Speech at the Administrative Judiciary Day and the 156th Anniversary Ceremony of the Council of State

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

10 May 2024 · Administrative Judiciary Day and 156th Anniversary Ceremony of the Council of State · Council of State, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed the 156th Anniversary Ceremony of the Council of State on May 10, 2024, commemorating Administrative Judiciary Day and praising the institution's role in upholding justice.
Main themes
Council of State anniversary, rule of law and judicial review, justice as foundation of the state, administrative judiciary, Turkish state continuity, historical injustices and coups, judicial independence, democracy and security, July 15 coup attempt, February 28 period, legal system integrity
Duration
~20 min
67th percentile
Words
2,451
67th percentile
Sentences
111
68th percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
2.98
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 78%77%
  • Ceremonial 15%14%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

111 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Dear Guests,

Ladies and Gentlemen;

I greet you with my heartfelt feelings, respect, and affection.

We last came together with the esteemed members of the Council of State on October 3, during the opening of the training facility and the closing of the Board of Directors meeting of the Union of International High Administrative Jurisdictions. It is with great pleasure that I am once again with you on the occasion of the 156th Anniversary Opening Ceremony of the Council of State. I sincerely congratulate you on the Day of the Council of State and Administrative Jurisdiction.

First of all, I congratulate Mr. Zeki Yiğit, who has been re-elected as the President of the Council of State after his four-year term, and I pray for his great success from the Almighty. I express my gratitude to all judges and staff who have served under the roof of the Council of State for 156 years since the State Council. I thank the members of the Council of State who have successfully completed their terms for their valuable services on behalf of my country and my nation.

The Council of State, which is one of the symbols of continuity in our state tradition, demonstrates that the Republic of Turkey is a state rooted in the past and looking to the future. With its history of over one and a half centuries, the Council of State is both a legacy passed down from our ancestors and a trust that we must strengthen and leave to future generations. God willing, we will continue to uphold this trust in the right way. One of the fundamental principles of the rule of law is the judicial review of the administration. The realization of this principle depends on the judicial oversight of all actions and transactions of the administration. The representative of this mission in our country is the Council of State. In addition to overseeing the administration through judicial means, our Council of State is also the final decision-maker in resolving disputes between the public and citizens. The Council of State, which guides lower courts with its decisions, also guarantees the implementation of the Constitution and laws. Each of our high courts works to ensure that justice is served in the best, fastest, and most effective way within their areas of responsibility. Each of our judicial bodies, which carries the honor and responsibility of making decisions on behalf of the Turkish nation, is a guarantee of peace, security, development, democracy, and social harmony in our country. There is not the slightest doubt or discussion on this matter.

Beyond our titles and positions, as individuals of 85 million, we all sincerely believe in this truth: Just as delayed justice is not justice, an accessible justice system that instills confidence in society is also the assurance of our survival. The inscription "Justice is the foundation of the state," found in all our courtrooms, reminds us of this truth and highlights the importance our civilization places on the establishment of justice. A state is strong and stands tall as long as it rules with justice, dispenses justice, and ensures the realization of justice. Where there is no justice, there is no peace, there is no prosperity, and the bond that holds the nation together begins to weaken. For this reason, I believe that to the extent we make the courthouse the door of justice, regardless of whether it is judicial or administrative, we can look to our future with confidence.

