Speech at the Opening Ceremony of the New Courthouse of the Court of Cassation and the 2021-2022 Judicial Year

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

1 September 2021 · Opening ceremony of the 2021-2022 judicial year · New Courthouse of the Court of Cassation, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed the opening ceremony of the new Court of Cassation building and the 2021–2022 judicial year on September 1, 2021, in Ankara, Turkey.
Main themes
Judicial reform and infrastructure, independence and impartiality of the judiciary, new Court of Cassation building, rule of law and justice, Ankara courthouse project, technological modernization of justice system, historical and Ottoman legacy of justice, pending caseload reduction, Turkey's international image
Duration
~23 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,804
73rd percentile
Sentences
129
75th percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
12.7
53rd percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 81%81%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

129 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Dear Nation, Honorable Speaker of the Parliament,

Esteemed Presidents of the Supreme Judiciary,

Valuable Members of Our Justice Organization,

Representatives of All Political Parties,

I greet you all with my heartfelt feelings, respect, and affection. I wish that the new judicial year of our Justice Organization will be a source of goodness for our country, our nation, our judges and prosecutors, our lawyers, and the entire judiciary community.

I find it particularly significant that we are welcoming the new judicial year in this magnificent building of our Supreme Court today.

We are witnessing yet another example of the physical and structural transformations that have changed the face of our Justice Organization over the last 20 years. I believe that this physical transformation will add value and distinction to the services provided by the Supreme Court. This building, whose foundation was laid in March 2018 and built on an area of 191 acres, has an enclosed area of over 422 thousand square meters. Our Supreme Court building, consisting of a total of 10 blocks, has the capacity, equipment, and technology to meet the needs of the chambers, members, research judges, employees, and all relevant parties. When Honorary President İsmail Rüştü Bey discussed this matter with me at the beginning, we said that we needed to take this step because we truly believed that the judiciary and the Supreme Court needed to be freed from these conditions, knowing very well the state of justice under the stairs. Of course, we did not only finish the Supreme Court; we first completed the Council of State, and then, thank God, we finished the Constitutional Court as well. Now, after the Constitutional Court, we are also fortunate to have completed this magnificent building of the Supreme Court as a neighbor.

With these developments, the country sends a message to the world, and in that respect, these are very, very important. I believe that our guests present here today will also recognize the necessity of this, and we will have a conversation with them up there, where we will hear from them as well. Turkey, hopefully, will send a distinct message to the world with these works.

By bringing together the Supreme Court, which is currently divided into 6 separate buildings in Ankara, under a single roof, we have prevented the loss of time and quality in the functioning of this institution, which currently has around 516 thousand pending cases. I wish that the new building of our Supreme Court will be beneficial to our country and our nation, as well as to the judiciary community.

Similarly, I hope that our Supreme Court Junction, which has been constructed right in front of our building and which I believe will contribute to the smooth and comfortable flow of traffic in the region, will also be beneficial to our city. And the contractor company has really added a separate richness to this place by completing this junction in a very short time. Of course, we did not stop there; we also expanded the area by crossing the road to the other side. I believe that shortly, within 1.5 to 2 years, a place of worship will also be built on the other side of the road.

We are determined to provide Ankara with a courthouse that befits its honor and history. Our Ministry of Justice and the Ministry of Environment and Urbanization are finalizing the project studies, and hopefully, the foundation of our new courthouse will be laid before the end of the year. The new courthouse, which will have approximately 700 thousand square meters of enclosed area, will be four times larger than the current one and will hopefully meet Ankara's needs for a long time. Thus, we will bring together all the units of our scattered courthouse in one place. I wish this project to be beneficial from now on.

Dear Friends,

Certainly, justice cannot be achieved solely through large buildings, developed physical facilities, and strong technological infrastructures. These merely contribute to the faster and healthier establishment of justice. The guarantee of establishing justice lies in the stance, representation, and ultimately the fair decisions that the judiciary will present with an independent and impartial understanding. To summarize with a saying attributed to some to Hazrat Omar and to others to Hazrat Ali, "the religion of the state is justice." If there is no justice in a state, it does not matter what system it is governed by, who administers it, or what beliefs or nationalities its citizens hold; only oppression prevails there. Yes, justice is the reason for the existence of the state. Our ancestors managed to govern the territories they conquered with peace and security for centuries thanks to justice. For this reason, Sultan Suleiman the Magnificent said, "What the sword cannot achieve, justice can." The greatest legacy we will leave to future generations will be this understanding. Justice is also the guarantee of the peace, happiness, and prosperity of society. It is justice and its representatives that will put an end to any injustice and deliver rights to their rightful owners. Therefore, every step taken to improve the justice system is valuable, precious, and important to us.

