Speech by Viktor Orbán on the occasion of the awarding of the János Hunyadi Prize

Hungary Viktor Orbán · Prime Minister of Hungary

21 March 2024 · Awarding of the János Hunyadi Prize

Context
Orbán addressed a ceremony in Warsaw awarding the János Hunyadi Prize to Polish philosopher Ryszard Legutko on March 21, 2024.
Main themes
Tribute to Professor Ryszard Legutko, parallels between communism and progressive liberalism, European Union as autocratic tendency, Polish resistance movement and Solidarity, Hungarian anti-communist resistance, philosophy and historical prediction, Central European political identity, János Hunyadi Prize ceremony
Duration
~23 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,808
73rd percentile
Sentences
122
72nd percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
74th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 34%33%
  • Ceremonial 24%23%
  • Institutional 21%20%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

122 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Good evening, ladies and gentlemen! Honorable Prime Minister! Dear Beata! Esteemed Professor!

I have received permission to speak in Hungarian. So, if you allow me, I will speak Hungarian. A rare occasion for you to enjoy a wonderful language, which is rather a secret code than a language. Don’t try to learn it! I had two options when I accepted the invitation. One was to speak about János Hunyadi, the other was to speak about Professor Legutko, and I found the latter more exciting. Therefore, if you permit me, I will speak about what we owe to Professor Legutko, who, when you look closely – which he obviously does not like to do – is a very special person behind the title of Professor.

In European civilization, there is a popular notion that a philosopher can never predict the course of history, but can only try to find meaning in it afterwards. Hegel then added that the only thing we have learned from history is that we have learned nothing from it. The reason I chose Professor Legutko and not Hunyadi as the subject of today’s laudation is that he is proof that Hegel was wrong. And that is no small feat! He is the philosophy professor who has not only learned from history but has also predicted what will come with the help of history. And everything, ladies and gentlemen, that he has predicted has come to pass. If we were to ask him whether that makes him happy, he would probably say what the simple weather frog, who predicted the hail, would have said: He would have been happier if he had been wrong. But unfortunately, he was not wrong; the professor was essentially right about everything. It is as he predicted: the progressive liberals have indeed become like the communists and now pose a real threat to our freedom because they are trying to realize their own utopian fever dreams. As a former resistance fighter, Professor Legutko knew the inner logic of the communist ideal very well and had also experienced how all the world-saving promises of communism ended in oppression and dictatorship. Up to this point, that is not such a great achievement, but the professor recognized, when he got to know Western progressive liberalism, the same signs that we knew from communism. Unlike many of us, that did not surprise him, and unlike us, he was not surprised that after 1990 the old communists transformed into well-mannered liberals within minutes. Just as we owe him the realization that both communism and liberalism require the same ideological discipline. He was also the first to say that when he examined the workings of the European Union, he discovered these signs in it as well; he discovered the typical signs of the pursuit of political autocracy, he discovered that it transforms normal language into a new speak, and that EU politics, by blurring reality, does not speak about what is, but describes a dream world. And he also recognized the relentless hostility of progressive liberals towards anyone who has a different opinion as a similar sign. Perhaps he was able to recognize all this, unlike us, because he, although he is a philosopher, was never a cloistered scholar and never shied away from going out, and those who, like him, fought against the communists in the 1980s can more easily translate their experiences into philosophical insights than the cloistered scholars who do not have that opportunity.

In the 1980s, when I was still a student, I spent years studying the Polish resistance. I tried to understand what the Poles were doing. The Poles distinguished themselves from other Central European countries because, for example, in '56, when we rose up against the communists, or in '68, when the Czechs tried to push back communism in a Czech way, both attempts were not only suppressed but also liquidated. There was not the slightest remnant of resistance left, neither in Hungary nor in the Czech Republic. What caught my attention in the period after the Solidarity movement – I attended university in the early 1980s – was that it was the first resistance movement in Central Europe that, although crushed by a military dictatorship, was not liquidated. And I wanted to find out what the secret behind it was, why it could not be liquidated. And if it was not possible to crush it there, does that not mean that it is not far away when communism collapses and the Soviet Union disappears from our lives? I looked into this Polish crystal ball and understood from the example of the Poles that the reason why the Polish resistance could not be liquidated was that it was organized in a special and persistent way. And the fact that I can stand here today as the Prime Minister of Hungary and represent a political organization and party alongside my government that was founded back in the 1980s and fought against the communists, and successfully so, is intellectually due to the fact that we managed to understand the secret of the Poles, that we managed to understand the logic of resistance, the logic of organization, the unity of philosophy and action, of thought and deed, which is symbolized for all of us most worthily by Professor Legutko.

