Xi Jinping: Explanation of the "Decision of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China on Several Major Issues Concerning the Comprehensive Promotion of the Rule of Law"
Xi Jinping · General Secretary of the Communist Party of China and President of the People's Republic of China
- Context
- Xi Jinping addressed the Fourth Plenary Session of the 18th CPC Central Committee in October 2014, explaining the drafting of the Decision on comprehensively promoting the rule of law.
- Main themes
- Rule of law, socialist rule of law state, CCP governance, legal system construction, judicial reform, law-based government, comprehensive deepening of reform, social fairness and justice, human rights protection, Party leadership, national governance capacity, moderately prosperous society
- Duration
- ~56 min
- Words
- 6,749
- Sentences
- 179
- Readability
- 8
- Grade
- 21.4
- Syntax
- 3.35
- Vocabulary
- 2.34
Translated from Chinese
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other179 sentences in 47 paragraphs
On behalf of the Central Political Bureau, I would like to explain the drafting process of the "Decision of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China on Several Major Issues Concerning the Comprehensive Promotion of the Rule of Law" to the plenary session.
I. Background and Process of the Drafting of the Decision
After the Third Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China, the Central Committee began to study and consider the agenda for the Fourth Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee. The 18th National Congress of the Communist Party of China proposed the goal of building a moderately prosperous society in all respects, and the Third Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee made top-level designs for comprehensively deepening reform. Achieving this goal and implementing this top-level design requires reliable legal guarantees.
The 18th National Congress emphasized that the rule of law is the fundamental way to govern the country and that efforts should be accelerated to build a socialist rule of law state and comprehensively promote the rule of law; by 2020, the basic strategy of governing the country by law should be fully implemented, a law-based government should be basically established, judicial credibility should be continuously improved, and human rights should be effectively respected and guaranteed. The Third Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee further proposed that to build a rule of law China, it is necessary to jointly promote the rule of law in governance, law-based administration, and law-based governance, and to adhere to the integrated construction of a rule of law state, rule of law government, and rule of law society. Fully implementing these deployments and requirements is related to accelerating the construction of a socialist rule of law state, implementing the top-level design of comprehensively deepening reform, and ensuring the long-term development of the cause of socialism with Chinese characteristics.
Law is a crucial tool for governing the country, and the rule of law is an important support for the national governance system and governance capacity. Comprehensively promoting the rule of law is a fundamental requirement for solving a series of major issues facing the development of the Party and the country, liberating and enhancing social vitality, promoting social fairness and justice, maintaining social harmony and stability, and ensuring the long-term stability of the Party and the country. To promote the sustained and healthy development of our economy and society and to continuously expand the broader development prospects of the cause of socialism with Chinese characteristics, it is necessary to comprehensively promote the construction of a socialist rule of law state and provide institutional solutions to these problems from the perspective of the rule of law.
Since the reform and opening up, our Party has consistently attached great importance to the rule of law. In December 1978, Comrade Deng Xiaoping pointed out: "We should concentrate our efforts on formulating criminal law, civil law, procedural law, and other necessary laws, such as factory law, people's commune law, forest law, grassland law, environmental protection law, labor law, foreign investment law, etc., which should be discussed and passed through certain democratic procedures, and strengthen the procuratorial and judicial organs to ensure that there are laws to follow, laws must be followed, law enforcement must be strict, and violations must be investigated." The 15th National Congress of the Communist Party of China proposed governing the country by law and building a socialist rule of law state, emphasizing that governing the country by law is the basic strategy for the Party to lead the people in governing the country, an objective need for developing a socialist market economy, an important symbol of social civilization and progress, and an important guarantee for the long-term stability of the country. The 16th National Congress proposed that the fundamental requirement for developing socialist democratic politics is to organically unify the adherence to the Party's leadership, the people's mastery of the country, and the rule of law. The 17th National Congress proposed that governing the country by law is a basic requirement of socialist democratic politics, emphasizing the need to fully implement the basic strategy of governing the country by law and accelerate the construction of a socialist rule of law state. The 18th National Congress emphasized the need to pay more attention to the important role of the rule of law in national governance and social management.
Since the 18th National Congress, the Central Committee has attached great importance to governing the country by law, emphasizing that the basic strategy of governing the country by law must be implemented, and that the construction of a socialist rule of law state must be accelerated by comprehensively promoting scientific legislation, strict law enforcement, fair justice, and the rule of law for all. It emphasizes adhering to the Party's leadership and paying more attention to improving the Party's leadership and governance methods; governing the country by law is primarily about governing the country according to the Constitution; governing according to law is fundamentally about governing according to the Constitution; under the new situation, our Party must fulfill its major responsibility for governing and revitalizing the country, strictly governing the Party according to the Party Constitution and governing the country according to the Constitution; the Party leads the people in formulating the Constitution and laws, the Party leads the people in implementing the Constitution and laws, and the Party itself must operate within the framework of the Constitution and laws, truly achieving Party leadership in legislation, ensuring law enforcement, and taking the lead in abiding by the law.
Now, the comprehensive construction of a moderately prosperous society has entered a decisive stage, and reform has entered a critical period and deep water zone. The tasks of reform, development, and stability that our Party faces are unprecedentedly heavy, and the contradictions, risks, and challenges are unprecedentedly numerous. The position of governing the country by law in the overall work of the Party and the country is more prominent, and its role is more significant. Comprehensively promoting the rule of law is a major strategic issue related to our Party's governance and revitalization, the happiness and well-being of the people, and the long-term stability of the Party and the country. It is an important aspect of improving and developing the system of socialism with Chinese characteristics and promoting the modernization of the national governance system and governance capacity. To achieve the series of strategic deployments made by the 18th National Congress and the Third Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee, to comprehensively build a moderately prosperous society, to realize the Chinese Dream of the great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation, to comprehensively deepen reform, and to improve and develop the system of socialism with Chinese characteristics, we must make overall arrangements, take practical measures, and take solid steps in comprehensively promoting the rule of law.
In light of this, in January of this year, the Central Political Bureau decided that the Fourth Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee would focus on studying the issue of comprehensively promoting the rule of law and make decisions. To this end, a drafting group was established, with myself as the leader, Comrades Zhang Dejiang and Wang Qishan as deputy leaders, and responsible comrades from relevant departments and two provincial leaders participating, to carry out the drafting work under the leadership of the Standing Committee of the Central Political Bureau.
On January 27, the Central Committee issued a notice soliciting opinions on the study of comprehensively promoting the rule of law at the Fourth Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee. On February 12, the drafting group held its first plenary meeting, officially launching the drafting work. From February 18 to 25, the drafting group formed eight research teams to conduct research in 14 provinces and regions.
From the feedback received and the on-site research, everyone unanimously believes that the study of comprehensively promoting the rule of law and the decisions made at the Fourth Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee are of great significance and far-reaching implications, meeting the needs of the Party and the country's development and the expectations of the people of all ethnic groups across the country. There is a widespread hope that this decision will clarify the guiding ideology and overall requirements for comprehensively promoting the rule of law, profoundly elaborate on the relationship between the Party's leadership and the rule of law, and address major theoretical and practical issues in the construction of the rule of law, proposing strong measures to address prominent issues that the public has strongly reflected in the work of the rule of law and making top-level designs for the construction of a socialist rule of law state.
