All-Russian Congress of Judges

Russia Vladimir Putin · President of Russia

29 November 2022

Context
Putin addressed the All-Russian Congress of Judges on November 29, 2022, marking the Supreme Court's 100th anniversary and reviewing judicial reforms and achievements.
Main themes
Judicial reform and development, Supreme Court centenary, judicial independence, rule of law, social justice and citizens' rights, humanization of criminal liability, economic crime and business climate, judicial workload and efficiency, alternative sentencing, appellate and cassation courts, constitutional rights and freedoms
Duration
~61 min
96th percentile
Words
7,311
96th percentile
Sentences
267
94th percentile
Readability
39
33rd percentile
Grade
14.6
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.28
80th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
41st percentile

Translated from Russian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 71%70%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

267 sentences in 120 paragraphs

Dear colleagues!

Almost simultaneously with the congress, we are also marking the 100th anniversary of the establishment of the Supreme Court of Russia. It became the first independent highest judicial authority in the history of our homeland. Its activities have been extremely significant for the state and society, including during complex historical turning points.

Thus, the leading role of the Supreme Court in shaping the Concept of Judicial Reform is well known: it was adopted in 1991 and defined the paths for the development of the judiciary as an independent and influential force in the state structure of Russia.

The Supreme Court and the judicial community actively engaged in the implementation of the reform, doing much to create a new legislative framework for justice, to strengthen the guarantees of judicial independence, adversarial proceedings, and transparency in judicial processes, and the rule of law as a whole.

You know that the judicial system is constantly evolving; this is required by life itself, its rapid changes, and key events, and the Supreme Court invariably responds to the new challenges of the times and the demands of our society.

It can be confidently stated that the Supreme Court meets its 100th anniversary with significant results. I would like to thank its leadership, judges, staff, and veterans for their hard work, for the high level of responsibility you demonstrate, and for your professionalism.

Dear colleagues!

Since the ninth congress of judges, measures have been implemented that have had a significant impact on the growth of the authority of the judiciary, even under conditions of still high judicial workload. For instance, in 2021, courts considered more than 39 million cases in the first instance alone – surely the Chairman of the Supreme Court [Vyacheslav Lebedev] will speak about this again – and over the past nine months of this year, more than 30 million cases have been considered.

It is important that even during the pandemic – I have mentioned this publicly before, and I want to highlight it again at your congress today – Russian courts continued to operate in their usual mode. This was not the case in all countries of the world, but our courts were functioning.

I would particularly emphasize the social orientation of justice. This year, courts have satisfied 95 percent of claims for wage payments, 53 percent of claims from citizens for reinstatement at work, and 84 percent for the protection of consumer rights. I believe that these issues should continue to receive the same heightened, focused attention as you have given them so far.

The Supreme Court of Russia is consistently moving towards a broader application of penalties alternative to imprisonment and measures of restraint not related to detention. From 2016 to 2021, the total number of convicted persons decreased by 22 percent, and the number of individuals sentenced to actual imprisonment decreased by 19 percent.

Measures are also being taken to humanize criminal liability for crimes committed in the sphere of economic activity. Over the past ten months, courts have considered five thousand such cases involving five and a half thousand individuals, with three and a half thousand convicted, and criminal cases against two thousand citizens have been terminated by the courts. Actual imprisonment has been imposed on nine percent of those convicted – these are real figures, and the measure of restraint in the form of detention has been chosen for 262 citizens.

I would add that the judicial community plays a significant role in strengthening the business climate in the country. Cases related to the work of entrepreneurs are often complex, intricate, and therefore require comprehensive and in-depth consideration, and they are always in the courts' sights.

The significance of judicial decisions made in the economic sphere is also high, as they largely determine the stable operation of entire enterprises, corporations, and large teams.

And I would like to emphasize one more point here. In general, the challenges and threats that the country has faced and continues to face today cannot serve as an excuse for a superficial or accusatory approach in conducting judicial proceedings, investigative, and other procedural actions. The rights and freedoms of our citizens are guaranteed by the Constitution: they are inviolable, and we must never forget this.

