- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on 30 July 1934, during the debate on the Opposition's Vote of Censure over the Air Force increase, demanding assurances of British air superiority over Germany.
- Main themes
- Vote of Censure on air defence increase, pacifist-minded Government, vulnerability of London to air attack, Geneva Disarmament Conference, collective security, German military air force in breach of treaty, German civil aviation convertible to war use, demand for air superiority assurance, comparison with pre-war naval ratios against Germany, German pilot training and gliders
- Duration
- ~28 min
- Words
- 3,384
- Sentences
- 132
- Readability
- 55
- Grade
- 11.8
- Syntax
- 3.07
- Vocabulary
- 2.06
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other132 sentences in 32 paragraphs
I really do not think we must get into such depths. The mere technicalities of the Air Force and the different kinds of machines and so forth are so extremely complicated, that if I were to add to them a consideration of those political ramifications I am sure I should detain the House much too long. My point is that the Government are to be censured for making this very minute and moderate increase in air defence at a time of so much danger, when we have obligations of the most vital character. One would have thought that the character of His Majesty's Government and the record of its principal Ministers would have induced the Opposition to view the request for an increase in the national defence with some confidence and some consideration. I do not suppose there has ever been such a pacifist-minded Government. There is my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister, unhappily not with us, who in the War proved in the most extreme manner and with very great courage his convictions and the sacrifices he would make for what he believed was the cause of pacifism. My right hon. Friend the Lord President of the Council is chiefly associated in the public mind with the repetition of the prayer, "Give peace in our time."
One would have supposed that when Ministers like them come forward and say that they feel it their duty to ask for some small increase in the means they have of guaranteeing the public safety, the mere fact that Ministers of this character do come forward would weigh with the Opposition and would be considered as a proof of the reality of the danger from which they seek to protect us. Then look at the apologies which the Government have made. No one could have put forward a proposal in such extremely inoffensive terms. Meekness has charac-
2368
terised every word which they have spoken since this subject was first mooted. We are assured that we can see for ourselves how small is the proposal. We are assured that it can be stopped at any minute if Geneva succeeds—on which, of course, we all have expectations; I beg pardon, official expectations. We are assured of that. And we are also assured that the steps we are taking, although they may to some lower minds have associated with them some idea of national self-defence, are really only associated with the great principle of collective security, which, I understand, is the only principle that will induce hon. Gentlemen opposite to make any preparation for the defence of this island.
But all these apologies and most soothing procedures are most curtly repulsed by the Opposition. Their only answer to these efforts to conciliate them is a Vote of Censure, which is to be decided tonight. It seems to me that we have got very nearly to the end of the period when it is worth while endeavouring to conciliate certain classes of opinion upon this subject. We are in the presence of an attempt to establish a kind of tyranny of opinion, and if its reign could be perpetuated the effect might be profoundly injurious to the stability and security of this country. We are a rich and easy prey. No country is so vulnerable and no country would better repay pillage than our own. With our enormous Metropolis here, the greatest target in the world, a kind of tremendous fat cow, a valuable fat cow tied up to attract the beasts of prey, we are in a position in which we have never been before, and in which no other country in the world is at the present time. Let us remember this: Our weakness does not only involve ourselves; our weakness involves also the stability of Europe. I was very glad to hear some admission from the Lord President of the Council of how he had found himself hampered, or his representatives had found themselves hampered at Geneva by our weakness. It is pretty well known that when you could say a word which might avert catastrophe, if it is thought that there is nothing behind your words, when you are in fact in a position of great danger to yourself, not much attention is paid to your word; the march of events takes place regardless of what was done. That march has been set in motion. Who can
2369
say that you will not yourself be dragged into it. There is also a European duty. Talk about being a good European. The best way in which a British Member of Parliament or statesman can be a good European is to make sure that our country is safe and strong in the first instance. All the rest may be added to you afterwards, but without that you are no kind of European. All you are is a source of great embarrassment and weakness to the whole of the rest of the world.
Yet when this Government, this peace-loving Government, makes this modest demand upon Parliament, when these world-famed pacifist Ministers—I use the term in order to put myself in harmony with modern modes of thought, because it is the greatest compliment that can be paid—when they feel driven by their duty to ask for additional security, what is the attitude of the Opposition? They have the same sort of look of pain and shocked surprise and disgust which came over the face of Mr. Bumble when Oliver Twist held out his little bowl and asked for more.