In the more than eight months since the drafting group was established, it has conducted in-depth research, widely solicited opinions, carried out special demonstrations, and repeatedly discussed and revised the draft. During this period, the Standing Committee of the Central Political Bureau held three meetings, and the Central Political Bureau held two meetings to review the decisions of the plenary session. In early August, the draft decision for soliciting opinions was distributed within a certain range of the Party for feedback, including soliciting opinions from veteran Party members and specifically listening to the opinions of leaders from various democratic parties, the All-China Federation of Industry and Commerce, and non-party figures.
From the feedback, all parties unanimously believe that the plenary session's decision directly addresses the prominent issues in the field of legal construction in our country, is based on the actual situation of socialist legal construction in our country, and clearly proposes the guiding ideology, overall goals, and basic principles for comprehensively promoting the rule of law. It puts forward a series of new viewpoints and new measures regarding the rule of law, answers a series of major theoretical and practical questions such as the relationship between the Party's leadership and the rule of law, makes comprehensive deployments for scientific legislation, strict law enforcement, fair justice, the rule of law for all, the construction of a legal team, and strengthening and improving the Party's leadership in comprehensively promoting the rule of law, and responds specifically to the voices and concerns of the people. All parties unanimously believe that the plenary session's decision clearly puts forward the major assertion of adhering to the path of socialist rule of law with Chinese characteristics and building a socialist rule of law system with Chinese characteristics, clarifying the nature, direction, path, and means of building a socialist rule of law state, which will strongly promote the construction of a socialist rule of law state.
During the process of soliciting opinions, many good opinions and suggestions were put forward by various parties. The Central Committee tasked the drafting group with carefully sorting out and studying these opinions and suggestions. The drafting group made significant revisions to the plenary session's decision.
II. Overall Framework and Main Content of the Decision
The Central Political Bureau believes that comprehensively promoting the rule of law involves all areas of reform, development, and stability, governance of the Party, the country, and the military, as well as domestic and foreign affairs and national defense, and must be planned and coordinated from a holistic and long-term perspective. The plenary session's decision should clearly address major theoretical and practical issues in legal construction, fully affirm the achievements and experiences of socialist legal construction in our country, and propose new viewpoints and new measures with a spirit of reform and innovation in response to practical problems; it should grasp the key points of legal construction while reflecting the overall requirements of the Party and the country's development; it should be high-level and well-designed while being practical and effective; it should focus on short-term achievements while seeking long-term effectiveness.
The drafting of the plenary session's decision highlighted five considerations. First, it implements the spirit of the 18th National Congress and the Third Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee, reflects the logical connection among the "three comprehensives" of building a moderately prosperous society in all respects, comprehensively deepening reform, and comprehensively promoting the rule of law. Second, it revolves around the overall layout of the cause of socialism with Chinese characteristics, reflecting the requirements of promoting reform and development in various fields to improve the level of the rule of law, rather than discussing the rule of law in isolation. Third, it reflects the current basic pattern of legal work, making work deployments from the four aspects of legislation, law enforcement, justice, and law observance. Fourth, it adheres to the direction of reform and problem orientation, adapts to the requirements of promoting the modernization of the national governance system and governance capacity, directly addresses prominent issues in the field of legal construction, responds to the expectations of the people, and strives to propose reform measures of significant importance for governing the country by law. Fifth, it is based on the national conditions of our country, starting from reality, adhering to the path of socialist rule of law with Chinese characteristics, both keeping pace with the times and reflecting the spirit of the era, while not copying or imitating foreign models.
The plenary session's decision is divided into three major sections. The introduction and the first part constitute the first section, which serves as a general overview. The first part clearly proposes adhering to the path of socialist rule of law with Chinese characteristics, building a socialist rule of law system, and constructing a socialist rule of law state, elaborating on the significant meaning, guiding ideology, overall goals, and basic principles of comprehensively promoting the rule of law, as well as the scientific connotation of the socialist rule of law system and major issues such as the relationship between the Party's leadership and the rule of law.
The second to fifth parts constitute the second section, starting from the current basic pattern of legal work, discussing and deploying scientific legislation, strict law enforcement, fair justice, and the rule of law for all. The second part discusses improving the socialist legal system with the Constitution at its core and strengthening the implementation of the Constitution, elaborating on four aspects: improving the system for implementing and supervising the Constitution, perfecting the legislative system, promoting scientific and democratic legislation, and strengthening legislation in key areas, proposing basic requirements and specific measures for the implementation and supervision of the Constitution, and reflecting the relationship between governing the country by law and the overall layout of the cause of socialism with Chinese characteristics through the deployment of key area legislation. The third part discusses deepening the administration according to law and accelerating the construction of a law-based government, elaborating on six aspects: fully performing government functions according to law, improving the legal decision-making mechanism, deepening the reform of the administrative law enforcement system, adhering to strict, standardized, fair, and civilized law enforcement, strengthening the constraints and supervision of administrative power, and comprehensively promoting government transparency. The fourth part discusses ensuring fair justice and improving judicial credibility, elaborating on six aspects: improving the system that ensures the independent and fair exercise of judicial and prosecutorial powers according to law, optimizing the allocation of judicial powers, promoting strict judicial practices, ensuring public participation in the judiciary, strengthening judicial protection of human rights, and enhancing supervision of judicial activities. The fifth part discusses enhancing the legal awareness of the entire population and promoting the construction of a rule of law society, elaborating on four aspects: promoting the establishment of legal awareness throughout society, advancing multi-level and multi-field governance according to law, building a complete legal service system, and improving mechanisms for legal rights protection and dispute resolution.
The sixth part, seventh part, and conclusion constitute the third section. The sixth part discusses strengthening the construction of the legal work team, elaborating on three aspects: building a high-quality legal professional team, strengthening the construction of the legal service team, and innovating the training mechanism for legal talents. The seventh part discusses strengthening and improving the Party's leadership in comprehensively promoting the rule of law, elaborating on seven aspects: adhering to governing according to law, strengthening the construction of internal Party regulations and systems, improving the legal thinking and law-based working capabilities of Party members and cadres, promoting the legalization of grassroots governance, deeply advancing the strict governance of the military according to law, legally ensuring the practice of "one country, two systems" and promoting national reunification, and strengthening foreign-related legal work. Finally, it calls on the entire Party and the nation to strive for the construction of a rule of law China.
III. Several Issues That Need Explanation
First, the relationship between the Party's leadership and governing the country by law. The relationship between the Party and the rule of law is the core issue of legal construction. Whether the major task of comprehensively promoting the rule of law can be accomplished depends critically on whether the direction is correct and whether the political guarantee is strong and effective. Specifically, it is necessary to adhere to the Party's leadership, uphold the system of socialism with Chinese characteristics, and implement the theory of the rule of law with Chinese characteristics. The Party's leadership is the most essential feature of socialism with Chinese characteristics and the fundamental guarantee of socialist rule of law. The system of socialism with Chinese characteristics is the fundamental institutional foundation of the socialist rule of law system and the fundamental institutional guarantee for comprehensively promoting the rule of law. The theory of the rule of law with Chinese characteristics is the theoretical guidance and academic support for the socialist rule of law system and the action guide for comprehensively promoting the rule of law. These three aspects essentially constitute the core essence of the path of socialist rule of law with Chinese characteristics, defining and ensuring the institutional attributes and forward direction of the socialist rule of law system.
