Speech at the Dinner in Honor of the Guest Ministers and Heads of Delegation at the 6th Ministerial Conference of the Budapest Process

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

19 February 2019 · 6th Ministerial Conference of the Budapest Process · Istanbul, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed ministers and delegation heads at a dinner hosted in Istanbul for the 6th Ministerial Conference of the Budapest Process on February 19, 2019.
Main themes
Migration crisis, refugee rights, irregular migration, global justice and inequality, humanitarian tragedies, colonialism and exploitation, Palestinian refugees, Mediterranean deaths, security vs. humanitarian approach, Turkey as refugee host, international cooperation on migration
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,766
72nd percentile
Sentences
132
76th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
11.9
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 41%39%
  • Geopolitical 27%26%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Economic 11%11%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

132 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Dear Executive Committee Chair,

Esteemed ministers, esteemed commissioner,

Valued guests, ladies and gentlemen;

I greet you with my warmest feelings and respect.

I would like to particularly express my pleasure in hosting you in our country on the occasion of the 6th Ministerial Conference of the Budapest Process.

Welcome to our beautiful Istanbul, the city of history and civilization, the crossroads of continents, cultures, and hearts.

This city, which has always embraced the oppressed and the victims throughout its thousands of years of history, is today hosting an important meeting in the field of migration. I hope that our meeting and the consultations we will hold will be a harbinger of good things.

The international community is facing a migration crisis that is rarely seen in history. Today, there are nearly 260 million migrants, over 68 million displaced persons, and more than 25 million refugees worldwide. This number is increasing day by day due to reasons such as hunger, famine, civil wars, terrorist attacks, and political uncertainties, in addition to economic reasons. People are migrating not only for a better job or a higher standard of living but to sustain their lives, to feed themselves, and to find a morsel of bread for their children. Unfortunately, these journeys of hope often end in death and disaster.

I emphasize this point; the adventure that has turned the Mediterranean into a great graveyard for refugees, where over 18,000 people have lost their lives in the last six years, is not a thrill-seeking endeavor, but this despair. Behind each life that withers away in the hellish heat of the Sahara Desert lies a great drama, a painful story. Those who leave their fates to the mercy of raging waves on a makeshift boat do so not out of an adrenaline rush, but out of hopelessness, because they have no other options left. To condemn these people, who have left everything behind, to open-air prisons and places resembling concentration camps is unconscionable and cannot be confined to our consciences. Moreover, it is even more shameful to politicize the dramas of these people, to pursue political gain by stirring up prejudices in society.

Cutting off aid to Palestinian refugees and trying to discipline them with deprivation and poverty is also inhumane. It is extremely wrong to make people who have been trying to hold on to life away from their homes and homelands for 70 years into political material. I do not say all this as the President of a country far removed from conflicts and irregular migration movements; I express it as the President of a country that hosts the most refugees in the world, according to United Nations data.

The humanitarian tragedies we witness almost every day are the visible tip of the iceberg in the migration issue. Approaching the issue of migration and refugees solely from a security perspective would be a reductionist approach. It is evident that building higher walls and erecting more barbed wire is not a solution to prevent irregular migration. If we are to evaluate this issue correctly, we must focus on the part that remains submerged, that is, the underlying problems, especially alongside the visible ones. We must courageously confront the issues behind migration, the reasons that force millions of people to leave their homes and homelands every year, and developed Western countries must do this as well, together with the source countries.

Here, I see it beneficial to make the following observation: Migration is a humanitarian and political issue that also has a security dimension. At the heart of this issue lies a gap in justice and a lack of empathy. Look, today the richest societies in the world are sometimes separated from the poorest by a sea, sometimes by a river, and sometimes by an indistinct border. On one side, people live in luxury and splendor, while just on the other side of the border, hunger and misery roam freely. In a structure where income inequality has become so pronounced, it is impossible to completely eliminate migration. The existing global system, which is based on power and the righteousness of the powerful, institutionalizes this injustice even further. The current order produces no solutions to conflicts, instabilities, or the reasons that push people to migrate. The resources and wealth of underdeveloped countries, their underground and above-ground riches, gold, diamonds, minerals, and oil continue to flow into the coffers of former colonial powers.

Let no one take offense; I say this openly and clearly: who has exploited the gold, diamonds, all the coppers, and krones of Africa until today? Who has taken these from there and transported them to their countries? And when the time came, who committed the massacres? But these are always hidden, these are not talked about. We cannot forget the Algerian massacre, we cannot forget the Rwandan massacre; all of these are evident. And in these places, not hundreds or thousands, but hundreds of thousands, and at times millions, have been killed.

