- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on February 10, 1947, during the debate on fuel and power cuts, attacking the Labour government's administrative failures and the Chancellor's blaming of private coalowners.
- Main themes
- Fuel and power cuts, growth of the civil service, failure to allocate coal and electricity, Chancellor of the Exchequer's Gateshead speech, blame placed on private coalowners, government control of the coal industry, administrative incompetence, burden on productive workers, national economy and finance, party partisanship versus national trusteeship
- Duration
- ~6 min
- Words
- 690
- Sentences
- 33
- Readability
- 56
- Grade
- 11.0
- Syntax
- 3.07
- Vocabulary
- 2.30
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other33 sentences in 12 paragraphs
The point I am going to make is of great importance. Here we have almost doubled the staff required to manage the country. This increase of those who do not add directly to the production of the country is an enormous
123
one, and yet with all the assistance of this 400,000 or 500,000 additional civil servants, we have not even got the capacity or the organising force to work out this simple plan for the distribution of electricity or to find the best means of allocating coal to the industries until it is admittedly too late. All this burden is cast upon us through the increase of the civil servants looking after our affairs—hundreds of thousands living on the sweat of the toilers, hampering energy, enterprise and ingenuity at every stage. Yet, with this vast increase, they are not even capable of taking the simplest administrative precautions against dangers which must have been, or ought to have been, apprehended as very likely to occur in the present season of the year. I have spoken about these matters, and I shall take other opportunities of speaking in the country upon them. There is no need for us on this side of the House to hesitate to point the moral. There is the Chancellor of the Exchequer. I believe he will reply. Tributes will be more welcome when they are the result of a fine performance, but not when they are merely the ebullition of perfervid loyalty.
I am astonished at the levity with which the Chancellor of the Exchequer deals with his tremendous task. The other day he made a speech at Gateshead which I can only characterise as odious and disgraceful. It was most unsuited to the position which he holds where from time to time some feeling of being a national trustee ought to break in upon his party factions. This is what he said, speaking. of the coal shortage:
The wretched private coalowners before they flitted "—
not a particularly accurate word to describe the transaction—
left us with stocks of coal lower than ever before in our history. This winter we have had coal cuts and sheddings of electricity loads. That is entirely the responsibility of private enterprise…
It is perfectly vain to suppose that by unthinking cheers, however warmly they may express partisanship, any change was made in the basis facts as known to the bulk of the nation. For at least seven years, the entire control of the coal industry, the regulation of its staffs and the provision against winter shortages have been regulated by the Government of the
124
country, first of all for five years under the national Coalition, and since then by those who now have the power. And yet although everything has been directed under this control to the necessary stocks to get us through the winter and to tide over the year, and although this control has been absolute and complete throughout the industry for seven years, it is considered a clever thing to say:
The wretched coalowners flitted…
Is it worth cheering that statement that this was "one of the great breakdowns of private enterprise"? Time alone will show whether this country will submit indefinitely to arguments so fallacious and absurd. It has well been said that one can fool all the people some of the time and some of the people all the time, but not all the people all the time. I have every hope, under the mercy of Providence, of living to see a very great awakening in our country, and that false arguments animated by harsh malicious jealousies and spites will be condemned in England, as they have been condemned in the past. I hope, indeed, that the crisis will soon pass, but the marks will remain for a long time in our economy and finance. We should all do our best to comply with such Government instructions as reach us, and let us hope that the nation will realise, from this flagrant example, the downward stairway upon which they are now thrust, and of which they have only descended the first few steps.