The plenary session's decision clearly states that adhering to the Party's leadership is a fundamental requirement of socialist rule of law, is the fundamental essence and lifeblood of the Party and the country, and is related to the interests and happiness of the people of all ethnic groups across the country. It is an inherent requirement of comprehensively promoting the rule of law; the Party's leadership and socialist rule of law are consistent, and socialist rule of law must adhere to the Party's leadership, while the Party's leadership must rely on socialist rule of law. The plenary session's decision proposes "three unifications" and "four good at" around strengthening and improving the Party's leadership in comprehensively promoting the rule of law and makes systematic deployments.
Integrating the adherence to the Party's leadership, the people's mastery of the country, and governing the country by law is a basic experience in the construction of socialist rule of law in our country. Our Constitution reflects the achievements of the Party leading the people in revolution, construction, and reform in the form of fundamental law, establishing the leadership position of the Communist Party of China formed through history and the people's choice. This point must be articulated boldly and prominently. It is necessary to clearly explain the essential characteristics of socialist rule of law in our country to the cadres and the masses, to clarify the source and ensure the correct understanding.
Second, the overall goal of comprehensively promoting the rule of law. The plenary session's decision states that the overall goal of comprehensively promoting the rule of law is to build a socialist rule of law system with Chinese characteristics and to construct a socialist rule of law state, and it elaborates on this overall goal: under the leadership of the Communist Party of China, adhering to the system of socialism with Chinese characteristics, implementing the theory of the rule of law with Chinese characteristics, forming a complete legal normative system, an efficient legal implementation system, a rigorous legal supervision system, and a strong legal guarantee system, forming a complete internal Party regulations system, adhering to the joint promotion of governing the country by law, governing according to law, and law-based administration, and adhering to the integrated construction of a rule of law state, rule of law government, and rule of law society, achieving scientific legislation, strict law enforcement, fair justice, and the rule of law for all, and promoting the modernization of the national governance system and governance capacity.
Proposing this overall goal not only clarifies the nature and direction of comprehensively promoting the rule of law but also highlights the work focus and overall grasp of comprehensively promoting the rule of law. First, it clearly declares to both domestic and international audiences that we will unswervingly follow the path of socialist rule of law with Chinese characteristics. The path of socialist rule of law with Chinese characteristics is a concentrated embodiment of the achievements and experiences of socialist legal construction and is the only correct path for building a socialist rule of law state. On the issue of what kind of legal path to follow, it is essential to send a correct and clear signal to society, indicating the right direction for comprehensively promoting the rule of law and unifying the understanding and actions of the entire Party and the people of all ethnic groups across the country. Second, it clarifies the overall grasp of comprehensively promoting the rule of law. Comprehensively promoting the rule of law involves many aspects, and in practical work, there must be an overall grasp that leads all parties, and this overall grasp is the construction of a socialist rule of law system with Chinese characteristics. All work related to governing the country by law should be planned and promoted around this overall grasp. Third, building a socialist rule of law system and constructing a socialist rule of law state are necessary requirements for achieving the modernization of the national governance system and governance capacity, as well as necessary requirements for comprehensively deepening reform. This is conducive to promoting the modernization of the national governance system and governance capacity along the path of the rule of law, to comprehensively promoting all work related to governing the country by law within the overall framework of comprehensively deepening reform, and to continuously deepening reform along the path of the rule of law.
Third, improving the implementation and supervision system of the Constitution. The Constitution is the fundamental law of the state. Whether the authority of the rule of law can be established first depends on whether the Constitution has authority. It is necessary to prioritize the promotion and establishment of the authority of the Constitution as a major task in comprehensively promoting the rule of law and to make substantial efforts in the implementation and supervision of the Constitution.
The Third Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee proposed to further improve the mechanism and procedures for supervising the implementation of the Constitution and to elevate the requirements for implementing the Constitution to a new level. This plenary session's decision further proposes to improve the constitutional supervision system of the National People's Congress and its Standing Committee, to establish a mechanism for interpreting the Constitution; to strengthen the system and capacity building for record review, to legally revoke and correct normative documents that are unconstitutional or illegal; to designate December 4 of each year as National Constitution Day; and to widely carry out constitutional education throughout society, promoting the spirit of the Constitution.
The plenary session's decision proposes to establish a system of constitutional oath. This is a system adopted by most countries with written constitutions. Among the 142 countries with written constitutions, 97 require relevant public officials to swear to uphold or be loyal to the Constitution. The subjects, content, and procedures of the constitutional oath vary among countries, but it is generally held before relevant personnel begin their duties or at the time of taking office. The plenary session's decision stipulates that all state personnel elected or appointed by the National People's Congress and its Standing Committee must publicly swear an oath to the Constitution upon taking office. This approach is beneficial for highlighting the authority of the Constitution, enhancing the constitutional awareness of public officials, encouraging public officials to be loyal to and safeguard the Constitution, and also beneficial for enhancing constitutional awareness and establishing the authority of the Constitution throughout society.
Fourth, improving the legislative system. Since the founding of New China, especially since the reform and opening up, through long-term efforts, we have formed a socialist legal system with Chinese characteristics, and various aspects of national and social life have generally achieved the goal of having laws to follow, which is a remarkable achievement. At the same time, we must also recognize that the development of practice is endless, and legislative work is also endless; the task of improving the socialist legal system with Chinese characteristics remains heavy.
We face some prominent issues in the legislative field, such as the need to further improve the quality of legislation, as some laws and regulations do not fully reflect objective laws and the will of the people, and their effectiveness in solving practical problems is insufficient, with weak relevance and operability; the need to further improve legislative efficiency. Additionally, there is a prominent tendency towards departmentalization in legislative work, and issues of power struggles and blame-shifting are quite common. Some legislation has effectively become a game of interests, resulting in either prolonged indecision or the enactment of laws and regulations that are not very effective. Some localities use regulations to implement local protectionism, creating obstacles to forming a unified, open, and competitively orderly market order nationwide, undermining the unity of the rule of law.
Promoting scientific legislation and democratic legislation is the fundamental way to improve the quality of legislation. The core of scientific legislation lies in respecting and reflecting objective laws, while the core of democratic legislation lies in serving the people and relying on the people. It is necessary to improve the mechanisms for scientific and democratic legislation and to innovate public participation in legislation, widely soliciting opinions and suggestions from all sides. The plenary session's decision proposes to clarify the boundaries of legislative power and effectively prevent the legalization of departmental interests and local protectionism from the perspectives of institutional mechanisms and work procedures. First, it is necessary to improve the system and mechanism in which the People's Congress with legislative power leads legislative work, giving full play to the leading role of the People's Congress and its Standing Committee in legislative work; establish a system in which relevant departments participate in drafting important legal drafts that are comprehensive, overarching, and foundational, organized by the relevant special committees of the National People's Congress and the Legislative Affairs Committee of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress; increase the proportion of full-time Standing Committee members with legal practice experience; and legally establish and improve the advisory system for legislative experts in special committees and working committees. Second, it is necessary to strengthen and improve the government legislative system, improve the procedures for formulating administrative regulations and rules, and improve the mechanisms for public participation in government legislation; important administrative management laws and regulations should be drafted by government legal institutions; for important legislative matters with significant inter-departmental disputes, third-party evaluations should be introduced by decision-making agencies, and delays should not be tolerated. Third, it is necessary to clarify the authority and scope of local legislation and prohibit localities from issuing documents with legislative nature.
