Statement by the President after the meeting with the Prime Minister

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

15 January 2024

Context
Duda addressed press after meeting Prime Minister Tusk on January 15, 2024, disputing the legality of changes made to the National Prosecutor's Office without presidential consultation.
Main themes
Rule of law and constitutional compliance, National Prosecutor's Office dispute, presidential prerogatives and consent, Attorney General Bodnar's actions, separation of powers, internal security, foreign policy discussion, legal validity of prosecutorial decisions, constitutional procedures for dismissal
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,522
68th percentile
Sentences
99
62nd percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
13.4
60th percentile
Syntax
3.21
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 50%48%
  • Geopolitical 40%38%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

99 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen,

Ladies and gentlemen, I have just concluded my meeting with Prime Minister Donald Tusk. The President of the Council of Ministers requested the meeting, announcing that he would like to discuss international matters related to our foreign policy, as well as personnel issues, including within the European Union.

However, I began the conversation with those very important topics that are happening today here, with us, on the ground, in Poland, because I have no doubt, and I think that most of you and most of my compatriots also have no doubt, that these are issues related to security and order in our country. I am thinking here about internal, legal matters. We also discussed external security.

I told the Prime Minister that this morning I had a meeting with prosecutors, that I received information from the prosecutors about the current situation in the National Prosecutor's Office, what actions have been taken by Minister Bodnar, the Attorney General, and I inquired about the actions that prosecutors are currently undertaking. I told the prosecutors that there had been no consultations with me – I emphasize once again – absolutely no consultations regarding changes in the National Prosecutor's Office, that I, as President, had not received any written document or inquiry, or any written request in this matter, and that I myself had not expressed any written position on this issue. Therefore, I believe that no legal actions have taken place. Because I want to emphasize this with all my strength.

Ladies and gentlemen, the law clearly states: the dismissal of the National Prosecutor can only occur after a consultation that is to be conducted between the Prime Minister and the President, requires the President's consent, requires the President's written consent, and such a consultation did not take place at all.

The letter that Minister Bodnar, as Attorney General, sent to the National Prosecutor – I will tell you – has no legal value. On the same principle, anyone in positions here, in the Chancellery of the President, could send a letter to the National Prosecutor and write that they understand that he is not fulfilling his office. It is simply worthless.

I appealed to the Prime Minister to restore the situation in accordance with the law, not only with the statute but also with the constitution, because we both have our competencies. The Attorney General should request the dismissal of the National Prosecutor.

The Prime Minister should request my consent, and in the case that a new National Prosecutor is to be appointed, I issue an opinion on this matter as the President of the Republic, this opinion is also a written opinion, there are procedures clearly described in the statutes in this regard, therefore there is no doubt that there has been a violation of the law here. Consequently, it is absolutely impossible to speak of any effective removal of the National Prosecutor from office.

It is obvious to you that I have called on the Prime Minister to restore order in this regard, to discuss this matter with Minister Bodnar, because what we are observing is simply unserious and raises great concerns in the country. No one needs to be told what it means to have a Prosecutor's Office that stands guard over the rule of law, that also stands guard over internal security, that deals with prosecuting criminals.

Ladies and gentlemen, if the Attorney General claims that the National Prosecutor has never been properly appointed from the very beginning, that is, for almost two years of his term, it means that all decisions, including procedural decisions, made by the National Prosecutor during this period, and procedural decisions made by prosecutors delegated by him, are legally questionable. And this affects all criminal proceedings that were conducted by them and in which they participated, so, excuse me, is this really about undermining these criminal proceedings? I hope not. So for me, it is obvious that Mr. Bodnar should step back from this path of lawlessness that he has embarked upon and cease these pathetic actions, because a normal legal path should be followed here, if at all.

And I told the Prime Minister that I expect lawful action, I expect legal action, I expect compliance with the statutes, I expect compliance with the constitution, I expect compliance with our mutual competencies as the highest state authorities.