In this regard, I consider it important to mention that the establishment of 16 new appellate and cassation courts of general jurisdiction has fully justified itself – both in terms of enhancing the guarantees of citizens' rights in judicial proceedings and for more thorough identification and prompt correction of judicial errors.

I would like to highlight another important step in the development of our judicial system. Over the past period, the legislation on the status and organizational support of the activities of justices of the peace has been significantly updated. This concerns the unification of the legal status of judges of federal courts and justices of the peace, as well as the consolidation of the principle of irremovability of justices of the peace.

The legislation also defines norms that provide for the interaction of regional councils of judges and the authorities of the subjects of the Federation, which is important for the development of regional budgets regarding the expenses for ensuring the activities of justices of the peace.

I would note the relevance and demand for the introduction of modern information technologies in the judicial system. They provide the opportunity for remote participation in court sessions, the ability to familiarize oneself with case materials, and to receive documents in electronic form. I have seen this in the example of the Supreme Court when I visited the Chairman: he showed me how it all works. But I would like to emphasize that the use of such technologies should serve not only the convenience of all parties in the administration of justice but also enhance the guarantees of the rights of citizens and legal entities to quality, fair judicial protection.

Dear colleagues!

I would especially like to highlight today the enormous significance of the work carried out by regional and district courts in recognizing the facts of genocide against civilians during the Great Patriotic War. The collection of evidence regarding the atrocities and crimes of the Nazis continues, and each such fact must be given a legal, judicial assessment.

Furthermore, as you know, following the referendums, by the will of millions of people, four new subjects of the Federation joined Russia: the Donetsk People's Republic, the Luhansk People's Republic, and the Zaporizhzhia and Kherson regions. Federal courts are expected to be established in these territories. The Supreme Court, together with other bodies of the judicial community, will have significant work ahead in forming new court compositions and their swift integration into the Russian judicial system.

This is a very serious volume of work, related not only to the selection of personnel for the courts, including judges and court staff, but also to the construction of new buildings and the material and technical support of the courts' activities. And this must be done in the shortest possible time so that citizens living in these territories are guaranteed their constitutional right to judicial protection. I am confident that you will cope with these tasks.

Dear colleagues!

You have chosen a very difficult, intense, and extremely responsible job for yourselves. It requires deep knowledge, focus, competence, a high level of procedural culture, and the need to be a positive example in work and simply in life: judges are always looked at with particular attention. I understand that meeting such societal demands is not easy, as you are constantly in the epicenter of conflicts and disputes, in an atmosphere where emotions can sometimes run high, but you must maintain composure, show respect and attention to all participants in judicial proceedings.

Each of you is a key figure in the court. It is you whom the state has endowed with special powers, and the quality of justice and the authority of the judiciary in the country depend on your work, your moral values, and your understanding of the significance and dignity of your mission, so that people, when turning to the court, trust it, are confident that they will receive a lawful and fair decision, and that the court will be presided over by impartial, honest, and incorruptible individuals.

I am confident that our judicial corps will always maintain this high standard, this height, and the state will do everything possible to ensure that your work is duly appreciated. Thus, a bill is currently under consideration in the State Duma that provides for the possibility of awarding a judge who has made a significant contribution to the administration of justice and has special merits before the judicial system a qualification class higher than that provided for their position. I believe that the adoption of this law will also contribute to the professional growth of judges and strengthen their status.

Allow me to conclude by wishing you success in your work and all the best.

Thank you for your attention.

V. Zorkin Zorkin Valery Dmitrievich Chairman of the Constitutional Court: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich!

Dear Vyacheslav Mikhailovich!

Dear colleagues! Ladies and gentlemen!

Before addressing the issues I wanted to raise from this podium, I would like to say that we have gathered in an extraordinary year, rich in dates. I am not even mentioning that the official 100th anniversary of the Supreme Court is a significant date, but I would also like to remind you that 160 years ago, at this time, Emperor Alexander II approved the Basic Provisions for the Reform of the Judicial System in Russia, from which, in fact, the judicial corps takes its start. On June 26, 1992, the term "judicial community bodies" was enshrined in law. And finally, the current congress, which took place six years [after the previous one].