It should be clarified that in our country, laws are requirements for all citizens, and Party regulations and systems are requirements for all Party members, and in many cases, they are stricter than legal requirements. Our Party is the vanguard, and the requirements for Party members should be stricter. Comprehensively promoting the rule of law must strive to form a pattern in which national laws and regulations and Party regulations and systems complement, promote, and guarantee each other.
Fifth, accelerating the construction of a law-based government. The vitality of law lies in its implementation, and the authority of law also lies in its implementation. "The difficulty of governance lies not in legislation, but in the enforcement of the law." If laws are made but not implemented, or if they are implemented ineffectively or superficially, then no amount of legislation will be of any use. The focus of comprehensively promoting the rule of law should be to ensure strict implementation of the law, ensuring that "laws are established, and violations must be punished; orders are issued, and actions must be taken without return."
The government is the main body of law enforcement, and there are prominent issues in the field of law enforcement, such as failure to enforce the law, lax enforcement, failure to investigate violations, and even the abuse of power, power-for-money transactions, and favoritism. The public is deeply resentful of these issues, and they must be addressed with great effort. The plenary session's decision states that all levels of government must work under the leadership of the Party and within the framework of the rule of law, accelerating the construction of a law-based government that is scientifically functional, legally defined in power and responsibility, strictly enforced, open and fair, clean and efficient, and law-abiding and trustworthy. The plenary session's decision proposes several important measures. First, it is necessary to promote the legalization of institutions, functions, powers, procedures, and responsibilities, stipulating that administrative agencies may not set powers outside the law, and decisions that diminish the legitimate rights and interests of citizens, legal persons, and other organizations or increase their obligations must have legal or regulatory basis; implement a government power list system to resolutely eliminate the space for power rent-seeking. Second, establish a mechanism for reviewing the legality of major decisions within administrative agencies, actively promote the government legal advisor system, ensuring that legal advisors play an active role in formulating major administrative decisions and promoting law-based administration; establish a lifelong accountability system for major decisions and a responsibility tracing mechanism. Third, promote comprehensive law enforcement, streamline the law enforcement system of urban management, improve law enforcement procedures, establish a system for recording the entire law enforcement process, strictly implement the legal review system for major law enforcement decisions, and comprehensively implement the administrative law enforcement responsibility system. Fourth, strengthen the constraints on internal government power, implementing separation of powers, separation of responsibilities, and hierarchical authorization for departments and positions with concentrated powers in areas such as the allocation and use of financial resources, supervision of state-owned assets, government investment, government procurement, and public resource transfer, regularly rotating positions, strengthening internal process control, and preventing abuse of power; improve internal hierarchical supervision and specialized supervision within the government; and ensure the independent exercise of audit supervision rights according to law. Fifth, comprehensively promote government transparency, advancing the openness of decision-making, execution, management, services, and results, with a focus on the disclosure of government information in areas such as financial budgets, public resource allocation, approval and implementation of major construction projects, and social welfare projects. These measures are highly targeted and are consistent with the spirit of the Third Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee, which is crucial for the construction of a law-based government.
Sixth, improving judicial credibility. The judiciary is the last line of defense for maintaining social fairness and justice. I have previously quoted a passage from British philosopher Francis Bacon, who said, "An unjust trial has worse consequences than ten crimes. For while crime disregards the law—like polluting a stream, an unjust trial destroys the law—like polluting the source of water." The reasoning here is profound. If the judiciary lacks credibility, social justice will be widely questioned, and social harmony and stability will be difficult to guarantee. Therefore, the plenary session's decision points out that fairness is the lifeline of the rule of law; judicial fairness plays an important leading role in social justice, while judicial injustice has a devastating destructive effect on social justice.
Currently, the main issues in the judicial field are that judicial injustice and low judicial credibility are particularly prominent, with some judicial personnel exhibiting improper conduct and corruption, handling cases based on money, relationships, or personal connections, and so on. The deep-seated reasons for judicial injustice lie in the imperfect judicial system, the unscientific allocation of judicial powers, and the inadequate protection of human rights in the judiciary.
The Third Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee proposed a series of reform measures to address the prominent issues in the judicial field, and reforms to the judicial system and operational mechanisms are being advanced in an orderly manner. This plenary session's decision makes deeper deployments for ensuring judicial fairness based on the decisions of the Third Plenary Session of the 18th Central Committee. For example, to ensure the independent and fair exercise of judicial and prosecutorial powers according to law, the plenary session's decision stipulates the establishment of a system for recording, reporting, and holding accountable leaders who interfere in judicial activities or intervene in specific cases; improving the system for administrative agencies to appear in court and respond to lawsuits, supporting courts in accepting administrative cases, and respecting and executing effective court judgments; establishing and improving mechanisms for protecting judicial personnel in fulfilling their statutory duties, and so on. To optimize the allocation of judicial powers, the plenary session's decision proposes to promote pilot reforms for separating judicial powers from enforcement powers; unify the system for executing criminal penalties; explore separating the management powers of judicial administrative affairs from judicial powers in courts and procuratorates; and change the case review system to a case registration system, among others. To ensure public participation in the judiciary, the plenary session's decision proposes to improve the system of people's jurors and expand the scope of participation; promote the openness of trials, judicial affairs, police affairs, and prison affairs; and establish a unified online publication and public inquiry system for effective legal documents, among others. The plenary session's decision also proposes important reform measures for strengthening human rights protection in the judiciary and enhancing supervision of judicial activities.
Seventh, the establishment of circuit courts by the Supreme People's Court. In recent years, with the increase in social conflicts, the number of cases accepted by courts nationwide has continuously risen, especially with a large number of cases flooding into the Supreme People's Court, leading to increased pressure on trials and difficulties in resolving disputes, which is not conducive to the Supreme People's Court fulfilling its function of supervising and guiding the work of courts nationwide, maintaining social stability, and facilitating litigation for parties involved.
The plenary session's decision proposes that the Supreme People's Court establish circuit courts to hear major administrative and civil cases that cross administrative regions. This approach is beneficial for shifting the focus of the judiciary downwards, resolving disputes locally, and facilitating litigation for parties involved, as well as allowing the Supreme People's Court to concentrate on formulating judicial policies and interpretations and hearing cases that have significant guiding implications for the uniform application of law.
Eighth, exploring the establishment of people's courts and people's procuratorates that cross administrative regions. With the deepening development of the socialist market economy and the emergence of administrative litigation, there are increasingly more cases that cross administrative regions or even borders, with larger amounts involved, leading to greater attention from relevant departments and leaders in the locality of the court, and even the use of power and relationships to intervene in case handling, resulting in a "home and away" phenomenon in related litigation, which is not conducive to equally protecting the legitimate rights and interests of parties from other regions, ensuring the independent trial of courts, supervising the government in administering according to law, and maintaining the fair implementation of law.
The plenary session's decision proposes to explore the establishment of people's courts and people's procuratorates that cross administrative regions. This is conducive to eliminating interference in judicial and prosecutorial work, ensuring that courts and procuratorates independently and fairly exercise their judicial and prosecutorial powers according to law, and constructing a litigation pattern in which ordinary cases are tried in administrative region courts and special cases are tried in cross-administrative region courts.