And in this matter, my position was and is, and, ladies and gentlemen, will be unequivocal. I told this to the Prime Minister, I also told this to the prosecutors at eight in the morning. Three deputy national prosecutors were with me here at the Presidential Palace. The entire management team of the Prosecutor's Office was on site at the Prosecutor's Office, we connected via the internet, so we had a very long conversation, lasting over an hour. And here my position on this matter is absolutely clear: please refrain from attempts to violate the law. All actions in this regard must be clearly stated to be legally ineffective. That is the first point.

Secondly, ladies and gentlemen, I appealed to the Prime Minister for the Minister of Justice – Attorney General, Mr. Bodnar, to fulfill the request I made to him. I expect this request to be fulfilled, that in connection with the initiated clemency proceedings regarding Mr. Mariusz Kamiński and Mr. Maciej Wąsik, the gentlemen will be released from prison for the duration of these proceedings, that they will be able to return home peacefully. Let us remember that they are individuals who have held and hold important public functions.

Today, by popular election, they have mandates as deputies. This is not a unilateral decision by someone that they have this mandate, but it was a decision made by the Polish society in elections, just as Prime Minister Donald Tusk was elected, just as the absolute majority of his ministers and deputies who cooperate with him in the current ruling coalition were elected. In this regard, the will of the people should be respected, and above all, good customs should be respected, especially since there is undoubtedly a legal dispute in this matter, because there is, that is the truth, but it is a legal dispute, a legal dispute that has not yet been resolved. It has not been resolved also because there are still possible actions to be taken by the courts in this regard, and they should be carried out.

And I called on the Prime Minister to ensure that during the time these proceedings are ongoing, the gentlemen are released and can return home peacefully. This is a fundamental issue, it is also a humanitarian issue, it is a matter of decency, but above all, it is a matter of social order.

We know, ladies and gentlemen, how many social emotions this issue raises. Among other things, that is why I decided to initiate this clemency proceeding, to start it, to initiate it, to calm these emotions. And that is why I turned to the only entity currently authorized in this regard, which is the Minister – Attorney General, to exercise his right and suspend the execution of this sentence.

In this regard, I appeal once again to the Minister. I also made a personal appeal to the Prime Minister today to influence his subordinate to ensure that this is simply realized. So those were the two main issues.

We also discussed the problem of public media. Ladies and gentlemen, I told the Prime Minister – Mr. Prime Minister, I asked for actions in accordance with the constitution, with the applicable regulations. There has been a gross violation of norms, which was immediately obvious to everyone.

Minister Sienkiewicz, acting on the basis of a resolution of the Sejm, which was absolutely not a universally binding act, was undertaking unilateral actions in violation of the law and the constitution against the bodies of public media. The Registry Court simply had no choice but to refuse to execute this entry, because there was simply no other option, the violation of the law here is absolutely egregious. I told the Prime Minister, there are forms of action, as well as cooperation between the bodies that can be realized. There are not only legislative procedures, but I said that I am always open to discussion and debate on potential legislative changes.

Earlier, as you know, I also held meetings with both the National Broadcasting Council and the National Media Council and asked them to prepare their positions on this matter.

I simply believe that we should calmly and consistently work out statutory solutions regarding the future of public media. And I hope that this will also happen in the future.

We then moved on to discussing Polish international affairs with the Prime Minister. We talked about the future appointments to key positions within the European Union, and of course we will certainly strive for one of our compatriots, some Polish politician, to take one of those most important European positions. But it will not be easy. Let us also be aware that Prime Minister Donald Tusk was not long ago the President of the European Council. That is a very prominent European position. But as the Prime Minister rightly reminded me during our conversation, not long ago, two representatives from Belgium held and are holding these positions, because Charles Michel, who is currently the President of the European Council, is also Belgian, a former Prime Minister of Belgium, and previously Mr. Van Rompuy, who was also Belgian, so hypothetically it is possible and Poland will probably seek this.

