Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 70th Banking Conference of the Federal Association of German Cooperative Banks on May 14, 2014, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

15 May 2014 · 70th Banking Conference of the Federal Association of German Cooperative Banks · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 70th Banking Conference of the Federal Association of German Cooperative Banks in Berlin on May 14, 2014.
Main themes
Cooperative banks, three-pillar banking model, financial crisis regulation, German banking system, lending to businesses, customer proximity, global financial market regulation, shadow banking, long-term financial stability, membership growth, systemic relevance, European banking policy
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,583
89th percentile
Sentences
257
93rd percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 74%74%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

257 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Graaf,

Mr. Fröhlich,

Mr. Mersch,

ladies and gentlemen,

welcome here in Berlin to your conference, which is taking place for the 70th time as the Banking Conference of the Cooperative Banks. From my side, I also extend my heartfelt congratulations on this anniversary. My presence here demonstrates the good tradition of dialogue and exchange between your association and politics. I would also like to tell you that the federal government will continue to work in partnership with you; this is a greeting right from the start, so to speak, as a birthday wish. This does not mean that everything can always go exactly as you wish. But I believe we have always tried to find cooperative good results and to represent the role of the cooperative banks analogously to that of the savings banks in Europe, repeatedly pointing to the long tradition and the good spirit here. The cooperative banks continue to play an extraordinarily important role in the economic life of our country.

In recent years, you have expanded your lending to businesses and self-employed individuals – by 4.1 percent alone in 2013. Thus, you are a reliable partner for the medium-sized economy and many self-employed individuals. In terms of savings deposits, the market share of the cooperative banks is around 30 percent. This is a significant vote of confidence from the citizens. It shows that it pays off to focus on proximity to the customer. With your dense branch network, you contribute to a comprehensive supply of the population with financial services.

The number of attendees indicates that many – certainly the vast majority – want to stop by such a conference as representatives of their branches. That is probably the case, isn’t it? A trip to the capital is also something nice. I do not know how the selection process in a branch looks and whether the boss is always allowed to go or if there are also honorary tickets for dedicated employees. I would like to connect this with a greeting to all those who cannot be here. This is obviously causing many discussions now, but if you were to do it – I mean the greeting – then I would appreciate it.

In recent years, the membership of the credit cooperatives has continuously grown to 17.7 million members. This is an impressive confirmation of the business model. Therefore, we can say: You are one of the pillars of the German banking system. I will say it again, even though everyone knows that I represent it: The three-pillar model has proven itself. And we will continue to advocate for it. We are doing this at the European level as well, in an ongoing process to address the financial crisis that hit us with force in the autumn of 2008. That much has changed in the financial sector and must change, I think, is also your opinion. As you, Mr. Fröhlich, just said. Of course, it must always be taken into account to what extent a bank is systemically relevant or not. However, a large part of the regulation also takes this difference into account.

The causes of the crisis in 2008, which plunged us into great turbulence worldwide, were deeply rooted in the system. The resilience of the institutions was too low. Ultimately, the risks were much greater than the liability options for these risks. This must be brought into balance. The risk awareness was too poorly developed. Another point was that one only oriented oneself to short-term incentives. An orientation towards long-term, sustainable stability was not present in many banks.

However, I want to explicitly state: The system of cooperative banks has come through this crisis very well. This is fundamentally an affirmation of the principle that led their founders to this type of banking and lending. It proves itself in the 21st century and should actually be the benchmark for everything related to lending.

The question of the right approach to financial markets and financial actors has been completely redefined. We know that many financial market actors operate globally. However, there were no global regulations. Therefore, our motto from the beginning had to be: No financial market actor, no financial product, and no market should remain without appropriate regulation.

When I look at things today, a lot has happened internationally. However, with the growing temporal distance from the event of the crisis, it has become increasingly difficult to achieve globally applicable regulations. We have certainly achieved 70 or 80 percent, but the last 20 percent – now we are dealing with shadow banks in the G20 framework – are hard to achieve. We must be careful that after an initial willingness to establish a "level playing field," meaning equal competitive conditions, the individual regions of the world do not diverge in their interpretation of the regulation, which could lead us back to significant problems.