Ninth, exploring the establishment of a public interest litigation system initiated by procuratorial organs. Currently, the supervision of administrative illegalities by procuratorial organs mainly involves investigating cases of corruption, bribery, and dereliction of duty by administrative personnel, which is relatively narrow in scope. However, the reality is that only a minority of administrative illegalities constitute criminal offenses; more often, they involve misconduct or inaction. If such illegalities are ignored and allowed to develop, they will not fundamentally reverse some local and departmental administrative chaos, and may even lead to some emerging issues evolving into criminal offenses. The plenary session's decision proposes that when procuratorial organs discover that administrative agencies are illegally exercising or failing to exercise their powers in the course of performing their duties, they should urge corrections. The purpose of this provision is to ensure that procuratorial organs promptly propose suggestions and urge corrections for illegal acts discovered in law enforcement and case handling by administrative agencies and their personnel. This reform can start with establishing a system for urging prosecution and improving the mechanism for procuratorial suggestions.
In real life, for some cases where administrative agencies illegally exercise their powers or fail to act, causing harm or potential harm to national and social public interests, such as the protection of state-owned assets, the transfer of state-owned land use rights, and the protection of ecological environment and resources, citizens, legal persons, and other social organizations often lack direct interests and thus cannot initiate public interest litigation, leading to a lack of effective judicial supervision over illegal administrative actions, which is not conducive to promoting law-based administration, strict law enforcement, and strengthening the protection of public interests. Allowing procuratorial organs to initiate public interest litigation is conducive to optimizing the allocation of judicial powers, improving the administrative litigation system, and promoting the construction of a law-based government.
Tenth, promoting the reform of the litigation system centered on trials. Fully leveraging the role of trials, especially court hearings, is an important link in ensuring the quality of case handling and judicial fairness. Our criminal procedure law stipulates that the three organs of public security, prosecution, and the judiciary perform their respective duties, cooperate with each other, and check and balance each other in criminal litigation activities. This is a litigation system that is in line with China's national conditions and has Chinese characteristics, and it must be upheld. At the same time, in judicial practice, there is a tendency for case handlers to undervalue court trials, often resulting in key evidence not being collected or not being collected according to law, and cases entering trials not meeting the legal requirements of "clear facts and sufficient evidence," making it difficult for trials to proceed smoothly.
The plenary session's decision proposes to promote the reform of the litigation system centered on trials, aiming to encourage case handlers to establish the concept that cases must withstand legal scrutiny, ensuring that the facts and evidence of cases investigated and reviewed for prosecution can withstand legal scrutiny, and guaranteeing that trials play a decisive role in clarifying facts, determining evidence, protecting litigation rights, and making fair judgments. This reform is conducive to prompting case handlers to enhance their sense of responsibility and to achieve substantive justice in case judgments through the procedural fairness of court trials, effectively preventing the occurrence of wrongful convictions.