Valued Friends,

Of course, I must express this point here. We are a nation that places great importance on justice, but at the same time, we have had to witness many injustices in our recent history. We have personally experienced and seen how the feeling of injustice can break the hearts of our people throughout our struggle for democracy. We do not forget the legal massacres committed by the May 27 coup plotters at Yassıada, which resembled a bad theater rather than a real court. Despite the 63 years that have passed since the executions of the late Menderes, Zorlu, and Polatkan, it still bleeds as a wound in the heart of our nation. The pain of the young people sent to the gallows by the 12 September dictatorship regime, supposedly to establish justice, has never ceased. The damage inflicted on our legal system by those who applauded the coup plotters in unison during the February 28 period took years to remedy. We are still bearing the burden of the troubles caused by the perpetrators of the December 17-25 judicial security operation. The heavy costs we paid on July 15 are evident. In this betrayal, which claimed the lives of 253 of our citizens in one night, not only those holding weapons were at the center, but also uniformed and robed organization militants. Had the treacherous coup plotters succeeded, they would have established new Yassıadas, shed blood, and committed new legal murders. The painful examples we have seen show us this truth: Our justice system has been subjected to the dominance and attacks of coup plotters at one time, oligarchic structures that see themselves as superior to the nation at another, and the treachery of the FETÖ gang at yet another. Although these temporary periods of oversight by parallel forces or tutelage over the judiciary have come to an end, their effects on society have persisted for a long time.

In recent years, it has been observed that media and social media have been added to these circles with their written, visual, and digital platforms. The media and social media taking on the oversight role on behalf of the nation is undoubtedly a gain for our democracy, but it must never reach the point of donning the judicial robe, establishing courts, and distributing justice left and right. The attempt to direct the judiciary, to put pressure on our judicial bodies, and to target our legal professionals when undesirable decisions are made has unfortunately become one of the threats we encounter more frequently each day. Among the groups victimized by the ruthless lynch culture on social media, unfortunately, our judicial bodies and their members are at the forefront. Our esteemed members of the high judiciary, judges, and prosecutors, who carry out a very important, sensitive, and truly heavy responsibility, unfortunately, sometimes face unjust accusations that exceed the limits of criticism.

Look, dear brothers and sisters, I want to say this very clearly: Just as the political institution is not above reproach, the judiciary is not beyond criticism either. We can dislike the decisions of the judiciary, appeal them, and express our dissatisfaction openly; no one can or should prevent this. As long as it does not glorify terrorism, promote violence, or resort to insults, people can freely write and share their opinions in different forums. Those who wield public power on behalf of the nation are expected to tolerate these strong reactions within certain limits and to see it as legitimate. However, we cannot accept the institutional degradation of the judiciary through a blanket understanding, nor can we accept mudslinging against our judicial bodies and their members. The progress of the law in its own course is the most beneficial and direct path to the realization of justice. We do not find it right to politicize judicial and administrative cases, as it will cast a shadow over the sense of justice in society, regardless of the outcome. Everyone should assist the judiciary, facilitate its work, and contribute to the flawless and timely realization of justice.

From here, I want to make this sincere call to all my nation: A strong, impartial, independent, well-functioning, and swift justice system is the most valuable legacy we can leave to our children. If there are deficiencies in this regard, it is our common duty as 85 million to complete them; if there are problems, to solve them; if there are blockages, to remove them. Just as it is wrong for the judiciary to intervene in the legislative and executive branches, it is equally erroneous for the judiciary to be drawn into political debates. We need to ensure that our judiciary, along with the government and opposition, the press, and civil society, stays away from all kinds of prejudice, interest-based groupings, and ideological polarization. We cannot and will not allow narrow-minded understandings that prioritize the interests of a certain group over the welfare of the nation and the safety of the country to take root again within our justice organization, including our state institutions. It is essential that we all act with a sense of responsibility in this regard. It is also important for our legal professionals, who hold the scales of justice, to positively contribute to this process with their stances in the media, social media, and daily life. I believe that when we achieve this, we will be in a much better position.