What I would like to note in this regard. First of all, over these years, work has continued on establishing the judicial system and its various branches. And here, I believe, there has been a noticeable, shall we say, progress, considering the interaction between appellate and cassation instances, the full cassation instance, and the actions of the Supreme Court.

In this regard, from this podium – not just because it is a jubilee, but in essence – I wanted to say that the activities of the Supreme Court give a special impetus to the work of the entire judicial system. And I would like to say that we, the judges of the Constitutional Court, give a high assessment of how effectively and delicately, in terms of the principle of independence and autonomy of the courts, the Supreme Court fulfills its role in ensuring the unity of the judicial system. At the same time, it should be emphasized that there is a high intensity in the adoption of resolutions by the Plenary Session of the Supreme Court on issues of judicial practice, as well as the quality of their work.

The basis for the work of the entire judicial corps is the significant changes that have occurred in the Constitution. In this sense, we all work under the sign of the updated Constitution and the new legislation adopted based on it. In this regard, it seems to me that there is a fairly close interaction and consolidation of the judicial system itself. And here I would like to note two points: the first, so to speak, regarding the external vector, and the second, actually, regarding the internal one.

We all know that there have been significant changes in the years since that congress: the Russian Federation withdrew its signature from the document on the establishment of the International Criminal Court and exited the European Court of Human Rights. There was a lot of noise about this – how could it be, Russia will not cope. But the caravan, so to speak, moves on, and we must think that, of course, we will not forget the positive role of the European Court, which it played in the establishment and development of the protection of rights and freedoms in our country. But I think that this conclusion is not limited to that, because it is no secret that especially in recent years, the politicization of this body has unfortunately increased.

It is enough to take one typical work that came from the pen of the Deputy Chair of the European Constitutional Court – she has now retired – which is dedicated to the authoritarian system in Russia, where it is stated approximately as follows: "There is no longer anything to expect from the Constitutional Court." Why? Because it began its decline since it did not support President Yeltsin. In what it did not support – is a question. And the second: "We all know perfectly well," – I am almost quoting, – "that beyond Moscow, more precisely, beyond the Garden Ring by 300 meters, Siberia begins." And this is said by a specialist who heads the largest institute in Germany for the study of Eastern European law, and he simultaneously shaped policy in the European Court. So I think that the judicial system will cope even without the European Court, as is evident from how it operates.

From this perspective, it seems to me that it is very satisfying that the discussions about creating yet another special internal court for human rights in the Russian Federation have ceased. It is clear that from both theoretical and practical perspectives, the problem of multilayering, overlapping, and so on would immediately arise. In fact, what do all courts do? Do they not engage in the protection of human rights, starting from the very lowest instance – justices of the peace – and including the Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court?

In this regard, I would like to note one more problem – which Vladimir Vladimirovich has already mentioned – regarding the complete effective judicial protection. This, in fact, is the main goal, purpose, and function of the court. In this regard, it is necessary to first note that the court, in this case, the judicial system, justice relies on the principle of legality, constitutional legality, even I would say, if we speak of the Constitution as the Fundamental Law, which organizes and formalizes this entire pyramid.

Why did I specifically decide to touch upon what seems to be a trivial question? Because just recently, we were talking with Vyacheslav Mikhailovich and seemingly discovered that in the 1990s, when there was a program for reforming the courts, the concept of judicial reform, the promotion of the court, in that famous program, I frankly did not find the word "legality." And this is surprising because back then, I will say, there were disputes. I am a living witness – it was. I asked one of the developers of this project: "Why didn't you do this?" "Right now, the main thing for us," said this developer, "is to affirm human rights. Legality is already a worn-out concept from the Soviet era." I said: "But allow me, you interned in Germany for a whole year, if I'm not mistaken, and you should know that the word 'legality' in the German language is one of the key concepts in both theoretical and practical jurisprudence in Germany." That's how things stood.

And I am glad that now this word resonates fully. After all, perhaps we should remember Confucius, that there is a time for forgetting, for the wearing away of names, and a time for their renewal and renaming of concepts – that is roughly how it sounds, if translated, various translations on this matter.