Comprehensively promoting the rule of law is a systematic project and a widespread and profound revolution in the field of national governance. Formulating this plenary session's decision is of great significance. Everyone should deeply understand the central spirit, comprehensively grasp and correctly treat the major reform measures proposed in the plenary session's decision from the perspective of the overall development of the Party and the country, deeply comprehend the significant practical significance and far-reaching historical significance of the relevant reforms, and consciously support and embrace the reforms. In discussions, I hope everyone can inspire and learn from each other, both proposing constructive amendments and suggestions to further improve the ideas and plans proposed in the plenary session's decision, and deepening understanding to facilitate post-meeting communication and implementation. Let us work together to ensure the success of this plenary session.
The original Chinese. The tags above are read on the English translation's sentences.
受中央政治局委托,我就《中共中央关于全面推进依法治国若干重大问题的决定》起草情况向全会作说明。
一、关于全会决定起草背景和过程
党的十八届三中全会后,中央即着手研究和考虑党的十八届四中全会的议题。党的十八大提出了全面建成小康社会的奋斗目标,党的十八届三中全会对全面深化改革作出了顶层设计,实现这个奋斗目标,落实这个顶层设计,需要从法治上提供可靠保障。
党的十八大提出,法治是治国理政的基本方式,要加快建设社会主义法治国家,全面推进依法治国;到2020年,依法治国基本方略全面落实,法治政府基本建成,司法公信力不断提高,人权得到切实尊重和保障。党的十八届三中全会进一步提出,建设法治中国,必须坚持依法治国、依法执政、依法行政共同推进,坚持法治国家、法治政府、法治社会一体建设。全面贯彻落实这些部署和要求,关系加快建设社会主义法治国家,关系落实全面深化改革顶层设计,关系中国特色社会主义事业长远发展。
法律是治国之重器,法治是国家治理体系和治理能力的重要依托。全面推进依法治国,是解决党和国家事业发展面临的一系列重大问题,解放和增强社会活力、促进社会公平正义、维护社会和谐稳定、确保党和国家长治久安的根本要求。要推动我国经济社会持续健康发展,不断开拓中国特色社会主义事业更加广阔的发展前景,就必须全面推进社会主义法治国家建设,从法治上为解决这些问题提供制度化方案。
改革开放以来,我们党一贯高度重视法治。1978年12月,邓小平同志就指出:“应该集中力量制定刑法、民法、诉讼法和其他各种必要的法律,例如工厂法、人民公社法、森林法、草原法、环境保护法、劳动法、外国人投资法等等,经过一定的民主程序讨论通过,并且加强检察机关和司法机关,做到有法可依,有法必依,执法必严,违法必究。”党的十五大提出依法治国、建设社会主义法治国家,强调依法治国是党领导人民治理国家的基本方略,是发展社会主义市场经济的客观需要,是社会文明进步的重要标志,是国家长治久安的重要保障。党的十六大提出,发展社会主义民主政治,最根本的是要把坚持党的领导、人民当家作主和依法治国有机统一起来。党的十七大提出,依法治国是社会主义民主政治的基本要求,强调要全面落实依法治国基本方略,加快建设社会主义法治国家。党的十八大强调,要更加注重发挥法治在国家治理和社会管理中的重要作用。
党的十八大以来,党中央高度重视依法治国,强调落实依法治国基本方略,加快建设社会主义法治国家,必须全面推进科学立法、严格执法、公正司法、全民守法进程,强调坚持党的领导,更加注重改进党的领导方式和执政方式;依法治国,首先是依宪治国;依法执政,关键是依宪执政;新形势下,我们党要履行好执政兴国的重大职责,必须依据党章从严治党、依据宪法治国理政;党领导人民制定宪法和法律,党领导人民执行宪法和法律,党自身必须在宪法和法律范围内活动,真正做到党领导立法、保证执法、带头守法。
现在,全面建成小康社会进入决定性阶段,改革进入攻坚期和深水区。我们党面对的改革发展稳定任务之重前所未有、矛盾风险挑战之多前所未有,依法治国在党和国家工作全局中的地位更加突出、作用更加重大。全面推进依法治国是关系我们党执政兴国、关系人民幸福安康、关系党和国家长治久安的重大战略问题,是完善和发展中国特色社会主义制度、推进国家治理体系和治理能力现代化的重要方面。我们要实现党的十八大和十八届三中全会作出的一系列战略部署,全面建成小康社会、实现中华民族伟大复兴的中国梦,全面深化改革、完善和发展中国特色社会主义制度,就必须在全面推进依法治国上作出总体部署、采取切实措施、迈出坚实步伐。
基于这样的考虑,今年1月,中央政治局决定,党的十八届四中全会重点研究全面推进依法治国问题并作出决定。为此,成立由我任组长,张德江同志、王岐山同志任副组长,相关部门负责同志、两位省里的领导同志参加的文件起草组,在中央政治局常委会领导下进行文件起草工作。
1月27日,党中央发出《关于对党的十八届四中全会研究全面推进依法治国问题征求意见的通知》。2月12日,文件起草组召开第一次全体会议,文件起草工作正式启动。2月18日至25日,文件起草组组成8个调研组分赴14个省区市进行调研。
从各方面反馈的意见和实地调研情况看,大家一致认为,党的十八届四中全会研究全面推进依法治国问题并作出决定,意义重大而深远,符合党和国家事业发展需要和全党全国各族人民期盼。大家普遍希望通过这个决定明确全面推进依法治国的指导思想和总体要求,深刻阐明党的领导和依法治国的关系等法治建设的重大理论和实践问题,针对法治工作中群众反映强烈的突出问题提出强有力的措施,对社会主义法治国家建设作出顶层设计。
文件起草组在成立以来的8个多月时间里,深入调查研究,广泛征求意见,开展专题论证,反复讨论修改。其间,中央政治局常委会召开3次会议、中央政治局召开2次会议分别审议全会决定。8月初,决定征求意见稿下发党内一定范围征求意见,包括征求党内老同志意见,还专门听取了各民主党派中央、全国工商联负责人和无党派人士意见。
从反馈的情况看,各方面一致认为,全会决定直面我国法治建设领域的突出问题,立足我国社会主义法治建设实际,明确提出了全面推进依法治国的指导思想、总目标、基本原则,提出了关于依法治国的一系列新观点、新举措,回答了党的领导和依法治国的关系等一系列重大理论和实践问题,对科学立法、严格执法、公正司法、全民守法、法治队伍建设、加强和改进党对全面推进依法治国的领导作出了全面部署,有针对性地回应了人民群众呼声和社会关切。各方面一致认为,全会决定鲜明提出坚持走中国特色社会主义法治道路、建设中国特色社会主义法治体系的重大论断,明确建设社会主义法治国家的性质、方向、道路、抓手,必将有力推进社会主义法治国家建设。
