Speech at the International Istanbul Law Congress

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

17 October 2016 · International Istanbul Law Congress · Istanbul, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed the inaugural International Istanbul Law Congress in Istanbul on October 17, 2016, speaking to justice ministers and judiciary leaders from nearly 40 countries.
Main themes
July 15 coup attempt, FETÖ terrorist organization, rule of law and judiciary independence, democracy and national resistance, international legal solidarity, judicial reform in Turkey, coup plotters and their networks, Turkey-West relations, constitutional legitimacy of post-coup measures
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,662
90th percentile
Sentences
266
94th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.77
19th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
41st percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 57%57%
  • Institutional 20%20%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

266 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Dear guests,

Valuable representatives of the judiciary,

Ladies and gentlemen;

I greet you all with love and respect.

I welcome our guests who have honored our congress from abroad to Turkey and Istanbul. I hope that the International Istanbul Law Congress will be a harbinger of good for our country and the entire world. I believe that we will have a productive meeting in the inspiring atmosphere of this historical place, the Bosphorus, which separates Europe and Asia.

I would like to thank everyone who contributed to the organization of the congress on behalf of myself and my nation. I hope that the presentations, academic discussions, and legal interpretations that will take place throughout the congress will be enlightening for both our country and the guest countries. I wish for this congress, which is being held for the first time, to transform into a global platform in this field and to continue in a broader manner in the coming years.

Nearly 40 countries are represented at our congress by ministers of justice, presidents of constitutional courts, supreme courts, and council of state, as well as chief public prosecutors, heads of equivalent institutions such as the Justice Academy and the High Council of Judges and Prosecutors, scholars, and legal professionals. I would like to especially express my satisfaction with this wide participation. By responding to our invitation after the coup attempt on July 15, you have sent the strongest message to the coup plotters, their lawless destructive mentality, and the powers behind them by being here with us. Our nation and our country will not forget the step you have taken at this point. Because you have provided serious solidarity in our democracy, for this, I thank you once again.

Valuable guests;

In recent years, Turkey has been subjected to unprecedented coup attempts in the world. The events we experienced on July 15, 2016, were an armed coup attempt by members of the Fethullahist Terrorist Organization within the military. On December 17-25, 2013, we faced a different coup attempt by members of the same organization within the judiciary and law enforcement agencies. They attempted to besiege the country's elected prime minister, his family, his colleagues, and businessmen who were carrying out major projects through fabricated evidence, unlawful actions, and completely perception-oriented shows. We did not remain silent against these members of the organization who sought to use the powers, opportunities, and support given to them for a political coup attempt. With the support of our nation, a strong resistance was put forth against this judicial and law enforcement coup attempt, and we quickly carried out the necessary operations.

Seeing that they could not achieve results this way, FETÖ resorted to arms as a last resort. Terrorists who seized the weapons entrusted to them by the state to protect the country rained blood and fire on the nation on the night of July 15. What FETÖ's judiciary and law enforcement gang could not achieve, they attempted to realize with their elements within the military. Frankly, we did not anticipate such betrayal.

But that night, it also became clear that the coup plotters had never considered that our nation would stand against them and not leave the field to them. Bombing warplanes, helicopters spewing fire, tanks passing over them, and randomly fired bullets were not enough to intimidate or push back our nation. This was also an important example for the world. Our nation, which gave 241 martyrs and 2,194 veterans that night, wrote an epic that would set an example for the whole world by standing up for its independence, future, and democracy. While our nation, in unity with its destiny, heart to heart, shoulder to shoulder, thwarted the coup plotters on the night of July 15, we saw the greatest contribution and support from our judiciary alongside our law enforcement forces.

The attack initiated by the coup plotters to eliminate me, our prime minister, and various institutions of our state and to seize strategic locations was, at the same time, a wave that faced our nation together. The judiciary, which was an instrument of a coup attempt on December 17-25, emerged this time as the institution that responded the fastest and most effectively against the coup. Thanks to the regulations made during this process, the judiciary has broken free from the control of the FETÖ terrorist organization and has transformed into the judiciary of the nation, which was very important.