Germany has taken the lead on many issues at the national level, always with the aim of setting an example. We have received some criticism for this, for example, regarding short selling. It was said: What can a country do alone? However, it has been shown: It has always been a driving force for Europe when it came to achieving a European regulation. We know, of course, that much cannot be regulated solely at the national level, but that we need European regulations and, above all, international regulations. Gradually, as I said, we have also achieved successes.

I want to mention a few, for example, the agreements of Basel III, which have been in effect since the beginning of the year. They concern stricter capital requirements in the European Union. Tending to make these requirements more resilient for banks and thus contribute to the stability of the financial markets. In addition to higher capital requirements, it is, of course, important that risk areas within banks are better separated from each other. Therefore, last year in Germany, we also created regulations to shield speculative transactions from deposit business and other lending activities. However, this remains only a first step, as we need such provisions at the European level as well. The proposal from the EU Commission in this regard is heading in the right direction. The federal government is closely monitoring the process. But we do not want the proven universal banking system for financing the economy to suffer. That is our premise.

We have also made good progress in eliminating inappropriate compensation incentives. We have required banks and insurers to create appropriate compensation systems focused on sustainable development. Those who have the chance for profits must also bear the consequences of their actions. This should actually be a matter of course, but practice often looked different in the past. In the crisis, it was also added that the financial supervision was not adequately equipped to identify misdevelopments in the financial markets early on, let alone to intervene. Therefore, supervision has been strengthened in Germany and in Europe.

In November, the European Central Bank will take over supervision of the large banks in the euro area. This is a central step for financial stability in Europe. – I believe that if Germany had been alone, we might not have needed this step at the European level. But overall, this step has been very important to restore trust in the entire lending system in Europe. – You all know: In advance, the banks' balance sheets will be thoroughly analyzed and subjected to a stress test. I can only urgently appeal for no political influence to be exerted here. Otherwise, the reputation of the European Central Bank as a supervisory authority will already be damaged before the work has even begun. We have all experienced how it was with the EBA. And therefore, it is very important to strengthen the trust of international financial markets in the European banking system in this process of creating a European banking supervision. We need reliable lending to businesses – not only in Germany but in all European countries – otherwise, we will not be able to further stimulate economic growth.

Two things are important to us. We want a consistent separation of monetary policy and supervision – this is absolutely necessary in connection with the ECB. And we want the concentration of direct supervision by the European Central Bank on the large banks. The principle of proportionality and subsidiarity – which is also very important to you – must be maintained.

The measures already mentioned primarily serve to prevent banks from getting into trouble in the first place through better requirements and controls. But precaution is only one side. The other is: We must also be prepared for emergencies. This is also a very essential lesson from the financial crisis. Therefore, we need appropriate instruments to restructure systemically relevant banks that have encountered serious economic difficulties in an orderly manner or, if necessary, to wind them down.

We passed a corresponding restructuring law in Germany as early as 2010. These regulations enable us to manage severe crises of a systemically relevant bank without endangering the financial stability of the entire system. Furthermore, it is important that banks and authorities think early on about how to act in case of an emergency. They must therefore deal with the possibilities for restructuring and the requirements for an orderly winding down. In this regard, Germany is also a pioneer; at least in Europe.

We have required potentially systemically dangerous banks to establish restructuring plans with measures for emergencies. If such a case actually occurs, the banks must be able to manage the situation as quickly, effectively, and independently as possible. But the supervisory authorities are also required to prepare for emergencies in advance and to develop winding down plans. Such instruments are now mandated across Europe, namely through the Recovery and Resolution Directive, which we were able to pass at the end of last year. The integration of the European banking market is therefore progressing. The law that the institutions have to apply is already highly harmonized. This promotes cooperation among banking supervisors and soon also among resolution authorities at the European level.