For this reason, it is expected in our ancient culture that members of the judiciary possess wisdom, insight, and foresight. From this perspective, those who dispense justice bear great responsibility, have a heavy burden, and carry a significant moral obligation. Unfortunately, in our recent history, we have encountered so-called members of the judiciary who were completely unaware of this sacred responsibility towards the nation and on behalf of the nation. We have all seen how the judiciary can turn into a machine of oppression in the hands of representatives of justice who have set aside their primary duties and bowed to the powers of guardianship, coup plotters, and juntas. Our nation has not forgotten the so-called court benches established by the coup plotters in the Yassiada courts of May 27. The audacity of the 12 September fascism, which sent young people to the gallows with orders saying "one from the right, one from the left," is still fresh in our memories. The disgrace exhibited by so-called members of the judiciary who received briefings from the guardians who participated in the oppression of February 28, which they claimed would last a thousand years, is still vivid in our eyes. The last link in this bad habit of using the law as an instrument of oppression was displayed by the treacherous FETÖ members. The members of this vile organization, disguised as judges and prosecutors, attempted to exploit our nation's sense of justice in the dirtiest and most disgraceful way. Those who tried to turn justice into an instrument for their dirty and secret agents through frame-up cases, the February 7 operation, and the December 17-25 judicial coup found themselves facing our nation. No matter what they did, no matter what games they tried, they did not succeed. Because oppression cannot be sustained, and indeed, they could not either. On this occasion, I express my gratitude on behalf of myself and my nation to all judges and prosecutors who stood tall during the July 15 coup attempt, fulfilling their duties properly without paying attention to the treacherous plots within their ranks or the death-threatening guns.

Indeed, July 15 is a turning point in our democracy history in many respects, as well as in terms of judicial culture. The struggle against the coup plotters was immortalized, and the democracy and justice vigil was reinforced by the investigations and detentions initiated in the courthouse corridors that very night. Our members of the judiciary, who stood by the right, the nation, the state, and above all, justice, courageously and decisively operated the law for the first time in our Republic's history against a coup attempt. This honorable stance has opened a clean page for Turkish justice and has set a great precedent that will guide future judges and prosecutors.

Once again, I congratulate everyone who contributed to this noble struggle, commemorate our martyrs with mercy, and kiss the foreheads of each of our heroes.

Valuable Friends,

The most important lesson to be drawn from past experiences is the fact that the independence and impartiality of the judiciary and adherence to the rule of law are vital for our democracy and the rule of law. We will continue our efforts until we completely erase the traces of the blows dealt to our nation's sense of justice by the coup plotters, the guardians, and finally FETÖ.

We will never forget the words of the late Aliya Izzetbegović: "We lose the war not when we die, but when we become like our enemies." For this reason, we will never give up on the truth and the law. We reject the understanding that sees every means permissible to achieve an end. We will continue to reach our correct and proper goals with correct and proper means. We will not see justice merely as a concept designated for courthouses and courtrooms. As the master Necip Fazıl said, "Justice is placing the right in its place, and it is a primary condition that must be sought not only in courts but in every branch of life and dealings." Yes, justice must be sought and meticulously fulfilled in every area of life, in every segment of society, and in all duties of the state. In this respect, the obligation to act justly is a valid obligation for every institution, every individual, and for all of us.

However, the independence and impartiality of the judiciary do not mean that its decisions cannot be criticized under any circumstances. Court decisions are certainly binding for everyone. The functioning of the system in this way is the foremost condition of the rule of law. However, the binding nature of a decision is one thing, and its criticism is another. In democracies, judicial decisions can be criticized, debated, and different opinions can be expressed within the limits of law and fairness. By the nature of life and the work done, there can be those who like a judicial decision as well as those who do not. In fact, scientific, legal, reasonable, logical, and constructive criticisms of judicial decisions do not hinder the judiciary; on the contrary, they support its development. For this reason, I believe that the judiciary should be open to all kinds of criticism that contribute to public debate. Of course, we must never forget that the judge and prosecutor are tasked with applying the laws. Sometimes what is criticized as a judicial decision may actually relate to the legislation on which that decision is based. In this respect, other relevant state institutions should also take their share from public sensitivities and swiftly take the necessary steps within their areas of responsibility.