So I would like to personally thank you, Professor, on behalf of the Hungarian freedom fighters for your contribution to the freedom of Hungarians. You edited a samizdat. You founded discussion groups. We copied this in Hungary. Therefore, Professor, it is a personal honor for me to welcome you today.

Ladies and gentlemen.

After the professor recognized the patterns of communism in progressive liberalism, he did not keep this insight to himself. He is therefore not only the man who first saw this connection but also the man who first spoke about it. He spoke openly about it, which means that today we are not only welcoming a great mind and an active man here, but also a brave man, because speaking about the authoritarian tendencies inherent in liberalism in the 1990s required great courage, and I must say it still requires courage, I would say.

Ladies and gentlemen.

We did not understand this. I must also admit in this laudation that what the professor saw at the beginning of the 1990s was something that we Hungarians, and I personally, for example as a representative of the young, free generation of Hungarians, did not see. I did not understand what he was telling us back then. We thought, and I thought, that there are of course all kinds of disputes with the liberals, but that this actually corresponds to the free or freedom-loving tradition of the West. Of course, we argue with each other, but on fundamental issues, we are on the same line, on the same ground as the liberals, let’s say, on the issue of freedom. It was Professor Legutko who pointed out to us already in the 1990s that this is a serious mistake. It is not a debate between different freedom-loving ideologies within Western European culture, as it tends to appear; it is different, it is dangerous. Those with whom we argue even try to eliminate us. The professor experienced firsthand that there is a very thin line between pioneering, pioneering work, and heresy. All great founders of religions started as heretics. And then we saw in the professor a heretic, not a pioneer, but a heretic who said that he was speaking about something we thought was only in his head because the world was developing in a completely different direction. However, I must admit that Professor Legutko assessed the situation and history correctly.

When we joined the Union in 2004, we thought we had arrived and come home. We thought that the Union would be a guarantee of prosperity and also a guarantee of our national independence. We were in an euphoric mood, and we pushed aside the Legutko doubts, if I may say so. The already existing dispute between federalists and sovereignists was only superficially known to us. The truth is that it was not only our mood, the mood of EU accession, that led us to reject the professor's insights, but also our lack of knowledge, for he as a professor had a much deeper understanding of the debates within the European Union. He knew that the advocates of federalism would actually mean the dissolution of nation-states, the far-reaching elimination of national powers, and their control through the dictates of community policy. We only recognized this later, but we had to agree with the professor.

Perhaps there is an excuse for our late entry into Professor Legutko's camp. Perhaps our excuse lies in the fact that the debate between sovereignists and federalists was not always conducted as it is today when looking at the writings of the founding fathers. It was not always the case that federalists wanted to exclude political thought and political actors defending the foundations of the nation-state. I even suspect that the founders saw this tension as beneficial. The debate between federalists and nationalists, the sovereignists, is therefore not a bad thing, but a good thing, as it is a fruitful conflict, an intellectual and political debate that generates ambitions and inspiration, and it is indeed this debate that will continue to force specific EU solutions, as no side can wish for the other to disappear. In view of the fact that if the sovereignists defeat the federalists, then the cohesive force is gone, but if the federalists eliminate the sovereignists, then only another oppressive empire can be created. I believe this insight was still present in the minds of the founding fathers. Monnet writes about these two tendencies: “Instead of clashing with each other while looking each other in the eye, they prefer to influence each other. In this way, with the help of the other, they can discover what they did not know themselves, and they naturally arrive at a dialogue and then to a common action.” Why did we go wrong? Why was Professor Legutko right – even though the founding fathers themselves described the struggle between federalists and sovereignists as a truly productive conflict? Why did we go wrong when we thought that this was still the case or could be the case in modernity, several decades after the founding fathers? And why was the professor right when he said that this is no longer the case? Simple things unravel great mysteries.