In addition, there is the European Banking Union – initially essentially for the euro area. I am convinced that it will stabilize the European banking sector as a whole and make it more crisis-resistant. A central and hotly debated component is also a common mechanism for the resolution of banks. Mr. Fröhlich has very politely spoken of steps towards mutualization and similar matters. You know how much Germany has worked to ensure that we do not develop too great incentives for mutualization. We certainly do not want member states to be overwhelmed, but we primarily want to ensure that precautions are taken and that the resolution instruments do not have to be used too much.

The negotiations were difficult, but the European Council and the European Parliament found a solution after tough negotiations. It places the common resolution mechanism on a good and legally secure foundation. The proposed decision-making mechanisms are designed to be applied quickly and efficiently. It is also important: The budgetary sovereignty of the participating member states remains preserved. We have found a solution for this, and we have also worked very hard for it.

We know: It can cost a lot of money if a bank is restructured or wound down in an orderly manner. The question of who pays in such a case is a central question for the people in the country. Therefore, it is very, very important that we can now say: Under no circumstances, as in the past, is the taxpayer the first to step in, but there are other mechanisms. First, the owners and the bank creditors will be liable. There is an additional safety net, within which banks must pay levies across the EU starting in 2015, as has been the case in Germany since 2011. The devil is in the details here; I have understood that. I also say frankly: I am a bit surprised that during the negotiations in Parliament, the establishment of this fund could not go fast enough. I had to point out in the discussions from time to time that banks still need to grant loans in the meantime and should not only be paying levies. In any case, many European countries are complaining about a credit crunch. Therefore, we must proceed with caution here. The establishment of the fund is a paradigm shift. We will need some time to implement this paradigm shift.

The specific rules for the European bank levy – you know this – are still open. But you are familiar with our discussion that we have had in Germany with the representatives of the three-pillar system. The word reciprocity, I believe, has become second nature to us. Therefore, we will also work in this direction. And if we do not, then you will come to us, as you are always well informed. But we are in agreement. However, you also know that this will not be entirely straightforward. We are now waiting for the Commission's proposals. And then we must, so to speak, ensure with concentrated energy that everything proceeds along the right lines.

On the open questions regarding bank recapitalization through the ESM, the finance ministers made significant progress at the beginning of the month. You know that we wanted to resolve the bank resolution first before addressing direct recapitalization, so that the supposedly attractive direct recapitalization is not already in place and the resolution is then imposed at our expense. We have now done this in the correct order.

We have also implemented important concerns regarding the reform of deposit insurance. This has indeed been a nearly eternal struggle. But we have also said: Before we talk about bank recapitalization through the ESM, we will first discuss a uniform deposit insurance in Europe. There is no mutualization in this regard. And the institutional protection systems of cooperative banks and savings banks remain recognized as deposit insurance systems. I believe this is an important success – so to speak, also in the service of the three-pillar model. Today, you are not only celebrating your 70th meeting but also an 80th birthday. Therefore, this is yet another gift that you can be pleased about, and of which we are also very convinced.

One cannot really say that nothing has happened regarding the reform of financial markets. Europe is often criticized for being able to act only very slowly. But if we consider how we reacted during the financial crisis and the speed with which we have now managed to establish a banking union, then these are examples of a truly good capacity for action.

However, everything in Europe can be assessed as absolutely inadequate if we do not also make real progress internationally. Therefore, the federal government will continue to insist with all its might that we make progress at the G20 summit in Australia. Our efforts must not, as I hinted at the beginning, falter now, but the international shadow banking sector must be regulated immediately. Risks also arise outside of banks. The more banks are regulated internationally, the more there is a tendency to push risks into the remaining instruments. Therefore, we need a parallel regulatory system, especially for systemically important banks.

Another major chapter is, of course, the stronger protection of consumers regarding financial transactions. It is necessary to enable citizens to make responsible and informed decisions. Risks must be highlighted, because only when risks are visible can appropriate investment decisions be made – although the rule of thumb that high returns are somehow related to risk has largely become known, even though I do not advocate for even lower interest rates, to put it cautiously. Therefore, transparency is the key term. Transparency is central to supervision in order to enforce effective regulation.