在征求意见的过程中,各方面提出了许多好的意见和建议。中央责成文件起草组认真梳理和研究这些意见和建议。文件起草组对全会决定作出重要修改。
二、关于全会决定的总体框架和主要内容
中央政治局认为,全面推进依法治国涉及改革发展稳定、治党治国治军、内政外交国防等各个领域,必须立足全局和长远来统筹谋划。全会决定应该旗帜鲜明就法治建设的重大理论和实践问题作出回答,既充分肯定我国社会主义法治建设的成就和经验,又针对现实问题提出富有改革创新精神的新观点新举措;既抓住法治建设的关键,又体现党和国家事业发展全局要求;既高屋建瓴、搞好顶层设计,又脚踏实地、做到切实管用;既讲近功,又求长效。
全会决定起草突出了5个方面的考虑。一是贯彻党的十八大和十八届三中全会精神,贯彻党的十八大以来党中央工作部署,体现全面建成小康社会、全面深化改革、全面推进依法治国这“三个全面”的逻辑联系。二是围绕中国特色社会主义事业总体布局,体现推进各领域改革发展对提高法治水平的要求,而不是就法治论法治。三是反映目前法治工作基本格局,从立法、执法、司法、守法4个方面作出工作部署。四是坚持改革方向、问题导向,适应推进国家治理体系和治理能力现代化要求,直面法治建设领域突出问题,回应人民群众期待,力争提出对依法治国具有重要意义的改革举措。五是立足我国国情,从实际出发,坚持走中国特色社会主义法治道路,既与时俱进、体现时代精神,又不照抄照搬别国模式。
全会决定共分三大板块。导语和第一部分构成第一板块,属于总论。第一部分旗帜鲜明提出坚持走中国特色社会主义法治道路、建设中国特色社会主义法治体系、建设社会主义法治国家,阐述全面推进依法治国的重大意义、指导思想、总目标、基本原则,阐述中国特色社会主义法治体系的科学内涵,阐述党的领导和依法治国的关系等重大问题。
第二部分至第五部分构成第二板块,从目前法治工作基本格局出发,对科学立法、严格执法、公正司法、全民守法进行论述和部署。第二部分讲完善以宪法为核心的中国特色社会主义法律体系、加强宪法实施,从健全宪法实施和监督制度、完善立法体制、深入推进科学立法民主立法、加强重点领域立法4个方面展开,对宪法实施和监督提出基本要求和具体措施,通过部署重点领域立法体现依法治国同中国特色社会主义事业总体布局的关系。第三部分讲深入推进依法行政、加快建设法治政府,从依法全面履行政府职能、健全依法决策机制、深化行政执法体制改革、坚持严格规范公正文明执法、强化对行政权力的制约和监督、全面推进政务公开6个方面展开。第四部分讲保证公正司法、提高司法公信力,从完善确保依法独立公正行使审判权和检察权的制度、优化司法职权配置、推进严格司法、保障人民群众参与司法、加强人权司法保障、加强对司法活动的监督6个方面展开。第五部分讲增强全民法治观念、推进法治社会建设,从推动全社会树立法治意识、推进多层次多领域依法治理、建设完备的法律服务体系、健全依法维权和化解纠纷机制4个方面展开。
第六部分、第七部分和结束语构成第三板块。第六部分讲加强法治工作队伍建设,从建设高素质法治专门队伍、加强法律服务队伍建设、创新法治人才培养机制3个方面展开。第七部分讲加强和改进党对全面推进依法治国的领导,从坚持依法执政、加强党内法规制度建设、提高党员干部法治思维和依法办事能力、推进基层治理法治化、深入推进依法治军从严治军、依法保障“一国两制”实践和推进祖国统一、加强涉外法律工作7个方面展开。最后,号召全党全国为建设法治中国而奋斗。
三、关于需要说明的几个问题
第一,党的领导和依法治国的关系。党和法治的关系是法治建设的核心问题。全面推进依法治国这件大事能不能办好,最关键的是方向是不是正确、政治保证是不是坚强有力,具体讲就是要坚持党的领导,坚持中国特色社会主义制度,贯彻中国特色社会主义法治理论。党的领导是中国特色社会主义最本质的特征,是社会主义法治最根本的保证。中国特色社会主义制度是中国特色社会主义法治体系的根本制度基础,是全面推进依法治国的根本制度保障。中国特色社会主义法治理论是中国特色社会主义法治体系的理论指导和学理支撑,是全面推进依法治国的行动指南。这3个方面实质上是中国特色社会主义法治道路的核心要义,规定和确保了中国特色社会主义法治体系的制度属性和前进方向。
全会决定明确提出,坚持党的领导,是社会主义法治的根本要求,是党和国家的根本所在、命脉所在,是全国各族人民的利益所系、幸福所系,是全面推进依法治国的题中应有之义;党的领导和社会主义法治是一致的,社会主义法治必须坚持党的领导,党的领导必须依靠社会主义法治。全会决定围绕加强和改进党对全面推进依法治国的领导提出“三统一”、“四善于”,并作出了系统部署。
把坚持党的领导、人民当家作主、依法治国有机统一起来是我国社会主义法治建设的一条基本经验。我国宪法以根本法的形式反映了党带领人民进行革命、建设、改革取得的成果,确立了在历史和人民选择中形成的中国共产党的领导地位。对这一点,要理直气壮讲、大张旗鼓讲。要向干部群众讲清楚我国社会主义法治的本质特征,做到正本清源、以正视听。
第二,全面推进依法治国的总目标。全会决定提出,全面推进依法治国,总目标是建设中国特色社会主义法治体系,建设社会主义法治国家,并对这个总目标作出了阐释:在中国共产党领导下,坚持中国特色社会主义制度,贯彻中国特色社会主义法治理论,形成完备的法律规范体系、高效的法治实施体系、严密的法治监督体系、有力的法治保障体系,形成完善的党内法规体系,坚持依法治国、依法执政、依法行政共同推进,坚持法治国家、法治政府、法治社会一体建设,实现科学立法、严格执法、公正司法、全民守法,促进国家治理体系和治理能力现代化。
提出这个总目标,既明确了全面推进依法治国的性质和方向,又突出了全面推进依法治国的工作重点和总抓手。一是向国内外鲜明宣示我们将坚定不移走中国特色社会主义法治道路。中国特色社会主义法治道路,是社会主义法治建设成就和经验的集中体现,是建设社会主义法治国家的唯一正确道路。在走什么样的法治道路问题上,必须向全社会释放正确而明确的信号,指明全面推进依法治国的正确方向,统一全党全国各族人民认识和行动。二是明确全面推进依法治国的总抓手。全面推进依法治国涉及很多方面,在实际工作中必须有一个总揽全局、牵引各方的总抓手,这个总抓手就是建设中国特色社会主义法治体系。依法治国各项工作都要围绕这个总抓手来谋划、来推进。三是建设中国特色社会主义法治体系、建设社会主义法治国家是实现国家治理体系和治理能力现代化的必然要求,也是全面深化改革的必然要求,有利于在法治轨道上推进国家治理体系和治理能力现代化,有利于在全面深化改革总体框架内全面推进依法治国各项工作,有利于在法治轨道上不断深化改革。
第三,健全宪法实施和监督制度。宪法是国家的根本法。法治权威能不能树立起来,首先要看宪法有没有权威。必须把宣传和树立宪法权威作为全面推进依法治国的重大事项抓紧抓好,切实在宪法实施和监督上下功夫。
党的十八届三中全会提出,要进一步健全宪法实施监督机制和程序,把实施宪法要求提高到一个新水平。这次全会决定进一步提出,完善全国人大及其常委会宪法监督制度,健全宪法解释程序机制;加强备案审查制度和能力建设,依法撤销和纠正违宪违法的规范性文件;将每年12月4日定为国家宪法日;在全社会普遍开展宪法教育,弘扬宪法精神。
全会决定提出建立宪法宣誓制度。这是世界上大多数有成文宪法的国家所采取的一种制度。在142个有成文宪法的国家中,规定相关国家公职人员必须宣誓拥护或效忠宪法的有97个。关于宪法宣誓的主体、内容、程序,各国做法不尽相同,一般都在有关人员开始履行职务之前或就职时举行宣誓。全会决定规定,凡经人大及其常委会选举或者决定任命的国家工作人员正式就职时公开向宪法宣誓。这样做,有利于彰显宪法权威,增强公职人员宪法观念,激励公职人员忠于和维护宪法,也有利于在全社会增强宪法意识、树立宪法权威。
第四,完善立法体制。新中国成立以来特别是改革开放以来,经过长期努力,我国形成了中国特色社会主义法律体系,国家生活和社会生活各方面总体上实现了有法可依,这是一个了不起的重大成就。同时,我们也要看到,实践发展永无止境,立法工作也永无止境,完善中国特色社会主义法律体系任务依然很重。
我们在立法领域面临着一些突出问题,比如,立法质量需要进一步提高,有的法律法规全面反映客观规律和人民意愿不够,解决实际问题有效性不足,针对性、可操作性不强;立法效率需要进一步提高。还有就是立法工作中部门化倾向、争权诿责现象较为突出,有的立法实际上成了一种利益博弈,不是久拖不决,就是制定的法律法规不大管用,一些地方利用法规实行地方保护主义,对全国形成统一开放、竞争有序的市场秩序造成障碍,损害国家法治统一。
