Speech Following the Evaluation Meeting

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

5 April 2021

Context
Erdoğan addressed the nation following an emergency evaluation meeting convened in response to a midnight statement signed by 104 retired admirals implying a coup threat.
Main themes
Retired admirals' declaration, coup implications, national will and democracy, freedom of expression limits, FETÖ and July 15 coup attempt, opposition party criticism, history of Turkish coups, civil-military relations, rule of law, political tutelage
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,199
61st percentile
Sentences
93
59th percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
53rd percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 52%52%
  • Geopolitical 28%28%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

93 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Dear Nation,

Esteemed Members of the Press,

I greet you all with my heartfelt feelings and affection. In the meeting we just held, we evaluated in detail the discussions regarding an issue that has occupied our country for the past two days.

First and foremost, this action carried out at midnight is undoubtedly a malicious initiative in terms of its style, method, and the discussions it will clearly provoke. The duty of retired admirals is not to come together and publish statements containing implications of a coup regarding a political discussion. Similarly, no retired public official has the right to collectively resort to such a path.

We have not seen these admirals, diplomats, and others come together to publish a statement of support for our country in any of the struggles we have faced recently, from Syria to Libya, from the Eastern Mediterranean to the Aegean, from Cyprus to Karabakh. We have also not seen them stand by our nation against the treacherous coup attempt initiated by FETÖ on July 15. On the contrary, we have sadly followed the statements made by some of the signatory admirals in the media against our country’s rights and interests from the past to the present.

The reason for the discussion is definitely not a matter of freedom of expression. Some of the names here have long expressed the same views in various media outlets and political arenas. No one has been subjected to any investigation or similar action due to their statements in the media and political sphere. However, it is absolutely unacceptable for 104 retired admirals to engage in such an initiative at midnight in a country with a history filled with coups and declarations. We cannot call this freedom of expression. Freedom of expression does not encompass sentences that begin with "otherwise" and threaten the elected government of the country with a coup. Even if it is under the title of retired admiral, such an initiative is an affront to the heroic Turkish Armed Forces. This method and this style of expression are considered an attack on democracy, the rule of law, and the supremacy of national will everywhere in the world and are treated accordingly.

Another reason why the published declaration has received such a strong reaction from our nation is that it has been perceived as part of a much larger campaign. Certain groups, composed of former diplomats, former parliamentarians, and so-called intellectuals known for their animosity towards our country, have been targeting the legislature, the executive, and the judiciary with similar rhetoric for some time. Moreover, many of these individuals have no contribution to the country and have not benefited the nation in the slightest. Unfortunately, some of our politicians are also supporting this dirty campaign, effectively denying themselves. We expected all politicians to firmly and loudly oppose the declaration as soon as it was published and to express their stance on this matter strongly. If they had done so, I would only be here today to thank you for the support given to the national will.

All coups in our country, all attempts to impose tutelage over the national will, and all anti-democratic declarations are backed by a mentality that has once again aligned itself in the same direction. Despite having received the necessary message from our nation in every election, we once again call on the Main Opposition Party, which has failed to break free from the control of a small but organized group, to take a stance in favor of democracy.

In return, I would like to express my gratitude, on behalf of myself and my nation, to all political party leaders and representatives who have taken a stand in favor of the national will by giving the statement the response it deserves, as well as to the judiciary, universities, and civil society organizations in our provinces.

As always, our interlocutor is directly our nation. Today, we have come together to account for what has happened with our nation and to share our roadmap with them. We will once again show those who dare to threaten the nation and the government elected by the nation their limits together with our people.

We see that some are belittling the matter by saying, "What is there to exaggerate?" Every attack on democracy in Turkey has come after such declarations; they did this to the late Menderes on May 27, the 12 March administration intervened with a declaration, they tried to intimidate the governments before September 12 in the same way, and they attacked the legitimate government of the country with this recklessness on February 28. Since we have shown the strongest reaction against such initiatives during our own governments, they could not carry it further. On the night of July 15, they attempted an armed coup, but faced with the glorious resistance of our nation, they were forced to tuck their tails and flee as dawn broke. Our nation knows very well from its recent history where things can lead if immediate and effective action is not taken against open threats to the national will. For this reason, we are demonstrating our determination to take all necessary measures, especially by paying particular attention to the published declaration. Of course, there will be those who want to exploit this issue for political gain, and we will hold them accountable at the ballot box.

Our nation sees who stands by democracy and the rule of law and who has aligned themselves with the coup plotters and the guardians. Inshallah, in the 2023 elections, we will present all these events to the judgment of our nation, and we will all follow the results of the struggle we have waged for independence and future together.

Dear Nation,

Two main claims are presented in the statement made. The first is the questioning of the Montreux Convention. The second claim is some images that have appeared in the press and on social media.