Today, we are resolutely distancing the members of the same terrorist organization from our state without compromising the rule of law in all our institutions, from the military to the judiciary. Every step we take is in accordance with our Constitution and our laws. Some so-called friends in the West say, "But are these legal?" Excuse me, as much as you understand the law, we understand the law at least as much as you do, and we are taking our steps in accordance with the law, and I want this to be known. Those who give us lessons on the law should first look at the period when East Germany and West Germany were reunified; if they see how many personnel were dismissed from all state institutions during that period, they will grasp the intricacies of the matter.

As for the declaration of a state of emergency; they should look at France, which declared a state of emergency for a year in response to a simple terrorist act in a 3+3+6 manner. We are not facing a simple terrorist act; we are facing a movement aimed at the destruction of the Republic of Turkey. Can this be solved with such simple measures? The step to be taken is a very important step, and it is the very essence of our country's prosperity, struggle for freedom, and struggle for democracy, and we will take this step. There is no application contrary to examples in the world, especially regarding the declaration of a state of emergency. As Turkey, we are determined to eradicate the roots of this terrorist organization that has spread like a cancer cell in our state and social life.

Valuable guests;

In our country, the judiciary carries out its duty of dispensing justice with independence and impartiality. It is, of course, very important that our judiciary members fulfill these responsibilities without being under any influence or pressure and without falling under the command of any opinion, ideology, or power center. The struggle we are waging against FETÖ is precisely aimed at this purpose. It is impossible for individuals who take orders not from the law but from an organization, who shape their conscience according to the instructions of the leader of this organization, to establish justice.

Turkey has gone through very troubled periods due to the judicial disasters caused by the members of this organization. At one point, the sense of trust in the institution of justice eroded. In order to correct the understanding of justice that has wounded our nation’s heart and paralyzed it, it is essential to first punish those responsible for these disasters as they deserve. We must continue the ongoing operations in the public sector, business world, and other areas with such severity and determination that no one will dare to attempt a coup in Turkey again. Are you looking for money laundering? Look at this organization; they are the broadest example of money laundering in the world. Are you trying to smuggle this money abroad? You will see it here. When you look at those who claim to be conducting educational activities in 170 countries, they do not stop there; there are other activities as well. And this is an organization whose money laundering has spread even to those places.

No one should expect this noble nation and ancient state to show helplessness in the face of terrorist organizations. We expect our judges and prosecutors, who are obliged to hold terrorists, coup plotters, and occupiers accountable on behalf of the Turkish nation, to be as brave as our people who stood against the guns on the night of July 15. If our judiciary and its members cannot provide sufficient trust to our nation in this regard, we cannot look to our future with confidence. I trust and believe in our judges, prosecutors, the judiciary, and all our institutions in this regard. On this occasion, I would like to express my gratitude once again to all your friends in your countries who were with us in heart and prayer during the armed coup attempt on July 15.

Valuable guests;

Terrorism has become an instrument that uses multidimensional different methods, can take on various disguises, and is unfortunately used by some countries as a tool of diplomatic pressure. Turkey is the country that has been most subjected to attacks by terrorist organizations in the world and has suffered the most losses. In this respect, our sensitivity to terrorism is different from everyone else's, greater than everyone else's.

Right now, among our friends here, there are brothers who are constantly facing terrorism, such as those from Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, and Somalia… All of these places have brothers who are in constant proximity to terrorism. Libya is the same, Egypt is the same, everywhere in this geography is constantly intertwined with terrorism.

Look at what we have experienced regarding Syria. We have constantly been patient; we have been hit by rockets from Syria, bombarded with mortars, and we have had hundreds of martyrs. In the end, it is very significant that a 14-year-old child was so trained and raised that, because he loved the Argentine footballer Messi so much, they dressed him in Messi's jersey. They strapped a bomb to him and sent him to a wedding ceremony, where he detonated it, killing 56 of our brothers and injuring nearly 100 of our people. When I visited these people in the hospitals and saw the condition of those children, the child was not even aware that his leg had been blown off; he was still smiling and laughing. Now, can you still stand as a person who has taken on the responsibility of your nation and represented your nation to the world when you see this whole picture? We said that we will no longer stand by; we will enter Syria together with the moderate opposition and the Free Syrian Army.

