Statements during a meeting with a group of teachers, scholars, and students from the seminaries of Kerman.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

11 November 1991 · Meeting with a group of teachers, scholars, and students from the seminaries of Kerman · Kerman, Iran

Context
Khamenei addressed teachers, scholars, and students from Kerman's seminaries in November 1991, reflecting on the clergy's historical role and his personal ties to Kerman.
Main themes
Role of the Shia clergy, finding one's place in revolution, history of Shia scholarship, clergy and the people, Safavid period scholars, taqiyya and persecution, religious leadership, seminary education, Islamic revolution in Iran, clerical independence
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,325
64th percentile
Sentences
96
61st percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 48%42%
  • Institutional 25%22%
  • Ceremonial 18%16%
  • Geopolitical 7%6%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 13%

96 sentences in 31 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful

(1)

We are very grateful to the esteemed gentlemen and dear brothers who have kindly traversed this long journey and illuminated our gathering with your presence. As Mr. Jafari pointed out, I am somewhat familiar with the esteemed clergy of Kerman and the situation of the clergy in Kerman, and the multiple trips I made to Kerman in the years before the revolution always remain in my mind as sweet and bright chapters of past memories. I first came to Kerman in 1963, during the height of the struggles, and the Masoumiyeh School was the center of the struggles. One day, the late Ayatollah Salehi Kermani (may God have mercy on him) — who at that time was the focal point of the clergy in Kerman — came, and I saw him up close, and I became acquainted with the situation of the clergy in Kerman, and I recognize some of the gentlemen present in this meeting from that year. Then, in the years 1971 and 1972 — apparently it was around those years — and later in 1979, upon returning from exile when I came to Kerman from Jiroft, I saw the situation in Kerman, the gatherings of the people, and the sincere presence of the clergy there, and I observed the impact of the dear brothers present in this meeting on the spirit of the people, their closeness to the people, and the work of the popular clergy of Kerman. God willing, this good trend will always remain in that bright, clear, and spiritually and materially prosperous city, and may God have mercy on the past generations and protect you dear gentlemen.

What is important for us clergy is to find our place in the course of the revolution. In my opinion, the art of the clergy throughout history has been to find their place; especially the young gentlemen, the energetic brothers should pay attention to this point for the future, and truly this insight defines the horizon of the clergy. The Shia clergy has remained for a thousand years as a class, a stratum. Well, of these thousand years, about four hundred years were the period of no taqiyya — during which the country was a Shia country and the clergy were Shia clergy — but six hundred years of this thousand years were periods in which the clergy lived in taqiyya, in secrecy, in flight, in imprisonment. This thousand-year history has gone through two completely distinct periods.

The great Allameh Hilli that you see, or the Muhaqqiq that you see, or Sheikh Tusi with his high status — who has truly not been matched in all the Shia scholars from the beginning until today in terms of knowledge — lived under the utmost hardship. The house of Sheikh Tusi and his library in Baghdad were burned; a man who had been teaching in Baghdad for many years was made a refugee; he sought refuge in Najaf; after that, he lived for years in Najaf, where Najaf became a seminary. Otherwise, the first Shia seminary was in Baghdad due to the presence of Sheikh Mufid, Seyyed Murtaza, Sheikh Tusi, and the like; after he was made a refugee, he came to Najaf and spread the teaching and knowledge there. These great scholars that you know: the two martyrs, Muhaqqiq Karaki, and others — this great chain of scholars — lived before the Safavid period. That period was a time of repression, a time of hardship; [despite all this] they were able to preserve themselves during that time, meaning they found their place. Where is their place? Their place is alongside the oppressed Shia people. That is, they could have separated their accounts from the people — it was possible — but they never did that; they remained alongside the people. Then suddenly a transformation occurred, and the Safavids came to power, and the scholars became free; that is, the Shia scholars found themselves in a broad space.

Well, you observe; among the scholars of the Safavid period, there is Sheikh al-Islam, a well-known scholar who was favored by the king, Mirdamad, Sheikh Baha'i, Mulla Muhammad Baqir Sabzevari; all of these were Sheikh al-Islams and great scholars, favored by the courts, but when you look at their lives, you see they lived like independent scholars; that is, right alongside the people, with the people, in service to the people, for the people; their lives are quite remarkable.

For example, Allameh Majlisi, who was the great Sheikh al-Islam of Isfahan and had that magnificent court, was a cleric to whom people would refer, inquire about their conditions, ask questions; these are the same activities that the clergy have been doing throughout this time. In the early Safavid period, for instance, the scholars had some connection with the rulers because the rulers needed them — they would constantly approach them and pay attention to them. After this period ended, you see that the scholars became a separate series, still in the service of religion, in the service of knowledge, in the service of the people; no one could exploit them. Compare this with the clergy of other Islamic sects; from the Sunnis — various Sunni sects — and sects like the Ibadi and Zaydi, which are not Sunni in that sense; some are Kharijites, some are [other groups] — none of these had the characteristics of the Imami scholars (may God be pleased with them). This, in my opinion, is a divine blessing; it is due to a divine intellect that God Almighty inspired them to find their place.

Now, I did not intend to speak in detail about this; the purpose was to point to the current situation. Consider the current situation. Of course, this situation that has arisen today has no precedent in the history of Islam. That is, religion has become the ruler; jurisprudence has become the ruler; this is something that has not existed since the period of Islamic governance after the early years — those few years. That is, this situation cannot be compared to the situation during the Safavid period. They were a bunch of coup plotters who came to power; they were bullies who happened to be Shia, nothing more; like, for example, the Qajars who were in this country. The Safavids and the Qajars did not differ in terms of the content of their work and rule and the other conditions of governance; they only had a Shia affiliation. Today, the issue is something else. I want to express that today what should be the position of the clergy; where should the clergy stand? This is the issue, and the truth is that this must never be forgotten, that the clergy must be in a position of guarding and defending the system in various directions. No factor should be able to separate the Shia clergy today from defending the Islamic Republic. Whatever conditions arise, this is the case.