Now, how will those who speak of migration here speak? They will speak from here. Why did these people leave their countries? Are those who are coming to my country now coming with joy, with pleasure? They had to leave their countries, their homes, their lands because barrel bombs were raining down on them, because of the barrel bombs that this murderer Assad dropped; that is why 3.6 million Syrians are currently in my country, and we are trying to host them.

As long as human rights violations and conflicts continue in the world, and as the gap between the rich and the poor widens, migrants will always seek new paths.

The international community must find ways to end conflicts, especially in Libya, Syria, Yemen, and Afghanistan. No country in today's world has the luxury of viewing these issues through the lens of geographical distance or proximity. We are holding donor meetings for underdeveloped countries, and you see, those who claim to be the richest in the world say, "I am number one in the world." No, you are not number one in the world; we must be honest. In terms of support to underdeveloped countries, the least developed countries, relative to national income, the number one in the world, according to OECD figures, is Turkey, but I am speaking in terms of national income. If you examine OECD reports, you will see this as well. Because while we take all these steps, we have always aimed for one thing: if we are not the giving hand, we too will fall into the same situation tomorrow.

In such a period where the world has turned into a gigantic village and distances have lost their meaning, the fate of Europe is no longer independent of that of Africa, and the fate of North America is no longer independent of that of South America. As developing technology and transportation opportunities bring us closer together, they also compel us to seek common solutions to our problems.

On the other hand, issues such as poverty, famine, civil wars, and political and economic troubles provide a suitable ground for human traffickers to exploit. We see that human trafficking is increasingly becoming linked to terrorism, drug trafficking, and organized crime. Terrorist organizations benefit from the reasons and outcomes that force people to migrate, which they themselves have created. It is imperative that we put forth a coordinated and determined struggle against this type of crime that threatens human life and our national security. As a solution, sinking refugee boats, aside from moral concerns, means condemning the problem to a state of unsolvability. The West, with its increasingly aging population and the human resources coming from the East, will not be able to escape the consequences of this problem. Therefore, establishing a healthy foundation for the migration issue will benefit Western countries the most.

Valued friends;

Turkey is not a country that is facing the migration issue for the first time, given its geographical position and the events occurring in its region. We are located at the crossroads of a geography that has been subjected to migrations in the east-west and north-south directions for centuries. It is the legacy of a world state whose borders and sphere of influence reached 22 million square kilometers at its strongest.

The events we have experienced in the last two centuries have made our country the last refuge for brotherly and friendly communities. In each of our 81 provinces, there are millions of our citizens who have migrated from Crimea, the Caucasus, the Balkans, Rumelia, and even the Middle and Far East, South Asia. People of different ethnic origins, languages, beliefs, and cultures live together in peace in our cities. Not only our kin, but everyone who has faced oppression and persecution has found the security, freedom, and the right to practice their religion in these lands. Jews fleeing the massacres in Spain in the 15th century, Christians fleeing the Inquisition, Jewish or Christian citizens of Germany and Austria fleeing Nazi persecution have sought refuge in our country. Today, Turkey hosts over 4 million migrants from different countries, including 3.6 million Syrians.

Since 2011, we have not forcibly sent anyone who has sought refuge from Syria back. We have not sent back the Assyrians, we have not sent back the Christians, we have not sent back the Armenians from the other side. Currently, there are nearly 100,000 Armenians in our country, about 40,000 of whom are our citizens, while the others are not our citizens, but we do not send them back. Because why did they come to our country? They came because of the difficulties they faced in their countries. However, in the world today, especially in the West, some propaganda is being made under the name of the so-called Armenian genocide. We say that this is a matter for historians; let historians bring this issue to the table and resolve it. Throughout our lives, throughout our history, this nation has never committed genocide against any ethnic group.