Dear friends;

Our border with Syria is 911 kilometers. However, those who have no connection to Syria say it is their right to enter Syria, but when it comes to us, they say, "You were not invited by the killer Assad, how can you go there?" Excuse me, we will go. Because if we are under the threat of terrorism, if that country threatens us with mortars and rockets, we will go; you know the legal terms for this better than I do, whether you call it self-defense or whatever. And we entered, starting from Jarabulus. More than 30,000 people from Jarabulus began to return to Jarabulus when we cleared it from ISIS. But ISIS left from there. Then we entered Rai, which also emptied, and ISIS left from there as well. The people of Rai began to settle there. Now, as of tonight, thank God, Dabik has also been cleared of ISIS, and the area up to Dabik has been cleaned, and now the people of those areas have started to settle there. Look, we are not bringing people from Turkey; the people of those areas are settling there; that is our difference.

And of course, we tell the coalition forces, especially the United States: Look, you made a promise in Manbij; we spoke with the President on the phone, and they said, "Absolutely, the PYD and YPG will not enter there." The PYD is a terrorist organization, the YPG is a terrorist organization, and it is an extension of the PKK in Turkey. If they are not going to enter there, keep your promise - 95% of the population there is Arab - and they did not keep their promise; they brought the PYD and YPG there. Of course, since they did not keep their promise, we took action and are taking action. And we tell them, look, even this morning, this was communicated to them; look, you still have not kept your promise; if you do not clear that area of the PYD and YPG, we cannot act together with you.

In other words, we are strategic partners with NATO coalition forces, especially the United States; you will not act with us. Who will you act with? You will act with a terrorist organization. Is there any explanation for this with reason and logic? Is there a place for this in the law? Can such a thing happen? The law is being violated, international law is being trampled underfoot. Therefore, where there is no justice, there is oppression, and oppression is occurring. We need to resolve this; in the three days of work to be done here, in my opinion, these issues should be thoroughly addressed, and I believe they should be included in the final declaration; these are very important.

Now, operations have begun in Mosul; operations are currently ongoing in Mosul. What do they say? "Turkey should not enter Mosul." How can I not enter? I have a 350-kilometer border, and I am under threat from that border. 911 kilometers with Syria, 350 kilometers with Iraq… Those who have no connection or relevance come and enter; what is it? Baghdad told them to come. When they did not invite them, why did you not say no to those coming to Iran and Iraq? Did Saddam tell them to come 14 years ago, 15 years ago? But they entered, and how the blood flowed there; more than a million people died.

Now, as legal professionals, I believe you are people who speak not with the language of laws but with the language of justice, and if we continue to be people who speak like this, justice will find its place. Because there is a law that is not written like in the English system. But there are also laws that the powerful write as they wish, and they play according to those laws.

This is very important for us; the steps we will take here are very important. Now, operations have begun in Mosul. We told them; right now, my Chief of General Staff is in the United States, having discussions with his counterpart. About an hour ago, we spoke with him again from the United States, and we discussed what steps we are taking, what we are doing, what we will do. And we told them the same thing; "Look, we are not responsible for the possible consequences of an operation that does not include Turkey." We will be part of the operation, we will be at the table; it is not possible for us to be excluded.

Because there is a history at stake for us. If gentlemen wish, they can read the National Pact, and they will better understand what our historical past here is. And right now, we have our brothers in Mosul, Arabs, Turkmen, Kurds; we have our brothers there. Likewise, as we go further north, as we approach the border, there are relatives there. We cannot be indifferent here.

"They say, 'Leave Başika.' No one should expect us to leave Başika; we are in Başika. We have carried out all kinds of operations against the ISIS terrorist organization there until today, and we will continue to do so. We are the ones who have fought the most honorable battle against ISIS there. If the issue is fighting against the terrorist organization, we have been the ones fighting this battle at the Başika Camp from the very beginning. We are the ones who have trained our brothers in Mosul at the Başika Camp so that they can fight against the ISIS terrorist organization, and we are also the ones who have trained the Peshmerga there. If these had not happened, you would not find a proper cadre there capable of fighting against the ISIS terrorist organization.

One of the issues we emphasize the most in the fight against terrorism is the need for a principled approach against all terrorist organizations. We sincerely warn countries that support terrorist organizations as a convenient tool for their strategic purposes, providing political and military support to terrorists, and we will continue to do so. We have seen this, and I repeat it once again from here. Terrorist organizations are like boomerangs; sooner or later, they will strike back at those who use them.