In this regard, full effective judicial protection is, of course, related to the legislator. There is no action of the court without the law. After all, we are not in a common law system of Anglo-Saxon type; we are in our continental system, where there are laws. What is the Constitution if not the Fundamental Law? Ultimately, Article 120 of the Constitution states that the court is guided by the law in its activities, and in this regard, of course, much depends on the legislator, but much also depends on the court. One cannot exist without the other.

In this regard, I would like to note that the entire activity of the judicial system is focused on social orientation. Here, two points could be noted.

General, so to speak, strategic. Keeping in mind that the prevention of offenses, warnings, and resolution of social conflicts is formed from the total sum of a huge number of lawful acts that are adopted in the judicial system.

And in a more specific sense – this is, of course, the implementation of the principles of a social state and social rights, which is especially important now, when in the current difficult time, the hard time that Russia is experiencing, it is certainly necessary to smooth out the consequences of the still insufficient level of the most vulnerable segments of the population, to mitigate the consequences of sanctions in the end as well.

These are very important tasks, and the court contributes its share within its powers. It is guided, of course, by the principle of humanism because the Constitutional Court is, in the literal sense and in a strict sense, indeed a humane court, not in an ironic sense, as it was in one of the films when the defendant said: "Long live our most glorious and humane court in the world." He paused and said: "Just kidding." In fact, the court does contribute a lot to stabilizing our overall system in Russia and to ensuring that people find the truth based on the principles that this is still a righteous, swift, fair, and just court, and so on.

In this regard – in connection with the principle of humanism – I cannot help but mention a problem whose resolution depended not only on the legislator but even at a certain stage, I would say, to a greater extent, on the judicial authority, including the Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court. I mean the issue of the death penalty.

In this context, with justice and humanism, which we must always remember, keeping in mind the principles of the court's activities and the administration of justice, the question periodically arises: let’s reintroduce the death penalty. I do not presume to speak instead of politicians, sociologists, philosophers, legislators, because that is their prerogative. But there is also a legal prerogative, including that of the Constitutional Court.

This moratorium is based on two decisions of the Constitutional Court – in 1999, and we confirmed this in 2009. Usually, those who seek to restore this measure of punishment immediately recall the European Court. Since we have withdrawn from the European Convention – that’s it, forget about it, we are free. I want to say that we should still read the ruling of the Constitutional Court carefully.

In 2009 – in 2009, not now – the Constitutional Court stated that in Russia, over many years of the moratorium, – and it [the death penalty] has not been applied since 1956, Vyacheslav Mikhailovich will correct me, there were, I think, two sentences carried out in August, – and that was it, it ended over those years. And now, after 2009, – we are already in 2022, – then the Constitutional Court said: "In Russia, a constitutional-legal regime has developed, within which citizens of the Russian Federation have the right not to be sentenced to death."

Please tell me, how in these cases can we introduce the death penalty now? Of course, they say: "In Article 20 of the Constitution, it is stated that until full abolition." But the fact is that the Constitutional Court interpreted this regime, which has developed based on all this. And the legislator has said nothing about this and does not say, thank God, that we suddenly need to turn the wheel back.

But, it seems to me, even more important are some points regarding the international vector. On December 16, 2020, the UN General Assembly adopted a resolution – a moratorium on the application of the death penalty – and calls on all countries to introduce this moratorium, those that, of course, have not introduced it. In 2017, the death penalty was not applied in 170 countries, and among them was, therefore, Russia; in 2007 – in 146, a certain movement occurred.

Starting from 2007, such resolutions were adopted, and Russia has always supported them. Of course, perhaps it is necessary, – I emphasize again, I do not want, cannot, and do not have the right to interfere in matters of political decision, legislative decision, – but perhaps it is still necessary in these conditions to come to the conclusion: only a change in the Constitution, since it has been given an official interpretation by the Constitutional Court, in these conditions can serve as the basis for the resumption of the death penalty.

But I remind you that this Article 20 relates to Chapter Two – "Rights and Freedoms of Man and Citizen." The fact is that the Constitution is structured in such a way that to change this article and introduce it, to give it a different meaning, it is practically necessary to adopt a new Constitution. Therefore, if those authors who advocate for this are ready, so to speak, the flag is in their hands, but I could not help but say this. I want to say that this is not my subjective opinion; I have spoken in this part on behalf of the judges, presenting the consolidated position of the Constitutional Court on this issue.