Then we are told that this might be all right for some other time, but not now. That was dwelt on by both the Opposition speakers this afternoon. The right hon. Gentleman the Leader of the particular section of the Liberal party to which my right hon. Friend the Member for Ross and Cromarty (Sir I. Macpherson) does not belong, begged that at any rate we might put these measures off for at least a few more weeks in order to see what would happen at Geneva. Eight years ago disarmament began to be discussed at Geneva. For two-and-a-half years the actual conference has been proceeding. The right hon. Member for Darwen has, therefore, had a good run for his experiment. His hope has been abounding. It has preserved him at, every stage from seeing the facts. Now when even those who have worked for it as no other Government has ever worked for disarmament, when even they say that they cannot take the responsibility of remaining in the present condition, the right hon. Gentleman gets up and asks for a few more weeks' delay.
I should have thought that the time had come when Ministers must not complicate the problems that already have to be solved by endeavouring to square the dis-
2370
charge of their duty with the particular formulas which have gained such popularity during the course of the Disarmament Conference. If they are only doing what is their duty they have no need to apologise to the House, and still less to the public out of doors. Of course, no one wants to spend money on armaments needlessly. But the mass of the electors of all parties in the country expect a Government to provide for the safety of the Homeland. That is what, the ordinary man regards as the Government's first duty, and that is what he considers they are paid for—to make sure that the country is safe. If Minister's especially with the record and temperaments of these, come forward and demand a certain measure of additional force and personnel, they have only to put that forward with courage and conviction to gain an enormous measure of support throughout the country.
I cannot think of anything more likely to rally their forces than that the issue should be joined as it is more or less suggested by the Vote of Censure this afternoon and that we should see the two Oppositions—or one-and-a-half Oppositions—presenting themselves on the ground that they will not support the necessary defence of the country and that they intend to utilise all the prejudice and unpopularity which they suppose may be brought against a Government which has to propose an increase of armaments. I believe if they do that they will only be making another of those historic miscalculations upon large issues ——for which they have so often, as the hon. Gentleman opposite feelingly agrees, been severely chastised but from which they seem incapable of learning wisdom. I may say that it is a source of wonder to me that public men who have filled high office and who aspire to fill it again, should be prepared, like the leaders we see opposite, to vote for either of the Motions which are put forward from the Opposition side. Such an act is of a far-reaching character. It will not affect the decision of Parliament, but by so doing hon. Members opposite place themselves in an invidious position as to which they may be required to give an answer, in circumstances which no human being can foresee. Surely, they might at least say: "If the Government hold this view and sincerely believe it to be
2371
necessary to take these steps then while we are not actually prepared to shoulder any part of the burden ourselves we will not obstruct those who are bearing the burden." I still hope that there may be some among them who will refrain from committing themselves to a vote which would deny even a minimum step towards security.
All this argument which I have been endeavouring to offer to the House of the need and the interest which the Government have in doing their duty, turns upon the point as to whether the measures which the Government propose are really a contribution to our security or not. If they are not, then I think the Government run the risk of falling between two stools. Their duty is to provide adequate measures of defence before it is too late. Whatever they propose, they are going to be assailed by the pacifists throughout the country with all that interested and unscrupulous vituperation which we saw in the squalid election at Fulham some time ago and which finds an echo in these Votes of Censure this afternoon. Whatever the Government do they are going to have that thrown at them and it is vital therefore that they should so shape their course as to gather around them and behind them all the forces upon which they would naturally rely and to whom they would naturally look for support upon a question of this character. To encounter all this storm, for something which is insufficient to meet the need is to have the worst of both worlds. The Government will get the abuse but may not get their support. The Government will get their abuse, but we shall not get our defence.
We must assume, of course, that Ministers have considered this aspect of the matter and that they see where their duty and their interest lie but I must point out that there are no grounds whatever for suggesting that it is not possible to increase the Air Force more rapidly than is now proposed. I do not intend to argue that matter, but I conceive that there are many ways in which our Air Force could be rapidly augmented which the Government have not adopted at present. The decision which they have just taken is a deliberate decision, and I confess I find it difficult to believe that it makes adequate provision against
2372
the dangers which we have to face and which are admitted. I hope therefore that we shall be further reassured this evening when the Foreign Secretary addresses us.
It is no use examining national defence in the abstract and talking in vague and general terms about hypothetical dangers and combinations which cannot be expressed. Of course, before the War the Liberal Government of those days did not hesitate to specify the quarter from which they expected danger and they did not hesitate to specify the navy against which we were determined to maintain an ample superiority. We measured ourselves before the War publicly and precisely against Germany. We laid down a ratio of 16 to 10 against existing programmes and of two to one against any additions to those programmes. Such calculations are perfectly well understood abroad. They were stated publicly and they bred no ill-will and caused no offence. As a matter of fact, the contrary was the case, and I think I shall be borne out in that statement by those who remember what happened in those days. As the preponderance of our Navy grew stronger our relations with Germany steadily improved and they were never better than in the last few months before the War. I hope hon. Members will allow me to complete what I was saying. As a matter of fact, the relations between Great Britain and Germany were never better than on the eve of the War which arose from troubles entirely outside our relations with the German Government and from that very quarter in Europe which hon. Members opposite are laughing at and where at the present time there is such a shocking and unmanageable state of affairs. I say the fact that our Navy was measured against the German Navy played no part in bringing about that struggle, and therefore I propose to speak quite plainly about Germany. It seems to me that that is the specific danger—we all know it—which we have to be prepared against and even if the Government prefer to cast their statements about it in more general terms it is absolutely necessary and right that the country should know what the position is.