It is impossible to solve this problem without a determined and principled international cooperation against terrorism. The suffering that Somalia has endured from terrorism for years is evident; Somalia cannot recover. Look, there are no embassies of the world's giants in Somalia. But Turkey is there. Why? We go there with everything we have, and we have built a magnificent embassy complex there, which we inaugurated. Because the bonds that connect us are different. But I see that the United States' embassy building and the United Kingdom's embassy building are within the campus of the airport. We have done all the maintenance and repairs of the airport. A Turkish entrepreneur is currently operating it, and he is now building a hotel next to it, and with the construction of this hotel, it will hopefully become different. That is our difference.

FETÖ, along with PKK and ISIS, DHKP-C, and other terrorist organizations are active within and around Turkey. There is hardly a day when our lives are not affected, when our blood is not shed. So, does Turkey not have the power to eliminate these organizations? Absolutely, we have that power, capability, and determination. When we compare the PKK, which has the longest and bloodiest history of actions among them, with the average number of terrorists it has, we have completely wiped it out 7-8 times in 35 years. But the PKK continues its actions. Because for every terrorist that Turkey neutralizes, new ones are being replaced from this organization's camps in Iraq and Syria.

Many countries provide covert support to this organization. Even though it is recognized as a terrorist organization, it can open tents in European capitals like a legal entity and can easily collect millions of euros in many countries. You esteemed friends know this as well. In Strasbourg, the center of the Council of Europe and the European Union, and in Brussels, they have centers where they can easily collect aid with pictures of the terrorist leader. Didn't the European Union declare them a terrorist organization? If it is a terrorist organization, how can you provide such an opportunity to this terrorist organization? How can you open ways for them to collect aid? But they do. We provide them with files. They should not take offense; I gave 4,000 files to the German Chancellor at the G-20 Cannes Summit. When he came to Istanbul 5-6 months ago, we talked about what happened to those 4,000 files. His response was very significant. He said, 'That 4,000 files has now become 4,500.' If the law, especially against terrorism, continues like this, it will be impossible to overcome it.

Look, we know that the organization called ISIS recruits members from all over the world; there are foreign fighters coming to ISIS from as far as Australia. Although we package them when we catch them, we either throw them in prison here or return them to their countries. To date, we have deported 3,800 foreign terrorists who came to join ISIS. We have imposed entry bans on 52,500 people. However, the source countries of these individuals have hardly lifted a finger to prevent their exit; such an understanding is unacceptable.

As you have witnessed, Syria and Iraq have unfortunately been subjected to great destruction due to operations involving 63 countries, using ISIS as an excuse. The number of innocent lives lost in Syria has exceeded 600,000 in six years. After we launched the Euphrates Shield Operation, it became clear that it was not necessary to destroy Syria to fight this organization. We could have resolved this among ourselves.

Of course, we know that ISIS is merely a tool, a Trojan horse, and that it can be neutralized quickly if desired. On the other hand, if these countries do not come together in a friendly manner, with our own means, with very simple measures, I believe that with a cross-border operation of not very large scale, like in Jarabulus and Rai, we have shown that it is possible.

The insistence on keeping Turkey outside the Mosul operation is known to be because we will disrupt the sectarian conflict trap that is being attempted to be established there under the pretext of ISIS. That is why we do not want to be involved there. But we told them the same thing, 'We cannot say yes to a Sunni-Shia conflict.' Do you know what their response was? They say, 'We will not allow a Shia-Sunni conflict.' Okay, but who makes up the Iraqi army? The Iraqi army is predominantly Shia. When they come to Mosul, who will they fight? They will fight the Sunnis. Who will they bring in? They will bring in Hashd al-Shaabi. Who is against them? Hashd al-Watani. Who is Hashd al-Watani? They are the local people of Mosul. Where does Hashd al-Shaabi come from? They come from outside. They should not take offense; we cannot say yes to new sectarian conflicts.

The PKK's Syrian branch, the PYD, and YPG terrorist organization are being supported, armed, and pampered under the pretext of ISIS. We have repeatedly told them this, we have warned them, and some of the weapons given to the PYD are going where? To ISIS. A significant portion is going to the PKK to be used against us. We seize these weapons. When we seize them, we also see which countries these weapons belong to. Our objections in this regard are literally ignored with lies. Organizations like DHKP-C and similar ones can operate freely in European countries. The blood-stained killers of this organization can live freely in Europe for years. Now I ask you; is it possible to fight terrorism with this understanding?