Vladimir Vladimirovich has already touched upon the problem of IT, electronics, new computerization, and so on. It is obvious that we can no longer live outside of this: if we do not master it, the country will be thrown back. But in this process, there are two aspects. Without this, it is impossible, but the question arises about the measure. Probably, not everything has been resolved in the judicial system yet – far from everything has been resolved – with the introduction of the so-called aspects of electronic justice.

But I would like to say that there are still, perhaps, limits – when it comes to the point where they say: "Instead of a person, electronics will carry out the court." And what about justice? What about humanism and all other things? I think, it seems to me, that electronics will never replace a judge – in the foreseeable future. And in this sense, there is nothing to worry about. I recall in this regard an excerpt; one poet recently said: "Science is advancing, and soon we will do without ourselves." But I think this is precisely a warning against the idea that there is, as it were, "Caesar's to Caesar, and God's to God."

Once again, I emphasize that without electronic justice on a large scale, which provides the opportunity to facilitate justice, to speed it up, all this is necessary because otherwise we will remain approximately as follows: we act according to the model of an iPhone, while living in some prehistoric box of Morse code from the late 19th century. That would be the case without electronics.

And it should also be said that in these conditions, all these problems that are tied into a tight knot around the tasks and functions, actions of the judicial authority, of course, lead to the problem of trust in the court, in the law of the courts in a broad sense, in the loyalty of citizens in general. And we must not forget that this problem, it seems to me, is acute in the context of competition between judicial systems, as well as competition between legal systems: which country – not only in the international but also in the regional sense, within itself – will provide more comfortable legal protection of human and civil rights and freedoms, protection of its sovereignty, protection of the interests of the state, society, and each individual.

It should be said that this does not happen without struggle; we constantly see both fakes and fierce ideological battles. In this regard, of course, we listened in the first part to reports, including that, of course, there are also sins in the judicial community. But let us still listen to the fact that in the country about 35 million cases or more are resolved, – Vyacheslav Mikhailovich will tell me, – and what, is all this done at the behest of clients, at the behest of the Kremlin, at the behest of the governor, and so on? I simply do not believe this; it cannot be.

Of course, in this regard, it should be said that our task is to make the judicial system competitive because it reflects the application of laws and rights, and they, in turn, are also in competition with legal systems on the international stage. The question is how they ensure the flows of technological development and technological competition, finance, investments, and finally, the entire humanitarian sphere of social services. I think that in this regard, judges, the entire judicial community have an even greater task.

I would like to conclude here by mentioning two points.

First – all this and all the problems boil down to the fact that despite the attractiveness of foreign models, there should be no import substitution of the court.

And the second – is that the court is still a power. We are not petitioners – we are one of the branches of power. And if the court does not find proper protection for its decisions and does not enforce its decisions, then there can be no justice. That is, if society, all of us do not protect the court in this sense, then the court will not protect us, our society. I believe that in disputes about the law, it is precisely the court that puts the dot over the "i," because the court is power.

Thank you.

V. Lebedev Vyacheslav Mikhailovich Lebedev: Dear President of the Russian Federation!

Dear Valery Dmitrievich!

Dear delegates and guests of the X, jubilee All-Russian Congress of Judges!

In the history of the judicial system of the Russian Federation, the year 2022 is associated with two important events that harmoniously complement each other – the 100th anniversary of the establishment of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation and the jubilee, X All-Russian Congress of Judges.

One hundred years ago, on November 11, 1922, the All-Russian Central Executive Committee adopted the regulation on the judiciary of the RSFSR, according to which the highest judicial body – the Supreme Court of the RSFSR – was created.

The legislative and law enforcement activities of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation became particularly rich and intense during the period of establishing the foundations of a democratic rule of law, a market economy, and changes in the socio-political life of the country.

On April 11, 1991, at a joint meeting of the Ministry of Justice and the Presidium of the Supreme Court, a decision was made to hold the I Congress of Judges, and the composition of the organizing committee for the preparation of the congresses was approved, which included representatives from all levels of the judicial system of Russia.

