations, threatens the survival of Turkey. No one is obliged to accept the role that has been assigned to us in this game. As Turkey, we will implement our own plans.

We have started. So far, our expenditure for 3 million people has exceeded 13 billion dollars in official state spending. There is also the expenditure made by NGOs and municipalities, which amounts to 26 billion dollars. The support we received from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees is 550 million dollars. The European Union said, "We will support you with 3 billion euros," and they will still provide it. The amount that has come, I do not know the final figure, but it is probably not more than 200-300 million euros. Because this money was supposed to come by the beginning of July. This money is not coming to us, it is coming to the refugees. If we keep these doors open, where will these refugees go? Europe. They said, "Okay, we will give this," because they are afraid of this, but they do not keep their promises. However, we said we cannot leave these people under the bombs, we cannot abandon them. When they come to the door, we open the door. We did this for 2 million 700 thousand Syrians, and we did this for 300 thousand Iraqis.

Oh Iraqi administration, isn’t it Turkey that has opened its doors to relieve you of these 300 thousand Iraqis? Others did not do this; we did. Therefore, when you throw a word at Turkey, when you say something to Turkey, you should think about this. You will not find such a friend. If you hurt this friendship, you will lose it. That is why I have been saying for days, "We will be both on the ground and at the table." And as a requirement of this new approach, we must solve the Mosul issue in Mosul. If we sacrifice Mosul, if we sacrifice it to sectarianism, we cannot prevent the problem from reaching our borders.

Our brothers in Mosul, the Northern Iraq Administration, and indeed the entire region will suffer greatly from this process. Just as we acted in Syria for a purpose and in a certain way, we are determined to act the same way for Mosul. Because the vast majority of Mosul is Arab Sunni, and there are also some Turkmen Sunni brothers. We cannot leave that place to a different sectarian understanding.

We are not enemies of Shia here. This is an interpretation; but I am against sectarianism. Because I say that Shia and Sunni; these are not religions. The religion above all is the true religion of Islam. For us, Islam is one, and we do what Islam commands; the others are interpretations. If you place Shiism in the place of Islam, I will be against it; if you place Sunnism in the place of Islam, I will be against that as well. Because for us, everything ends with the one religion, Islam, and we must accept this.

Countries that are active in the region must respect Turkey's right in this matter. We have a 911-kilometer border with Syria and a 350-kilometer border with Iraq. We will be neighbors here; we will not speak; they will cut and shape as they wish without borders, and then they will make the garment... There is no such thing. This attitude has nothing to do with war-mongering, violating Iraq's sovereignty, or any other ill intent. We want to be where we need to fight to protect our independence and future. Right now, that place is Mosul, so we will be in Mosul. Indeed, an agreement has been reached with American soldiers and generals regarding the participation of our air elements in the Mosul Operation. Hopefully, progress will be made on other issues as soon as possible.

In Syria, we have made significant progress in implementing our project for a 5,000 square kilometer safe zone by reaching Al-Bab and clearing Manbij of all terrorist organizations. Hopefully, we will resolve this issue as soon as possible.

On the other hand, every tear shed in Aleppo, every heart that burns, every house that is destroyed is a wound that opens in our hearts. Last night, I had a meeting with Mr. Putin, and we discussed Aleppo in this meeting. As of 10 PM, they expressed that they had stopped the air bombardments and would stop them. They also made requests regarding the departure of Al-Nusra from there. We have given our friends the necessary instructions on this matter, and we discussed a mutual agreement to work on removing Al-Nusra from Aleppo and ensuring the peace of the people of Aleppo.

Like all places in Syria, Iraq, the Balkans, and the Caucasus, we do not see Aleppo as separate from ourselves, nor can we. It is our duty to extinguish the fire burning in Aleppo as soon as possible for our brothers there. What is the border of Aleppo? Kilis, Gaziantep; right? If a migration starts in Aleppo, God forbid, at least 1 million people will come to Turkey, no matter how you look at it. We cannot afford the cost of this, excuse me. Those who provoke this must sit at the table with Turkey and discuss it. When the conflicts in Syria end, we will rebuild Aleppo together.

Oh my dear Aleppo, what has become of you? What has become of that city of civilization, that city of history... There is almost no stone left on stone there. Now, when we see the video recordings and so on, as someone who knows Aleppo well, our hearts truly bleed. We consider it important to establish a temporary ceasefire, even if for the first stage, and we will do what is necessary to take steps to ensure lasting security and peace in Aleppo.

Dear brothers and sisters;

The intensification of PKK and ISIS attacks within our country, and the continued attempts to keep FETÖ alive, are signs that we are progressing on the right path in Iraq after Syria. Those who encourage these actions think that if Turkey deals with PKK, ISIS, and FETÖ, it will lose its mobility in the region. They had the same hope on July 15. They thought that the Turkish Army had lost its operational capability due to the cleaning operations it initiated within itself after the coup attempt. Less than 40 days after the coup attempt, we showed them that this was not the case by launching the Euphrates Shield Operation.