As Turkey, we have formally requested the extradition of the leader of the organization responsible for the July 15 coup attempt from the United States according to our mutual extradition agreement. However, the United States does not fulfill this request by citing its own legal system and judicial system; this is unfortunate. Can there be a legal system that protects and shelters terrorism, terrorist organizations, and terrorist leaders? Can a terrorist be given a Green Card? He lives in America like a gentleman with a Green Card. He has a 400-acre farm, lives his life there, and commands this operation from there. Who are you fooling?

When Al-Qaeda carried out a terrorist act in America, was there not the same law, the same judiciary? On what basis did America carry out so many operations both inside and outside the country? When they hit Osama bin Laden in Pakistan, Afghanistan, and that region, what legal system did they rely on?

It seems that when it hurts, they can go and hit there. If you operate the law with such double standards, when you find yourself in trouble tomorrow, you will have no words to say to anyone. For this reason, I once again invite all countries to adopt a principled and consistent stance against terrorism. Every country that approaches terrorism as a tool should know that it is digging its own grave.

We see a similar inconsistency in the refugee issue as well. Right now, there are 3 million refugees in our territory. And while we are hosting all of them, look, the European Union promised to provide us with 3 billion euros for these refugees by July. They were supposed to give another 3 billion euros next year, and it was supposed to continue like this. Look, so much time has passed, and the promises they made have not been fulfilled. Our expenses have reached 13 billion dollars as a documented cost. The contributions of our civil society organizations are just as much. We do not expect aid to come from there. We say let us take care of these needy, oppressed people. And the support that has come from the United Nations so far is 550 million dollars. However, whether it comes or not, we will continue to take care of all these refugees.

Dear brothers and sisters;

Alongside all this, Europe, as you see, cannot even tolerate a few hundred refugees. While resource-limited countries share all their resources with these people, rich, prosperous countries spend their resources on surrounding their borders with barbed wire.

This situation inflicts deep wounds on the conscience of humanity. It is your responsibility to express these truths in your own countries and on all international platforms where you have a say, to urge those responsible. I believe we owe at least this much to future generations for a safer and more peaceful world.

Esteemed guests;

The rule of law is the most important and oldest tool that provides balance in the lives of the state, society, and individuals. For this reason, the issue of justice holds an important place in all beliefs. Our holy book, the Quran, says: 'Allah commands justice, the doing of good, and liberality to kinsfolk.' Of course, the fine line between justice and oppression is a matter that makes establishing justice extraordinarily difficult. When watering a flower or a tree, while acting justly, you can also stray into the path of oppression by giving the same water to a thorn. Confucius said, 'Justice stands still like the North Star, and everything else revolves around it,' emphasizing the importance of this issue in human history.

On the walls of our country's justice institutions, it is written, 'Justice is the foundation of the state.' This saying expresses how important justice is for the stability and continuity of the state. Again, the understanding that 'he who saves a life saves all mankind' requires a governance based on justice. That is why, when we took on the responsibility of governing the country in November 2002, we identified four priority areas. The first is education, the second is health, the third is justice, and the fourth is security.

From the renewal of fundamental laws to strengthening the physical infrastructure with modern courthouses that have traditional architecture, we have carried out the largest reforms in the history of the Republic in every field, including the establishment of the national judiciary network UYAP. The opportunity for individual applications to the Constitutional Court, the establishment of the Public Ombudsman Institution, and the transition to a two-tier trial system with appellate courts are also significant reforms carried out recently. I hope that the issue of the new constitution, which has been a commitment to our nation for years but has not made concrete progress due to the lack of necessary political consensus, will be resolved as soon as possible.

On the other hand, like life itself, justice is also a dynamic field that is constantly changing and must adapt to change. In situations where classical legal tools and arguments are insufficient, new solutions must definitely be produced. Methods of reconciliation, such as arbitration and mediation, are rapidly becoming widespread.

I believe that all these issues will be discussed thoroughly at the Congress, and that results will be reached that will benefit the whole world in light of the experiences of the countries.

Once again, I wish the International Istanbul Law Congress to be fruitful and filled with success. I thank everyone who contributed to the organization of the Congress and who will contribute to the discussions with their presentations and evaluations throughout the Congress. I greet you once again with love and respect. Stay healthy."