The I All-Russian Congress of Judges took place on October 17-18, 1991. Its delegates supported the proposals for the concept of judicial reform prepared by the organizing committee of the congress, which provided for the construction of civil and criminal proceedings based on the principle of adversarial process, the conduct of trials with the participation of jurors, the restoration of the appellate instance, and the revival of the institution of justices of the peace.

The delegates also discussed proposals for introducing judicial procedures for selecting and extending measures of restraint in the form of detention, establishing judicial control over the actions and decisions of investigative bodies, and forming a system of judicial community bodies. The statement of the I All-Russian Congress of Judges emphasized the need to affirm the judicial power as an independent and influential force, equal in significance to the legislative and executive powers. The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, together with the judicial community, began to implement these conceptual provisions, actively using the right of legislative initiative for this purpose.

On June 26, 1992, at the legislative initiative of the President of the Russian Federation, the Supreme Court, and the Committee on Legislation of the Supreme Soviet, the Law "On the Status of Judges in the Russian Federation" was adopted. This law became the first regulatory act that contained provisions on judges as bearers of judicial power, acting independently of the legislative and executive powers, as well as on the legal guarantees of independence, irremovability, and inviolability of judges.

The end of the last century was a difficult time in the history of our country when individual subjects of the Russian Federation attempted to form independent judicial systems. Ensuring the unity of the legal space of the Russian Federation, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation recognized as invalid the provisions of legislative acts of the subjects of the Russian Federation that did not comply with federal legislation, annulled judicial acts issued by judges who were not appointed by the President of the Russian Federation but by the authorities of the subjects of the Federation.

In order to strengthen the rule of law, on March 25, 1994, the III extraordinary All-Russian Congress of Judges approved the Concept of the Judicial System of the Russian Federation. Its provisions became the basis for the draft Federal Constitutional Law "On the Judicial System of the Russian Federation," in the preparation and discussion of which the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation actively participated.

One of the most pressing issues arising during this period has been the failure to fulfill the provisions of Article 124 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation regarding the financing of courts in a manner that ensures the possibility of complete and independent administration of justice, as the material support for the courts has been extremely low, and court financing has been irregular and incomplete.

In order to address these systemic problems, an extraordinary IV Congress of Judges was convened in December 1996, which recognized the necessity of creating a Judicial Department under the Supreme Court and adopting a federal law on the procedure for financing the courts. Implementing the proposals of the Congress, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation submitted draft federal laws on the Judicial Department under the Supreme Court and court financing to the State Duma, which received support from legislators and became laws.

Similar problems have arisen in the field of military justice. In this regard, at the legislative initiative of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, the Federal Constitutional Law "On Military Courts" was adopted, according to which their main focus became the judicial protection of the rights of military personnel.

In order to legally enshrine the competence of the judicial community, on March 14, 2002, at the legislative initiative of the Supreme Court, the Federal Law "On the Bodies of the Judicial Community" was adopted, with which the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation studies, analyzes, and implements their proposals, including in the form of legislative initiatives.

Compliance with the principles of the rule of law and the separation of powers is ensured through judicial control in the procedure of administrative proceedings. The Supreme Court of Russia has consistently advocated for the necessity of legislative enshrinement of this legal institution.

In September 2000, the Supreme Court of Russia submitted to the State Duma a draft Federal Constitutional Law "On Federal Administrative Courts," which was adopted in the first reading on November 13, 2000. Considering that the constitutional provision on administrative justice had long remained unimplemented, by order of the Supreme Court dated September 15, 2003, a judicial panel for administrative cases was established in the Judicial Board for Civil Cases. In November 2006, the Supreme Court submitted to the State Duma a draft Code of Administrative Procedure. The revised draft Code of Administrative Procedure was adopted at your, esteemed Vladimir Vladimirovich, legislative initiative and came into effect on September 15, 2015.

Administrative justice has proven to be a sought-after and effective institution. In the first ten months of this year, the courts of the Russian Federation considered over four million 500 thousand administrative cases. The Plenary Session of the Supreme Court adopted 24 resolutions on issues related to the consideration of administrative cases and submitted five draft federal laws to the State Duma aimed at improving administrative justice. The formation of administrative proceedings is not yet fully completed, and the potential of administrative justice still needs to be realized.

