- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on December 20, 1946, criticising the Prime Minister's statement on Burma's transfer of power as a hasty scuttle and warning that it was irrevocable.
- Main themes
- British withdrawal from Burma, Prime Minister's declaration on Burmese independence, elimination of Dominion status stage, comparison with India, Japanese occupation and its aftermath, absence of representative elections in Burma, accusation of scuttle, British Empire decline, Labour government's haste, irreversibility of the declaration
- Duration
- ~9 min
- Words
- 1,137
- Sentences
- 51
- Readability
- 51
- Grade
- 11.6
- Syntax
- 3.01
- Vocabulary
- 2.20
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other51 sentences in 13 paragraphs
(Woodford)
I was not proposing to embark upon a formal or full-dress Debate upon the evacuation or abandonment of Burma. This, it seems to me, must be a subject for discussion upon another occasion. All that I was intending to do was to mark, for the nation and the country at large, the significance of the statement which the Prime Minister rattled off so quickly and so smoothly as if it were an ordinary matter or routine. It should be realised that a very important and far-reaching declaration has now been made by the Prime Minister, and we should consider what its consequences will be.
As I said on another occasion, it is less than a year since the Japanese were expelled or destroyed. There have been no adequate, elections, no representative assembly formed, and nothing that could be said to be a representative or settled view of the people there. Those people are only now returning, with great difficulty, as the Government have pointed
2349
out, and as was pointed out in the White Paper issued last year, to their ruined homes in many parts of that country, which were ravaged by the Japanese. Yet we are told that we must accelerate the process of our departure as much as possible, that special measures must be taken, and these gentlemen invited from Burma to come over here and discuss with the Government the peaceful transference of power and the rapid departure of the British. Before they come, before they would even condescend to come, a declaration has to be made in terms which place this matter in the same state as what is happening now in India.
This must be realised. We have held Burma since 1885. We have followed its affairs with attention. My father was the Minister responsible for the annexation of Burma. During that time, great progress has been made in that small country. There are 17 million people, mostly, or a very large proportion of them, primitive people. Good progress has been made. We defended them as well as we could against the Japanese invasion, but we were not successful. It was only after the tremendous campaign of three years of heavy fighting that the Japanese were driven out, and the country was liberated from the invaders' hands. In those circumstances it would have been reasonable to allow law and order to be established, and the people to settle down on their farms and in their habitations. Then we could have resumed consideration of the question of self-government, to which we had definitely pledged ourselves, but all in due course, and in due time. Again, by the unfortunate form of the Prime Minister's declaration to which the right hon. Gentleman has now given vent, and which has taken its place as an operative declaration, the intermediate stage of Dominion status is, to all intents and purposes, eliminated, just as it was in India. In eliminating that interim stage in India it was said: "This makes no difference, because Dominion status implies the right to contract out of the British Empire."
The proper stages are of the utmost consequence. If, in India, we had proceeded under Dominion status, and had established a Government based upon Dominion status, that Government could then have addressed itself to the question whether to use what I call the escalator Clause or not. A very different situation would then have
2350
arisen. There would have been an opportunity for the friends of this country who desire that we should stay, and who appreciate the blessings which British rule has conferred upon those regions, to rally. They would have had a chance to decide whether, upon a basis of full Dominion status, they would be partners in the British Commonwealth of Nations or not. The elimination of that stage, the short-circuiting of that process, has the effect, and could only have the effect, of repulsing all loyalties, the abandoning or friends, and compelling everyone in India to face the fact that the British were going. The result is that no fair chance has been given to the people of India to express themselves, in a calm atmosphere and under proper conditions, upon the question whether, having obtained full self-government, they would wish to leave the British Commonwealth of Nations or not.
This evil process, which has been attended by disasters of which at present we are only on the threshold, and which will to a large extent occupy or dominate the mind and attention of the present Parliament in the months and years to come, is now quite needlessly extended to Burma. I cannot see why this should be done, unless it is to try to induce the Burmese representatives to come over here and discuss this matter with us. This haste is appalling. "Scuttle" is the only word that can be applied. What, spread over a number of years, would be a healthy and constitutional process and might easily have given the Burmese people an opportunity of continuing their association with our congregation of nations, has been cast aside. We are seeing in home affairs the unseemly rush of legislation, disorganising our national life and impeding our recovery, legislation thrust upon Parliament at break-neck speed, hon. Members debarred from taking part in Debates by matters being transferred from the Floor of this House to other parts of the building. We see the same haste which, I suppose, will be paraded as vigour. "Labour gets things done‡"
As regards divesting ourselves of these great possessions of the British Crown, and freeing ourselves from all responsibility for the populations—primitive and often divided—who have hitherto looked to British justice and administration for the means of leading their ordinary lives in peace, I thought it necessary at the
2351
earliest moment to dissociate myself and those who sit on this side from the course of action which the Government are taking. I said the other day about India that we take no responsibility for the course the Government take; they must bear the responsibility. I see it was said in another place that I was suggesting that should the Conservative Party be returned to power, we would reverse this process. I think it would be utterly impossible to reverse it. The words that have come from the lips of the right hon. Gentleman today, supported as they are by the overwhelming majority of this House—unrepresentative of the balance of forces in the country—are irrevocable. He has in fact shorn Burma away from the British Crown by what is being done. That, at least, is a matter of which notice should be taken, if it be only passing notice, even in this period when we are getting so accustomed and indurated to the process of the decline and fall of the British Empire.