Valued Guests,

In line with the demands from you and our nation, we have taken many steps to strengthen our administrative judiciary and our Council of State over the past 21 years. The number of members of the Council of State has been increased, and the need for judges has been met. The issue of auxiliary personnel in our high court has been resolved. We raised the number of courts from 146 in 2002 to 221. Recently, we established 44 additional administrative and tax courts. Additionally, we established 10 additional administrative litigation chambers in the administrative courts of appeal. We will continue these efforts by increasing the number of judges and courts. We activated the appellate jurisdiction in administrative judiciary in 2016 in 7 regions. We increased this number to 8 in 2020 and to 9 in 2021. At the establishment stage of the regional administrative courts, there were a total of 62 chambers, including 42 administrative litigation chambers and 20 tax litigation chambers, while today this number has reached 90, with 64 administrative and 26 tax chambers. Thus, the workload of the Council of State has decreased, and the legal assurance for citizens has increased. Disputes are resolved more quickly with more effective adjudication. We have raised the number of judges working in administrative judiciary to 2266 in response to needs over time. Despite the heavy workload, our administrative courts and our Council of State successfully carry out justice services in their areas of responsibility. There are 338,611 pending cases in first instance and appellate courts, and 114,224 pending cases in our Council of State. In 2023, a total of 860,494 cases were concluded.

Starting from 2009, we have met the need for modern service buildings for all our high courts. Our Council of State, which served in Sıhhiye for 36 years, moved to its current building in 2012. Last year, we provided our Council of State with a new social facility. We made significant changes to ensure that administrative proceedings are concluded more quickly and that the rights of our citizens are better protected. Within the framework of needs, there have been more than 20 amendments to the Administrative Jurisdiction Procedure Law and 16 amendments to the Council of State Law.

The enactment of the Right to Information Law has been one of the reforms that empower citizens against the administration. The right to information was constitutionally guaranteed in 2010. Additionally, in 2010, we removed all provisions in the constitution that hindered the pursuit of rights. In 2016, we established the Turkish Human Rights and Equality Institution. In 2021, with the 4th judicial package, we reduced the response time for applications made to administrative authorities from 60 days to 30 days.

Furthermore, we have regulated that the justifications for final decisions made by administrative courts must be written within a maximum of 30 days.

After the February disaster of the century, all necessary measures have been taken to ensure that administrative judicial activities in the earthquake zone are not disrupted.

In addition to what we have listed here, we have implemented many more regulations over the past 21 years that protect citizens against the administration, accelerate the functioning of administrative judiciary, and enhance the rights and opportunities of our judicial members.

Valued Friends,

Our aim in all these reform initiatives, each of which is a silent revolution, has been to establish the principle of the democratic rule of law in all its elements in our country. We cannot yet say that we have fully achieved this goal, but no one can deny that we are very close to it. We will walk the remaining path with determination, without tiring or faltering. I want to emphasize that the distance we have covered by overcoming all obstacles has instilled courage in us. We are still keeping our reform will alive in light of what we have done and what we have not done.

We are very well aware of one truth: Turkey can only build its future on more democracy, more economic prosperity, and, in parallel, more security. Security is the guarantee of a strong democracy, while democracy is the foundation of security. We are a government that has truly paid a price and overcome many hardships in the service of the nation over the past 21 years. We have brought Turkey together with the greatest democracy, development, and legal leaps in its history, yet we have not been able to provide our country with a new constitution prepared by civilians. This understanding is at the heart of our proposal for a new civil constitution. We cannot accept that the 100th anniversary of our Republic has been met and passed with a constitution born of a coup. It will be a new milestone in Turkish politics, strengthening our democracy, for this deficiency to be remedied again by the hand of the national will. We do not find it right for the political institution to want to remove the need for a civil constitution from the agenda by citing economic and social problems.

We certainly know that the new constitution will not magically eliminate our problems at once. The new constitution will accelerate the resolution of our country's issues by expanding the space for civil politics, from the economy to social life. The intensification of consultative discussions between different political parties with the softening of politics presents an important opportunity in this regard. We hope that Turkish politics will turn this opportunity into a lasting gain for our country, our nation, and our democracy. We will continue to play our constructive role within the framework of the expectations of our nation.

With these thoughts, I congratulate you on the 156th Anniversary of our Council of State and your Day of Administrative Jurisdiction, and I extend my love and respect to you. Stay healthy.