Iron And Steel Bill

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Leader of the Opposition of the United Kingdom

16 November 1948 · House of Commons debate on the Iron and Steel Bill · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on 16 November 1948, in the debate on the Iron and Steel Bill, attacking steel nationalisation as a plot and arguing for fair compensation.
Main themes
Nationalisation of the iron and steel industry, Iron and Steel Bill as a plot against free enterprise, coal nationalisation and a 20 per cent rise in coal prices, losses of the nationalised coal industry, State railways and competition from road transport, 107 steel firms under a State monopoly, threat to the 80 per cent of industry still free, export trade burdens, fair compensation versus confiscation, Stock Exchange valuation of shares, Socialist Government and totalitarian designs, miners and Mr. Bob Smillie
Duration
~8 min
28th percentile
Words
972
28th percentile
Sentences
44
28th percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
11.1
33rd percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 57%57%
  • Institutional 27%27%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

44 sentences in 11 paragraphs

Yes, in 1926 particularly. If the hon. Gentleman perused the story of those negotiations he would see how unjust is his interruption. Forty years have passed since I moved the Second Reading of the mines' Eight Hours Bill. In comradeship with Mr. Bob Smillie—I do not know if the hon. Member has ever heard of him, he was a much admired leader in those days—I introduced baths at the pitheads. I greatly admired the spirit of the miners in both wars and regretted that I had to deny so many of them the opportunity of winning distinction in the field to which they ardently aspired.

Nationalisation in the mines has already, largely by the creation of its incompetent and top-heavy, over-staffed and over-paid organisation at the top produced an average 20 per cent. increase in the cost of coal to the consumers whether it be for the home firesides or for the public services, power, heat, light and transport. That is a heavy handicap to all our production and above all to our export trade. There was a loss of £20 million last year in this nationalised industry, in spite of the increase in price, which affects us so seriously. I see that Lord Balfour, who is. I believe, the head of the Scottish Coal Board, stated the other day that this year the State monopoly of coal would show a profit of £5 million. It is, of course, quite easy for an all-powerful State monopoly of a vital supply to make a profit by raising the price against the general consumer. They only have to know what the loss was to make a provision in price that covers it. It is not so easy to measure the reactions of this price raising upon the main economy of the nation. It must certainly be most injurious.

Let me take another instance, now that we are asked to nationalise another industry; another instance of what is

228

already apparent. There are the State railways which have to compete with modern forms of road transport. We are informed that the railways are to show a heavy loss and such result will reflect upon State monopoly and State management. Can anyone doubt that a Socialist Government, having to brazen out its failures and fallacies, will throw its weight against road transport in all its forms, whether nationalised, or still free? I am speaking of what is going to happen in the minor firms in the steel trade. The machinery is in the hands of the Government. They are taking all power and their machinery is at once simple and overwhelming. They have only to raise the fares on omnibuses and other vehicles under their control until the deficit on the State railways has been wiped out through more passengers and goods being forced to use them. "We must make a success of our Socialist Railways," or British Railways—I believe they allow the word British in that connection.

How much greater will be the temptation of the Socialist Minister with a State monopoly of the 107 greatest steel firms in his hands to defend himself and his party from ever-growing criticism and complaint—how much greater will be the temptation for him to knock about these weaker brethren outside the compound and thus to demonstrate the failure of private enterprise and the wisdom and elevation of Socialist methods and ideals?

I say this is not a Bill, it is a plot; not a plan to increase production, but rather, in effect, at any rate, an operation in restraint of trade. It is not a plan to help our patient struggling people, but a burglar's jemmy to crack the capitalist crib— The right hon. Gentleman laughs, but he lives on the exertions of 80 per cent. of industries still free and all his hopes are founded on their activities. Those free industries constitute practically the whole of our export trade. They are already hampered by having to bear the weight and extra charges of the nationalised services and the weight of enormous taxation. They are already cramped by a vast network of regulations, interferences and restrictions, but still they are carrying the whole burden of our life and represent our only solvent economic earning power.

By this Bill the 80 per cent. of whose exploits in these hard times the Govern-

229

ment frequently boast and dilate upon, are to be subjected to the deadly attack of the State steel monopoly, whose tentacles will stretch around, penetrate and ultimately paralyse every form of free national activity. At every turn the Socialist Government and party, whose reputation and survival are engaged in proving the success of their nationalising experiments will have the means of striking down every industrial opponent of their totalitarian or equalitarian—for they come to much the same thing in this case—designs.

I will make only one reference to compensation. We had a very thoughtful and interesting speech last night from my hon. Friend the Member for Central Southwark (Mr. Jenkins). I can only speak in general terms about this matter. I do not intend to develop it at length, because my right hon. Friend the Member for the Scottish Universities (Sir J. Anderson) will deal with it later on. No one disputes that Parliament has the right to acquire any property which the public interest requires, provided that compensation is paid. The Socialist Government have accepted the principle of compensation and have declared themselves opposed to confiscation; but compensation means fair compensation. Insofar as compensation is unfair, an act of confiscation has been committed. The best method for the compulsory acquisition of property is either agreement or arbitration on certain well designed principles. The system of taking over property compulsorily at its Stock Exchange market value from day to day is not fair to the shareholder——