Air Supplementary Estimate, 1937.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

21 March 1938 · House of Commons debate on the Air Supplementary Estimate, 1937 · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on March 21, 1938, during the Air Supplementary Estimate debate, accusing the government of abandoning first-line strength as its air parity standard and defending RAF pilots against slurs.
Main themes
First-line air strength as the measure of parity, Baldwin's 1934 pledge on air parity with Germany, Inskip's reinterpretation of the parity standard, German Air Force growth forecast, 1934 Amendment to the Address on rearmament, March 1935 admission of German air parity, government responsibility for miscalculation, terminological inexactitude, Royal Air Force court-martial and alcohol in messes
Duration
~13 min
47th percentile
Words
1,595
47th percentile
Sentences
67
44th percentile
Readability
66
95th percentile
Grade
9.1
12th percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
28th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 54%52%
  • Institutional 32%31%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

67 sentences in 35 paragraphs

I desire to take up the time of the House for only a very little while this afternoon, and only to touch upon two points. The first one concerns my right hon. Friend the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence, but I understand that he has public duties which make it difficult for him to attend the Chamber this afternoon, and I will therefore make my point to the Under-Secre-

882

tary of State and to the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster and rely upon their good offices to convey anything they may think of the slightest interest or value to their colleague. Last Tuesday night the right hon. Gentleman made the following statement:

I think the Prime Minister is only doing what most men of common sense would do in saying that if you attempt to take first-line strength as the one yard stick in determining parity, you are proceeding on a wholly deceitful basis.

MR. CHURCHILL: That is the one the Government chose.

SIR T. INSKIP: I am not responsible for that; I am stating the facts. The right hon. Member for Epping says it was the one the Government chose. But the famous statement which Lord Baldwin made was that of 8th March, 1934, and there was no reference to first-line strength at all in it. What Lord Baldwin then said was that the then Government would see to it that in air strength and air power this country should no longer be in a position inferior to any country within striking distance of our shores. The present Prime Minister has made it plain that he is not prepared to interpret that in terms solely of first-line strength."—[OFFICIAL REPORT, 15th March, 1938; cols. 371–2, Vol. 333.]

But we really must look back in this controversy and see what the truth of these matters is. On 28th November, 1934—that is, three and a half years ago—I and some other gentlemen, including my right hon. Friend who is now the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, put down an Amendment to the Address calling attention to the dangers that we ran by neglecting to re-arm, and I made a quite definite forecast of the growth of the German Air Force, which was then officially supposed not to exist, declaring that in 1937 it would be nearly double, and so on. I will not trouble the House with that; that is only to introduce the point. In reply to this statement of mine, of which I had sent a précis beforehand to the Prime Minister, the late Prime Minister the present Lord Baldwin, gave us a definition of the standard which ought to be adopted in regard to relative air strengths. He said:

I am convinced that a great many of the figures we see in the Press to-day, and the confusion of figures, arise from the fact that sufficient account is not paid to what I am going to say. The total number of Service aircraft which any country possesses is an entirely different thing from the total number of aircraft of first-line strength.

That was the first time we heard this statement, and it was his own chosen term. He went on:

883

The total number, of course, includes the first line strength and all the reserve machines used in practice and many things of that kind. I would like the House to remember that one may get a wholly erroneous picture in making comparisons—just to mention the number of aircraft of our own country—when perhaps the figures that have been mentioned are but the figures of first line strength.

We might examine the figures of this country first. The first line strength of the regular units of the Royal Air Force to-day, at home and overseas, is 880 aircraft.

There is not the slightest doubt of what was meant by that. Then, in the course of the same speech, speaking of the increases proposed, he said:

This means that our first line strength, as I said, will be increased by 300 aircraft."—[OFFICIAL REPORT, 28th November, 1934; cols. 876–8; Vol. 295.]

He proceeded, of course, to deny the forecast which I had made and said:

Such investigations as I have been able to make lead me to believe that his figures are considerably exaggerated." —[OFFICIAL REPORT, 28th November, 1934; col. 882, Vol. 295.]

