- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on July 30, 1934, in a debate on armaments, warning of British air weakness against Germany and urging faster, larger rearmament.
- Main themes
- British air weakness against German aviation, German military aircraft expansion, transfer of pilots from civil to military aviation, Vote of Censure on air estimates, dependence on France for home security, freedom to judge continental obligations, harmony of policy with France and its allies, delays over disarmament at Geneva, German equality of armaments
- Duration
- ~5 min
- Words
- 612
- Sentences
- 23
- Readability
- 52
- Grade
- 13.3
- Syntax
- 2.98
- Vocabulary
- 2.06
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other23 sentences in 7 paragraphs
Whereas we have only about 50 in this country. As to those figures, I do not know. The ones that I am quoting are good enough, and I have been careful to take minimum figures. If, therefore, you have to add to the regular increase in German military aeroplanes, which we have to expect and which, I imagine, the Government are well informed about, and which alone will bring the forces almost to equality by the end of 1935—if you have to add to that an enormous and indefinite transference of pilots and machines from civil to military aviation, it would seem that there
2376
is a very obvious danger that before the end of next year we shall be definitely weaker than the German aviation. I have tried to state these facts with moderation, and, as I say, nothing would give me greater pleasure than to learn that I have discovered another mare's nest. I will rejoice at my own discomforture if these facts are able to be overturned or superseded by other more reassuring facts. But unless these facts can be contradicted, precisely and categorically, it seems to me that our position is a, very serious one, and that not, only should we brush aside a, Vote of Censure on this small increase, but that we should urge a much greater degree of action, both in scale and speed, upon the responsible Ministers.
Our weakness in the air has a very direct bearing on the foreign situation, and on those foreign obligations to which I ventured to refer at the beginning of my remarks. So long as our policy harmonised with that of France and that of other countries who were the Allies or associates of France, the preponderance against Germany, if Germany became an aggressor, would be so large as to, constitute a deterrent against any action other than action so desperate as to be Almost insane. But a new series of questions arises. We must ask ourselves whether we wish to be dependent on France for our domestic safety. We must ask ourselves whether we can accept the protection of a foreign country for any long period of time without losing that freedom to place our own interpretation upon our Continental obligations, which it seems to me is absolutely vital to the sound conduct of our affairs. We have these obligations, but we still have the right to judge according to our sense of justice and the circumstances of the time. If you are going to be in a position where you could not defend yourself and where you would be in a position of far greater danger but for the exertions of a neighbouring Power, that is not a position into which anyone should be drawn.
I should have thought that the pacifists and the isolationists would have joined with the main quarter of His Majesty's Government in urging that we should at least make our island for its safety independent of foreign protection. If, however, owing to the long delays to
2377
which we have agreed in the hope of arriving at some arrangement at Geneva, we have fallen behind and are not able to put ourselves in a secure position, it seems to me that we must regulate our policy so as to harmonise with that of France and of the other powerful countries who are associated with France. That, it seems to me, is absolutely necessary. But what is the course of those who now urge us to pass this Vote of Censure? They have been doing all that they could to urge France to disarm and have pleaded for German equality of armaments.