The first question which I want to ask the Government is this: What is their
2373
view about the German military air forces? My right hon. Friend used some sentences upon this point which I think were not cast by him with the intention of achieving any special degree of clarity. I understand, of course, that, officially, Germany has no air force at all. She is prohibited by the solemn treaties which she signed after the War from having any military aviation. But after all the right hon. Gentleman said that the worst crime is not to tell the truth to the public and I think we must ask the Foreign Secretary and the Government to assure us that Germany has observed and is observing her treaty obligations in respect of military aviation. If so, I shall be greatly relieved, and I think the House will be greatly relieved. But if that assurance cannot be given—and, of course, it cannot be given—then I say we are bound to probe and examine what is taking place as far as we are in a position to do so. I am, naturally, not going into details, nor would I ask the Government at this stage to make a statistical pronouncement upon the highly complicated and disputable figures of German air forces. It was a different matter when we were talking about Dreadnoughts. You could not build Dreadnoughts in boat houses on the Elbe and what Admiral Von Tirpitz said before the War was found to be true that nothing outside the regular programme was being embarked upon. It is a different matter with regard to aeroplanes which can be so easily constructed and the component parts of which can be so easily assembled and military aviation shades into civil aviation by such indefinable processes that I dare say the Government are right in not making statements which would in fact be charges and no doubt would be capable of being rebutted or denied.
I will venture however to assert some broad facts, and I hope the Government will be able to contradict them. I shall be delighted if the Government are able to contradict them. I first assert that Germany has already in violation of the treaty created a military air force which is now nearly two-thirds as strong as our present home defence air force. That is the first statement which I put before the Government for their consideration. The second is that Germany is rapidly
2374
increasing this air force, not only by large sums of money which figure in her estimates, but also by public subscriptions very often almost forced subscriptions, which are in progress and have been in progress for some time all over Germany. By the end of 1935 the German air force will be nearly equal in numbers and efficiency—and after all no one must under-rate German efficiency, because there could be no more deadly mistake than that—it will be nearly equal, as I say, to our home defence air force at that date even if the present proposals are carried out.
The third statement is that if Germany continues this expansion and if we continue to carry out our scheme, then, some time in 1936, that is to say when this Government will be giving an account of their stewardship, Germany will be definitely and substantially stronger in the air than Great Britain. Fourthly, and this is the point which is causing anxiety, once they have got that lead we may never be able to overtake them. If these assertions cannot be contradicted, then there is cause for the very grave anxiety which exists in all parts of the House not only because of the physical strength of the German air force, but I am bound to say also because of the character of the present German dictatorship. If the Government have to admit at any time in the next few years that the German air forces are stronger than our own, then, they will be held, and I think rightly held, to have failed in their prime duty to the country.
I ask, therefore, for a solemn, specific assurance from the Government that at no moment for which they will have responsibility, will they fail to have a substantially superior military Air Force at home to that which they have reason to believe has been set on foot in Germany. Can that assurance be given? Will it be given? I think it will make a great difference to the judgment which must be passed upon these proposals if the Government are in a position to say that that is their resolve.
But in this connection we must face some of the facts about German civil aviation and British civil aviation. I am assured that the German civil aviation is three or four times as large as our civil aviation; but that is only a part of
2375
the story. The British civil aviation is in its character purely commercial, and the machines cannot be converted for military purposes without falling far below the comfortable standard of war machines. Our civil machines would have little war value, if they were to be converted. We are, I think, the only country whose civil aviation is so completely divorced from the technical and military aspects. The German machines, on the other hand, have been deliberately and scientifically planned by the Government for the express purpose of being converted into war machines. Not only have they a speed and a design suited for this purpose, with machines going at over 200 miles an hour, but the whole scheme of conversion has been prepared and organised with minute and earnest forethought. I am perfectly ready to be corrected, and no one will be more pleased than I to hear a convincing, an overwhelming, answer on the subject, but I am informed that the bombing racks which would be substituted for the passenger accommodation in a great number of these fast German civil machines have already been made and delivered, and it would be a matter of only a few hours to unbolt the one and fasten in the other.
The same story can be told about the pilots. Germany has a trained personnel of pilots which is many times more numerous than our own. Gliders are a wonderful process for training pilots, giving them air sense, and there are, I believe, over 500 qualified glider pilots in Germany.
