Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the twelfth district assembly of the German District Association on January 23, 2007, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

24 January 2007 · Twelfth district assembly of the German District Association · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the twelfth district assembly of the German District Association in Berlin on January 23, 2007, marking the association's 90th anniversary and discussing federalism reform.
Main themes
Federalism reform, municipal self-government, subsidiarity, EU Constitutional Treaty, German District Association anniversary, decentralized responsibility, federal-state-municipal relations, EU Council Presidency, legislative efficiency, community vitality, bureaucratic reform
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,915
85th percentile
Sentences
228
92nd percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 46%45%
  • Social 25%25%
  • Economic 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

228 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President, Mr. District Administrator Duppré,

dear Professor Henneke,

dear Professor Würth,

dear district administrators,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be able to speak to you today despite a tight schedule. The German District Association looks back on a 90-year history. I believe that one can say, on the one hand, that the framework conditions have of course changed dramatically during this time, but that the concern of the District Association has remained the same, namely to bundle the interests of municipalities, which means taking care of a stable community. I believe we completely agree that we have a stable community. This only works if there are lively and vital municipalities that can also articulate their interests clearly.

Life takes place on the ground – in the cities and municipalities of our country. There, people experience our country in terms of infrastructure, in terms of childcare options, and in terms of work opportunities. I want to explicitly state that what has always distinguished the Federal Republic of Germany is its diversity and differences. This can only be ensured through decentralized responsibility. Therefore, the federal government is primarily there to support this diversity and thus also your work in the German District Association.

The federal government is now limited by the federal systems. There is the structure of the states. I believe we also agree – I thank you for your statement – that it was right to carry out the first stage of the federalism reform. Even when I look at the final phase of the negotiations, one can rightly say today: Probably only a grand coalition could have actually pushed through this federalism reform. The members of the Bundestag present will confirm this to me. In the end, there were so many interests to bring together again that it required a real effort.

In the future, there will be fewer laws requiring approval. We hope for a more efficient and faster legislative process from this. We also hope that responsibilities can be better assigned, meaning that one can say where the responsibilities of the states lie and where there is a federal responsibility, so that complaints and commendations can also be directed more clearly to specific individuals. It is always very difficult when one no longer knows in a democracy who is actually responsible for which decision.

You – Mr. Duppré just mentioned it – will of course benefit from this reform, as the federal government is no longer allowed to directly assign tasks to municipalities. We now need to gain experience with this regulation. With all due respect for the District Association, I would like to say: I believe the Federal President made his decision out of his own conviction. I would place great importance on that. This is also in your interest. We now need to ensure that we do not fall back into overly bureaucratic procedures. If the federal government assigns something to the states and then all states assign something to the municipalities, we need to ensure that this always proceeds in a manner appropriate to the circumstances.

We will now tackle a second stage of the federalism reform. You mentioned yesterday, if I read that correctly, that we should hurry. I would say that the date of March 8, when this is supposed to start, is quite okay. I have understood that you are not entirely satisfied with your involvement. However, you will also be heard on the topics that concern cities and municipalities and will have the opportunity to participate. Of course, the states are your friends. But sometimes they also think they know everything particularly well. They are not represented here today. Now we do not want to complain about them. This is certainly a matter where we from the federal government can assure you that we want to listen to and take your concerns very seriously.

We have a lot to do at the federal level this year. We also hold the EU Council Presidency. Therefore, let me remind you that we also have the task, within the framework of this Council Presidency, to get the constitutional process back on track. Many people in the country – we should not delude ourselves – do not even know what exactly is meant by the EU Constitutional Treaty. Therefore, it would be very important to me that it is made clear, especially from your ranks, that this draft of the constitutional treaty is a step in the right direction, namely towards more citizen proximity and a stronger commitment to subsidiarity. This means that the Treaty of Nice is by no means better in any way.

We have ratified the constitutional treaty in Germany. But I also say this, for example, in the direction of our Polish guests. For the first time, there is the recognition of regional and municipal self-government. There is also a right to sue with the Committee of the Regions and the so-called subsidiarity early warning system, where we can hear you much better and can do something from the national responsibility. This is sometimes misunderstood in the midst of concern for the word.