We have therefore regulated over-the-counter derivatives trading at the European level. We have directed more transactions to transparent exchanges and other transparently organized trading venues. Supervision over hedge funds and rating agencies has improved. However, I know that there is still much to be done internationally and that one cannot be satisfied with what has been achieved. I can only warn: If we were to have another financial crisis, the shock to the credibility of the system would be truly great. There must be a bit more sense of responsibility among all actors. I know that it exists among the cooperative and savings banks. I am speaking in the wrong place here; that is perfectly clear. But it must find more acceptance internationally.

In the wake of the international financial crisis, there was also a severe loss of trust in the euro system, which occupied us for years – caused by a combination of very high national debt, lack of competitiveness, and certainly also the attempt to subject the euro system to a political test internationally. Therefore, it was important for us to demonstrate the political will to stabilize the euro system and to say: The euro is important to us. It is important for Germany; we stand by the euro. It is, by the way, more than just a financial project. Today we can say: Europe has made good progress on the path to stability and growth, but this path is not yet finished.

We have further developed economic and budgetary monitoring. We have created a basis for sound budgeting with the fiscal treaty. And we have applied the concept of linking aid to the countries' own efforts. If we look today at Spain coming out of its banking aid program, that Portugal will leave its program, and that Ireland has left its program, then we see that we have indeed made good progress. The efforts of the member states are therefore bearing initial fruit. There is also a very encouraging development in interest rates regarding government bonds. There is also an improvement in the competitiveness of member states that were under a support program, as well as other member states. But we know that this is partly also a vote of confidence that this development will continue.

Therefore, the question of competitiveness remains of central importance. The fight against unemployment is fundamentally linked to this, because unemployment can only be reduced if Europe is truly an attractive investment location. Therefore, after the European elections, the first task will be to develop a program for the next five years together with Parliament – the European Council will be involved in this – that clearly shows where more jobs can be created. The many young people who are unemployed are rightly asking for employment opportunities.

When we see that we no longer belong to the world elite in many areas of innovation, we know what homework we have to do. When one considers where jobs are currently being created, we come to the conclusion that this is, among other things, very much the case in the digital economy. However, Europe is not in a leading position in many areas, which is why we have a lot of catching up to do.

We must therefore ensure that sound budget policy is combined with more economic policy coherence – oriented towards the best in the world and not the average of what we find in the eurozone. If we do this consistently, then Europe has, in my firm opinion, good chances of securing its competitiveness and thus its prosperity in the 21st century. But that is anything but a given. We must be aware that the world is not standing still, that the world is not waiting for us to act, but that many people around the world want to live in greater prosperity. If one looks at what is happening in Asia – not only in China but also in South Korea, Vietnam, and other countries – one gets a sense that alongside the classic competitors like the United States, completely new players have also entered the world markets. Ninety percent of global growth occurs outside of Europe, even in normal times. If we are not able to export and have a share in these growth markets, it will be very difficult to maintain our prosperity in Europe.

Germany has a special responsibility in this regard. We have good results to report regarding sound budget management. We have developed a federal budget that is structurally balanced. The planned net borrowing amounts to 6.5 billion euros. This is the lowest it has been in 40 years. The key figures for the financial plan until 2018 follow the growth-oriented consolidation course we have taken. We do not want to incur new debts from 2015 onwards.

When a lot is being said these days about generational equity in connection with pensions and other matters, I want to say: It is truly a contribution for the younger generation if we live within our means. This is actually a very normal thing, but it has not been realized for decades. Given our demographic development, this is, of course, important.

Various federal governments have – I do not want to hide this – promised a balanced budget. Theo Waigel once said as finance minister in the early 1990s: "I could have achieved a balanced budget in 1990 and 1991, but I decided against it in order not to cancel the reunification." I would say: This political decision was fine; otherwise, I would not be able to stand here before you. Finance Minister Steinbrück had, in principle, already had a balanced budget in sight during the first grand coalition. Then came the great financial crisis. The fact that we managed to cushion the economic downturn of over five percent with very smart decisions, such as short-time work, has proven to be correct. But we are working to ensure that we can now achieve a balanced budget, with the motto "All good things come in threes"; and the third attempt should succeed.