Here is a declaration—and I hope the attention of the Minister for the Coordination of Defence may be drawn to it—which was given in this very same speech where first-line aircraft is prescribed as the criterion:

All that I would say is this, that His Majesty's Government are determined in no conditions to accept any position of inferiority with regard to what air force may be raised in Germany in the future.

My right hon. Friend the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence seemed to suppose that nothing was said about first-line air strength on the occasion when Lord Baldwin gave this pledge. It is true that he gave another pledge too, but here is a perfectly definite pledge, and it was made very precise. The Debate continued as follows:

Earl WINTERTON: When my right hon. Friend spoke of Europe, did he include the Mediterranean?

Mr. BALDWIN: The Mediterranean, I think, is generally recognised as part of Europe, but—

Earl WINTERTON Not merely for home defence?

Mr. BALDWIN: I referred to machines available for home defence which are stationed in the United Kingdom."—[OFFICIAL REPORT, 28th November, 1934; col. 883, Vol. 295.]

It is impossible to have anything plainer than that. First-line air strength was the

884

criterion, and first-line air strength in respect of machines stationed for home defence in the United Kingdom, and it is with regard to that that those calculations and pledges of parity were definitely made to refer. I find that in March, 1935, the next time we had a Debate on these matters, it was admitted that the Germans had already obtained air parity, but still the calculations of the Government were all presented on the basis of first-line air strength. For instance, the then Under-Secretary of State for Air said:

What we want to know is our first-line strength to-day, and if the figure is more satisfactory than the right hon. Gentleman expected, I imagine he is delighted to hear it.

I said:

Do we mean the same thing?

The right hon. Gentleman replied:

I mean the first-line strength of the British Air Force, that is to say, every aeroplane in the first line of the squadrons, not including reserve machines, or training machines, or anything."—[OFFICIAL REPORT, 19th March, 1935; col. 1091, Vol. 299.]

Then, finally, we came to the general exposure of the Government's error, the concession of the Government's grave miscalculation—how grave we shall learn as the years unfold—and Lord Baldwin's definite admission that the responsibility is the responsibility of the Government as a whole. "We are all responsible, and we are all to blame" —that very well known and celebrated speech. But in regard to that, the right hon. Gentleman made his statement, and afterwards I criticised these figures, again proceeding entirely on the basis of first-line air strength. I drew attention to the fact that this was a matter of terminology, that he had established this principle of first-line air strength, and that in regard to that there was now an admission of failure to make good the pledge. Those statements were made to us three and a-half years ago, and I think it is very unsatisfactory that now, this having been deliberately adopted as the standard by the Government, we should be invited to adopt an entirely new and vague standard. I am quite certain that we should not have been invited to adopt that standard unless it was impossible for the Government to show that they had maintained their pledge upon the standard which they formerly prescribed to the House. I hope that the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence will read this other speech, of which he evidently

885

was not aware, and will see that the statement which he made last Tuesday night to the House was one which rests on no better foundation than an extremely inadequate and ill-considered brief. One might say, when we are dealing with this question of terminology, that this is really a case of terminological inexactitude.

I have only one other point to make this afternoon, and it was a little suggested to me by the reference in the speech of the hon. Member for North Aberdeen (Mr. Garro Jones) to a certain court-martial which have occurred in the Royal Air Force. I quite see that the hon. Member did not intend to cast any general slur at all upon the pilots of the Royal Air Force. Still, the prominence which he assigned to it, and the fact that he picked it out as practically his sole topic in regard to the inferior economy and life of the Royal Air Force, might lead to misunderstandings outside, and I cannot feel that the severity with which the hon. Member for Mossley (Mr. Hopkinson) fell upon him, however to be deprecated from the point of view of human charity and indulgence, was at all out of place, having regard to the importance of correcting the impression that there is any general, abnormal tendency to alcoholic abuses in the messes of the Royal Air Force. All that I have been able to learn would certainly support the view that there is no ground for any exceptional stigmatization of the habits which prevail—