As is known, following our War of Independence, the resolution of the issue regarding the status of the Straits was also left to subsequent years along with some other matters. After long negotiations, just before the Second World War, in 1936, we signed the Montreux Convention with some states, some of which were not directly related to the Straits. Undoubtedly, this convention, which left the control of the Straits to Turkey, albeit with many limitations, instead of an international commission, is an important achievement under the conditions of the time. It is also a fact that since the date it was signed, we have encountered many controversial issues that do not comply with this convention in the Straits. The fact that the ship traffic in the Straits has reached a level that threatens navigation safety at times or causes serious delays is another dimension of the issue. Nevertheless, we consider the gains that Montreux has provided to our country to be significant and we continue our commitment to this convention until we find a better alternative.

So, where did the current discussion about Montreux come from? In fact, since the date we signed it, many opinions have been expressed regarding this convention in the academic world, the media, diplomacy, and the military sphere. Today, the convention continues to be discussed in all its dimensions. During the days when Turkey decided to withdraw from the Istanbul Convention, a question was directed to our Speaker of the Parliament in this context, citing the Montreux example. Our Speaker, who is also a jurist, provided a response that he stated was completely theoretical, explaining the issue, but also clearly stated that there was no situation of withdrawing from Montreux. The academic discussion that has been ongoing for a long time has been transformed into the backbone of the declaration published by the retired admirals. If the aim is to contribute to the discussion regarding the Montreux Convention, the appropriate channel for this is not to publish a declaration, but to express opinions in the academic world and the media, which is already being done. No one has clung to anyone due to the discussions in academia, the media, or the political sphere, nor has anyone tried to divert the issue to other channels. However, the declaration published the night before last is completely outside this framework. The connection established between Kanal Istanbul and Montreux is fundamentally incorrect. Thanks to Kanal Istanbul, Turkey will alleviate the heavy maritime traffic burden in the Istanbul Strait and will also have a completely sovereign alternative outside the limitations of Montreux. This is our struggle for sovereignty. So, are we currently sovereign in the Istanbul Strait? Unfortunately, no. In other words, Kanal Istanbul is a project that will strengthen our sovereignty rights in the strait. Those who oppose such a project that will reinforce Turkey's national sovereignty rights in the name of Atatürkism and Republicanism are the greatest enemies of Atatürk and the Republic. As the President and the Chairman of the country’s largest party, my duty is to do whatever is necessary for the rights and interests of Turkey and the Turkish nation. We currently have no work or intention to withdraw from the Montreux Convention. However, if this need arises in the future, we will not hesitate to review every treaty to bring our country to a better state. We will also open these to international agreements or discussions.

Regarding the second issue in the declaration, I would like to convey the following points that I mentioned in the opening speech of the previous meeting to my nation: We have opposed the rectors who participated in rallies against the elected government in the past in the name of democracy and law. We have also criticized judicial members who participated in briefings targeting the political authority in the past in the name of democracy and law. Again, we have clearly stated that we do not find the actions of soldiers who trample on the national will in their uniforms to be correct in the name of democracy and law. Today, we are in the same place. We do not look favorably upon soldiers who present a photo that is incompatible with the discipline understanding of the Turkish Armed Forces, nor will we. It is clear that this is an isolated incident. On the day the relevant image was published, our Turkish Armed Forces had already initiated and concluded a multifaceted administrative investigation within itself. Our Ministry of National Defense, which is still working on the issue, will certainly do its part. We see the use of this image, which we also find wrong, as a pretext for a declaration that will lead to nationwide unrest as absolutely malicious.

Similarly, those who attempt to drag our National Defense University into discussions of secularism and Atatürkism with completely false or misleading information have sinister motives. It is understood that those who previously expressed coup implications by saying "young officers are disturbed" have now handed over the job to retired admirals since they are deprived of this opportunity thanks to our National Defense University.

I reiterate: The transformation of issues that can be resolved within democracy and law into a pretext for coup-implying declarations is not a demonstration of loyalty to the Constitution against the political authority; on the contrary, it is an open threat to the Constitution. Just this discussion alone is sufficient to prove the need for a transition from a Constitution that is a product of Turkey's coup periods to a new and civilian constitution. At a time when Turkey needs to look to the future with hope the most, we cannot tolerate any actions that will demoralize our nation, especially our youth.

A segment led by the Main Opposition Party claims that this discussion is being used to cover up economic troubles. However, it is precisely these kinds of discussions that they continuously stoke that cause the most harm to the economy. On Wednesday, I will share in detail with our nation the successes that the Turkish economy has achieved under pandemic conditions. We leave the greedy individuals who are chasing power from the disaster of their own country and nation to the judgment of our nation.

Right now, among these 104 individuals, there are members of the Republican People's Party, including themselves, their spouses, their nephews, their sons, and so on. You will soon see these in the written and visual media. And at the center of this issue is actually the Main Opposition Party itself.

We are discussing something in the economy; I have explained this; we will continue to strive to grow the Turkish economy based on investment, employment, production, and export, to bring it to much better places. Since we came to power, I will chronologically explain where we took our country from, where we are today, including investments, in my address to the nation on Wednesday.

In the same way, we will strengthen our democracy by fighting against coups, juntas, and tutelage when necessary, at the cost of our lives, based on the supremacy of the national will.

With these feelings, I once again extend my love and respect to all of you, wishing you a good evening and good health.