Fuel And Power Cuts

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Leader of the Opposition of the United Kingdom

10 February 1947 · House of Commons debate on fuel and power cuts · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on February 10, 1947, in a debate on fuel and power cuts, attacking the Labour Government's administrative failures and the growth of the civil service.
Main themes
Fuel and power cuts, electricity rationing, Shinwell plan, Cripps plan, departmental breakdown, coal allocation, bread rationing, Socialist planning and mismanagement, nationalisation, growth in the civil service, Attorney-General's admission, winter blizzard crisis
Duration
~6 min
21st percentile
Words
748
21st percentile
Sentences
39
24th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.8
18th percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 44%41%
  • Economic 36%33%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

39 sentences in 10 paragraphs

I still think that bread rationing could easily have been averted by good administration. It may well be that before this Session is concluded, it will be possible to submit a convincing argument to the House on that subject.

121

It foresight had been used, and the consumers had been taught to spread their use of electricity—if you like by alphabetical groups over the different hours of the day, there might have been an average reduction of tension, rather than this not very helpful gap of three hours in the morning and two hours in the afternoon. As for industry, there was what is called the Shinwell plan. Presently, that plan was superseded by what is called—a term of art—the Cripps plan.

Presumably the Cripps plan was adopted by the Government because it was thought to be better than the Shinwell plan. We can hardly believe it was adopted because it was known to he worse. Why was this so-called Cripps plan not made effective earlier? Clearly there was a departmental breakdown. We heard a pathetic lament from an hon. Member below the Gangway opposite last wee k about his journeys from one Department to another in a matter connected with the fuel supply of the companies in his constituency.

Why was not the Cripps plan adopted earlier if it was a better plan? Apart from the distribution of electricity, if the industry has been consulted earlier this plan of allocation of coal, or whatever was the best plan, would have been operative long before the weather crisis was likely to arise. It would have been operative and not just ready in January—when just as it was going to come into operation down came the shocking blizzard. It could perfectly well have been operated two or three months before, and there would have been no shock such as has been administered to our industry. We should have had the best allocation of coal, if it is the best allocation—and I cannot see that the right hon. Gentleman the President of the Board of Trade had any doctrinaire motive for not making it the best allocation of coal. It seems to me one of the cases where his theories and his duties flowed into one channel. In addition, we should have had an exactly worked out scheme for curtailing electricity supplies and administering them in a period of emergency should it come.

Here are two grave faults and administrative collapses by the Socialist planning Government First, they did not adopt the right allocation plan in good time. That is admitted. Secondly, they did not

122

draw up a carefully worked out scheme, which could be put into operation by a simple order for the effective rationing of electric current throughout the 24 hours. I must tell you the truth, Mr. Deputy-Speaker. They are all so busy with doctrinaire nationalisation, and so ardently involved in the class war, that they have no time, or strength or brains for making the ordinary administrative arrangements which common prudence demands. This is characteristic of our affairs at this time at home and abroad. What we are experiencing now is a sample of Socialism or, if you will, of half-baked Socialism.

I notice that the Attorney-General is not here. He is probably busy making some speech for which he will afterwards have to apologise. I am not attacking the right hon. and learned Gentleman because, as a matter of fact, I welcome his admission, with great frankness, as rightly linking this breakdown with the fortunes of the Socialist experiment. He made a remarkable admission. The whole fortunes of Socialism apparently depend on whether we can get out of this crisis or not. He should have a little more confidence in the theoretical foundations of a great movement, or—I notice that the right hon. and learned Gentleman has just come in and I will finish with him—a more careful study of Karl Marx, if he can spare the time from his many activities, will perhaps refresh his flagging fortitude and faith.

The brute fact is that Socialism means mismanagement. It means mismanagement, bad housekeeping, incompetence in high places and progressive degeneration of our island life. We now have a vast increase of civil servants looking after our affairs. I have some figures here. In June,1939, there were 539,000 civil servants engaged in national government; in November,1946 there were 1,007,000, or almost double. In local government there was a rise from 846,000 to 1,025,000—a great increase.