We have not left the innocents who come to our door at the mercy of regimes that apply state terror against their own citizens or of murderous organizations like ISIS and the PKK. We have embraced everyone, regardless of their ethnic identity, language, or belief, and we have provided them with a protective shelter. We have offered a wide range of services to these people who have left everything behind, from education to health, from employment to social psychological support. Currently, there are nearly 1 million Syrians of school age in our country. By stretching our conditions, we have only been able to provide educational opportunities for 328,000 of them. The number of Syrians who have opened their eyes to the world in our country in the last 7 years has exceeded 380,000. The amount we have spent for refugees with our national resources has currently exceeded 37 billion dollars according to United Nations criteria. However, the European Union promised us 3+3 billion euros, saying they would pay it through international organizations. So far, 1.75 billion euros have come through these international organizations, and 750 million dollars have come through the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, while we have spent 37 billion dollars; that is the calculation. The world remains silent on this issue, the West is silent, and they have made many promises, but they have not kept them.

Additionally, according to the global humanitarian aid report, our country rose to the top ranks in 2017 with over 8.1 billion dollars in aid. Meanwhile, the amount of aid coming to our country from abroad is extremely limited.

The first tranche of the 6 billion euros that the European Union has committed has not yet reached the Syrians.

Valued friends;

Especially the efforts of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees have come to a certain point during Mr. Guterres' term, and it has remained there. I must say that we have been left alone in this process as a country that is not a burden in the irregular migration and refugee issue, but one that bears the burden.

We see that humanitarian values have been abandoned for prejudices in a very short time. While we have been supporting 4 million people for 8 years, countries with greater economic means than us are practically fighting each other to avoid accepting 100-150 migrants. European politicians, especially racist parties, are calculating how to gain seats through anti-refugee sentiment. In many countries that give lessons on democracy and human rights to other states in the world, refugees and foreigners are seen as the greatest threat.

Xenophobia and Islamophobia are spreading day by day in European societies like a poisonous vine. We receive news every day that our citizens are subjected to fascist attacks and that their rights are being violated simply because they are Turkish and Muslim. It is impossible for our country to remain silent and unresponsive in the face of such lawlessness. We are taking the necessary actions with our relevant units, our counterparts, and the courts, and we will continue to do so.

In addition, we are making efforts to prevent irregular migration from our neighbor Syria to our country and to Europe. The only solution to the Syrian-origin migration problem cannot be seen as keeping refugees within our borders. Turkey is not obliged to bear such a heavy responsibility indefinitely. Our country has more than sufficiently put its hand under the stone for humanity and the international community over the past 8 years.

I say this openly and clearly: if a new wave of migration occurs, we will no longer be able to cope with it alone. If the people of Idlib had entered Turkey, which is 300-400 thousand people, this situation could have developed in a very different way; I must emphasize this from here. Formulas must be put into action to keep refugees within Syria and to return those in our country to their homelands. The Idlib agreement we established with Mr. Putin in Sochi has prevented a large-scale migration.

The Euphrates Shield and Olive Branch operations have accelerated returns, enabling 312,000 refugees to return to their own lands. Today, the areas in our country that are free from terrorism are the most livable and peaceful areas in Syria. The safe zone formula I proposed in the early years of the crisis is the most practical solution for the return of Syrian refugees. The functionality of this formula depends on the safe zone being under Turkey's control, while other countries provide us with logistical support. Inshallah, we will implement this formula in the field very soon. We have made the necessary preparations along our border line, and we have determined our plans and strategies. Last week, we discussed this issue in detail with Mr. Putin and Mr. Rouhani in Sochi. I believe that our European friends will also provide the necessary support to our country in establishing a safe zone.

As Turkey, if we cannot return millions of Syrians living in our lands to their homes in this way, sooner or later the problem will knock on the doors of Europe, and I want you to particularly know this. I want to emphasize that the support to be given to our country regarding the safe zone will not only prevent the influx of refugees and the threats of terrorism but will also be a contribution to the national security of European countries.

Esteemed guests;

It is important not only to prevent irregular migration but also to manage the phenomenon of migration in the broadest sense. In this direction, we took a significant step in 2018 by adopting the Global Compact for Migration. The 6th Ministerial Conference of the Budapest Process is the most important high-level event in the field of migration since the adoption of the Global Compact for Migration.

Since 2006, the Budapest Process, which we have been chairing as Turkey, is a valuable platform aimed at fostering cooperation among source, transit, and destination countries along the migration route. Our process has proven its worth by holding 5 ministerial conferences and 26 senior officials' meetings to date. The messages we will convey and the decisions to be made during the 6th Ministerial Conference will also affect the lives of millions of people around the world. I believe that all my friends here view the issue with this sensitivity.

As I conclude my remarks, I once again welcome all esteemed participants to our Istanbul, wishing that your work will lead to good outcomes, and I extend my love and respect to you all.

Stay safe.