推进科学立法、民主立法,是提高立法质量的根本途径。科学立法的核心在于尊重和体现客观规律,民主立法的核心在于为了人民、依靠人民。要完善科学立法、民主立法机制,创新公众参与立法方式,广泛听取各方面意见和建议。全会决定提出,明确立法权力边界,从体制机制和工作程序上有效防止部门利益和地方保护主义法律化。一是健全有立法权的人大主导立法工作的体制机制,发挥人大及其常委会在立法工作中的主导作用;建立由全国人大相关专门委员会、全国人大常委会法制工作委员会组织有关部门参与起草综合性、全局性、基础性等重要法律草案制度;增加有法治实践经验的专职常委比例;依法建立健全专门委员会、工作委员会立法专家顾问制度。二是加强和改进政府立法制度建设,完善行政法规、规章制定程序,完善公众参与政府立法机制;重要行政管理法律法规由政府法制机构组织起草;对部门间争议较大的重要立法事项,由决策机关引入第三方评估,不能久拖不决。三是明确地方立法权限和范围,禁止地方制发带有立法性质的文件。
需要明确的是,在我们国家,法律是对全体公民的要求,党内法规制度是对全体党员的要求,而且很多地方比法律的要求更严格。我们党是先锋队,对党员的要求应该更严。全面推进依法治国,必须努力形成国家法律法规和党内法规制度相辅相成、相互促进、相互保障的格局。
第五,加快建设法治政府。法律的生命力在于实施,法律的权威也在于实施。“天下之事,不难于立法,而难于法之必行。”如果有了法律而不实施、束之高阁,或者实施不力、做表面文章,那制定再多法律也无济于事。全面推进依法治国的重点应该是保证法律严格实施,做到“法立,有犯而必施;令出,唯行而不返”。
政府是执法主体,对执法领域存在的有法不依、执法不严、违法不究甚至以权压法、权钱交易、徇私枉法等突出问题,老百姓深恶痛绝,必须下大气力解决。全会决定提出,各级政府必须坚持在党的领导下、在法治轨道上开展工作,加快建设职能科学、权责法定、执法严明、公开公正、廉洁高效、守法诚信的法治政府。全会决定提出了一些重要措施。一是推进机构、职能、权限、程序、责任法定化,规定行政机关不得法外设定权力,没有法律法规依据不得作出减损公民、法人和其他组织合法权益或者增加其义务的决定;推行政府权力清单制度,坚决消除权力设租寻租空间。二是建立行政机关内部重大决策合法性审查机制,积极推行政府法律顾问制度,保证法律顾问在制定重大行政决策、推进依法行政中发挥积极作用;建立重大决策终身责任追究制度及责任倒查机制。三是推进综合执法,理顺城管执法体制,完善执法程序,建立执法全过程记录制度,严格执行重大执法决定法制审核制度,全面落实行政执法责任制。四是加强对政府内部权力的制约,对财政资金分配使用、国有资产监管、政府投资、政府采购、公共资源转让、公共工程建设等权力集中的部门和岗位实行分事行权、分岗设权、分级授权,定期轮岗,强化内部流程控制,防止权力滥用;完善政府内部层级监督和专门监督;保障依法独立行使审计监督权。五是全面推进政务公开,推进决策公开、执行公开、管理公开、服务公开、结果公开,重点推进财政预算、公共资源配置、重大建设项目批准和实施、社会公益事业建设等领域的政府信息公开。这些措施都有很强的针对性,也同党的十八届三中全会精神一脉相承,对法治政府建设十分紧要。
第六,提高司法公信力。司法是维护社会公平正义的最后一道防线。我曾经引用过英国哲学家培根的一段话,他说:“一次不公正的审判,其恶果甚至超过十次犯罪。因为犯罪虽是无视法律——好比污染了水流,而不公正的审判则毁坏法律——好比污染了水源。”这其中的道理是深刻的。如果司法这道防线缺乏公信力,社会公正就会受到普遍质疑,社会和谐稳定就难以保障。因此,全会决定指出,公正是法治的生命线;司法公正对社会公正具有重要引领作用,司法不公对社会公正具有致命破坏作用。
当前,司法领域存在的主要问题是,司法不公、司法公信力不高问题十分突出,一些司法人员作风不正、办案不廉,办金钱案、关系案、人情案,“吃了原告吃被告”,等等。司法不公的深层次原因在于司法体制不完善、司法职权配置和权力运行机制不科学、人权司法保障制度不健全。
党的十八届三中全会针对司法领域存在的突出问题提出了一系列改革举措,司法体制和运行机制改革正在有序推进。这次全会决定在党的十八届三中全会决定的基础上对保障司法公正作出了更深入的部署。比如,为确保依法独立公正行使审判权和检察权,全会决定规定,建立领导干部干预司法活动、插手具体案件处理的记录、通报和责任追究制度;健全行政机关依法出庭应诉、支持法院受理行政案件、尊重并执行法院生效裁判的制度;建立健全司法人员履行法定职责保护机制,等等。为优化司法职权配置,全会决定提出,推动实行审判权和执行权相分离的体制改革试点;统一刑罚执行体制;探索实行法院、检察院司法行政事务管理权和审判权、检察权相分离;变立案审查制为立案登记制,等等。为保障人民群众参与司法,全会决定提出,完善人民陪审员制度,扩大参审范围;推进审判公开、检务公开、警务公开、狱务公开;建立生效法律文书统一上网和公开查询制度,等等。全会决定还就加强人权司法保障和加强对司法活动的监督提出了重要改革措施。
第七,最高人民法院设立巡回法庭。近年来,随着社会矛盾增多,全国法院受理案件数量不断增加,尤其是大量案件涌入最高人民法院,导致审判接访压力增大,息诉罢访难度增加,不利于最高人民法院发挥监督指导全国法院工作职能,不利于维护社会稳定,不利于方便当事人诉讼。
全会决定提出,最高人民法院设立巡回法庭,审理跨行政区域重大行政和民商事案件。这样做,有利于审判机关重心下移、就地解决纠纷、方便当事人诉讼,有利于最高人民法院本部集中精力制定司法政策和司法解释、审理对统一法律适用有重大指导意义的案件。
第八,探索设立跨行政区划的人民法院和人民检察院。随着社会主义市场经济深入发展和行政诉讼出现,跨行政区划乃至跨境案件越来越多,涉案金额越来越大,导致法院所在地有关部门和领导越来越关注案件处理,甚至利用职权和关系插手案件处理,造成相关诉讼出现“主客场”现象,不利于平等保护外地当事人合法权益、保障法院独立审判、监督政府依法行政、维护法律公正实施。
全会决定提出,探索设立跨行政区划的人民法院和人民检察院。这有利于排除对审判工作和检察工作的干扰、保障法院和检察院依法独立公正行使审判权和检察权,有利于构建普通案件在行政区划法院审理、特殊案件在跨行政区划法院审理的诉讼格局。
第九,探索建立检察机关提起公益诉讼制度。现在,检察机关对行政违法行为的监督,主要是依法查办行政机关工作人员涉嫌贪污贿赂、渎职侵权等职务犯罪案件,范围相对比较窄。而实际情况是,行政违法行为构成刑事犯罪的毕竟是少数,更多的是乱作为、不作为。如果对这类违法行为置之不理、任其发展,一方面不可能根本扭转一些地方和部门的行政乱象,另一方面可能使一些苗头性问题演变为刑事犯罪。全会决定提出,检察机关在履行职责中发现行政机关违法行使职权或者不行使职权的行为,应该督促其纠正。作出这项规定,目的就是要使检察机关对在执法办案中发现的行政机关及其工作人员的违法行为及时提出建议并督促其纠正。这项改革可以从建立督促起诉制度、完善检察建议工作机制等入手。
在现实生活中,对一些行政机关违法行使职权或者不作为造成对国家和社会公共利益侵害或者有侵害危险的案件,如国有资产保护、国有土地使用权转让、生态环境和资源保护等,由于与公民、法人和其他社会组织没有直接利害关系,使其没有也无法提起公益诉讼,导致违法行政行为缺乏有效司法监督,不利于促进依法行政、严格执法,加强对公共利益的保护。由检察机关提起公益诉讼,有利于优化司法职权配置、完善行政诉讼制度,也有利于推进法治政府建设。
第十,推进以审判为中心的诉讼制度改革。充分发挥审判特别是庭审的作用,是确保案件处理质量和司法公正的重要环节。我国刑事诉讼法规定公检法三机关在刑事诉讼活动中各司其职、互相配合、互相制约,这是符合中国国情、具有中国特色的诉讼制度,必须坚持。同时,在司法实践中,存在办案人员对法庭审判重视不够,常常出现一些关键证据没有收集或者没有依法收集,进入庭审的案件没有达到“案件事实清楚、证据确实充分”的法定要求,使审判无法顺利进行。
全会决定提出推进以审判为中心的诉讼制度改革,目的是促使办案人员树立办案必须经得起法律检验的理念,确保侦查、审查起诉的案件事实证据经得起法律检验,保证庭审在查明事实、认定证据、保护诉权、公正裁判中发挥决定性作用。这项改革有利于促使办案人员增强责任意识,通过法庭审判的程序公正实现案件裁判的实体公正,有效防范冤假错案产生。
全面推进依法治国是一个系统工程,是国家治理领域一场广泛而深刻的革命。制定好这次全会决定具有十分重要的意义。大家要深刻领会中央精神,从党和国家事业发展全局出发,全面理解和正确对待全会决定提出的重大改革举措,深刻领会有关改革的重大现实意义和深远历史意义,自觉支持改革、拥护改革。在讨论中,希望大家相互启发、相互切磋,既提出建设性的修改意见和建议,进一步完善全会决定提出的思路和方案,又加深理解,以利于会后传达贯彻。让我们共同努力,把这次全会开好。(新华网北京10月28日电)