The constitutional treaty was a response to the realization that citizens no longer really understand who is responsible for what. The attempt to bring more order into this – certainly it has not yet succeeded one hundred percent – is definitely a step in the right direction. Therefore, we need the regions in Europe also on other issues, as you know: in energy supply, climate protection, and other questions.

We are also very committed to another topic in our work, both during the European Council Presidency and in the federal government, which we want to put on the agenda of the Council at the spring council in March. That is the topic of bureaucracy. I believe this is also our common interest. The European Union has finally stated, almost 50 years after the adoption of the Treaty of Rome, under the motto of "better regulation," that a directive can also be abolished. Until now, in Europe, something has always been added. The older the European Union gets, the more it must think about whether what was adopted in 1960, 1970, or 1980 is still so urgent. I have the impression that the current Commission and also the European Parliament have become much more sensitive to what we really need for Europe.

We certainly do not need directives that regulate the density of sunshades in beer gardens uniformly across Europe. I am very grateful to the European Parliament for rejecting this directive and saying: This is complete nonsense. This now evokes a certain amusement. However, I must say the following: We sometimes make it particularly difficult for ourselves in Germany with the directives. When I ask my European colleagues about such exciting topics as the Flora-Fauna-Habitat and Birds Protection Directive, they have only a fraction of the problems with it because it is a very widespread characteristic in Germany that certain associations always try to undermine other associations in Brussels, to put it somewhat loosely, and then the Commission becomes aware of it. Therefore, I also ask you to refrain from such efforts, should it ever be the case in the District Association that you want to throw someone else under the bus. It ultimately does not pay off. When the Commission then tells us all the stories about which German is currently going against which German, we do not look good as a country. Other member states sometimes do it differently. But that is now a very private matter.

Regarding bureaucracy costs: We want to try to save companies in the European Union as well as in Germany from bureaucracy costs in the area of reporting and statistical obligations. About 25 percent is targeted. I am pleased that the National Norm Control Council includes two individuals, the former district director Mr. Kreibohm and the former president of the Bavarian Administrative Court, Professor Wittmann, who know where the shoe pinches for municipalities.

Reducing bureaucracy is not an end in itself. We know that. But our central goal – this is your goal, this is our goal – is of course the reduction of unemployment and, above all, the increase in social insurance-contributing employment relationships. It is not enough if we statistically reduce unemployment; we must also really have more social insurance-contributing employment relationships. We are currently at an exciting point. There is an economic upturn. We must solidify this through further reforms.

At this point, I would also like to extend a heartfelt thank you to all of you, because you as district administrators and as people who work on the ground know the problems. You know where people are struggling. You are aware of the suffering and hardship that arises from unemployment. Therefore, you are the contact persons, especially for those who are long-term unemployed. We must succeed in reducing the base of long-term unemployment. Therefore, we want to do everything we can to improve the incentives for taking up work. We know, of course, that in some areas the incentives under Hartz IV need to be critically reviewed. Especially regarding the opportunities for additional income, I believe we all agree that a number of problems arise here. From what I hear from the municipal level, the changes we have made, especially for those under 25, are already a step in the right direction from your perspective.

Mr. Duppré, you pointed out the lawsuits and the decision of the Federal Constitutional Court. We must now wait for that. But you also know – this is part of reality – that if I had the German Association of Cities as a guest in the neighboring room and would go over there, I would hear a completely opposite position, turned 180 degrees, at least on the point you mentioned regarding the complete municipalization of responsibility. Since we also pay attention to the people in the large cities, we face a problem there. Therefore, I say: It is best when the top associations of municipalities have a unified opinion. Then we can really work together sensibly. Professor Henneke, please convince Mr. Articus, and then come back to me.

But still, I want to extend a heartfelt thank you for the work of many, many people in the ARGEn. Many have come together under sometimes difficult conditions for the sake of the people involved. I can say that the Federal Minister of Labor has looked at many, many examples here and wants to see how we can bring things together sensibly. However, I also want to say: Do not underestimate that interregional job placement is a crucial factor, especially for younger people. In this respect, the Federal Employment Agency is trying to improve diversity with target specifications. I will not be able to convince you now. I think we need to see how we proceed in light of the case law.