Now, for example, Mr. Jafari referred to the issue of security in Kerman, and as he pointed out, I am aware of the details of the matters. I should also mention that currently, the responsible agencies are working on this issue; that is, there is no need for me to reiterate; they did not undertake a temporary, piecemeal job and did not intend to do so; it is a continuous movement. Of course, until the complete results are achieved, it will take some time; they are currently busy. Because that region is not just Kerman; it is Kerman and Sistan and Baluchestan, meaning in reality these areas are one region; they have one ruling and are interconnected. Yesterday, the officials were here, reporting and doing work, and they will do other works, God willing. In any case, work is progressing; that is, behind these demands, there is effort, and the officials are striving. The same issue of inflation and rising prices that you mentioned, these are not things that the officials of the country are unaware of or indifferent to or hopeless about; no, none of this is true. They know what the reality is, they are not indifferent to this issue, meaning they are concerned about it, and they are not hopeless; they think they are moving towards solving the issue. That is, this must be truly understood and recognized that such a thing exists.

Well, now my point was this: these problems certainly exist. A number of people may become disheartened by these problems, may face issues. After all, in a household, in a family, if the lunch is served a little late or is a bit undercooked, one segment of this family chain that is weaker may become angry. The one who has more capacity, who is more mature, who is more patient, who looks further ahead, says, "Well, after all, one day the food came out undercooked, what can we do; now it was ten minutes late, that is nothing"; but the one who is less patient, has less capacity, is more hasty, is younger, stamps his feet, screams, and shouts; this is naturally the case. A number of people become troubled by these issues, problems arise for them. A second group uses this issue of becoming troubled in a wrong way; that is, with malicious intentions; [for example, they say] "Look! Look how poorly they prepare the food! Look how late they serve the food!"; they have political motives; these are the two groups. There is also a third group that, even though they feel pain, they are patient to see what will happen. Here, where does the clergy stand? Pay attention to this. The clergy should not be part of the first group; they should not be part of the second group either; they should not be part of the third group either. The clergy should be in the position of someone who explains to the people that this issue has nothing to do with the entirety of the system. Yes, it is possible that such and such a problem exists, but there are officials, and God willing, they will fix it.

I do not recommend that you always be in a position of justification, [that is, for example, if any municipality makes a mistake, the Friday prayer leader or the local scholar should immediately defend that mayor's actions; no, we do not recommend this; we want to say separate this from the entirety of the system in the minds of the people. It should be said that yes, it is the Islamic Republic, there are many enemies, there are many problems, there are good and caring officials; it must be, God willing, resolved. However, the sanctity and solidity of the Islamic system must always be preserved; the clergy must stand in this position.

And for this work to be done well, I believe that in the existing political disputes, there should be less interference; that is, in a sense, there should be no interference at all. However, because if the atmosphere is not a completely healthy one, every breath taken will be interpreted in a certain way and in a certain meaning, in such an atmosphere, they should strive to keep themselves as far away as possible from conflicts; that is, the paternal aspect, the general aspect, being for all the people, should be maintained, considering both conflicting groups as their children and possibly having mistakes.

Of course, this formation of the clergy is a very good thing; that is, any formation for the clergy is a good thing. The clergy should be together, think together, correct each other's mistakes, and complete each other's work. We are a collective; we have similar tasks in relation to the people. We may not all have the necessary capacity sufficiently; we should use each other, from each other's experiences, from each other's words; this seems to us to be a very good thing, and this is done in clerical formations. This collective that Mr. Jafari referred to is a very good collective; they should be together, of course, they should strive to be inclusive; that is, it should not be such that now another group comes from that side and creates a similar or rival collective or possibly an opposing one; this is not in the interest; it is better that everyone be together. Which two people are there who think, understand, and decide exactly the same? Now, if these people are fifty, well, let them become seventy, for example; even with some differences in certain matters. The generalities of agreement are still more. The clergy should have a comprehensive dignity that transcends the other dignities that may separate individuals from each other.

In any case, we are very happy to see the gentlemen and the eloquent, beautiful, and fluent poetry of Mr. Fakhr, with whom I have a history and familiarity with his sweet language; as mentioned, it was very good poetry, except that we believe the occasion of its revelation had a flaw!

(7)

Otherwise, the essence of the poem was truly very, very good. God willing, may God always bestow His favors and kindness upon his pure and gentle heart and spirit; may His blessings descend upon him and all the dear brothers, God willing.

And peace be upon you and God's mercy and blessings.

(1)

At the beginning of this meeting, Hujjat al-Islam wal-Muslimin Sayyid Yahya Jafari (Representative of the Supreme Leader and Friday Prayer Leader of Kerman) made some remarks.

(2)

Abu al-Qasim Najm al-Din Hilli (known as Muhaqqiq Hilli)

(3)

Shams al-Din Muhammad ibn Maki al-Amili (the First Martyr) and Zain al-Din ibn Nur al-Din Ali Juba'i al-Amili (the Second Martyr)

(4)

Concerned, attentive

(5)

The Society of Clergy of Kerman

(6)

Hujjat al-Islam wal-Muslimin Sayyid Ahmad Fakhr Mahdavi (one of the revolutionary clerics and poets of Kerman)

(7)

This poetry was composed in praise of Ayatollah Khamenei.