Now they are trying to distract us with PKK and ISIS and keep us away from Mosul. You know that PKK is there, having sent 3,000 terrorists there. ISIS is there, and there are various reports about the number of ISIS members. While global communication networks are under the control of Western countries, both PKK and ISIS, as well as FETÖ, use these tools incredibly effectively. However, no organization or movement that poses a threat within the West has such a chance. In this direction, those who show even the slightest movement are immediately silenced, and their area of movement is eliminated. Any terrorist who has carried out or is preparing to carry out actions against Western countries is subjected to operations wherever they are. In contrast, for example, the perpetrators of terrorist actions targeting Turkey roam freely in Western countries, carrying out all kinds of activities. Now, with all these facts on the table, can we tolerate the lies told to us any longer?

Those who think they can shape our future through terrorist organizations are mistaken. On the contrary, we know that the weapon of terror will soon explode in their hands and start hurting them. As a country that has deported thousands of ISIS members and banned tens of thousands from entering our country, no one should underestimate our experience and foresight in this matter.

I once again warn those who side with terrorist organizations like PYD, YPG, sectarian fanatics like the Baghdad administration, and those who kill their own people like the Assad regime: You are on the wrong path; the fire you are trying to ignite will burn you more than it will burn us. The Baghdad administration should first explain to the world the sectarian structure of its own army; let’s see what percentage is made up of which sect. This is something I personally told Mr. Maliki during my term as Prime Minister for years: "Come and form your army according to the sectarian ratio in your population," but those who did not raise their voices continued to read what they knew.

Turkey has no other purpose than the peace, security, and well-being of its own citizens and its brothers in the region. Every move aimed at sidelining us is a step towards dragging the region into new pains. The consequences of these threats faced by Turkey, which is the most important representative of global values such as democracy, freedom, and human rights in our region, will be very heavy for everyone.

We are extremely careful not to take steps that will lead to permanent damage in our relations. We believe it is our right to expect the same sensitivity from our counterparts. We have not brought the issue to the point of "let it break where it is thin," nor do we want to.

But as a requirement of our new security understanding, we are determined to solve problems before they knock on our door. With our 2,200-year-old state tradition, our thousand-year presence in the geography, and our ancient civilization heritage, with God's permission, we will overcome these difficulties.

When everything is left behind tomorrow, we will not forget our friends who supported us in solving our problems during these difficult days, nor will we forget those who laid mines on our paths, those who opened the pits.

Dear brothers and sisters;

Today marks the 13th anniversary of the death of Aliya Izzetbegović, the first President of Bosnia and Herzegovina, a great fighter and thinker. I remember him once again with mercy, longing, and gratitude, and I pray for God's mercy upon him.

Aliya's leadership in the struggle of Bosnian Muslims has perhaps ensured the continued existence of the most important Islamic community in the heart of Europe, and hopefully, it will last forever. I believe it is the duty of every Muslim to keep alive the memory of this great man who kept the Bosniaks standing in the face of the genocide they were subjected to, guiding and leading them.

Today, the greatest deficiency of Muslim communities fighting for freedom and dignity in various parts of the world is their lack of wise leaders like Aliya. Every person can fight when necessary; if they have military training, they know how to fight. But the path to victory lies in knowing why you are fighting. Leaders like Aliya teach people why they are fighting. The places where Bosniaks were subjected to massacre are only and solely the places where they trusted the guarantees given to them and surrendered to international powers.

In no other place where the struggle was led by Aliya or where it was fought have such disasters occurred.

Do you know what is written on the very modest grave of Aliya in the Kovači Martyrs' Cemetery in Sarajevo? On the tombstone: "I swear by Allah, who is capable of all things, that we will not be slaves." And they did not become slaves. Yes, our duty is to fight to the death when necessary, in accordance with Aliya's will, but never to become slaves. On the 13th anniversary of his passing, I once again pray for God's mercy upon the wise king Aliya Izzetbegović. May God bless him with His Paradise and His beauty.

And oh Aliya, do not forget; there is a nation in Turkey that on the night of July 15 stood against F16s, helicopters, tanks, cannons, and weapons, saying, as our Independence Poet expressed, "Friend, do not let my homeland fall into the hands of the lowly; protect your body, let this shameless assault stop," and they shielded their bodies against these heavy weapons, F16s, but they did not surrender this country.

With these feelings, I once again express my gratitude to each of you for honoring the Presidential Complex, this sacred place. I ask you to convey my warmest greetings to my brothers in your neighborhoods and villages. We will be together at dinner shortly; for now, I greet you with love and respect, and I say may God be our helper. Stay safe.