I believe that with the financial commitment we have made, we have represented your interests very well. You will not praise us, but it could have been much worse. I believe that the federal government has represented the concerns of municipalities very well, as have the states. All the more, we must talk again about the 2.5 billion euros in relief for municipalities. You have committed to spending the funds for childcare under very different conditions. In any case, we will continue to insist on that. We must also see that the states really pass the money on to the municipalities adequately. That is also an important point.

Let us move on to another topic. The topic of unemployment benefits and social assistance will occupy us for a while longer. We must stay in close contact here. I am also always interested in seeing the experiences from practice. The mid-term comparison of the option municipalities with the ARGEn will also be of great interest to us. But it also seems to be the case, as it is everywhere: Not one thing is generally good, but there are very good and also problematic examples everywhere. It is important that you have enough maneuvering room to get the right things done for the people.

A central instrument of federal-state policy and municipal policy is the improvement of the regional economic structure. I believe it was right that we agreed to continue the GA. There was talk of it being terminated. We have allocated 650 million euros for 2007. I believe you are also satisfied that the investment grant for business investments, especially for the new federal states, continues to exist. That was also a very, very important point.

The European Structural Funds remain a key point for the promotion of regions in Germany. We are also having many discussions on your behalf to keep everything manageable and appropriate. In the European Union – I would like to reiterate this during our presidency – there is, of course, an incessant competition regarding what constitutes competitive distortion and what constitutes political influence. If you think in terms of regulatory policy, you can certainly say: Any form of promotion is somewhere a competitive distortion.

If only market forces are at work, then we no longer need politics. Then inequality will always become more pronounced, and what you rightly mentioned, namely the equivalence of living conditions, will not be possible under very different conditions. We have an ongoing discussion process with the European Union regarding the notification of various subsidies and various funding programs. Therefore, this will also have to continue.

I believe there is another topic when we think about integration assistance for people with disabilities. You also mentioned the topic of basic security. These are issues that are associated with exploding or at least very rapidly growing costs. Therefore, we naturally need help for the people here. On the other hand, it must be financially feasible. We have further discussions ahead of us on this matter. We have also discussed the topic of "communicating tubes" between long-term care insurance and social assistance tasks. We still have a lot to do here.

But I want to be honest with you at this point: When we think about legislation, for example in child and youth welfare law, about which you, understandably, say that you are dealing with many claims arising from "indeterminate legal concepts," we see from examples, such as that of little Kevin, which you and all of us experienced with horror last year, that child and youth welfare is, of course, a very important field, because we can no longer assume that parents will always provide the necessary educational power. This is a sad finding, but one that the state must not turn a blind eye to, because every child must have a chance. Above all, we must also promote the educational power of parents. But the state cannot take on more and more tasks in this regard. From my perspective, this is a very difficult field.

Regarding the integration of immigrants, we agree that integration is a prerequisite for educational opportunities and employment. Therefore, integration courses and migration counseling are very important. We want to bring this topic into public awareness through our integration dialogue, the establishment of integration plans, or certain benchmarks. We know the questions of responsibility. It is not about the federal government interfering. That is why we are doing this together with states and municipalities. But if we are honest, the topic of integration of immigrants has often been swept under the rug for a long time.

If you look at the demographic development and see that today in cities like Augsburg and soon also in Munich – I could name other cities just as well – the number of enrolled migrant children is higher than that of those enrolled with a German background, then you know what problems lie ahead. If we have more and more children who do not understand their teacher even in the first grade, then in the end we will have children who do not graduate from school and cannot complete an apprenticeship. We cannot afford all of this in light of the declining number of young people. Therefore, it is our common concern to make up for past shortcomings and give every child a chance.

You know much better than I do that these are complicated matters because the immigration authorities must work with the ARGEn, the employment agencies, the municipalities, and the counseling services. It is a web. By the way, I am also very grateful that there is an incredible amount of volunteer engagement in this area. The state cannot manage all of this. But this is a topic that will occupy us in the coming years.

You also mentioned the topic of childcare. I believe we agree that children should receive educational opportunities at an early age. There has been a change in the discussion on this. I was the Minister for Youth in the early 1990s. If I had spoken about providing educational opportunities in kindergarten, I would have been looked at with furrowed brows and thought – it was not said out loud: "Well, she comes from the GDR; she just doesn't know what is right." But in the meantime, these things have changed to some extent. Early childhood education is one of the treasures we still need to tap into, without essentially pushing children into school too early. Therefore, the expansion of childcare is a key task.