We also have a law on cooperation regarding the appointment of these offices within the European Union, which are legally and politically appointed by Poland on a permanent basis, and in this regard, I am of course open to cooperation and consultations, and I told the Prime Minister this as well. This was, by the way, a reiteration of my earlier position, because I have been saying from the very beginning that I am ready for consultations in every matter and I am open, and I am ready for that.

Ladies and gentlemen, we also discussed a very important topic, which is the situation in Ukraine. As you know, yesterday in Davos there was a meeting of the Peace Formula, which is a meeting of representatives from an increasing number of countries, which is a good sign, recently 17 more countries joined this initiative, where discussions are held and a peaceful solution to the conflict arising from the Russian aggression against Ukraine is sought on one side. But on the other hand, it is also, as I see it clearly and obviously, a place where one can firmly speak about who the aggressor is and where from the very beginning President Volodymyr Zelensky has presented his clear position and his peace plan, which, I want to express my satisfaction with, is the starting point for these discussions.

My representatives, that is, representatives of Poland, have been participating in these discussions from the very beginning. There have already been several of these meetings. Yesterday, Minister Mieszko Pawlak participated in this meeting. I told the Prime Minister how the meeting went, what the current situation is there. I also told the Prime Minister that I will be in Davos in the coming days and that these topics will certainly be discussed.

As you know, President Volodymyr Zelensky is also in Davos. There are also other leaders, the Secretary General of NATO, the Secretary General of the United Nations has also announced his presence. A whole series of presidents will be there. We will be discussing, first and foremost, the situation in Ukraine.

I have a whole series of meetings planned within the House of Ukraine, which Ukraine has organized in Davos, not for the first time. There will be another exhibition dedicated to the victims of this war, in short, the victims of Russian crimes in Ukraine, we are talking about civilian casualties. I will also certainly participate in this event, which will be the opening and promotion of this exhibition, so that as many participants of the Forum as possible visit this exhibition, especially politicians, because it is important to raise awareness of how dramatic the situation is.

But of course, an extremely important issue for us is also the question of discussions about development, not only cooperation but the development of cooperation with the countries of the Three Seas. Not only cooperation within the Three Seas but also with the countries of the Three Seas. As Poland, we are co-organizers of the Three Seas House, where a very broad agenda of meetings is planned, also concerning security, as well as the development of cooperation, primarily this infrastructural cooperation within the Three Seas. In the Three Seas House, I will have meetings with presidents, we will have debates, there will be panel discussions. The American Atlantic Council is also involved in all of this, so in this regard, we are also working in cooperation with our partner in the Three Seas, which is the United States. Here we also encourage everyone to take an interest in this cooperation with the Three Seas. There will certainly be many representatives from Arab countries, there will certainly be representatives from Asian countries. We want to present the Three Seas as a very attractive region of Europe for investment, as a region attractive for development, as that part of Europe that is currently developing the most dynamically.

So, there are many tasks that we have to accomplish in Davos, but I want to emphasize with all my strength – for me, this is primarily a matter of security. Of course, this is the Economic Forum, and that is also a very important element. Economic and investment topics will certainly arise, but above all, security issues. I think that just as it was last year, this year the issue of Ukraine will dominate. As you know, this is one of the most important topics for us today. The war in Ukraine must end simply with a victory for Ukraine. This victory will consist of the peace plan of Volodymyr Zelensky, which involves Ukraine regaining the territories occupied by Russia and ensuring that Ukraine remains a sovereign, independent state within its internationally recognized borders, and that this plan will be implemented, so there is a great task here to encourage strengthening the eastern flank of NATO.

I will certainly discuss this with our allies, as I consider it one of my absolutely most important tasks – the security of Poland, the security of Poland, and once again – the security of Poland. Here I can tell you that I understand that we are in agreement with the Prime Minister on this matter, that there is one direction.

However, regarding internal security matters, I have appealed to the Prime Minister for de-escalation and calming the situation and to act solely within the limits and based on the law, because this is fundamentally important for the internal situation in the country, for alleviating the tensions that have arisen.

Thank you very much.