- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on February 10, 1947, in the emergency debate on fuel and power cuts, criticising the Minister of Fuel and Power and the government's handling of coal.
- Main themes
- Fuel and power cuts emergency, coal production and manpower, criticism of the Minister of Fuel and Power, Polish workers in the coal mines, Polish troops in the Army of Occupation, mining machinery, miners' output and timekeeping, Burke on government and people, government complacency, coming hardship for the country
- Duration
- ~5 min
- Words
- 617
- Sentences
- 28
- Readability
- 62
- Grade
- 9.6
- Syntax
- 3.10
- Vocabulary
- 2.06
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other28 sentences in 10 paragraphs
If it should result in the expulsion from power of our present rulers, it would, indeed, be a merciful deliverance. I leave the hon. Member for East Coventry (Mr. Grossman) where he properly belongs.
I should like to say that I did not rise tonight for the purpose of making a prolonged and detailed examination of the
115
coal problem. We shall have other opportunities; and I may make it clear that, in view of the fact that absolutely no answer has been given to the statements which we have made, and for many reasons outside the scope of this emergency Debate, we shall seek other opportunities. I trust that they will lead to a very thorough consideration of the whole coal position, to the means of providing the necessary manpower, and, what is, in my opinion, still more efficacious. the best machinery. The hon. Gentleman spoke of the Poles. We all know the difficulty there is about getting them to work in the mines. I have no hesitation in saying to the House that, personally, had I been responsible, I had always intended that the 18o,000 Poles and their dependants should go to Germany as part of the Army of Occupation, far from the Russian or Polish frontiers, and we might then have had 150,000 or 18o,000 Englishmen at home with their families and working in our industries; but this was brushed aside by what I think were superficial and shortsighted criticisms.
Presently in this Session we will ask for a further opportunity of discussing the coal problem, but today we have nothing before us except the speech of the Minister of Fuel and Power. I listened to his speech with attention, and I felt sure he was going to reach a thoroughly complacent conclusion. It reminded me of what I think Burke said of the Governments he was attacking in a former century:
We have a very good Government, but we have a very bad people.
As a subsection of this argument, we were told of all the achievements with which the right hon. Gentleman had adorned his Ministerial career. That part really amounted to saying, "How Bill Adams did not win the Battle of Waterloo." I have followed very closely the right hon. Gentleman in war and in peace. He was a bitter critic of any errors we made in the times that are gone, in the years of struggle, but he was infinitely glad whenever we won. In that respect his attitude was differentiated markedly from that of some other colleagues who sit with him now upon that Front Bench. I, for my part, will follow his example, and, though critical, I would like to say how very glad I am whenever I read of a
116
better output from the mines as a result of better work and more regular timekeeping by the miners. Whatever one may think about political considerations, one must always rejoice at anything which helps our country in its perils and harsh times. There is very little doubt in my mind that things are going to get worse.I do net mean that this particular emergency is going to lay us low, but the country is going to suffer. It is going to suffer increasingly, and it will learn by its sufferings. We hope and pray that this period of tribulation may be abridged and mitigated as far as possible.
We have a long way to look back in this coal problem, and the right hon. Gentleman, foreseeing perhaps that he might be deprived of his igloo of bad weather by some of his critics below the Gangway, went right back to 1940. That is a long way back—