The old federalists, ladies and gentlemen, Schumann, Monnet, de Gaspary, were good Catholic people. Here lies the problem! They knew the idea of Catholic universalism, which once made Europe great, and this Catholic universalism never included the abolition of nations, the establishment of utopias, or the creation of an authoritarian empire. But these old federalists, ladies and gentlemen, the great old buffaloes have moved on to the eternal hunting grounds. Today, it is no longer these people who represent federalism in the European Union; their place has been taken by progressive liberals, and as Professor Legutko has emphasized multiple times in his writings: They do not really care about the people in Europe. They are only interested in their own ideals, and their politics is also about enforcing these. If the price for implementing their ideals is the destruction of European industry and agriculture, then they will do it. If the price for their plans is the obliteration of the culture and past of Europe through illegal migration, then they will do that too, because the obliteration of the past is as self-evident to them as it was for the communists, who believed that the past must be erased once and for all.

Ladies and gentlemen, it is only part of the problem that those who advocate for a federalist position today differ from the federalist individuals among the Founding Fathers. There is another major problem, namely that the sovereign powers have been weakened. It is a significant issue that the British, who have always thought in terms of nation-states, have departed and left the representation of sovereignty to the Central Europeans. If you do a quick calculation, you will see that the Central Europeans do not have a blocking minority without the British. But the problem is even greater than that, because even this isolated Central Europe is not united, but shows a picture of division in the sovereignist-federalist debate; as if we cannot decide on which foot we should stand.

My esteemed ladies and gentlemen!

We Poles and Hungarians have always been united on the matter of sovereignty. For many years, we have been grinding the same mill with Professor Legutko. We knew what it meant when Báthory came, we knew what it meant when Sobieski came there, under Vienna, we knew what it meant when Father Bem came in our War of Independence in 1848/49 and became the greatest Hungarian military leader. Now, however, we are a bit perplexed regarding Poland. In Poland – I do not want to interfere in the affairs of the country that Professor Legutko is better acquainted with, but from here in Budapest, it seems that the Soros Empire has come to power in Poland, and that is the worst omen that a Hungarian can imagine.

We did not come here to talk about that, but I would like to remind everyone that there is a key sentence that can help understand everything that is happening today in Central Europe and thus also in Poland, which was written down in a very clear sentence by the intellectual founder of the Soros Empire, Mr. Popper, and that is the common intellectual basis of our current opponents. I will try to paraphrase it broadly. The credo, let us say, the liberal credo of Soros sounds like, I quote Popper: “Anyone who attributes a special value and historical mission to their own nation is fundamentally an enemy of the open society, and whether they know it or not, they are building a tyranny.” This is how we are seen today by the other side, and this is how we are treated.

My esteemed ladies and gentlemen!

We, who remain steadfast, believe, of course, that in the end, it will not be the Soros Empire and not the Brussels federalists, but the peoples who will win this struggle, and that the Popperian idea of the open society cannot take root in Central Europe. We will send it exactly where it belongs, to the dustbin of history, just as we sent the communists there. We have defeated the communists before, we have driven them out before, we know what it is about, we know how to do it, and we want to chase away the progressive liberals just the same.

My esteemed ladies and gentlemen!

For the first time in many decades, I feel that the sovereignist Central Europeans are not alone. I see a movement in Germany, in France, in Spain, and also in Portugal, and within a few years, forces standing on a national, conservative, sovereignist, and Christian basis have become dominant. Not to mention the Netherlands. Europe is giving a sign of life, defending itself, and making its voice heard. For a long time, I have not seen such a good opportunity for forces standing on a national, conservative, sovereignist, and Christian basis to become decisive in the European Union.

Unlike our opponents, we do not represent ideas, but the people in Europe, and we are the nightmare of the Brussels elites who oppress the people in Europe. Our optimism is also strengthened by this event today, because when the dark clouds gathered over Europe, there were always a few people who did not accept the situation, who fought, who struggled, and turned the tide of history. That was János Hunyadi, the namesake of today’s medal, that was Sobieski, but I could also mention El Cid or even Charles Martel.

And I would add to this list the name of Professor Legutko, whose education and worldview, worthy of a European scholar, are at a level unattainable for us, and who nevertheless has taken on the difficult task of fighting for his ideals, for his people, for the people in Europe, as a politician since 2000 and as a Member of the European Parliament since 2009, against the hordes of progressive liberal federalists. We have only one thing to do, my ladies and gentlemen, namely to stand by Professor Legutko. If Hunyadi were here with us today, he would say: Stand behind Professor Legutko, seize the opportunity, and win the election that lies ahead of us, that is – politically speaking – take Brussels.

God bless Professor Legutko! God protect Europe! It has been an honor for me to deliver the laudation for Professor Legutko.

Thank you very much for your attention!