One of the criteria for the effectiveness of judicial proceedings is the quality of justice, which is ensured, among other things, by the uniformity of judicial practice. Over the past 30 years, the Plenary Session of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation has adopted over 400 resolutions on issues of law enforcement, and the Presidium of the Supreme Court has approved more than 150 reviews of judicial practice.

In this work, increased attention is paid to the implementation of the constitutional provision according to which the Russian Federation is a social state. During this period, the Plenary Session of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation has addressed the issues of consideration by the courts of cases concerning the protection of labor, pension, social, and housing rights of citizens more than 70 times.

Sustainable socio-economic development is also facilitated by the improvement of judicial protection of the rights and legitimate interests of businesses, compliance with, and adoption of legal certainty in the economic sphere.

After the merger of the Supreme Court and the Higher Arbitration Court, the Plenary Session of the Supreme Court of Russia adopted 39 resolutions containing legal positions that are taken into account by the courts in both civil and arbitration proceedings. As a result of this work, contradictions in the interpretation and application of legislative provisions by courts of general and arbitration jurisdiction have been eliminated, and the necessary legal conditions for the stable conduct of investment and commercial activities in the Russian Federation have been created.

The quality of justice is primarily determined by the level of professionalism of judges in the first and appellate instances, who are endowed with broad procedural powers in the area of evidence examination and establishing the factual circumstances of the case.

In order to improve professionalism, professional training of judges, and enhance their qualifications, the Russian Academy of Justice was established in 1999 at the initiative of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, which has been granted university status since 2015, and is expected to more fully realize the accumulated scientific potential and activate work in the field of fundamental legal research.

An important condition for improving the quality of justice is the timely identification and elimination of judicial errors. In this regard, at the legislative initiative of the Supreme Court, cassation and appellate courts of general jurisdiction, as well as cassation and appellate military courts, were established, which began operations on October 1, 2019. In the procedure of these courts, the principles of extraterritoriality and continuous cassation have been implemented, according to which cassation complaints are considered collegially in a court session with the invitation of the parties.

The results of the work of these courts over the past three years indicate that their establishment has allowed for an increase in the efficiency of appellate and cassation instances, as well as the proceedings in these instances.

Given the increasing volume of work, one of the relevant areas for improving justice is the optimization of judicial workload, eliminating excessive judicial procedures.

Legislative initiatives of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation have been implemented to expand the scope of application of summary and simplified proceedings in civil, administrative cases, and economic disputes. The constitutional guarantee of judicial protection for citizens and organizations is ensured by compliance with reasonable timeframes for judicial proceedings, for violations of which, as well as for violations of reasonable timeframes for the execution of judicial acts, compensation is awarded.

The democratic foundations of justice provide for the openness of judicial procedures and open access for society to information about the activities of the judicial system of the Russian Federation. Therefore, over the past 30 years, the Plenary Session of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation has addressed the issues of compliance by the courts with the principle of openness of judicial proceedings 17 times.

In this regard, at the legislative initiative of the Supreme Court, the Federal Law of December 22, 2002, "On Ensuring Access to Information about the Activities of the Courts of the Russian Federation" was adopted. The mandatory placement by the courts on the Internet of judicial acts without any prior selection is a condition for the transparency of judicial activity, for the improvement of which, on April 26 of this year, Roskomnadzor registered a single online publication of the judicial system of the Russian Federation – a multimedia resource "Justice."

The result of the legislative and law enforcement activities of the Supreme Court has been a wide discussion in society on issues of improving judicial proceedings, and this year the mass media published over 80 thousand materials on the legislative initiatives and legal positions of the Supreme Court.

The principle of openness of judicial proceedings is organically linked to the accessibility of justice, the acceleration of procedures for appealing to the court, and the expansion of opportunities for remote participation in court sessions using digital technologies. In all types of proceedings, the possibility of submitting procedural documents electronically, conducting court sessions using video conferencing, and web conferences is implemented. The expansion of the super service "Justice Online" provides for the use of artificial intelligence technologies by the courts.