The framework conditions for economic development are, of course, also set politically. Therefore, the issues of affordable energy prices and management of the energy transition are central topics. With the draft for a new Renewable Energy Act, which is now in parliamentary consultation, we have taken an important first step. The Federal Minister of Economics and I have fought together to ensure that the exemptions for energy-intensive industries in Germany are such that no jobs are endangered. One wonders what one sometimes has to spend time on to actually realize what should be self-evident.

However, we still have a multitude of steps to take in connection with the energy transition. This Renewable Energy Act will be a transitional law because we will also have to tender the expansion of renewable energies starting in 2017. This means that we will have to create a second draft of the Renewable Energy Act during this legislative period. We need to advance the expansion of the grid. We need to get the capacity markets right. We need to promote the market integration of renewable energies. This means that a whole bundle of measures is still necessary before we can say that everything is on a reasonable course.

We have said that we do not want to increase the tax burden on companies. This has been an important decision because jobs are essentially created by companies, and what companies earn should also be sufficient to invest in the future.

We are also clear that we need to invest more in public infrastructure. This applies to roads and transport projects overall, for which we will spend five billion euros more than in the last four years. The same applies to broadband infrastructure, where we hope for a swift auction of the second digital dividend to obtain funds for the faster expansion of broadband connections. It should also be of great interest to you and your clients that there are decent internet access points in rural areas.

We must, of course, also ensure that we do not simply let things run, especially regarding long-term unemployment, but we must also decisively try to bring more people into work in light of the impending shortage of skilled workers. We currently have an unemployment figure of about three million, of which more than one million are long-term unemployed. That is too much. The federal government is spending more than 30 billion euros – which is more than ten percent of our budget – on financing long-term unemployed individuals. This is a huge burden on the budget. Every billion saved could be invested in the future. At the same time, it is also a stroke of luck for the affected individuals when they find work. This means that, especially regarding younger unemployed individuals between the ages of 25 and 35, the federal government will now make another effort to ensure that they find work; also those who do not have a completed vocational training.

In this context, I would also like to thank you for what you are doing in the field of education. We will further develop the training pact into a new alliance for education and training, hoping that the trade unions will also participate. Securing skilled labor will occupy us significantly in the coming years. This also includes the entire area of integration and, in parts, immigration. This means that we will not run out of work.

Dear Mr. Fröhlich, at the beginning of your speech – and with this, I would like to conclude – you pointed out what is also occupying us these days. This year 2014 is not only a year in which your security institution turns 80 years old and you hold your 70th major conference, but we also think of the beginning of the First World War 100 years ago and the beginning of the Second World War 75 years ago. Fortunately, after the Second World War, we experienced a good development in Europe, which was only possible because people who had previously waged war against each other were willing to extend their hands to one another. The wise decisions made after the Second World War are the foundation of today's European unification.

That we also think of the fall of the Berlin Wall 25 years ago this year and that Poland and other Central and Eastern European countries have been members of the European Union for ten years now shows what a unique success story European unification represents. We can be happy about that. It is worth all the effort – especially when we consider the problems of our great-grandfathers, grandfathers, and fathers – to work today to ensure that this Europe remains successful in the future. The conflict in Ukraine also shows that the European peace project, which we often take for granted, must be continually worked on and that one can find oneself in a difficult situation more quickly than one thinks. Therefore, I assure you: The Federal Government is working with all its might to continue the peace project in Europe.

I also thank you for your willingness to contribute to this. You have always advocated for the common good. You have always relied on the fact that people – as evidenced by the 17.7 million members – share a piece of responsibility, leading to long-term responsible action. In this sense, we are partners in a time when the idea of long-term thinking and sustainability certainly still needs strengthening.

I wish you a successful anniversary conference, all the best, and I thank you once again for the invitation.