I know the questions associated with financing. This needs to be discussed. But too few childcare places will also be a problem for the location in the future. You as districts are in a location competition. I predict that in the next ten or twenty years, you will enter a location competition for young families; that is what I foresee. Therefore, the question of childcare and the living environment for young families will be a very important point. You must always keep in mind: In just four or five years, there will be a great demand for apprentices, even though we are still discussing how to accommodate all apprentices today. The problems will shift completely. Therefore, I can only say to everyone: If you want to be an interesting, attractive living space, you must also strive for a family-friendly climate.

Now, the pleasant fact of better tax revenues has not yet been discussed today. You will probably find a way to utilize them in the form of district levies. That is justified. I am in favor of ensuring that the tasks that the districts implement excellently can indeed be fulfilled. But please, no one should say that I have called for higher district levies – that would bring me too much trouble tomorrow; that is not the case. One must find the right balance.

I believe that when we talk about family-friendliness, we have taken an interesting and important step with parental allowance. The enthusiasm for the father months in these circles is probably somewhat muted. But recently, the Swedish Prime Minister was with us and told us about Swedish experiences. It was quite amusing that he said there was a spike in fathers taking parental months during the World Cup. That is not actually the intention of parental allowance. But with parental allowance – I would like to remind you of this – we have done something quite exciting. We have shifted from the question of support for reasons of social need, as it was before, to a compensation in a way for not being available in the labor market. This means that even for those who earn more, this is now a benefit. It is therefore not a purely social transfer payment, but a recognition by the state for the decision to have children, which is, of course, always a highly personal one. This benefits all women who are employed.

But I also predict to you: Because this benefit will only last for one year, the pressure for more childcare options – whether regarding individual childcare options for children under three years – will grow. That is also the reality. Nevertheless, we cannot be satisfied that many women and men, especially in the academic field, no longer decide to have children. This decision-making pressure between career and family, which does not exist in other European countries, must be lifted in Germany. This is a very complex problem, but I believe that municipalities can contribute significantly to the solution.

I want to address a topic that concerns us all. That is anti-Semitism, xenophobia, and right-wing extremism. We have renewed and expanded our program. But I simply ask you for honest feedback. We know that not every program implementation is already a success. Above all, this area needs people who are simply courageous and brave. I know that many local politicians are. It will not work any other way, because those who are committed to extremism are people who also test how far they can go with this society. I would say that there must be zero tolerance for all acts of violence, whether from the right or the left.

We are working on corporate tax reform. I believe you can follow this relatively calmly, although you will keep a close eye on it. But we have refrained from abolishing the trade tax. I believe that we have now found solutions in the area of corporate taxes that allow municipalities to generate revenue – I have already pointed out the record revenues – while also giving German companies the opportunity to operate competitively. Especially the districts located in border regions know what I am talking about. This means we cannot sit idly by while our companies ultimately move to other European countries and the tax revenues end up there. Therefore, a short-term burden at the beginning of such a corporate tax reform is certainly better than the permanent loss of tax revenues in Germany. Together with the inheritance tax reform, I believe we have quite good and interesting plans.

Last point: The savings banks: I believe we have made our contribution to ensure the security of the savings banks. I just ask that we do not create the causes for this ourselves again – the president, Mr. Haasis, is here, and you will also do this in your framework – so that in the end we have to fight battles. It is very important: If one stands by the three-pillar model, one must not seek false connections when it is convenient. This is being closely monitored in Brussels, but above all in other countries.

I have now taken a tour through the things that bring us together. You see: Despite the fact that we are not allowed to assign you any more tasks, we are not on completely separate paths. This is also in the nature of things, because you make policy for the people in the country, and we make policy for the people in the country. We want to do this in a way that we do not constantly find ourselves in disputes over competencies, but in a way that conveys to the citizens that we are working for them, their lives, and this beautiful country, which should remain livable and a home, a diverse home, but ultimately always a German home. Therefore, thank you very much for your work, for your commitment in the German District Association, which is not a given, and here’s to further good cooperation!