During the pandemic, the Presidium of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation and the Presidium of the Council of Judges of Russia adopted three joint resolutions on the issues of administering justice while respecting citizens' rights to health protection, which paid special attention to the use of electronic technologies by the courts. Compliance with these procedures ensured free access to justice, and its administration was not interrupted or suspended.

The result of the constructive interaction of the judicial system with the Government of the Russian Federation has been the official enshrinement of the possibility of appealing to the courts through multifunctional centers for the provision of state and municipal services in accordance with the "one-stop shop" principle.

In addition, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation has submitted draft laws to the State Duma aimed at expanding the application of modern technologies in judicial proceedings.

The Supreme Court is implementing measures aimed at differentiating crimes and individualizing criminal penalties, as well as a broader application of preventive measures not related to detention. The result of the humanization of criminal legislation and law enforcement practice has been a reduction in the conviction rate by more than half over the past 20 years. At the same time, the number of individuals whose criminal prosecution has been terminated by the court has increased from two percent in 1999 to 21 percent this year.

An important direction for improving criminal proceedings is the elimination of negative social consequences of convictions for individuals who have committed a crime for the first time and do not pose a significant public danger. At the legislative initiative of the Supreme Court, some types of crimes have been decriminalized with the introduction of administrative preclusion, while for other types of crimes, the possibility of terminating criminal prosecution with the imposition of a judicial fine for individuals who have committed a crime for the first time has been provided.

The Plenary Session of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation has submitted to the State Duma a draft federal law on the introduction of the institution of criminal misdemeanors, the adoption of which will contribute to a broader application of measures alternative to criminal punishment. The principles of justice and humanity are also implemented by the courts when resolving issues related to the execution of sentences.

In connection with the admission of new subjects of the Russian Federation, the Supreme Court, the Judicial Department under the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, and the bodies of the judicial community are implementing measures aimed at their integration into the legal space of the Russian Federation and creating the necessary conditions for the effective administration of justice.

Dear colleagues!

The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, the bodies of the judicial community, and the Judicial Department under the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation have carried out certain work to improve the judicial system, judicial proceedings, the legal status of judges, and ensure the functioning of the courts. The meetings we held with the delegates of the X, anniversary All-Russian Congress of Judges indicate that the judicial community of Russia has expressed a considerable number of new proposals aimed at increasing the effectiveness of justice.

I am convinced that the decisions of the X, anniversary All-Russian Congress of Judges will make a worthy contribution to ensuring the rule of law and the sustainable development of society.

Esteemed Vladimir Vladimirovich!

Please accept my sincere gratitude for your constant attention to the development of the judicial system of the Russian Federation. The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation expresses gratitude to the Government of the Russian Federation, the State Duma, and the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation for constructive and fruitful cooperation.

Thank you for your attention.

Thank you very much.

What I would like to say in conclusion of this part of your work.

In the economic sphere, the foundation lies in the railway, road network, and energy system in the broadest sense of the word – electric power, gas supply, and so on, the financial system that ensures, like blood vessels, the movement of funds throughout the economy and between citizens. This is real production, and all of this together ensures the country a proper level of addressing social issues, the level of material well-being of citizens, and the security of the state.

There is the spiritual sphere, culture. In the spiritual sphere, a lot of norms of so-called customary law are applied, that is, traditions passed down from generation to generation, although there are also statutes and written norms there.

One way or another, all these relationships, including relationships between citizens, relationships between citizens and the state, participants in economic activity, ultimately are regulated by legislation, legal norms.

And the application of these norms, the final word on the application of these norms is in the hands of the courts, which stand at the very top of the legal system, at the pinnacle of this legal system. And overall, ultimately, it depends on specific people – on you and your colleagues – how the law is applied and ultimately how this reflects on all the areas of life of the state and each individual person separately that I have mentioned, and even those not mentioned.

And I ask you very much to correspond to this Olympic, high status, like those who still live there according to well-known ancient traditions, referring to the Olympic gods. Please, this is extremely important for practical activity and the entire moral and ethical state of society. Please correspond to this highest status – the status of the judicial system of Russia.

I want to thank you for the results that have been achieved by the judicial system and by you, your colleagues in the past, in previous years, and I wish you every success in this unique and very important field for the entire country.

All the best, thank you. Good luck to you.