As the executive, our duty is to provide every convenience to enhance the performance of the judiciary, to bring innovation, and to establish the infrastructure. Thank God, we have made significant progress in this regard recently. For example, the annual case load for a judge in the judicial jurisdiction is 709, and in the administrative jurisdiction, it is 408. These figures indicate a 38% decrease in workload over the last 10 years. We will develop alternatives to further reduce this rate.

As you know, we implemented our regulation on the right to be presumed innocent, which protects individuals' honor and reputation, in 2017. We wanted to ensure that no one is taken as a suspect based on unfounded allegations or smear campaigns, and that no investigation is even opened. We see that over 400 thousand of our citizens have benefited from this regulation to date. These are significant gains. Hopefully, we are determined to further advance these gains.

In the new judicial year, we will accelerate our judicial reform efforts that will relieve both our justice organization and our nation. With the awareness that humanity's quest for justice will continue until the Day of Judgment, we will continue our work uninterruptedly.

Valuable Friends,

During our governments, we have continuously kept our reform will alive in the field of justice, as in every area. The latest links in our reform will in justice are the Judicial Reform Strategy Document we announced in 2019 and the Human Rights Action Plan we shared with our nation last March. At the core of our reform strategy is our ideal of a free individual, a strong society, and a more democratic Turkey. We know that the path that will add strength to Turkey passes through law, democracy, and development. In this direction, we work day and night. We have never surrendered concepts such as rights, law, and human rights to any daily agenda or cheap politics, and we will not. We are all witnessing how these concepts have been packaged for various injustices and what human dramas have been experienced around the world. We sincerely believe that societies and states can only stand firm with the dominance of conscience and justice. With the Human Rights Action Plan we prepared under the principle of "Live and let live," we aim for a state understanding based on human rights to be fundamental in both the administration's operations and in judicial practice. We are following the implementation schedule of the document in accordance with the timelines we have set for each activity.

With our 4th Judicial Package, which was issued just before the judicial recess, we strengthened the fight against violence against women with changes made at the level of the Penal Code. Again, with this package, we made changes that strengthen the exceptional nature of detention and the characteristic of being a precautionary measure, allowing appeals against detention decisions made by criminal judges to be reviewed by the criminal court of first instance.

We have also restructured the judicial control measure by adding a time limit and review condition.

We expanded the possibilities for judicial summons and notifications to be made through technological means. With the new regulation, we put an end to practices such as midnight detentions for the sole purpose of taking statements and arrests in hotels and airports. We see that the courthouse established at Istanbul Airport has filled an important gap in this regard.

Again, with the last judicial package, while reducing the response time of administrative authorities to citizens' applications from 60 days to 30 days, we also introduced the provision that the reasoned decision must be written within a maximum of 30 days.

All these regulations represent significant changes that meet the expectations of our nation regarding the functioning of judicial processes and administration. Of course, we are not satisfied with what we have done so far; we are looking forward to what we will do next. We have already rolled up our sleeves for a new judicial package. Our friends will bring this new package to the agenda of the Parliament as soon as possible.

We are closely following the process regarding the new constitution. Together with our partner in the People's Alliance, we are gradually shaping our own preparation. It is our heartfelt desire that all political parties come together to prepare the constitution. We believe that we will produce a reasonable text that will be embraced by the vast majority of our nation, that has internal consistency, and that will meet the medium and long-term needs of our country. We expect other parties to announce their constitutional texts in the coming months. If the opportunity arises to negotiate these drafts and produce a common text, it would be a great gain for Turkey. However, our past experiences and the current attitude do not give us much hope in this regard. In any case, we are determined to present our preparation to the appreciation of our nation in the first months of the coming year. Ultimately, we are followers of all reforms that will ensure the better functioning of democracy, the rule of law, the legislature, the executive, and the judiciary in our country.

With these feelings, I once again wish that the new judicial year will be a harbinger of good for all parties in our judiciary and legal community. On behalf of myself and my nation, I wish ease to our judges, prosecutors, lawyers, and judicial staff who serve the realization of justice across Turkey.

Additionally, I would like to once again express my heartfelt thanks to everyone involved in the construction of this magnificent work, from the architect to the engineer, and especially to the contracting firm Rönesans. Completing this place in just 2 years and 4 months was truly not an easy feat, and they succeeded in doing so, preparing it for our nation and our judiciary community, for which I am very grateful to them.

I extend my love and respect to you all, and may you stay healthy.